OER in Practice: The Big Idea of Open Education
Open education is currently a big idea that is playing out globally in higher education with potentially transformative effects on the sector. Already we can see that openness in education takes different forms: in some instances, resources may be accessible but not free to use - conditions apply. OER offers more than accessible education resources, it is also a standard for reusable and participatory education. The OER movement is a particular form of global open education that is now in its second decade of growth. The type of openness provided through OER implies specific practices of use, reuse, licensing and repurposing. This Webinar will give a quick tour over the OER global landscape, mark out some controversies and spaces to watch, and also demonstrate how to put OER into practice at the local level
Open Education Resources in Practice: Webinar to JCU
1. OER in Practice:
The Big Idea of
Open Education
John Hannon, La Trobe Learning & Teaching
Simon Huggard, La Trobe University Library
La Trobe University 2014
latrobe.edu.au CRICOS Provider 00115M
2. Practice: The Big Idea of Open Education
1. OER: What it is, what it looks like.
2. Impact: OER as a Big Idea
3. OER in practice
4. Levels of OER: From access to read-write (RW)
5. OER matters: Transformative?
6. OER Challenges
7. OER to OEP: Open Education Practices
8. Embedding OER: Examples. What you can do?
Click to edit Master text styles 2
3. Open education OER: What resources it is, what (OER)
it looks like
OER is Open Education Resources:
OER “are educational materials which are licensed in ways that provide
permissions for individuals and institutions to reuse, adapt and modify the
materials for their own use.” OER Foundation. http://wikieducator.org/OERF:Home
Definitions: https://wiki.creativecommons.org/What_is_OER
RATIONALE for OER:
“the simple and powerful idea that the world’s knowledge is a public good
and that technology in general and the Worldwide Web in particular provide
an extraordinary opportunity for everyone to share, use, and reuse
knowledge." The William and Flora Hewlett Foundation
Click to edit Master text styles 3
4. Open education resources (OER)
OER: What it is, what it looks like
Full courses, textbooks, streaming videos, exams, software, and any other
materials or techniques supporting learning
Learning content:
courseware, modules,
objects, collections and
journals
Tools: software to
support the
development, use, re-use
and delivery of
learning content
Implementation
Resources: eg.
intellectual property
licenses to promote
open publishing,
design principles of
best practice and
localisation of
content
Bossu et al. (2014) Adoption, use & management of OER..., OLT Report.
wikiresearcher.org/OER_in_Australia
Click to edit Master text styles 4
5. Impact: OER as a big idea
The NMC Horizon Report: 2013 Higher Education
Edition (Johnson et al. (2013)
The OLCOS Roadmap (Geser 2012)
OPAL Report (2011) Beyond OER: Shifting Focus to
Open Educational Practices
They argue that: open practices of knowledge
creation challenge the arrangements for university
teaching
Click to edit Master text styles 5
6. Impact of OER: Australia
OLT Report, Bossu et al. (2014)
OER worldwide - a “rapid global expansion”
distance providers reaching “millions of learners”
OERs increase collaboration institutionally and
internationally;
can save time and avoid duplication of effort;
can improve quality of educational materials;
can increase access and participation in HE across
Australia
Bridging the gap: Teaching adaptations
across the disciplines and sharing
content for curriculum renewal
(The Adapt Project)
Final Report 2013
University of Tasmania (lead institution)
Professor Imelda Whelehan (project leader)
Professor David Sadler
Dr Lisa Fletcher
Monash University
Dr Christopher Worth
The University of Queensland
Associate Professor Jason Jacobs
Associate Professor Frances Bonner
The University of Western Australia
Dr Hila Shachar
Report Authors: Felix Wilson, Professor Imelda Whelehan and Professor
David Sadler
www.adapt.edu.au
Bridging the gap: Teaching adaptations
across the disciplines and sharing
content for curriculum renewal
(The Adapt Project)
Final Report 2013
University of Tasmania (lead institution)
Professor Imelda Whelehan (project leader)
Professor David Sadler
Dr Lisa Fletcher
Bridging the gap
Develop national “subject-based communities” in
CoP methodologies
Link “dispersed and possibly atomised scholars
across institutional boundaries”
Click to edit Master text styles 6
7. Impact of OER: global
Best practice examples
http://www.dehub.edu.au/publications/occasional-papers/
List of courses, lectures, videos, textbooks, simulations
Open Professionals Educational Network, US Dept
of Labor. http://open4us.org/find-oer/
PRACTI
Openlearn: “free learning from The Open University”
UK. http://www.open.edu/openlearn/
Disciplinary, cross-institutional global projects
Medici Project: A multi-disciplinary, sustainable resource for blended learning
initiatives in tertiary medical education, OLT. http://www.emedici.com/
JISC/HEA. Open Educational Resources (OER). http://www.heacademy.ac.uk/oe
The HumBox: http://humbox.ac.uk
Click to edit Master text styles 7
8. Impact of OER: global
Medici Project: A multi-disciplinary,
sustainable resource for blended
learning initiatives in tertiary medical
education, OLT
eMedici is an educational resource
containing clinical case studies,
examination materials and topics for
continuing professional development..
