SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 21
vs. ? Copyleft
So what is copyright and copyleft?  Is there a balance between the two?
Copyright “[They] own the culture that we live in, they represent the past. …For these people, ideas are intellectual property, locked up until purchased.”-Gaylor
Copyleft “Those who want to share ideas, those people believe that the public domain must be protected to ensure the free exchange of ideas and the future of art and culture.”-Gaylor
The right balance for both the “right” people and the “left” people will be to cite the borrowed work.
An example of a copyright infringement:
Is his Music not original enough?  What is originality?
“Originality is when you mix two things that haven’t been mix together.”-DJ Marlboro, Brazil
But the RIAA doesn’t think so
…and clearly Simon Fraser University doesn’t think so: “SFU is handing over to the copyright system various regulatory functions that could be handled, and normally are handled, by the citation system.”-Murray
What can be our solution? I am using The Verve’s Sweet Symphony!!!!! Happy now?
What can be our solution? Citation is the answer
Without citation, your work, with borrowed information, is a plagiarized work. Or is it a copyright infringement?
What are the differences? Plagiarism “…is a matter of ethics… [the] use or reuse of words without acknowledgement.”-Murray Copyright infringement “…is a matter of law…[the] use or reuse of words without permission.”-Murray
Plagiarism “…is a matter of etiquette, a crime against the group (the audience).”-Murray
Copyright infringement “…is a matter of law, a crime against the individual (the source).”-Murray
Why ask permission…
…when you can “footnote with grace?”-Murray
“Today we are exploiting electronics writing to oppose standardization and unification.”-Bolter … to share, and to create
Acknowledge the authors; cite borrowed works; and protect our public domain.
Work Cited Bolter, Jay David. “The Network Culture.” Writing Space Second Edition (2001).  Murray, Laura J. “The Costs of Confusion” Plagiarism and Copyright Infringement (2008) Gaylor, Brett. RiP! A Remix Manifesto." RiP! A 	Remix Manifesto. Web. 25 Sep 2010. 	<http://films.nfb.ca/rip-a-remix-	manifesto/>.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Copyright Models of The Past
Copyright Models of The PastCopyright Models of The Past
Copyright Models of The Pastderincag
 
Remix Mega-Mix for Digital Rhetoric and Writing
Remix Mega-Mix for Digital Rhetoric and WritingRemix Mega-Mix for Digital Rhetoric and Writing
Remix Mega-Mix for Digital Rhetoric and WritingMiami University
 
ENG/IMS 224 January 24th, 2013
ENG/IMS 224 January 24th, 2013ENG/IMS 224 January 24th, 2013
ENG/IMS 224 January 24th, 2013Miami University
 
Copyright presentation
Copyright presentationCopyright presentation
Copyright presentationKristi DeRoche
 
Copyright And Fairuse
Copyright And FairuseCopyright And Fairuse
Copyright And Fairusewebbs1
 
Who wins when copyright and free speech clash?
Who wins when copyright and free speech clash?Who wins when copyright and free speech clash?
Who wins when copyright and free speech clash?Graham Smith
 
Copyright Presentation
Copyright PresentationCopyright Presentation
Copyright Presentationaheitel
 
Introduction To Copyright Law
Introduction To Copyright LawIntroduction To Copyright Law
Introduction To Copyright LawJerry Stovall
 
EDT-7820 Fair-Use Summary
EDT-7820 Fair-Use SummaryEDT-7820 Fair-Use Summary
EDT-7820 Fair-Use Summaryslw321
 
copyright (under indian cyber law)
copyright (under indian cyber law)copyright (under indian cyber law)
copyright (under indian cyber law)ravindra sharma
 

Mais procurados (20)

Copyright fair use-cc
Copyright fair use-ccCopyright fair use-cc
Copyright fair use-cc
 
Copyright Models of The Past
Copyright Models of The PastCopyright Models of The Past
Copyright Models of The Past
 
