How can we learn from customer experience to win the war for talent? From customer experience to candidate experience is the keynote address by Geert Martens on the Candidate Experience workshop organised by Vacature/Références on 30/11/2011 in Wemmel, Belgium.
1. From customer experience to c
candidate experience
@geert_martens, competence leader customer experience
Brussels, 30th November 2011
Prepared for the Vacature Candidate Experience Workshop
p f p p
2. Book us for experience inspiration:
k
• Conference speaking
C
• In
nspiration workshops
Hire us for experience transformation:
• Customer experience statement
C
• Candidate experience statement
C dd
• Emotional Signature
• Moments of Truth transformation
M
• Training & coaching
T
Geer
rt Martens, competence leader customer experience
• Mobile: +32 477 365 166
M
• Email: geert.martens@4cconsulting.com
• Twitter: @geert_martens
T g _
• Linkedin: http://be.linkedin.com/in/martensgeert
• Slideshare: http://www.slideshare.net/gmartens
3. 4C Consulting | Service por
g | p rtfolio
C t
Customer E
Experien M
i nce Management
t
Naïve‐to‐Natural | Emotional Signature | Moments of Truth | Mu
ulti‐channel Strategy | Unique Customer View | CRM Roadmap
Marketing Excellence Sales Exce
ellence Service Excellence
• Marketing Maturity Assessment • SFA Management & & Automation • Customer Service Automation
• Campaign Management & Automation • Sales Portfolio Manaagement • Self Service Strategy & Management
• Campaign Management Outsourcing
p g g g • Sales Middle Office • Complaints Handling
p g
• Marketing Resource Management • Training & Coachingg
Customer Insight
t Management
Intelligent reporting | Data Quality | D
Data Integration | Advanced Analytics
3
4. Content
01 Welcome to the age of the customer
to the age of the
02 What is a customer experie
p ence?
03 What is a great customer e
experience?
04 What is a candidate experie
ence?
05 Best practices
11. A customer e
experience is
em jou
jo orga
g
otio rn
n nizati
ns ey on
How a customer a journ of
ney with and about
feels and remembers interac
ctions an organization
12. Reason Conclus
sions
Emotion Action
The essential difference between emotion and reaso is
on
that emotion leads to action while reason leads to co
onclusions
Donald Calne
13. “Emotions color
Emotions color
the experience and,
p
more importantly,
how the experience
how the experience
will be remembered”
Donald A. Norman
D ld A N
Source: http://www.slideshare.net/koenatclaes/on-why-we-should-not-focus-on-ux
14. A customer e
experience is
em jou
jo orga
g
otio rn
n nizati
ns ey on
How a customer a journ of
ney with and about
feels and remembers interac
ctions an organization
15. Affection
Anger
Annoyance
Anxiety
Apathy
Arousal
Impacting
Awe
Cared for the way
the way you feel
Contempt
Curiosity
Boredom i about
Depression
Desire
Despair i i
Disappointment
Disgust At
At The brand
Dread
Ecstasy
Embarrassment
each i i
Empathy
Energized interaction, The
Envy
Euphoria emotions company
jou
jo
Fear
Focused
Fretful
Frustration
are i i
Gratitude evoked The
rn
n
Grief products
Guilt
Happiness
Hatred
Hope
i
i
ey
Horror The
Hostility service
Hurried
Hysteria
Indifference
Interest
Irritation
Jealousy
Loathing
i
i The people
Loneliness
Love
Lust
Misery Value
Neglected received
Pampered
Pity
Pleased
Pride
Rage Other
Regret
g customers
Remorse
Sadness
Satisfaction
Shame
Shock
Shyness
Sorrow
Yourself
Suffering
Surprise
Stressed
Trust
Valued
Wonder
Worry
Source: xprnc.be
17.
Make or Break moments
ak moments
“Moments of Truth”
s
18.
“Break” moments “Make” moments
An interaction within the customer journey at An interaction within the customer journey at
which you risk to strongly trigger value‐ which you have the opportunity to strongly
destroying emotions that will ruin the entire trigger value‐driving emotions that will boost the
experience entire experience
Objective: AVOID Objective: GRASP
One time: nothing,
Repeatedly: trust, secure, safe Emotional engagement
One time: nothing,
O ti thi
Emotional disconnect Repeatedly: unappreciated, not
valued, taken for granted
19. A customer e
experience is
em jou
jo orga
g
otio rn
n nizati
ns ey on
How a customer a journ of
ney with and about
feels and remembers interac
ctions an organization
20.
21. What is a
is a
great customer
g t
ex
xperience?
22. Deliberate
& valued
on a emotional level
Perfect performance EMOTIONALLY
Great custo
omer ENGAGED
on all Moments of CUSTOMERS
experienc
p ces
Truth
Consistent
across touchpoints
& customer lifecycle
24.
g
great
g
great
1
2
Potential over‐investment in less crucial interactions:
customer experience is not about trying to delight
all your customers all the time
27. Source: http://www.ere.net/2011/10/31/help‐identify‐the‐dumbest‐things‐recruiters‐do/
1 Not managing the
candidate experience
2.
