Given the task of exploring a topic within "sex in advertising", my team and I chose to perform research on the prevalence of violence and sex in advertising. (Project completed April 2013).
6. A G E N D A
I N T R O D U C T I O N
S E C O N D A R Y D ATA
P R I M A R Y D ATA
R E L E VA N C E O F F I N D I N G S
R E C O M M E N D AT I O N S
C O N C L U S I O N
7. H Y P O T H E S I S
The threshold of the acceptability of
sexualized violence will be higher for men
than women, due to the desensitizing and
normative influences of advertising media on
consumers.
8. S E C O N D A R Y D A T A
O V E R V I E W
The evolution of sex in
advertising
• Focused on desensitization
• Normative influences
Sexualized violence
9. E V O L U T I O N O F S E X
I N A D V E R T I S I N G
Consistent trend to push the boundaries of
acceptability
• Contingent upon socio-cultural climate
Sex transcends product categories
• The progression is increasingly controversial
Sex is an attention-grabbing
technique
10. F E A T U R E D S T U D Y
Research looked at ...
“Influence of sexualized violence as an
advertising appeal on consumers’
beliefs, attitudes, and intentions within
the theoretical framework of social
learning.”
T H E I M PA C T O F V I O L E N C E A G A I N S T W O M E N I N
A D V E R T I S E M E N T S
11. F E A T U R E D S T U D Y
( C O N T ’ D )
Three dependent variables Compared across
G E N D E R
• Males generally held positive
attitudes towards the ads
compared to females
A G E
• Younger respondents had
higher levels of acceptance
towards sexual ads
A T T I T U D E
TOWARDS
THE AD
ATTITUDE
TOWARDS
THE FIRM
PURCHASE
INTENTIONS
AGE
GEN D ER
12. M A R K E T I N G
I M P L I C A T I O N S
“Women are being
trivialized and sexual
violence is being
glamourized.”
- John Beyer, Director of MediaWatch
UK (2007)
• Sexism & sexualized violence
DESENSITIZATION
13. M E T H O D O L O G Y
Exploratory research
University students (19-22
years old)
• Projective techniques
• Free association
• Group discussion
Facilitation:
14. L I M I T A T I O N S
T I M E
A C C E S S
T O
P O P U L A -
T I O N
Q U A N T I T Y
O F
P R I M A R Y
D AT A
N O T A
R A N D O M
S A M P L E
15. P R I M A R Y D A T A
FORMS OF
COLLECTION
FOCUS
GROUP
EXPERT
INTERVIEW
16. F O C U S G R O U P
P O W E R P O IN T 1 : C O C A - C O L A
• Ads from the 50’s: “Conservative,
not scantily clad and respectful.”
• Ads today: “There is a lack of
clothing; it takes away from the
value of women.”
17. F O C U S G R O U P
F I N D I N G S
POWERPOINT 1: CLOTHING
• Ads from the 80’s: “sexual for people who
were living back then but with what we’re
used to these days, it’s hard for us to get
affected.”
18. A D S T O D A Y
PARTIAL NUDITY
SEXUAL POSITIONS
BORDERLINE PORNOGRAPHIC
19. F O C U S G R O U P
F I N D I N G S
POWERPOINT 1: ANALYSIS OF GENDER
DIFFERENCES
: “it doesn’t bother me that much because we
always relate women to sex.”
: “there are always guys in ads with just
underwear on, but no one gets offended. But if
it’s a girl, then everyone would find it offensive.”
20. F O C U S G R O U P
F I N D I N G S : A N A L Y S I S
ACCUSTOMED TO
SEXUAL
ADVERTISING
TODAY
“COP-OUT” FOR
MARKETERS
DESENSITIZATION
TO SEX
“Sex is sort of boring now, it doesn’t make the ad stand out. I
may find the girl hot, but that’s about it.” (Male Respondent)
21. F O C U S G R O U P
F I N D I N G S
POWERPOINT 2: SEXUAL VIOLENCE IN
ADVERTISING
ANSWERS
• “RAPE”
• “GUY IS CONTROLLING THE
GIRL”
• “GANG-RAPE”
• “DIRTY”
22. W E R E T H E V I O L E N T
A D S O F F E N S I V E ?
“No, because I wouldn’t remember what it
was for. It’s also not depicting real women
because, if women had a choice, no woman
would do that because it’s not okay”.
(Female Respondent)
23. G E N D E R & O P I N I O N O N
S E X U A L L Y V I O L E N T
A D V E R T I S I N G
• No apparent difference
• Both showed signs of desensitization
• Unrepresentative of real life
• Never knew what the ad was selling
24. I N T E R V I E W : P R A G N I
S A N G H V I
• Senior Marketing Manager at Kutoto Inc.
