SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 27
Baixar para ler offline
Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement
For use with the GRI 2002
Sustainability Reporting Guidelines
November 2002
GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Primary Authors
The Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement was developed by a multi-stakeholder
working group convened by the United Nations Environment Programme’s Tour
Operators’ Initiative (TOI) in partnership with the GRI. The Tour Operators’
Initiative (TOI) is a network of tour operators committed to introducing sustainability
into their business practices. The Initiative has been developed by tour operators for
tour operators with the support of the United Nations Environment Programme
(UNEP), the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization
(UNESCO) and the World Tourism Organization (WTO/OMT), who are also full
members of the Initiative. Under this international umbrella, tour operators who are
members of the Initiative are able to respond to international agendas while creating a
platform to develop ideas and projects to address the environmental, social, economic
and cultural aspects of sustainable development within the tourism sector.
The Initiative is voluntary, non-profit, and open to all tour operators, regardless of
their size and geographical location. The main requirement for membership is to sign
a commitment to adopt the principles of sustainable tourism and to implement these
principles through a corporate sustainable tourism policy. As part of this
commitment, members also agree to monitor and report their progress.
Contact
For any questions or comments about this supplement and its use as part of the GRI
framework, please contact:
GRI Secretariat
Phone: +31(0)20 531 00 00
E-mail: guidelines@globalreporting.org
Web: www.globalreporting.org
6 NOVEMBER 2002 i GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Preface
The GRI is pleased to release the pilot version of the Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement.
This document offers a set of supplemental sustainability performance indicators for use
in conjunction with the GRI 2002 Sustainability Reporting Guidelines (‘the Guidelines’).
The indicators were identified as specifically relevant to the tour operators’ sector
through an extensive multi-stakeholder process convened by GRI and the Tour Operators
Initiative (TOI).
In 2001, the GRI launched its supplement programme in response to consistent feedback
on the importance of sector-specific guidance built on the foundation of the Guidelines.
These supplements capture issues unique and essential to reporting in a specific sector,
but which may not appear in the Guidelines since they are relevant primarily for a
particular range of reporting organisations. Combining the Guidelines and the
supplements, such as the Tour Operators supplement , will support comparison of
reporting organisations both across sectors and within the context of their own sector.
This supplement adds to, but does not replace, the Guidelines’ section on performance
indicators.
The release of this document, and the Financial Services Sector Supplement, represents
the first step in GRI’s development of a complete set of sector-specific guidance. These
supplements will be developed over the next few years using multi-stakeholder processes
convened through GRI. The supplements are designed as complements to the Guidelines,
and outline performance measures of specific importance to a given sector The
Guidelines remain the starting point for any organisation seeking to use the GRI reporting
framework. The conditions for reporting “in accordance” as outlined in the 2002
Guidelines remain unchanged and are independent of whether or not supplements are
applied. Over the longer-term, the GRI Board of Directors will pursue the continued
integration of GRI products in a manner that maximises utility and efficiency for users of
the GRI reporting framework.
In keeping with the new due process structure for GRI documents approved by the GRI
Board of Directors, this supplement is being released as a pilot version. Under GRI due
process, documents under preparation by working groups are first released as exposure
drafts for consultation and testing. Next, when the document has reached an advanced
state of maturity (typically following up to a year or more of exposure drafts,
consultation, and testing), the document is reviewed for release as a pilot version. Such a
release signifies that a document has passed a serious review of its technical merits (both
the content and the process of development), and is ready for use by companies.
Following release of a pilot, the GRI will establish a structured feedback process under
the supervision of its Technical Advisory Council to capture the new learning that
emerges through actual use. This process will engage report makers and users to monitor
the reaction in the marketplace as the supplement receives active use. The structured
feedback process will focus heavily on the interaction between the Guidelines and the
6 NOVEMBER 2002 ii GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
supplements. The early experiences in using pilot versions will provide invaluable
feedback on the effective and practical integration of the family of GRI documents. At
the end of the structured feedback process, the Technical Advisory Council will present
its recommendations to the GRI Board of Directors and the supplement will be released
in its final version. GRI anticipates that this process will extend into 2004.
This due process is based on common practices used for setting other international
standards, and reflects the basic steps that have been applied to the development of the
GRI Guidelines since 1999. It should be noted, however, that even “final” versions will
continue to follow the cycle of review, testing, and improvement that is required of all
GRI documents, including the Guidelines. At the same time, GRI recognises the need for
stability and predictability in such products and will ensure that these objectives are
properly balanced with innovation.
GRI strongly encourages the uptake and use of this pilot supplement. Learning by doing
has been the key force driving continued improvement in the GRI reporting framework,
and the supplements will be no exception. This document represents the best thinking to
date, developed through the GRI multi-stakeholder process, on sustainability
performance indicators specific to the tour operators’ sector, and the culmination of
almost a year of work by the TOI and its many collaborators.
The GRI expresses its deep appreciation to the TOI members and all the stakeholders
who participated in the development of this supplement. The GRI looks forward to
continued engagement with the participants in this process and welcomes new
opportunities for developing supplements for other sectors.
6 NOVEMBER 2002 iii GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Table of Contents
Preface................................................................................................................................ ii
Introduction....................................................................................................................... 1
Reporting Using the GRI Framework................................................................................. 1
Applicability of This Supplement....................................................................................... 2
The Process for Developing This Supplement.................................................................... 2
Comments from the Multi-Stakeholder Working Group.................................................... 4
Next Steps........................................................................................................................... 4
Supplement Content ......................................................................................................... 7
Overview of the Indicator Framework................................................................................ 7
Linkages Between GRI 2002 Guidelines and the Tour Operators’ Supplement................ 8
Performance Indicators.................................................................................................. 10
Product Management and Development (PMD)............................................................... 10
Internal Management (IM)................................................................................................ 11
Labour practices........................................................................................................ 11
Health and safety....................................................................................................... 11
Training and education.............................................................................................. 11
Materials.................................................................................................................... 11
Waste.......................................................................................................................... 12
Supply Chain Management (SCM)................................................................................... 12
Customer Relations (CR).................................................................................................. 14
Cooperation with Destinations (D)................................................................................... 15
Partnerships............................................................................................................... 15
