SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 8
Redistricting Committee
Report
August 2012
1
Purpose of the Report
 Delegates have questioned the uneven distribution
of Lots between Districts that result in wide
variations in voting power between Delegates.
 Creating Districts that have a comparable number
of Lots requires changing the Community
Declaration.
 The Committee has strived to research and
document the steps, procedures, and expenses that
this would involve.
2
Redistricting Committee Recommends
Against Initiating this Process:
 Staggering potential costs to HRCA w/no certainty of a
successful result
 Substantial drain on staff resources
 Difficulty and costly undertaking to determine the number &
size of the proposed newly drawn districts
 Overcoming considerable obstacles to educate & engage the
community
 Significant challenges in obtaining the agreement of all sub
associations (if required)
 Potentially overwhelming challenges in obtaining the approval
of the required 67% of all Lots, or of even the 33.5% of Lots,
that is required to initiate the judicial option
 Only a marginal chance of success due to multiple expensive
hurdles that must be successfully and timely overcome
3
The current Delegate District structure
adheres to the fundamental
democratic principle of “one lot-one
vote” upon which the HRCA
Community Declaration is based.
4
5
Appendix A Redistricting - Steps 1-10 and associated tasks Time estimate Cost estimate Roadblocks
1A. Proposal by a Member(s), Delegate(s) or HRCA Board Member(s) to begin the process is
delivered to and approved by the HRCA Board.
2 months none HRCA Board does not
approve
1B. Establish funding for the project and build it into the budgets for successive years 6-15 months staff time Not funded by Board
2. Committee appointed by the HRCA Board:
Feasibility study is begun. Committee will manage the process including:
Defining the sections of the Declarations that need changing and
Seeking legal advice in answer to many questions.
Addressing the challenges with sub-associations
Recommending how districts will be drawn, such as contiguous etc.
6-12 months to
step #3
Legal (estimate)
$200,000-$400,000
including step #3 but
not step #7 or #8
3. Formal Resolution for the ballot question is written and the new district map redrawn. 1 month Map - (estimate)
$24,000-$30,400+
4. Mailing to all Lot owners and all sub-associations: The mailing includes the ballot
question along with FAQ’s and the map showing the new Districts. Possibility of a 2nd notice
reminder.
1 month Postage $30,030
+ 2nd notice
5. District meetings for all existing districts including sub-associations.
with 67% affirmative vote of lots and all sub-associations approval the amendment passes
proceed to step 6 and the judicial option (step 8, judicial option) is not required
with 10% of lots (quorum) voting and the majority opposing the amendment then it fails
with at least 10% (quorum) voting and with a majority but not a 33.5% affirmative vote OR
with less than 10% (quorum) voting - redo the election in an attempt to reach 33.5%
affirmative vote and less that 33.5% negative so that step 8, the judicial option can be
pursued
up to 12
months
Will HRCA cover
these unknown costs
including revisions to
sub-association
documents?
67% required
including all sub-
associations
or 33.5% affirmative
and less than 33.5%
negative required for
step 8 (judicial option)
6. Identify First Mortgage holders and notify: First Mortgage holders, Declarant, FHA and VA
by Certified mail. Publish Public Notice in newspapers two times at least one week apart.
4 months $150,000 + newsp +
certified mail
1st mortgage holders
object
7. Determine whether the amendments violate the terms of the bond financing documents and
if bond holders must approve the amendments. Notify bond holders if required.
1 month Legal review of bond
documents
Bond holders fail to
agree
