SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 113
Interpreting Native
American Connections
in National Parks
Five case studies

Moderated by Mary Lou Herlihy,
NPS Pacific West Regional Office
Johnpaul Jones, FAIA
Jones + Jones
Indigenous Design: Emerging Gifts
       Johnpaul Jones, FAIA
There is no place without a story.
Natural World   Animal World




Spirit World    Human World
National Museum of the American Indian
National Museum of the American Indian
Southern Ute Cultural Center & Museum
Southern Ute Cultural Center & Museum
Vancouver Land Bridge
Vancouver Land Bridge
Evergreen State College Longhouse Education and Cultural Center
Evergreen State College Longhouse Education and Cultural Center
Northwest Native Canoe Center
Agua Caliente Cultural Museum
Johnpaul Jones, FAIA
Jones + Jones
Julie Sayigh
   EDX: Edquist Davis Exhibits

Project: Fort Bowie National Historic Site
Long-Range Interpretive Plan
Fort Bowie National Historic Site
Long – Range Interpretive Plan
PROCESS                Looking critically at consultation




Long-distance travel
PROCESS   Informal meetings,
          free-form discussion
PROCESS   Walking the site
Visit to Apache Spring
One-sided interpretation
may omit information…
One-sided interpretation can reinforce stereotypes.
“…every time I come here
I sit and find [Cochise’s] spirit.”




                                      Authentic voices
                                      can reinforce a
                                      continuity of culture.
RESULTS
Old interpretive theme:

The clash of cultures between Chiricahua Apaches and
Americans resulted in expanded opportunities for American
entrepreneurs at the expense of the Chiricahua Apaches,
who lost their homeland.
RESULTS
Old interpretive theme:

The clash of cultures between Chiricahua Apaches and
Americans resulted in expanded opportunities for American
entrepreneurs at the expense of the Chiricahua Apaches,
who lost their homeland.

New interpretive theme:

The protracted conflict that pitted the US army’s intent to gain
control over the area against the Chiricahua Apache people’s
desire to retain their homeland escalated at Apache pass,
continued with the capitulation of the Chiricahua Apache in
Skeleton Canyon, and is echoed today in the form of multiple
perspectives that paint a complex picture of these events.
RESULTS
Old interpretive theme:

The proximity of Apache Pass to Apache Spring
gave rise to an environment conducive to many important
historic events that continue to affect the destinies
of those living in southeast Arizona and beyond.
RESULTS
Old interpretive theme:

The proximity of Apache Pass to Apache Spring
gave rise to an environment conducive to many important
historic events that continue to affect the destinies
of those living in southeast Arizona and beyond.

New interpretive theme:

Apache Spring represents the life-giving qualities of water in
the harsh, arid deserts of the American West. Drawing
prehistoric indigenous people and later the Chiricahua Apache
people, the U.S. Army, Euro-American settlers, and those
traveling on trade routes, the spring endures as a place where
cultures met and conflict arose, altering lives and destinies.
RESULTS

From the report appendix:

Stereotyped as “brutal and warlike”,
Apache representatives expressed that while proud
of the historic prowess of their people,
they view their warlike nature as an outgrowth
of the skills needed to survive in a harsh land…
RESULTS

From the report appendix:

Stereotyped as “brutal and warlike”,
Apache representatives expressed that while proud
of the historic prowess of their people,
they view their warlike nature as an outgrowth
of the skills needed to survive in a harsh land…

Response by a park staff member:

“This overlooks what early anthropologists refer to as
the “Novice Complex” where Apache youth were
rigorously trained in warfare…”
LESSONS                LEARNED




 A process tailored to the stakeholders can yield better results
 and build stronger relationships.
LESSONS               LEARNED




 Rewriting history may not be possible.
 But acknowledging multiple truths about history is essential.
LESSONS               LEARNED




  A multi-perspective story provides a richer experience
  of history for all visitors, promoting inquiry and involvement.
Julie Sayigh
   EDX: Edquist Davis Exhibits

Project: Fort Bowie National Historic Site
Long-Range Interpretive Plan
Mark Wagner
Glacier National Park

Project: St. Mary
Visitor Center
Exhibits
Mark Wagner
Glacier National Park

Project: St. Mary
Visitor Center
Exhibits
Charles Davis, AIA
EDX: Edquist Davis Exhibits

  Project: At the Confluence
  Fort Spokane Interpretive
  Exhibits
Linus:   That cloud looks like the profile of Thomas Eakins,
         the famous painter and sculptor . . . And over there
         gives me the impression of the Stoning of Stephen .
         . . There’s the Apostle Paul standing to one side . . .

Charlie Brown: I was going to say I saw a duckie and a
        horsie but I’ve changed my mind . . .
Fort Spokane
Lake Roosevelt National
Recreation Area




    Fort Spokane:
    1880-1898
FORT SPOKANE INDIAN
BOARDING SCHOOL: 1900-
1907
Lessons Learned:

Design/consultation process:

• contributes to cross-
cultural dialogue and
understanding.

• can catalyze discussion
and awareness within the tribe.
Lessons Learned:

Design/consultation process:

• contributes to cross-
cultural dialogue and
understanding.

• can catalyze discussion
and awareness within the tribe.

• can provide opportunity for
cultural pride and healing.