Community development............................................................................................ 15
Philanthropy and charitable donations..................................................................... 15
Table 1: Correlation of Guidelines and Tour Operators’ Supplement Indicators............. 17
Table 2: Analysis of Linkages: Guidelines and Tour Operators’ Specific Indicators...... 18
Annex 1: Members of the Multi-Stakeholder Working Group......................................... 19
Annex 2: Tour Operators’ Suppliers................................................................................. 20
Annex 3: Tour Operators’ Stakeholders ........................................................................... 22
6 NOVEMBER 2002 iv GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Introduction
Reporting Using the GRI Framework
The GRI reporting framework comprises three sets of documents. Together, this family
of documents represents a comprehensive framework for measuring and reporting on
economic, environmental, and social reporting at an organizational level.
• The GRI Sustainability Reporting Guidelines (the “Guidelines”)
• Sector and Issue supplements
• Technical protocols
The Guidelines represent the foundation upon which all other GRI reporting documents
are based, and outline core content that is broadly relevant to all organisations regardless
of size, sector, or location. All organisations seeking to report using the GRI framework
should use the Guidelines as the basis for their report, supported by the other GRI
documents as applicable.
In addition to the Guidelines, the GRI family of documents will also include a growing
number of sector supplements. While GRI believes that establishing a core set of
Guidelines is essential to achieve consistent and comparable reporting across diverse
organisations, GRI also recognises that a generic set of indicators may fail to capture
aspects of sustainability performance that are unique and crucial to a given industry
sector (e.g., mining, automotive, pharmaceuticals). The sector supplements will be
designed to provide indicators for use in conjunction with the Guidelines that highlight
the specific issues that characterise a given industry sector.
Lastly, GRI is also drafting technical protocols that offer specific guidance on various
technical aspects of reporting within the GRI framework, including expectations related
to measurement of specific indicators.
For more information on GRI or to obtain a copy of the 2002 GRI Guidelines or other
GRI documents, please visit the GRI website at: www.globalreporting.org. Use of the
GRI framework is voluntary.
6 NOVEMBER 2002 1 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Applicability of This Supplement
This sector supplement applies only to businesses dedicated to organising holiday
packages1
. This supplement was not designed to capture sector-specific aspects of the
various service industries associated with a package, such as transport, accommodation,
and other tourism services.
The Process for Developing This Supplement
The development of the tour operators’ sector-specific performance indicators had to take
into account three main considerations.
First, the supplemental indicators had to complement the performance indicators
contained in the 2002 Guidelines. Therefore, the supplement aimed to capture issues that
were either:
• Essential components of sustainability unique to tour operators; or
• Relevant to numerous sectors, but of critical importance to tour operators’
sustainability performance.
The second consideration was the recognition of the ‘middle man’ role of tour operators
in the tourism industry. Tour operators don’t deliver services or produce physical
products. Clearly defining the boundaries of responsibility was therefore considered a
necessary first step in the process.
Lastly, a final consideration was that the lack of examples of sustainability reports in the
sector meant that the performance indicators could not be based on existing practices.
The Multi-Stakeholder Working Group (MSWG) that revised the performance indicators,
included representatives from:
• Civil society organisations (non-profit advocacy groups, consumers’ and trade
unions);
• Local authorities and tourism boards;
• Tour operators’ suppliers (accommodation, cruise liners, airlines, ground
transport); and
1 According to the European Commission, a package is a pre-arranged combination of not fewer than two
of the following when sold or offered for sale at an inclusive price and when the service covers a period of
more than twenty-four hours or includes overnight accommodation:
a) transport
b) accommodation
c) other tourism services not ancillary to transport or accommodation and accounting for a significant
proportion of the package.
6 NOVEMBER 2002 2 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
• Tour operators selected from among the members of the Tour Operators’
Initiative.
Two co-chairs—one business and one non-business representative—were elected to
ensure that all perspectives were equally and properly integrated during the development
of the supplement. The two co-chairs, Nico Visser of Travel Unie Nederland and Graham
Gordon of Tearfund, facilitated the meetings of the MSWG. A GRI-TOI Reporting
Committee consisting of a GRI liaison, a TOI representative, the two MSWG Co-Chairs,
and a UNEP representative oversaw the process. The work of the MSWG was co-
ordinated by UNEP, which also acts as the TOI Secretariat.
The process began with an advisory meeting in September 2001 in Paris that brought
together tour operators and their direct stakeholders to agree on which actions and
decisions in the preparation and delivery of the holiday package have an environmental,
social, and/or economic influence or impact, thereby setting the boundaries of
responsibility for reporting. The participants in the advisory meeting recognised that a
clear and shared agreement on ‘how far’ a tour operator could go in improving the
sustainability of its product was a necessary pre-requisite to beginning a discussion on
performance indicators.
Following the meeting, UNEP and GRI invited a number of tour operators and
stakeholders to form the MSWG. Each member was selected based on their demonstrated
interest and competence in this subject, and readiness to engage in the process. Efforts
were also made to ensure geographical balance amongst the participants. See Annex 1 for
a complete list of the members of the MSWG.
The indicators were developed over the course of three meetings of the MSWG (16
November 2001, 18-19 February and 25-26 April 2002). During the first consultation the
group focused on identifying the sustainability issues specific to the tour operators’
sector, and not sufficiently addressed by the Guidelines. This ‘gap analysis’ brought to
light a number of suggestions for indicators to supplement those in the 2002 Guidelines.
The meeting resulted in the first draft of the sector specific indicators for tour operators.
The draft was further discussed and developed at the second meeting of the MSWG in
February 2002. Following the third meeting in April 2002, the MSWG agreed to the
content of the final draft for submission to the GRI Board of Directors. The final
document was submitted in June 2002 for review at the 20 June meeting of the GRI
Board of Directors.
The drafting process was also designed to encourage input from other stakeholders and
tour operators. Each draft of the supplement was posted on the TOI website with a direct
link from the GRI web site for two months. In addition, copies were sent to key
organisations and individuals with requests for comments. All comments received were
discussed during the consultations, as well as posted on the TOI website.
6 NOVEMBER 2002 3 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Comments from the Multi-Stakeholder Working Group
In preparing the Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement, it was necessary to elaborate on
certain aspects of reporting that are not fully developed within the core Guidelines. This
is particularly true for the category of Supply Chain Management. These differences have
significant bearing on the possibility of effectively comparing reports from companies
that use only the core GRI Guidelines, to tour operators that also use this sector
supplement.
Early in the process, members of the MSWG agreed to include qualitative performance
indicators as well as quantitative indicators. A number of the indicators chosen for the
supplement are qualitative measures that provide detailed information on implementation
of the reporting organisation’s policies. This is consistent with the approach taken to
numerous performance indicators in the 2002 Guidelines.
Lastly, it should be noted that the indicators in this supplement are the product of a multi-
stakeholder consultative process. Therefore, while each indicator represents a commonly
agreed upon position, it does not necessarily reflect the specific position of each
individual participant. The MSWG acknowledges that both the process for developing
this supplement and the selected indicators do not fully cover the expectations of each
and every stakeholder.
This sector supplement was undertaken based on the understanding that virtually all
dimensions of the tour operating business have environmental, economic, and social
impacts.
Next Steps
This supplement is the result of a nine-month process that included numerous meetings
and on-line exchanges. All participants in the process recognised that there are some
limitations to this process and in particular the difficulty of bringing into the discussion
