SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 17
Tackling historiography through local history Sian Morgan Hall, Historic Houses Trust NSW  Dr John McLellan, Nowra Anglican College Philip Roberts, University of Canberra.
Thinking Historically ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Substantive Knowledge Procedural Knowledge
Lévesque, 2008
Benchmarks of Historical Thinking  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Historical Literacy Taylor, T. and C. Young (2004)
Challenge the ‘generic’ wisdom Authentic Pedagogy (Newman et al USA) Productive Pedagogy (Lingard et al Qld) Quality Teaching  (Gore et al NSW)
 
Positioning the source Content-Meaning Context Reinforces dominance Empowers local Context Content-Meaning
Aim ,[object Object]
Objectives - Learn about ,[object Object],[object Object]
Objectives - appreciate ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Part 1: What is History ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Part II: History Project ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What is History? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],The Readings Students will use a source book of historical readings to gain a background understanding of historiographical issues in order to place the issues examined in their case study within a broader context. Case Studies Each case study has a principal focus and five associated areas of historical debate. The case study enables students to examine historiographical issues within a specific context.
Option 22: The Arrival of the British in Australia Principal focus:  students investigate changing interpretations of the arrival of the British in Australia (to 1848). Students examine the approaches to history and interpretations (including recent historiography) that have resulted in historical debate in the areas of: – terra nullius and land – invasion or settlement – colonial administrators (eg Phillip, Gipps) – expansion and exploration – the response of indigenous Australians to the arrival of  the British.
Part II: History Project ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
History Project Assessment Criteria Component Criteria Weighting Synopsis Coherent and appropriate description of: •  the development of the precise research question •  the way the essay addresses the precise question •  why content used in the essay was included The Product Essay In response to the precise research question(s): •  presents a sustained and coherent argument •  supports argument through detailed coherent analysis and evaluation of significant historiographical questions •  uses a recognised system of referencing 30 The Bibliography •  Use of a range of relevant sources •  Consistently formatted alphabetical list •  Appropriate correlation of sources in bibliography to sources used in the essay •  Sound selection, analysis and evaluation of three sources The Process Proposal •  Appropriate enquiry question(s)  •  Sound analysis of relevant issues •  Coherent explanation of preliminary research and anticipated resources The Process Log •  Detailed description of procedures and of the sequential development of the project •  Detailed analytical and coherent review of cumulative self, peer and teacher evaluation of the project 10

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Hist 2005 teaching a topic lc
Hist 2005 teaching a topic lcHist 2005 teaching a topic lc
Hist 2005 teaching a topic lc
siobhanpdst
 
07. historical method
07. historical method07. historical method
07. historical method
Justin Morris
 
Historical research
Historical researchHistorical research
Historical research
Noor Hasmida
 
Primary Source Research Day
Primary Source Research DayPrimary Source Research Day
Primary Source Research Day
Ann Johnson
 

Mais procurados (18)

Historical comparative research
Historical comparative researchHistorical comparative research
Historical comparative research
 
Group presentation (ethnographic and historical research)
Group presentation (ethnographic and historical research)Group presentation (ethnographic and historical research)
Group presentation (ethnographic and historical research)
 
Hist 2005 teaching a topic lc
Hist 2005 teaching a topic lcHist 2005 teaching a topic lc
Hist 2005 teaching a topic lc
 
07. historical method
07. historical method07. historical method
07. historical method
 
Historical Research
Historical ResearchHistorical Research
Historical Research
 
M.ed ii year syllubus
M.ed ii year syllubusM.ed ii year syllubus
M.ed ii year syllubus
 
Historical method (written report)
Historical method (written report)Historical method (written report)
Historical method (written report)
 
Restrepo arango russell-sti2014 (1)
Restrepo arango russell-sti2014 (1)Restrepo arango russell-sti2014 (1)
Restrepo arango russell-sti2014 (1)
 
Historical research
Historical researchHistorical research
Historical research
 
Historical Research in Education
Historical Research in EducationHistorical Research in Education
Historical Research in Education
 
Designing impactful research in social sciences
Designing impactful research in social sciencesDesigning impactful research in social sciences
Designing impactful research in social sciences
 