• supports tribal artisans and
the local economy.
My ancestors suffered from
here to here in order to be
where we are today—
educated, able to sit
down as equals,
at this table,
and be heard.
Tim Brookes, Colville

Confederated Tribes
                              Charles Davis, AIA
                              EDX: Edquist Davis Exhibits

                                Project: At the Confluence
                                Fort Spokane Interpretive
                                Exhibits
Marc K. Blackburn, PhD.
Nez Perce National Historical Park

      Project: Big Hole National
      Battlefield Visitor Center
Revisiting the Past
Exhibit Replacement at Big Hole National Battlefield
The Place: Nez Perce National Historical Park
The Park: Big Hole National Battlefield
The Process: Scoping
! "#$ & (#))*$ Engaging0Our% &, #&
The %'
     Process:+, - . - /, - $ 1& Partners
                              $. 2 )
The Gift

                      And in with the new




   Out with the old
The Challenge: Objects with no context
The Challenge: Misused Space
The Results: Compelling and smart exhibit plan

  Unobstructed View of battlefield




   Repurposed
  exhibit room –
   now theater
   AND objects




                                          New airlock
The Results: Inviting Lobby
The Results: ADA Accessible Map
The Results: The Voices of the Nimiipuu
The Results: Objects in Context
The Results: Direct Visual Connection With Resource
The Results: Relevance, Relevance, Relevance
Making Connections . . . . .
                        [April 2012] K. :

                        "While I have sympathy for the Native
                        Americans who suffered, much of what is
                        put forth here is inaccurate.

                        Most of the bands slated as having
                        strong, amicable relationships were at
                        constant odds with each other. They
                        were poorly led and their own hierarchy
                        left much to be desired. Few had much,
                        most were destitute diseased and often
                        starving. They were not peaceful in
                        nature, stealing, killing, kidnapping were
                        all part of their culture.

                        This display is lovey, but mush, much too
                        one sided. History is not changed by
                        wishful thinking."
Making Connections . . . . .
                        Joe from Helena:

                        "I am disturbed by the critical entry on April
                        2012. To refer to what is shared here as
                        "mush" is a sad commentary on what
                        happened here.

                        The "stealing, killing, and kidnapping" the writer
                        refers to as part of white American culture at
                        that time. In fact stealing and killing were
                        clearly displayed in the breaking of the 1863
                        treaty and in a brutal attack on a sleeping
                        village. No culture or society is perfect in the
                        way lives are lived and actions carried out. But
                        the onslaught of the dominant white invaders,
                        beginning with the Vikings and in some forms
                        continue to this day, is at least addressed
                        honestly here and a balance is achieved.

                        Am I—a white male—responsible for what
                        happened here? No. But I am responsible for
                        understanding what happened here and its
                        significance. And I am responsible for applying
                        what I learn to my own life."
Success

• Collaboration with Tribal Partners driving
  the narrative.

• Using partners’ subject matter expertise to
  drive content creation.

• Having the courage to tell the truth and make
  a strong emotional statement.

• Making planning process inclusive and transparent.



                                EXPERIENCE     YOUR   AMERICA
Lessons


•   Get thematic consensus as early as possible.


•   Include ALL stakeholders, not just Tribal Partners.


•   For project continuity, try to get the same participants

    at each meeting.


•   Select the right contractors and keep an open

    line of communication.


•   BE PATIENT.                        EXPERIENCE    YOUR      AMERICA
Dena from Long Beach, California:

"May we never forget the love Chief Joseph had for his
people.

May we learn that conflict is not the answer. Let us
understand what the Native Americans understood
about our land, earth and animals that live with us.
Thank you for telling the story.

Draw it to your heart and share with the young and not
born- we must never forget the pain that was felt on this
hallowed ground."

                                 EXPERIENCE   YOUR   AMERICA
Marc K. Blackburn, PhD.
Nez Perce National Historical Park

      Project: Big Hole National
      Battlefield Visitor Center
Interpreting Native
American Connections
in National Parks
Five case studies

Moderated by Mary Lou Herlihy,
NPS Pacific West Regional Office

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Fall 2011 Issue of "Florida Libraries"
Fall 2011 Issue of "Florida Libraries"Fall 2011 Issue of "Florida Libraries"
Fall 2011 Issue of "Florida Libraries"
Maria Gebhardt
 
FINAL Aboriginal Ed Presentation
FINAL Aboriginal Ed PresentationFINAL Aboriginal Ed Presentation
FINAL Aboriginal Ed Presentation
jcamuyong
 
Bishop Museum Ka Elele Winter13
Bishop Museum Ka Elele Winter13Bishop Museum Ka Elele Winter13
Bishop Museum Ka Elele Winter13
David Kamida
 
Exhibiting the Photobook
Exhibiting the PhotobookExhibiting the Photobook
Exhibiting the Photobook
Stephen Clarke
 

Mais procurados (15)

Fall 2011 Issue of "Florida Libraries"
Fall 2011 Issue of "Florida Libraries"Fall 2011 Issue of "Florida Libraries"
Fall 2011 Issue of "Florida Libraries"
 
Hypatia-in-the-Woods Newsletter Winter 2011
Hypatia-in-the-Woods Newsletter Winter 2011Hypatia-in-the-Woods Newsletter Winter 2011
Hypatia-in-the-Woods Newsletter Winter 2011
 
Every person is a book every life tells a story
Every person is a book every life tells a story Every person is a book every life tells a story
Every person is a book every life tells a story
 
Freedom dreams freedom now University of Illinois at Chicago
Freedom dreams freedom now University of Illinois at ChicagoFreedom dreams freedom now University of Illinois at Chicago
Freedom dreams freedom now University of Illinois at Chicago
 
HW_Spark Magazine-Fall2014]
HW_Spark Magazine-Fall2014]HW_Spark Magazine-Fall2014]
HW_Spark Magazine-Fall2014]
 
October CELASA Newsletter(1)
October CELASA Newsletter(1)October CELASA Newsletter(1)
October CELASA Newsletter(1)
 
2018 Program Catalog
2018 Program Catalog2018 Program Catalog
2018 Program Catalog
 
Portfolio.Pdf
Portfolio.PdfPortfolio.Pdf
Portfolio.Pdf
 
FINAL Aboriginal Ed Presentation
FINAL Aboriginal Ed PresentationFINAL Aboriginal Ed Presentation
FINAL Aboriginal Ed Presentation
 
