Mais conteúdo relacionado Semelhante a Provenance-awareness: A pre-requisite to explanation-awareness (8) Provenance-awareness: A pre-requisite to explanation-awareness1. Competence Center
Case-Based Reasoning
PROVENANCE-AWARENESS:
A PRE-REQUISITE TO
EXPLANATION-AWARENESS
Thomas Roth-Berghofer and Benjamin Adrian
German Research Center for Artificial Intelligence DFKI GmbH
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
2. AWARENESS OF SYSTEM,
DESIGNER AND USER
• Awareness – from knowledge level perspective – always
means:
• Explicit knowledge
• Formal knowledge
• Recording / storing
• Book-keeping
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
3. AWARENESS OF SYSTEM,
DESIGNER AND USER
• Awareness – from knowledge level perspective – always
means:
• Explicit knowledge URI
• Formal knowledge
RDF
• Recording / storing
• Book-keeping HTTP
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
4. WITH PROVENANCE DATA
• Answer questions on …
• Where
• When
• Who
• How
•… provenance information was gathered or produced.
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
5. WITH PROVENANCE DATA
Trust?
• Answer questions on …
Quality?
• Where
• When Reliability?
Trust-
• Who
worthiness?
• How
•… provenance information was gathered or produced.
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
6. flickr RKB
Project
Geo- Euro- wrappr Explorer
Guten- Virtuoso
names Pisa
USING LINKED
stat berg Sponger
Open
Calais
RKB
World Linked
ECS
Magna- Fact- MDB South-
DATA FOR CASE
tune book
ampton
RDF Book
DBpedia Mashup
lingvoj Freebase
CiteSeer
W3C DBLP
GENERATION
WordNet Hannover
UniR
GEO
UMBEL Species DBLP
Berlin
Reactome
LinkedCT UniParc
o Drug
PROSITE
Daily Bank
Med
Pub GeneID
Chem
KEGG UniProt
Pfam
Disea- CAS
Gene
some
ChEBI Ontology
l OMIM
UniSTS
Case Inter
Pro
PDB
HGNC
MGI
PubMed
Model
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
7. flickr RKB
Project
Geo-
names
Euro- Guten- wrappr <skos:Concept
Virtuoso Pisa
Explorer
USING LINKED
stat berg Sponger
rdf:about="http://mycbr-project.net/models/
Open
Calais Recipe#Shallots">
RKB
Magna-
World
Fact-
Linked
MDB
<skos:prefLabel>
ECS
South-
DATA FOR CASE
tune book
RDF Book
Shallots
ampton
DBpedia Mashup </skos:prefLabel>
lingvoj Freebase
<rdf:type rdf:resource="ingredients_vegetables"/>
CiteSeer
W3C
</skos:Concept>
DBLP
GENERATION
WordNet Hannover
UniR
GEO
UMBEL Species DBLP
Berlin <skos:Concept
Reactome
LinkedCT
rdf:about="http://mycbr-project.net/models/
UniParc
o Drug
Daily Bank Recipe#Onions"> PROSITE
Pub
Med
GeneID
<skos:prefLabel>
Chem
KEGG Onions
UniProt
</skos:prefLabel> Pfam
Disea- CAS
Gene
<rdf:type rdf:resource="ingredients_vegetables"/>
some
l OMIM
ChEBI Ontology </skos:Concept>
UniSTS
CaseInter
Pro
PDB
HGNC
MGI
PubMed
Model
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
8. flickr RKB
Project
Geo- Euro- wrappr Explorer
Guten- Virtuoso
names Pisa
USING LINKED
stat berg Sponger
Open
Calais
RKB
World Linked
ECS
Magna- Fact- MDB South-
DATA FOR CASE
tune book
ampton
RDF Book
DBpedia Mashup
lingvoj Freebase
CiteSeer
W3C DBLP
GENERATION
WordNet Hannover
UniR
GEO
UMBEL Species DBLP
Berlin
Reactome
LinkedCT UniParc
o Drug
PROSITE
Daily Bank
Med
Pub GeneID
Chem
KEGG UniProt
Pfam
Disea- CAS
Gene
some
ChEBI Ontology
l OMIM
UniSTS
Case Inter
Pro
PDB
HGNC
MGI
