SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 22
Baixar para ler offline
What Are the Grand
Challenges for Cultural
Evolution?
A Research Report for the Society for the Study of
Cultural Evolution
Prepared by:
	 Joe Brewer	 	 Ian MacDonald
	 Culture Designer	 Biology Researcher

	 Evolution Institute	 Binghamton University

What You Will Find In This Report
An ad hoc steering committee initiated steps to form the Society for the Study of Cultural Evolution
(SSCE) in the summer of 2015. As part of the inaugural proceedings, a survey of SSCE members
was conducted to identify a suite of "grand challenge" problems of broad scientific and social
interest that can drive cutting-edge research and practice within the field of cultural evolutionary
studies for future decades.
Over the course of several weeks, a total of 236 SSCE members from around the world completed
an online questionnaire in which they could nominate up to ten such challenges, providing a brief
description and rationale for each. Additionally, SSCE members were also asked to indicate their
level of understanding and mode of training in core domains (cultural studies and evolutionary
theory), how they see their current work fitting into the wider world of cultural evolutionary studies,
and how they see themselves contributing to the grand challenges facing the society.
The responses to the initial grand challenges survey are summarized below.
Qualitative Assessment — Close-Text Semantic Analysis of Survey Responses
As noted above, we received 236 completed surveys. Respondents could nominate more than
one grand challenge, so we received a total of 435 Grand Challenge Ideas. The methodology used
to analyze the content of these Grand Challenge Ideas is called close-text semantic analysis
which is to closely read each text entry and create a coding system of hashtags for thematic
content found within them.
The procedure goes like this:
1. Place all Grand Challenge Ideas (GCIs) in a single spreadsheet column.
2. Go through all 435 GCIs and create hashtags for content by filling in the accompanying row
for each entry.
3. Build up a "master list" of these hashtags to create thematic categories for organizing the
responses.
4. Count the number of entries “tagged” by each hashtag as a measure of thematic
composition and emphasis.
5. Construct “network graphs” that reveal how the most prominent themes cluster together in
order to create complex thematic categories that reveal key relationships between the
hashtags (and the themes they represent).1
Special thanks to Ken Cousins of The Vicinus Group for conducting this network graph analysis for us.1
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
Before going into the findings from this analysis, it may be helpful to see what a typical Grand
Challenge Idea looks like. Here are two representative examples taken from the survey responses.
Note how both are richly sophisticated and thoughtfully articulated. The full collection of responses
came through this way. We really have a phenomenal community of engaged participants in our
founding membership at the SSCE!
Grand Challenge Response — Representative Example 1
Learning how to harness the power of conformist biased transmission to support political
policy or health related measures that are widely supported by the public and by specialists
even if not by the small minority of well-heeled lobbying groups. Perhaps this would allow
democratic governments to better work for the people's interest rather than the large,
multinational conglomerates' interest.
Tags: #ConformistBias, #CulturalTransmission, #PolicyMaking, #PracticalSolutions, #CultureDesign
Grand Challenge Response — Representative Example 2
The world is loosing indigenous cultures at an unprecedented rate reflected by an
estimated loss of 1 language per day. These cultures hold knowledge and wisdom essential
to humanity's well-being and prosperity. More than 370 million Indigenous Peoples live in
over 90 countries and constitute the largest minority in the world. Indigenous territories
cover 24 percent of the earth’s land surface that harbor 80 percent of the earth’s remaining
biodiversity. Indigenous peoples are the stewards of some of the world’s most biologically
diverse areas, and their traditional knowledge about nature is invaluable. Today, climate
change is among the forces of globalization threatening the very existence of many
Indigenous Peoples; some estimate the world is loosing one indigenous language every
day. Ironically, traditional indigenous knowledge passed down through the centuries offers
highly valuable sources of wisdom to guide all of us in addressing the greatest challenges
of our times, as well as offering sources of knowledge and wisdom as a basis for innovation
and guiding social well-being.
Tags: #Diversity, #ComparingCultures, #CulturalExtinction, #Environment, #Globalization
Another thing to note in the way hashtags are used is that each entry typically was given several
tags—making it possible to add up the number of entries associated with each tag and to capture
the relationships between tags that appear together. The analysis that follows is garnered from
these two types of information.
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
What Were The Top Ten Hashtags?
A total of 149 hashtags were created (a full list can be found in the appendix at the end of this
report), revealing a great diversity of topics that have been flagged as important for consideration
by the society. The first thing we wanted to know was which thematic elements appear most
frequently in the survey responses.
Since each entry was coded with several hashtags, it was straightforward to add them up and see
which ones occur most frequently. This table shows the top ten themes and gives the number of
entries that were tagged by each of them.
The highest priority theme was knowledge synthesis. It was tagged in 99 of the 435 entries (22.8%
of the total) and appeared almost twice as often as the second-ranked theme of prosociaiity.
Similar second-ranked emphasis was given to culture definition, environmental concerns, cultural
transmission, and economics.
Each theme was treated as a “generally relevant topic” for the entry it was tagged onto. What this
means methodologically is that we created a hashtag each time a new topic appeared as we went
through the survey responses. When the same topic was mentioned again (often with a different,
albeit related, focus), we applied the hashtag to the new entry. Topics were loosely defined
intentionally such that entries can be clustered into categories of themes that are related to each
other in a variety of ways. To help this make more sense, here are brief descriptors for the six most
frequently used thematic elements:
Knowledge Synthesis deals with the need to combine information across disparate fields of
inquiry, such as bridging research from social psychology with anthropological studies of
Thematic Element Frequency of Responses
#KnowledgeSynthesis 99
#ProSociality 51
#CultureDefinition 48
#Environment 46
#CulturalTransmission 45
#Economics 44
#Theory 42
#HistoricTrajectories 38
#ComparingCultures 36
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
indigenous cultures. Each entry tagged with this theme was a call for synthesis and integration of
knowledge to tackle otherwise intractable problems.
ProSociality deals with the underlying mechanisms that give rise to trust, cooperation, altruism,
and other social behaviors that enhance the functioning for groups of people. Each entry tagged
with this theme was a call for safer communities, better cooperation, and more effective
institutions.
Culture Definition deals with lingering confusion about the relationship between biology and
culture. Each entry tagged with this theme was a call for greater clarity about the similarities and
differences between inheritance through the diverse mechanisms of genetics, epigenetics, social
behavior, and symbolic culture.
Environment deals with environmental concerns that threaten human communities and the
biosphere in general. Each entry tagged with this theme was a call for action on climate change or
for deeper understandings about the roles played by culture in harmonious (and dysfunctional)
relationships between humans and the more-than-human world.
Cultural Transmission deals with processes of social learning and exchanges of knowledge from
one generation to the next. Each entry tagged with this theme was a call for deeper
understandings about the cognitive, anatomical, and evolutionary aspects of cultural change that
give rise to and constrain the transmission of cultural practices from one person to another.
Economics deals with the foundational social science of productivity and resource allocation in
human societies. Each entry tagged with this theme was a call for clarity about scientifically
credible economic knowledge and its applications to both organizational management and public
policy.
These are only six of 149 themes that arose at least once in the collection of survey responses—a
rich dataset indeed! For this reason, it is unwieldy to tackle the full complexity of the idea network
comprising all 435 entries. The next step was to rank order the full list of hashtags and see which
ones appear most frequently (not only the top ten listed above). After this we can start to organize
the tags into relational webs of co-occurence to see how the themes clustered together in the full
collection of responses.
Pulling Back To See The Big Picture
We have already seen that our founding members want the society to promote knowledge
synthesis, increase collective learning about the nature of cultural change and how it differs from
genetic evolution, and apply this knowledge to important environmental and economic projects
that impact the real world.
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
So what else do our founding members want us to focus on? Pulling back to see the bigger
picture, let’s start by looking at the top 50 thematic elements, ranked according to their frequency
in the survey responses.
This graph shows the top ten entries listed above plus the next forty topics that appeared with
decreasing frequency. As you can see there are quite a few worthy themes for consideration, some
of them having fairly obvious relationships with each other.
For example, governance and policymaking are going to have important linkages with each other.
They will also be implicated in attempts to deal with the global crisis (convergence of threats due to
globalization, ecological decline, population growth, and the systemic threats that arise among
them). We can also see how storytelling and science communication are relevant to practical
solutions and are specifically connected for attempts to deal with resistance to evolution both in
the academy and for the lay public.
This tells us that the topics are not separate from each other. They already have semantic
structure where their meanings are interrelated and actions around some will influence or be
influenced by others. Another way to see the systemic nature of these topics is to construct a
graph showing all 149 thematic elements with lines drawn connecting each of them that appears
together in at least one entry. Thicken the connections in a linear manner to represent the number
of times they appear together and you get this mess—affectionally called the “kitchen sink” graph
by the researcher who created it for us.
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
0
5
10
15
20
25
Top$50$Thematic$Elements$of$Grand$Survey$Results
(%$of$Responses$with$Each$Theme)
The “Kitchen Sink” — A Mangle of Topics From All Survey Responses
For example, if historic trajectories appears in the same entry with technology we draw a line
between them. The line is then made thicker each time they appear together in a new entry. Do this
for a large number of themes and we get a graph like this:
"
This graph is not a full “kitchen sink” because it only includes the topics that appeared at least 13
times in the full collection of survey responses. (This graphic is also simplified further by removing
knowledge synthesis to declutter and emphasize second-tier relationships.) Even when simplified in
this way, we can see that a great deal of clustering exists between the themes—a reflection of the
sophistication and richness for each individual entry as we saw earlier in this report.
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
The next step we took was to look at the “ego network” for the most prominent themes. This is
done by graphing one topic with all of the others that link to it, revealing how this theme stands in
relation to others. Here is the ego network for knowledge synthesis:
Several things leap out when we view the data in this way. Firstly, we can see yet again how no
topic stands alone. It is not surprising that knowledge synthesis (being the most prominent theme
to come up in survey responses) will be connected to almost every other topic. More interesting to
note is that this theme is linked most strongly with theory, shared language, culture definition,
institutional silos, and method diversity. The structure of this category is revealing itself.
What we can take away from the analysis so far is that SSCE members want to see our fledgling
society organize itself around a process of unification in the social sciences. To do this we
will need to create a shared language to integrate knowledge across disciplinary silos in the
academy. We will have to focus effort on deep theoretical issues—particularly those having to do
with the methodological approaches we take to the study of culture (and how this is similar to or
divergent from the study of biology, physics, and other scientific domains). And we will have to
overcome the institutional barriers that hinder this kind of synthesis, in a sense “evolving” the way
our institutions are set up so they can better enable the integration of knowledge across fields.
Clearly, this implies a need for our society to be collaborative and diverse in its membership.
Tackling this grand challenge will take many years and require that we form excellent relationships
with complementary societies and institutions.
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
On the practitioner side, we have already mentioned that a number of grand challenge ideas are
about the threats of ecological collapse, issues pertaining to governance and community well-
being, and many other practical (and urgent!) issues. We were able to unpack this by looking at the
ego network for the global crisis theme.
This graph shows how our founding members perceive the human predicament as we enter the
early middle of the 21st Century. The largest linkage, not surprisingly, is with environmental
concerns—principally global warming and the systemic threats associated with it. More revealing
for how we structure the SSCE agenda is how several other themes cluster with each other as they
are referenced to the global crisis. Note how historic trajectories, prosociaiity, economics,
policymaking, governance, complexity, tribalism, and culture design form a tight weave as a
category for strategic engagement.
Some of the implications are:
✦ Practitioners working on the transition to sustainability will need to understand the historic
patterns of civilization and how they relate to our evolved psychological dispositions in
prehistoric times.
✦ The society needs to provide practical guidance for public policy, community development,
and governance through insights about the ways human beings cooperate and build trust,
naturally break down into tribal groups where conflict might arise, and how to manage this
complexity with design principles.
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
✦ All of this will depend upon our ability to tackle the grand challenge of knowledge synthesis
as part of organizational development efforts worldwide. The SSCE needs to balance
scientific rigor with considerable expertise in practical applications.
We could continue this analysis with other themes but the outcomes would be broadly similar. The
topics our founding members want this society to address are systemic both in knowledge area
and practical application. The survey results tell us that we need to cultivate a strongly
collaborative, cross-disciplinary network of partnerships that both advance deep theoretical inquiry
and provide assistance to urgent real-world challenges at every level of society.
So how prepared are we now? The rest of this report offers a glimpse at who the founding
membership is and what we are already capable of doing together.
Quantitative Assessment — Who Are the Founding Members of SSCE?
The survey we sent out included a series of multiple choice questions to help us get a sense of
who the founding membership is, what they do, and how extensive their knowledge is about
cultural evolutionary studies.
The first question we asked was How do you see your current work fitting into the field of cultural
evolutionary studies? Respondents could select one or more of four options. The results are
presented in Table 1 showing that 75% of those who filled out the survey come from the research
world, more than a third are teachers, and a third work on practical applications.
Table	
  1.	
  The	
  propor(on	
  of	
  respondents	
  that	
  see	
  their	
  current	
  work	
  as	
  fi5ng	
  into	
  one	
  (or	
  more)	
  of	
  four	
  
