In our annual Toronto event, held at the Four Seasons Toronto, we presented Strategic Decisions for an Uncertain Future:
John Nicola, Chairman & CEO addresses several issues facing high net worth families:
• How will the Liberals’ tax changes affect financial planning for Canadians?
• How will inflated prices impact future returns?
• Are there best practices for navigating the current environment?
Rob Edel, Chief Investment Officer provides an investment roadmap for 2018:
• After a record-breaking period for the S&P 500, what signs might indicate an economic downturn?
• What current events could most affect the economy and investment strategy?
• What should one make of bitcoin, marijuana stocks, electric vehicles, and other hot topics for the upcoming year?
12. 2017 in Review S&P 500
2017 S&P 500 +21.8%
+1% Declines
Last
+5% Decline
June 24-27 2016
Feb 2, 2018
404 Days
Average since 1929
92 Days
Feb 8, 2018
-10.1%
Feb 2, 2018
404 Days
(Avg since 1929
92 Days)
Feb 8, 2018
-10.1%
2017 S&P 500 +21.8%
1%+ Declines
Last
+5% Drawdown
June 24-27 2016
13. 2017 in Review S&P/TSX
Sept 8, 2017
-0.1%
Sept 8, 2017
Dec 29, 2017
+9.2%
2017
S&P/TSX
+9.1%
• Financials: Concern over housing and consumer debt
• Energy: Western Canadian Select Crude differentials
• Small Technology weight
• NAFTA
• No tax reform
14. 2017 in Review Canadian and U.S. Yield Curves
Yield Curve
Yield Curve
Dec 31, 2017
Dec 30, 2016
Dec 31, 2017
Dec 30, 2016
0.74%
1.69%
2.04%
1.72%
+95 bps
+32 bps
1.19%
1.88%
2.44%
2.41%
+69 bps
Mar 20, 2018
15. Investment Road Map The Art of Forecasting – Tricks of the Trade
Business Insider Jan 4, 2016
24. Morgan Stanley Research – Sunday Start – What’s Next in Global Macro Dec 10, 2017
Investment Road Map
U.S. Tax Reform:
• Corp rate 35% to 21%
• U.S. Corporations hold estimated $2.6 trillion overseas
• Full expensing of business investment for five years
26. Bad Neighborhood Trade Wars
Source: Financial Times, February 2018
Trump strategy:
• Use the threat of tariffs as a negotiating tool
• Real target - China
• Reduce trade deficit by $100 billion, but intellectual property is key
• Made in China 2025 program
• 10 priority sectors - Advanced IT (5G), EV, AI, Robotics, Aviation…..
• China requires U.S. companies to form joint ventures & transfer IP
• US believes WTO have been too soft
• Designed before rise of Chinese state-backed capitalism
• Other countries in the same position
33. Bloomberg – Feb 3, 2018
Points of Interest Bitcoin: Blockchain
MIT Study: $270 - $317 million raised by ICO’s are
frauds or scams
Charles Kindleberger: “There is nothing so disturbing to
one’s wellbeing and judgement as to see a friend get rich.”
Blockchain
• A secure database, or ledger, spread across multiple computers
• Eliminate paperwork & speed up transactions
• Used to store and transfer ownership of goods & track them
through a supply chain
Bitcoin
• Digital Global Currency – used for everyday transactions?
• Store of value?
• Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index = Algeria
34. Points of Interest Bitcoin: Useless Etherium Token
Contributions in US$’s - $276,342
Enough to buy 230 televisions!
35. Points of Interest Marijuana
1 Year Cannabis Stock Performance
Barron’s – Mar 30, 2018
Canopy CEO Bruce LintonROB Magazine – Nov 12, 2017
Barely existed 3 years ago
Now dozens of companies
~$30 billion market cap
36. Points of Interest Marijuana
Globe & Mail – Feb 8, 2018Globe & Mail – Feb 8, 2018
Barron’s Mar 30, 2018
60 Private and public companies
Health Canada granted 89 licenses
Feb 1 – 244 more in review stage
Oregon/Colorado – wholesale $0.50 - $2.00
Commodity business
Low barriers to entry
No sustainable advantage
Canada
• Deloitte: After legalization
• $4.9-$8.7 billion market
• Low=rum, High=wine
• Price: $10/gram initially
Constellation Brands
• U.S. $50 billion Market
• Global: $200 billion in 15 years
• Wine: $60 billion
• Tobacco: $75 billion
37. Points of Interest Active vs. Passive Investing
Strategas – Technical Strategy & Analysis October, 2017
Strategas
3,202 active equity mutual funds
• Flat since 2002
• 2009-2017 $1.09 trillion in
outflows
ETFs
• 2003: 100
• 2009-2017 $1.7 trillion in
inflows
• 44% of equity AUM ETFs or
passive mutual funds
Strategas Technical Analysis Research – May 16, 2017
38. Points of Interest Active vs. Passive Investing
Strategas Technical Analysis Research – May 16, 2017
Low interest rates mean more bad companies are able to survive
39. WSJ – Feb 13, 2018
Long time horizon
$1 Billion in Dry Powder
Manager Selection
Points of Interest Active vs. Passive Investing: Private Equity
40. Summary
• Next recession at least 12 months away
• Conditions more challenging during next recession
• Risk asset still attractive in this environment
• Watch for sign of end of the cycle – lower risk exposure
• Avoid investment fads
• Active management to outperform
• We have reached our destinationBusiness Insider – Feb 7, 2018
45. What is the Rest?
Life insurance,
corporate bonds,
mortgages, private
debt
Private equity,
commercial real
estate, farmland
46. Asset Class Returns 1870-2015 (NBER)
1.3%
2.5%
6.7% 7.0%
T-Bills Bonds Real estate Equities
Real Returns
47. What asset allocation would achieve a real
return of 4% after fees over 30 years ?
