Effect of mobile_marketing_on_youngsters_of_ahmedabad_city[1]
1. Chapter-1
LITERATURE REVIEW
A study done by Heinonen & Strandvik (2003) showed that mobile channels are perceived to
be more personal than traditional and e mail channels. This creates high expectations for
the relevance of marketing communication messages. A consumer expects messages
to be personal and of high interest and this makes the disappointment greater when
they get undesired messages. Mobile advertising may even step over the line of discretion
and invade consumers’ privacy because of the personal nature of the mobile device. Li et
al (2002) discusses how negative reactions like irritation arise through intrusion
advertising. The channel influences consumer responsiveness to marketing
communication by being perceived as either disturbing or acceptable (Abernethy 1991).
If the consumer considers marketing communication via a channel as disturbing it may
negatively affect the attention to and perception of the message. In contrast, the channel
may also enhance the acceptance of the marketing communication if it is perceived as
appropriate for the specific marketing communication. Also, some consumers may
perceive the channels as neutral, i.e. it is neither disturbing nor accepted.
Despite substantial marketing potential, research on mobile advertising and
particularly through its most successful application, short message service (SMS) is still
embryonic. In a comprehensive survey concerning consumers’ experiences of direct
marketing channels in Finland it was found that consumers perceived direct
marketing channels differently compared to each other. (Finnish Direct Marketing
Association, 2002) The experiences of mail order, Internet and email experiences were
more positive compared to other direct market channels such as telemarketing and door-
to-door sales. 80 % of the respondents had positive experiences of mail order, 77% had
positive experiences of Internet and email as marketing channels and the corresponding
number for SMS and WAP was 65%. For telemarketing and door-to-door sales the
number of positive consumers was down to 30% and 25% respectively. Concerning
satisfaction with information received, there seemed to be
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 1
2. differences between the channels. The study also indicated that consumers have
considerable less experience of SMS messages compared to mail order, Internet and email.
New media in the digital economy have created potentially powerful tools for direct and
interactive marketing. Traditional marketing communication strategies have been based on
the interruption logic (Godin 1999) where the consumer is forced to momentarily
pay attention. Permission marketing was introduced as a new managerial approach in
marketing communication. It has been argued that firms benefit from getting consumers’
permission to be contacted (Marinova, Murphy and Massey 2002). Permission from the
consumer would resolve the difficulties to get access to the consumer. Permission is,
however, not necessarily a guarantee that the consumer pays attention; it is only a door
opener and gives an indication of the consumer’s potential interest areas.
We believe that by using the information retrieval and filtering capabilities of mobile
agents and location information about the user, there exists a good opportunity for
value-added services to be provided to the end-users. This also brings about a new way for
cellular phone service providers to achieve competitive advantage by competing not only
on the basis of price and packaging, but also on the basis of the set of value-added services
that they provide to their clients. In order to overcome the input/output limitations brought
about by mobile devices, the system should be free of user’s intervention. To that end,
we propose to use mobile agents for provisioning context-aware advertisements to
mobile users. Schilit and Theimer first introduced the concept of context-awareness in
the project Active Map in which they took advantage of the location concept to define the
context as people, object, and the changes that occur to them. Dey and Abowd stated that
a system is context -aware if it uses context to provide relevant information and/or
services to the user, where relevancy depends on user’s task.
Krishnamurthy (2001) also proposes a conceptual framework for managing
online
advertising using the permission marketing approach. Permission marketing requires the
consumer to participate in the programme by giving the permission and the information
for continuing the relationship. The interest in this participation arises from the
balance of
3. benefits (message relevance and monetary benefits) and costs (personal information,
message processing costs, privacy costs) for consumers.
One of the main challenges and opportunities for mobile advertising companies is
to understand and respect the personal nature of the usage of mobile phones (Barwise &
Strong
2002; Heinonen & Strandvik 2003; Barnes & Scornavacca 2004; Jelassi & Enders 2004).
The key is to use interactive wireless media to provide customers with time- and
locationsensitive, personalized information that promotes goods, services and ideas,
thereby generating value for all stakeholders (Dickinger et al. 2004). The mobile
advertising relevance can be influenced by the contextualization (Kenny and Marshall,
2000; Yuan & Tsao 2003) of advertising messages. Barwise & Strong (2002) take up the
flexibility, and time-based nature but also the fact that the small screens restrict the length
of the message. Barnes (2002) stresses the interactive nature of mobile advertising and
the ability to use contextual information to target the messages to individual receivers,
in other words to personalize the message. Location-aware advertising messages are
creating five to ten times higher click-through rates compared to traditional internet
advertising messages (Ververidis
& Polyzos 2002).
1. INTRODUCTION
Information technology affects everything from daily life to business in the 21st century.
In business environment, it shapes not only commerce but also the way in which
companies implement their marketing strategies. Offering new marketing channels to
interact with customers is crucial to increase sales for company. Thus, the successful
application of information technology to connect marketing applications is highly
prominent. One of the advances in information technology is wireless mobile
communication technology that makes the ―anytime-to-anyplace‖ communication
possible. This technology system allows increased mobility and extended services
even to remote areas. Due to wireless communication system, mobile phone users are
able to access their e-mails, search, order and buy products and services from everywhere
without computers (Yen and Chou, 2000; Aungst and Wilson, 2005). Besides the Internet
and personal computers, the mobile phone is the key
4. to marketers because it is extremely popular and offers people the opportunity of mobility
now. Through the introduction of data services, Short Message Services (SMS), Multimedia
Message Service (MMS), Mobile Internet, etc., the mobile phone is rapidly becoming a
viable commercial marketing channel.
Even though companies are investing heavily in mobile commerce and mobile marketing,
the nature and implications of this channel have yet to be fully understood and studies need
to be performed to gain an insight into how to utilize it best (Bauer et al., 2005).
Nowadays, mobile marketing adoption and acceptance is on the rise, but marketers would
have little ability to consistently generate profits without a clear understanding of the
elements driving consumer acceptance (Becker, 2005).
The main objective of this study is to draw Global System for Mobile Communications
(GSM) operators‟ and entrepreneurs‟ attention to new opportunities in mobile commerce and
mobile marketing. Therefore, in this study, mobile commerce and mobile marketing
concepts, the importance and benefits of mobile commerce and mobile marketing, how
mobile phone influences marketing and business activities and the success factors
and barriers of mobile commerce in consumer markets are explained and analyzed. The
results of
the survey conducted on 389 mobile phone users to determine consumers‟ attitudes towards
mobile marketing tools are provided.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 4
5. Ch a p t er- 2
Research methodology
Research Objectives
• To check the awareness of the mobile marketing on the youngsters of Ahmedabad
city
• To know the preference of people towards mobile marketing on the youngsters of
Ahmedabad city
• To check the reliability of mobile marketing on the youngsters of Ahmedabad city
Research Design
Sampling frame: all individuals between 18 years to 35 years in
Ahmedabad. Sampling unit: all individuals between 18 years to 35 years in
Ahmedabad Sample size: 100 respondents
Sampling method: non-probabilistic convenience sampling
Primary Sources: survey
Instrument:
Questionnaire
Secondary Sources:
Websites , book for market research
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 5
6. Beneficiaries
1. mobile marketers
2. students who are going to do research on mobile marketing
Limitations
1. Time is short ,
2. Respondents may give bias answers or may not feel questionnaire properly
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 6
7. Chapter – 3
Industry Review
Introduction
The Indian Telecommunications network with 110.01 million connections is the fifth
largest in the world and the second largest among the emerging economies of Asia. Today,
it is the fastest growing market in the world and represents unique opportunities for U.S.
companies in the stagnant global scenario. The total subscriber base, which has grown by
40% in 2005, is expected to reach 250 million in 2007.
According to Broadband Policy 2004, Government of India aims at 9 million broadband
connections and 18 million internet connections by 2007. The wireless subscriber base has
jumped from 33.69 million in 2004 to 62.57 million in FY2004- 2005. In the last 3 years,
two out of every three new telephone subscribers were wireless subscribers.
Consequently, wireless now accounts for 54.6% of the total telephone subscriber base, as
compared to only
40% in 2003. Wireless subscriber growth is expected to bypass 2.5 million new subscribers
per month by 2007. The wireless technologies currently in use are Global System for
Mobile Communications (GSM) and Code Division Multiple Access (CDMA). There are
primarily 9
GSM and 5 CDMA operators providing mobile services in 19 telecom circles and 4 metro
cities, covering 2000 towns across the country.
8. Indian telecom industry –a snapshot
•India has one of the biggest telecom markets in the world. It has more GSM subscribers
than fixed-lin subscribers.
•Total telecom subscribers –494.07 million (August 2009)
•Teledensity –42.27 per cent (August 2009)
•Addition of mobile subscribers (July–August 2009) –15.08 million
•Annual growth rate of telecom subscribers (June 2008–June 2009) –42.68 per cent
•Average Revenue Per User (ARPU) for GSM (as on 30 June 2009) –US$ 3.801
•Telecom equipment market (2008–09) –US$ 24.99 billion2,3
•Handset market (2008-09) –US$ 5.82 billion2,3
•Expected mobile subscriber base (2013) –About 771 million.