20 Subjects in 90 minutes: Themed Programs for Adults Workshop
20 Subjects in 90 minutes: Themed Programs for Adults Workshop20 Subjects in 90 minutes: Themed Programs for Adults Workshop
20 Subjects in 90 minutes: Themed Programs for Adults Workshop
 
Diversity in Children's Literature
Diversity in Children's LiteratureDiversity in Children's Literature
Diversity in Children's Literature
 
20 subjects in 90 minutes: Themed Programs for Adults
20 subjects in 90 minutes: Themed Programs for Adults20 subjects in 90 minutes: Themed Programs for Adults
20 subjects in 90 minutes: Themed Programs for Adults
 
Things fall apart as p.col. presentation
Things fall apart as p.col. presentationThings fall apart as p.col. presentation
Things fall apart as p.col. presentation
 
Bishop Museum Ka Elele Winter13
Bishop Museum Ka Elele Winter13Bishop Museum Ka Elele Winter13
Bishop Museum Ka Elele Winter13
 
Exhibiting the Photobook
Exhibiting the PhotobookExhibiting the Photobook
Exhibiting the Photobook
 

Destaque

Intensivdagarna Nai certification lisa brochu
Intensivdagarna Nai certification lisa brochuIntensivdagarna Nai certification lisa brochu
Intensivdagarna Nai certification lisa brochu
Stefan_Riksutstallningar
 

Destaque (6)

Intensivdagarna Nai certification lisa brochu
Intensivdagarna Nai certification lisa brochuIntensivdagarna Nai certification lisa brochu
Intensivdagarna Nai certification lisa brochu
 
Casestudy on National Museum , New Delhi
Casestudy on National Museum , New DelhiCasestudy on National Museum , New Delhi
Casestudy on National Museum , New Delhi
 
Museum Architecture - what does it take to design a museum?
Museum Architecture - what does it take to design a museum?Museum Architecture - what does it take to design a museum?
Museum Architecture - what does it take to design a museum?
 
Museum case study by Sarthak
Museum case study by SarthakMuseum case study by Sarthak
Museum case study by Sarthak
 
Museum Architectural Considerations
Museum Architectural ConsiderationsMuseum Architectural Considerations
Museum Architectural Considerations
 
Museum Case Studies
Museum Case StudiesMuseum Case Studies
Museum Case Studies
 

Semelhante a Working with Tribal Members to Interpret Native American Themes in the National Park Service

Running head TEAM ROLES1TEAM ROLES2Team Roles.docx
Running head TEAM ROLES1TEAM ROLES2Team Roles.docxRunning head TEAM ROLES1TEAM ROLES2Team Roles.docx
Running head TEAM ROLES1TEAM ROLES2Team Roles.docx
toltonkendal
 

Semelhante a Working with Tribal Members to Interpret Native American Themes in the National Park Service (11)

343002 week 3
343002 week 3343002 week 3
343002 week 3
 
343002 week 3
343002 week 3343002 week 3
343002 week 3
 
Working with tribal
Working with tribalWorking with tribal
Working with tribal
 
Essay About Educational And Career Goals.pdf
Essay About Educational And Career Goals.pdfEssay About Educational And Career Goals.pdf
Essay About Educational And Career Goals.pdf
 
Schlesinger 2013
Schlesinger 2013Schlesinger 2013
Schlesinger 2013
 
research cited
research citedresearch cited
research cited
 
Expressions of Place: an interdisciplinary and interactive community event se...
Expressions of Place: an interdisciplinary and interactive community event se...Expressions of Place: an interdisciplinary and interactive community event se...
Expressions of Place: an interdisciplinary and interactive community event se...
 
Essay Definition.pdf
Essay Definition.pdfEssay Definition.pdf
Essay Definition.pdf
 
Culture And Music Essay
Culture And Music EssayCulture And Music Essay
Culture And Music Essay
 
Running head TEAM ROLES1TEAM ROLES2Team Roles.docx
Running head TEAM ROLES1TEAM ROLES2Team Roles.docxRunning head TEAM ROLES1TEAM ROLES2Team Roles.docx
Running head TEAM ROLES1TEAM ROLES2Team Roles.docx
 
Native American Essay
Native American EssayNative American Essay
Native American Essay
 

Mais de West Muse

Mais de West Muse (20)

Archives Alive! Activating Archives for Engagement & Equity
Archives Alive! Activating Archives for Engagement & EquityArchives Alive! Activating Archives for Engagement & Equity
Archives Alive! Activating Archives for Engagement & Equity
 
Beyond Land Acknowledgements: Real Collaboration with Tribes & Tribal Leaders
Beyond Land Acknowledgements: Real Collaboration with Tribes & Tribal LeadersBeyond Land Acknowledgements: Real Collaboration with Tribes & Tribal Leaders
Beyond Land Acknowledgements: Real Collaboration with Tribes & Tribal Leaders
 
Digital Strategy: A Means for Museum Transformation
Digital Strategy: A Means for Museum TransformationDigital Strategy: A Means for Museum Transformation
Digital Strategy: A Means for Museum Transformation
 
Building Community: Discovering Resources for Professional Support, Learning,...
Building Community: Discovering Resources for Professional Support, Learning,...Building Community: Discovering Resources for Professional Support, Learning,...
Building Community: Discovering Resources for Professional Support, Learning,...
 
