4. Including, but not limited to . . .
Engagement Interest
Ownership Need
Challenge Emotion
Meaningful Novelty
Vested Confidence
Desire Passion
Shared Commitment Ah-ha moment
26. “A paradigm shift occurs when a question is asked
inside the current paradigm that can only be
answered from outside of it.”
Marilee Goldberg
Image: Empower Magazine
27. What is the achievement gap?
Image: Corbis Images
28. How do we close the achievement
gap? Image: Corbis Images
29. Why does the achievement gap
persist? Image: Corbis Images
30. What does learning look like when it is
meaningful to students? Image: Corbis Images
31. A powerful question . . .
)
• stimulates reflective thinking.
• challenges assumptions.
• is thought-provoking.
• generates energy and a vector to explore.
• channels inquiry, promises insight.
• is broad and enduring.
• touches a deeper meaning.
• evokes more questions.
Eric Vogt, 1994
Image: IO9
32. More Powerful 1. Architecture
Why
How What
Where Which
When Who
Closed yes/no questions
Less Powerful
Source: Vogt
33. Are you feeling okay? Where does it hurt?
How are you feeling in general?
Why do you suppose you aren’t feeling well?
Image: New Black Magazine
Questions: Vogt, Brown, Isaacs
34. What can we do?
Vs.
What could we do?
Image: New Black Magazine
Questions: Vogt, Brown, Isaacs
35. Why is my coat unbuttoned?
Vs.
Where can we find spiritual peace?
Image: New Black Magazine
Questions: Vogt, Brown, Isaacs
55. and
Connect Ideas
People
Include Diverse Perspectives
Image: Wired
Content: Vogt, Brown, Isaacs
56. What’s wrong?
What’s working? Who’s to
What’s possible? blame?
Vs.
Support Appreciative Inquiry
Image: Wired
Content: Vogt, Brown, Isaacs
57. Images
System-wide and
Reflection Metaphors
Share
Insights
Fostering Shared Meaning
Image: Wired
Content: Vogt, Brown, Isaacs
58. On the
Fostering Front Lines
Learning
Networks
Nurture Communities of Practice
Image: Wired
Content: Vogt, Brown, Isaacs
59. Powerful Questions
+
Whole Child Focus
+
Community Involvement
=
Old Learning that Transforms
Paradigm
Image: Kootation
60. Thank you
Contact
Jason Flom Resources
JasonQED@gmail.com ASCD Whole Child
@JasonFlom Art Of Powerful Questions
QEDfoundation.org Art & Architecture of
AllKindsOfMinds.org Powerful Questions
Image: career education
Notas do Editor
When was a time when your learning curve was off the charts? What learning experience consumed you? Your most powerful learning?
What were the essential elements of that learning experience (elements without which the experience would not have been as powerful)? What made it so incredible, all consuming, instructive?
Commonly cited elements. How many listed the same exact experience as being the one that was so powerful? (probably none) Variability – complex set of experiences, emotions, interests and feedback loops.
These transformative learning experiences -- how do we cultivate opportunities for students to experience them as well? What student behavior do we see when they are having transformative learning experiences?
This is what everyone’s thinking, right?
QED’s TLM – our road map to transformational learning in schools and other learning environments. – a working living document. The white areas represent a break in practice.
We see the whole child work as an essential element that effecitively influences a number of the other elements. For example, we will not attain racial and social justice without focusing on the whole child. The justice necessitates that students be healthy, safe, engaged, challenged and supported.
Healthy – physically, mentally, emotionally and socially – Relationships, well being, in mind, body, spirtit, and relationships
Just, equitable – does everyone have the same, or does everyone have what they need?
Intentionally involving in things that are meaningful – to the students and to the mission/goal of the school/learning community. Value.
Personalized, keyed into to the individual well being, and communicated through various channels. – Build on their strengths, affinities, and cultivating optimism in the face of adversity.
Intellectually, within the context of a safe environment – that goes beyond the silos of traditional subjects.
Neurodiversity – where we are, what’s going on all around us – emotion plays a huge role how people are feeling – memory informs perception