Sources: 1) Exchange rate as on 30 June 2009 (1 US$ = INR 48.64380) , TRAI and TRAI; 2)
Average exchange rate for the year 2008–09 and TRAI;3) Cyber media; 4) Stock watch
Telecommunications September
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 8
9. The Key players in the Telecom Market in India
Cellular Service provider:
1. BSNL
2. Airtel
3. Vodafone
4. Reliance
5. Tata indicom
6. Spice
Subscribers
Wireless subscribers crosses 200 million mark
Tele density reaches 21.20%
The total number of telephone subscribers has reached 241.02 million at the end of
August
2009 as compared to 232.87 million in July 2009. The overall teledensity has increased to
21.20% in August 2009 as compared to 20.52% in July 2009.
In the wireless segment, 8.31 million subscribers have been added in August 2009 while
8.06 million subscribers were added in July 2007. The total wireless subscribers (GSM,
CDMA & WLL(F)) base reaches 201.29 million at the end of August 2009.
The wireline segment subscriber base stood at 39.73 million with a decrease of 0.16 million
at the end of August 2009. Circle wise wire line subscriber base of service providers is
given at following chart.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 9
10. Future Plans
The thrust areas presently are:
1. 1.Building a modern and efficient infrastructure ensuring greater competitive
environment
2. With equal opportunities and level playing field for all stakeholders.
3. Strengthening research and development for manufacturing, value added services.
4. Efficient and transparent spectrum management
5. To accelerate broadband penetration
6. Universal service to all uncovered areas including rural areas.
7. Enabling Indian telecom companies to become global players.
Recent things to watch in Indian telecom sector are:
1. 3G and BWA auctions
2. MVNO
3. Mobile Number Portability
4. New Policy for Value Added Services
5. Market dynamics once the recently licensed new telecom operators start rolling out
6. Services.
7. Increased thrust on telecom equipment manufacturing and exports.
8. Reduction in Mobile Termination Charges as the cost per line has substantially
reduced
9. Due to technological advancement and increase in traffic.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 10
11. GLOBAL SCENARIO
Until the 1980s the world telecommunications systems had a simply administrative
structure. The United States telephone service was supplied by a regulated monopoly,
American Telephone and Telegraph (AT&T). Telegraph service was provided mainly by
the Western Union Corporation. In almost all other countries both services were the
monopolies of government agencies known as PTTs (for Post, Telephone, and
Telegraph). In the United States beginning in 1983, AT&T agreed in a court settlement to
divest itself of the local operating companies that provided basic telephonic service. They
remained regulated local monopolies, grouped together into eight regional companies.
AT&T now offers long distance service in competition with half a dozen major and many
minor competitors while retaining ownership of a subsidiary that produces telephonic
equipment, computers and other electronic devices. During the same period Great
Britain’s national telephone company was sold to private investors as was Japan’s NTT
telephone monopoly. For telegraphy and data transmission, Western Union was joined by
other major companies, while many multinational firms formed their own
telecommunications services that link offices scattered throughout the world. New
technology also brought continuing changes in the providers of telecommunication.
Private companies such as Comsat in the United States were organized to provide satellite
communication links within the country. Around the world we are witnessing remarkable
changes to the telecoms environment. After years of debate, structural separation is now
taking place in many parts of the world including Hong Kong, New Zealand,
Singapore and some European markets. Structural separation – or at least full-blown
operational separation – is required to advance the entire industry and to create new
business opportunities and innovations which will benefit our society, our economy and
ultimately our industry.
The focus is also shifting away from broadband to what it can actually achieve. Next
Generation Telecommunications better describes this new environment and is essential for
the emerging digital economy. Important services that depend on NGT include tele-health,
e-
12. education, e-business, digital media, e-government and environmental applications such as
smart utility meters.
In order to meet this burgeoning consumer demand for NGT applications, we are seeing
increasing investment in All-IP Next Generation Networks and fibre networks. A proper
inventory of national infrastructure assets is required if we want to establish an efficient
and economically viable national broadband structure for these services. In the
developing markets, next generations telecoms will take the form of wireless NGNs (ie,
LTE/WiMAX). These are some of the elements of the broader ICT revolution that is
unfolding before our very eyes. We are right in the midst of the transition from old
communications structures (mainly one-way streets) to new structures that are fully-
interactive and video-based.
One of the drivers behind the industry changes are the declining revenues experienced by
the telcos in their traditional markets. Over the past 10 years or so, fixed-line operators
have been affected by deregulation, a severe industry downturn, declining prices and
major inroads by mobile services. In addition, people are drifting to other forms of
communication, such as email, online chat, and mobile text messaging instead of the
traditional phone.
This has also led to an increased need for bandwidth, which in turn has revived the
submarine cable sector. In recent times there have been many cable build-out announcements
around the world, and some major systems are again being constructed. Over 25 systems
are expected to be built over the next two to three years and network upgrades are also on
the agenda for some existing systems.
It is clear that the mobile industry is also undergoing profound changes. The saturated
developed markets are forcing the industry to find new revenue streams and we are now
seeing other organizations such as media companies, content providers, Internet
media companies and private equity companies becoming involved in this market.
For the time being however, voice will remain the killer application for mobile with some
data services included as support services and niche market services. 4G (ie,
WiMAX/LTE) is the real solution for mobile data and by 2015 it is expected that the
majority of mobile revenues will come from data.
With the Internet economy, digital media and other telecommunications activities
becoming further established, the need for modern and efficient infrastructure is
becoming more critical.
13. Telephony services (mobile and basic) and internet services
dominate the Indian telecom services market.
• The Indian telecom industry can be primarily divided into basic, cellular mobile and
internet services. It also has smaller segments such as radio paging services, Very Small
Aperture Terminals (VSATs), Public Mobile Radio Trunked Services (PMRTS) and Global
Mobile Personal Communications by Satellite (GMPCS).
• The mobile services in India are growing more than basic wire line
services.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 13
14. TECHNOLOGIES
Technology is very much related to the way we conduct business. Today everything that we talk
about in business, like, the way we conduct business, the way we do things, the way we deliver to the
customers, etc. is using some form of technology. Therefore, role of technology cannot be defined
because it is a mindset and it happens over a period of time.
The various technologies used by the Telecom Service Providers are as follows:
1 GSM (Global System for Mobile Communication)
GSM, first introduced in 1991, is the leading digital cellular system. It uses narrowband TDMA
(Time Division Multiple Access). Eight simultaneous calls can occupy the same radio frequency.
GSM simplifies data transmission to allow laptop and palmtop computers to be connected to GSM
phones. It provides integrated voice mail, high-speed data, fax, paging and Short Message Services
(SMS) capabilities, as well as secure communications. It offers the best voice quality of any current
digital wireless standard.
Originally a European standard for digital mobile telephony, GSM has become the world's most
widely used mobile system and is now being used in more than 100 countries. GSM networks operate
on the 900MHz, 1800MHz and 1900MHz wavebands all over the world.
2 GPRS (General packet radio service)
GPRS is a packet oriented mobile data service available to users of the 2G
cellular communicat ion systems glo bal system for mobile communicat ions (GSM), as well
as in the
3G systems. In the 2G systems, GPRS provides data rates of 56-114 kbit/s.
GPRS data transfer is typically charged per megabyte of traffic transferred, while data
communication via traditional circuit switching is billed per minute of connection time,
independent of whether the user actually is using the capacity or is in an idle state. GPRS is a
best-effort packet switched service, as opposed to circuit switching, where a certain
qualit y of service (QoS) is guaranteed during the connection for non-mobile users.
2G cellular systems combined with GPRS are often described as 2.5G, that is, a technology
between the second (2G) and third (3G) generations of mobile telephony. It provides
moderate speed data transfer, by using unused time divisio n mult iple access (TDMA)
channels in, for example, the GSM system. Originally there was some thought to extend
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 14
15. GPRS to cover other standards, but instead those networks are being converted to use the
GSM standard, so that GSM is the only kind of network where GPRS is in use. GPRS is
integrated into GSM Release 97 and newer releases. It was originally standardized
by European Teleco mmunicat ions Standards Institute (ETSI), but now by the 3rd
Generat ion Partnership Project (3GPP).
3 EDGE (Enhanced Data rates for GSM Evolution)
EDGE, Enhanced GPRS (EGPRS), or IMT Single Carrier (IMT-SC) is a backward-
compat ible digital mo bile phone technology that allows improved data transmission rates,
as an extension on top of standard GSM. EDGE is considered a 3G radio technology and is
part of ITU's 3G definition,[1]. EDGE was deployed on GSM networks beginning in
2003— initially by Cingular (now AT&T) in the United States.
EDGE is implemented as a bo lt -on enhancement for 2G and 2.5G GSM and GPRS networks,
making it easier for existing GSM carriers to upgrade to it. EDGE is a superset to GPRS and
can function on any network with GPRS deployed on it, provided the carrier implements the
necessary upgrade.