8. If initiative failed to get 67% but it passed with all sub-associations (if required) approval
plus approval of 33.5% of all lots and less than 33.5% disapproval, and no objections from
bond holders (if required) and from First Mortgagees within 60 days; file a petition with the
court requesting the court to approve the proposed amendment. Then notify, in writing, within
10 days, all Unit Owners, the Declarant, First Mortgagees, FHA, and VA.
possibly 12-24
months
Unknown legal and
court costs
Judge’s decision is
unknown
9. If initiative is successful record the amendment in the records of Douglas County. 1 month p.1 $11 + $5 per page
10. Amend the bylaws to be consistent if legal has identified any inconsistencies. 3-6 months Legal - unknown
[1] See appendices A and C - Issues Requiring Legal Review
[2] Includes plat research and based on $150-$190 an hour for 160 hours, but could take longer
[3] $1 per mailing x 30,000 homes and 30 sub-associations = $30,030
[4] Requires Legal’s answer to: Must all sub-associations approve?
[5] Requires Legal’s answer to: Can court proceedings begin with 33.5% approval and all sub-associations agreeing?
[6] Requires Legal’s answer to: Is this a “material change” that requires First Mortgagees be notified?
[7] From title company’s estimate of $5 per home x 30,000 homes = $150,000
Appendix B
Members of the Committee
Greg Herman - District #17 - 166 lots
Jim Freeman - District #30 - 368 lots
Nancy Smith - District #62 - 197 lots
Jed Caswall - District #112 - 298 lots
Rick Werkheiser - from the HR community at large
David Gundersen - withdrew
6
Appendix C
FAQ’s on “Viable alternatives to redistricting that would
substantially equalize the voting power of Delegates”:
Q. Can small districts merge?
A. The Community Declaration states that “…each Delegate District shall elect one (1)
Delegate…” (Section 4.4) This applies to both sub-associations and districts that are not sub-
associations and so merging can only be done by going through the process outlined to change
the Community Declaration.
Q. Can large districts be split into separate, smaller districts?
A. Most likely sub-associations would not agree to this but in addition, the Community Declaration
states that “…each Delegate District shall elect one (1) Delegate…” (Section 4.4) This applies
to both sub-associations and districts that are not sub-associations and so dividing can only be
done by going through the process outlined to change the Community Declaration.
Q. Can Delegates work together and form voting groups?
A. Yes, Delegates can work together and form voting blocks to support issues. These would be
voluntary.
Q. Are there any other “Viable alternatives to redistricting that would substantially equalize
the voting power of Delegates”?
A. No, other than voting blocks, there are none that the Redistricting Committee has identified.
7
Appendix D
Legal questions on changing the HRCA documents
to redraw the Delegate district boundaries
1) What sections of what documents, including the Articles of Incorporation, the
Community Declaration and the Bylaws, will need to be changed?
2) Does the Declarant (currently Shea Homes) need to be given notice?
3) Must members vote at District meetings or could mail ballots be used?
4) Must all sub-associations agree to the change for the proposal to go forward?
5) Will the sub-associations have to amend their own sub-association documents?
6) Is this a change in a “material provision” which therefore requires notification of First
Mortgagees?
7) Does the failure of a First Mortgagee to have registered with the HRCA relieve the
HRCA from having to provide notice?
8) What happens if some First Mortgagees object?
9) What happens if FHA or VA don’t approve?
10) Do these changes violate any of the bond financing documents? Must the bond
holders be notified? What happens if they object?
11) Can this initiative go to court with a majority affirmative vote of at least 33.5% of the
lot holders?
8