Historical research
Historical researchHistorical research
Historical research
 
Historical research design
Historical research designHistorical research design
Historical research design
 
HISTORICAL RESEARCH
HISTORICAL RESEARCHHISTORICAL RESEARCH
HISTORICAL RESEARCH
 
historical research
historical researchhistorical research
historical research
 
Primary Source Research Day
Primary Source Research DayPrimary Source Research Day
Primary Source Research Day
 
Historical research
Historical researchHistorical research
Historical research
 
For all
For allFor all
For all
 

Destaque (9)

Showlab CiB_presentacion_int>act
Showlab CiB_presentacion_int>actShowlab CiB_presentacion_int>act
Showlab CiB_presentacion_int>act
 
Morgan hall
Morgan hallMorgan hall
Morgan hall
 
Diffey
DiffeyDiffey
Diffey
 
Isa
IsaIsa
Isa
 
Baird
BairdBaird
Baird
 
Mc lellan
Mc lellanMc lellan
Mc lellan
 
Drupal Performance - SerBenfiquista.com Case Study
Drupal Performance - SerBenfiquista.com Case StudyDrupal Performance - SerBenfiquista.com Case Study
Drupal Performance - SerBenfiquista.com Case Study
 
Lesssons from reform_around_the_world_0
Lesssons from reform_around_the_world_0Lesssons from reform_around_the_world_0
Lesssons from reform_around_the_world_0
 
Griffin
GriffinGriffin
Griffin
 

Semelhante a Tackling historiography through local p1

Lc history guidelines for teachers
Lc history guidelines for teachersLc history guidelines for teachers
Lc history guidelines for teachers
siobhanpdst
 
Patterns of study compliled
Patterns of study compliledPatterns of study compliled
Patterns of study compliled
belindaastanton
 
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
DanicaAnnStaRosa2
 
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
DanicaAnnStaRosa2
 
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
DanicaAnnStaRosa2
 
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
DanicaAnnStaRosa2
 
slide show Case%20 studiestropf
slide show Case%20 studiestropfslide show Case%20 studiestropf
slide show Case%20 studiestropf
Karly Bagaipo
 
Ucbhsspaugustusbuildsaromanempireworkshoppresentation 110302130532-phpapp02
Ucbhsspaugustusbuildsaromanempireworkshoppresentation 110302130532-phpapp02Ucbhsspaugustusbuildsaromanempireworkshoppresentation 110302130532-phpapp02
Ucbhsspaugustusbuildsaromanempireworkshoppresentation 110302130532-phpapp02
Rebekah Madera
 

Semelhante a Tackling historiography through local p1 (20)

dravya research.pptx
dravya research.pptxdravya research.pptx
dravya research.pptx
 
dravya research.pptx
dravya research.pptxdravya research.pptx
dravya research.pptx
 
Arch_research_methods.pdf
Arch_research_methods.pdfArch_research_methods.pdf
Arch_research_methods.pdf
 
Lc history guidelines for teachers
Lc history guidelines for teachersLc history guidelines for teachers
Lc history guidelines for teachers
 
Jameel 6461 day 2.pdf
Jameel 6461 day 2.pdfJameel 6461 day 2.pdf
Jameel 6461 day 2.pdf
 
Patterns of study compliled
Patterns of study compliledPatterns of study compliled
Patterns of study compliled
 
Historical research
Historical researchHistorical research
Historical research
 
Lc history sy
Lc history syLc history sy
Lc history sy
 
Teaching research methods in LIS programs: Approaches, formats, and innovativ...
Teaching research methods in LIS programs: Approaches, formats, and innovativ...Teaching research methods in LIS programs: Approaches, formats, and innovativ...
Teaching research methods in LIS programs: Approaches, formats, and innovativ...
 
Teaching research methods in LIS programs: Approaches, formats, and innovativ...
Teaching research methods in LIS programs: Approaches, formats, and innovativ...Teaching research methods in LIS programs: Approaches, formats, and innovativ...
Teaching research methods in LIS programs: Approaches, formats, and innovativ...
 
toaz.info-readings-in-philippine-history-syllabus-pr_dc64ffaf9c8687ab5215cf8c...
toaz.info-readings-in-philippine-history-syllabus-pr_dc64ffaf9c8687ab5215cf8c...toaz.info-readings-in-philippine-history-syllabus-pr_dc64ffaf9c8687ab5215cf8c...
toaz.info-readings-in-philippine-history-syllabus-pr_dc64ffaf9c8687ab5215cf8c...
 