broad	
  domains	
  within	
  the	
  realm	
  of	
  cultural	
  evolu(onary	
  studies	
  (n	
  =	
  236).	
  Note:	
  members	
  were	
  able	
  to	
  
select	
  more	
  than	
  one	
  op(on.	
  
A follow-up question was asked about how they would like to contribute to activities through the
SSCE. The results are shown in Table 2 on the next page. The founding members who filled out
this survey are predominantly interested in providing research and educational support to the grand
challenges. Some want to help increase the financial investments in cultural evolutionary studies
(and design practice, as we saw in the qualitative analysis above) through government funding and
private philanthropy.
A strong signal comes through that our members would like to be entrepreneurial and creative
through the society—notable emphasis came with 34% wanting to help improve academic
institutions and 21% having an interest in creating or improving social impact enterprises.
Research Teaching Applied
(Not Active, But)
Interested
0.75 0.38 0.35 0.13
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
Table	
  2.	
  The	
  propor(on	
  of	
  respondents	
  who	
  see	
  themselves	
  contribu(ng	
  to	
  the	
  grand	
  challenge	
  effort	
  
via	
  several	
  means	
  (n	
  =	
  236).	
  Note:	
  respondents	
  were	
  able	
  to	
  select	
  more	
  than	
  one	
  op(on.	
  
So how much do our founding members know about cultural evolutionary studies? And how did
they acquire the knowledge they currently have. We started by separating cultural studies from
evolutionary studies to see how each subdomain of the field is represented by our membership.
This allowed us to look at the relative strengths in each area and—as we’ll see in a moment—to
get a glimpse into the opportunities for educational improvement this society can help make
happen through its activities.
Figure	
  1.	
  Distribu(on	
  of	
  respondents’	
  self-­‐reported	
  level	
  of	
  understanding	
  in	
  the	
  domain	
  of	
  cultural	
  stud-­‐
ies	
  (n	
  =	
  235).	
  Scale	
  ranged	
  from	
  1	
  (Novice)	
  to	
  7	
  (Expert).	
  
Contribution to Tackling Grand Challenges Through the SSCE
Proportion of
Respondents
Conduct basic and applied research 0.72
Improve academic institutions to better address societal issues 0.34
Run campaigns that change policy outcomes 0.17
Design policy frameworks and new metrics based on scientific research 0.28
Increase financial support for efforts through government funding 0.11
Increase financial support for efforts through private philanthropy 0.08
Engage in entrepreneurial efforts to build social impact enterprises 0.21
Educate the public through communication pathways in the media 0.55
Other 0.16
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
Not surprisingly, the founding members have a strong knowledge base in cultural studies. Few
consider themselves novices and most are approaching the level of mastery, while still feeling they
have more to learn.
Figure	
  2.	
  Distribu(on	
  of	
  respondents’	
  mode	
  of	
  training	
  within	
  the	
  domain	
  of	
  cultural	
  studies	
  (n	
  =	
  232).	
  
Scale	
  ranged	
  from	
  1	
  (Completely	
  Self-­‐Taught)	
  to	
  7	
  (Completely	
  Formal	
  Educa(on).	
  
Interestingly, when we asked how they acquired their training in cultural studies most said it was a
mix of self-directed informal learning and formal academic education. Fewer respondents
described themselves as formally educated than self-educated—indicating that community
members entered their respective fields of cultural studies through informal and formal pathways.
We ran a subsequent analysis of these results to create a “bi-variate response distribution” that
tells us how the mode of learning corresponds with the level of expertise acquired. The results are
presented in Figure 3.
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
Figure	
  3.	
  The	
  bivariate	
  response	
  distribu(on	
  of	
  re-­‐
spondents’	
  level	
  of	
  understanding	
  by	
  mode	
  of	
  training	
  
within	
  the	
  domain	
  of	
  cultural	
  studies.	
  Cell	
  color	
  is	
  
scaled	
  to	
  the	
  propor(on	
  of	
  overall	
  responses	
  in	
  falling	
  
in	
  each	
  (r	
  =	
  0.588,	
  p	
  <	
  0.001,	
  n	
  =	
  232).
We then did the same sequence of analysis for evolutionary studies. This is where it gets
interesting because a notable strength stands out. Nearly all respondents described themselves as
being well trained in the Theory of Evolution. Very few described themselves as novices. Yet when
we look at where they received this education a bimodal pattern emerged. The majority of
members are self-taught, with support from formal institutions for some of them.
In other words, while our community is strong on evolution, the academy is not serving them well
enough. A lot of people get trained in evolution on their own.
Figure	
  4.	
  Distribu(on	
  of	
  respondents’	
  self-­‐reported	
  level	
  of	
  understanding	
  of	
  evolu(onary	
  theory	
  (n	
  =	
  
235).	
  Scale	
  ranged	
  from	
  1	
  (Novice)	
  to	
  7	
  (Expert).	
  
Figure	
  5.	
  Distribu(on	
  of	
  respondents’	
  mode	
  of	
  training	
  within	
  the	
  domain	
  of	
  evolu(onary	
  theory	
  (n	
  =	
  
233).	
  Scale	
  ranged	
  from	
  1	
  (Completely	
  Self-­‐Taught)	
  to	
  7	
  (Completely	
  Formal	
  Educa(on).	
  
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
This becomes even more apparent when we look at the bivariate response distribution in Figure 6.
One “peak” is found at the intersection of formal training and expertise. Another “peak” exists for
people with slightly less confidence in their knowledge who are mostly self-taught. Herein lies an
opportunity to bridge these pathways to educational attainment—bringing the academics together
with practitioners who study evolution on their own.
A lesson we can take away from this analysis is that the SSCE is well positioned to unite cultural
researchers with evolutionary scientists, both in formal academic settings and among practitioners
with informal training. And we can be confident that we have the requisite human capacities by
looking at Figure 7 combining these dual strengths in one community of people.
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
Figure	
  6.	
  The	
  bivariate	
  response	
  distribu(on	
  of	
  re-­‐
spondents’	
  level	
  of	
  understanding	
  by	
  mode	
  of	
  training	
  
within	
  the	
  domain	
  of	
  evolu(onary	
  theory.	
  Cell	
  color	
  is	
  
scaled	
  to	
  the	
  propor(on	
  of	
  overall	
  responses	
  in	
  falling	
  
in	
  each	
  (r	
  =	
  0.505,	
  p	
  <	
  0.001,	
  n	
  =	
  233.
Figure	
  7.	
  The	
  bivariate	
  response	
  distribu(on	
  of	
  re-­‐
spondents’	
  level	
  of	
  understanding	
  of	
  cultural	
  studies	
  