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Destaque

$16 Pre-Paid Legal Employee Benefits Plan
$16 Pre-Paid Legal Employee Benefits Plan$16 Pre-Paid Legal Employee Benefits Plan
$16 Pre-Paid Legal Employee Benefits Plan
therog1
 
Taskit business presentation
Taskit business presentationTaskit business presentation
Taskit business presentation
taskit
 
2014 proposed budget delegates 101513 final
2014 proposed budget delegates 101513 final2014 proposed budget delegates 101513 final
2014 proposed budget delegates 101513 final
HRCA
 
Taskit business presentation
Taskit business presentationTaskit business presentation
Taskit business presentation
taskit
 

Destaque (20)

2016 Delegate Orientation
2016 Delegate Orientation2016 Delegate Orientation
2016 Delegate Orientation
 
2016 Delegate Orientation
2016 Delegate Orientation2016 Delegate Orientation
2016 Delegate Orientation
 
Case study: Artfinder
Case study:  ArtfinderCase study:  Artfinder
Case study: Artfinder
 
$16 Pre-Paid Legal Employee Benefits Plan
$16 Pre-Paid Legal Employee Benefits Plan$16 Pre-Paid Legal Employee Benefits Plan
$16 Pre-Paid Legal Employee Benefits Plan
 
Pavasaris
PavasarisPavasaris
Pavasaris
 
Lmt Catalog22111
Lmt Catalog22111Lmt Catalog22111
Lmt Catalog22111
 
Case study: artplayer.tv
Case study: artplayer.tvCase study: artplayer.tv
Case study: artplayer.tv
 
Taskit business presentation
Taskit business presentationTaskit business presentation
Taskit business presentation
 
Be somebody be yourself
Be somebody be yourselfBe somebody be yourself
Be somebody be yourself
 
Sergio
SergioSergio
Sergio
 
November book buzz
November book buzzNovember book buzz
November book buzz
 
Sales & Marketing
Sales & MarketingSales & Marketing
Sales & Marketing
 
2014 proposed budget delegates 101513 final
2014 proposed budget delegates 101513 final2014 proposed budget delegates 101513 final
2014 proposed budget delegates 101513 final
 
Case study: Archives at Getty Images
Case study: Archives at Getty ImagesCase study: Archives at Getty Images
Case study: Archives at Getty Images
 
Business Writing Skills Asmita
Business Writing Skills AsmitaBusiness Writing Skills Asmita
Business Writing Skills Asmita
 
2015 staff objectives delegate presentation jerry
2015 staff objectives delegate presentation jerry2015 staff objectives delegate presentation jerry
2015 staff objectives delegate presentation jerry
 
Name file something the public will understand
Name file something the public will understandName file something the public will understand
Name file something the public will understand
 
Digital R&D Fund for the Arts - Application process
Digital R&D Fund for the Arts - Application processDigital R&D Fund for the Arts - Application process
Digital R&D Fund for the Arts - Application process
 
Dfsk slideshare line up
Dfsk slideshare line upDfsk slideshare line up
Dfsk slideshare line up
 
Taskit business presentation
Taskit business presentationTaskit business presentation
Taskit business presentation
 

Semelhante a Redistricting Committee Report 2012

The pros and cons of rezoning a property(finished)
The pros and cons of rezoning a property(finished)The pros and cons of rezoning a property(finished)
The pros and cons of rezoning a property(finished)
RandyBett
 
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
EmpowerLA
 
Short Essay Analysis Assignment 2Due Date June 28, 2017B.docx
Short Essay Analysis Assignment 2Due Date June 28, 2017B.docxShort Essay Analysis Assignment 2Due Date June 28, 2017B.docx
Short Essay Analysis Assignment 2Due Date June 28, 2017B.docx
maoanderton
 
Presentation to House Redistricting Committee
Presentation to House Redistricting CommitteePresentation to House Redistricting Committee
Presentation to House Redistricting Committee
Mike
 
Education conference the good the bad and the ugly
Education conference the good the bad and the uglyEducation conference the good the bad and the ugly
Education conference the good the bad and the ugly
Jennifer Berkshire
 
Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docxDeanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
edwardmarivel
 
The Legislative BranchArticle ICongressTerms and Ses.docx
The Legislative BranchArticle ICongressTerms and Ses.docxThe Legislative BranchArticle ICongressTerms and Ses.docx
The Legislative BranchArticle ICongressTerms and Ses.docx
cdorothy
 

Semelhante a Redistricting Committee Report 2012 (20)

R2R Meeting 17 ppt
R2R Meeting 17 pptR2R Meeting 17 ppt
R2R Meeting 17 ppt
 
2011 Fairfax County Common Interest Community Educational Seminar
2011 Fairfax County Common Interest Community Educational Seminar2011 Fairfax County Common Interest Community Educational Seminar
2011 Fairfax County Common Interest Community Educational Seminar
 
R2R Meeting 17 pdf
R2R Meeting 17 pdfR2R Meeting 17 pdf
R2R Meeting 17 pdf
 
The pros and cons of rezoning a property(finished)
The pros and cons of rezoning a property(finished)The pros and cons of rezoning a property(finished)
The pros and cons of rezoning a property(finished)
 
