This talk provides a speculative contemplation of philosophical topics that might arise with brain-machine interface technology and explores the new ways that individuals and society might self-enact as a result. Brain-machine interfaces that could be pervasive, continuous, and widely-adopted suggest interesting new possibilities for our future selves. From a philosophical perspective, these possibilities concern the definition of what it is to be human, our current existence and interaction with reality, and how all of this could be dramatically different in a scenario of digitally-linked cloudmind collaborations. This talk looks at some of the foundational ontological questions of how the progression of the existence of the classic human might evolve. Perhaps the most pressing question that currently-minded potential adopters have is how to avoid getting irreparably pulled into a groupmind. To protect against this, there could be an expansion and letting go of the term and concepts of personal identity, and humans as a unit of organization, in favor of instead self-relying on a decentralized permissioning structure like blockchain technology for managing empowered and resilient crowdmind participations.
1. Sunnyvale CA, April 2, 2016
Slides: http://slideshare.net/LaBlogga
Blockchain Cloudminds
Human-Machine Pooled-Mind DACs
Melanie Swan
Blockchain Theorist
Philosophy & Economic Theory
New School for Social Research, NY NY
melanie@BlockchainStudies.org
2. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds 1
Melanie Swan
Blockchain Theorist, Philosophy and Economic
Theory, New School for Social Research, NY
Founder, Institute for Blockchain Studies
Instructor, Singularity University; Affiliate Scholar,
Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technology (IEET);
Contributor, EDGE
Traditional Markets Background Economic Theory Leadership
http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
Book: Blockchain:
Blueprint for a New
Economy
3. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
‘Fermi’s Crypto Paradox’
First contact attempted via blockchain confirmation but…
Earth using hierarchical not decentralized power models
Backward crypto (SHA 3 vs SHA 78)
Object-oriented not state-change programming models;
immature category theory, no general typing or Haskell
Smart contract DAC oracle found no lookup on Earth
No consensus-based algorithmic trust to validate the
incoming message, lack of digital smartnetworks
Periphery node could not join the decentralized
computing network; no asynchronous BFT1 truth-state
updating in distributed computing network
Human (physical) time not integrated with compute time
paradigms and so missed the blocktime confirm
2
1BFT: Byzantine Fault Tolerance
4. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Contemporary Challenge
3
http://www.robotandhwang.com/attorneys/
How to develop
empowering human-
machine collaborations?
San Francisco CA law firm
5. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Thesis Statement
Crypto Abundance Theory of Flourishing
4
Blockchains might be an important singularity-class
technology (e.g.; one that is globally robust with checks
and balances) for producing an empowering relation
with technology, for example through the safe adoption
of BCI cloudminds
6. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Blockchain Cloudminds Agenda
Introduction
BCIs (Brain-computer Interfaces)
Cloudminds
Applications: health, info-entertainment, subjectivation
Adoption Risks
Expected: privacy, security, etc.
Credit-assignation via blockchain administration
Fear of personal identity loss
Concluding Vision: Theory of Crypto Flourishing
5
7. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Modern Relations with Technology
6
The Prosthetic Relation The Drone Relation
L’Intrus (The Intruder) – Jean-Luc Nancy Théorie du drone (Drone Theory)
– Gregoire Chamayou
Impoverished relation:
roving invisible Panopticon, never
safe from unseen eyes
Intimate relation: Accepting the
foreign into our own body
8. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
The Data Relation
Cloud, background, crunching away,
silent tracking, continuous uploading
Algorithms predicting and defining our
preferences
What is our relation? Impoverished:
neither side has full mental model of
the other (the very basis for
conducive interaction with another)
Data models humans as a sketch:
purchasing agent not aspirational being
Humans have no way see, grasp or act
on big data, it acts on us (drone relation)
7
9. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds 8
Think through the problem of human-machine
collaboration in one of the most vulnerable cases:
opening our brains up to big data in BCI Cloudminds
10. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
What is a Brain-Computer Interface (BCI)?