PubMed
Model
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
9. flickr RKB
Project
Geo- Euro- wrappr Explorer
Guten- Virtuoso
names Pisa
USING LINKED
stat berg Sponger
Open
Calais
RKB
World Linked
ECS
Magna- Fact- MDB South-
DATA FOR CASE
tune book
ampton
RDF Book
DBpedia Mashup
lingvoj Freebase
CiteSeer
W3C DBLP
GENERATION
WordNet Hannover
UniR
GEO
UMBEL Species DBLP
Berlin
Reactome
LinkedCT UniParc
o Drug
PROSITE
Daily Bank
Med
Pub GeneID
Chem
KEGG UniProt
Pfam
Disea- CAS
Gene
some
ChEBI Ontology
l OMIM
UniSTS
Connection Case Inter
Pro
PDB
HGNC
Model MGI
PubMed
Model
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
10. flickr
flickr RKB
RKB
Project
Project
Geo-
Geo- Euro-
Euro- wrappr
wrappr Explorer
Explorer
Guten-
Guten- Virtuoso
Virtuoso
names
names Pisa
Pisa CORDIS
USING LINKED
stat
stat berg
berg Sponger
Sponger eprints
Open
Open
Calais
Calais
RKB
RKB
World
World Linked
Linked
ECS
ECS
Magna-
Magna- Fact-
Fact- MDB
MDB IEEE New-
South-
South-
DATA FOR CASE
tune
tune book
book
ampton
ampton castle
RDF Book
RDF Book
DBpedia
DBpedia Mashup
Mashup
lingvoj
lingvoj Freebase
Freebase LAAS-
CiteSeer
CiteSeer
CNRS
W3C
W3C DBLP
DBLP
GENERATION
IBM
WordNet
WordNet Hannover
Hannover
UniRef
UniR
GEO
GEO
UMBEL
UMBEL Species
Species DBLP
DBLP
Berlin
Berlin
Reactome
Reactome
LinkedCT
LinkedCT UniParc
UniParc
Taxonomy
o
o Drug
Drug
owl:sameas
PROSITE
PROSITE
Daily
Daily Bank
Bank
Med
Med
Pub
Pub GeneID
GeneID
Chem
Chem
KEGG
KEGG UniProt
UniProt
Pfam
Pfam ProDom
Disea-
Disea- CAS
CAS
Gene
Gene
some
some
ChEBI
ChEBI Ontology
Ontology
l OMIM
OMIM
UniSTS
UniSTS
Connection CaseInter
Inter
Pro
Pro
PDB
PDB
HGNC
HGNC
Model MGI
MGI
PubMed
PubMed
Model
As of July 2009
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
11. flickr
flickr RKB
RKB
Project
Project
Geo-
Geo- Euro-
Euro- wrappr
wrappr Explorer
Explorer
Guten-
Guten- Virtuoso
Virtuoso
names
names Pisa
Pisa CORDIS
USING LINKED
stat
stat berg
berg Sponger
Sponger eprints
Open
Open
Calais
Calais
RKB
RKB
World
World Linked
Linked
ECS
ECS
Magna-
Magna- Fact-
Fact- MDB
MDB IEEE New-
South-
South-
DATA FOR CASE
tune
tune book
book
ampton
ampton castle
RDF Book
RDF Book
DBpedia
DBpedia Mashup
Mashup
lingvoj
lingvoj Freebase
Freebase LAAS-
CiteSeer
CiteSeer
CNRS
W3C
W3C DBLP
DBLP
GENERATION
IBM
WordNet
WordNet Hannover
Hannover
UniRef
UniR
GEO
GEO
UMBEL
UMBEL Species
Species DBLP
DBLP
Berlin
Berlin
Reactome
Reactome
LinkedCT
LinkedCT UniParc
UniParc
Taxonomy
o
o Drug
Drug
owl:sameas
PROSITE
PROSITE
Daily
Daily Bank
Bank
Med
Med
Pub
Pub GeneID
GeneID
Chem
Chem
KEGG
KEGG UniProt
UniProt
Pfam
Pfam ProDom
Disea-
Disea- CAS
CAS
Gene
Gene
some
some
ChEBI
ChEBI Ontology
Ontology
l OMIM
OMIM
UniSTS
UniSTS
Connection CaseInter
Inter
Pro
Pro
PDB
PDB
HGNC
HGNC
Model MGI
MGI
PubMed
PubMed
Model
<http://mycbr-project.net/models/Recipe#onions> 2009
As of July
owl:sameas <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Onion>
<http://mycbr-project.net/models/Recipe#green_fettuccine">
owl:sameas <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Fettucine>
<http://mycbr-project.net/models/Recipe#spinach_noodles">
owl:sameas <http://dbpedia.org/resource/Noodle>
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
12. flickr
flickr RKB
RKB
Project
Project
Geo-
Geo- Euro-
Euro- wrappr