by	
  level	
  of	
  understanding	
  of	
  evolu(onary	
  theory.	
  Cell	
  
colour	
  is	
  scaled	
  to	
  the	
  propor(on	
  of	
  overall	
  responses	
  
in	
  falling	
  in	
  each	
  (r	
  =	
  0.466,	
  p	
  <	
  0.001,	
  n	
  =	
  235).
Figure 7 shows more than half of survey respondents with dual strength in cultural studies and
evolutionary theory. Those of us with experience in the academic world know that this is rare
indeed. Most social scientists are not trained in evolution. And many evolutionists remain skeptical
about the applications of biology to human affairs.
These survey responses are a sign of cultural evolution unfolding in real time. People are scattered
across the intellectual landscape with respect to academic institutions and whether they have
formal training or not. And these people are finding each other (or will be able to do so as we build
capacity) under the heading of cultural evolutionary studies.
In Closing — Where Do We Go From Here?
We have learned a great deal from analyzing these survey responses. The next step is to assimilate
these findings and present them back to the SSCE community for discussion, elaboration, and
refinement. To help get this process going, we offer summary points and propose a course of
action.
Summary of Key Findings
✦ The number of responses is a clear indicator of interest in forming this society. We received
435 suggestions for Grand Challenge Ideas from 236 respondents, each articulating a
thoughtful and important commentary for what the SSCE might want to do.
✦ Several focus areas became clear from these Grand Challenge Ideas—a strong focus on
knowledge synthesis, clear delineation of what culture is and how it changes, and
applications of this knowledge to major challenges confronting real-world communities.
✦ The themes offered as grand challenges are plentiful, yet it does feel plausible to tackle
them systemically by acknowledging how deeply interwoven and interconnected they are.
✦ The founding members are uniquely prepared to make this effort a success. We have
strength in both cultural studies and deep knowledge of evolutionary theory in our midst.
✦ Formation of the society itself is a measure of “cultural evolution in action” as we are already
observing a process of those formally trained in academic institutions coming together with
practitioners who have been self-taught, with combinations of both life paths for many of
our members who straddle academic and institutional boundaries.
Now we are ready to begin. This analysis has one primary purpose—to help the ad hoc steering
committee set the SSCE on a launch trajectory that creates real value for its founding members. It
is a great pleasure to see how deeply aligned this community is both in terms of focus areas held in
common and for bringing diverse intellectual strengths that improve our institutions and
communities as we move forward.
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
Proposed Course of Action
✦ Present these findings to the SSCE community on the Social Evolution Forum and facilitate
discussion about scope and focus.
✦ Convene the ad hoc steering committee in person (already scheduled for late December) to
unpack what we have learned and propose a strategic planning process to present back to
the community.
✦ Build up the community supports—member database, website, publishing and
communication platforms, etc.—for the formation of Special Interest Groups as “action
committees” or task forces that self-organize around different grand challenges.
✦ Weave this process into the parallel track already underway to create bylaws and
membership due structures, plan the first annual meeting of the SSCE, and get members
involved in the process using the grand challenges as organizing themes.
This is an exciting time to work in cultural evolution. The field is ready to pop! And these findings,
while preliminary, are very encouraging for what is possible to achieve through the Society for the
Study of Cultural Evolution for many years to come.
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
Appendix — Full List of Themes
Theme Number	
  of	
  Times	
  Men<oned
#Adapta(on 16
#AffectControlTheory 3
#Agency 2
#Algorithms 1
#Altruism 2
#AnimalBehavior 5
#AnimalCruelty 1
#Atheism 1
#BrainCulture 5
#Ci(es 1
#Civiliza(onCollapse 2
#CivilSociety 1
#Cogni(on 25
#Collabora(on 19
#Collec(veAc(on 10
#ComparingCultures 36
#Complexity 28
#ConflictResolu(on 20
#ConformistBias 2
#Consump(onPa^erns 1
#Corpora(ons 3
#Corrup(on 5
#CulturalA^rac(on 1
#CulturalEx(nc(on 3
#CulturallyBiasedResearch 6
#CulturalStability 8
#CulturalTransmission 45
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
#CultureDefini(on	
   48
#CultureDesign 29
#Cumula(veCulture 22
#CurriculumDesign 1
#Databases 12
#DemographicTransi(on 1
#Development 1
#DirectDemocracy 1
#Diversity 17
#Ea(ngHabits 1
#EcologicalVaria(on 1
#Economics 44
#Educa(on 21
#Emo(ons 1
#EnergyTransi(on 6
#Entropy 3
#Environment 46
#ExtendedLifeSpan 1
#Fairness 6
#FaultyBeliefs 10
#FieldStudies 1
#FinancialSystem 3
#FundingChallenges 1
#GameTheory 1
#GenderDifferences 2
#GenderEquality 8
#GeneCulture 7
#GlobalCrisis 30
#Globaliza(on 10
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
#Governance 33
#GrandHumanNarra(ve 1
#GroupProcess 4
#HateCrimes 1
#Hierarchy 10
#HistoricTrajectories 38
#HopeVsDespair 2
#HumanBiome 1
#HumanDevelopment 9
#HumanTrafficking 1
#HumanUniqueness 18
#HumanUniversals 1
#IncestuousThinking 1
#IncorporateHumani(es 1
#Individualism 1
#Inequality 15
#Informa(onExplosion 2
#Inheritance 7
#Innova(onDiffusion 19
#Ins(tu(onalSilos 24
#Inten(onalCommuni(es 1
#Interspirituality 1
#KnowledgeSynthesis 99
#LanguageOrigins 10
#LearningHeuris(cs 25
#LegalTheory 1
#LGBTQViolence 1
#Literacy 1
#Localism 5
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
#Medicine 2
#Meme(cs 3
#MethodDiversity 23
#Militarism 3
#ModelingStudies 6
#MonetarySystem 1
#Morality 11
#Mul(LevelSelec(on 3
#NetworkedSociety 1
#NewMetrics 2
#NicheConstruc(on 3
#Ontology 1
#Organiza(onDevelopment 26
#OutdatedIncen(ves 1
#PathDependence 2
#PolicyMaking 32
#Poli(calPower 1
#Popula(on 1
#Popula(onGene(cs 4
#PostCapitalism 1
#Poverty 1
#Prac(calSolu(ons 15
#ProblemIden(fica(on 3
#ProSociality 51
#PublicHealth 2
#Publishing 1
#Quan(fiedSelf 1
#RaceIssues 6
#RamblingMess 1
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
#RateOfChange 3
#Reduc(onism 1
#Reframing 1
#Religion 15
#Replicators 3
#ResistanceToEvolu(on 26
#ResourceWars 1
#RuralCommuni(es 1
#ScienceCommunica(on 20
#ScienceStudies 2
#Selec(on 3
#Seman(cs 4
#Sexuality 1
#SharedLanguage 28
#SocialAnaly(cs 1
#SocialConsciousness 4
#SocialIden(ty 1
#Socialism 1
#SocialMovements 15
#SocialOrganiza(on 22
#SocialValues 1
#Storytelling 20
#SystemicRisks 1
#SystemsThinking 2
#Taxes 1
#Technology 13
#TenureProblems 1
#Terrorism 3
#Theory	
   42
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015
#Transparency 1
#Tribalism 35
#UX/UI 1
#Violence 3
#WorkLifeBalance 1
#Worldviews 1
What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution?	 Prepared on November 9, 2015

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Food: speaking questions
Food: speaking questionsFood: speaking questions
Food: speaking questionsRaquel FC
 
Parts of the computer ppt
Parts of the computer pptParts of the computer ppt
Parts of the computer pptRAHULSIR1
 
Computer Lab Rules
Computer Lab  RulesComputer Lab  Rules
Computer Lab Rulesguest5431f2
 
Components of a computer system
Components of a computer systemComponents of a computer system
Components of a computer systemMark Santos
 
Computer Hardware
Computer HardwareComputer Hardware
Computer Hardwarenitinmote
 

Mais procurados (11)

Great kapok tree
Great kapok treeGreat kapok tree
Great kapok tree
 
Food: speaking questions
Food: speaking questionsFood: speaking questions
Food: speaking questions
 
Parts of the computer ppt
Parts of the computer pptParts of the computer ppt
Parts of the computer ppt
 
Computer Lab Rules
Computer Lab  RulesComputer Lab  Rules
Computer Lab Rules
 
Computer lab rules asma
Computer lab rules asmaComputer lab rules asma
Computer lab rules asma
 
About Tea
About TeaAbout Tea
About Tea
 
Components of a computer system
Components of a computer systemComponents of a computer system
Components of a computer system
 
Community helpers
Community helpers Community helpers
Community helpers
 
coffee
coffeecoffee
coffee
 
Computer Hardware
Computer HardwareComputer Hardware
Computer Hardware
 
Parts of the Computer
Parts of the ComputerParts of the Computer
Parts of the Computer
 

Destaque

Communication, Creativity, Consilience and Cost-Benefit Ratios in Cinema - JT...
Communication, Creativity, Consilience and Cost-Benefit Ratios in Cinema - JT...Communication, Creativity, Consilience and Cost-Benefit Ratios in Cinema - JT...
Communication, Creativity, Consilience and Cost-Benefit Ratios in Cinema - JT...JT Velikovsky
 
Tools for Culture Design:
Tools for Culture Design: Tools for Culture Design:
Tools for Culture Design: Joe Brewer
 
StoryAlity Theory - 2014 UWS PG Conference - JT Velikovsky
StoryAlity Theory - 2014 UWS PG Conference - JT VelikovskyStoryAlity Theory - 2014 UWS PG Conference - JT Velikovsky
StoryAlity Theory - 2014 UWS PG Conference - JT VelikovskyJT Velikovsky
 
A Linguistic Analysis of the Gates Foundation's 2014 Annual Letter
A Linguistic Analysis of the Gates Foundation's 2014 Annual LetterA Linguistic Analysis of the Gates Foundation's 2014 Annual Letter
A Linguistic Analysis of the Gates Foundation's 2014 Annual LetterJames North
 
One Party Planet
One Party PlanetOne Party Planet
One Party Planet/The Rules
 
Creative Practice Theory and Feature Film Screenwriting - JT Velikovsky
Creative Practice Theory and Feature Film Screenwriting -  JT VelikovskyCreative Practice Theory and Feature Film Screenwriting -  JT Velikovsky
Creative Practice Theory and Feature Film Screenwriting - JT VelikovskyJT Velikovsky
 
Who Framed Global Development?
Who Framed Global Development?Who Framed Global Development?
Who Framed Global Development?Joe Brewer
 
Seeing Wetiko: Tracking the Spread of Memes on Social Media
Seeing Wetiko: Tracking the Spread of Memes on Social MediaSeeing Wetiko: Tracking the Spread of Memes on Social Media
Seeing Wetiko: Tracking the Spread of Memes on Social MediaJoe Brewer
 
Cultural studies part 1-
Cultural studies part 1-Cultural studies part 1-
Cultural studies part 1-nmbinq
 
East meets west -by yang liu
East meets west  -by yang liuEast meets west  -by yang liu
East meets west -by yang liuBob Wong
 
When Yes Means No (or Yes or Maybe)
When Yes Means No (or Yes or Maybe)When Yes Means No (or Yes or Maybe)
When Yes Means No (or Yes or Maybe)David Gilbert
 
Western and Eastern Cultures!!!
Western and Eastern Cultures!!!Western and Eastern Cultures!!!
Western and Eastern Cultures!!!Physmech2010
 
Eastern Culture Vs Western Culture
Eastern Culture Vs Western CultureEastern Culture Vs Western Culture
Eastern Culture Vs Western Culturepraveenvarghese
 

Destaque (20)

Communication, Creativity, Consilience and Cost-Benefit Ratios in Cinema - JT...
Communication, Creativity, Consilience and Cost-Benefit Ratios in Cinema - JT...Communication, Creativity, Consilience and Cost-Benefit Ratios in Cinema - JT...
Communication, Creativity, Consilience and Cost-Benefit Ratios in Cinema - JT...
 