A brain-computer interface (BCI), brain-
machine interface (BMI), or neural
prosthesis is any technology linking the
human brain to a computer
A computational system implanted in the brain
that allows a person to control a computer
using only brainwaves; for example reading the
electrical signals from the brain as a person
focuses on a computer screen
Used to repair human cognitive and
sensory-motor function
Over 219,000 worldwide cochlear implants
9
Source: http://www.asha.org/public/hearing/Cochlear-Implant-Frequently-Asked-Questions/
11. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Future Applications of BCIs
24-7 connectivity to the Internet and other minds
Pathology resolution; cognitive enhancement;
platform for human-machine collaboration
The BCI functionality of typing on a keyboard
with the mind suggests the possibility of having
an always-on brain-Internet connection
Cell phones connected every individual, BCIs connect
every brain? (cloudmind, telepathic noosphere)
Ubiquitous BCIs, on-board smartphones (‘better
horse’); new possibilities like cloudminds (‘car’)
Key functionality: 24-7 connectivity
Human cognitive processing continuously linked to the
Internet and other minds in cloudminds via BCI, VR
headset, QS wearables, smart contact lenses, etc.
10
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
12. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Blockchain Cloudminds Agenda
Introduction
BCIs (Brain-computer Interfaces)
Cloudminds
Applications: health, info-entertainment, subjectivation
Adoption Risks
Expected: privacy, security, etc.
Credit-assignation via blockchain administration
Fear of personal identity loss
Concluding Vision: Theory of Crypto Flourishing
11
13. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds 12
A Cloudmind is a cloud-based thinker, a mind
based in the Internet cloud; some sort of virtual
processing or thinking capability (‘a mind’), located
in Internet databanks without physical incorporeality
‘Mind’ is generally denoting an entity with some
capacity for processing, not the volitionary action and
free will of a consciousness agent
What is a Cloudmind?
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
14. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Different types of Cloudminds
Machine minds
Deep-learners, big data analytics, algorithms
crunching in the background, IoT ecosystems
Human minds
Backups, sims, digital selves
Human-human minds
Human-machine minds
A person plus a cloud-based personal assistant
‘thinker helper’ such as Siri or Her
Mind-pools
Multi-agent minds operating together, multiple
entities pooled together, human minds, human-
machine minds, or machine minds
13
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
15. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Prototypical Cloudminds
Functionality already exists: automated cloud-
based coordination of processing activity by
multiple agents
Mechanical Turk
Orchestrated tasks requiring human intelligence
Crowdsourced eLabor marketplaces
Topcoder, Elance, Upwork (formerly Odesk), etc.
Humans as a community computing network
Each person a computing node operating on data
Big data algorithms
Classifiers, recommendation parsers, sentiment
engines, neural nets
14
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
16. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Cloudmind Starter App: SETI@home for the brain
Sell permissioned braincycles to the
cloud (like selling generated electricity
back into the power grid)
Sharing unused computing resource
Community computing projects such as
SETI@home or protein Folding@home
Timesharing cognitive processing
power during sleep cycles or other
down time
Securely and unobtrusively share
one’s own unused resources,
downtime braincycles
15
17. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
3 Classes of BCI Cloudmind Applications
1. Health and biology
Survival, pathology resolution, cure and
enhancement, health-tracking, daily health
check, neural data-logging to EMRs, virtual
patient modeling
2. Information and entertainment
In-mind 24-7 information query (antiquated
device lookup), permissioned experience-
sharing, crowdfile event memories
3. Actualization, self-creating
Realization of individual cognitive and artistic
potential, individual and collaborative sense
16
Source: EMR: Electronic Medical Record. http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
18. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Cloudmind App:
Crowdminding an IoT Archipelago
Commanding IoT-connected objects in
the environment
Sense of feeling as one entity: commander
and ship, remote telepresencing robot
Control physical objects in a local or
remote environment
A security guard could command a whole
smart building
Link with your smarthome IoT security system
Concept: One cloudmind entity that is a
human plus IoT objects, functioning
together
17
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
19. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Blockchain Cloudminds Agenda
Introduction
BCIs (Brain-computer Interfaces)
Cloudminds
Applications: health, info-entertainment, subjectivation
Adoption Risks
Expected: privacy, security, etc.