2 Expecting dull position descriptions to attract
3.
3 Not taking advantage of employee referrals
Top 10
p 4.
4
5.
5
Not learning the business
Using the same recruiting process for different level
Using the same recruiting process for different level
jobs
dumbest things 6.
6 Making slow hiring decisions
7.
7 Assuming interviews are accurate
g
recruiters can do 8.
8 Using active sourcing approaches for passive
9.
candidates
9 Not prioritizing jobs
10. Not identifying job acceptance criteria
28. A candidate e
experience is
em jou
jo orga
g
otio rn
n nizati
ns ey on
How a candidate a journ of
ney with and about
feels and remembers interac
ctions an organization
he seeks to work for
29. Source: The candidate experience, november 2011, n=3.200
refused a job offer, not
because of job content or
74%
% remuneration but because it
did not feel OK.
Low management
wer 80%
Cur tl employed
rrently l d 79%
35‐44 years 79%
Changed jobs <6m 79%
Flanders 78%
30. Source: The candidate experience, november 2011, n=3.200
drivers for satisfaction with a
drivers for satisfaction with a
Top5
p5 recruitment interview are
purely emotion based.
purely emotion based
Interviewer shows
s genuine interest
Being treated
B i t t d i f i dl
d in a friendly way
Being treated in a personal way
Ma
ade to feel at ease
Welcome
ed in a warm way
31. A candidate e
experience is
em jou
jo orga
g
otio rn
n nizati
ns ey on
How a candidate a journ of
ney with and about
feels and remembers interac
ctions an organization
he seeks to work for
33. Source: The candidate experience, november 2011, n=3.200
About the customer
experience
Adjust sourcing approaches to
types of candidates
Generation Y prefers network
referrals as first source of job
opportunities
5.
5. 1.
1.
Onboarding Awareness Be creative
Attractive advertisement 4. 65%
2.
“Silent”
Exploration
Career site zone 46%
Recommendation 27% 3
3.
Intera
action
Contact on job fair 11%
Social media 10%
34. 5.
5. 1.
1.
Onboarding Awareness
Over 90% of candidates
f dd
4. who reach a career site do
2.
“Silent” not apply
Exploration
zone (Dr. John Sullivan &
(Dr John Sullivan &
Associates, 2010)
3
3.
Intera
action
33% of senior management
candidates do not rate the
recruitment process as easy and
recruitment process as easy and
intuitive
(The candidate experience,
Vacature & 4C Consulting, 2011)
35. Source: The candidate experience, november 2011, n=3.200
46% is said it to be (very) ea
asy
to reach someone for additional informat tion
1. 2. 3. 4.
Consistent Emotional Interactive Functional
Does your career site
Is your career site Is your career site a
evoke the desired Is your career site
aligned with your
g y communication
emotions of your
ti f functional?
f ti l?
brand positioning? vehicle?
candidate experience?
71% is satisfied with the information on the organisation
51% is sa
atisfied with the information on the job
36. 5.
5. 1.
1.
Onboarding Awareness
4.
2.
“Silent”
Exploration
zone
3
3.
Intera
action
Delays at any stage of the Lack of quality information
recruitment negatively about selection steps and
impact candidate methodology leads to rapid
reactions (CareerXroads,
reactions (CareerXroads abandonment
abandonment
2011) (CareerXroads, 2011)
37. Source: The candidate experience, november 2011, n=2.458
GOOD
Genuine interest
Personal Friendly
At ease
Time
Co
ompetences Warm
Well‐prepared Info on job
Info on job
Ho
onest feedback Info on organisation
Capabilities
IMPORTANCE 36%
Usefull feedback Keeps promises Information in Clear view
lin
ne with jobdescription
On time
Privacy issues
BAD
BAD PERFORMANCE 4 GOOD
38. 5.
5. 1.
1.
Onboarding Awareness
Only 3% of
companies breaks the
silence i th “ il t”
il in the “silent”
zone in a structured 4.
2.
way (Bissell, 2010) “Silent”
Exploration
zone
Best practice: A new‐
hire onboarding site
3
3.
Intera
action
Best practice: a new‐
hire package
39. 22% of staff turnover
occurs in the first 45 days
occurs in the first 45 days
of employment (The
Wynhurst Group 2011)
New employees with
structured onboarding
program were 58% more
program were 58% more 5.
5. 1.
1.
likely to be with the Onboarding Awareness
organization after three
y
years. (The Wynhurst
( y
Group 2011)
4.
2.
“Silent”
Exploration
zone
3
3.
Intera
action
40. A candidate e
experience is
em jou
jo orga
g
otio rn
n nizati
ns ey on
How a candidate a journ of
ney with and about
feels and remembers interac
ctions an organization
he seeks to work for
44. People will forget what you s
said,
people will forget what you d
people will forget what you d
did,
did,
but people will never forget how you made them feel.
Maya Angelou