• Bachelors in Mass Media and Advertising from
the University of Mumbai
• Masters of Science in Advertising from the
University of Illinois at Urbana- Champaign
CREDENTIALS
25. I N T E R V I E W B A S I S
QUESTIONS
• Experience working with sex in advertising
• Use of sex in advertising today
• Different perceptions between genders
26. T H E E F F I C A C Y O F
S E X I N M E D I A
“Sex always sells.
Morally it doesn’t
work, but it works
commercially.”
27. G E N D E R D I F F E R E N C E S
• Tolerant
• Comfortable associating violence with sex
MEN ARE MORE…
“They are psychologically and physically built in such a
way that makes them think that they can take a lot more,
so it makes them okay with it. They don’t know about the
fragility of women.”
28. W H Y A R E C O M P A N I E S
U S I N G S E X A N D
V I O L E N C E ?
SEX
Create the
“double-
take” factor
Stimulate
consumer
pull factor
Companies
want to
stand out
Establish
the “shock
factor”
“They’re
not selling
a product
anymore.”
29. W H Y A R E C O M P A N I E S
U S I N G S E X U A L I Z E D
V I O L E N C E ?
• Found the shock factor in violence
• Needed something “new and raw”
• Contributing to increasing consumer
desensitization
• Unconscious acceptance of something that
is wrong
30. R E L E V A N C E O F
F I N D I N G S
• Many of the findings are supported
• Ads have become controversial and
offensive
“Women have
become
objects of
sexual desire
for men.”
31. F O C U S G R O U P V S .
R E S E A R C H
P r i m a r y : F o c u s
G r o u p
Vi o l e n c e i n a d s
i s n ’ t r e a l i s t i c
S e c o n d a r y D a t a
Vi o l e n c e i s b e i n g
g l a m o u r i z e d
Desensitization
towards sex
Desensitization
towards sexualized
violence
32. R E C O M M E N D A T I O N S
• Gradually tone down the sex and couple it
with other stimuli
HUMOR
Romanticism
35. R E C O M M E N D A T I O N S
• Avoid overreliance on sex in
advertising due to its
saturation
FIRST
• It is the responsibility of
marketers to provide
meaningful advertising
SECOND
36. C O N C L U S I O N
• Moral implications
– How media portrays sex has normative
influences on how the public perceives these
issues
– Desensitization could lead to tolerance of
sexualized violence and rape
• Saturation of sex in advertising
– Doesn’t stand out
AnnyPushing boundaries. Ex: ankle was controversial, now nudity is the norm. Depends on socio-cultural climate = ex: other countries and their religious climate.Product categories: used to be perfume/underpants, now it’s even used for cementAttention-grabbing: increasingly desensitized, advertising using more and more overt/loud imageryWhy is this progression controversial? It has prompted sexual ads in products that have no direct relationship with sex.Women are being objectified “Women are being trivialized and sexual violence is being glamourized.”
AnnyVillanova Business School (in the States), study done recently that sought to explore our exact hypothesisSexualized violence in ads Consumers’ beliefs, attitudes, and intentionsSocial learning: if you see it, then you’ll think it’s okay (normative influence)
AnnySurvey – people wrote down their attitude towards the ad, firm, and purchase intentions when looking at 3 different ads (low was gang, medium was spanking, high was blood and on a stretcher). Compared across gender and ageMention that age = measure of desensitization across time
Pam No diverse population Not representative Not much time: mention how interview could only last 30 minutes
Pam2 sources of primary data
PamMention that we had 2 powerpoints: 1 for desensitization and another for the violence aspect
Pam
Pam Quotes from focus group members in response to those advertisements
PamAs you can see, both males/females were desensitizedJuxtaposition between genders
Pam
AmandaFor this ppt, we showed respondents pictures and first word in mind
Amanda
Amanda
Change to smartartEileen
Eileen
Eileen
EileenSales – no gender sensitization
EileenNot selling product – because markets are so saturated, more about memory-recall than actually selling a product. They just want to ring a bell.
Eileen
Amanda
Amanda“Companies aren’t trying to sell consumers their products anymore; they’re just trying to get the consumers to remember them.”First desensitized to sex, now towards sexualized violence major moral and societal implications (ex: rape myth, rape is okay)
AmandaEx: humorDouble factor without violence
Amanda
Amanda
Amanda
PaulHow media portrays sex has normative influences on how the public perceives these issuesDesensitization could lead to tolerance of sexualized violence and rape