Tools for Culture Design:
Tools for Culture Design: Tools for Culture Design:
Tools for Culture Design:
 
StoryAlity Theory - 2014 UWS PG Conference - JT Velikovsky
StoryAlity Theory - 2014 UWS PG Conference - JT VelikovskyStoryAlity Theory - 2014 UWS PG Conference - JT Velikovsky
StoryAlity Theory - 2014 UWS PG Conference - JT Velikovsky
 
Coca-Cola Meme Analyis
Coca-Cola Meme AnalyisCoca-Cola Meme Analyis
Coca-Cola Meme Analyis
 
Intro
IntroIntro
Intro
 
Culture Design 101
Culture Design 101Culture Design 101
Culture Design 101
 
A Linguistic Analysis of the Gates Foundation's 2014 Annual Letter
A Linguistic Analysis of the Gates Foundation's 2014 Annual LetterA Linguistic Analysis of the Gates Foundation's 2014 Annual Letter
A Linguistic Analysis of the Gates Foundation's 2014 Annual Letter
 
ClimateMeme1
ClimateMeme1ClimateMeme1
ClimateMeme1
 
One Party Planet
One Party PlanetOne Party Planet
One Party Planet
 
Creative Practice Theory and Feature Film Screenwriting - JT Velikovsky
Creative Practice Theory and Feature Film Screenwriting -  JT VelikovskyCreative Practice Theory and Feature Film Screenwriting -  JT Velikovsky
Creative Practice Theory and Feature Film Screenwriting - JT Velikovsky
 
Who Framed Global Development?
Who Framed Global Development?Who Framed Global Development?
Who Framed Global Development?
 
Seeing Wetiko: Tracking the Spread of Memes on Social Media
Seeing Wetiko: Tracking the Spread of Memes on Social MediaSeeing Wetiko: Tracking the Spread of Memes on Social Media
Seeing Wetiko: Tracking the Spread of Memes on Social Media
 
Cultural studies part 1-
Cultural studies part 1-Cultural studies part 1-
Cultural studies part 1-
 
East meets west -by yang liu
East meets west  -by yang liuEast meets west  -by yang liu
East meets west -by yang liu
 
When Yes Means No (or Yes or Maybe)
When Yes Means No (or Yes or Maybe)When Yes Means No (or Yes or Maybe)
When Yes Means No (or Yes or Maybe)
 
Western and Eastern Cultures!!!
Western and Eastern Cultures!!!Western and Eastern Cultures!!!
Western and Eastern Cultures!!!
 
Humanistic education
Humanistic educationHumanistic education
Humanistic education
 
Eastern Culture Vs Western Culture
Eastern Culture Vs Western CultureEastern Culture Vs Western Culture
Eastern Culture Vs Western Culture
 
Realism
RealismRealism
Realism
 
Realism
Realism Realism
Realism
 

Semelhante a What Are the Grand challenges for Cultural Evolution?

ASEM 2014 IAC EMJ Culture Final
ASEM 2014 IAC EMJ Culture FinalASEM 2014 IAC EMJ Culture Final
ASEM 2014 IAC EMJ Culture Finaloliverinva
 
Brandon’s Post· Identify the global societal issue you ha.docx
Brandon’s Post· Identify the global societal issue you ha.docxBrandon’s Post· Identify the global societal issue you ha.docx
Brandon’s Post· Identify the global societal issue you ha.docxrichardnorman90310
 
French Essay.pdfFrench Essay. French a level essay help - writefiction581.web...
French Essay.pdfFrench Essay. French a level essay help - writefiction581.web...French Essay.pdfFrench Essay. French a level essay help - writefiction581.web...
French Essay.pdfFrench Essay. French a level essay help - writefiction581.web...Nicole Heinen
 
ECON315 – Global Economy – Research Paper .docx
ECON315 – Global Economy – Research Paper                     .docxECON315 – Global Economy – Research Paper                     .docx
ECON315 – Global Economy – Research Paper .docxtidwellveronique
 
WK1 DQ 1The first step in the research process is selecting a to.docx
WK1 DQ 1The first step in the research process is selecting a to.docxWK1 DQ 1The first step in the research process is selecting a to.docx
WK1 DQ 1The first step in the research process is selecting a to.docxericbrooks84875
 
Discus the Sociology of globalization updated 2023 doc 16.docx
Discus the Sociology of globalization updated 2023 doc 16.docxDiscus the Sociology of globalization updated 2023 doc 16.docx
Discus the Sociology of globalization updated 2023 doc 16.docxintel-writers.com
 
High School Application Essay Samples. FREE 8 School Essay Samples in MS Word...
High School Application Essay Samples. FREE 8 School Essay Samples in MS Word...High School Application Essay Samples. FREE 8 School Essay Samples in MS Word...
High School Application Essay Samples. FREE 8 School Essay Samples in MS Word...Veronica Diaz
 
Should Cigarette Smoking Be Banned Essay
Should Cigarette Smoking Be Banned EssayShould Cigarette Smoking Be Banned Essay
Should Cigarette Smoking Be Banned EssayAshley Arrington
 
Barnett_3300_L8-RP
Barnett_3300_L8-RPBarnett_3300_L8-RP
Barnett_3300_L8-RPJohn Barnett
 
5 My Nursing Assignment.pdf
5 My Nursing Assignment.pdf5 My Nursing Assignment.pdf
5 My Nursing Assignment.pdfstudy help
 
Policy Learning And Knowledge Perceptions
Policy Learning And Knowledge PerceptionsPolicy Learning And Knowledge Perceptions
Policy Learning And Knowledge PerceptionsPer Koch
 
What Type of Digital Transformation? Reinventing Social Thought and Action...
What Type of Digital Transformation?  Reinventing  Social Thought  and Action...What Type of Digital Transformation?  Reinventing  Social Thought  and Action...
What Type of Digital Transformation? Reinventing Social Thought and Action...Douglas Schuler
 
Social Development Essay. Sample essay on effects of gender inequality on dev...
Social Development Essay. Sample essay on effects of gender inequality on dev...Social Development Essay. Sample essay on effects of gender inequality on dev...
Social Development Essay. Sample essay on effects of gender inequality on dev...Chelsea Cote
 
Science Essay Examples
Science Essay ExamplesScience Essay Examples
Science Essay ExamplesReina Rosado
 
Insights of Engineering Technology and Organizational Leadership on Human Tra...
Insights of Engineering Technology and Organizational Leadership on Human Tra...Insights of Engineering Technology and Organizational Leadership on Human Tra...
Insights of Engineering Technology and Organizational Leadership on Human Tra...Pablo Villa-Martinez
 

Semelhante a What Are the Grand challenges for Cultural Evolution? (20)

ASEM 2014 IAC EMJ Culture Final
ASEM 2014 IAC EMJ Culture FinalASEM 2014 IAC EMJ Culture Final
ASEM 2014 IAC EMJ Culture Final
 
Color Essay
Color EssayColor Essay
Color Essay
 
Brandon’s Post· Identify the global societal issue you ha.docx
Brandon’s Post· Identify the global societal issue you ha.docxBrandon’s Post· Identify the global societal issue you ha.docx
Brandon’s Post· Identify the global societal issue you ha.docx
 
Development theories and approaches
Development theories and approachesDevelopment theories and approaches
Development theories and approaches
 
Final report on Ethnocentrism
Final report on EthnocentrismFinal report on Ethnocentrism
Final report on Ethnocentrism
 
French Essay.pdfFrench Essay. French a level essay help - writefiction581.web...
French Essay.pdfFrench Essay. French a level essay help - writefiction581.web...French Essay.pdfFrench Essay. French a level essay help - writefiction581.web...
French Essay.pdfFrench Essay. French a level essay help - writefiction581.web...
 
ECON315 – Global Economy – Research Paper .docx
ECON315 – Global Economy – Research Paper                     .docxECON315 – Global Economy – Research Paper                     .docx
ECON315 – Global Economy – Research Paper .docx
 
WK1 DQ 1The first step in the research process is selecting a to.docx
WK1 DQ 1The first step in the research process is selecting a to.docxWK1 DQ 1The first step in the research process is selecting a to.docx
WK1 DQ 1The first step in the research process is selecting a to.docx
 
Discus the Sociology of globalization updated 2023 doc 16.docx
Discus the Sociology of globalization updated 2023 doc 16.docxDiscus the Sociology of globalization updated 2023 doc 16.docx
Discus the Sociology of globalization updated 2023 doc 16.docx
 
High School Application Essay Samples. FREE 8 School Essay Samples in MS Word...
High School Application Essay Samples. FREE 8 School Essay Samples in MS Word...High School Application Essay Samples. FREE 8 School Essay Samples in MS Word...
High School Application Essay Samples. FREE 8 School Essay Samples in MS Word...
 