2011 SAFE-D Fall Workshop - Overlapping Districts
2011 SAFE-D Fall Workshop - Overlapping Districts2011 SAFE-D Fall Workshop - Overlapping Districts
2011 SAFE-D Fall Workshop - Overlapping Districts
 
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
NC Checking Account Training 6-24-13
 
Hot Topics in Community Association Law
Hot Topics in Community Association LawHot Topics in Community Association Law
Hot Topics in Community Association Law
 
Short Essay Analysis Assignment 2Due Date June 28, 2017B.docx
Short Essay Analysis Assignment 2Due Date June 28, 2017B.docxShort Essay Analysis Assignment 2Due Date June 28, 2017B.docx
Short Essay Analysis Assignment 2Due Date June 28, 2017B.docx
 
ICSA Not-for-Profit Policy Update May 2015
ICSA Not-for-Profit Policy Update May 2015ICSA Not-for-Profit Policy Update May 2015
ICSA Not-for-Profit Policy Update May 2015
 
Strata Meetings and the New Laws
Strata Meetings and the New LawsStrata Meetings and the New Laws
Strata Meetings and the New Laws
 
Presentation to House Redistricting Committee
Presentation to House Redistricting CommitteePresentation to House Redistricting Committee
Presentation to House Redistricting Committee
 
Proposed radical changes a & c 1996
Proposed radical changes a & c 1996Proposed radical changes a & c 1996
Proposed radical changes a & c 1996
 
consumer protection act 1986.pptx
consumer protection act 1986.pptxconsumer protection act 1986.pptx
consumer protection act 1986.pptx
 
Education conference the good the bad and the ugly
Education conference the good the bad and the uglyEducation conference the good the bad and the ugly
Education conference the good the bad and the ugly
 
Expiry of operating agreements may 2015
Expiry of operating agreements  may 2015Expiry of operating agreements  may 2015
Expiry of operating agreements may 2015
 
Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docxDeanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
Deanna’s Input for Question 3As Chief Financial Management Of.docx
 
House Bill 516
House Bill 516House Bill 516
House Bill 516
 
R%20 case%20rules%20powerpoint%202015%20public
R%20 case%20rules%20powerpoint%202015%20publicR%20 case%20rules%20powerpoint%202015%20public
R%20 case%20rules%20powerpoint%202015%20public
 
The Legislative BranchArticle ICongressTerms and Ses.docx
The Legislative BranchArticle ICongressTerms and Ses.docxThe Legislative BranchArticle ICongressTerms and Ses.docx
The Legislative BranchArticle ICongressTerms and Ses.docx
 
Southwest California Legislative Coouncil February Agenda
Southwest California Legislative Coouncil February AgendaSouthwest California Legislative Coouncil February Agenda
Southwest California Legislative Coouncil February Agenda
 

Mais de HRCA

Mais de HRCA (20)

HRCA Backcountry Outdoor Center Amendment
HRCA Backcountry Outdoor Center AmendmentHRCA Backcountry Outdoor Center Amendment
HRCA Backcountry Outdoor Center Amendment
 
BOC.Web.CIP.pdf
BOC.Web.CIP.pdfBOC.Web.CIP.pdf
BOC.Web.CIP.pdf
 
HRCA Backcountry Outdoor Center Presentation
HRCA Backcountry Outdoor Center PresentationHRCA Backcountry Outdoor Center Presentation
HRCA Backcountry Outdoor Center Presentation
 
HRCA Hunt Harvest Photos
HRCA Hunt Harvest PhotosHRCA Hunt Harvest Photos
HRCA Hunt Harvest Photos
 
Hunt Harvest Photos
Hunt Harvest PhotosHunt Harvest Photos
Hunt Harvest Photos
 
June 19, 2018 - HRCA Delegate Meeting Budget Presentation
June 19, 2018 -  HRCA Delegate Meeting Budget PresentationJune 19, 2018 -  HRCA Delegate Meeting Budget Presentation
June 19, 2018 - HRCA Delegate Meeting Budget Presentation
 