Creative Attention: Art & Community Restoration
Creative Attention: Art & Community RestorationCreative Attention: Art & Community Restoration
Creative Attention: Art & Community Restoration
 
Director & Leadership Teams Luncheon
Director & Leadership Teams LuncheonDirector & Leadership Teams Luncheon
Director & Leadership Teams Luncheon
 
Facilitating Critical Conversations Around Exhibitions
Facilitating Critical Conversations Around ExhibitionsFacilitating Critical Conversations Around Exhibitions
Facilitating Critical Conversations Around Exhibitions
 
Helping Communities Heal in the Wake of Local Crisis
Helping Communities Heal in the Wake of Local CrisisHelping Communities Heal in the Wake of Local Crisis
Helping Communities Heal in the Wake of Local Crisis
 
Labelling Legacies Branded Final.pptx
Labelling Legacies Branded Final.pptxLabelling Legacies Branded Final.pptx
Labelling Legacies Branded Final.pptx
 
Measuring Museum Social Impact
Measuring Museum Social ImpactMeasuring Museum Social Impact
Measuring Museum Social Impact
 
Museum People: Exploring Museum Workforce Issues in 2022
Museum People: Exploring Museum Workforce Issues in 2022Museum People: Exploring Museum Workforce Issues in 2022
Museum People: Exploring Museum Workforce Issues in 2022
 
Preserving History Through Restoration
Preserving History Through RestorationPreserving History Through Restoration
Preserving History Through Restoration
 
Strategies for Surfacing Truth and Fostering Reconciliation for Racial Equity
Strategies for Surfacing Truth and Fostering Reconciliation for Racial EquityStrategies for Surfacing Truth and Fostering Reconciliation for Racial Equity
Strategies for Surfacing Truth and Fostering Reconciliation for Racial Equity
 
Tools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship Programs
Tools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship ProgramsTools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship Programs
Tools for Meaningful and Engaging Internship Programs
 
Planned Giving Opportunities with the Upcoming Transfer of Wealth (Pt 2/2)
Planned Giving Opportunities with the Upcoming Transfer of Wealth (Pt 2/2)Planned Giving Opportunities with the Upcoming Transfer of Wealth (Pt 2/2)
Planned Giving Opportunities with the Upcoming Transfer of Wealth (Pt 2/2)
 
Planned Giving Opportunities with the Upcoming Transfer of Wealth (Pt. 1/2)
Planned Giving Opportunities with the Upcoming Transfer of Wealth (Pt. 1/2)Planned Giving Opportunities with the Upcoming Transfer of Wealth (Pt. 1/2)
Planned Giving Opportunities with the Upcoming Transfer of Wealth (Pt. 1/2)
 
Board Engagement in Fundraising
Board Engagement in FundraisingBoard Engagement in Fundraising
Board Engagement in Fundraising
 
Inclusivity, Difficult History, and the Modern Museum Audience
Inclusivity, Difficult History, and the Modern Museum Audience Inclusivity, Difficult History, and the Modern Museum Audience
Inclusivity, Difficult History, and the Modern Museum Audience
 
Museums and Climate Change: Creating a Sustainable Path Forward
Museums and Climate Change: Creating a Sustainable Path ForwardMuseums and Climate Change: Creating a Sustainable Path Forward
Museums and Climate Change: Creating a Sustainable Path Forward
 
Recalculating, Recalculating...Using the Museum Assessment Program as Your Mu...
Recalculating, Recalculating...Using the Museum Assessment Program as Your Mu...Recalculating, Recalculating...Using the Museum Assessment Program as Your Mu...
Recalculating, Recalculating...Using the Museum Assessment Program as Your Mu...
 

Working with Tribal Members to Interpret Native American Themes in the National Park Service