EDGE requires no hardware or software changes to be made in GSM core networks. EDGE
compatible transceiver units must be installed and the base station subsystem needs to be
upgraded to support EDGE. If the operator already has this in place, which is often the case
today, the network can be upgraded to EDGE by activating an optional software feature.
Today EDGE is supported by all major chip vendors for both GSM and WCDMA/HSPA.
4 CDMA (Code division multiple access)
CDMA is a channel access method utilized by various radio communication technologies.
It should not be confused with the mo bile phone standards called cdmaOne and
CDMA2000 (which are often referred to as simply "CDMA"), which use CDMA as an
underlying channe l access method.
One of the basic concepts in data communication is the idea of allowing several
transmitters to send information simultaneously over a single communication channel.
This allows several users to share a bandwidth of frequencies. This concept is called
mult iplexing.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 15
16. CDMA employs spread-spectrum technology and a special coding scheme (where each
transmitter is assigned a code) to allow multiple users to be multiplexed over the same
physical channel. By contrast, time divisio n mult iple access (TDMA) divides access by
t ime, while frequency-divisio n mult iple access (FDMA) divides it by frequency. CDMA is
a form of "spread-spectrum" signaling, since the modulated coded signal has a much
higher data bandwidth than the data being communicated.
5 HSDPA (High-Speed Downlink Packet Access)
HSDPA is a 3G (third generation) mo bile telephony co mmunicat ions protocol in the High-
Speed Packet Access (HSPA) family, which allows networks based on Universal Mobile
Teleco mmunicat ions System (UMTS) to have higher data transfer speeds and capacity.
Current HSDPA deployments support down-link speeds of 1.8, 3.6, 7.2 and 14.4 Mbit/s.
Further speed increases are available with HSPA+, which provides speeds of up to 42 Mbit/s
downlink
The High-Speed Downlink Shared Channel (HS-DSCH) lacks two basic features of other W-
CDMA channels—variable spreading factor and fast power control. Instead, it delivers the
improved downlink performance using adapt ive modulat ion and coding (AMC), fast
packet scheduling at the base station, and fast retransmissions from the base station,
known as hybrid automat ic repeat -request (HARQ).
6 WLL (Wireless Local Loop)
Wireless local loop (WLL), is a term for the use of a wireless communications link as the "last mile /
first mile" connection for delivering plain old t elephone service (POTS) and/or broadband Int ernet to
telecommunications customers. Various types of WLL systems and technologies exist.
WLL (Wireless in Local Loop) is a communication system that connects subscribers to the public
Switched Telephone Network (PSTN) using radio frequency signals as a substitute for conventional
wires for all or part of the connection between the subscriber and the telephone exchange. It is useful
for those subscribers who are located in pockets where immediate telephone connections cannot be
provided due to lack of underground cable network but radio coverage is available.
Other terms for this type of access include Broadband Wireless Access (BWA), Radio In The Loop
(RITL), Fixed-Radio Access (FRA) and Fixed Wireless Access (FWA).
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 16
17. 7 WiMax
WiMax (Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave Access) is a technology designed to
give people high speed access to the net over relatively long distances. A typical WiMax
system could theoretically give users in an area three to 10 kilometers wide a 40 Mbps
connection to the net.
This technology already deployed in some urban centres like Chennai (Madras) and Mumba
i
(Bombay) would overcome the need to lay expensive cables or fibre optics to
villages.
At the moment there is a wired backbone throughout India but many villages are 30 to
40km away from the nearest connection. Wimax services can overcome that. One or t wo
WiMax base stations are enough to connect three or four villages.
The government telecoms operator BSNL is also in the process of rolling out some
WiMax services. But it is still expensive and at the moment is aimed squarely at large
businesses that need a quick-fix solution to broadband access.
8 3G TECHNOLOGIES
3G or Third Generation technology is a convergence of various Second Generation
telecommunication systems. The technology is intended for SMARTPHONES -
multimedia cell phones. Video broadcasting and other e-commerce services such as, stock
transactions and e-learning will now be made possible much faster. It offers 3
Mbps speed for downloading, which is very high as compared to that of the 2G
technology. The 3G technology provides for internet surfing, downloading, e-mail
attachment downloading, audio-video conferencing, fax services and many other broadband
applications.
3G Technology was implemented in Japan for the first time in the world. Today the
technology is serving 25 countries over more than 60 networks having its existence in
Asia, Europe and USA. Video conferencing has been a major factor in the success
of the technology.
18. 3G Technology in Indian Teleco m Industry
From the time of telegraphs Indian telecom sector has witnessed an immense growth and
has diversified into various segments like, Fixed Line Telephony, mobile telephony,
GSM, CDMA, WLL etc. The telecom industry is growing at a fast pace introducing
newer technologies. Even the network operators and handset providers are also coming
up with newer value added services and advanced technology cell phones with
multimedia applications. Now it's time to welcome the much-awaited 3G Technology.
Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited is all set to launch the technology by December 2007. Not
o nly the network providers but also the handset providers in India are waiting eagerly for
the launch of 3G to earn very high revenues from the value added services provided by the
technology.
The technology is initially being launched on CDMA platform. The technology is being
tested over various platforms and cellular networks.
9 4G TECHNOLOGY
4G (also known as Beyond 3G), an abbreviation for Fourth-Generation, is a term used to
describe the next complete evolution in wireless communications. A 4G system will be
able to provide a comprehensive IP solution where voice, data and streamed multimedia
can be given to users on an "Anytime, Anywhere" basis, and at higher data rates than
previous generations.
As the second generation was a total replacement of the first generation networks and
handsets, and the third generation was a total replacement of second generation networks
and handsets, so too the fourth generation cannot be an incremental evolution of current
3G technologies, but rather the total replacement of the current 3G networks and handsets.
The international telecommunications regulatory and standardization bodies are working for
commercial deployment of 4G networks roughly in the 2012-2015 time scale. At that point it is
predicted that even with current evolutions of third generation 3G networks, these will tend to be
congested.
There is no formal definition for what 4G is; however, there are certain objectives that are
projected for 4G. These objectives include: that 4G will be a fully IP-based integrated
19. system. 4G will be capable of providing between 100 Mbit/s and 1 Gbit/s speeds both
indoors and outdoors, with premium qualit y and high securit y.
Many companies have taken self-serving definitions and distortions about 4G to suggest
they have 4G already in existence today, such as several early trials and launches of
WiMAX. Other companies have made prototype systems calling those 4G. While it is
possible that some currently demonstrated technologies may become part of 4G, until the
4G standard or standards have been defined, it is impossible for any company currently to
provide with any certainty wireless solutions that could be called 4G cellular networks that
would conform to the eventual international standards for 4G. These confusing statements
around "existing" 4G have served to confuse investors and analysts about the wireless
industry.
10 HOW IS 3G DIFFERENT FROM 2G AND 4G
While 2G stands for second-generation wireless telephone technology, 1G networks used are
analog, 2G networks are digital and 3G (third-generation) technology is used to enhance
mobile phone standards.
3G helps to simultaneously transfer both voice data (a telephone call) and non-voice data
(such as downloading information, exchanging e-mail, and instant messaging. The
highlight of 3G is video telephony. 4G technology stands to be the future standard of
wireless devices.
Currently, Japanese company NTT DoCoMo and Samsung are testing 4G communication.
3G services will enable video broadcast and data-intensive services such as stock
transactions, e-learning and telemedicine through wireless communications.
All telecom operators are waiting to launch 3G in India to cash in on revenues by providing
high-end services to customers, which are voice data and video enabled. India lags behind
many Asian countries in introducing 3G services.
20. The telecom subscriber base in India is likely to reach 500 million
by 2010.
• The subscriber base grew to 494.07 million (August 2009), registering a growth
of approximately 42.67 per cent over last year. It grew at a CAGR of 45.21 per cent from
June
2004 to June 2009.
•Teledensity in India is still low as compared to that in some countries. As on August 2009,
India had a teledensity of 42.27 per cent as compared to the previous year’s figure of 29.83
per cent.
source : TRAI report
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 20
21. T RA I
TELECOM REGULATORY AUTHORITY OF INDIA
Telecom Regulatory Authority Of India, a statutory and quasi-judicial body was formed
by an Act in Indian Parliament to regulate the vast telecom sector. The necessity to form
such a regulatory body in line with SEBI, IRDA etc. was felt when the telecom sector was
open to private sector. Plainly speaking its job could be comparable to an umpires’ of a
game field. It has been given the liberty to act without the intervention of bureaucracy or
some self-serving politicians,
The skirmishes encompassing TRAI came to limelight due to conflict among various
telecom operators. That’s exactly the duty of this regulatory body, as has been entrusted
with the statutory power, umpiring on behalf of the public for smooth telecom service.
If one reviews the sequence of its orders/regulations, chronologically, to various telecom
operators and the crucial policy changes with regards to service changes, the monopolistic
and arbitrary attitude is clearly visible.