Remix Mega-Mix for Digital Rhetoric and Writing
Remix Mega-Mix for Digital Rhetoric and WritingRemix Mega-Mix for Digital Rhetoric and Writing
Remix Mega-Mix for Digital Rhetoric and Writing
 
ENG/IMS 224 January 24th, 2013
ENG/IMS 224 January 24th, 2013ENG/IMS 224 January 24th, 2013
ENG/IMS 224 January 24th, 2013
 
Copyright presentation
Copyright presentationCopyright presentation
Copyright presentation
 
Copyright, fair use & public domain
Copyright, fair use & public domainCopyright, fair use & public domain
Copyright, fair use & public domain
 
Copyright And Fairuse
Copyright And FairuseCopyright And Fairuse
Copyright And Fairuse
 
Who wins when copyright and free speech clash?
Who wins when copyright and free speech clash?Who wins when copyright and free speech clash?
Who wins when copyright and free speech clash?
 
Copyright Presentation
Copyright PresentationCopyright Presentation
Copyright Presentation
 
ENG IMS 224 April 9, 2013
ENG IMS 224 April 9, 2013ENG IMS 224 April 9, 2013
ENG IMS 224 April 9, 2013
 
Copyright
Copyright Copyright
Copyright
 
Copyright
CopyrightCopyright
Copyright
 
Introduction To Copyright Law
Introduction To Copyright LawIntroduction To Copyright Law
Introduction To Copyright Law
 
EDT-7820 Fair-Use Summary
EDT-7820 Fair-Use SummaryEDT-7820 Fair-Use Summary
EDT-7820 Fair-Use Summary
 
Copyright lecture
Copyright lectureCopyright lecture
Copyright lecture
 
Copyright lesson ppt
Copyright lesson pptCopyright lesson ppt
Copyright lesson ppt
 
Copyright act
Copyright actCopyright act
Copyright act
 
copyright (under indian cyber law)
copyright (under indian cyber law)copyright (under indian cyber law)
copyright (under indian cyber law)
 
A Lecture in Copyright
A Lecture in CopyrightA Lecture in Copyright
A Lecture in Copyright
 
Copyright Act 1957
Copyright Act 1957Copyright Act 1957
Copyright Act 1957
 

Semelhante a Citation wins the war

The public domain book it
The public domain book itThe public domain book it
The public domain book itchubbyat
 
Copyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and PlagiarismCopyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and PlagiarismPaula Pavlova
 
Blog3 final
Blog3 finalBlog3 final
Blog3 finalAlicia
 
Copyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and PlagiarismCopyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and PlagiarismPaula Pavlova
 
Copyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and PlagiarismCopyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and PlagiarismPaula Pavlova
 
Copyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty WordCopyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty WordAlicia
 
Copyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty WordCopyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty WordAlicia
 
Plagiarism
PlagiarismPlagiarism
PlagiarismDuc
 
Blog3 final
Blog3 finalBlog3 final
Blog3 finalAlicia
 
Shalini sahoo -copyright vs. plagiarism[1]
Shalini sahoo -copyright vs. plagiarism[1]Shalini sahoo -copyright vs. plagiarism[1]
Shalini sahoo -copyright vs. plagiarism[1]shalinisahoo
 
Copyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty WordCopyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty WordAlicia
 
Smith l cse619 blog 6
Smith l cse619 blog 6Smith l cse619 blog 6
Smith l cse619 blog 6smithwoumse
 
Feb 24th Monday Night VisRhet
Feb 24th Monday Night VisRhetFeb 24th Monday Night VisRhet
Feb 24th Monday Night VisRhetMiami University
 
Mp3, copyright and culture industry presentation
Mp3, copyright and culture industry presentationMp3, copyright and culture industry presentation
Mp3, copyright and culture industry presentationJames Bedford
 
Whyquestioncopyright
WhyquestioncopyrightWhyquestioncopyright
WhyquestioncopyrightCamille Acey
 

Semelhante a Citation wins the war (20)

The public domain book it
The public domain book itThe public domain book it
The public domain book it
 
Copyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and PlagiarismCopyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and Plagiarism
 