HRCA 3D Archery Range Targets
HRCA 3D Archery Range TargetsHRCA 3D Archery Range Targets
HRCA 3D Archery Range Targets
 
2018 HRCA Delegate Orientation
2018 HRCA Delegate Orientation2018 HRCA Delegate Orientation
2018 HRCA Delegate Orientation
 
Photos for Proposed Verizon Cell Tower
Photos for Proposed Verizon Cell TowerPhotos for Proposed Verizon Cell Tower
Photos for Proposed Verizon Cell Tower
 
Photos for Proposed Verizon Cell Tower
Photos for Proposed Verizon Cell TowerPhotos for Proposed Verizon Cell Tower
Photos for Proposed Verizon Cell Tower
 
Photos for Proposed Verizon Cell Tower
Photos for Proposed Verizon Cell TowerPhotos for Proposed Verizon Cell Tower
Photos for Proposed Verizon Cell Tower
 
Verison Wireless Telecommunication Facility Proposal
Verison Wireless Telecommunication Facility ProposalVerison Wireless Telecommunication Facility Proposal
Verison Wireless Telecommunication Facility Proposal
 
HRCA Backcountry Wilderness Area Bench
HRCA Backcountry Wilderness Area BenchHRCA Backcountry Wilderness Area Bench
HRCA Backcountry Wilderness Area Bench
 
Northridge Construction Update 2018
Northridge Construction Update 2018Northridge Construction Update 2018
Northridge Construction Update 2018
 
2017 HRCA Delegate Orientation
2017 HRCA Delegate Orientation2017 HRCA Delegate Orientation
2017 HRCA Delegate Orientation
 
Northridge Renovation - Watch Our Progress - posted November 2017
Northridge Renovation - Watch Our Progress - posted November 2017Northridge Renovation - Watch Our Progress - posted November 2017
Northridge Renovation - Watch Our Progress - posted November 2017
 
Northridge Renovation - Watch Our Progress
Northridge Renovation - Watch Our ProgressNorthridge Renovation - Watch Our Progress
Northridge Renovation - Watch Our Progress
 
HRCA Budget Presentation | August 15, 2017
HRCA Budget Presentation | August 15, 2017HRCA Budget Presentation | August 15, 2017
HRCA Budget Presentation | August 15, 2017
 
Northridge Construction Update
Northridge Construction UpdateNorthridge Construction Update
Northridge Construction Update
 
Mundus Conceptual Plan Final Report for HRCA Backcountry Wilderness Area
Mundus Conceptual Plan Final Report for HRCA Backcountry Wilderness AreaMundus Conceptual Plan Final Report for HRCA Backcountry Wilderness Area
Mundus Conceptual Plan Final Report for HRCA Backcountry Wilderness Area
 

Último

Russian Escorts in Abu Dhabi 0508644382 Abu Dhabi Escorts
Russian Escorts in Abu Dhabi 0508644382 Abu Dhabi EscortsRussian Escorts in Abu Dhabi 0508644382 Abu Dhabi Escorts
Russian Escorts in Abu Dhabi 0508644382 Abu Dhabi Escorts
Monica Sydney
 
Competitive Advantage slide deck___.pptx
Competitive Advantage slide deck___.pptxCompetitive Advantage slide deck___.pptx
Competitive Advantage slide deck___.pptx
ScottMeyers35
 

Último (20)

Dating Call Girls inBaloda Bazar Bhatapara 9332606886Call Girls Advance Cash...
Dating Call Girls inBaloda Bazar Bhatapara  9332606886Call Girls Advance Cash...Dating Call Girls inBaloda Bazar Bhatapara  9332606886Call Girls Advance Cash...
Dating Call Girls inBaloda Bazar Bhatapara 9332606886Call Girls Advance Cash...
 