Unfortunately, It’s a matter of concern that INTER CONNECT USAGE REGIME ordered
by the same agency is being reviewed again by itself within two month’s of it’s
enforcement. It could have been reviewed before it has been implemented or could have
been kept for public perception or operator’s opinion. If an telecom regulator of a country
having almost 7
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 21
22. crores telephone connections could act in such a haste manner without taking into
consideration of aspects of technical feasibility, accounting, public psyche etc. into oblivion.
Though operators have the requisite expertise technically and financially to provide
cheaper telecom service, TRAI is there only to make it costlier. e.g. BSNL and RELIANCE
. If they could offer cheaper telecom services them, TRAI should not prevent them in the
name of
’PREDATORY PRICING ’.
It’s appropriate time to review the role of TRAI and other Statutory Regulatory bodies by
the public forum and parliament as well, rather than giving it a free reign to act on this way
to the tune of certain players.
On April 25, 1997, the recently constituted Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI)
gave its first judgment -- a landmark one, delivered with speed and style. This judgment
and its no-nonsense approach could well set the stage for things to come.
TRAI quashed DoT’s (Department of Technology) order of January 29, which had sought to
hike rather steeply, the price of calls made by users of ordinary fixed line phones to
cellular subscribers in the non-metro areas.
Even the cellular operators, whose stand was accepted by the TRAI, would accept privately
that the respondent DoT was poorly served by many of its officers and lawyers who were
entrusted with the task of representing DoT’s case.
They seemed to have cut a very sorry figure before TRAI, ignoring or not being prepared by
reading pertinent papers, such as tender documents, the clarifications offered to would-be
bidders, or the correspondence that DoT was having with the operators later. Since the tender
documents mentioned that tariffs would be the same for circles and metros, it would have
made sense for DoT to seek legal advice on how to correct a mistake, if that is what it was.
An appeal to TRAI could perhaps have been recourse, as the body is in charge of tariffs.
Fixed line users pay local call rates when they dial a cellular number in the four metros
(Calcutta, Chennai, Delhi, and Mumbai). But users in the circles (which are typically the
same as states) would be charged Rs10 per call for the same facility, if the DoT order in
question had not been quashed.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 22
23. DoT had raised current rates on grounds that such charges were low and allowed users in the
circles which are much larger than metros, to make long distance calls without paying
STD charges. On the face of it, DoT is entitled to want to change this state of affairs. But in
trying to correct one injustice to itself, it managed to inflict several on the users and other
service providers.
The cellular operators lost no time in going to the courts, since TRAI did not then exist.
The courts in turn took an enlightened decision to pass the matter on to TRAI on March 3,
as the body had been formally constituted by then.
TRAI took a few weeks to give its judgment and ruled against the Department of
Telecom.
The body was not persuaded about the justness of DoT’s order.
Nor was TRAI particularly impressed by the operator’s contention that DoT was not
authorized to raise these tariffs. The judgment clearly says that the order of DoT to raise the
tariff was passed before the TRAI was formally constituted and during the said period in
question, the DoT was the sole body with the power to amend tariffs.
Mission
To ensure that the interests of consumers are protected and at the same time to nurture
conditions for growth of telecommunications, broadcasting and cable services in a manner
and at a pace which will enable India to play a leading role in the emerging global
information society. Function of Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 23
24. Functions of TRAI
1. Recommendatory Functions
Need and timing for introduction of new service provider
Terms and conditions of licence to a service provider
Revocation of license for non-compliance of terms and conditions of license
Measures to facilitate competition and promote efficiency in the operation to
facilitate growth in industry
Technological improvement in services by service providers
Inspection of type of equipment used by service provider
Efficient Management of available spectrum
2. Mandatory Functions
Ensure compliance of terms and conditions of license
Fix the terms and conditions of their inter connectivity between service providers
Ensure Technical compatibility and effective inter-connection between different
service providers.
Regulate arrangements for sharing of revenues amongst service providers
Lay-down the standards of QoS to be provided by service provider,ensure this by
periodical survey
Lay-down and ensure time period for providing local and long-distance circuits of
telecommunication between different service providers
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 24
25. 3. Other functions
Levy fees and other charges as determined by regulations
Perform administrative functions as entrusted to it by Central government or as per
TRAI act
Notify in Official Gazette the service rates and message rates within and outside India
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 25
26. Evolution of the industry-Important Milestones
History of Indian Telecommunications
Year
1851 First operational land lines were laid by the government near Calcutta (seat of
British power)
1881 Telephone service introduced in India
1883 Merger with the postal system
1923 Formation of Indian Radio Telegraph Company (IRT)
1932 Merger of ETC and IRT into the Indian Radio and Cable Communication
Company (IRCC)
1947 Nationalization of all foreign telecommunication companies to form the Posts,
Telephone and Telegraph (PTT), a monopoly run by the government's Ministry
of Communications
1985 Department of Telecommunications (DOT) established, an exclusive provider of
domestic and long-distance service that would be its own regulator (separate
from the postal system)
1986 Conversion of DOT into two wholly government-owned companies: the Videsh
Sanchar Nigam Limited (VSNL) for international telecommunications and
Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited (MTNL) for service in Metropolitan areas.
1997 Telecom Regulatory Authority of India created.
2000 DoT becomes a corporation, BSNL
2008 3-G Service is launched
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 26
27. Value added services
What is Mobile VAS?
A mobile value-added service (m-VAS) is the ability for cellular operators and service providers to
charge a premium price for the services (beyond voice conversation) they offer to their subscribers
(mobile users). Some of the services include: SMS (text messages), MMS (multimedia messages) ,
USSD (interactive menu based services) ,CRBT (caller ring back tone), video streaming , mobile
advertisements, participation in polls and contests, location based services, mCommerce (financial
transactions), Instant messaging, Infotainment services (news, weather reports, songs, recipes ),
content downloads (wallpapers, screen savers, games, ring tones), down loadable mobile
applications.
Factors driving the growth of VAS in India
The Indian VAS industry is growing at a rapid rate for various reasons. For one thing, the
Indian economy is currently booming and has a high GDP rate. Another important factor is
the availability of mobile phones and data plans at much cheaper rates. In India, VAS
services are mostly provided in monthly plans. Two or more VAS services are often
packaged together in a single set, which appeals to a lot of subscribers. Moreover, Indians
love to participate in SMS contests of reality bites, SMS contests and other digital
services. At present, VAS revenues are mostly from SMS services, but when 3G services
finally get
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 27
28. out of their red tape, an increase in the general usage of VAS is anticipated.
Early 2009, survey was conducted for mobile users based on various demographics (gender,
age, education, income ). Mobile users are spread across all parts of India. Take a look at
the summary (statistical reports) of the survey results of two popular services in Mobile
VAS: Internet usage and SMS (Voting for TV contests).
Mobile Vas in India - Statistics and Trend
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 28
29. VAS in India: Past, Present and Future
• VAS constitutes 7% of total telecom revenue for Indian operators.
• SMS constituted 55% of VAS revenue in 2006 [P2P/A2P/P2A, A = Application,
P=Person), the growth was majorly driven by reality shows like Indian
Idol/Kelloggs/KBC etc.
• Digital music (including CRBT and ringtones) constitutes 35% of VAS revenue.
• CAGR of 44% (2007 – 2010), VAS revenues will reach USD 2,744 mn (926mn $ by
2007): This is dependent on several factors like regulatory (e.g. number portability)
and non-regulatory factors.
Growth acceleration will begin in 2009, as various challenges are overcome, size of
mature user base increases, and telco focus on high end user VAS heightens
• Bollywood and Cricket is the killer content - though no significant investment has gone
beyond developing local apps or even content/services.
• Revenue share between telcos & content providers / aggregators is 70:30, substantially
more skewed in favor of telco than in other countries - further aggravated by lack of
payment mechanisms.
• SMS/IVR/Music downloads/Internet Apps/Search will see an upsurge; limited growth of
UGC and M-Commerce
• Almost half of Indians use ULCH (Ultra Low Cost Handsets)
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 29
30. Types of Value Added Services:
Sl. No. Type of Value Description
Added Service
1. News National, International, Business, Entertainment , Sports
News
2. Finance Stocks (NSE, BSE, NASDAQ), Forex
3. Entertainment Games, Mobile TV and Jokes
4. Travel Railways, Airlines
5. Downloads Logos, Ringtones, Caller tones etc.
6. Astrology service Personal Horoscope / Personalized prediction
7. Cricket Cricket scores, Match clippings, cricket commentary
8. Missed call alters Subscriber to get a SMS alert of incoming calls when
the subscriber’s mobile phone is switched off / not
reachable and busy
9. E-mail E-mail through SMS
10. Music on demand Dial a song
11. Contest Reality shows
12. GPRS / WAP Mobile Internet, Mobile Chat, Mobile TV
13. MMS Picture messages, picture clippings
14. Health Health tips, Beauty tips
15. M-commerce Transactions based services with multiple payment modes
and support in multiple domains like WAP, GPRS, SMS,
IVR and Web
16. Miscellaneous Devotional, Movies & Music, Fun, Navigation etc.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 30
31. PORTER’S FIVE FORCES
There is continuing interest in the study of the forces that impact on an organisation or an
industry, particularly those that can be harnessed to provide competitive advantage. The
ideas and models which emerged during the period from 1979 to the mid-1980s (Porter,
1998) were based on the idea that competitive advantage came from the ability to earn a
return on investment that was better than the average for the industry sector (Thurlby, 1998).