http://www.emedici.com/
eMedici Modules
Case of the week
Psychology
A Miscellany
Core Curriculum in Ophthalmology
Core Curriculum in Psychiatry
Core Curriculum in Health Psychology
Core Curriculum in Obstetrics and Gynaecology
Isolated skin lesions - 1
Selected Topics in General Surgery
Continuing Professional Development:
Carcinoma of the Oesophagus
Cardiology Vignettes
Venous Thromboembolism
Ethical issues, practice and risk management:
The Seven Deadly Sins - 1
Click to edit Master text styles 8
9. Impact of OER: global to local
1. OER global: UNESCO, JISC, Wikieducator,
2. OER national: OLT, ACER
National policies: Gov 2.0, Ausgoal, ARC and NHMRC
3. OER local innovation: institutional T&L strategy, IP policy
4. OER individual innovation: OER Commons images,
content & activities
Hannon et al. (2013) Accessible, reusable, participatory:.. Ascililte
Click to edit Master text styles 9
10. OOpEeRn iend upcraatcitoinc er:e sPoOuLrLc es (OER)
A curriculum puzzle: How to avoid re-inventing the wheel
You need to prepare an introductory Anatomy unit for a large cohort of
first year Health Science students. So you:
1. require students to buy a print textbook for $80
2. acquire an e-textbook through the University Library
3. purchase an e-textbook licence from an academic publisher, with
pre-made quizzes (cost $100,000)
4. produce original images for each topic
5. source open education resources and activities
6. adopt another strategy
Click to edit Master text styles 10
11. OER in Practice
Search Evaluate Adapt Use Share
Embed into courses,
activities, assessments
OER sources
•wikimedia commons
•OER commons
•OER disciplinary sources: medici Open courseware
Check license restrictions
•How CC licenses work
creativecommons.org/licenses/
Student-generated resources
•class textbook
•class wiki: Digital media across Asia
Click to edit Master text styles 11
12. OER in Practice: Finding media
1. Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository:
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Main_Page
2. OER Commons: https://www.oercommons.org/
3. Creative commons:
http://search.creativecommons.org/
4. Open Professionals Educational Network, US Dept of
Labor. http://open4us.org/find-oer/
http://www.google.com/advanced_image_search
Select “free to use, share or modify, even commercially
Search for: Phrenology
5. Google images – advanced:
"OER Logo" by Unknown - Unknown. Licensed under Public domain via Wikimedia Commons -
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:OER_Logo.svg#mediaviewer/File:OER_Logo.svg
Click to edit Master text styles 12
13. OER in Practice: Finding media
1. Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository:
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Main_Page
Click to edit Master text styles 13
14. OER in Practice: Finding media
1. Wikimedia Commons, the free media repository:
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Main_Page
Click to edit Master text styles 14
15. OER in Practice: Finding media
Text about Science, pseudo-science
and Phrenology
http://creativecommons.org.au/le
arn/licences/
"Phrenology-journal clean". Licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 via
Wikimedia Commons - http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Phrenology-journal_
clean.jpg#mediaviewer/File:Phrenology-journal_clean.jpg
Click to edit Master text styles 15
16. OER in Practice: Finding media
Questions?