Chapter7
Chapter7Chapter7
Chapter7
 
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
 
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
 
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
 
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
Lesson 3 and 4 Qualitative VS Quantitative, Strengths, Weaknesses and Kinds o...
 
Research papers in History For UK.pptx
Research papers in History For UK.pptxResearch papers in History For UK.pptx
Research papers in History For UK.pptx
 
Historical Research
Historical ResearchHistorical Research
Historical Research
 
slide show Case%20 studiestropf
slide show Case%20 studiestropfslide show Case%20 studiestropf
slide show Case%20 studiestropf
 
Ucbhsspaugustusbuildsaromanempireworkshoppresentation 110302130532-phpapp02
Ucbhsspaugustusbuildsaromanempireworkshoppresentation 110302130532-phpapp02Ucbhsspaugustusbuildsaromanempireworkshoppresentation 110302130532-phpapp02
Ucbhsspaugustusbuildsaromanempireworkshoppresentation 110302130532-phpapp02
 

Mais de leadingcurriculum (13)

Henwood
HenwoodHenwood
Henwood
 
Troy
TroyTroy
Troy
 
Gardiner
GardinerGardiner
Gardiner
 
Fitzgerald et al
Fitzgerald et alFitzgerald et al
Fitzgerald et al
 
Barker
BarkerBarker
Barker
 
Zarmati
ZarmatiZarmati
Zarmati
 
Kelham
KelhamKelham
Kelham
 
Kelham
KelhamKelham
Kelham
 
Dobozy
DobozyDobozy
Dobozy
 
Staats hands mindson(2)
Staats hands mindson(2)Staats hands mindson(2)
Staats hands mindson(2)
 
Roberts history & tpack
Roberts history & tpackRoberts history & tpack
Roberts history & tpack
 
Roberts history & tpack
Roberts history & tpackRoberts history & tpack
Roberts history & tpack
 
Roberts historical literacy pedagogy
Roberts historical literacy   pedagogyRoberts historical literacy   pedagogy
Roberts historical literacy pedagogy
 

Tackling historiography through local p1

  • 1. Tackling historiography through local history Sian Morgan Hall, Historic Houses Trust NSW Dr John McLellan, Nowra Anglican College Philip Roberts, University of Canberra.
  • 2.
  • 4.
  • 5. Historical Literacy Taylor, T. and C. Young (2004)
  • 6. Challenge the ‘generic’ wisdom Authentic Pedagogy (Newman et al USA) Productive Pedagogy (Lingard et al Qld) Quality Teaching (Gore et al NSW)
  • 7.  
  • 8. Positioning the source Content-Meaning Context Reinforces dominance Empowers local Context Content-Meaning
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15. Option 22: The Arrival of the British in Australia Principal focus: students investigate changing interpretations of the arrival of the British in Australia (to 1848). Students examine the approaches to history and interpretations (including recent historiography) that have resulted in historical debate in the areas of: – terra nullius and land – invasion or settlement – colonial administrators (eg Phillip, Gipps) – expansion and exploration – the response of indigenous Australians to the arrival of the British.
  • 16.
  • 17. History Project Assessment Criteria Component Criteria Weighting Synopsis Coherent and appropriate description of: • the development of the precise research question • the way the essay addresses the precise question • why content used in the essay was included The Product Essay In response to the precise research question(s): • presents a sustained and coherent argument • supports argument through detailed coherent analysis and evaluation of significant historiographical questions • uses a recognised system of referencing 30 The Bibliography • Use of a range of relevant sources • Consistently formatted alphabetical list • Appropriate correlation of sources in bibliography to sources used in the essay • Sound selection, analysis and evaluation of three sources The Process Proposal • Appropriate enquiry question(s) • Sound analysis of relevant issues • Coherent explanation of preliminary research and anticipated resources The Process Log • Detailed description of procedures and of the sequential development of the project • Detailed analytical and coherent review of cumulative self, peer and teacher evaluation of the project 10