As Porter's 5 Forces analysis deals with factors outside an industry that influence the nature
of competition within it, the forces inside the industry (microenvironment) that influence
the way in which firms compete, and so the industry’s likely profitability is conducted in
Porter’s five forces model. A business has to understand the dynamics of its industries and
markets in order to compete effectively in the marketplace. Porter (1980) defined the forces
which drive competition, contending that the competitive environment is created by the
interaction of five different forces acting on a business. In addition to rivalry among
existing firms and the threat of new entrants into the market, there are also the forces of
supplier power, the power of the buyers, and the threat of substitute products or services.
Porter suggested that the intensity of competition is determined by the relative strengths of
these forces.
The nature of competition in an industry is strongly affected by suggested five forces. The
stronger the power of buyers and suppliers, and the stronger the threats of entry and
substitution, the more intense competition is likely to be within the industry. However,
these five factors are not the only ones that determine how firms in an industry will compete
– the structure of the industry itself may play an important role. Indeed, the whole five-
forces framework is based on an economic theory know as the ―Structure-Conduct-
Performance‖ (SCP) model: the structure of an industry determines organizations’
competitive behaviour (conduct), which in turn determines their profitability
(performance). In concentrated industries, according to this model, organizations would be
expected to compete less fiercely, and make higher profits, than in fragmented ones.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 31
32. M ain As pe c ts of P or te r ’s F ive F or c e
s Analys is
The original competitive forces model, as proposed by Porter, identified five forces which
would impact on an organization’s behaviour in a competitive market. These include the
following:
• The rivalry between existing sellers in the market
• The power exerted by the customers in the market
• The impact of the suppliers on the sellers
• The potential threat of new sellers entering the market
• The threat of substitute products becoming available in the market
Understanding the nature of each of these forces gives organizations the necessary insights
to enable them to formulate the appropriate strategies to be successful in their market
(Thurlby,
1998). We will examine these concepts as described by Porter’s 5 force model and as applied
to Indian telecom industry simultaneously.
33. Force 1: The Degree of Rivalry
The intensity of rivalry, which is the most obvious of the five forces in an industry, helps
determine the extent to which the value created by an industry will be dissipated through
head-to-head competition. The most valuable contribution of Porter's ―five
forces‖ framework in this issue may be its suggestion that rivalry, while important, is
only one of several forces that determine industry attractiveness.
• This force is located at the centre of the diagram
• Is most likely to be high in those industries where there is a threat of substitute
products; and existing power of suppliers and buyers in the market
Now let us understand the implication of degree of revelry in Indian telecom sector. The
dimensions of this parameter are determined by:
High Exit Barriers: In any industry, if the exit barrier is high it increases the difficulty of
any organization to leave the industry sector. So it makes any difficult to any willing to
leave company to leave the industry. The telecom industry suffers from high exit barriers,
mainly due to its specialized equipment. Networks and billing systems cannot really be
used for much else, and their swift obsolescence makes liquidat ion pretty difficult.
High Fixed Cost: The industry also suffers from high fixed cost which makes the entry
barrier also very high for the industry. It comes as no surprise that in the capital-intensive
telecom industry the biggest barrier to entry is access to finance. To cover high fixed costs,
serious contenders typically require a lot of cash. When capital markets are generous, the
threat of competitive entrants escalates. When financing opportunities are less
readily available, the pace of entry slows. Meanwhile, ownership of a telecom license can
represent a huge barrier to entry.
• 6-7 players in each region
• 3 out of 4 BIG-Four present in each region
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 33
34. Very less time to gain advantage by an innovation: Every company in this industrial sector
in investing a huge amount in research and development and marketing strategy. That is
why we see any offer launched by any company is counter attacked by other companies
very soon. This makes the industry rivalry most prominent.
Eg. Caller tunes, life time card
Price wars: The price war is really very fierce in this industry. Price war in telecom
industry has commoditized the market that branding has taken a backseat.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 34
35. Force 2: The Threat of New Entrants
Both potential and existing competitors influence average industry profitability. The threat
of new entrants is usually based on the market entry barriers. They can take diverse forms
and are used to prevent an influx of firms into an industry whenever profits, adjusted for the
cost of capital, rise above zero. In contrast, entry barriers exist whenever it is difficult or
not economically feasible for an outsider to replicate the incumbents’ position. The
most common forms of entry barriers, except intrinsic physical or legal obstacles, are as
follows:
• Economies of scale: In telecom industry the economies of scale exists from the
supplier side. That is why companies try to increase their subscriber base at
drastic rate.
• Distribution channels: Distribution channels are also providing a major
determining factor. These channels are not loyal to any company and
competitors can easily access them and make out work for them.
• Customer Switching Costs: Customer switching cost is very low, as cost of new
connection is really low. And new connection offers more benefits to
the customers.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 35
36. Force 3: The Threat of Substitutes
The threat that substitute products pose to an industry's profitability depends on the
relative price-to-performance ratios of the different types of products or services to which
customers can turn to satisfy the same basic need. The threat of substitution is also
affected by switching costs – that is, the costs in areas such as retraining, retooling and
redesigning that are incurred when a customer switches to a different type of product or
service. It also involves:
• Product-for-product substitution (email for mail, fax); is based on the substitution
of need;
• Generic substitution (Video suppliers compete with travel companies);
• Substitution that relates to something that people can do without (cigarettes, alcohol).
Now let us discuss this concept for telecom industry. The potential major substitutes for
telecom industry are as follows
VOIP (Skype, Messenger etc.)
Online Chat
Email
Satellite phones
All of these technologies have a huge potential, though none of the above a major threat
in current scenario. So the telecom industry has to keep a close look on these substitutes.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 36
37. Force 4: Buyer Power
Buyer power is one of forces that influence the appropriation of the value created by an
industry. The most important determinants of buyer power are the size and the
concentration of customers. Other factors are the extent to which the buyers are
informed and the concentration or differentiation of the competitors. Kippenberger (1998)
states that it is often useful to distinguish potential buyer power from the buyer's
willingness or incentive to use that power, willingness that derives mainly from the ―risk
of failure‖ associated with a product's use.
• This force is relatively high where there a few, large players in the market, as it is
the case with retailers a grocery stores;
• Present where there is a large number of undifferentiated, small suppliers, such as
small farming businesses supplying large grocery companies;
• Low cost of switching between suppliers, such as from one fleet supplier of trucks to another.
In the context of Indian telecom industry we can say that the following points influence
the buyer power:
Lack of differentiation among the service provider
Cut throat competition
Customer is price sensitive
Low switching costs
Number portability to have negative impact
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 37
38. Force 5: Supplier Power
Supplier power is a mirror image of the buyer power. As a result, the analysis of supplier power
typically focuses first on the relative size and concentration of suppliers relative to industry
participants and second on the degree of differentiation in the inputs supplied.
The ability to charge customers different prices in line with differences in the value created for each
of those buyers usually indicates that the market is characterized by high supplier power and at the
same time by low buyer power.
In the drawback of Indian telecom industry the following should be kept in mind:
Large number of suppliers: The industry basically has a large number of suppliers,
which helps them to choose from a lot of options. So they try to select the best option
to deliver the value to the customers and to have a competitive advantage from
their competitor.
Shared tower infrastructure: Technology has helped them to share the tower
infrastructure. This basically helps them to reduce the initial investment a lot.
Limited pool of skilled managers and engineers especially those well versed in the
latest.
Medium cost of switching since changing their hardware would lead to additional cost
in modifying the architecture.
Overall influence on the industry – medium.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 38
39. SWOT ANALYSIS
A scan of the internal and external environment is an important part of the strategic planning
process. Environmental factors internal to the firm usually can be classified as strengths (
S) or weaknesses (W), and those external to the firm can be classified as opportunities (O)
or threats (T). Such an analysis of the strategic environment is referred to as a SWOT
analysis. The SWOT analysis provides information that is helpful in matching the firm's
resources and capabilities to the competitive environment in which it operates. As such, it is
instrumental in strategy formulation and selection. The following diagram shows how a
SWOT analysis fits into an environmental scan:
SWOT Analysis Framework
Environmental Scan
Internal Analysis External Analysis
Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities Threats
SWOT Matrix
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 39
40. Strengths
Here we will analyze the strengths of the telecom industry as a whole. The most important
factors are:
• Technology is advanced and easy to implement: For telecom industry the
technology is really advanced and more and more investment is done on
technology to get world class infrastructure and knowhow to put in this fie ld.
Recently the telecom sector is going to add 3G spectrum as its latest up-gradation.
• Management Team has prior experience: The management team controlling
Indian telecom sector in really efficient. Thank goes to the IITs which produce
world class engineers. So Indian telecom sector has abundance of
technological knowhow.
