1. Home | Yahoo Answers
Very best answer: Men and women who concentrate on the Tale.............Overlook the position of
what exactly can make the movie so good.
The cause most film critics RAVE above the Shawshank Redemption..........is since a Movie CRITIC's
occupation is not to just sit and view a film......and say whether he personally favored the Tale or
not.............but to Rate the film, and the CRAFT of film producing.
At the Oscars, -----if movies ended up JUST about the tale.........then there would only be one
particular Oscar, for best tale....and then absolutely everyone would go house.
But films are judged on Numerous issues........ like performing, costumes, actuality of the SETS,
lights, digicam operate, enhancing, directon, hair styling, make up...........and so on..........the
checklist goes on and on.
What tends to make Shawshank stand arms previously mentioned the relaxation.........is that the
movie receives a solid ten out of 10, if not an 11 in most types, in each and every classification a
movie CAN be judged on.
The acting was Outstanding, down to the smallest role and very last participant. *Every person* just
did a excellent job, and in simple fact, Equally Tim Robbins AND Morgan Freeman had been
nominated for their roles. ------that is how excellent the 2 stars were. The camera operate, and use of
angles, was imaginative and entire world class. The Set, was an true Prison. The costumes, down to
the smallest particulars , have been place on. As the film spanned a long time, the period items had
been Spot ON. The lighting was outstanding......the sound was excellent........
in brief........if this have been the Olympics........the film earned a straight 10, throughout the board.
It was just FLAWLESS movie making. As opposed, to let's say Titanic....... which has total websites
focused to pointing out all the errors and sloppy enhancing. ---however it received "Greatest Photo"-
--------------which was a damn JOKE, and an INSULT, to the art of film making, given that it was
RIDDLED with sloppy problems .
I have watched Shawshank many times, Searching for mistakes.......and can not place 1. The movie is
flawless.
The ****ONLY**** explanation this movie did NOT sweep the Oscars, is because it had the
misfortune of becoming a quite late beneath the wire entry.............just before any reliable phrase of
mouth had been constructed up about it........PLUSSSSSSSSS, it went up towards nothing at all less
than Forrest Gump and Tom Hanks.........which was a smash hit and cultural phenomon that
yr.......and had MONTHS of hype and excellent push, ahead of Shawshank even arrived out -
---incredibly late in the calendar year.
Shawshank WAS nominated in most categories.......but, almost everything went to Forrest Gump.
Shawshank acquired shut out.
2. But now, as the a long time have passed.........significant movie critics, who have now witnessed and
examined Equally movies............will flat out inform you, that Shawshank was the far better,
effectively crafted movie............and most will have it in their best 10 lists............of ALL
time............if not the leading five.
Forrest, hardly ever can make such lists......(granted, as excellent as it was. )
But in phrases of superb movie generating...........it's rather tough, if not extremely hard to defeat
Shawshank .
It truly is a single flaw...........(if you wish to contact it that) .......is that it is a dark and depressing
tale....and not everyone's cup of tea........ it truly is not a "feel excellent" motion picture......and
stories about men becoming raped in prison, are not just "date motion pictures"-
But if you enjoy the CRAFT of movie producing..........then you can recognize just how Exceptional,
Shawshank really is