Observations?
Your experiences?
Click to edit Master text styles 16
17. Levels of OER: from access to RW
Search Evaluate Adapt Use Share
Reuse, revise,
remix, redistribute
(Wiley’s 4Rs)
OER access
•Finding an image
•Finding content Open courseware: cross-institutional,
Check license restrictions
•How open?
disciplinary projects
Read-write (RW) activity
•Reinvent & recreate (Lessig 2008)
•Student-generated resources
Wiley, D. & Gurrell, S. (2009): A decade of development..., Open Learning: The Journal of Open, Distance
and e-Learning, 24 (1), pp. 11-21.
Lessig, L. (2008) Remix: Making Art and Commerce Thrive in the Hybrid Economy. Bloomsbury Academic
Click to edit Master text styles 17
18. Levels of OER: from access to RW
Student-generated resources
Example:
James Neill
Students collaborate to generate a
textbook on Motivation and Emotion
Third year final semester unit
Each student produces a chapter as
well as a multi media presentation of
that chapter.
http://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/Motivation_and_emotion
By Sunshine Connelly (Own work) [CC-BY-
SA-3.0
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses
/by-sa/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons
Click to edit Master text styles 18
19. OER matters: is it transformative?
Landmark, 2004
Charles Robb
Challenges
Slow adoption of OER
Institutional support for OER
Awareness & Incentives for staff
Bossu et al. 2014
University business models
OPENNESS
Click to edit Master text styles 19
20. OER matters: is it transformative?
The future of the university 1
Click to edit Master text styles 20 Landmark, 2004
Charles Robb
The 21st century university
(Barnett 2011):
from the “metaphysical”
research
corporate university
Barnett, R. (2011) The idea of the university
in the twenty-first century: Where’s the
imagination?
21. OER matters: is it transformative?
The future of the university 2
Click to edit Master text styles 21 Landmark, 2004
Charles Robb
“refashioning” the university
“do more than simply redesign
curricula, but go further and
redesign the organizing principle”
…through new relations between
academic, public and knowledge
creation
Neary and Winn (2009) The student as
producer: reinventing the student experience
in higher education
22. the early development of MOOCs, various open learning platforms have been set up by elite institutions; examples 2012 include MIT edX and OU’s Futurelearn. A key message that emerges is that the evolution of MOOCs is leading more players in the market as HEI and private organisations seek to take advantage of these innovations in online Figure 1: MOOCs and Open Education Timeline
OOpeEnR eCdhuaclaletinogne rsesources (OER)
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File%3AFigure_1_MOOCs_and_Open_Education_Timeline_p6.jpg
Yuan, Li, and Stephen Powell [CC-BY-3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0)], via Wikimedia Commons
Click to edit Master text styles 22
23. OER Challenges
Openness that is not so open
xMOOCs as marketing for elite universities:
Harvard: a $35 billion endowment, educates 10th of 1% of US students
(Shirky 2012)
Predatory publishing
Academic journal publishing worth $65 bn
shift from textbook to digital e-texts
new forms of digital containment/licensing that tend to increase
costs to students and exclude university libraries (Hallam 2012)
contravening the HES Act
“Business as usual”
OER is poor fit with transmissive approaches of LMS
awareness and opportunities for staff to practice
Click to edit Master text styles 23
24. OER to OEP: Open Education Practices
Shift from viewing content as “canned products”
(OLCOS Roadmap 2012) to open practices of
knowledge creation that challenges the
arrangements for university teaching
Shift to openness encountered “institutional inertia”
NMC Horizon Report: 2013 Higher Education Edition
Need for policies for “networks of innovation”
OPAL Report (2011) Beyond OER: Shifting Focus from
Resources to Practices
Click to edit Master text styles 24
25. OEP: Starting at the local
ESmcableed: dinindgiv OidEuRa li n– tinhset iotrugtaionnisaal t–io gnlo: bal
vertically: through policies, and guidelines
horizontally: through meso-level of the university
Technologies: digital repository that connects to OER
Practices: disciplinary & academic
HOW?