feedback generated through experience, as this requires a much longer time. Furthermore,
all participants recognise that understanding of sustainable development and sustainable
performance continuously evolves.
The members of the MSWG were unanimous in calling for regular revisions to the tour
operators’ sector-specific performance indicators. Future revisions should also
incorporate practical experience gained in using this first set as well as evolving
understanding of sustainable development and performance.
Most participants indicated (through a questionnaire circulated during the third
consultation) that indicators should be reviewed in two to three years’ time. Key in this
revision process will be the experience gained by tour operators in using the GRI 2002
Sustainability Reporting Guidelines and the sector-specific indicators.
6 NOVEMBER 2002 4 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
It was therefore proposed to initiate a pilot test of the GRI 2002 Sustainability Reporting
Guidelines and the Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement, involving members of the Tour
Operators’ Initiative. Many of the stakeholders involved in the process confirmed their
interest in supporting this effort.
The pilot test would build awareness and know-how of reporting principles. Secondly, it
would facilitate the revisions and improvement of the indicators through the generation of
various outputs, among which may be:
• Structured feedback for revision of the indicators based on a common survey to
be developed with the Global Reporting Initiative.
• A user’s manual containing guidance notes to a number of indicators based on
collected best practices, as well as measurement protocols.
• Recommendations on most effective reporting formats for the sector.
• A proposed model suitable to the tour operators’ sector for organising the internal
flow of information to support reporting efforts.
• Recommendations of the links between the core Guidelines and tour operator-
specific indicators.
• A proposed classification of core and advanced indicators for the tour operators’
sector.
6 NOVEMBER 2002 5 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Where to send feedback on this supplement:
Any comments and suggestions on how to improve this current version of the Tour
Operators’ Sector Supplement should be addressed to BOTH the:
TOI Secretariat
c/o United Nations Environment Programme
Division of Technology, Industry and Economics
Tour Mirabeau - 39-43, quai André Citroën
75739 Paris Cedex 15 - France
Fax: +33-1-44371474
E-mail: unep.tie@unep.fr
Global Reporting Initiative Secretariat
Keizersgracht 209
P.O. Box 10039
1001 EA Amsterdam
The Netherlands
Tel: +31 (0) 20 531 00 00
Fax: +31 (0) 20 531 00 31
E-mail: guidelines@globalreporting.org
6 NOVEMBER 2002 6 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Supplement Content
General Notes
A number of general issues should be taken into account when using
this supplement:
1. Definitions of the term “social” vary widely amongst different groups. In the
context of tour operators, it is important to give specific consideration to the
role of culture in social sustainability, and ensure that reporting on “social
performance” reflects tour operators’ impacts and contributions to the cultures
in which they operate.
2. The supplement does not include a definition of “destination.” The MSWG
was unable to reach agreement on this question, and specifically the
geographical scope implied in the term. The definition not only varies among
tour operators, but the same tour operator uses the term “destination” to refer
to a town, a country, a region, or a continent interchangeably. It is therefore
requested that reporting organisations clearly state the definition of
‘destination’ as used in the preparation of their report.
3. During the process of developing the supplement, the participants began to
develop ‘guidance notes’ listing recommended best practices for specific
indicators, as well as more specific instruction on the sustainability issues to
be taken into account. The members of the MSWG felt that these guidance
notes should be further developed based on experience, and therefore were not
included in this supplement. The draft notes are posted on the TOI web site at
www.toinitiative.org/reporting/reporting.htm. It should be noted that these
guidance notes have not been officially reviewed and approved as part of the
GRI framework and represent the experience and recommendations of the
TOI. For technical guidance related to reporting within the GRI framework,
please see the GRI website (www.globalreporting.org) or contact the GRI
Secretariat.
Overview of the Indicator Framework
The performance indicators drafted by the MSWG request information on tour operators’
performance both in terms of policies and management systems as well as areas of
impact. The indicators are divided into categories that reflect the life cycle of the holiday
product: from the planning stage, to the development and delivery of the product. The
indicators have been grouped under five categories:
6 NOVEMBER 2002 7 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
• Product management and development (PMD) includes actions related to the
choice of the destination as well as the type of services to be included (e.g., the
use of train vs. plane).
• Internal management (IM) reflects all the operations and activities that take place
in the headquarters or country offices (e.g., use of office supplies, production of
brochures, direct employment).
• Supply chain management (SCM) addresses actions related to the selection and
contracting of service providers.
• Customer relations (CR) summarises the actions taken to deal with customers, not
only with regards to the responsibility to serve them and reply to their comments,
but also the opportunity to provide information and raise consumer awareness
regarding sustainability.
• Co-operation with destination (D) includes all activities and decisions related to
destinations that tour operators make beyond the production and delivery of their
holiday package. This mainly includes efforts made by tour operators to engage in
dialogues with destination operators about the impacts of tour packages, and
philanthropic activities.
The first four categories cover actions and decisions that tour operators make in
preparation of the holiday package. Through these actions and decisions, tour operators
have either a direct impact on sustainability (e.g., managing office supplies), or a
significant influence on sustainability (e.g., through the supply chain). The fifth area
covers efforts to address product impacts at the destination.
Within these five categories, the indicators have been further grouped in the three
sustainability headings where the MSWG felt relatively clear boundaries between
environmental, social, and economic performance exist (e.g., internal management). In
some categories, the indicators have not been separated into economic, environmental,
and social, since the operators could not make a distinction between these issues within
their business operations.
Linkages Between GRI 2002 Guidelines and the Tour Operators’
Supplement
When using the indicators in the Guidelines, tour operators should take into account that
some overlaps exist between the general set of indicators in the Guidelines and those in
the Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement. In many cases, the sector supplement represents
a more specific dimension of a general indicator that appears in the Guidelines. The
6 NOVEMBER 2002 8 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
overlapping and complementary areas are highlighted in Table 1. An analysis of those
linkages and suggested approaches for use of the indicators are provided in Table 2.
Specific points to note in the use of this supplement are:
• This supplement contains a number of indicators that request specific information
on policies and procedures that overlap with elements in the Guidelines section on
Governance Structure and Management Systems (Part C, Section 3). The general
subject of the inquiries is the same, but the indicators in this supplement are more
directly focused on the policy and procedural concerns important to measuring
sustainability performance in the tour operators’ sector.
• To facilitate responding to the supply chain management indicators, this
supplement includes a classification of suppliers specific to tour operators (see
Annex 2).
• When reporting on stakeholder involvement (Guidelines, Part C, Section 2.9)
reporting companies should refer to the stakeholders listed in this supplement (see
Annex 3). This list is consistent with the general stakeholder structure presented
in the Guidelines, but is further refined to reflect the specific range of
stakeholders relevant to the tour operators’ sector.
6 NOVEMBER 2002 9 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Performance Indicators
PRODUCT MANAGEMENT AND DEVELOPMENT (PMD)
PMD1. Indicate percentage of reporting organisation’s business (by
passengers carried) and market share in operating destinations.
PMD2. Describe policies on selecting, developing and deselecting destinations
based on environmental, social and economic issues.
PMD3. Describe key environmental, economic and social issues identified in
destinations and types of information gathered2.
Issues may include:
Environment: water, wastewater, energy, and transport infrastructures;
hazardous and solid waste disposal; air and water quality; land-use and
biodiversity conservation; local environmental management structures.
