Presentation by Jen Unwin at the SFCT research conference Orienting Solutions 2013, University of Hertfordshire.
For more resources like this, go to http://herts.ac.uk/hesian.
Call Girls Bareilly Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Jen Unwin: SF - the hope therapy
1. SF: The Hope Therapy
Dr Jen Unwin
BSc, MSc, PsyD, CPsychol, AFBPsS
Southport & Ormskirk NHS Trust
j.unwin@nhs.net
2. “HOPE is what makes us
strong. It is why we are here.
It is what we fight with when
all else is lost.”
- Pandora
3. Overview
• The importance of hope
• The placebo effect = hope
• Can we define and measure hope?
• What kinds of hope make a difference?
• Solution focused brief therapy and hope
• What next?
4. The Importance being Hopeful
Positive Psychology: Hope as a major component of
wellbeing and adjustment to adversity-Seligman
Wellbeing: High hope individuals have higher wellbeing
and self reported ‘health’ (synonymous?)
Morbidity: High hope individuals are less likely to get ill and
more likely to cope well if they do-Snyder 2002
Mortality: High hope people live longer-happy nun Study
A million anecdotes-’The Anatomy of Hope: how people
prevail in the face of Illness’ Dr J Groopman 2009
5. Unwin, Kacperek & Clarke (2009)
A prospective study of positive adjustment in
N= 99 lower limb amputation patients over 6 months
Including variables previously suggested to relate to
outcome in cross sectional studies (type and cause of
amputation, age, gender, disability, social support, coping
style)
Hope at the start of rehabilitation was the only variable to
explain significant variance in positive mood outcomes 6
months after lower limb amputation
6. The Placebo Effect
Latin: placēbō, "I shall please"
Levine et al (1981)
The percentage of post-op patients who reported pain relief
following
Placebo (39%)
4 mg morphine (36%)
Kahn et al (2008)
79% of placebo responders in anti-depressant trials do not
relapse
Kaptchuk et al (2013)
Open label placebos work for IBS patients-no deception
needed!
7. Dr Frank developed his understanding that all psychotherapies make
effective use of certain common principles, including a healing rationale,
hope, mastery, and a caring therapeutic relationship
8. Can we define Hope?
Frank (1975)
The perception that one can reach desired goals
Snyder (2002)
The belief that one can find pathways to desired goals
and the agency (motivation) to use those pathways
Scioli (2009)
Four Linked Sub-networks : mastery, attachment,
survival, spirituality
9. Unwin & Dickson (2010)
Goal focused hope, spiritual hope and wellbeing
On line cross sectional questionnaire study of N=207
university staff and students
Measures of goal focused hope, spiritual hope, satisfaction
with life and positive affect
Goal focused hope and spiritual hope are not correlated.
Goal focused hope is an independent predictor of
wellbeing but spiritual hope is not.
Spiritual hope has a buffering effect when goal focused
hope is low.
10. Hope SF
Desired Goals
Agency thinking
Pathways thinking
Iterative
SF & Hope
11. Can an SF intervention increase
Hope?
The Living Well Project
A co-constructed wellbeing course for patients with
long-term health conditions, facilitated by patient tutors
Five sessions based on SF principles
Uncovering each person’s:
Desired wellbeing goals
Strengths and resources (agency)
Weekly small steps (pathways)
12. Living Well pilot data
N Mean Sig
Hope 1 30 28.17 >.01
Hope 2 30 33.75
Positive mood 1 27 33.37 >.01
Positive mood 2 27 35.15
Subjective
Wellbeing 1
28 4.83 >.01
Subjective
Wellbeing 2
28 6.73
13. Conclusions
Hope is central to human flourishing
Hope is about a confidence that one can reach one’s
desired future
Solution focused therapy concentrates on enhancing the
research-identified key cognitive components of hope
Much more research to be done-which therapies are best
at enhancing hope, does wellbeing improvement mirror
rising hope? How can we maximise hope enhancement in
our work?
Should we re-name SFBT ‘Hope Therapy’?
14. References and Resources
Billington, Simpson, Unwin, Bray, & Giles (2008). Does hope
predict adjustment to end-stage renal failure and consequent
dialysis? British Journal of Health Psychology, 13, 4, 683-700.
