2. Double Taxation
Taxpayer pays double taxes on their income earned from the source country as well as the
residence country. And also for partners charged taxes separately on single income.
imbalance in tax collection on global income of individuals
Demotivating for the taxpayer
Against free flow of trade
Against the development of the nation
Taxes are charged by nation on the basis of
Resident Status
Non Resident - Source of Income
Doctrinal research methodology of study
has been used for studies.
Why different model convention are
followed while DTAA
How DTAA is important for the
development of the nation Special study
on India and China .
3. Residential Status and Income
Residential Status
Resident
Resident and ordinary
resident (days 182+ or 60+
days in previous year 365
days in last 4 years )
Resident but not ordinary
Resident(9 out 0f 10 years
or 729 days in last 7 years)
Non Resident
Income
Income from house
properties
Salaries
Profit and gains from
business and profession
Capital gains
Income from other
sources
4. Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement
- DTAA
Bilateral treaty or Multilateral treaty
on matter concerning Taxation
Model Convention used to draft and
follow the treaty
OECD and UN MC are the popular
one
Reciprocal Agreement
Fiscal Jurisdiction
Domestic Law of States Vs Internal
Treaty
DTAA
Free flow of trade
Protection against
double taxation
Non discrimination
Mutual Exchange
of Information
Legal and Fiscal
Certainty
Encourage
Technology
transfer and
investment
5. Objective of DTAA
Proper arrangement and allocation of Tax
Define different types of Tax
Tax transaction between Resident and non
resident
Protect interest of tax payer
Avoids Confusion
Tax Avoidance
• Not Illegal
• Before tax calculation
• Vodafone Case
• GAAR
Tax Evasion
• Illegal in nature
• Fraud in nature
• Unfair Practice
• Punishable
6. Vodafone case
Vodafone AG Vodafone International
Holdings Netherlands
CGP Investment Holdings
(67%) (Claman Island)
Hutchison Essar
Hutchison
Telecommunication Ltd
India Lost -
Capital gain Tax (CGT)
Tax deduction at source (TDS)
12000 Cr loss
55000 Cr Deal
2008 Bombay HC decision in favour
of Indian Govt.
2012 SC decision in Favour of
Vodafone
D
E
A
L
7. Kinds of DTAA
Comprehensive Agreement (All Big Economies USA UK )
Limited Agreement (Lebanon Pakistan, Afghanistan )
Tax Info Exchange Agreement (British Virgin Island, Bahamas ,
Bermuda)
Limited Multilateral Agreement (Bangladesh , Nepal)
8. Relief Provided by DTAA
Bilateral Relief
• Section 90 of IT Act 1961(DTAA)
• Section 90A of IT Act 1961
• Sec 90B of IT ACT
Unilateral Relief
• Section 91of IT Act 1961
• When There is no DTAA
• When Tax paid in Source country where income arose.
(Deduction/Credit relief)
9. Composition of DTAA Treaties
• Permanent establishment
• Source
• Resident
• Business Profit
• Shipping inland waterways and Air
Transport
• Associated enterprise
• Dividend
• Interest and Royalties
• Independent or Personal services
• Dependent Personal services
• Income by sports persons or performers
• Salary and pension in respect to the
government services
• Pension and social securities payments
• Directors Fees and remuneration for top
level managerial official
• Exchange of information
• Mutual agreement
• Non Discrimination
• Payment received by students
• Method of eliminations
• Diplomats and consular officers
• Terminations
10. Model Conventions
Article 23 Eliminates double Taxation
Art. 23A – Exemptions Method
Art. 23B Credit Methods
Adopted by Resident States
• 1955 - 1st Resolution
• Bilateral agreement of parties on multilateral trade
network
• Defined multiple aspect of trade
• Specially for developed nations
• Brought uniformity
• 1963 – Agreement approved by European States
• 1977 – New technologies and settellite
communication
• Sharing tax and cross boarder transaction
provisions.
Article 23 Eliminates double Taxation
Art. 23A – Exemptions Method
Art. 23B Credit Methods
Adopted by Resident States
• 1963-64 - affirmed by general assembly and
ECOSOC
• Interest of Developing nations considered- UN
Secretary General formed an Ad-hoc committee on
Tax treaties between developing and developed
countries
• 1980 – Model conventions published
• OECD updated - 2001
11. Bilateral Relief Methods
Methods
Credit
Full Credit
Ordinary
Credit
Tax Sparing
Exemption
Full
Exemption
With
Progression
Resident Country Exempts
the income Arising in
source country
Tax Paid only in Source
country
Preferred between
Developing and developed
country as developed
country exports
technologies and capital
Resident Country Exempts
Taxes Paid in source
country
Lost of revenue is less
Not refunded in case if
more tax paid in the source
country.
12. Interpretation of DTAA
Vienna Conventions of Law and
Treaties
Interpretation of Convention and
International Laws
Anti Abuse Provision under
International Laws
• International Law Treaty – 1969
• Referred as Treaty on treaties
• 116 - Parties States
• Drafted by International Law Commission
• Defines Treaty as : an international agreement
concluded between states in written form
and governed by international law
1. Union of India VS Aazadi Bachao Andolan
2. CIT VS Vishakhapatnam port Trust
13. DTAA Between India and China
88 countries - India has signed DTAA
Biggest Trade Partner - China
Comprehensive Agreement to avoid Double Taxation -
Complete structure of the tax avoidance.
Bilateral System of Relief
OECD Model convention is followed by India
14. Conclusion
Impact of DTAA –
DTAA makes a positive changes in the trade and economic environment. Gives confidence to the international
trade and FDI.
Direct Tax Code
Single code for direct taxes
Use of simple languages
Reducing scope of litigation
Elimination of regulatory functions
Stability in Market and Economy
Effective and efficient use of DTAA improves international interaction , reduces the disputes between states and
supports the concept of globalization with free flow of trade and movement of people across globe.
Suggestion : -
• Uniformity in Model Conventions.
• Strong Municipal Laws for the implementation
• Judicial interpretation in favour of DTAA
• Strong International organization required
• An arbitration body for resolution of Tax Disputes.