  • 1. Interpreting Native American Connections in National Parks Five case studies Moderated by Mary Lou Herlihy, NPS Pacific West Regional Office
  • 3. Indigenous Design: Emerging Gifts Johnpaul Jones, FAIA
  • 4. There is no place without a story.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12. Natural World Animal World Spirit World Human World
  • 13. National Museum of the American Indian
  • 14. National Museum of the American Indian
  • 15. Southern Ute Cultural Center & Museum
  • 16. Southern Ute Cultural Center & Museum
  • 19. Evergreen State College Longhouse Education and Cultural Center
  • 20. Evergreen State College Longhouse Education and Cultural Center
  • 24. Julie Sayigh EDX: Edquist Davis Exhibits Project: Fort Bowie National Historic Site Long-Range Interpretive Plan
  • 25. Fort Bowie National Historic Site
  • 26. Long – Range Interpretive Plan
  • 27. PROCESS Looking critically at consultation Long-distance travel
  • 28. PROCESS Informal meetings, free-form discussion
  • 29. PROCESS Walking the site
  • 30. Visit to Apache Spring
  • 32.
  • 33. One-sided interpretation can reinforce stereotypes.
  • 34.
  • 35. “…every time I come here I sit and find [Cochise’s] spirit.” Authentic voices can reinforce a continuity of culture.
  • 36. RESULTS Old interpretive theme: The clash of cultures between Chiricahua Apaches and Americans resulted in expanded opportunities for American entrepreneurs at the expense of the Chiricahua Apaches, who lost their homeland.
  • 37. RESULTS Old interpretive theme: The clash of cultures between Chiricahua Apaches and Americans resulted in expanded opportunities for American entrepreneurs at the expense of the Chiricahua Apaches, who lost their homeland. New interpretive theme: The protracted conflict that pitted the US army’s intent to gain control over the area against the Chiricahua Apache people’s desire to retain their homeland escalated at Apache pass, continued with the capitulation of the Chiricahua Apache in Skeleton Canyon, and is echoed today in the form of multiple perspectives that paint a complex picture of these events.
  • 38. RESULTS Old interpretive theme: The proximity of Apache Pass to Apache Spring gave rise to an environment conducive to many important historic events that continue to affect the destinies of those living in southeast Arizona and beyond.
  • 39. RESULTS Old interpretive theme: The proximity of Apache Pass to Apache Spring gave rise to an environment conducive to many important historic events that continue to affect the destinies of those living in southeast Arizona and beyond. New interpretive theme: Apache Spring represents the life-giving qualities of water in the harsh, arid deserts of the American West. Drawing prehistoric indigenous people and later the Chiricahua Apache people, the U.S. Army, Euro-American settlers, and those traveling on trade routes, the spring endures as a place where cultures met and conflict arose, altering lives and destinies.
  • 40. RESULTS From the report appendix: Stereotyped as “brutal and warlike”, Apache representatives expressed that while proud of the historic prowess of their people, they view their warlike nature as an outgrowth of the skills needed to survive in a harsh land…
  • 41. RESULTS From the report appendix: Stereotyped as “brutal and warlike”, Apache representatives expressed that while proud of the historic prowess of their people, they view their warlike nature as an outgrowth of the skills needed to survive in a harsh land… Response by a park staff member: “This overlooks what early anthropologists refer to as the “Novice Complex” where Apache youth were rigorously trained in warfare…”
  • 42. LESSONS LEARNED A process tailored to the stakeholders can yield better results and build stronger relationships.
  • 43. LESSONS LEARNED Rewriting history may not be possible. But acknowledging multiple truths about history is essential.
  • 44. LESSONS LEARNED A multi-perspective story provides a richer experience of history for all visitors, promoting inquiry and involvement.
  • 45. Julie Sayigh EDX: Edquist Davis Exhibits Project: Fort Bowie National Historic Site Long-Range Interpretive Plan
  • 46. Mark Wagner Glacier National Park Project: St. Mary Visitor Center Exhibits
  • 47.
  • 48.
  • 49.
  • 50.
  • 51.
  • 52.
  • 53.
  • 54.
  • 55.
  • 56.
  • 57.
  • 58.
  • 59.
  • 60.
  • 61.
  • 62.
  • 63.
  • 64.
  • 65.
  • 66.
  • 67. Mark Wagner Glacier National Park Project: St. Mary Visitor Center Exhibits
  • 68. Charles Davis, AIA EDX: Edquist Davis Exhibits Project: At the Confluence Fort Spokane Interpretive Exhibits
  • 69. Linus: That cloud looks like the profile of Thomas Eakins, the famous painter and sculptor . . . And over there gives me the impression of the Stoning of Stephen . . . There’s the Apostle Paul standing to one side . . . Charlie Brown: I was going to say I saw a duckie and a horsie but I’ve changed my mind . . .
  • 70.
  • 71. Fort Spokane Lake Roosevelt National Recreation Area Fort Spokane: 1880-1898
  • 72. FORT SPOKANE INDIAN BOARDING SCHOOL: 1900- 1907
  • 73.
  • 74.
  • 75.
  • 76.
  • 77.
  • 78.
  • 79.
  • 80.
  • 81.
  • 82.
  • 83.
  • 84.
  • 85.
  • 86.
  • 87.
  • 88. Lessons Learned: Design/consultation process: • contributes to cross- cultural dialogue and understanding. • can catalyze discussion and awareness within the tribe.
  • 89. Lessons Learned: Design/consultation process: • contributes to cross- cultural dialogue and understanding. • can catalyze discussion and awareness within the tribe. • can provide opportunity for cultural pride and healing. • supports tribal artisans and the local economy.
  • 90. My ancestors suffered from here to here in order to be where we are today— educated, able to sit down as equals, at this table, and be heard. Tim Brookes, Colville Confederated Tribes Charles Davis, AIA EDX: Edquist Davis Exhibits Project: At the Confluence Fort Spokane Interpretive Exhibits
  • 91. Marc K. Blackburn, PhD. Nez Perce National Historical Park Project: Big Hole National Battlefield Visitor Center
  • 92. Revisiting the Past Exhibit Replacement at Big Hole National Battlefield
  • 93. The Place: Nez Perce National Historical Park
  • 94. The Park: Big Hole National Battlefield
  • 96. ! "#$ & (#))*$ Engaging0Our% &, #& The %' Process:+, - . - /, - $ 1& Partners $. 2 )
  • 97. The Gift And in with the new Out with the old
  • 98. The Challenge: Objects with no context
  • 100. The Results: Compelling and smart exhibit plan Unobstructed View of battlefield Repurposed exhibit room – now theater AND objects New airlock
  • 102. The Results: ADA Accessible Map
  • 103. The Results: The Voices of the Nimiipuu
  • 104. The Results: Objects in Context
  • 105. The Results: Direct Visual Connection With Resource
  • 106. The Results: Relevance, Relevance, Relevance
  • 107. Making Connections . . . . . [April 2012] K. : "While I have sympathy for the Native Americans who suffered, much of what is put forth here is inaccurate. Most of the bands slated as having strong, amicable relationships were at constant odds with each other. They were poorly led and their own hierarchy left much to be desired. Few had much, most were destitute diseased and often starving. They were not peaceful in nature, stealing, killing, kidnapping were all part of their culture. This display is lovey, but mush, much too one sided. History is not changed by wishful thinking."
  • 108. Making Connections . . . . . Joe from Helena: "I am disturbed by the critical entry on April 2012. To refer to what is shared here as "mush" is a sad commentary on what happened here. The "stealing, killing, and kidnapping" the writer refers to as part of white American culture at that time. In fact stealing and killing were clearly displayed in the breaking of the 1863 treaty and in a brutal attack on a sleeping village. No culture or society is perfect in the way lives are lived and actions carried out. But the onslaught of the dominant white invaders, beginning with the Vikings and in some forms continue to this day, is at least addressed honestly here and a balance is achieved. Am I—a white male—responsible for what happened here? No. But I am responsible for understanding what happened here and its significance. And I am responsible for applying what I learn to my own life."
  • 109. Success • Collaboration with Tribal Partners driving the narrative. • Using partners’ subject matter expertise to drive content creation. • Having the courage to tell the truth and make a strong emotional statement. • Making planning process inclusive and transparent. EXPERIENCE YOUR AMERICA
  • 110. Lessons • Get thematic consensus as early as possible. • Include ALL stakeholders, not just Tribal Partners. • For project continuity, try to get the same participants at each meeting. • Select the right contractors and keep an open line of communication. • BE PATIENT. EXPERIENCE YOUR AMERICA
  • 111. Dena from Long Beach, California: "May we never forget the love Chief Joseph had for his people. May we learn that conflict is not the answer. Let us understand what the Native Americans understood about our land, earth and animals that live with us. Thank you for telling the story. Draw it to your heart and share with the young and not born- we must never forget the pain that was felt on this hallowed ground." EXPERIENCE YOUR AMERICA
  • 112. Marc K. Blackburn, PhD. Nez Perce National Historical Park Project: Big Hole National Battlefield Visitor Center
  • 113. Interpreting Native American Connections in National Parks Five case studies Moderated by Mary Lou Herlihy, NPS Pacific West Regional Office