What connections, negotiations, structures in policy, guidelines,
technologies and institutional practices are needed?
Click to edit Master text styles 25
26. OEP 1: Institutional Library Repository
Library Digital Infrastructure Team
• Digital repository work
• Mostly includes publications to support promotion of La Trobe research
• Moving towards a more diversified range of data (research outputs, conference
papers, grey literature, working papers, manuscript versions, theses)
• OER material, videos, etc
Click to edit Master text styles 26
36. Embedding OEP: Individually
Design OEP into your curriculum:
source OER content
share OER across your discipline; in an OER repository
design student participation in open assessments
share OER in communities of practice
Click to edit Master text styles 36
37. Embedding OEP: Institutionally
Connect disparate parts of the University: Develop
institutional policies to support OEP and IP:
Gov 2.0, NHMRC and Feasibility Protocol (Bossu et al. 2013)
Embed practices: Establish projects that model OEP: from curriculum
as “canned content” to knowledge creation in the discipline
Harness Library expertise: repurpose existing digital repositories
Visibility: Guides for busy academics: source & create high quality
resources and images
Which license? What does NC mean?
http://www.oerafrica.org/copyright-and-licensing-toolkit/what-does-non-commercial-mean
Raise awareness of predatory publishing practices
Click to edit Master text styles 37
38. OEP: a long game
Scale: individual – institutional – global
The configuration of traditional
educational resources has
developed over centuries
OER is in its early years – leading
open education and knowledge
sharing – a key goal of the Web
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File%3A1623_Shakespeare_Folio-edition-p-xvii..png
William Shakespeare [Public domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Click to edit Master text styles 38
40. Thank you
Dr John Hannon
Snr Lecturer, La Trobe Learning & Teaching, La Trobe University
http://www.latrobe.edu.au/ltlt/about/staff-profiles/profile?uname=JHannon
Simon Huggard
Digital Infrastructure Manager
La Trobe University
latrobe.edu.au CRICOS Provider 00115M
Notas do Editor
Enabled by Internet connectivity
Lots of stuff
Show open4us.org, (humbox), medici
Participate – the high end – will show examples, but first
If I wanted to illustrate pseudo science
An open license identifies permissions described by Wiley as
Reuse content as is;
revise – adapt, modify or alter, eg. Translate;
remix – combine with other content;
redistribute - share the revised or remixed content
MOOCs have taken the limelight despite being latecomers
Much talk of bus models, rather than pedagogy
Open education is contradictory with MOOCs
“The idea of the university has, of course, undergone many shifts and been subject to varying conceptions over time. For some hundreds of years, the idea of the university was as it might be said connections with God, or the Universe, or Truth or Spirit or even the State. That conception gave way to the research university which in turn is giving way to that of the entrepreneurial university, which is closely allied to the emergence of a tacit idea of the corporate university. What is striking about this conceptual journey that the idea of the university has undergone over nearly one thousand years is that it has gradually shrunk. Whereas the metaphysical university was associated -understanding and relationships with the world, the idea of the university has increasingly and now especially in its contemporary entrepreneurial and corporate incarnations closed in. The entrepreneurial university is expected to fend for itself, and attend to its potential impact on particular segments of the economy, and become distinctive. This university has abandoned any pretence with universal themes.