Weakness
The weaknesses of the Indian telecom sector are as follows.
• High Cost of Infrastructure: The infrastructure cost of telecom industry is very
high.
• Low customer retention power: The customer retention power for telecom
industry is really low and the customer changes their service provider
company very soon.
Opportunity
• Population: The population of India is really an opportunity of telecom service
providers, as the number of population without telecom service is also very high.
The industry has to target India’s huge population to grow.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 40
41. • Changing Population psychograph: Population psychograph is also changing.
Previously telecom service was thought as an emergency service, now it has
become an essential part of life in our country.
• Increased Penetration Level: All the organizations of the industry are trying to
increase their penetration level, in other word to increase the tele-density of the
country. The urban Indian population gives a real growth prospect to the industry.
• FDI: The foreign direct investment in telecom has been hiked up from 49% to 74%.
This move is positive for the sector, as it requires investments of Rs 700 –900
million over the next 5 years. FDI inflow by 2004 was 9950.94 cores in telecom.
Countries like Europe, Korea, and Japan telecom are likely to enter India, as India
is seen as fastest growing telecom market in world.
Threats
The treats to the industry are the following:
• Government Policies – Government may provide licenses to many foreign operators,
which may already have pose a threat for the existing players in the industry.
• New Technology can change the market dynamics: A lot of new technologies are
coming. Then even have the potential of changing the entire industry dynamics or
even create substitute of the telecom services existing.
Some of the examples are follows:
VOIP (Skype, Messenger etc.)
Online Chat
Email
Satellite phones
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 41
42. Chapter – 4
Introduction to Mobile Marketing Sector
1. Introduction
Marketing mobile
Marketers must remember that mobile cannot, and must not, be treated like other mass
mediums out there.
Mobile is a highly personal channel, with attendant sensitivities and double opt-in
permission requirements. So it’s not the quantity that should matter for marketers looking to
incorporate mobile into their multichannel marketing plans. It’s the quality – and that’s
where mobile excels.
While the economy could be better, that hasn’t stopped consumers from quickly shifting
to mobile many tasks that previously were conducted on computers.
The choice for marketers and ad agencies then is not to deliberate whether to have an SMS
program or mobile banner ads or a mobile Web site or a mobile coupon program or a .mobi
domain or an iPhone/BlackBerry/Android application.
Instead, the decision to be made is which one of these options – or a combination – is
relevant for the brand in its efforts to reach consumers through multiple, relevant touch
points.
Smart marketers and agencies will think like smart fishermen: fish where the fish are.
Consumers have already moved to mobile, and are staying there for a long time.
Marketers should focus this year and next on using mobile – especially SMS and
applications
– to build databases of consumers who have opted in not once but twice to receive targeted
offers, alerts and information from marketers.
A marketer without a mobile loyalty program in 2009 or 2010 will risk losing customers to
competitors who have such efforts in place
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 42
43. “Mobile advertising has increasingly become a two-way street, providing a link for engagement
between customers and companies,” said Bob Kraut, vice president of marketing
communications at Pizza Hut.
“Rather than simply giving customers information, companies are using mobile advertising as a way
to provide customers with meaningful brand engagement,” he said.
“In 2009, you’ll see an increase in people using mobile devices to make purchases. Mobile
advertising will give consumers a way to immediately interact with Pizza Hut by placing an order
entirely from their mobile devices.”
.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 43
44. 2. CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
2.1. Mobile Phone, Mobile Marketing and Mobile Commerce
One of the marketers‟ demands is to be able to communicate with potential customers and to
contact them anywhere and anytime. Mobile phone made a revolutionary contribution to fulfilling
the anywhere and anytime connectivity marketers‟ wishes. Yuan and Cheng (2004) emphasize that
mobile marketing is getting increasingly popular because mobile phone is a personal device used in
marketing. Scharl et al., (2005) define mobile marketing as using a wireless medium to provide
consumers with time- and location-sensitive, personalized information that promotes products,
services and ideas, thereby benefiting all stakeholders. Shortly, mobile marketing refers to
marketing activities and programs performed via mobile phone in mobile commerce.
The rapid growth of mobile phone has also come up with a new term: mobile commerce. It has a
strong impact on industries like e-commerce in general (E-Business Report, 2000) and transformed
mobile commerce into a major driving force for the next wave of e-commerce (Liang and Wei,
2004). The growth and use of mobile commerce as an emerging technology has the potential to
dramatically change the way consumers make business. Mobile commerce driven by wireless
communication technology is also generating interest from marketers (Aungst and Wilson, 2005).
Therefore, the penetration of this new technology has evoked changes in advertising, retailing and
shopping in marketing, and companies wishing to make business in mobile markets should be ready
for mobile marketing and mobile commerce.
In the literature, all mobile commerce definitions are very similar. In principle, any transaction with
a monetary value conducted via mobile communication networks can be considered mobile
commerce (E-Business Report, 2000). As regards this definition, Siau et al., (2001) define mobile
commerce as a new type of e-commerce transaction conducted through mobile devices using
wireless telecommunication networks and other wired e-commerce technologies. Dholakia and
Dholakia (2004) describe mobile commerce as electronic commerce transactions carried out via
mobile phones and wireless terminals. Bai et al., (2005) simply identify as the transaction conducted
over a wireless telecommunication network, either directly or indirectly. Briefly, mobile commerce
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 44
45. can be understood as a business model that allows a consumer to complete all steps of a
commercial transaction using a mobile phone (DSTI/CP, 2006).
In mobile commerce, mobile marketing is increasingly prevailing and appealing to marketing for
many reasons. For example, consumers carry them every day, everywhere, and mobile phones are
almost always on (Yuan and Cheng, 2004). The forces underpinning the emergence of mobile
commerce can be summarized as (1) proliferation of mobile devices, (2) convergence of mobile
telecommunication networks and Internet, (3) transition to 3G (Third Generation Mobile System),
and (4) the emergence of broad set of highly personalized location applications and services (Sadeh,
2002). Therefore, mobile commerce has attracted growing attention over the last few years and
continued to revolutionize marketplaces by introducing new business models as well as offering
some advantages to customers, retailers and GSM operators. Even though Barnes (2002) put
forward that the diffusion of mobile commerce services are very poor so far due to high cost, slow
transmission rates, high power consumption of devices and inadequate mobile interfaces, mobile
commerce come true these days because of the wireless mobile technology developments and 3G
phones.
2.2. Mobile Commerce Businesses and Services
In addition to e-commerce, mobile commerce creates new marketplaces among producers,
distributors, retailers and customers anywhere and at any time. seen in Figure 1, mobile commerce
models are divided into B2B (business to business) and B2C (business to customer) perspectives.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 45
46. B2C mobile commerce is composed of three parts: GSM operators or retailers, customers and
logistics providers. GSM operators or retailers adopt pull promotion strategy over
customers who have mobile phones in order to market and sell products and services.
Customers can order products and services via mobile phone and purchase them. Logistics
providers carry them from warehouse or store to customers. B2C perspective is just one
example where this kind of powerful information could be aggregated by a carrier or a
service provider for marketing purposes (Casal et al., 2004). B2C mobile commerce
also requires a strong relationship among customers, retailers, GSM operators, logistic
providers and banks etc. (Barutçu, 2007).
Basically, mobile commerce is a service-based business, and many business opportunities
are offered in mobile commerce. Various classification attempts have been made in the
literature to classify existing and possible mobile commerce services like commerce,
shopping, entertaining, advertising, information service and personal interaction
(Schnicke, 2002). According to Leem et al., (2004), the B2C mobile commerce is
subdivided into commerce, intermediary and information models, and subcategories of B2C
models represent the current outstanding mobile businesses in Figure 2. Funk (2005)
analyzed the potential mobile service applications and explained how mobile phone
affects the business, marketing and entertainment as seven applications; (1) multi-
media mail, (2) mobile phones as portable entertainment players, (3) mobile marketing,
(4) mobile shopping, (5) navigation, (6) use in
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 46
47. lieu of tickets and money, and (7) mobile intranet applications. Consumers’
Attitudes
Towards Mobile Marketing and Mobile Commerce in Consumer Markets 19
Location-based mobile information and service play a significant part in B2C
mobile commerce. The vast majority of uses for location-based mobile services are
likely to be commercial, involving the provision of specific services adapted to individual
profiles and their location (Casal et al., 2004). Using the information on the users
identity, position, access time, and profiles, GSM operators or retailers can offer the users
optimal information or services, which are contextually relevant to them at the point of
need (Liang et al., 2004) and the resulting customers‟ location data can be used for direct
marketing (Casal et al.,
2004). To this date, GSM operators have been most interested in the use of location
information for providing innovative location-based mobile services. These services have
gained attention as companies are facing new opportunities in offering more customized
services. The ability to identify the customer's location at a certain time is one of the
most promising applications of mobile commerce (Barnes, 2003; Pura, 2005).
