See some of the lessons learned by Gilt Groupe as they converted from Selenium 1 to Selenium 2.

1. Findings
and
Challenges

2.  Background
 Tools
 Past
 Challenges
 “The
Decision”
 Benefits
 Conversion
 Present
 Examples

3.  Custom
framework
written
in
Java
 In
house
test
management
system
 TestElements
▪ Projects
▪ Test
Suites
 Test
Cases
 Actions
 Data
Elements
 Object
Store
 Fully
integrated
with
our
Framework

4.  Eclipse
IDE
 TestElements
 Results
Viewer
 +
iPad
version
 SauceLabs
 SeleniumIDE
 Firebug
 Ivy
 Git
-­‐
version
control

5.  Selenium
1
&
Selenium
Grid
 6
lab
machines
▪ Mac’s
and
PCs
with
different
browser
combinations
 RC
for
each
desired
browser
on
local
machines
 RC
for
each
desired
browser
on
each
remote
machine
running
on
SeleniumGrid

6.  Maintenance
of
RC’s
 If
1
RC
had
an
issue,
must
kill
all
RC’s,
restart
HUB,
and
restart
each
one
again
 >
800
test
cases
executed
amongst
6
machines
multiple
times
a
day
▪ (approx.
2500/day)
 Parallel
execution
was
challenging
 Cross
browser
testing

7.  Solved
every
challenge
on
the
list
 Selenium
RC’s
in
the
cloud
 No
maintenance
 Video
 Replaced
Selenium
with
WebDriverBackedSelenium
 Selenium
1
backwards
compatible
 New
code
would
use
WebDriver

8.  WebDriverBackedSelenium
on
Sauce
 Each
selenium
1
command
would
spit
back
javascript,
causing
very
slow
test
execution
times
 WebDriver
commands
were
OK
 Did
not
realize
this
right
away
 Santiago
the
‘Sauce
Ninja’

10.  Convert
EVERYTHING…
 No
more
XPATH!
 CSS_SELECTOR
▪ Native
support
on
each
browser
 ID
 LINK_TEXT

11.  Improve
execution
speed
on
Sauce
 (no
more
JavaScript)
 Better
emulation
of
user
interactions
 Better
API
–
More
object
oriented
 Stability
 Improve
logic
in
codebase
 Don’t
want
to
be
left
behind
 New
version
of
Selenium
all
the
time
 Bug
fixes,
improvements
 Feel
they
care
about
the
product
 Fun

12.  Line
by
Line
conversion
 remove
any
selenium1
references
 Not
enough
documentation
existed
 Not
everything
appeared
to
be
easily
converted
 hover
/
mouseOver
 select
from
combo
box
 attachFile

13.  Different
functionality
 Objects
must
be
visible
before
acting
on
them
 Type
mechanism
does
not
clear
the
text
field
before
filling
it
out
*
changed
in
2.6
 Selenium2
is
blocking
▪ No
more
waitForPageToLoad(….)

 Use
ExpectedCondition
class
to
wait
for
presence
/
visibility
of
element
 Different
names
 no
more
isElementPresent
/
isVisible

14.  Simplify
codebase
 Find
Selenium2
conversion
for
everything
and
create
wrapper
in
our
Framework
 SeleniumBase.java
was
born
 Custom
WebDriver
commands
 All
scripts
extend
from
this
class
 Less
clutter
 Maintainability

17. public WebDriver getWebDriver() {
return webDriver;
}
public WebElement getWebElement(LocatorType locatorType, String locator) throws Exception {
return getWebDriver().findElement(by(locatorType, locator));
}
public List<WebElement> getWebElements(LocatorType locatorType, String locator) throws Exception {
return getWebDriver().findElements(by(locatorType, locator));
}
public boolean isElementPresent(LocatorType locatorType, String locator) throws Exception {
return getWebElements(locatorType,locator).size() > 0;
}
public boolean isVisible(LocatorType locatorType, String locator) throws Exception {
return getWebElement(locatorType,locator).isDisplayed();
}
public void waitForElementPresent(final LocatorType locatorType, final String locator) throws Exception {
getWait().until(new ExpectedCondition<Boolean>() {
public Boolean apply(WebDriver d) {
try {
return isElementPresent(locatorType, locator);
} catch (Exception e) {
return false;
}
}
});
}

18. public void clearAndSendKeys(LocatorType locatorType, String locator, String keys) throws Exception {
getWebElement(locatorType, locator).clear();
getWebElement(locatorType, locator).sendKeys(keys);
}
public void check(LocatorType locatorType, String locator) throws Exception {
if(!getWebElement(locatorType, locator).isSelected())
getWebElement(locatorType, locator).click();
}
public void mouseOver(LocatorType locatorType, String locator) throws Exception{
Actions action = new Actions(getWebDriver());
action.moveToElement(getWebElement(locatorType, locator)).perform();
}
public void selectComboBoxByVisibleText(LocatorType locatorType, String locator, String value) throws
Exception{
Select comboBox = new Select(getWebElement(locatorType, locator));
comboBox.selectByVisibleText(value);
}
public void switchToWindow(String windowTitle){
Set<String> windowHandles = getWebDriver().getWindowHandles();
Iterator<String> iter = windowHandles.iterator();
while(iter.hasNext()){
String currentWindowHandle = iter.next();
getWebDriver().switchTo().window(currentWindowHandle);
if(getWebDriver().getTitle().equals(windowTitle))
break;
}
}

19. clearAndSendKeys(LocatorType.ID,"Gilt Login Page","Email Address Text Field”,emailAddress);
clearAndSendKeys(LocatorType.ID,"Gilt Login Page","Password Text Field”,password);
getWebElement(LocatorType.ID,"Gilt Login Page","Sign In Button").click();

20. waitForElementPresentAndVisible(LocatorType.CSS_SELECTOR,"Gilt Carousel Bar","Selected Tab");
mouseOver(LocatorType.CSS_SELECTOR,"Gilt Carousel Bar","Selected Tab");
List<WebElement> saleTitle = getWebElements(LocatorType.CSS_SELECTOR,"Gilt Carousel Bar","Selected Tab Sale Links");

21. List<WebElement> productLookTitleAll =
getWebElements(LocatorType.CSS_SELECTOR,"Gilt Product Listing Page","Product Look Title Links");
List<WebElement> productLookTitleAvailable =
getWebElements(LocatorType.CSS_SELECTOR,"Gilt Product Listing Page","Available Product Look Title Links");
List<WebElement> productLookSoldOut =
getWebElements(LocatorType.CSS_SELECTOR,"Gilt Product Listing Page","Sold Out Product Look Title Links");

22.  99.9999%
converted
to
Selenium2
▪ attachFile()
 Stable
results
 Clean,
easy
to
manage
code
 SeleniumBase
continues
to
grow
 Ivy
to
manage
dependencies
 Upgrade
to
Selenium
2.x
quickly
 Push
changes
to
team
through
Git

23.  Make
the
switch
 Spread
the
work
out
to
save
time
 Be
aware
of
the
differences
b/t
Sel1
and
Sel2
 More
documentation
 Modularize
common
selenium
commands
 Selenium
Users
google
group

24.  Question???
 Comments….
Email:
jsanchez@gilt.com
Invitation:
http://www.gilt.com/invite/josesanchez