Should Cigarette Smoking Be Banned Essay
Should Cigarette Smoking Be Banned EssayShould Cigarette Smoking Be Banned Essay
Should Cigarette Smoking Be Banned Essay
 
Critical Analysis Of Research Articles
Critical Analysis Of Research ArticlesCritical Analysis Of Research Articles
Critical Analysis Of Research Articles
 
Barnett_3300_L8-RP
Barnett_3300_L8-RPBarnett_3300_L8-RP
Barnett_3300_L8-RP
 
5 My Nursing Assignment.pdf
5 My Nursing Assignment.pdf5 My Nursing Assignment.pdf
5 My Nursing Assignment.pdf
 
Policy Learning And Knowledge Perceptions
Policy Learning And Knowledge PerceptionsPolicy Learning And Knowledge Perceptions
Policy Learning And Knowledge Perceptions
 
Chapters 1 and 2
Chapters 1 and 2Chapters 1 and 2
Chapters 1 and 2
 
What Type of Digital Transformation? Reinventing Social Thought and Action...
What Type of Digital Transformation?  Reinventing  Social Thought  and Action...What Type of Digital Transformation?  Reinventing  Social Thought  and Action...
What Type of Digital Transformation? Reinventing Social Thought and Action...
 
Social Development Essay. Sample essay on effects of gender inequality on dev...
Social Development Essay. Sample essay on effects of gender inequality on dev...Social Development Essay. Sample essay on effects of gender inequality on dev...
Social Development Essay. Sample essay on effects of gender inequality on dev...
 
Science Essay Examples
Science Essay ExamplesScience Essay Examples
Science Essay Examples
 
Insights of Engineering Technology and Organizational Leadership on Human Tra...
Insights of Engineering Technology and Organizational Leadership on Human Tra...Insights of Engineering Technology and Organizational Leadership on Human Tra...
Insights of Engineering Technology and Organizational Leadership on Human Tra...
 

Mais de Joe Brewer

Barichara Regeneration Model
Barichara Regeneration ModelBarichara Regeneration Model
Barichara Regeneration ModelJoe Brewer
 
Regenerating Bioregions with Universities
Regenerating Bioregions with UniversitiesRegenerating Bioregions with Universities
Regenerating Bioregions with UniversitiesJoe Brewer
 
Design Institute for Regenerating the Earth
Design Institute for Regenerating the EarthDesign Institute for Regenerating the Earth
Design Institute for Regenerating the EarthJoe Brewer
 
Guiding the Emergence of Humanity's Future
Guiding the Emergence of Humanity's FutureGuiding the Emergence of Humanity's Future
Guiding the Emergence of Humanity's FutureJoe Brewer
 
Restoring Planetary Health
Restoring Planetary HealthRestoring Planetary Health
Restoring Planetary HealthJoe Brewer
 
Regenerating Bioregions
Regenerating BioregionsRegenerating Bioregions
Regenerating BioregionsJoe Brewer
 
Graduate Program in Applied Cultural Evolution
Graduate Program in Applied Cultural EvolutionGraduate Program in Applied Cultural Evolution
Graduate Program in Applied Cultural EvolutionJoe Brewer
 
Regenerative Path to Planetary Health
Regenerative Path to Planetary HealthRegenerative Path to Planetary Health
Regenerative Path to Planetary HealthJoe Brewer
 
School for Applied Cultural Evolution
School for Applied Cultural EvolutionSchool for Applied Cultural Evolution
School for Applied Cultural EvolutionJoe Brewer
 
Creating A School of Applied Cultural Evolution
Creating A School of Applied Cultural EvolutionCreating A School of Applied Cultural Evolution
Creating A School of Applied Cultural EvolutionJoe Brewer
 
Billion Dollar Proposal for Applied Cultural Evolution
Billion Dollar Proposal for Applied Cultural EvolutionBillion Dollar Proposal for Applied Cultural Evolution
Billion Dollar Proposal for Applied Cultural EvolutionJoe Brewer
 
Why I Am No Longer Attempting to Build A Rigorous Science of Social Change
Why I Am No Longer Attempting to Build A Rigorous Science of Social ChangeWhy I Am No Longer Attempting to Build A Rigorous Science of Social Change
Why I Am No Longer Attempting to Build A Rigorous Science of Social ChangeJoe Brewer
 
Why Global Warming Won't Go Viral
Why Global Warming Won't Go ViralWhy Global Warming Won't Go Viral
Why Global Warming Won't Go ViralJoe Brewer
 
Culture Design Research Center - A Strategic Plan
Culture Design Research Center - A Strategic PlanCulture Design Research Center - A Strategic Plan
Culture Design Research Center - A Strategic PlanJoe Brewer
 
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Election Results
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Election ResultsCultural Evolution Society 2016 Election Results
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Election ResultsJoe Brewer
 
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Voter's Manual
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Voter's ManualCultural Evolution Society 2016 Voter's Manual
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Voter's ManualJoe Brewer
 
Exploring the Tools for Meme Propagation
Exploring the Tools for Meme PropagationExploring the Tools for Meme Propagation
Exploring the Tools for Meme PropagationJoe Brewer
 
How Do We Think About 21st Century Farming?
How Do We Think About 21st Century Farming?How Do We Think About 21st Century Farming?
How Do We Think About 21st Century Farming?Joe Brewer
 
Why the Framing of Globalization Matters
Why the Framing of Globalization MattersWhy the Framing of Globalization Matters
Why the Framing of Globalization MattersJoe Brewer
 
Where Did This Global Movement Come From?
Where Did This Global Movement Come From?Where Did This Global Movement Come From?
Where Did This Global Movement Come From?Joe Brewer
 

Mais de Joe Brewer (20)

Barichara Regeneration Model
Barichara Regeneration ModelBarichara Regeneration Model
Barichara Regeneration Model
 
Regenerating Bioregions with Universities
Regenerating Bioregions with UniversitiesRegenerating Bioregions with Universities
Regenerating Bioregions with Universities
 
Design Institute for Regenerating the Earth
Design Institute for Regenerating the EarthDesign Institute for Regenerating the Earth
Design Institute for Regenerating the Earth
 
Guiding the Emergence of Humanity's Future
Guiding the Emergence of Humanity's FutureGuiding the Emergence of Humanity's Future
Guiding the Emergence of Humanity's Future
 
Restoring Planetary Health
Restoring Planetary HealthRestoring Planetary Health
Restoring Planetary Health
 
Regenerating Bioregions
Regenerating BioregionsRegenerating Bioregions
Regenerating Bioregions
 
Graduate Program in Applied Cultural Evolution
Graduate Program in Applied Cultural EvolutionGraduate Program in Applied Cultural Evolution
Graduate Program in Applied Cultural Evolution
 
Regenerative Path to Planetary Health
Regenerative Path to Planetary HealthRegenerative Path to Planetary Health
Regenerative Path to Planetary Health
 
School for Applied Cultural Evolution
School for Applied Cultural EvolutionSchool for Applied Cultural Evolution
School for Applied Cultural Evolution
 
Creating A School of Applied Cultural Evolution
Creating A School of Applied Cultural EvolutionCreating A School of Applied Cultural Evolution
Creating A School of Applied Cultural Evolution
 
Billion Dollar Proposal for Applied Cultural Evolution
Billion Dollar Proposal for Applied Cultural EvolutionBillion Dollar Proposal for Applied Cultural Evolution
Billion Dollar Proposal for Applied Cultural Evolution
 
Why I Am No Longer Attempting to Build A Rigorous Science of Social Change
Why I Am No Longer Attempting to Build A Rigorous Science of Social ChangeWhy I Am No Longer Attempting to Build A Rigorous Science of Social Change
Why I Am No Longer Attempting to Build A Rigorous Science of Social Change
 
Why Global Warming Won't Go Viral
Why Global Warming Won't Go ViralWhy Global Warming Won't Go Viral
Why Global Warming Won't Go Viral
 
Culture Design Research Center - A Strategic Plan
Culture Design Research Center - A Strategic PlanCulture Design Research Center - A Strategic Plan
Culture Design Research Center - A Strategic Plan
 
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Election Results
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Election ResultsCultural Evolution Society 2016 Election Results
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Election Results
 
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Voter's Manual
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Voter's ManualCultural Evolution Society 2016 Voter's Manual
Cultural Evolution Society 2016 Voter's Manual
 
Exploring the Tools for Meme Propagation
Exploring the Tools for Meme PropagationExploring the Tools for Meme Propagation
Exploring the Tools for Meme Propagation
 
How Do We Think About 21st Century Farming?
How Do We Think About 21st Century Farming?How Do We Think About 21st Century Farming?
How Do We Think About 21st Century Farming?
 
Why the Framing of Globalization Matters
Why the Framing of Globalization MattersWhy the Framing of Globalization Matters
Why the Framing of Globalization Matters
 
Where Did This Global Movement Come From?
Where Did This Global Movement Come From?Where Did This Global Movement Come From?
Where Did This Global Movement Come From?
 

Último

Pulmonary drug delivery system M.pharm -2nd sem P'ceutics
Pulmonary drug delivery system M.pharm -2nd sem P'ceuticsPulmonary drug delivery system M.pharm -2nd sem P'ceutics
Pulmonary drug delivery system M.pharm -2nd sem P'ceuticssakshisoni2385
 
Forensic Biology & Its biological significance.pdf
Forensic Biology & Its biological significance.pdfForensic Biology & Its biological significance.pdf
Forensic Biology & Its biological significance.pdfrohankumarsinghrore1
 
Dopamine neurotransmitter determination using graphite sheet- graphene nano-s...
Dopamine neurotransmitter determination using graphite sheet- graphene nano-s...Dopamine neurotransmitter determination using graphite sheet- graphene nano-s...
Dopamine neurotransmitter determination using graphite sheet- graphene nano-s...Mohammad Khajehpour
 
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 1)
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 1)GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 1)
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 1)Areesha Ahmad
 
Justdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts Service
Justdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts ServiceJustdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts Service
Justdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts Servicemonikaservice1
 
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdfZoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdfSumit Kumar yadav
 
Pests of cotton_Borer_Pests_Binomics_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of cotton_Borer_Pests_Binomics_Dr.UPR.pdfPests of cotton_Borer_Pests_Binomics_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of cotton_Borer_Pests_Binomics_Dr.UPR.pdfPirithiRaju
 
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar🍑
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar🍑High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar🍑
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar🍑Damini Dixit
 
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic data.pptx
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic  data.pptxSeismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic  data.pptx
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic data.pptxAlMamun560346
 
Call Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Bookingroncy bisnoi
 
Bacterial Identification and Classifications
Bacterial Identification and ClassificationsBacterial Identification and Classifications
Bacterial Identification and ClassificationsAreesha Ahmad
 