Socio-economic: respect for human rights (including indigenous and tribal
people); compliance with International Labour Organization (ILO)
conventions on child and forced labour; freedom of association; non-
discrimination; programmes to combat sexual exploitation of children and to
combat and mitigate the social impacts of HIV/AIDS; citizen participation in
planning process.
PMD4. Indicate percentage of destinations in which organisation operates for
which issues (PMD3) have been identified, and percentage of reporting
organisation’s business this represents (by passengers carried).
PMD5. Describe types of approaches taken in gathering information (PMD3)
and rationale for applying an approach to a given destination.
Approaches include own research, third party report, customer feedback,
destination self-assessment, stakeholders’ consultation, dialogue with
competitors. Specify stakeholders approached.
PMD6. Indicate length of time over which this information (PMD3) has been
collected, and the frequency with which it is updated.
PMD7. Quantify overall economic, environmental, and social impacts of typical
holiday products.
2
A draft guidance note providing additional information is available for reporting companies on the Tour Operators’
Initiative web site: www.toinitiative.org
6 NOVEMBER 2002 10 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
PMD8. Describe changes in design of holiday packages and other actions to
address key environmental, economic and social issues (see PMD3) of
destinations.
PMD9. Describe Measures to maximise economic benefits to destinations.
INTERNAL MANAGEMENT (IM)
Labour practices:
IM1. Provide evidence of recruiting local residents (including destination
nationals) for destination posts including management positions.
Health and safety:
IM2. Describe existence of policies and programmes to address the physical
and mental well-being of staff at headquarters and destinations.
Training and education:
IM3. Describe types and mechanisms of training on environmental, social
and economic issues by category of employee.
Include destination representatives, senior management, middle management,
professional, technical, administrative, production, and maintenance.
IM4. Describe policies and actions in place to accommodate cultural
customs, traditions and practices of staff throughout the organisation.
Materials:
IM5. Describe policies to minimise the environmental impacts associated
with the production, distribution and use of promotional materials and
customer documentation.
IM6. Indicate total quantity (tonnes or kg) of material used by type (e.g.,
paper, plastic) and environmental quality (e.g., recycled content), for the
production of promotional materials and customer documentation.
IM7. Indicate percentage of promotional materials and customer
documentation that are produced in accordance with an environmental
standard.
Specify standard.
6 NOVEMBER 2002 11 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Waste:
IM8. Describe policies and targets for redistribution, reuse and recycling of
promotional materials.
IM9. Indicate percentage of total travel retailers that agree to adopt policies
and practices on reuse and recycling of promotional materials.
Also refer to Supply Chain Management section.
SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT (SCM)
SCM1. Describe the supply chain management policy, objectives and targets
on environmental, social, and economic performance.
State the use of supplier prioritisation and screening criteria.
SCM2. Describe processes through which suppliers, by type, are consulted
during development and implementation of the supply chain
management policy, described in SCM1.
SCM3. Describe issues identified through supplier consultation and actions to
address them.
SCM4. Describe processes through which suppliers, by type, are engaged in
the implementation of the supply chain management policy, described
in SCM1.
Processes include: One way communication (e.g., questionnaires), two-way
communication (e.g., information exchange), active co-operation (e.g.,
supplier training), rewards and recognition for high performers.
SCM5. State joint actions taken with suppliers, by type, to support
improvements in suppliers own environmental and social performance.
SCM6. Describe progress in achieving objectives and targets related to supply
chain policy.
SCM7. Indicate percentage of suppliers, by type, subject to supply chain
management policy.
SCM8. Indicate percentages of suppliers, by type, subject to supply chain
policy that have a published sustainability policy, implemented a
6 NOVEMBER 2002 12 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
sustainability management system and/or have a staff person with
management responsibility for corporate sustainability.
SCM9. State types of information requested from suppliers, by type, on their3
:
(a) Environmental practices and performance.
Include: Materials, water, energy, purchasing, solid waste, hazardous waste,
effluents, emissions, transport, land-use and biodiversity.
(b) Social practices and performance.
Include: Community and staff development, indigenous and tribal people’s
rights, formal employment contracts, social security, working conditions
according to ILO Convention 172, equal treatment, non-discrimination,
recognition of independent trade unions and application of collective
bargaining agreements, health and safety committees, policies excluding child
labour as defined by ILO, programmes to combat commercial sexual
exploitation of children, and to combat and mitigate the social impacts of
HIV/AIDS.
SCM10. Indicate percentage of suppliers, by type, subject to supply chain
management policy that provided the requested information.
SCM11. Indicate percentage of suppliers, by type, subject to supply chain
management policy whose environmental, social and economic
performance has been reported.
Through, for example:
• Supplier self declaration;
• Spot checks by reporting organization;
• Environmental and social audits;
• Certification schemes (including eco labels);
• Third party verification (state if verifier is accredited, and by whom).
SCM12. State actions taken by the reporting organisation in response to
suppliers reported performance (as per SCM 11), by type of suppliers.
Include incentives and rewards.
SCM13. State actions to inform suppliers of customers’ requirements.
SCM14. State contracting policy and how it is communicated to suppliers.
Include negotiating terms and conditions for payment, cancellation and
compensation of contracts with suppliers.
3
A draft guidance note providing additional information is available for reporting companies on the Tour
Operators’ Initiative web site www.toinitiative.org
6 NOVEMBER 2002 13 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
SCM15. Describe joint initiatives with suppliers to improve environmental, social
and economic conditions in destinations.
SCM16. State benefits for the reporting organisation from implementing the
sustainable supply chain policy.
CUSTOMER RELATIONS (CR)
CR1. Describe tools and measures used by reporting organisation to raise
the awareness of consumers of suppliers’ environmental, social and
economic performance.
Indicate joint efforts with suppliers, NGOs, national tourism organisations
(NTOs), and authorities in destinations; main themes communicated; and
specify the moment of the holiday experience, from selection to return, at
which communication took place.
CR2. Describe tools and measures used by reporting organisation to raise
the awareness of consumers of destinations’ environmental, social and
economic issues.
Indicate joint efforts with suppliers, NGOs, NTOs, and authorities in
destinations; main themes communicated; and specify the moment of the
holiday experience, from selection to return, at which communication took
place.
CR3. Describe tools and measures used by reporting organisation to raise
the awareness of consumers of sustainable holiday-making.
Indicate joint efforts with suppliers, NGOs, NTOs, and authorities in
destinations; main themes communicated; and specify the moment of the
holiday experience, from selection to return, at which communication took
place.
CR4. Describe means to invite customers’ feedback on economic,
environmental, and social issues related to the holiday product and
actions taken to respond to feedback.
CR5. Indicate percentage of total feedback received, related to economic,
environmental and social issues.
Break down feedback in terms of positive and negative and main issues
covered.
6 NOVEMBER 2002 14 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
CR6. Provide evidence of consultation with destination stakeholders and
suppliers on how the destination and services are portrayed to
customers.
CR7. Indicate number of complaints from destinations’ stakeholders and
holiday-makers regarding misleading and inaccurate representation of
destinations.
Indicate actions taken to address complaints.
COOPERATION WITH DESTINATIONS (D)
Partnerships:
D1. Describe ways reporting organisation engages with destination
stakeholders to address issues, including those identified in PMD34
.
Include information exchange, awareness raising, consultation, dialogues and
incentives provided.
Community development:
D2. Describe measures taken to identify and offer commercial opportunities
and assistance to non-contracted suppliers that support community
development.
Philanthropy and charitable donations:
D3. Describe procedures and criteria for selecting projects and
organisations to which philanthropic and charitable donations are made.
D4. Indicate total funds (in cash and estimated value of in-kind
contributions) for conservation and social development projects.