Blog3 final
Blog3 finalBlog3 final
Blog3 final
 
Copyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and PlagiarismCopyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and Plagiarism
 
Copyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and PlagiarismCopyright and Plagiarism
Copyright and Plagiarism
 
Copyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty WordCopyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty Word
 
Copyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty WordCopyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty Word
 
Plagiarism
PlagiarismPlagiarism
Plagiarism
 
Blog 3
Blog 3Blog 3
Blog 3
 
Blog3 final
Blog3 finalBlog3 final
Blog3 final
 
Shalini sahoo -copyright vs. plagiarism[1]
Shalini sahoo -copyright vs. plagiarism[1]Shalini sahoo -copyright vs. plagiarism[1]
Shalini sahoo -copyright vs. plagiarism[1]
 
Copyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty WordCopyright: A Dirty Word
Copyright: A Dirty Word
 
Fys (1)
Fys (1)Fys (1)
Fys (1)
 
Fys (1) (1)
Fys (1) (1)Fys (1) (1)
Fys (1) (1)
 
FYS Research Paper
FYS Research PaperFYS Research Paper
FYS Research Paper
 
Smith l cse619 blog 6
Smith l cse619 blog 6Smith l cse619 blog 6
Smith l cse619 blog 6
 
Remix culture
Remix cultureRemix culture
Remix culture
 
Feb 24th Monday Night VisRhet
Feb 24th Monday Night VisRhetFeb 24th Monday Night VisRhet
Feb 24th Monday Night VisRhet
 
Mp3, copyright and culture industry presentation
Mp3, copyright and culture industry presentationMp3, copyright and culture industry presentation
Mp3, copyright and culture industry presentation
 
Whyquestioncopyright
WhyquestioncopyrightWhyquestioncopyright
Whyquestioncopyright
 

Citation wins the war

  • 2. So what is copyright and copyleft? Is there a balance between the two?
  • 3. Copyright “[They] own the culture that we live in, they represent the past. …For these people, ideas are intellectual property, locked up until purchased.”-Gaylor
  • 4. Copyleft “Those who want to share ideas, those people believe that the public domain must be protected to ensure the free exchange of ideas and the future of art and culture.”-Gaylor
  • 5. The right balance for both the “right” people and the “left” people will be to cite the borrowed work.
  • 6. An example of a copyright infringement:
  • 7. Is his Music not original enough? What is originality?
  • 8. “Originality is when you mix two things that haven’t been mix together.”-DJ Marlboro, Brazil
  • 9. But the RIAA doesn’t think so
  • 10. …and clearly Simon Fraser University doesn’t think so: “SFU is handing over to the copyright system various regulatory functions that could be handled, and normally are handled, by the citation system.”-Murray
  • 11. What can be our solution? I am using The Verve’s Sweet Symphony!!!!! Happy now?
  • 12. What can be our solution? Citation is the answer
  • 13. Without citation, your work, with borrowed information, is a plagiarized work. Or is it a copyright infringement?
  • 14. What are the differences? Plagiarism “…is a matter of ethics… [the] use or reuse of words without acknowledgement.”-Murray Copyright infringement “…is a matter of law…[the] use or reuse of words without permission.”-Murray
  • 15. Plagiarism “…is a matter of etiquette, a crime against the group (the audience).”-Murray
  • 16. Copyright infringement “…is a matter of law, a crime against the individual (the source).”-Murray
  • 18. …when you can “footnote with grace?”-Murray
  • 19. “Today we are exploiting electronics writing to oppose standardization and unification.”-Bolter … to share, and to create
  • 20. Acknowledge the authors; cite borrowed works; and protect our public domain.
  • 21. Work Cited Bolter, Jay David. “The Network Culture.” Writing Space Second Edition (2001). Murray, Laura J. “The Costs of Confusion” Plagiarism and Copyright Infringement (2008) Gaylor, Brett. RiP! A Remix Manifesto." RiP! A Remix Manifesto. Web. 25 Sep 2010. <http://films.nfb.ca/rip-a-remix- manifesto/>.