Credit-assignation via blockchain administration
Fear of personal identity loss
Concluding Vision: Theory of Crypto Flourishing
18
20. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Adoption Risks
1. Expected: privacy, security, etc.
2. Credit-assignation
Blockchain-tracking
3. Personal identity protection
Identity multiplicity
Brain: enormous sensitivity for a
trustworthy and responsible adoption
path could be one that is gradual and
identifies specific limited use cases
19
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
21. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
1. Expected Adoption Risks
Accommodate wide spectrum of adoption and
non-adoption
Clear pathways to increased engagement
Uncoerced and reversible adoption
Responsible technology design principles
Monitoring ecosystem with external referees
Industry standards bodies (BCIs: IEEE 802.15 Wireless
Personal Area Networks (WPANs) working group)
Security, anti-virus protection, mind-hacking
safeguards
Privacy: transparency, opt-out, and monetization
selections regarding data collection and use
20
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
22. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Fear of being absorbed into the vortex
Cloudminds so
entrancing as to
become extremely
addictive, possibly to
the detriment of
otherwise being able
to ‘participate in a
meaningful life’
21
23. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Video Games: mixed research results
Negative
Susceptibility to addiction, player fatigue, etc.
Positive
Social interaction remains a priority
Ultimately novelty preferred to pleasure, turn away from
pleasure-center stimulation out of boredom
Gamers have more grey matter and better brain connectivity
Conclusion
Video games are not only for fun, entertainment, community,
and status-garnering, but also for brain development and
intelligence amplification: “brainjack our potential”
BCI cloudmind design challenge: produce applications that
safely extend our being as humans while balancing risks
22
Source: References cited in Swan, M. The Future of Brain-Computer Interfaces: Blockchaining your way into a Cloudmind. Journal
of Evolution and Technology. In review.
24. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
The Future:
Cloudmind Fulfillment or Couch Potato?
What is ‘healthy’ or ‘addictive’ in
mentally-stimulating virtual reality?
Cloudminds might be exactly the
venue for meaningful engagement
opportunities, remuneration, and
fulfillment, especially in a post-
scarcity automation economy where
labor-work is no longer compulsory
Unclear why ‘couch-potatoing’ into
virtually-fulfilling states might be
categorially ‘bad’
23
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
25. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Blockchain Cloudminds Agenda
Introduction
BCIs (Brain-computer Interfaces)
Cloudminds
Applications: health, info-entertainment, subjectivation
Adoption Risks
Expected: privacy, security, etc.
Credit-assignation via blockchain administration
Fear of personal identity loss
Concluding Vision: Theory of Crypto Flourishing
24
26. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
What is blockchain technology?
25
Blockchains are the secure distributed ledger software
that underlies cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin –
a giant tracking ledger or database, a means of
updating truth states in distributed computing network
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
27. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
What is blockchain technology?
26
More broadly, blockchains are a new form of singularity-class
technology, core next-gen infrastructure for Kardashev-level
advance; planetary-scale projects; hierarchical models break;
cannot get to million-member genome banks with centralized
models, need secure distributed smartnetworks; modernizing IT
System of checks-and-balances; trust-manufacturing system;
enrichens the impoverished big data relationship we have with
the cloud, now data quietly crunches in the background with
accountability; in a way that is tracked and can be inspected on-
demand, including with remuneration
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
28. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Blockchain Cloudmind Administration
Blockchains (giant online
cryptographic ledgers), might be used
to administer all of the coordination
aspects of cloudminds
Privacy
Security
Credit-tracking
27
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
29. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Line-item Tracking and Credit-Assignation
Like Github, or SVN or CVS for brainstorming,
tracking line-items
Deep-learning algorithms could automatically
transcribe BCI thoughts, like creating a written
transcript from Skype calls now
Ideas logged to blockchains with time date-stamped
hashes
Line-item contributions thus tracked in
cloudminds, acknowledging and rewarding
new ideas in a trustable annuity stream, in an
open but inconspicuous ledger that does not
detract from the idea generation itself
28
Source: http://www.amazon.com/Bitcoin-Blueprint-New-World-Currency/dp/1491920491
30. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
3. Fear of Personal Identity loss
Fear of being irreversibly
incorporated into a
groupmind
Personal identity (Webster):
The persistent and continuous
unity of the individual person
29
31. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Personal Identity: Multidisciplinary Question
30
Philosophy of Mind Psychology
Evolutionary Biology
Evolutionary Psychology
Philosophy of Biology
Theoretical Biology
Social Theory
Sociology
Sociobiology
Biology
32. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Philosophical Views of Personal Identity
Traditional ‘philosophy of mind’ view
Assumes already-existing subject
Personal identity needed for continuity
and persistence
Personal identity is not required for
the survival of the person, relational
experience between past/future
selves and experience is (Parfit)
fMRI studies: We procrastinate because
we think of our future selves as strangers
Third persons no different than politicians
or celebrities
31
Sources: http://nautil.us/issue/9/time/why-we-procrastinate citing van Gelder JL, Hershfield HE, Nordgren LF. (2013).