Notas do Editor

  1. Click to advance this slide. Laptop and screen both set up, connected, and on. Go to Slide Show > Set Up Show > Screen > choose monitor without white bar for audience screen. 3. Go to View > presenter tools 4. Leave presenter’s intro slide on until they are ready. Then click the slide to advance Right as they start talking. 5. Try to quickly click the timer at upper left simultaneously so they get the timer function.
  2. JPJ profile by MLH. Click to advance.
  3. • There is no place without a Native American story in this entire country. Indigenous people have been here a long, long time.
  4. The Elders of every Indigenous community know every habitat; know every plant; know every animal; know the water; they know the dirt; they know the rocks; they know the sky; clouds, and the wind.
  5. The America Government has tried repeatedly to eliminate Indigenous people in many different ways: war, relocation, special training and schools. Harm done by these attempts at assimilation are profound– but Native Americans are still here - they have survived. • There
  6. There is also a rich, magnificent ancient Indigenous architectural heritage here in this country that can and should be used in current Indigenous landscape and architectural planning and design.
  7. I love our American Indigenous architecture heritage.
  8. However, much of what the Indigenous ancestors have given is verbal – songs, ceremonies, storytelling, dances, poems, and art.
  9. But it ’s the verbal and art stories that are most important. It ’s these stories/gifts from the Elders that should be used to create Indigenous site and architecture design, and be used to interpret Native American people.
  10. As an American Indian architect involved in Native American site and architectural design, I try to find and use the verbal stories. I try to “ stand” in the ancestor’s ways and beliefs – not in themes or motifs.
  11. My Choctaw Grandmother and Mother verbally passed on to me Four Ancient Gifts. I use them in all my Native American planning and design projects; Natural World, Animal World, Spirit World and our Human World.
  12. Here are some of my Native American planning & design projects (case studies) in which I ’ve tried to go beyond the sterotypical Native American themes and motifs– beginning with the Smithsonian National Museum of the American Indian in Washington D.C.
  13. We needed to create a place that respected the circular nature of life and show the diversity of Native People in this country.
  14. The Southern Ute Tribal Cultural Center & Museum • The Southern Ute Tribal Board asked us to listen to their Tribal Elders, then plan and design a site & building that respected their “Circle of Life” story.
  15. • Create a place to “sustain” their Southern Ute culture and their “Circle of LIfe” story in southern Colorado on their land for their Tribal community & outside visitors.
  16. The Landbridge at Fort Vancouver, Washington • It ’s a “Re-Connect place”! A design for re-connection to the Columbia River, and a re-connection of an ancient Indigenous trading place, and an honoring/ceremony place.
  17. And a re-connecting of existing modern communities, land to river and river to land, and people to a special historic place.
  18. The Evergreen State College Longhouse Educaiton & Cultural Center - Olympia, Washington • First Native American Center on a college campus in the U.S., 20 years ago • A re-emerging cultural place of welcome, and a place to teach Indigenous knowledge.
  19. -Re-emerging “Coast Salish” longhouse architecture & art
  20. Northwest Native Canoe Center - Lake Union, Seattle, Washington • Teach & celebrate the Native NW Coast Canoe Craft • A place to share the NW Coast Canoe Story
  21. The Agua Caliente Tribal Cultural Museum - Palm Springs, California • A place that physically shares their ancient story and gifts. • Native people have woven their lives into the non-Native culture of North American for hundreds of years – It ’s now time to re-establish their identity in planning and design. They have many ancient gifts, verbal & architectural that they can share with us that just might be helpful in solving some of our country ’s difficult environmental, social, and cultural problems. And, they are worth interpreting! Thank You !
  22. Q & A on JPJ ’s talk. Click to advance.
  23. JNS introduction by MLH. Click to advance.
  24. This case study begins at Fort Bowie NHS. located in the Chiricahua Mountains of southeast Arizona, The area is part of the traditional homeland of the Chiricahua Apache people. It contains a year-round flowing spring. It was the location of a US army fort, And in 1886, the surrender of Geronimo and the Chiricahua Apache happened there.
  25. We were asked to create a long range interpretive plan for the site. This report would create new interpretive themes and make recommendations based on them that would guide the park for the next 10 years. We used an innovative process to involve descendants of the Chiricahua Apache in consultation.
  26. The park wanted to include the perspective of the Apache to create more balanced interpretive themes. Based on our experience with many other tribes, we felt that a long sit-down meeting with multiple stake-holders would not be effective. In addition, the four associated Apache bands no would need to travel from as far as Oklahoma to attend the meeting. So we really needed to take advantage of their efforts.
  27. We decided to invite descendants of the Chiricahua Apache for a day on the site. At this time we didn ’t include other stakeholders. The setting was informal, outside. We met briefly and then walked with them throughout the park. Through informal conversation we got a lot of insight about their perspectives on the events that took place here.
  28. 1. The park encompasses a 1.5 mile walk from parking lot to visitor center. Along the way are many historic sites.   2. we walked as a group to some of the locations significant to the Apache.   3. One of the sites we stopped at was the spring —it ’s actually named Apache spring. (PAUSE)
  29. At Apache Spring, one Apache woman knelt and touched and spoke with the spring and it told her that it needs to breathe. This showed a deep stewardship of natural resources that is relevant today, and is an opportunity for interpretation.
  30. In another location, the group critiqued the wayside panels. This panel about “The bascom affair” shows strong ethnocentric bias. The panel relays that Bascom and Cochise “collided” over the kidnapping of a young boy, But it doesn ’t mention that Bascom wrongly accused Cochise’s band of the kidnapping. Insulted and framed, Cochise used his knife to cut the army tent and escape. To the Apache, this event is known as “Cut the Tent.”
  31.   What Bascom and other Euro-Americans did not know is that the Apache had multiple bands with multiple leaders. Expanding the story here would bring cross-cultural awareness and perspective.