By using new browsers and other mobile applications, the new range of mobile
technology
offers the Internet „in user pocket‟ for which the users possibilities are endless, including
48. banking, booking or buying tickets, shopping and real-time news (Barnes, 2002). When
using the mobile Internet, mobile phone users reach all web pages via 3G mobile phone
without computer. Therefore, Funk (2004) described the key technological trajectories
and their potential effect on the expansion of mobile Internet applications. The
advanced mobile Internet technologies make the phone a portable entertainment player, a
new marketing tool for retailers and manufacturers, a multi-channel shopping device, a
navigation tool, a new type of ticket and money, and a new mobile intranet device.
2.3. Mobile Marketing Tools
Mobile advertising, mobile sales promotion, mobile entertainment and mobile shopping
stand out as the critical elements in mobile marketing and mobile commerce.
(i) Mobile Advertising: A key component of mobile marketing communication is
advertising, either in a push or pull mode. After obtaining the consumer‟s permission,
push advert ising sends relevant but not explicitly requested text and video messages.
Quah and Lim (2002) argue that the push model will dominate mobile advertising since it
saves consumers‟ time and money compared to browsing content. SMS and MMS
messages are main mobile advertising systems. SMS has become a technological
buzzword in transmitting B2C messages to such wireless devices as mobile phones.
Many brands and media companies include text message numbers in their
advertisements to enable interested consumers t o obtain more information. This mode of
advertising takes advantage of valuable channels of wireless communication to enhance
customer relationships, and to carry out direct marketing and promotional activities (Frolick
and Chen, 2004). Moreover, MMS has provided more visual and active messages.
Marketers can benefit from the use of photos, music, logos and animation, videos by
advertising to consumers' mobile phones. SMS and MMS advertising are expected to
achieve higher response rates than that of e-mail or television because all advertisements
can be sent personally.
(ii) Mobile Sales Promotion: Sales promotion is one of the promotional mix including coupons,
discounts, rebates, free samples, gifts and incentive items in order to observe an immediate effect
on sales. Mobile coupons in sales promotion play a vital role, and marketers can predict a higher
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 48
49. usage of mobile compared to their paper-based equivalents. Mobile coupons boast at least three
advantages: (1) targeting based on mobile phone numbers, (2) time sensitivity, and (3) efficient
handling by scanning the coupon‟s bar code at the point of sale (Scharl et al., 2005). Thousands of
Japanese retailers, restaurants, manufacturers, and other companies employ the mobile Internet to
send discount coupons, conduct surveys, and offer free samples to registered users via mobile mail.
For example, many restaurants use these mobile-based coupons to offer temporary discounts on
slow nights, thus creating a form of dynamic pricing (Funk 2005).
(iii) Mobile Entertainment: The mobile phone has become an important media and entertainment
platform. In the mobile entertainment industry, there are lots of entertainment services like
listening music, playing games, gambling, watching television, video and sport matches etc., which
have set a stage for an explosion of mobile entertainment industry.
(iv) Mobile Shopping: Mobile phone is an exciting tool to expand customers‟ shopping options after
the Internet. At first, mobile phone can seem like a scary place to shop; however, mobile phone
users can go online to buy just about Consumers’ Attitudes Towards Mobile Marketing and Mobile
Commerce in Consumer Markets 21 anything their need or want. Used properly, mobile shopping is
a new easy, practical, and economical shopping tool. The sudden growth of mobile shopping has
placed mobile retailers at consumers‟ fingertips, and allowed mobile phone users to purchase
nearly anything they desire without ever leaving their houses and offices.
2.4. Success Factors and Barriers of Mobile Commerce and Mobile Marketing
There seem to be a good many issues that require attention from both the practitioner and
academic worlds in mobile commerce and mobile marketing. Researchers from several
countries gathered at the Fourth International Conference on Telecommunications
and Information Markets to discuss some of the issues regarding e-commerce and
mobile commerce in July 2001 (Dholakia, 2004). The fact that mobile commerce is not
mature brings many challenges to mobile commerce adopters. Integrating content,
software and hardware design and reconfiguring an effective business model to
implement mobile commerce requires careful study and decision making (Wu and Hisa,
2004). Therefore, developing a successful mobile commerce system needs to meet a variety
of success factors,
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 49
50. including process supports, functional capability, implementation, marketing (Bai et
al.,
2005) and improving trust.
Major barriers to mobile commerce and mobile marketing are the mobile web browsers,
technological skills, perception of risks and traditional shopping culture, lack of
awareness and understanding of the benefits provided by them. While it is possible to use
the mobile phone itself to purchase products, the small screens and keyboards make it
difficult to search for products. Because the small screen and keyboard make it
demanding to search for products via a search engine, a large number of the products
purchased with a mobile phone are selected from personalized mail services that provide
information on a specific type of product, which the user has registered for (Funk
2005) On the other hand, security, tangibility, and the lack of experience are also main
barriers of mobile commerce (Fenech,
2002). Therefore, Yuan and Cheng (2004) and Bai et al., (2005) suggested that special
software like recommender system or intelligent on-line purchasing advisors should be
developed in order to recommend or advice products and services on a one-to-one basis.
Recommender systems of automated product recommendation acquire customers'
preferences and recommend products accordingly on a one-to-one basis in real time at a
lower cost (Yuan and Cheng, 2004). Intelligent online purchasing advisors will assist buyers
in specifying their product requirements, searching for product information and selecting
the best supplier (Bai et al., 2005).
2.5. Mobile Marketing Strategy
Mobile marketing strategies and tools are directed at the mobile target market/markets to
enhance or change their buying behaviors and overcome barriers of mobile commerce. In
order to successfully market products and services via mobile phone, marketers and
retailers should gain an insight into mobile phone users‟ attitudes, perceptions,
characteristics, and shopping patterns. For example, Tsang et al., (2004) investigated
consumer attitudes toward mobile advertising and the relationship between attitude and
behavior. The results of their survey indicate that consumers generally have negative
attitudes toward mobile advertising unless they have specifically consented to receive the
advertising messages. Therefore, in
51. order to develop mobile advertising messages and mobile marketing mix (product, price,
promotion place) mobile marketers should ask and answers some questions as seen in
Figure
3 (Bourke, 2006).
Figure 3: Stages of Mobile Marketing Strategy
Briefly, mobile marketing managers should determine target customers and understand their
demographics characteristics to develop successful mobile marketing programs and strategies .
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 51
52. 3. The future of mobile marketing
As Mobile Marketer’s Outlook 2009 proves, marketers understand the need to integrate
mobile into their multi-channel branding, customer acquisition and customer retention plans.
Top of the trends list is the consumer’s growing comfort with consuming news and content
on mobile phones, along with exchanging SMS text messages, shopping for products and
services, checking email, playing games, conducting mobile banking transactions and
searching for retail locations or driving directions.
Indeed, the mobile channel’s use as a location-enabling tool is quickly becoming evident
to brands, ad agencies, retailers and, most importantly, consumers.
MOBILES ALLOWS YOU TO USE VARIOUS TOOLS & ITS UNIQUE
FACTORS
• Click-to-call :- Call the call center
• Click-to-video :- Watch the video on your phone
• Click-to-participate :- Contest to win goodies or generate leads
• Click-to-download :- Download branded/paid/unpaid mobile content
• Click-to-SMS :- SMS yourself or your friends address or m-coupon
Mobile Has unique form factors
• Screen is small – less is better than more
• Not all phone are same – use 80:20 rule
• Phone and computer are different –
– @symbol
– Long drop-down
– Field validations
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 52
53. “Compared to traditional media and wired Web advertising, mobile
is claimed to typically deliver better ROI.”
How to budget for a mobile marketing campaign
The most important factor for marketers to keep in mind is the goals of the campaign and
which mobile channels are best suited to attain those goals. About the only consensus in
the mobile industry on this topic is that there are many variables to consider and that costs
range widely depending on the scale and complexity of the campaign.
Many industry insiders claimed that a basic mobile campaign can be launched for much
less than an online, print or television effort.
―Surprisingly, SMS alert, WAP mobile Web site, mobile banner ad campaigns and pre-
roll/post-roll mobile video ad campaigns are not as expensive as one would think,‖ said
Edward Lang, senior vice president/general manager of mobile for Playboy Media Group,
Los Angeles.
Another industry executive claimed that a bare-bones SMS/text alert campaign can
be launched for a few hundred dollars – excluding the cost of the common short code – and
that a basic mobile Web/WAP campaign can be launched for several thousand dollars.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 53
54. Mobile marketing in INDIA
India – Essential Facts
• Over 700 million people below the age of 30!
– First internet experience for this generation will be through the mobile
–
• 350 million+ mobile phone users estimated to double to over 700
million in 3 years!
– 8 to 10 million new users added a month
• Mobile internet users outnumber broadband users by 19 to 1
– 38 million mobile internet users as of Oct 2008
– Mobile internet users doubled in the last 12 months
• Most of the handsets sold in India are internet enabled
• India is the largest consumer of mobile internet in Asia
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 54
55. • Reported by Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
Entertainment dominates mobile internet consumption in India
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 55
56. Why mobile advertising in India is a winning bet
• Mobile enjoys a higher market penetration than fixed internet
– In emerging markets like India the mobile phone, rather than the PC, is the primary
connected device
• This gives mobile a great opportunity for being one of the main advertising mediums,
especially in a more digital future
• Catalysts for industry growth
– Dropping data charges
– Increasing recognition amongst agencies
– Advertisers increasingly focused on measurability
– Increasing capabilities of mobile devices
– Better connectivity and user experience
Mobile marketing statistics
The future of mobile marketing is bright. Very bright.