Identify:
• Sources (corporate budget, consumers’ contributions);
• Type (cash, in-kind);
• Distribution of funds to conservation and community development projects
and organisations;
• Location of projects/organisations receiving the funds (in operating
destinations, headquarters and international).
4
A draft guidance note providing additional information is available for reporting companies on the Tour
Operators’ Initiative web site, www.toinitiative.org
6 NOVEMBER 2002 15 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
D5. Describe programmes for philanthropic and charitable donations in
relation to conservation and community development projects.
D6. Provide evidence of benefits generated (in D4 and D5), particularly at
destinations, in support of community development, biodiversity
conservation and other social, economic and environmental
improvements at destinations.
6 NOVEMBER 2002 16 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Table 1: Correlation of Guidelines and Tour Operators’ Supplement
Indicators
Product Management and Development
GRI 2002 Guidelines
Tour Operators’ Supplement
Economic Environmental Social
PMD1, PMD2, PMD3, PMD4, PMD5,
PMD6, PMD7, PMD8, PMD9
EC13* EN7, EN14, EN15, EN18*,
EN25*, EN26* , EN27*,
EN28*, EN30*, EN35*
HR2, HR12*, HR13*,
HR14*
SO1
Internal Management
GRI 2002 GuidelinesTour Operators’
Supplement Economic Environmental Social
IM1, IM2, IM3, IM4,
IM5, IM6, IM7, IM8,
IM9
EC1, EC2,
EC5, EC6,
EC7, EC8,
EC9,
EC12*,
EN1, EN2, EN3, EN4, EN5,
EN6, , EN7, EN8, EN9, EN10,
EN11, EN12, EN13, EN16,
EN17*, EN19*, EN20*, EN21*,
EN22*, EN23*, EN24*, EN27*,
EN29*, EN31*, EN32*, EN34*,
EN35*
LA1, LA2, LA3, LA4, LA5, LA6, LA7,
LA8, LA9, LA10, LA11, LA12*, LA13*,
LA14*, LA15*, LA16*, LA17*
HR1, HR4, HR5, HR6, HR7, HR8*,
HR9*, HR10*, HR11*, HR12*,
SO2, SO3, SO4*, SO5*, SO6* SO7*
Supply Chain Management
GRI 2002 Guidelines
Tour Operators’ Supplement
Economic Environmental Social
SCM1, SCM2, SCM3, SCM4, SCM5, SCM6, SCM7, SCM8, SCM9,
SCM10, SCM11, SCM12, SCM13, SCM14, SCM15, SCM16
EC3, EC4,
EC11*
EN 30*, EN33*,
EN35*
HR2, HR3
Customer Relations
GRI 2002 GuidelinesTour Operators’
Supplement Economic Environmental Social
CR1, CR2, CR3, CR4, CR5,
CR6, CR7
PR1, PR2, PR3, PR4*, PR5*, PR6*,
PR7* PR8*, PR9*, PR10*, PR11*
Co-operation with Destination
GRI 2002 Guidelines
Tour Operators’ Supplement
Economic Environmental Social
D1, D2, D3, D4, D5, D6 EC10
* Denotes an additional (rather than core) indicator in the 2002 Guidelines.
Note: Some Guidelines indicators correspond with more than one Tour Operators' Category
6 NOVEMBER 2002 17 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Table 2: Analysis of Linkages: Guidelines and Tour Operators’
Specific Indicators
Guidelines
Indicators
Tour
Operators
Indicators
Comments Suggestions
EC1 and
EC2
PMD1
EC1 and EC2 are an extension of PMD1. The tour
operators’ specific indicator uses the traditional tour
operators’ unit measure ‘passenger/destination’ rather
than turnover.
Combine the three indicators.
EC12 PMD9
The tour operators’ specific indicator PMD9 reflects
the pro-active actions taken by tour operators to
maximise and enhance their positive economic
benefits at the destination level.
Cross-link the replies to the
two indicators.
EC12
PMD7 and
PMD9
EC12 is partially included in PMD7 and PMD9.
Focus on the two aspects
highlighted by PMD7 and
PMD9.
EN1 and
EN2
IM5, IM6
and IM7
Tour operators specific indicators IM5, IM6 and IM7
address specifically the material used related to the
production and distribution of tour operators’
promotional material and customer documentation,
that represent a major source of solid waste.
Complement the replies to
EN1 and EN2 with the specific
answers addressing
promotional material and
customer documentation.
EN11 IM8 and IM9
Tour operators’ specific indicators IM8 and IM9
address specifically waste management practices
related to the production and distribution of tour
operators’ promotional material and customer
documentation that represent a major source of solid
waste.
Complement the information
provided in EN11 with the
specific data addressing
promotional material and
customer documentation, in
IM8 and IM9.
EN33 and
HR3
SCM1 to
SCM16
The Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement provides a
more detailed and sector-specific set of indicators
addressing environmental, social and economic
aspects of supply chain management.
Focus on SCM1 to SCM16
and indicate the links with
EN33 and HR3
HR2 and
HR3
SCM9
SCM9 provides the opportunity to report on all types of
information requested from suppliers on environmental
and social issues, while HR2 and HR3 focus more
specifically on suppliers’ human rights performance.
Complement information
provided in SCM9 with
information provided in HR2
and HR3.
HR2 PMD2
PMD2 provides tour operators the opportunity to report
on their general destination selection policy, while HR2
focuses in particular on human rights issues.
Complement information
provided in PMD2 with
information provided in HR2.
SO1
PMD1 to
PMD9
The Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement provides a
more detailed set of indicators reflecting tour
operators’ performance in stakeholder engagement
and actions taken to minimise negative impacts and
influence on destinations through product development
and management.
Focus on PMD1 to PMD9, and
indicate the links with SO1.
EC13,
EN14, and
HR3
PMD7 EC13, EN14 and HR3 are covered under PMD 7 Cross reference responses.
EC10,
EC12, HR2
and SO1
D1 to D6
The Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement provides a
more specific set of indicators that facilitate the
illustration of conservation and philanthropic
investments to benefit the destination, beyond the
company.
Focus on D1 to D6, and
indicate the links with EC10,
EC12, HR2 and SO1.
6 NOVEMBER 2002 18 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Annex 1: Members of the Multi-Stakeholder Working Group
Last First Organisation
Ashton Jane First Choice Holidays
Austria Gregorio City of Puerto Princesa
Bah Adama Gambia Tourism Concern
Belau Dirk International Labour Organization (Observer)
Bermann Ellen Viaggi del Ventaglio
Botet i Pont Ramon Lloret de Mar (Spain – Costa Brava)
Carroll-Simon Elizabeth International Hotel & Restaurant Association
Cresswell Carolyn P&O Princess Cruises plc
Dietsch Klaus Studiosus Reisen
Fletcher Karen International Hotel Environment Initiative (Observer)
Gordon Graham Tearfund
Guglielmi Gabriele Filcams CGIL Nazionale (Italy)
Hess Kaspar Hotelplan
Hügel Jens Union International des Transports Routier (IRU)
Hustache Bennani Isabelle Dynamic Tours
Jackson Jan British Airways Holidays
Le Dantec Alexandre Accor Tours
Lotta Sand Thomson Travel
Museler Andreas LTU-Touristik GmbH (formerly ITS Reisen)
Nawaz Homar Tourist Board of Sri Lanka
Newton Victoria British Airways
Nico Visser Travel Unie Nederland
Őrnek Yusuh Vasco Travel
Orsoni Pierre Telefono Blu, SOS Turismo Consumatori
Paul Matell Scandinavian Leisure Group
Richards Keith Association of British Travel Agents
Selanniemi Tom Aurinkomatkat-Suntours
Sweeting Jamie Conservation International
van Beurden Jan Lions Dive & Beach Resort
Wilson James Six Continents/BASS
Woolford Justin WWF UK
6 NOVEMBER 2002 19 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Annex 2: Tour Operators’ Suppliers
“Packaging” Holiday Services
Transport Services
Transport to and from embarkation and disembarkation points:
• Transport terminals: airports, stations, terminals etc.
• Pickup services: taxi, coach
Transport to and from destinations and transfers within destinations:
• Inbound Tour Operator services
• Air
• Rail
• Coach
• Taxi
• Ferry
Accommodation Services
• Hotels
• Self-catering
• Pension/Bed & Breakfast
• Holiday house/villa/chalet
• Campsites
Leisure Services
• Inbound tour operators and/or local agents offering natural and cultural
excursions
• Sport and adventure tourism service providers
• Guiding Services
• Catering Services
• Retailers
Cruise Lines
Producing Holiday Brochures, Promotion Material and Travel Documents
Graphic Designers
Printing Services
Distribution Services and Promotions Mailing Houses
Retailing Holidays
Travel Agencies
(continued)
6 NOVEMBER 2002 20 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Internal Corporate Management
Obtaining Office Space
• Building design and construction services
• Building material suppliers
• Real estate agents and rental services
Daily Business Processes
• Water supply and waste water disposal services
• Energy suppliers
• Waste disposal services
• Telecommunication and IT services
• Suppliers of office equipment, furniture, paper and other supplies
• Cleaning services
• Catering services
• Gardening/landscaping services
• Couriers
• Vehicle renting and parking services
• Management and financial consultants
• PR and communication agencies
• Financial institutions
6 NOVEMBER 2002 21 GRI (2002)
PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT
Annex 3: Tour Operators’ Stakeholders
Tour Operators’ Stakeholders in Countries of Origin and Destinations
Employees
Shareholders
Financial and Insurance Institutions
Local population
Customers
Suppliers of Leisure and Tourism Services/Products
Suppliers of Office supplies and Services
Buyers and Representatives based overseas and in destinations
Management Consultants and Auditors
Marketing and PR Consultants and Advertising Agencies
Legislators
Local and National Governments
Trade Unions
Trade and Employers’ Associations
National and Regional Tourism Boards/Authorities/Organisations
Non Government Organisations (NGOs)
Civil Society Organisations (CSOs)
Press and Media
6 NOVEMBER 2002 22 GRI (2002)