  32. The Apache representatives expressed frustration at the stereotypical portrayal of their ancestors as “Warlike” and “Warriors.” Fort Bowie presents an opportunity to challenge some of the stereotypes of the Apache prevalent in mainstream culture. They envisioned a more nuanced interpretation of their survivalist skills as very transferrable to the role of a warrior.
  33. Some panels reinforce the stereotype where they could be focusing on universal themes. Imagine that you were confined to a small area where you couldn ’t make a living and forced to desperate measures for survival. Would you consider this a fair and accurate description of the situation – that you are “ renewing hostilities for another decade”
  34. 1. The Apache representatives spoke about the spiritual connection to their homeland even though they have been separated from it for many years.   2. This idea reinforces the continuity of their culture and connects past to present.
  35. We were able to take away so much from this consultation.   The resulting report.   In this theme, dealing with tension and conflict, the original concept uses the phrase “clash of cultures,” which we rejected as too simplistic.
  36. The new theme paints a more detailed picture of the goals of each side that led to conflict. It also emphasizes that the story is still being interpreted today from multiple perspectives.
  37. This theme deals with the land and the spring. It only describes the spring ’s location as significant.   We again felt that “many important historic events” as well as “those living in southeast Arizona and beyond” were too generalized.
  38.   1. The new theme sets out to emphasize the water and the spring as a vital, central resource and cast it as the setting for every event that happened here.   2. The new report also makes a recommendation to restore the spring and asks the park if a new name might be considered – Apache Spring National Historic Site.
  39. 1. We were initially surprised to find that not all park staff were in agreement with the input we received from the Apache Representatives.   2. In the appendix of the report, we provided some raw material from discussions or emails that were part of the process. Many of these were statements and rebuttals.
  40.   Some staff members have a career of scholarship on these topics. Some created the existing interpretive elements. It was important to create space for these exciting new stories to be told, but also space for discussion and dissent to happen.
  41. Lesson learned: process is key. this innovative approach led to an honest and insightful interchange with the representatives of the Apache people. Tribal representatives and other stakeholders had input at further stages of the process.
  42. Don ’t be too excited to go out the old, in with the new. You risk alienating people if you bulldoze through old truths, or tip the focus too much on new information.
  43. Multiple perspectives paint the most accurate picture. There are multiple truths about situations with conflict. Multiple perspectives also take into account the visitor – making them part of the conversation.
  44. We are very excited about the results of our work and how the report will influence the interpretation of this site for visitors. Q & A of JNS presentation. Click to advance.
  45. MW introduction by MLH. Click to advance.
  46. The land we today call Glacier National Park Just celebrated 100 years as a national park Native people have called this land home for over 10,000 years Glacier interpretive theme on cultural resources
  47. First new exhibits since VC built in 1966 Only park VC with a permanent exhibition Some controversy over choosing a cultural theme vs. wider natural history
  48. We worked with several tribes – Blackfeet, Kootenai, Salish, Pend d ’Oreille Exhibits needed to provide balanced perspective of each Avoid generic names like “Plains Indians”
  49. Equal recognition presented design challenges – 3 or 4 views on each exhibit Desire of tribes to be even more specific Flags issue
  50. Bringing tribes together can create conflicts – traditional or new Blackfeet vs west side tribes
  51. Stories about the same resources or history not likely to agree This can require good negotiation skills to get to an acceptable place
  52. Have exhibits speak from tribal perspective, not your interp of tribal ideas Most important part of our project – this drove design
  53. NPS intro in first panel and then got out of the way Tribal leaders recorded welcomes to visitors at first exhibit Chief, cultural leaders, young Blackfeet girl
  54. Embrace controversial topics from the start and plan them into your exhibition Some of these may be known at start – others come up during consultation Be flexible!
  55. Ceded Strip and Hellgate Treaty Ceded Strip (1895) – still very much a current concern Our first full exhibit – give it a place of importance; don ’t hide away
  56.   Recognize communication protocols with each tribe Involve the highest level person in your organization if possible
  57. Tribal perspective is enhanced when members literally provide their own voice Use video interviews or voice recordings so tribes literally speak for themselves
  58. Most powerful part of our exhibition Nine short videos spoken from the heart Working on DVD for sales item and education outreach
  59. Embrace ambiguity and the diversity of tribal viewpoints Often times 2+2 does not equal 4
  60. To provide balance, may need to include conflicting viewpoints Time line idea wasn ’t going to work Blackfeet vs Kootenai – who was here first?
  61. You may be surprised by ideas and views that are very new and different Example – Divide – delta – VC location
  62. No other tribe should be represented in exhibit because of Divide connection Almost stopped the entire project
  63. Tribes are not living in the past – vibrant modern cultures Good to include historic views, but not by themselves
  64.   Having special events in association with exhibits shows modern perspectives Blackfoot Confederacy – NAS - Dancers
  65. Exhibits as good interpretation – NAI awards Building relationships with local tribes – most important
  66. Q & A of MW presentation. Click to advance.
  67. CD introduction by MLH. Click to advance. Richard West tie in
  68. CD introduction by MLH. Click to advance.
  69. Thank you to our partners in this project.
  70. For Fort Spokane Visitor Center is located in Guardhouse, one of only 4 remaining buildings Last of the forts of western expansion Its purpose was to keep peace between tribes on the reservations to the north and encroaching Euro-American settlement to the south. Fort operated from 1880 to 1898