Frank & Frank (1993). Persuasion & Healing. JHU Press.
Scioli & Biller (2009). Hope in the Age of Anxiety. OUP.
Snyder (2002). Hope Theory: Rainbows in the mind. Psychological
Inquiry 13(4): 249-275.
Unwin & Dickson (2010). Goal focused hope, spiritual hope and
well-being. Social Scientific Study of Religion, 21, 161-174.
Unwin, Kacperek, & Clark (2009). A prospective study of
positive adjustment to lower limb amputation. Clinical
Rehabilitation, 23, 1044-1050.
Notas do Editor
I’m a clinical Psychologist who works in health settings some of you may have come across my colleagues Dominic Bray, Vicky Bliss & Suzi Curtis
We work with people in health settings who have mislaid their hope
A belief that things will get better ‘a light at the end of the tunnel’ is all it takes.
But what about when hope is gone? 30% of people in hospital are depressed. This is a well established finding. We have focused much research on studying hopelessness. Working in an acute hospital I was struck by the amazing resilience of people in the worst circumstances. 70% - the majority are not depressed they are hope..ful
One chap found himself more hopeful after loosing his arm in an explosion-ask me later.
This paper is an attempt to summarise some of my thinking from the last 8 or so years on the topic of hope and why I believe that solution focused therapy is THE hope therapy.
I shall be discussing
The importance of hope-no one would disagree but what is the evidence?
I’m going to may a slight excursion into the topic of the placebo effect
The attempts for much finer minds than mine to define and measure hope (dad!)
What kinds of hope make a difference to wellbeing?
How do hope research findings map on to SFBT?
Where next?
Cross sectional study with a student and Dominic demonstrating the importance of hope in adjustment to renal disease
My own first study-seemed important not to do a cross sectional study and to have adequate power
So it seems that hope is pretty important it getting us through challenging experiences.
Another way that we can study the important effects of hope is through placebo research. In placebo trials the effect is HOPE. A belief that things will get better. As most of you know the effect can be very large indeed. And can also be long lasting. In meta analyses has been shown to have a genuine lasting effect in pain conditions.
Patients randomized to the open-label placebo group were given a typical prescription medicine bottle of placebo pills with a label clearly marked “placebo pills” “take 2 pills twice daily.” They were told that other people had benefitted in placebo trials.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3008733/
Of course this relates above all to psychotherapies. There is no medicine. There is only hope. And there is also nothing new under the sun.
We know that all the major types of therapy are effective to some extent.
Jerome Frank (a psychiatrist) devoted his career to understanding what made effective helping and the placebo effect.
His book was published in 1961. I commend it to you. I read it in 1986. then unfortunately trained to be a CP. And took a very long excursion away from simplicity!
So coming on to how to define hope. I’m sure you’ll appreciate that people have devoted lifetimes to this so apologies for the brevity of this summary
Frank and snyder. Scioli-just not simple enough!
There seem to be two key and different conceptualisations of hope in the literature goal focused and spiritual (feeling empowered/protected by a spiritual force or presence)
My second study
Recently replicated and currently a further replication with a clinical sample fibromyalgia patients
To summarise so far hope is important in a range of outcomes
A little bit of hope/placebo goes a long way!
A useful and useable conceptualisation of hope is Snyders agency/pathways model and seems to relate to meaningful outcomes
So let’s have a closer look at hope and SF
Pretty simple
Hope: having desired goals -approach goals, being able to visualise a pathway to those goals, have the confidence and motivation to pursue those pathways.
Solution focused therapy: uncovering and re connecting to desired goals and preferred futures, uncovering and re-discovering a sense of agency and ability, noticing oneself moving towards the desired future and imagining the next step.
Both iterative-each element re-inforcing the other. Hope theory was a theory without a practice and SF is a practice without a theory.
For me there could not be a better match than hope theory and the associated research and SF therapy as an intervention. Its wonderfully parsimonious
SF interventions should logically increase hope and I have a tiny bit of data on that so far
From our local version of the expert patient programme co constructed with LTC patients and based on SF principles. 5 week programme facilitated by patients themselves. Can talk about measures etc if people want to find me after
SWB is a 10 point scale