Private Call Girls Bidar 9332606886Call Girls Advance Cash On Delivery Service
Private Call Girls Bidar  9332606886Call Girls Advance Cash On Delivery ServicePrivate Call Girls Bidar  9332606886Call Girls Advance Cash On Delivery Service
Private Call Girls Bidar 9332606886Call Girls Advance Cash On Delivery Service
 
Bhubaneswar Call Girls Bhubaneswar 👉👉 9777949614 Top Class Call Girl Service ...
Bhubaneswar Call Girls Bhubaneswar 👉👉 9777949614 Top Class Call Girl Service ...Bhubaneswar Call Girls Bhubaneswar 👉👉 9777949614 Top Class Call Girl Service ...
Bhubaneswar Call Girls Bhubaneswar 👉👉 9777949614 Top Class Call Girl Service ...
 
Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'
Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'
Coastal Protection Measures in Hulhumale'
 
Call Girls Mehsana / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos and Number
Call Girls Mehsana / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos and NumberCall Girls Mehsana / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos and Number
Call Girls Mehsana / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos and Number
 
Call Girls Basheerbagh ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budget
Call Girls Basheerbagh ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budgetCall Girls Basheerbagh ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budget
Call Girls Basheerbagh ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budget
 
Russian Escorts in Abu Dhabi 0508644382 Abu Dhabi Escorts
Russian Escorts in Abu Dhabi 0508644382 Abu Dhabi EscortsRussian Escorts in Abu Dhabi 0508644382 Abu Dhabi Escorts
Russian Escorts in Abu Dhabi 0508644382 Abu Dhabi Escorts
 
Peace-Conflict-and-National-Adaptation-Plan-NAP-Processes-.pdf
Peace-Conflict-and-National-Adaptation-Plan-NAP-Processes-.pdfPeace-Conflict-and-National-Adaptation-Plan-NAP-Processes-.pdf
Peace-Conflict-and-National-Adaptation-Plan-NAP-Processes-.pdf
 
sponsor for poor old age person food.pdf
sponsor for poor old age person food.pdfsponsor for poor old age person food.pdf
sponsor for poor old age person food.pdf
 
2024 UN Civil Society Conference in Support of the Summit of the Future.
2024 UN Civil Society Conference in Support of the Summit of the Future.2024 UN Civil Society Conference in Support of the Summit of the Future.
2024 UN Civil Society Conference in Support of the Summit of the Future.
 
Genuine Call Girls in Salem 9332606886 HOT & SEXY Models beautiful and charm...
Genuine Call Girls in Salem  9332606886 HOT & SEXY Models beautiful and charm...Genuine Call Girls in Salem  9332606886 HOT & SEXY Models beautiful and charm...
Genuine Call Girls in Salem 9332606886 HOT & SEXY Models beautiful and charm...
 
Pakistani Call girls in Sharjah 0505086370 Sharjah Call girls
Pakistani Call girls in Sharjah 0505086370 Sharjah Call girlsPakistani Call girls in Sharjah 0505086370 Sharjah Call girls
Pakistani Call girls in Sharjah 0505086370 Sharjah Call girls
 
Delivery in 20 Mins Call Girls Malappuram { 9332606886 } VVIP NISHA Call Girl...
Delivery in 20 Mins Call Girls Malappuram { 9332606886 } VVIP NISHA Call Girl...Delivery in 20 Mins Call Girls Malappuram { 9332606886 } VVIP NISHA Call Girl...
Delivery in 20 Mins Call Girls Malappuram { 9332606886 } VVIP NISHA Call Girl...
 
Lorain Road Business District Revitalization Plan Final Presentation
Lorain Road Business District Revitalization Plan Final PresentationLorain Road Business District Revitalization Plan Final Presentation
Lorain Road Business District Revitalization Plan Final Presentation
 
Competitive Advantage slide deck___.pptx
Competitive Advantage slide deck___.pptxCompetitive Advantage slide deck___.pptx
Competitive Advantage slide deck___.pptx
 
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 32
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 322024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 32
2024: The FAR, Federal Acquisition Regulations, Part 32
 
AHMR volume 10 number 1 January-April 2024
AHMR volume 10 number 1 January-April 2024AHMR volume 10 number 1 January-April 2024
AHMR volume 10 number 1 January-April 2024
 
Vivek @ Cheap Call Girls In Kamla Nagar | Book 8448380779 Extreme Call Girls ...
Vivek @ Cheap Call Girls In Kamla Nagar | Book 8448380779 Extreme Call Girls ...Vivek @ Cheap Call Girls In Kamla Nagar | Book 8448380779 Extreme Call Girls ...
Vivek @ Cheap Call Girls In Kamla Nagar | Book 8448380779 Extreme Call Girls ...
 