IDENTIFICATION OF THE LIVING- forensic medicine
IDENTIFICATION OF THE LIVING- forensic medicineIDENTIFICATION OF THE LIVING- forensic medicine
IDENTIFICATION OF THE LIVING- forensic medicinesherlingomez2
 
Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.
Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.
Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.Silpa
 
Locating and isolating a gene, FISH, GISH, Chromosome walking and jumping, te...
Locating and isolating a gene, FISH, GISH, Chromosome walking and jumping, te...Locating and isolating a gene, FISH, GISH, Chromosome walking and jumping, te...
Locating and isolating a gene, FISH, GISH, Chromosome walking and jumping, te...Silpa
 
SCIENCE-4-QUARTER4-WEEK-4-PPT-1 (1).pptx
SCIENCE-4-QUARTER4-WEEK-4-PPT-1 (1).pptxSCIENCE-4-QUARTER4-WEEK-4-PPT-1 (1).pptx
SCIENCE-4-QUARTER4-WEEK-4-PPT-1 (1).pptxRizalinePalanog2
 
9654467111 Call Girls In Raj Nagar Delhi Short 1500 Night 6000
9654467111 Call Girls In Raj Nagar Delhi Short 1500 Night 60009654467111 Call Girls In Raj Nagar Delhi Short 1500 Night 6000
9654467111 Call Girls In Raj Nagar Delhi Short 1500 Night 6000Sapana Sha
 
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx .
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx       .Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx       .
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx .Poonam Aher Patil
 
PSYCHOSOCIAL NEEDS. in nursing II sem pptx
PSYCHOSOCIAL NEEDS. in nursing II sem pptxPSYCHOSOCIAL NEEDS. in nursing II sem pptx
PSYCHOSOCIAL NEEDS. in nursing II sem pptxSuji236384
 
Asymmetry in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76 b
Asymmetry in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76 bAsymmetry in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76 b
Asymmetry in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76 bSérgio Sacani
 

Último (20)

Pulmonary drug delivery system M.pharm -2nd sem P'ceutics
Pulmonary drug delivery system M.pharm -2nd sem P'ceuticsPulmonary drug delivery system M.pharm -2nd sem P'ceutics
Pulmonary drug delivery system M.pharm -2nd sem P'ceutics
 
Forensic Biology & Its biological significance.pdf
Forensic Biology & Its biological significance.pdfForensic Biology & Its biological significance.pdf
Forensic Biology & Its biological significance.pdf
 
Dopamine neurotransmitter determination using graphite sheet- graphene nano-s...
Dopamine neurotransmitter determination using graphite sheet- graphene nano-s...Dopamine neurotransmitter determination using graphite sheet- graphene nano-s...
Dopamine neurotransmitter determination using graphite sheet- graphene nano-s...
 
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 1)
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 1)GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 1)
GBSN - Biochemistry (Unit 1)
 
Justdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts Service
Justdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts ServiceJustdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts Service
Justdial Call Girls In Indirapuram, Ghaziabad, 8800357707 Escorts Service
 
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdfZoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
 
Pests of cotton_Borer_Pests_Binomics_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of cotton_Borer_Pests_Binomics_Dr.UPR.pdfPests of cotton_Borer_Pests_Binomics_Dr.UPR.pdf
Pests of cotton_Borer_Pests_Binomics_Dr.UPR.pdf
 
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar🍑
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar🍑High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar🍑
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in GTB Nagar🍑
 
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic data.pptx
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic  data.pptxSeismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic  data.pptx
Seismic Method Estimate velocity from seismic data.pptx
 
Call Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Alandi Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
 
Bacterial Identification and Classifications
Bacterial Identification and ClassificationsBacterial Identification and Classifications
Bacterial Identification and Classifications
 
IDENTIFICATION OF THE LIVING- forensic medicine
IDENTIFICATION OF THE LIVING- forensic medicineIDENTIFICATION OF THE LIVING- forensic medicine
IDENTIFICATION OF THE LIVING- forensic medicine
 
Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.
Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.
Proteomics: types, protein profiling steps etc.
 
Locating and isolating a gene, FISH, GISH, Chromosome walking and jumping, te...
Locating and isolating a gene, FISH, GISH, Chromosome walking and jumping, te...Locating and isolating a gene, FISH, GISH, Chromosome walking and jumping, te...
Locating and isolating a gene, FISH, GISH, Chromosome walking and jumping, te...
 
SCIENCE-4-QUARTER4-WEEK-4-PPT-1 (1).pptx
SCIENCE-4-QUARTER4-WEEK-4-PPT-1 (1).pptxSCIENCE-4-QUARTER4-WEEK-4-PPT-1 (1).pptx
SCIENCE-4-QUARTER4-WEEK-4-PPT-1 (1).pptx
 
9654467111 Call Girls In Raj Nagar Delhi Short 1500 Night 6000
9654467111 Call Girls In Raj Nagar Delhi Short 1500 Night 60009654467111 Call Girls In Raj Nagar Delhi Short 1500 Night 6000
9654467111 Call Girls In Raj Nagar Delhi Short 1500 Night 6000
 
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx .
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx       .Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx       .
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx .
 
PSYCHOSOCIAL NEEDS. in nursing II sem pptx
PSYCHOSOCIAL NEEDS. in nursing II sem pptxPSYCHOSOCIAL NEEDS. in nursing II sem pptx
PSYCHOSOCIAL NEEDS. in nursing II sem pptx
 
Site Acceptance Test .
Site Acceptance Test                    .Site Acceptance Test                    .
Site Acceptance Test .
 
Asymmetry in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76 b
Asymmetry in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76 bAsymmetry in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76 b
Asymmetry in the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-76 b
 

What Are the Grand challenges for Cultural Evolution?

  • 1. What Are the Grand Challenges for Cultural Evolution? A Research Report for the Society for the Study of Cultural Evolution Prepared by: Joe Brewer Ian MacDonald Culture Designer Biology Researcher
 Evolution Institute Binghamton University