• 200+ million Americans carry mobile phones—over half of the country's population
• Cell phones are used by over 3.1 billion people globally
• 40% of major brands have deployed text messaging (SMS) campaigns
• 18% of major brands have deployed multimedia messaging (MMS) campaigns
Source: Airwide Solutions independent survey of 50 brand name companies
• The global mobile advertising market will be valued at over $16 billion by 2011
• In August 2007, nearly 40 million US consumers received SMS advertisements, and 12
percent responded to them
Source: M:Metrics, Common Short Codes: Cracking the Mobile Marketing Code
• A survey of 2,400 moms reveals that the single most important tech gadget in their lives
is the cell phone (23%), followed by the Internet (21%) and the digital camera (19%)
Source: Babycenter.com, March 2008
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 56
57. From advertising to invertising
Though mobile is a powerful tool for targeting consumers, marketers have been cautious
about tapping this medium since it often intrudes into the consumers' private space.
Besides, the National Do Not Disturb (NDND) Registry of telecom regulator TRAI
(Telecom Regulatory Authority of India) seeks to curb unsolicited commercial
communications (UCCs). The NDNC Registry is a database of telephone numbers of
subscribers who do not want to receive UCCs.
As they tap on this growing medium, SMS marketing companies must also overcome
spamming. To do this, they have created various platforms designed to satisfy the needs
of both advertisers and consumers.
According to Saxena, there are two ways to ensure no messages are sent to subscribers on
the
NDNC Registry.
"One, we insist on scrubbing the messages with the NDNC list. Two, subscribers
explicitly opt-in to any service or messages. This has been pioneered by us," Saxena said.
For instance, if you buy something from a retail store and want to be updated on this
product, you "invite" information from the store on new arrivals and it will send multiple
SMS messages every month telling you what's new. You can also opt-out of this service.
This concept, known as invertising or invited-advertising, seeks to prohibit
spam.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 57
58. Chapter – 5
Analysis
1. I decide to purchase on the basis of advertisements
Here it can be analyzed that majority people are neutral but we can see that 28 % people
are agree with the statement. So gives clear idea that some how advertisement do effect
on the mind set of consumer
2. I do not respond to tele-callers
Here it can be analyzed that majority is with the option of agree and majority are
strongly agree also so most of the people do not like to respond tele-callers at all.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 58
59. 3. I always seek detailed information before purchasing any product.
Here it can be analyzed that majority are strongly agree with this statement that they
seek full information before purchasing
4. I get angry if caller calls frequently
Here it can be analyzed that majority is with the option of agree and majority are strongly
agree also so most of the people do not like that callers call them on the frequent basis and
ask for the feed back or something as reminder for the purchasing
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 59
60. 5. Advertisement is the best source to decide to buy any product.
Here it can be analyzed that majority are agree and neutral so by the cross checking of
question 1 and question 5 are almost same respond. So it can be clear those respondents
are truly aware about the filling questionnaire
6. Mobile is more than just means of communication
Majority are fully agreed with the statement because they think that mobile phone can be
use for entertaining perspective. And today most of the teenagers use mobile for that
perspective only as camera facilities are also available.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 60
61. 7. I check full details before buying any new product.
Here this statement is asked for the verification of the respondent is giving true respond or
rd
not. It is cross checked with the 3 question. So it can be said that majority of
respondents had given true respond. As the ratio is almost same for both the statements.
8. I always give response to sms
Here it can be analyzed that respondents like to delete the sms are rarely read it on the
immediate basis. As they read the sms only when they get time .only students do the
immediate respond to sms.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 61
62. Q1. Do you have registered for DND ( do not disturb service ) ?
Ho : Preference for the DND registration is independent on the occupation at the
significance level of 0.05
H1 : Preference for the DND registration is dependent on the occupation at the
significance level of 0.05
DND * Occupation Crosstabulation
Count
Occupation
student Business man Employee Total
DND yes 0 4 4 8
no 49 11 32 92
Total 49 15 36 100
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 62
63. Chi-Square Tests
Asymp. Sig. (2-
Value df sided)
a
Pearson Chi-Square 11.836 2 .003
Likelihood Ratio 13.241 2 .001
Linear-by-Linear Association 4.101 1 .043
N of Valid Cases 100
a. 3 cells (50.0%) have expected count less than 5. The minimum expected
count is 1.20.
• Out of the 100 respondents 92 have not registered for the DND as they like to know
various schemes through mobile marketing. And they also want that they are
interested in the calls coming from the service provider.
• In the hypothesis chi-square calculated is 11.836 but tabulated is .103 so hypothesis is
rejected. So it also can be analyzed that preference of registration to DND is
dependent on the occupation of the person.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 63
64. Q2. Do you use GPRS ?
Ho : GPRS usage is independent on the occupation at the significance level of 0.05
H1 : GPRS usage is dependent on the occupation at the significance level of 0.05
GPRS * Occupation Crosstabulation
Count
Occupation
student Business man Employee Total
GPRS yes 22 10 18 50
no 27 1 14 42
Total 49 11 32 92
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 64
65. Chi-Square Tests
Asymp. Sig. (2-
Value df sided)
a
Pearson Chi-Square 7.737 2 .021
Likelihood Ratio 8.863 2 .012
Linear-by-Linear Association 1.405 1 .236
N of Valid Cases 92
a. 0 cells (.0%) have expected count less than 5. The minimum expected
count is 5.02.
• Here it can be analyzed that students are the most users of GPRS than others.
• Here chi-square tabulated is 0.103 and which is lesser than calculated which is 7.737
so it is rejected at the significance level of 0.05. So the analysis says that GPRS
usage is dependent on the occupation.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 65
66. Q3. Do you use internet ?
Here it can be analyzed that the internet users are same at all the levels and it is not
dependent on the occupation. As internet usage is must for every individual today. By this
question it also can be conclude that internet users not only use internet for the
registration on the web-sites like MY-TOADY. They register with sms also which gives
revenue to both marketer as well as service provider.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 66
67. Q 4. Do you have 3G enabled mobile phone?
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 67
68. Ho : 3G enabled mobile usage is independent on the occupation at the significance level
of 0.05
H1 : 3G enabled mobile usage is dependent on the occupation at the significance level of
0.05
third_generation * Age Crosstabulation
Count
Age
18-23 24-29 30-35 Total
third_generation Yes 12 6 7 25
No 42 17 8 67
Total 54 23 15 92
Chi-Square Tests
Asymp. Sig. (2-
Value df sided)
a
Pearson Chi-Square 3.563 2 .168
Likelihood Ratio 3.298 2 .192
Linear-by-Linear Association 2.985 1 .084
N of Valid Cases 92
a. 1 cells (16.7%) have expected count less than 5. The minimum expected count
is 4.08.
Here it can be analyzed that the age group of 30-35 are using 3G enabled mobile than any
other age group as in Gujarat 3G service is not yet started so many people do not have that
mobile phone. As business men use that phone because they want facilities like video-
conferencing. And also like to use internet so that they can send e-mail and download files.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 68
69. Q5. Which sites you have registered ?
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 69
70. Here it can be analyzed that sms-gupshup is more famous and subscribed by many than
any other sms providing and mean of the sms-gupshup is 0.42 which is highest among all
the other sites and the second highest is mytoday site which has 0.37 mean. As the skew
ness in all the graphs is at right hand side in all the graphs. Which shows that it is far from
the mean means selected is less than not selected in all.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 70
71. Q6. How do you currently react on receiving
mobile advertising through sms ?
Descriptive Statistics
N Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation
mobile_advertising_through_ 92 1.00 3.00 1.7391 .69329
sms
Valid N (listwise) 92
Here it can be analized that the more number of people like read the sms but rarely try to
nd
follow it. Mean is 1.7931 which suggests that the average is fall near by the 2 option
which
is selected by many.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 71
72. Q7. Recall of the brand increase if you get sms
on mobile
Descriptive Statistics
N Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation
recall_increase 92 1.00 3.00 2.0000 .81200
Valid N (listwise) 92
• Here it can analysed that people are not much aware that whether the recall
is increased or not. Here the mean is 2.0000 which suggest that recall do not increase
by mobile marketing.
• As many respondents has selected can’t say option which suggests they are not aware
whether recall increases or not.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 72
73. Q8. In how much time you delete the sms?
Descriptive Statistics
N Minimum Maximum Mean Std. Deviation
Time_to_delete_sms 92 1.00 4.00 1.4565 .81757
Valid N (listwise) 92
Here it can analyzed that people like to ignore such sms and do not like to store it in mobile
which clearly gives idea that people are not like to give response or search for it.
N.R.INSTITUTE OF BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 73