Externalities are spill-over effects from production and consumption where no compensation is paid. They can be positive or negative. Negative production externalities occur when the social costs of production exceed private costs, such as pollution from factories. This leads to overproduction and deadweight loss. Positive consumption externalities exist when social benefits exceed private benefits, like public education, resulting in underconsumption. Government intervention may be needed to correct market failures from externalities and achieve social optimum. Externalities must be evaluated on their net social impact rather than in isolation.
2. What are externalities?
• Externalities are spill-over
effects from production and
consumption for which no
appropriate compensation is
paid
• Externalities lie outside the
initial market transaction / price
• Externalities cause market
failure if the price mechanism
does not take account of the
social costs and benefits of
production and consumption
• Externalities can be positive
and/or negative
Negative
Production
Externalities
Negative
Consumption
Externalities
Positive
Production
Externalities
Positive
Consumption
Externalities
3. Typology of Externalities
Production – Negatives Consumption - Positives
Where the marginal social cost
of production is higher than the
marginal private cost.
Where the marginal social
benefit of consumption is higher
than the marginal private
benefit.
Example (Negative) Example (Positive)
Air, land, river and noise
pollution which results from
factory emissions
Space junk
Community-access defibrillators
External benefits from museums
4. Negative production externalities
Air pollution from
factories
Pollution from
fertilizers
Industrial waste
Noise pollution Collapsing fish
stocks
Methane
emissions
When
answering
any question
on negative
externalities –
consider
whether the
external costs
are significant
and if so,
whether they
can be
measured
and valued
accurately
Marginal social cost > marginal private cost
8. Negative production externalities
MPB= MSB
MPC
Benefit,
Cost
Quantity
supplied
Q1 Q2
Deadweight
loss of social
welfare
A
B
C
MSC
Over-production
Social optimum is
where MSB = MSC
12. Typology of Externalities (2)
Production – Positives Consumption - Negatives
Where the marginal social cost
of production is lower than the
marginal private cost.
Where the marginal social
benefit of consumption is lower
than the marginal private
benefit.
Example (Negative) Example (Positive)
Lower transport costs for local
firms following construction of
new roads.
The impact on family life / social
cohesion of problem gambling or
drug addiction
Especially for AQA and OCR students
18. Evaluating externalities
• Externalities lie outside of market transactions
• Involve a divergence of private & social cost/benefit
• Some externalities are trivial
• Some are significant e.g. related to climate change
• Most goods and services have both positive and
negative externalities
• E.g. . If a government encourages consumption of a
good with positive externalities, it will also create some
negative externalities
• Key is to focus on the net social benefit or cost
19. Private optimum higher than social optimum
MPB
MSC
Benefit,
Cost
Quantity
consumed
Q2 Q1
C
A
MPC
MSB
Social optimum is
where MSB = MSC
20. Private optimum higher than social optimum
MPB
MSC
Benefit,
Cost
Quantity
consumed
Q2 Q1
B
A
MPC
MSB
Net loss of
social welfare
There are NET
negative
externalities in this
market) i.e. it is
costing society more
to produce these
units than society is
valuing these units.
A: Where MPB=MPC
B: Where MSB = MSC
21. Look out for
our revision
video
analysing and
evaluating
policies
designed to
cut carbon
emissions