Cheap Call Girls In Hyderabad Phone No 📞 9352988975 📞 Elite Escort Service Av...
Cheap Call Girls In Hyderabad Phone No 📞 9352988975 📞 Elite Escort Service Av...Cheap Call Girls In Hyderabad Phone No 📞 9352988975 📞 Elite Escort Service Av...
Cheap Call Girls In Hyderabad Phone No 📞 9352988975 📞 Elite Escort Service Av...
 
An Atoll Futures Research Institute? Presentation for CANCC
An Atoll Futures Research Institute? Presentation for CANCCAn Atoll Futures Research Institute? Presentation for CANCC
An Atoll Futures Research Institute? Presentation for CANCC
 

Redistricting Committee Report 2012

  • 2. Purpose of the Report  Delegates have questioned the uneven distribution of Lots between Districts that result in wide variations in voting power between Delegates.  Creating Districts that have a comparable number of Lots requires changing the Community Declaration.  The Committee has strived to research and document the steps, procedures, and expenses that this would involve. 2
  • 3. Redistricting Committee Recommends Against Initiating this Process:  Staggering potential costs to HRCA w/no certainty of a successful result  Substantial drain on staff resources  Difficulty and costly undertaking to determine the number & size of the proposed newly drawn districts  Overcoming considerable obstacles to educate & engage the community  Significant challenges in obtaining the agreement of all sub associations (if required)  Potentially overwhelming challenges in obtaining the approval of the required 67% of all Lots, or of even the 33.5% of Lots, that is required to initiate the judicial option  Only a marginal chance of success due to multiple expensive hurdles that must be successfully and timely overcome 3
  • 4. The current Delegate District structure adheres to the fundamental democratic principle of “one lot-one vote” upon which the HRCA Community Declaration is based. 4
  • 5. 5 Appendix A Redistricting - Steps 1-10 and associated tasks Time estimate Cost estimate Roadblocks 1A. Proposal by a Member(s), Delegate(s) or HRCA Board Member(s) to begin the process is delivered to and approved by the HRCA Board. 2 months none HRCA Board does not approve 1B. Establish funding for the project and build it into the budgets for successive years 6-15 months staff time Not funded by Board 2. Committee appointed by the HRCA Board: Feasibility study is begun. Committee will manage the process including: Defining the sections of the Declarations that need changing and Seeking legal advice in answer to many questions. Addressing the challenges with sub-associations Recommending how districts will be drawn, such as contiguous etc. 6-12 months to step #3 Legal (estimate) $200,000-$400,000 including step #3 but not step #7 or #8 3. Formal Resolution for the ballot question is written and the new district map redrawn. 1 month Map - (estimate) $24,000-$30,400+ 4. Mailing to all Lot owners and all sub-associations: The mailing includes the ballot question along with FAQ’s and the map showing the new Districts. Possibility of a 2nd notice reminder. 1 month Postage $30,030 + 2nd notice 5. District meetings for all existing districts including sub-associations. with 67% affirmative vote of lots and all sub-associations approval the amendment passes proceed to step 6 and the judicial option (step 8, judicial option) is not required with 10% of lots (quorum) voting and the majority opposing the amendment then it fails with at least 10% (quorum) voting and with a majority but not a 33.5% affirmative vote OR with less than 10% (quorum) voting - redo the election in an attempt to reach 33.5% affirmative vote and less that 33.5% negative so that step 8, the judicial option can be pursued up to 12 months Will HRCA cover these unknown costs including revisions to sub-association documents? 67% required including all sub- associations or 33.5% affirmative and less than 33.5% negative required for step 8 (judicial option) 6. Identify First Mortgage holders and notify: First Mortgage holders, Declarant, FHA and VA by Certified mail. Publish Public Notice in newspapers two times at least one week apart. 