Vividness of the future self predicts delinquency. Psychol Sci. 24(6):974-80, and Pronin, Emily. (2008). How we see
ourselves and how we see others. Science. 320(5880):1177-80.
33. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Biology: Individuals are not a Privileged Unit
What are the appropriate units in
biology?
Organisms do not play a privileged role
Genes, genomes, mechanisms,
phenotypes, gene pools, organisms,
populations, ecologies
Individual is merely convenient
terminology
Individuals are spatiotemporally localized
entities that have reasonably sharp
beginnings and endings in time
32
Hull, David (1980), "Individuality and Selection," Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 11: 311-332.
34. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Multidisciplinary Conclusion: Personal
Identity is Ephemeral and Constructive
Hypothesis is supported by multiple fields
If the evolutionary biological drivers that caused personal
identity to develop as a fitness adaptation were to change, the
need for personal identity too would change/disappear
Biology
Individuality is not personal identity
Psychology/Sociology
Malleability of self
Philosophy
Relationality and subjectivation
Evolutionary Biology
Fitness adaptation
33
35. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Personal Identity: custom and familiarity
Preferencing of personal identity and
humans as an organizational unit is
custom and familiarity - so far there been
no other alternative
Having known only one mode of existence we
may have developed a natural attachment
Assumption (bias?) that memory,
emotion, and ‘meaning’ can only be
instantiated in humans, but it is possible
that in the future, any pattern associated
with the human brain might be stored as
information
34
36. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
BCI Cloudminds: Identity Multiplicity
BCI cloudminds do not
necessarily preclude or curtail
personal identity, and some
rather accentuate and extend it
One or more digital selves
participate in cloudminds on a
limited basis
‘Classic meatspace brains’
Different configurations of selves
(for example, a team of selves,
what Hanson calls a ‘self clan’ or
an ‘em[ulation] clan’)
35
37. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Blockchain Cloudminds Agenda
Introduction
BCIs (Brain-computer Interfaces)
Cloudminds
Applications: health, info-entertainment, subjectivation
Adoption Risks
Expected: privacy, security, etc.
Credit-assignation via blockchain administration
Fear of personal identity loss
Concluding Vision: Theory of Crypto Flourishing
36
38. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
BCI Cloudminds
Gradual Adoption Strategies
Sharing unused brain processing cycles
SETI@home for your brain
Backup, archival, storage
Life-logging, memory-logging
Digital self as opposed to original self
Permissioning limited access to certain domains
of the brain and cognitive activity
Demarcating structural borders
Personal connectome files limit cortical access
Limited time blocks (sleep cycles) for mindstream access
Full cloudmind participation: problem-solving,
creative-expression, idea-generation
37
39. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Conclusion, this talk addressed:
The potential advent of brain-
computer interfaces (BCIs) that
are ubiquitous and widely-
adopted, where humans might
be continuously connected to the
Internet and other minds in
cloudmind formats
Adoption risk solutions
Privacy, security, reversibility, credit
assignation, and personal identity
retention
38
40. April 2, 2016
Blockchain Cloudminds
Thesis Statement
Crypto Abundance Theory of Flourishing
39
Blockchains might be an important singularity-class
technology (e.g.; one that is globally robust with checks
and balances) for producing an empowering relation
with technology, for example through the safe adoption
of BCI cloudminds
Accelerando: blockchain-type trust networks join
humans and technology in partnership, where digital
copies “watch over their originals from the consensus
cyberspace of the city”
Source: Stross (2006). Accelerando. P. 355
41. Sunnyvale CA, April 2, 2016
Slides: http://slideshare.net/LaBlogga
Blockchain Cloudminds
Human-Machine Pooled-Mind DACs
Thank You! Questions?
Melanie Swan
Blockchain Theorist
Philosophy & Economic Theory
New School for Social Research, NY NY
melanie@BlockchainStudies.org