“The idea of the university, therefore, has closed in ideologically, spatially and ethically. Ideologically, it is now intent on pursuing narrow interests, particularly those of money (in the service of a national learning economy); spatially, it is enjoined to engage with its region, especially with industrial and business organisations in its environs; and ethically, it becomes focused on its own interests. It will, as a result, close departments in chemistry, or physics, or modern languages or philosophy because it sees such closures as serving its own (usually financial) interests rather than being placed in a wider set of public interests.“
OER open and collaborative initiatives has the disruptive potential to challenge the relations for the production of academic knowledge – conflicts with commercialisation opportunities.
through a process of open and public knowledge creation or “business as usual”
Are MOOCs the main game?
Since 2000 the concept of openness in education has been evolving rapidly,
MIT established OpenCourseWare in 2002
early development of MOOCs set up open learning platforms by elite institutions; MIT edX and OU’s Futurelearn.
the evolution of MOOCs is leading to more players in the market as HEI and private organisations seek to take advantage of these innovations in online learning.
Different ideologies have driven MOOCs in two distinct pedagogical directions:
the connectivist MOOCs (cMOOC) which are based on a connectivism theory of learning with networks developed informally;
content-based MOOCs (xMOOCs), which follow a more behaviourist approach.
In many ways, this is the same learning process versus learning content debate that educationalists have had for many decades and failed to resolve.
xMOOCs not the main game
Publisher bundling of anatomy and excluding libraries
Teacher-centred education ; Practices
embedding OEP cannot be achieved by proceeding in a “business as usual” manner, with OER as “bolted-on” to existing learning technology systems or information repositories. Rather, OEP entails a fundamental shift in thinking about knowledge in the university: a shift from a view of content as “canned products” (Geser 2007, p. 44) with fixed boundaries, formats and timeframes, to one with open practices of knowledge creation that challenge the arrangements for university teaching, how it is located, what its boundaries are, and whether it should be protected and promoted as a reusable and adaptable resource.
Two examples
Skills/attributes/roles: Systems integration; Data analysis (scholarly content) and data migration/ingest/management ; Persistent identifiers and metadata management
Application management (at in-depth level); Technical troubleshooting; Problem logging, analysis, resolution; Technical requirements
Vendor and ICT liaison; Advocate for open data, linked data, open access; Supporting research from grant application to data management to publication to “archiving”
Front page of the repository
Development of the subject required the collaboration of a range of physically and institutionally dispersed stakeholders, a number of whom were not university staff and could not access the university LMS and other systems. It was critical that both the development and the actual resources produced be openly viewable, usable and modifiable by the communities, health and social care agencies local to each of La Trobe’s campuses. Then access is not restricted to staff and enrolled students, and access to the resource after completion enabled ongoing partnership with practitioners. Open access for ongoing collaboration with the community partner teachers was seen as being integral to delivery
the OER took the form of the unit of study Indigenous and Intercultural Health, in a process that established connections beyond the institution through an open wikiversity location. Curriculum development in wikiversity was then reflected in the LMS, and this coupling of two platforms made curriculum work more sustainable. The embedded LMS arrangements were not resisted or disrupted, rather a “workaround” or unofficial system (Brown 2013) was deployed that accomplished the curriculum projects goals.
Significantly, the wikiversity case demonstrated an inclusive community partnership that did not exclude participants with closed university systems and staff/student logins
OEP and open education in general is a long game –
Just as the configuration of traditional resources has developed over centuries - an arrangement involving set textbooks, academic publishers, their markets embedded in undergrad courses, and their attempts to translate the bounded ness of these market models to digital forms and licences. So open education is modelling and testing new arrangements, more fluid and less contained formats of knowledge, resources that are shared instances of knowledge generation that are never complete.
Shifts to OER and open publishing for academic journals, both challenge existing long embedded models of contained content.
Weller 2011: 24
The open education movement is still in its relative infancy, and so if it hasn’t seen the widespread disruption to higher education some had hoped for, we shouldn’t be too surprised. Education, as we know it today, has had several hundred years to develop the lecture based model, do to expect an open model to radically alter this in just a few years may be expecting too much…. In the OER movement, its probably fair to say that they are leading the thinking and development of concepts about free education, not responding to a social demand.