Summary of my User Experience Research-Practice Interaction conversation at the Decipher 2018 conference. My intro slides and notes from the discussion.
4. Research culture
âPublish or perishâ
Answers narrow questions
Open sharing
Experimentation
Corporate culture
âProduce or perishâ
Wants broad answers
Strategic advantage
Fear of failure
HCI research culture
Publish for researchers
Expanding field
Status within academia
UX practice culture
No time for research
Rapidly evolving practice
Status within corporations
5. Research culture
âPublish or perishâ
Answers narrow questions
Open sharing
Experimentation
Corporate culture
âProduce or perishâ
Wants broad answers
Strategic advantage
Fear of failure
HCI research culture
Publish for researchers
Expanding field
Status within academia
UX practice culture
No time for research
Rapidly evolving practice
Status within corporations
Education
Position of UX within academia
Amateur professionals
Competing with business for training
Knowledge
No shared knowledge base
Hard to organize research for practical use
Multi-/inter-disciplinary
Communication
Little shared language
Speed-of-operation differences
Finding (time for) each other
Fragmented professional organizations
Mapping âanswersâ to âquestionsâ
14. Open Discussion
âą Mindsets around collaboration
â Relationship between researcher, teacher,
student, practitioner
âą Mooshiness of âUXâ
â Also, importance of evaluation and human factors
(lost in visual design focus)
âą Data is listened to but does not explain âwhyâ
âą Business model: Industry pays for education
15. Examples
âą Get practitioners on campus
â Practitioners teach classes with junior designers as TAs
â Practitioners review portfolios on campus
â Student organization events
âą Get professors in industry
â Professors as active practitioners
âą Example projects
â Smart home technology, nutrition, machine learning, museum design,
medical portal, âŠ
âą Business models & infrastructure
â Companies creating their own schools: train them in exactly what they
want
â Industry sponsored class
â Labs (as physical place where collaboration happens)
16. Wish List
âą Assistantships for people without a college
degree
âą A way to open doors to students at scale (e.g.,
not swamped with email and one-offs)
âą Inter-disciplinary classroom
âą Industry experience trajectory from peer
perspective
âą Longer term collaboration projects
âą Cloning practitioners
17. Barriers
âą Logistics & infrastructure: labs, contracts, IP, non-disclosure
agreements
âą Time
â Industry too busy for students
â Too much curriculum to cover for collaborative projects
âą Mindset (e.g., stereotypical thought processes within universities)
âą Communication & shared language
âą Relationships
âą Definitions and understanding of UX
âą Definitions and understanding of research
â Recognition of research within practice AND researcher doing design-
led research
18. Meta-Collaboration
âą Thu 2:30pm: Instone, USER EXPERIENCE
PRACTITIONER POV
âą Thu 3:30pm: Lane & Tegtmeyer, DESIGN
PROFESSOR POV
âą Sat 3pm: Barness & Meija, Cultural change is
needed
19. Examples of Collaboration
âą Thu 3pm: Elrod, Performance psychologist
âą Thu 3pm: Thomas, Critical race design studies
âą Fri 10am: Jacobs, Experiential education
âą Fri 2:30pm: Miller & Winter, Government
âą Sat 10am: Henriques, Multi-disciplinary
20. Supporting Collaboration?
âą Various: Writing (for practitioner readers?)
âą Thu 1:30pm: Parker & Barry, Pitching research (to
industry?)
âą Thu 1:30pm: Gibson & Owens, Framing research
(for industry?)
âą Fri 11am: Coorey, etal, Integrating research into
the classroom (for better practitioners)
âą Sat 2pm: Kothandaraman & Ludin, Roadmapping
tool (for practitioner consumption?)
21. âBe a Better Practitionerâ
âą Thu 1:30pm, Kotwas, IBM
âą Fri 10: Siegel & Fath, Biases in Product Teams
âą Sat 10am: Pontis, Visualization of field
research data
âą Sat 11:30am: Stirling, etal, Teaching non-
designers
âą Sat 2pm: Blazo, Participatory design to engage
stakeholders
22. Thanks!
âą Colleague discussions: instone@user-
experience.org & @keithinstone & #UXRPI
â Want to be interviewed for our research about
collaboration?
âą Business model discussions:
instone@dexterityux.com