Presented at DeSForM 2013

1. Academic Publications For Designers
Christoph Bartneck
Tuesday, 15 October 13

2. Design as a craft
Tuesday, 15 October 13

3. Design as science
Tuesday, 15 October 13

4. Engineering - Psychology
Tuesday, 15 October 13

5. Approaches to
Design Science
•
•
•
•
Tuesday, 15 October 13
Design History
Rational Problem Solving
Systematic Organization Of Knowledge
Design Methodology

6. Quality
Tuesday, 15 October 13

7. Design Journals
Tuesday, 15 October 13

8. Design Patterns
Tuesday, 15 October 13

9. Generalizibility
Tuesday, 15 October 13

10. Tuesday, 15 October 13
g,
"T
ec
hn
ol
cie
og
nc
y"a
es
nd
" an
"A
d"
rc
Ot
hi
he
te
r"C
ct
ur
ul
e"
tu
Hu
ra
l /S
m
an
oc
iE
ia
M
es
l"
at
"an
he
Ph
d"
m
La
ys
aE
w
ica
ca
"
l "S
l "a
cie
nd
nc
"In
es
fo
"
rm
Ed
aE
uc
on
aE
Bu
"S c
on
si n
"
ie
nc
es
es
s"a
"an
nd
d"
"E
co
Bi
Cr
no
ol
ea
m
og
Ev
ics
ica
e"
"
l "S
an
cie
d"
Pe
nc
rfo
es
"
rm
in
M
g"A
M
ed
rts
āo
ici
"
ri"
ne
Kn
"an
He
ow
d"
al
le
Pu
th
dg
"
bl
e"
ic"
an
He
d"
al
De
th
ve
"
lo
pm
en
t"
l "S
ee
rin
cia
gin
So
En
Average'Output'Per'Person'
100"
90"
80"
70"
60"
50"
40"
30"
20"
10"
0"

11. Count of Outputs
500"
Biological"Sciences"
450"
Business"and"Economics"
400"
Crea=ve"and"Performing"Arts"
350"
Educa=on"
300"
Engineering,"Technology"and"Architecture"
250"
Health"
Humani=es"and"Law"
200"
Māori"Knowledge"and"Development"
150"
Mathema=cal"and"Informa=on"Sciences"and"
Technology"
100"
Medicine"and"Public"Health"
50"
Physical"Sciences"
0"
1"
Tuesday, 15 October 13
11"
21"
31"
41"
51"
61"
71"
81"
91"

12. Peer Review
Tuesday, 15 October 13

13. Provide suggestions
for improvement
Tuesday, 15 October 13

14. Judge the quality
of the paper
Tuesday, 15 October 13

15. Errors in the process
Quality of paper
high
low
accept
correct
type II error
reject
type I
error
correct
Judgement
Tuesday, 15 October 13

16. Everything that gets written,
gets published eventually.
Tuesday, 15 October 13

17. Tuesday, 15 October 13

18. Tuesday, 15 October 13

19. Tuesday, 15 October 13

20. Policies
•
•
•
•
Tuesday, 15 October 13
Only papers that have been rejected three times already are eligible
The rejections will be verified, but no additional peer review process
The peer comments will be published together with the paper
Authors write a response

21. Please submit!
Tuesday, 15 October 13