wrappr Explorer
Explorer
Guten-
Guten- Virtuoso
Virtuoso
names
names Pisa
Pisa CORDIS
USING LINKED
stat
stat berg
berg Sponger
Sponger eprints
Open
Open
Calais
Calais
RKB
RKB
World
World Linked
Linked
ECS
ECS
Magna-
Magna- Fact-
Fact- MDB
MDB IEEE New-
South-
South-
DATA FOR CASE
tune
tune book
book
ampton
ampton castle
RDF Book
RDF Book
DBpedia
DBpedia Mashup
Mashup
lingvoj
lingvoj Freebase
Freebase LAAS-
CiteSeer
CiteSeer
CNRS
W3C
W3C DBLP
DBLP
GENERATION
IBM
WordNet
WordNet Hannover
Hannover
UniRef
UniR
GEO
GEO
UMBEL
UMBEL Species
Species DBLP
DBLP
Berlin
Berlin
Reactome
Reactome
LinkedCT
LinkedCT UniParc
UniParc
Taxonomy
o
o Drug
Drug
owl:sameas
PROSITE
PROSITE
Daily
Daily Bank
Bank
Med
Med
Pub
Pub GeneID
GeneID
Chem
Chem
KEGG
KEGG UniProt
UniProt
Pfam
Pfam ProDom
Disea-
Disea- CAS
CAS
Gene
Gene
some
some
ChEBI
ChEBI Ontology
Ontology
l OMIM
OMIM
UniSTS
UniSTS
Connection CaseInter
Inter
Pro
Pro
PDB
PDB
HGNC
HGNC
Model MGI
MGI
PubMed
PubMed
Model
As of July 2009
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
13. flickr
flickr RKB
RKB
Project
Project
Geo-
Geo- Euro-
Euro- wrappr
wrappr Explorer
Explorer
Guten-
Guten- Virtuoso
Virtuoso
names
names Pisa
Pisa CORDIS
USING LINKED
stat
stat berg
berg Sponger
Sponger eprints
Open
Open
Calais
Calais
RKB
RKB
World
World Linked
Linked
ECS
ECS
Magna-
Magna- Fact-
Fact- MDB
MDB IEEE New-
South-
South-
DATA FOR CASE
tune
tune book
book
ampton
ampton castle
RDF Book
RDF Book
DBpedia
DBpedia Mashup
Mashup
lingvoj
lingvoj Freebase
Freebase LAAS-
CiteSeer
CiteSeer
CNRS
W3C
W3C DBLP
DBLP
GENERATION
IBM
WordNet
WordNet Hannover
Hannover
UniRef
UniR
GEO
GEO
UMBEL
UMBEL Species
Species DBLP
DBLP
Berlin
Berlin
Reactome
Reactome
LinkedCT
LinkedCT UniParc
UniParc
Taxonomy
o
o Drug
Drug
owl:sameas
PROSITE
PROSITE
Daily
Daily Bank
Bank
Med
Med
Pub
Pub GeneID
GeneID
Chem
Chem
KEGG
KEGG UniProt
UniProt
Pfam
Pfam ProDom
Disea-
Disea- CAS
CAS
Gene
Gene
some
some
ChEBI
ChEBI Ontology
Ontology
l OMIM
OMIM
UniSTS
UniSTS
Connection CaseInter
Inter
Pro
Pro
PDB
PDB
HGNC
HGNC
Model MGI
MGI
PubMed
PubMed
Model
As of July 2009
Texts
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010
14. flickr
flickr RKB
RKB
Project
Project
Geo-
Geo- Euro-
Euro- wrappr
wrappr Explorer
Explorer
Guten-
Guten- Virtuoso
Virtuoso
names
names Pisa
Pisa CORDIS
USING LINKED
stat
stat berg
berg Sponger
Sponger eprints
Open
Open
Calais
Calais
RKB
RKB
World
World Linked
Linked
ECS
ECS
Magna-
Magna- Fact-
Fact- MDB
MDB IEEE New-
South-
South-
DATA FOR CASE
tune
tune book
book
ampton
ampton castle
RDF Book
RDF Book
DBpedia
DBpedia Mashup
Mashup
lingvoj
lingvoj Freebase
Freebase LAAS-
CiteSeer
CiteSeer
CNRS
W3C
W3C DBLP
DBLP
GENERATION
IBM
WordNet
WordNet Hannover
Hannover
UniRef
UniR
GEO
GEO
UMBEL
UMBEL Species
Species DBLP
DBLP
Berlin
Berlin
Reactome
Reactome
LinkedCT
LinkedCT UniParc
UniParc
Taxonomy
o
o Drug
Drug
owl:sameas
PROSITE
PROSITE
Daily
Daily Bank
Bank
Med
Med
Pub
Pub GeneID
GeneID
Chem
Chem
KEGG
KEGG UniProt
UniProt
Pfam
Pfam ProDom
Disea-
Disea- CAS
CAS
Gene
Gene
some
some
ChEBI
ChEBI Ontology
Ontology
l OMIM
OMIM
UniSTS
UniSTS
Connection CaseInter
Inter
Pro
Pro
PDB
PDB
HGNC
HGNC
Model MGI
MGI
PubMed
PubMed
Model
As of July 2009
Ontology-based
Texts
Information Extraction
© 2010 DFKI CC CBR
Donnerstag, 5. August 2010