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Destaque

Baze de date
Baze de dateBaze de date
Baze de date
dalex4c
 
Principlesofdesign10
Principlesofdesign10Principlesofdesign10
Principlesofdesign10
ahill7
 
3 de noviembre de 1820 independencia de cuenca
3 de noviembre de 1820 independencia de cuenca3 de noviembre de 1820 independencia de cuenca
3 de noviembre de 1820 independencia de cuenca
Elizabeth Velasquez
 

Destaque (14)

JavaOne 2015: Scaling micro services at Gilt
JavaOne 2015: Scaling micro services at GiltJavaOne 2015: Scaling micro services at Gilt
JavaOne 2015: Scaling micro services at Gilt
 
Filosofia institucional
Filosofia institucional Filosofia institucional
Filosofia institucional
 
Baze de date
Baze de dateBaze de date
Baze de date
 
1997 04 24 turismo e sistemi territoriali integrati
1997 04 24 turismo e sistemi territoriali integrati1997 04 24 turismo e sistemi territoriali integrati
1997 04 24 turismo e sistemi territoriali integrati
 
User Experience: Glücksgefühle im Katalog 2.0
User Experience: Glücksgefühle im Katalog 2.0User Experience: Glücksgefühle im Katalog 2.0
User Experience: Glücksgefühle im Katalog 2.0
 
Una valle incantata per tutti
Una valle incantata per tutti Una valle incantata per tutti
Una valle incantata per tutti
 
Principlesofdesign10
Principlesofdesign10Principlesofdesign10
Principlesofdesign10
 
RESEÑA HISTÓRICA SANTA ANA - 2015
RESEÑA HISTÓRICA SANTA ANA - 2015RESEÑA HISTÓRICA SANTA ANA - 2015
RESEÑA HISTÓRICA SANTA ANA - 2015
 
3 de noviembre de 1820 independencia de cuenca
3 de noviembre de 1820 independencia de cuenca3 de noviembre de 1820 independencia de cuenca
3 de noviembre de 1820 independencia de cuenca
 