1.3%
2.5%
6.7% 7.0%
T-Bills Bonds Real
Estate
Equities
Real Returns
T-Bills
15%
Bonds
25%
Equities
30%
Real
Estate
30%
Asset Allocation
Different kind
of 60/40
48. Asset Class Returns 1870-2015 (NBER)
4.6%
6.1%
11.1% 10.8%
3.3%
8.9%
10.7%
22.8%
T-Bills Bonds Real Estate Equities
Nominal Return Volatility
Same Return
Liquidity and
behaviour
60. Harbour Towers Hotel & Suites
Acquired: October 2015
Purchase Price: $23.0 M
Hotel Rooms: 196
Pre-Acquisition
• NOI – $1.5M
• NOI Yield – 6.5%
• Occupancy – 62%
• ADR* – $130
Post-Acquisition (2016)
• NOI – $2.0M
• NOI Yield – 8.7%
• Occupancy – 70%
• ADR* – $148
*Average Daily Rate
Acquisition, Victoria
61. Harbour Towers – Value Creation
Multi-Family Rental Conversion
219 New Rental Units
Projected Cost: ~$56.4 M
Projected Value: ~$67 M
Return on Cost: ~19%
Projected IRR: ~17% BEFORE
AFTER
62.
63. Transportation as a Service (TaaS)
• By 2030, 95% of all Passenger Miles will be
by Automated Electric Vehicles (AEVs)
• This will add about $5600 per family in
discretionary spending (10% of income or
$1 trillion)
• There will be minimal production of
Internal Combustion Engines (ICEs) or
individual ownership of cars.
• IO cars will be 40% of the fleet, but 5% of
passenger miles
• AEVs will have a lifetime mileage capacity
between 500,000 and 1 million miles
64. Transportation as a Service (TaaS)
• TaaS will be 4 to 10 times cheaper than
traditional owner driving
• Pre-TaaS companies (Uber and Lyft) drove
500,000 passengers per day in NYC in 2016
• By 2030 passenger cars in the US will drop
from 237 million to 44 million
• 70% fewer cars manufactured annually
• 50% more passenger miles in total at a cost
of $400 billion vs. $1.5 trillion today
65. Transportation as a Service (TaaS)
• Oil demand would drop to 70 million BPD
from what is predicted by the IEA at 110 million
BPD
• Price of oil could drop to $25 and make 50% or
more of North American Oil uncommercial but
still leave us energy independent
• Keystone and Dakota Access Pipeline would be
stranded
• Energy requirements would drop by 80% and
emissions by 90%
• Huge impact on oil industry, autos/trucks, auto
insurance
• Big geopolitical outcomes (impact on Canada?)
66. 39% Mid East
15% Russia
1% US
5% Canada
Oil Dependency
Cheaper oil
Who needs oil?
67. • When will this occur?
• Winners/Losers?
• Impact on related
products and
services?
• Impact on portfolio
mix?
68.
69. 60% drop in 4 years (average = $35/barrel)
It is now about
technology
76. Tax Reform 2017
What’s Being Plucked?
• Income splitting of dividends from private corporations
• Increase tax on passive corporate income that could reach 71% when paid
out as dividends
• Pipeline planning that converts dividends to capital gains is prevented
How is the Goose Doing Now?
• Income splitting allowed over age 65 with a spouse
• Otherwise no, unless labour or financial contribution
• Passive rules stay the same except reduction in SBD if passive income over
$50,000/year; more expensive to recover RDTOH in some cases
• Integrated tax on passive income can be as high as 56% in Ontario
77. Tax Reform 2018
Before Tax Reform
• Dividend compensation if SBD
• Income split using dividends and trust
• Accumulate passive assets in CCPC
and recover RDTOH when dividends
paid
• SBD not impacted by passive assets
After Tax Reform
• Salary RRSP/IPP better
• Over 65 on with spouse otherwise
labour or capital
• CCPC still better but try and minimize
taxable passive income
• Start losing SBD at $50,000 of passive
income. 100% gone at $150,000. Does
it make much difference?
84. Saving Corporately $100,000 pre-tax income
$88,000
$73,000
$12,000
$27,000
12% Business Tax 27% Business Tax
Tax
Saving
20% more to
save
85. Assumptions
• Save for 30 years
• 6% after tax return
• Take out income at
retirement as dividends
$7,300,000
$6,100,000
Assets in 30 years
SBD General Rate
20% more
saved