  • 2. What You Will Find In This Report An ad hoc steering committee initiated steps to form the Society for the Study of Cultural Evolution (SSCE) in the summer of 2015. As part of the inaugural proceedings, a survey of SSCE members was conducted to identify a suite of "grand challenge" problems of broad scientific and social interest that can drive cutting-edge research and practice within the field of cultural evolutionary studies for future decades. Over the course of several weeks, a total of 236 SSCE members from around the world completed an online questionnaire in which they could nominate up to ten such challenges, providing a brief description and rationale for each. Additionally, SSCE members were also asked to indicate their level of understanding and mode of training in core domains (cultural studies and evolutionary theory), how they see their current work fitting into the wider world of cultural evolutionary studies, and how they see themselves contributing to the grand challenges facing the society. The responses to the initial grand challenges survey are summarized below. Qualitative Assessment — Close-Text Semantic Analysis of Survey Responses As noted above, we received 236 completed surveys. Respondents could nominate more than one grand challenge, so we received a total of 435 Grand Challenge Ideas. The methodology used to analyze the content of these Grand Challenge Ideas is called close-text semantic analysis which is to closely read each text entry and create a coding system of hashtags for thematic content found within them. The procedure goes like this: 1. Place all Grand Challenge Ideas (GCIs) in a single spreadsheet column. 2. Go through all 435 GCIs and create hashtags for content by filling in the accompanying row for each entry. 3. Build up a "master list" of these hashtags to create thematic categories for organizing the responses. 4. Count the number of entries “tagged” by each hashtag as a measure of thematic composition and emphasis. 5. Construct “network graphs” that reveal how the most prominent themes cluster together in order to create complex thematic categories that reveal key relationships between the hashtags (and the themes they represent).1 Special thanks to Ken Cousins of The Vicinus Group for conducting this network graph analysis for us.1 What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 3. Before going into the findings from this analysis, it may be helpful to see what a typical Grand Challenge Idea looks like. Here are two representative examples taken from the survey responses. Note how both are richly sophisticated and thoughtfully articulated. The full collection of responses came through this way. We really have a phenomenal community of engaged participants in our founding membership at the SSCE! Grand Challenge Response — Representative Example 1 Learning how to harness the power of conformist biased transmission to support political policy or health related measures that are widely supported by the public and by specialists even if not by the small minority of well-heeled lobbying groups. Perhaps this would allow democratic governments to better work for the people's interest rather than the large, multinational conglomerates' interest. Tags: #ConformistBias, #CulturalTransmission, #PolicyMaking, #PracticalSolutions, #CultureDesign Grand Challenge Response — Representative Example 2 The world is loosing indigenous cultures at an unprecedented rate reflected by an estimated loss of 1 language per day. These cultures hold knowledge and wisdom essential to humanity's well-being and prosperity. More than 370 million Indigenous Peoples live in over 90 countries and constitute the largest minority in the world. Indigenous territories cover 24 percent of the earth’s land surface that harbor 80 percent of the earth’s remaining biodiversity. Indigenous peoples are the stewards of some of the world’s most biologically diverse areas, and their traditional knowledge about nature is invaluable. Today, climate change is among the forces of globalization threatening the very existence of many Indigenous Peoples; some estimate the world is loosing one indigenous language every day. Ironically, traditional indigenous knowledge passed down through the centuries offers highly valuable sources of wisdom to guide all of us in addressing the greatest challenges of our times, as well as offering sources of knowledge and wisdom as a basis for innovation and guiding social well-being. Tags: #Diversity, #ComparingCultures, #CulturalExtinction, #Environment, #Globalization Another thing to note in the way hashtags are used is that each entry typically was given several tags—making it possible to add up the number of entries associated with each tag and to capture the relationships between tags that appear together. The analysis that follows is garnered from these two types of information. What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 4. What Were The Top Ten Hashtags? A total of 149 hashtags were created (a full list can be found in the appendix at the end of this report), revealing a great diversity of topics that have been flagged as important for consideration by the society. The first thing we wanted to know was which thematic elements appear most frequently in the survey responses. Since each entry was coded with several hashtags, it was straightforward to add them up and see which ones occur most frequently. This table shows the top ten themes and gives the number of entries that were tagged by each of them. The highest priority theme was knowledge synthesis. It was tagged in 99 of the 435 entries (22.8% of the total) and appeared almost twice as often as the second-ranked theme of prosociaiity. Similar second-ranked emphasis was given to culture definition, environmental concerns, cultural transmission, and economics. Each theme was treated as a “generally relevant topic” for the entry it was tagged onto. What this means methodologically is that we created a hashtag each time a new topic appeared as we went through the survey responses. When the same topic was mentioned again (often with a different, albeit related, focus), we applied the hashtag to the new entry. Topics were loosely defined intentionally such that entries can be clustered into categories of themes that are related to each other in a variety of ways. To help this make more sense, here are brief descriptors for the six most frequently used thematic elements: Knowledge Synthesis deals with the need to combine information across disparate fields of inquiry, such as bridging research from social psychology with anthropological studies of Thematic Element Frequency of Responses #KnowledgeSynthesis 99 #ProSociality 51 #CultureDefinition 48 #Environment 46 #CulturalTransmission 45 #Economics 44 #Theory 42 #HistoricTrajectories 38 #ComparingCultures 36 What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 5. indigenous cultures. Each entry tagged with this theme was a call for synthesis and integration of knowledge to tackle otherwise intractable problems. ProSociality deals with the underlying mechanisms that give rise to trust, cooperation, altruism, and other social behaviors that enhance the functioning for groups of people. Each entry tagged with this theme was a call for safer communities, better cooperation, and more effective institutions. Culture Definition deals with lingering confusion about the relationship between biology and culture. Each entry tagged with this theme was a call for greater clarity about the similarities and differences between inheritance through the diverse mechanisms of genetics, epigenetics, social behavior, and symbolic culture. Environment deals with environmental concerns that threaten human communities and the biosphere in general. Each entry tagged with this theme was a call for action on climate change or for deeper understandings about the roles played by culture in harmonious (and dysfunctional) relationships between humans and the more-than-human world. Cultural Transmission deals with processes of social learning and exchanges of knowledge from one generation to the next. Each entry tagged with this theme was a call for deeper understandings about the cognitive, anatomical, and evolutionary aspects of cultural change that give rise to and constrain the transmission of cultural practices from one person to another. Economics deals with the foundational social science of productivity and resource allocation in human societies. Each entry tagged with this theme was a call for clarity about scientifically credible economic knowledge and its applications to both organizational management and public policy. These are only six of 149 themes that arose at least once in the collection of survey responses—a rich dataset indeed! For this reason, it is unwieldy to tackle the full complexity of the idea network comprising all 435 entries. The next step was to rank order the full list of hashtags and see which ones appear most frequently (not only the top ten listed above). After this we can start to organize the tags into relational webs of co-occurence to see how the themes clustered together in the full collection of responses. Pulling Back To See The Big Picture We have already seen that our founding members want the society to promote knowledge synthesis, increase collective learning about the nature of cultural change and how it differs from genetic evolution, and apply this knowledge to important environmental and economic projects that impact the real world. What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 6. So what else do our founding members want us to focus on? Pulling back to see the bigger picture, let’s start by looking at the top 50 thematic elements, ranked according to their frequency in the survey responses. This graph shows the top ten entries listed above plus the next forty topics that appeared with decreasing frequency. As you can see there are quite a few worthy themes for consideration, some of them having fairly obvious relationships with each other. For example, governance and policymaking are going to have important linkages with each other. They will also be implicated in attempts to deal with the global crisis (convergence of threats due to globalization, ecological decline, population growth, and the systemic threats that arise among them). We can also see how storytelling and science communication are relevant to practical solutions and are specifically connected for attempts to deal with resistance to evolution both in the academy and for the lay public. This tells us that the topics are not separate from each other. They already have semantic structure where their meanings are interrelated and actions around some will influence or be influenced by others. Another way to see the systemic nature of these topics is to construct a graph showing all 149 thematic elements with lines drawn connecting each of them that appears together in at least one entry. Thicken the connections in a linear manner to represent the number of times they appear together and you get this mess—affectionally called the “kitchen sink” graph by the researcher who created it for us. What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015 0 5 10 15 20 25 Top$50$Thematic$Elements$of$Grand$Survey$Results (%$of$Responses$with$Each$Theme)
  • 7. The “Kitchen Sink” — A Mangle of Topics From All Survey Responses For example, if historic trajectories appears in the same entry with technology we draw a line between them. The line is then made thicker each time they appear together in a new entry. Do this for a large number of themes and we get a graph like this: " This graph is not a full “kitchen sink” because it only includes the topics that appeared at least 13 times in the full collection of survey responses. (This graphic is also simplified further by removing knowledge synthesis to declutter and emphasize second-tier relationships.) Even when simplified in this way, we can see that a great deal of clustering exists between the themes—a reflection of the sophistication and richness for each individual entry as we saw earlier in this report. What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 8. The next step we took was to look at the “ego network” for the most prominent themes. This is done by graphing one topic with all of the others that link to it, revealing how this theme stands in relation to others. Here is the ego network for knowledge synthesis: Several things leap out when we view the data in this way. Firstly, we can see yet again how no topic stands alone. It is not surprising that knowledge synthesis (being the most prominent theme to come up in survey responses) will be connected to almost every other topic. More interesting to note is that this theme is linked most strongly with theory, shared language, culture definition, institutional silos, and method diversity. The structure of this category is revealing itself. What we can take away from the analysis so far is that SSCE members want to see our fledgling society organize itself around a process of unification in the social sciences. To do this we will need to create a shared language to integrate knowledge across disciplinary silos in the academy. We will have to focus effort on deep theoretical issues—particularly those having to do with the methodological approaches we take to the study of culture (and how this is similar to or divergent from the study of biology, physics, and other scientific domains). And we will have to overcome the institutional barriers that hinder this kind of synthesis, in a sense “evolving” the way our institutions are set up so they can better enable the integration of knowledge across fields. Clearly, this implies a need for our society to be collaborative and diverse in its membership. Tackling this grand challenge will take many years and require that we form excellent relationships with complementary societies and institutions. What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 9. On the practitioner side, we have already mentioned that a number of grand challenge ideas are about the threats of ecological collapse, issues pertaining to governance and community well- being, and many other practical (and urgent!) issues. We were able to unpack this by looking at the ego network for the global crisis theme. This graph shows how our founding members perceive the human predicament as we enter the early middle of the 21st Century. The largest linkage, not surprisingly, is with environmental concerns—principally global warming and the systemic threats associated with it. More revealing for how we structure the SSCE agenda is how several other themes cluster with each other as they are referenced to the global crisis. Note how historic trajectories, prosociaiity, economics, policymaking, governance, complexity, tribalism, and culture design form a tight weave as a category for strategic engagement. Some of the implications are: ✦ Practitioners working on the transition to sustainability will need to understand the historic patterns of civilization and how they relate to our evolved psychological dispositions in prehistoric times. ✦ The society needs to provide practical guidance for public policy, community development, and governance through insights about the ways human beings cooperate and build trust, naturally break down into tribal groups where conflict might arise, and how to manage this complexity with design principles. What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 10. ✦ All of this will depend upon our ability to tackle the grand challenge of knowledge synthesis as part of organizational development efforts worldwide. The SSCE needs to balance scientific rigor with considerable expertise in practical applications. We could continue this analysis with other themes but the outcomes would be broadly similar. The topics our founding members want this society to address are systemic both in knowledge area and practical application. The survey results tell us that we need to cultivate a strongly collaborative, cross-disciplinary network of partnerships that both advance deep theoretical inquiry and provide assistance to urgent real-world challenges at every level of society. So how prepared are we now? The rest of this report offers a glimpse at who the founding membership is and what we are already capable of doing together. Quantitative Assessment — Who Are the Founding Members of SSCE? The survey we sent out included a series of multiple choice questions to help us get a sense of who the founding membership is, what they do, and how extensive their knowledge is about cultural evolutionary studies. The first question we asked was How do you see your current work fitting into the field of cultural evolutionary studies? Respondents could select one or more of four options. The results are presented in Table 1 showing that 75% of those who filled out the survey come from the research world, more than a third are teachers, and a third work on practical applications. Table  1.  