Representació de la TERRA
Representació de la TERRARepresentació de la TERRA
Representació de la TERRA
 
Our school timetable by Elia
Our school timetable by EliaOur school timetable by Elia
Our school timetable by Elia
 
1r eso tema 4 exercicis
1r eso tema  4 exercicis1r eso tema  4 exercicis
1r eso tema 4 exercicis
 
Les primeres civilitzacions (inacabat)
Les primeres civilitzacions (inacabat)Les primeres civilitzacions (inacabat)
Les primeres civilitzacions (inacabat)
 
โครงร่างโครงงานคอมพิวเตอร์
โครงร่างโครงงานคอมพิวเตอร์โครงร่างโครงงานคอมพิวเตอร์
โครงร่างโครงงานคอมพิวเตอร์
 

Semelhante a GRI TOUR OPERATORS SECTOR SUPPLEMENT

Financial Services Sector Supplement: Environmental Performance
Financial Services Sector Supplement: Environmental PerformanceFinancial Services Sector Supplement: Environmental Performance
Financial Services Sector Supplement: Environmental Performance
Dr Lendy Spires
 
Progress international guidelines for industrial parks
Progress international guidelines for industrial parksProgress international guidelines for industrial parks
Progress international guidelines for industrial parks
Fasika Alemu
 
Guide to the Monitoring Framework of the Global Partnership
Guide to the Monitoring Framework of the Global PartnershipGuide to the Monitoring Framework of the Global Partnership
Guide to the Monitoring Framework of the Global Partnership
Dr Lendy Spires
 
ECE_CTCS_WP.6_2016_4E_GRM
ECE_CTCS_WP.6_2016_4E_GRMECE_CTCS_WP.6_2016_4E_GRM
ECE_CTCS_WP.6_2016_4E_GRM
Markus Krebsz
 

Semelhante a GRI TOUR OPERATORS SECTOR SUPPLEMENT (20)

Financial Services Sector Supplement: Environmental Performance
Financial Services Sector Supplement: Environmental PerformanceFinancial Services Sector Supplement: Environmental Performance
Financial Services Sector Supplement: Environmental Performance
 
Gri financial env
Gri financial envGri financial env
Gri financial env
 
The Sustainability Content of Integrated Reports - A Survey of Pioneers (iNu...
The Sustainability Content of Integrated Reports -  A Survey of Pioneers (iNu...The Sustainability Content of Integrated Reports -  A Survey of Pioneers (iNu...
The Sustainability Content of Integrated Reports - A Survey of Pioneers (iNu...
 
The Sustainability Content of Integrated Reports (iNugget Issue Aug 18-24, 2014)
The Sustainability Content of Integrated Reports (iNugget Issue Aug 18-24, 2014)The Sustainability Content of Integrated Reports (iNugget Issue Aug 18-24, 2014)
The Sustainability Content of Integrated Reports (iNugget Issue Aug 18-24, 2014)
 
WP6_2015_05E
WP6_2015_05EWP6_2015_05E
WP6_2015_05E
 
Csr gri framework
Csr  gri frameworkCsr  gri framework
Csr gri framework
 
Progress international guidelines for industrial parks
Progress international guidelines for industrial parksProgress international guidelines for industrial parks
Progress international guidelines for industrial parks
 
Sustainability Reporting Guidance for the Oil and Gas Industry
Sustainability Reporting Guidance for the Oil and Gas IndustrySustainability Reporting Guidance for the Oil and Gas Industry
Sustainability Reporting Guidance for the Oil and Gas Industry
 
Science Based Targets: Scope and Goals of the Transport Refinement Project
Science Based Targets: Scope and Goals of the Transport Refinement ProjectScience Based Targets: Scope and Goals of the Transport Refinement Project
Science Based Targets: Scope and Goals of the Transport Refinement Project
 
2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.3 - Promoting Green Deal Raediness in EaP c...
2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.3 - Promoting Green Deal Raediness in EaP c...2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.3 - Promoting Green Deal Raediness in EaP c...
2022 GATF Annual Meeting - Item 7.3 - Promoting Green Deal Raediness in EaP c...
 
Democratizing Co-Production Of Sustainable Public Services
Democratizing Co-Production Of Sustainable Public Services Democratizing Co-Production Of Sustainable Public Services
Democratizing Co-Production Of Sustainable Public Services
 
Results Management System for IFAD supported country programmes
Results Management System for IFAD supported country programmesResults Management System for IFAD supported country programmes
Results Management System for IFAD supported country programmes
 
Guide to the Monitoring Framework of the Global Partnership
Guide to the Monitoring Framework of the Global PartnershipGuide to the Monitoring Framework of the Global Partnership
Guide to the Monitoring Framework of the Global Partnership
 
ECE_CTCS_WP.6_2016_4E_GRM
ECE_CTCS_WP.6_2016_4E_GRMECE_CTCS_WP.6_2016_4E_GRM
ECE_CTCS_WP.6_2016_4E_GRM
 
Production of the Industrial Development Report 2024.
Production of the Industrial Development Report 2024.Production of the Industrial Development Report 2024.
Production of the Industrial Development Report 2024.
 
What is the global reporting initiative?
What is the global reporting initiative?What is the global reporting initiative?
What is the global reporting initiative?
 
CCXG Forum, March 2020, Felipe De Leon
CCXG Forum, March 2020, Felipe De LeonCCXG Forum, March 2020, Felipe De Leon
CCXG Forum, March 2020, Felipe De Leon
 
Changes in the sustainability/ESG reporting landscape
Changes in the sustainability/ESG reporting landscapeChanges in the sustainability/ESG reporting landscape
Changes in the sustainability/ESG reporting landscape
 
United Nations Global Compact Network Georgia 2023 Value Propistion_ENG.pdf
United Nations Global Compact Network Georgia 2023 Value Propistion_ENG.pdfUnited Nations Global Compact Network Georgia 2023 Value Propistion_ENG.pdf
United Nations Global Compact Network Georgia 2023 Value Propistion_ENG.pdf
 
G20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance
G20/OECD Principles of Corporate GovernanceG20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance
G20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance
 

Mais de GABRIELE GUGLIELMI

Mais de GABRIELE GUGLIELMI (20)

Open Corporation Ranking (eng)
Open Corporation Ranking (eng)Open Corporation Ranking (eng)
Open Corporation Ranking (eng)
 
Open Corporation Ranking
Open Corporation RankingOpen Corporation Ranking
Open Corporation Ranking
 
2017 02 03 ewc autogrill gg
2017 02 03 ewc autogrill gg2017 02 03 ewc autogrill gg
2017 02 03 ewc autogrill gg
 
