The document discusses the biology and management of hydrilla (Hydrilla verticillata), an invasive aquatic plant. It describes hydrilla's rapid growth rate, ability to spread through vegetative fragments and specialized structures, and high genetic diversity, which allow it to quickly dominate water bodies. The document also outlines different control methods used, including herbicides and biocontrol with grass carp, and debates the feasibility of eradication efforts. Factors that influence hydrilla's establishment and spread, such as climate and water quality parameters, are also reviewed.
AWS Community Day CPH - Three problems of Terraform
The Biology and Management of Hydrilla
1. The Biology and Management of Hydrilla
Michael D. Netherland
US Army Engineer Research and Development Center
Gainesville, FL
BUILDING STRONG®
2. Does Hydrilla Pose a Greater
Threat to Missouri Waters
Than Other Invasive Plants ?
Hydrilla Eurasian Milfoil Curlyleaf Pondweed
BUILDING STRONG®
3. Overview
Hydrilla
► Life history
► The “Perfect Weed”
► Invasion History
Factors Impacting Establishment & Spread
► Abiotic contraints
Control Methods
Feasibility of Eradication
BUILDING STRONG®
4. Hydrilla verticillata L.f. Royle
Hydrilla is a monocot - Hydrocharitaceae family
► Elodea, Egeria, and Vallisneria
► Early detection ?
Native to tropical SE Asia
► Found on 6 Continents as far North as Poland
Dioecious and Monoecious Biotypes
► Separate Introductions to the US
► Worldwide – Monoecious is tropical and Dioecious is
temperate
BUILDING STRONG®
5. Hydrilla - “The Almost Perfect Weed”
* Ability to cover thousands of contiguous acres
* propagates by fragments, turions, tubers, crowns
- tubers can remain quiescent for years (seed)
* Low light and CO2 compensation points
* Clonal plant - but high genetic diversity
BUILDING STRONG®
6. Why Plant Biology Matters ?
What is it about Hydrilla that
Allows it to Grow to Such
Abundance ?
6 BUILDING STRONG®
7. Does Hydrilla Grow an Inch per
Day ?
Data often presented in terms of biomass
► E.g. 400 grams dry wt. /square meter
Single 4” shoot grown for 35 days
1.2 M
BUILDING STRONG®
8. 3500
Hydrilla change in Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 Week 5
inches over 35 d
3000
Laterals 2±2 13 ± 6 43 ± 11 109 ± 29 127 ± 38
191.7 New Stems 2±0 6±1 34 ± 13 71 ± 16 110 ± 63
Runners 0±0 1±1 3±2 9±6 35 ± 20
2500
Total Length of New Growth (in)
2000
-A single 9 inch shoot resulted
in over 3200 inches of growth in
1500 182.3
5 weeks
1000
500
58.8
2.9 11.5
0
7/23/09 7/30/09 8/6/09 8/13/09 8/20/09 8/27/09
Harvest Date
BUILDING STRONG®
10. Dioecious Hydrilla
Southern Distribution in the US
► Clonal female population
Tubers produced - day length < 12 hr
► Fall
production (short window in North)
► May switch to axillary turions in North (rapid process)
Rapid Canopy formation
► Internodes measured in feet
Fluridone Resistant Populations are in FL
BUILDING STRONG®
11. Monoecious Hydrilla
Northern Distribution in the US
Tubers produced in summer
Dies Back in Winter (propagules)
Rapid lateral expansion
► Competitive interactions not documented
Multiple Eradication Programs Ongoing
BUILDING STRONG®
12. Greatest Threat to Missouri ?
Monoecious Biotype May be Well Suited to
Missouri
► Tolerates much higher disturbance
► Reservoir fluctuations
► Found in Reservoirs throughout the S.E.
► Becoming well established in TVA reservoirs
• Expansion westward
► We know much less about monoecious hydrilla
12 BUILDING STRONG®
13. Significant Milfoil or Hydrilla Presence
Natural Lakes
Reservoirs
Ohio River – Hydrilla
Expanding where no SAV
Was previously noted
High Energy Reservoirs /
Turbid with water level fluctuations
Generally not conducive to SAV (Monoecious hydrilla ? )
BUILDING STRONG®
14. Progression of Hydrilla
Spread
Year Number States
of States
1960 – 1969 1 FL (1953)