4 months $150,000 + newsp + certified mail 1st mortgage holders object 7. Determine whether the amendments violate the terms of the bond financing documents and if bond holders must approve the amendments. Notify bond holders if required. 1 month Legal review of bond documents Bond holders fail to agree 8. If initiative failed to get 67% but it passed with all sub-associations (if required) approval plus approval of 33.5% of all lots and less than 33.5% disapproval, and no objections from bond holders (if required) and from First Mortgagees within 60 days; file a petition with the court requesting the court to approve the proposed amendment. Then notify, in writing, within 10 days, all Unit Owners, the Declarant, First Mortgagees, FHA, and VA. possibly 12-24 months Unknown legal and court costs Judge’s decision is unknown 9. If initiative is successful record the amendment in the records of Douglas County. 1 month p.1 $11 + $5 per page 10. Amend the bylaws to be consistent if legal has identified any inconsistencies. 3-6 months Legal - unknown [1] See appendices A and C - Issues Requiring Legal Review [2] Includes plat research and based on $150-$190 an hour for 160 hours, but could take longer [3] $1 per mailing x 30,000 homes and 30 sub-associations = $30,030 [4] Requires Legal’s answer to: Must all sub-associations approve? [5] Requires Legal’s answer to: Can court proceedings begin with 33.5% approval and all sub-associations agreeing? [6] Requires Legal’s answer to: Is this a “material change” that requires First Mortgagees be notified? [7] From title company’s estimate of $5 per home x 30,000 homes = $150,000
  • 6. Appendix B Members of the Committee Greg Herman - District #17 - 166 lots Jim Freeman - District #30 - 368 lots Nancy Smith - District #62 - 197 lots Jed Caswall - District #112 - 298 lots Rick Werkheiser - from the HR community at large David Gundersen - withdrew 6
  • 7. Appendix C FAQ’s on “Viable alternatives to redistricting that would substantially equalize the voting power of Delegates”: Q. Can small districts merge? A. The Community Declaration states that “…each Delegate District shall elect one (1) Delegate…” (Section 4.4) This applies to both sub-associations and districts that are not sub- associations and so merging can only be done by going through the process outlined to change the Community Declaration. Q. Can large districts be split into separate, smaller districts? A. Most likely sub-associations would not agree to this but in addition, the Community Declaration states that “…each Delegate District shall elect one (1) Delegate…” (Section 4.4) This applies to both sub-associations and districts that are not sub-associations and so dividing can only be done by going through the process outlined to change the Community Declaration. Q. Can Delegates work together and form voting groups? A. Yes, Delegates can work together and form voting blocks to support issues. These would be voluntary. Q. Are there any other “Viable alternatives to redistricting that would substantially equalize the voting power of Delegates”? A. No, other than voting blocks, there are none that the Redistricting Committee has identified. 7
  • 8. Appendix D Legal questions on changing the HRCA documents to redraw the Delegate district boundaries 1) What sections of what documents, including the Articles of Incorporation, the Community Declaration and the Bylaws, will need to be changed? 2) Does the Declarant (currently Shea Homes) need to be given notice? 3) Must members vote at District meetings or could mail ballots be used? 4) Must all sub-associations agree to the change for the proposal to go forward? 5) Will the sub-associations have to amend their own sub-association documents? 6) Is this a change in a “material provision” which therefore requires notification of First Mortgagees? 7) Does the failure of a First Mortgagee to have registered with the HRCA relieve the HRCA from having to provide notice? 8) What happens if some First Mortgagees object? 9) What happens if FHA or VA don’t approve? 10) Do these changes violate any of the bond financing documents? Must the bond holders be notified? What happens if they object? 11) Can this initiative go to court with a majority affirmative vote of at least 33.5% of the lot holders? 8