SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 9
The  Effect of Narrativisation on the Comprehension of Jury Instructions Sally Nelson Forensic Linguistics, CLCR, Cardiff University
Narrativisation of judicial directions ,[object Object],[object Object],US Standardised ‘Pattern’ instructions read verbatim England and Wales Judge’s sum up each case, reviewing the evidence. Vs.
Design ,[object Object],1  Only the legal directions from the Specimen Directions 2  Integrating specific evidence from the case into the Specimen Directions 3  Integrating specific evidence and using narrativising features e.g. vocatives and discourse markers
[object Object]
Mock jurors watched a simulated rape trial prior to receiving one of the three summings-up. Procedure
Preliminary findings
 
 
[object Object],[object Object]

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais de Michael Bromby

Annotated bibliography
Annotated bibliographyAnnotated bibliography
Annotated bibliographyMichael Bromby
 
OU Visual Evidence Programme
OU Visual Evidence ProgrammeOU Visual Evidence Programme
OU Visual Evidence ProgrammeMichael Bromby
 
Jury Symposium Outcomes & Plans 2010
Jury Symposium Outcomes & Plans 2010Jury Symposium Outcomes & Plans 2010
Jury Symposium Outcomes & Plans 2010Michael Bromby
 
Identifying And Measuring Juror Bias About Forensic Science Evidence
Identifying And Measuring Juror Bias About Forensic Science EvidenceIdentifying And Measuring Juror Bias About Forensic Science Evidence
Identifying And Measuring Juror Bias About Forensic Science EvidenceMichael Bromby
 
A Trust In Legal Professionals Scale Implications For Jury Functioning
A Trust In Legal Professionals Scale Implications For Jury FunctioningA Trust In Legal Professionals Scale Implications For Jury Functioning
A Trust In Legal Professionals Scale Implications For Jury FunctioningMichael Bromby
 
Juror understanding of evidence
Juror understanding of evidenceJuror understanding of evidence
Juror understanding of evidenceMichael Bromby
 
What jurors do with evidence during jury deliberation?
What jurors do with evidence during jury deliberation?What jurors do with evidence during jury deliberation?
What jurors do with evidence during jury deliberation?Michael Bromby
 
Legal Systems and Court Structures
Legal Systems and Court StructuresLegal Systems and Court Structures
Legal Systems and Court StructuresMichael Bromby
 
What is the Quality of this New Digital Legal World?
What is the Quality of this New Digital Legal World?What is the Quality of this New Digital Legal World?
What is the Quality of this New Digital Legal World?Michael Bromby
 
IAS Justice Programme Launch
IAS Justice Programme LaunchIAS Justice Programme Launch
IAS Justice Programme LaunchMichael Bromby
 
Digital Identity & Security
Digital Identity & SecurityDigital Identity & Security
Digital Identity & SecurityMichael Bromby
 
Glasgow Caledonian University's Innocence Project
Glasgow Caledonian University's Innocence ProjectGlasgow Caledonian University's Innocence Project
Glasgow Caledonian University's Innocence ProjectMichael Bromby
 

Mais de Michael Bromby (16)

Simulated learning
Simulated learningSimulated learning
Simulated learning
 
Annotated bibliography
Annotated bibliographyAnnotated bibliography
Annotated bibliography
 
OU Visual Evidence Programme
OU Visual Evidence ProgrammeOU Visual Evidence Programme
OU Visual Evidence Programme
 
Brain Imaging
Brain ImagingBrain Imaging
Brain Imaging
 
Research and The Law
Research and The LawResearch and The Law
Research and The Law
 
Jury Symposium Outcomes & Plans 2010
Jury Symposium Outcomes & Plans 2010Jury Symposium Outcomes & Plans 2010
Jury Symposium Outcomes & Plans 2010
 
Identifying And Measuring Juror Bias About Forensic Science Evidence
Identifying And Measuring Juror Bias About Forensic Science EvidenceIdentifying And Measuring Juror Bias About Forensic Science Evidence
Identifying And Measuring Juror Bias About Forensic Science Evidence
 
A Trust In Legal Professionals Scale Implications For Jury Functioning
A Trust In Legal Professionals Scale Implications For Jury FunctioningA Trust In Legal Professionals Scale Implications For Jury Functioning
A Trust In Legal Professionals Scale Implications For Jury Functioning
 
Juror understanding of evidence
Juror understanding of evidenceJuror understanding of evidence
Juror understanding of evidence
 
What jurors do with evidence during jury deliberation?
What jurors do with evidence during jury deliberation?What jurors do with evidence during jury deliberation?
What jurors do with evidence during jury deliberation?
 
BILETA 2010
BILETA 2010BILETA 2010
BILETA 2010
 
Legal Systems and Court Structures
Legal Systems and Court StructuresLegal Systems and Court Structures
Legal Systems and Court Structures
 
What is the Quality of this New Digital Legal World?
What is the Quality of this New Digital Legal World?What is the Quality of this New Digital Legal World?
What is the Quality of this New Digital Legal World?
 
IAS Justice Programme Launch
IAS Justice Programme LaunchIAS Justice Programme Launch
IAS Justice Programme Launch
 
Digital Identity & Security
Digital Identity & SecurityDigital Identity & Security
Digital Identity & Security
 
Glasgow Caledonian University's Innocence Project
Glasgow Caledonian University's Innocence ProjectGlasgow Caledonian University's Innocence Project
Glasgow Caledonian University's Innocence Project
 

The Effect Of Narrativisation On The Comprehension Of Jury Instructions