The  propor(on  of  respondents  that  see  their  current  work  as  fi5ng  into  one  (or  more)  of  four   broad  domains  within  the  realm  of  cultural  evolu(onary  studies  (n  =  236).  Note:  members  were  able  to   select  more  than  one  op(on.   A follow-up question was asked about how they would like to contribute to activities through the SSCE. The results are shown in Table 2 on the next page. The founding members who filled out this survey are predominantly interested in providing research and educational support to the grand challenges. Some want to help increase the financial investments in cultural evolutionary studies (and design practice, as we saw in the qualitative analysis above) through government funding and private philanthropy. A strong signal comes through that our members would like to be entrepreneurial and creative through the society—notable emphasis came with 34% wanting to help improve academic institutions and 21% having an interest in creating or improving social impact enterprises. Research Teaching Applied (Not Active, But) Interested 0.75 0.38 0.35 0.13 What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 11. Table  2.  The  propor(on  of  respondents  who  see  themselves  contribu(ng  to  the  grand  challenge  effort   via  several  means  (n  =  236).  Note:  respondents  were  able  to  select  more  than  one  op(on.   So how much do our founding members know about cultural evolutionary studies? And how did they acquire the knowledge they currently have. We started by separating cultural studies from evolutionary studies to see how each subdomain of the field is represented by our membership. This allowed us to look at the relative strengths in each area and—as we’ll see in a moment—to get a glimpse into the opportunities for educational improvement this society can help make happen through its activities. Figure  1.  Distribu(on  of  respondents’  self-­‐reported  level  of  understanding  in  the  domain  of  cultural  stud-­‐ ies  (n  =  235).  Scale  ranged  from  1  (Novice)  to  7  (Expert).   Contribution to Tackling Grand Challenges Through the SSCE Proportion of Respondents Conduct basic and applied research 0.72 Improve academic institutions to better address societal issues 0.34 Run campaigns that change policy outcomes 0.17 Design policy frameworks and new metrics based on scientific research 0.28 Increase financial support for efforts through government funding 0.11 Increase financial support for efforts through private philanthropy 0.08 Engage in entrepreneurial efforts to build social impact enterprises 0.21 Educate the public through communication pathways in the media 0.55 Other 0.16 What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 12. Not surprisingly, the founding members have a strong knowledge base in cultural studies. Few consider themselves novices and most are approaching the level of mastery, while still feeling they have more to learn. Figure  2.  Distribu(on  of  respondents’  mode  of  training  within  the  domain  of  cultural  studies  (n  =  232).   Scale  ranged  from  1  (Completely  Self-­‐Taught)  to  7  (Completely  Formal  Educa(on).   Interestingly, when we asked how they acquired their training in cultural studies most said it was a mix of self-directed informal learning and formal academic education. Fewer respondents described themselves as formally educated than self-educated—indicating that community members entered their respective fields of cultural studies through informal and formal pathways. We ran a subsequent analysis of these results to create a “bi-variate response distribution” that tells us how the mode of learning corresponds with the level of expertise acquired. The results are presented in Figure 3. What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015 Figure  3.  The  bivariate  response  distribu(on  of  re-­‐ spondents’  level  of  understanding  by  mode  of  training   within  the  domain  of  cultural  studies.  Cell  color  is   scaled  to  the  propor(on  of  overall  responses  in  falling   in  each  (r  =  0.588,  p  <  0.001,  n  =  232).
  • 13. We then did the same sequence of analysis for evolutionary studies. This is where it gets interesting because a notable strength stands out. Nearly all respondents described themselves as being well trained in the Theory of Evolution. Very few described themselves as novices. Yet when we look at where they received this education a bimodal pattern emerged. The majority of members are self-taught, with support from formal institutions for some of them. In other words, while our community is strong on evolution, the academy is not serving them well enough. A lot of people get trained in evolution on their own. Figure  4.  Distribu(on  of  respondents’  self-­‐reported  level  of  understanding  of  evolu(onary  theory  (n  =   235).  Scale  ranged  from  1  (Novice)  to  7  (Expert).   Figure  5.  Distribu(on  of  respondents’  mode  of  training  within  the  domain  of  evolu(onary  theory  (n  =   233).  Scale  ranged  from  1  (Completely  Self-­‐Taught)  to  7  (Completely  Formal  Educa(on).   What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 14. This becomes even more apparent when we look at the bivariate response distribution in Figure 6. One “peak” is found at the intersection of formal training and expertise. Another “peak” exists for people with slightly less confidence in their knowledge who are mostly self-taught. Herein lies an opportunity to bridge these pathways to educational attainment—bringing the academics together with practitioners who study evolution on their own. A lesson we can take away from this analysis is that the SSCE is well positioned to unite cultural researchers with evolutionary scientists, both in formal academic settings and among practitioners with informal training. And we can be confident that we have the requisite human capacities by looking at Figure 7 combining these dual strengths in one community of people. What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015 Figure  6.  The  bivariate  response  distribu(on  of  re-­‐ spondents’  level  of  understanding  by  mode  of  training   within  the  domain  of  evolu(onary  theory.  Cell  color  is   scaled  to  the  propor(on  of  overall  responses  in  falling   in  each  (r  =  0.505,  p  <  0.001,  n  =  233. Figure  7.  The  bivariate  response  distribu(on  of  re-­‐ spondents’  level  of  understanding  of  cultural  studies   by  level  of  understanding  of  evolu(onary  theory.  Cell   colour  is  scaled  to  the  propor(on  of  overall  responses   in  falling  in  each  (r  =  0.466,  p  <  0.001,  n  =  235).
  • 15. Figure 7 shows more than half of survey respondents with dual strength in cultural studies and evolutionary theory. Those of us with experience in the academic world know that this is rare indeed. Most social scientists are not trained in evolution. And many evolutionists remain skeptical about the applications of biology to human affairs. These survey responses are a sign of cultural evolution unfolding in real time. People are scattered across the intellectual landscape with respect to academic institutions and whether they have formal training or not. And these people are finding each other (or will be able to do so as we build capacity) under the heading of cultural evolutionary studies. In Closing — Where Do We Go From Here? We have learned a great deal from analyzing these survey responses. The next step is to assimilate these findings and present them back to the SSCE community for discussion, elaboration, and refinement. To help get this process going, we offer summary points and propose a course of action. Summary of Key Findings ✦ The number of responses is a clear indicator of interest in forming this society. We received 435 suggestions for Grand Challenge Ideas from 236 respondents, each articulating a thoughtful and important commentary for what the SSCE might want to do. ✦ Several focus areas became clear from these Grand Challenge Ideas—a strong focus on knowledge synthesis, clear delineation of what culture is and how it changes, and applications of this knowledge to major challenges confronting real-world communities. ✦ The themes offered as grand challenges are plentiful, yet it does feel plausible to tackle them systemically by acknowledging how deeply interwoven and interconnected they are. ✦ The founding members are uniquely prepared to make this effort a success. We have strength in both cultural studies and deep knowledge of evolutionary theory in our midst. ✦ Formation of the society itself is a measure of “cultural evolution in action” as we are already observing a process of those formally trained in academic institutions coming together with practitioners who have been self-taught, with combinations of both life paths for many of our members who straddle academic and institutional boundaries. Now we are ready to begin. This analysis has one primary purpose—to help the ad hoc steering committee set the SSCE on a launch trajectory that creates real value for its founding members. It is a great pleasure to see how deeply aligned this community is both in terms of focus areas held in common and for bringing diverse intellectual strengths that improve our institutions and communities as we move forward. What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 16. Proposed Course of Action ✦ Present these findings to the SSCE community on the Social Evolution Forum and facilitate discussion about scope and focus. ✦ Convene the ad hoc steering committee in person (already scheduled for late December) to unpack what we have learned and propose a strategic planning process to present back to the community. ✦ Build up the community supports—member database, website, publishing and communication platforms, etc.—for the formation of Special Interest Groups as “action committees” or task forces that self-organize around different grand challenges. ✦ Weave this process into the parallel track already underway to create bylaws and membership due structures, plan the first annual meeting of the SSCE, and get members involved in the process using the grand challenges as organizing themes. This is an exciting time to work in cultural evolution. The field is ready to pop! And these findings, while preliminary, are very encouraging for what is possible to achieve through the Society for the Study of Cultural Evolution for many years to come. What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 17. Appendix — Full List of Themes Theme Number  of  Times  Men<oned #Adapta(on 16 #AffectControlTheory 3 #Agency 2 #Algorithms 1 #Altruism 2 #AnimalBehavior 5 #AnimalCruelty 1 #Atheism 1 #BrainCulture 5 #Ci(es 1 #Civiliza(onCollapse 2 #CivilSociety 1 #Cogni(on 25 #Collabora(on 19 #Collec(veAc(on 10 #ComparingCultures 36 #Complexity 28 #ConflictResolu(on 20 #ConformistBias 2 #Consump(onPa^erns 1 #Corpora(ons 3 #Corrup(on 5 #CulturalA^rac(on 1 #CulturalEx(nc(on 3 #CulturallyBiasedResearch 6 #CulturalStability 8 #CulturalTransmission 45 What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 18. #CultureDefini(on   48 #CultureDesign 29 #Cumula(veCulture 22 #CurriculumDesign 1 #Databases 12 #DemographicTransi(on 1 #Development 1 #DirectDemocracy 1 #Diversity 17 #Ea(ngHabits 1 #EcologicalVaria(on 1 #Economics 44 #Educa(on 21 #Emo(ons 1 #EnergyTransi(on 6 #Entropy 3 #Environment 46 #ExtendedLifeSpan 1 #Fairness 6 #FaultyBeliefs 10 #FieldStudies 1 #FinancialSystem 3 #FundingChallenges 1 #GameTheory 1 #GenderDifferences 2 #GenderEquality 8 #GeneCulture 7 #GlobalCrisis 30 #Globaliza(on 10 What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 19. #Governance 33 #GrandHumanNarra(ve 1 #GroupProcess 4 #HateCrimes 1 #Hierarchy 10 #HistoricTrajectories 38 #HopeVsDespair 2 #HumanBiome 1 #HumanDevelopment 9 #HumanTrafficking 1 #HumanUniqueness 18 #HumanUniversals 1 #IncestuousThinking 1 #IncorporateHumani(es 1 #Individualism 1 #Inequality 15 #Informa(onExplosion 2 #Inheritance 7 #Innova(onDiffusion 19 #Ins(tu(onalSilos 24 #Inten(onalCommuni(es 1 #Interspirituality 1 #KnowledgeSynthesis 99 #LanguageOrigins 10 #LearningHeuris(cs 25 #LegalTheory 1 #LGBTQViolence 1 #Literacy 1 #Localism 5 What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 20. #Medicine 2 #Meme(cs 3 #MethodDiversity 23 #Militarism 3 #ModelingStudies 6 #MonetarySystem 1 #Morality 11 #Mul(LevelSelec(on 3 #NetworkedSociety 1 #NewMetrics 2 #NicheConstruc(on 3 #Ontology 1 #Organiza(onDevelopment 26 #OutdatedIncen(ves 1 #PathDependence 2 #PolicyMaking 32 #Poli(calPower 1 #Popula(on 1 #Popula(onGene(cs 4 #PostCapitalism 1 #Poverty 1 #Prac(calSolu(ons 15 #ProblemIden(fica(on 3 #ProSociality 51 #PublicHealth 2 #Publishing 1 #Quan(fiedSelf 1 #RaceIssues 6 #RamblingMess 1 What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 21. #RateOfChange 3 #Reduc(onism 1 #Reframing 1 #Religion 15 #Replicators 3 #ResistanceToEvolu(on 26 #ResourceWars 1 #RuralCommuni(es 1 #ScienceCommunica(on 20 #ScienceStudies 2 #Selec(on 3 #Seman(cs 4 #Sexuality 1 #SharedLanguage 28 #SocialAnaly(cs 1 #SocialConsciousness 4 #SocialIden(ty 1 #Socialism 1 #SocialMovements 15 #SocialOrganiza(on 22 #SocialValues 1 #Storytelling 20 #SystemicRisks 1 #SystemsThinking 2 #Taxes 1 #Technology 13 #TenureProblems 1 #Terrorism 3 #Theory   42 What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015
  • 22. #Transparency 1 #Tribalism 35 #UX/UI 1 #Violence 3 #WorkLifeBalance 1 #Worldviews 1 What Are The Grand Challenges For Cultural Evolution? Prepared on November 9, 2015