  71. Second story is that of Boarding School which operated using fort buildings from 1900-1907 The boarding school was part of a nation-wide effort at coerced assimilation of American Indian children into the dominant culture. Children as young as 3 were taken from their homes and forced to attend boarding schools often many days travel from their homes. This effort was backed by a odd assortment of people including progressive thinkers who believed it was the only way American Indians would survive.
  72. Fort Spokane is located on the south side of the Spokane river at its confluence with the Columbia. On the north side of the Spokane River
  73. Representatives of the Spokane Tribe and of the Confederated Colville Tribes participated in the early planning process reviewed all phases of design Provided important input including language expertise Boarding school was a very traumatic experience for many children, and it is beginning to be recognized the long-term impacts and cultural disruption that the boarding school movement caused to tribes across the country. At the beginning several representatives expressed reluctance to interpret the boarding school story afraid it would open up too many painful memories A
  74. Representatives of the Spokane Tribe and of the Confederated Colville Tribes participated in the early planning process reviewed all phases of design Provided important input including language expertise Boarding school was a very traumatic experience for many children, and it is beginning to be recognized the long-term impacts and cultural disruption that the boarding school movement caused to tribes across the country. At the beginning several representatives expressed reluctance to interpret the boarding school story afraid it would open up too many painful memories A
  75. Worked with tribes to establish an overall exhibit theme of At the Confluence. To provide context we felt a historical timeline was important Tribal representatives expressed that their view of time was different than the linear approach of a timeline
  76. For this reason several elements were added An introduction, including an audio welcome, in their own voice A traditional calendar ball was added: women in the tribe add a bead or a shell for important family or tribal events. Then they can unravel the ball and recount the stories and events. A graphic representation of the calendar ball runs the length of the timeline linking tribal events.
  77. The timeline was divided up into some broad historical eras Each with an introduction, seeking to provide a balanced account of Euro-American and Tribal impacts. Too often histories only account for Euro-American perspectives.
  78. 3D relief model depicted the confluence, the fort, and a native American encampment. Provides visitors with a mental picture of the area and proximity of the two Central piece of the exhibit Scenes from Ft. Spokane series of immersive exhibits depicting life at the fort and life at the boarding school
  79. For both the fort and boarding school stories, an introductory panel A composite character was created for each to personalize the exhibits A composite was selected for two reasons: difficult to find first person accounts that cover the whole story tribes requested a composite to protect the privacy of individuals
  80. Children arriving at the fort were forbidden from speaking their native tongues, and their long hair was cut. Each immersive “vignette” included a backdrop of a historical photo, interactive elements (iron, laundry folding) and an interpretive panel. These two: vocational training the children received, and dormitory life
  81. This vignette depicts the academic schooling the children received. Each vignette also included a binder of historical photos and a period phone set on which visitors can listen to Sipi ’s narration about her experiences. The final vignette is in a surviving solitary cell.
  82. A final vignette, located in actual surviving solitary cells, Describes Sipi ’s experience.
  83. Separating fort and boarding school vignettes is a display case of artifacts depicting items familiar to children from their own cultures and those they were expected to wear and use at boarding school.. The day before the exhibit opened to the public . . . .
  84. • The process can facilitate cross-cultural dialogue and understanding. • The process can catalyze intra-tribal discussion and awareness . • The process, and the completed exhibit, can provide opportunities for cultural healing and pride . • Creation of artifacts and artworks for the exhibit supports local tribal economies and helps build pride in the community.
  85. • The process can facilitate cross-cultural dialogue and understanding. • The process can catalyze intra-tribal discussion and awareness . • The process, and the completed exhibit, can provide opportunities for cultural healing and pride . • Creation of artifacts and artworks for the exhibit supports local tribal economies and helps build pride in the community.
  86. • The process, and the completed exhibit, can provide opportunities for cultural healing and pride . • Creation of artifacts and artworks for the exhibit supports local tribal economies and helps build pride in the community.
  87. Q & A of CD presentation. Click to advance.
  88. MKB introduction by MLH. Click to advance.
  89. Nez Perce NHP – non traditional park with 38 sites in four states that encompass 13,000 years of Nez Perce history and culture. Administer directly three battlefields associated with the 1877 conflict between Nez Perce and US Army: White Bird (ID), Big Hole (MT), and Bear Paw (MT). Big Hole separately legislated site from 1910. Folded into NEPE orbit in 1992.
  90. Battlefield largely intact. Footprint includes sites associated with the Nez Perce (village site) and the soldiers (memorial site).
  91. Money came in for targeted changes, but anticipate money for replacement so it was repurposed for theme workshop facilitated by Aldrich-Pears and John Paul Jones.
  92. Stars aligned for project – renovation of VC coincides with exhibit project. Mission 66 facility upgraded and improves habitability of the bldg. and replaces outdated exhibit with more appropriate materials.
  93. Exhibit space odd angles; crowded lobby; inadequate and outdated exhibits that were a product of outdated historical views/historiography and really didn ’t do much to prepare the visitor for the story.
  94. New exhibit repurposes space; decreases foot print of lobby and provided more extensive exhibits that did a better job in preparing the public for what they were about to experience.
  95. Lobby – welcoming space; well lit with sky lights and provides something to entice visitors in
  96. Accessible, interactive map – 1877 about an event that transcends space and time
  97. NP voices
  98. Repurpose old exhibit room as theater
  99. Tie in exhibit with resource
  100. Exhibit brings story to modern times – audio stations and exhibit for visitor comments
  101. Q & A of MKB presentation. Click to advance to last slide.
  102. Final Slide.