1970 –1979 6 AL, CA, DE, GA, LA
1980 – 1989 13 CT, MD, MS, NC, SC, TX,
VA
1990 – 1999 17 AR, PA, TN, WA
2000 – 2010 29 ID, IN, KY, MA, ME, NJ,
OK, WI, WV, NY, KS, OH
BUILDING STRONG®
15. Water Bodies in Wake County, NC with Hydrilla
70
Number of Water Bodies
60
58
50
40
30
20
12
10
10
1 2
0
1980 1982 1984 1986 1989
Year Surveyed
BUILDING STRONG®
16. Each Water Body Requires an INTRODUCTION !
Lake Gaston, NC
Plants move from large to small
water bodies and vice versa
Small Landscape Pond in NC
BUILDING STRONG®
17. Hydrilla in Wisconsin Pond –
Response by DNR
Positive i.d. in fall of 07
Completely drained pond for
winter drawdown
Spring 08- refilled and
treated with fluridone
Why such a strong response ?
Where did the hydrilla come from ?
BUILDING STRONG®
18. Management Options Are
Limited
Grass Carp – SE Reservoirs
Selective Biocontrol
Environmental Extremes
18 BUILDING STRONG®
19. Hydrilla Management
Grass Carp –
► “All or None control” in large systems
► generally non-selective or at least non-
predictable
► Still no efficient means for removal of fish
► Limited use in northern lakes due to low
preference for milfoil
• Cold water can reduce feeding
efficiency/predictability
BUILDING STRONG®
20. 13 Herbicides Labeled for Aquatic Use
(223 labeled for terrestrial use)
Copper (1900’s) 2,4-D (1950’s)
Endothall (1960) Diquat (1962)
Glyphosate (1977) Fluridone (1986)
*Amitrole, Dicamba, Dalapon Simazine, Fenac,
Dichlobenil, Silvex (most cancelled in 1987)
Triclopyr (2002)
Imazapyr (2003) Carfentrazone (2004)
Penoxsulam (2007) Imazamox (2008)
Flumioxazin (2010) Bispyribac (2011)
Blue = Plant Enzyme Specific Inhibitors
BUILDING STRONG®
22. California – Eradication Policy
Ongoing Eradication efforts for 30+years
► concern = agricultural irrigation
Aggressive and Immediate Action
Clear Lake (~ 40,000 acres)
► Eradication policy
► Treat 5 acres around individual plant finds
► Poor Economics on an acre basis / Good overall
Policy ?
Nationwide Eradication projects > 6 years
BUILDING STRONG®
23. Hydrilla and Ecosystem Services
Increased water clarity
Provides Structure and Food
► Hydrilla- low density = native plant
Does Not Produce Toxins (e.g. golden algae)
Valued by the Fishing and Hunting
Communities
►“ Fishing the Edge” “Ringneck duck buffet”
Growth Rate , Canopy formation, & “Just leave us a little”
Ability to Occupy Vast Expanses
► Access, Flood Control, Fishery Mgmt.
► Native Plants, Water Quality
BUILDING STRONG®
24. Hydrilla Expansion
Initial Establishment – difficult step
2 to 10% may be the hardest step
Once well established plant can
easily go from 30 to >70% coverage
- widespread cover and low biomass !
Hydrilla creates habitat for more Hydrilla
• Water clarification and wave reduction in open fetches
BUILDING STRONG®
25. Unintended Consequences
of Hydrilla Growth
Stignematalan algae – produces a novel toxin
25 BUILDING STRONG®
26. Kissimmee Chain of Lakes
– Headwaters- C&SF Flood Control Project
- Extensive hydrilla management
In a cruel twist of irony –
Florida DEP recently declared Lake
Toho impaired for Excessive
Macrophyte Growth (HYDRILLA)
BUILDING STRONG®
27. What Limits Hydrilla Growth ?
“It’s the light”, stupid
► Algal turbidity, suspended sediments
Poor Sediment quality or nutrition
Cyanobacteria blooms – toxins ?
Herbivores – general and specialists
► Grass carp, snails, etc.
Consistent Management ?
► Setting back the clock
27 BUILDING STRONG®
28. Unknowns for Hydrilla in MO
What is the greatest environmental
constraint to hydrilla growth in MO waters ?
• Fluctuating Reservoirs
• Seasonal Extremes (temp, flow, etc.)
• Sediment Composition
• Water Clarity
Can hydrilla colonize & proliferate in MO
Reservoirs ?
• We will likely find out
BUILDING STRONG®