Nascita del progetto To.Be.e. EWC
Nascita del progetto To.Be.e. EWCNascita del progetto To.Be.e. EWC
Nascita del progetto To.Be.e. EWC
 
Birth of the To.Be.e. EWC
Birth of the To.Be.e. EWCBirth of the To.Be.e. EWC
Birth of the To.Be.e. EWC
 
#JobArt: culture brings growth
#JobArt: culture brings growth#JobArt: culture brings growth
#JobArt: culture brings growth
 
12-12-12 In italia sciopero generale
12-12-12 In italia sciopero generale12-12-12 In italia sciopero generale
12-12-12 In italia sciopero generale
 
SAFE HOST Phase 2; Canpaign and Task Force
SAFE HOST Phase 2; Canpaign and Task ForceSAFE HOST Phase 2; Canpaign and Task Force
SAFE HOST Phase 2; Canpaign and Task Force
 
SAFE HOST Fase 2, Campagna
SAFE HOST Fase 2, CampagnaSAFE HOST Fase 2, Campagna
SAFE HOST Fase 2, Campagna
 
SAFE HOST Project and HO.RE.CA. Social Dialogue Committee
SAFE HOST Project and HO.RE.CA. Social Dialogue CommitteeSAFE HOST Project and HO.RE.CA. Social Dialogue Committee
SAFE HOST Project and HO.RE.CA. Social Dialogue Committee
 
SAFE HOST Project, our first year of work
SAFE HOST Project, our first year of workSAFE HOST Project, our first year of work
SAFE HOST Project, our first year of work
 
SAFE HOST Project and iuf hrct trade group Copenhagen
SAFE HOST Project and iuf hrct trade group Copenhagen SAFE HOST Project and iuf hrct trade group Copenhagen
SAFE HOST Project and iuf hrct trade group Copenhagen
 
SAFE HOST Project and IT.A.CA.
SAFE HOST Project and IT.A.CA.SAFE HOST Project and IT.A.CA.
SAFE HOST Project and IT.A.CA.
 
SAFE HOST Project and ETLC
SAFE HOST Project and ETLCSAFE HOST Project and ETLC
SAFE HOST Project and ETLC
 
SAFE HOST Project 2nd Steering Committee meeting, Madrid
SAFE HOST Project 2nd Steering Committee meeting, MadridSAFE HOST Project 2nd Steering Committee meeting, Madrid
SAFE HOST Project 2nd Steering Committee meeting, Madrid
 
ITALIA: RISTORAZIONE IN CONCESSIONE FOCUS SU STRADE E AUTOSTRADE
ITALIA: RISTORAZIONE IN CONCESSIONE FOCUS SU STRADE E AUTOSTRADEITALIA: RISTORAZIONE IN CONCESSIONE FOCUS SU STRADE E AUTOSTRADE
ITALIA: RISTORAZIONE IN CONCESSIONE FOCUS SU STRADE E AUTOSTRADE
 
Il modello sociale europeo
Il modello sociale europeoIl modello sociale europeo
Il modello sociale europeo
 
I lavori nel turismo
I lavori nel turismoI lavori nel turismo
I lavori nel turismo
 
Grazie per la lavagna
Grazie per la lavagnaGrazie per la lavagna
Grazie per la lavagna
 
Progetto DOTEC, l'impatto della crisi in Italia
Progetto DOTEC,  l'impatto della crisi in ItaliaProgetto DOTEC,  l'impatto della crisi in Italia
Progetto DOTEC, l'impatto della crisi in Italia
 

Último

CYTOTEC DUBAI ☎️ +966572737505 } Abortion pills in Abu dhabi,get misoprostal ...
CYTOTEC DUBAI ☎️ +966572737505 } Abortion pills in Abu dhabi,get misoprostal ...CYTOTEC DUBAI ☎️ +966572737505 } Abortion pills in Abu dhabi,get misoprostal ...
CYTOTEC DUBAI ☎️ +966572737505 } Abortion pills in Abu dhabi,get misoprostal ...
Abortion pills in Riyadh +966572737505 get cytotec
 
sample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample samplesample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample sample
Casey Keith
 
sample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample samplesample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample sample
Casey Keith
 

Último (20)

Papi kondalu Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Papi kondalu Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot ModelPapi kondalu Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Papi kondalu Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
 
ITALY - Visa Options for expats and digital nomads
ITALY - Visa Options for expats and digital nomadsITALY - Visa Options for expats and digital nomads
ITALY - Visa Options for expats and digital nomads
 
Hire 💕 8617697112 Surat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Surat Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617697112 Surat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Surat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
 
VIP Vapi Call Girls 📞 8617697112 Vapi Call Girls
VIP Vapi Call Girls 📞 8617697112 Vapi Call GirlsVIP Vapi Call Girls 📞 8617697112 Vapi Call Girls
VIP Vapi Call Girls 📞 8617697112 Vapi Call Girls
 
Varanasi Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Varanasi Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot ModelVaranasi Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Varanasi Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
 
Mathura Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Mathura Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot ModelMathura Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
Mathura Call Girls 8250077686 Service Offer VIP Hot Model
 
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in Siri Fort🍑
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in Siri Fort🍑High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in Siri Fort🍑
High Profile 🔝 8250077686 📞 Call Girls Service in Siri Fort🍑
 
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Suri Call Girls available for hotel room package
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Suri Call Girls available for hotel room packageWhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Suri Call Girls available for hotel room package
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Suri Call Girls available for hotel room package
 
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Hire Call Girls Cooch Behar For a Sensual Sex Exp...
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Hire Call Girls Cooch Behar For a Sensual Sex Exp...WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Hire Call Girls Cooch Behar For a Sensual Sex Exp...
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Hire Call Girls Cooch Behar For a Sensual Sex Exp...
 
CYTOTEC DUBAI ☎️ +966572737505 } Abortion pills in Abu dhabi,get misoprostal ...
CYTOTEC DUBAI ☎️ +966572737505 } Abortion pills in Abu dhabi,get misoprostal ...CYTOTEC DUBAI ☎️ +966572737505 } Abortion pills in Abu dhabi,get misoprostal ...
CYTOTEC DUBAI ☎️ +966572737505 } Abortion pills in Abu dhabi,get misoprostal ...
 
Genesis 1:6 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:6  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verseGenesis 1:6  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:6 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
 
Hire 8617697112 Call Girls Udhampur For an Amazing Night
Hire 8617697112 Call Girls Udhampur For an Amazing NightHire 8617697112 Call Girls Udhampur For an Amazing Night
Hire 8617697112 Call Girls Udhampur For an Amazing Night
 
Tamluk ❤CALL GIRL 8617697112 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Tamluk ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRL
Tamluk ❤CALL GIRL 8617697112 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Tamluk ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRLTamluk ❤CALL GIRL 8617697112 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Tamluk ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRL
Tamluk ❤CALL GIRL 8617697112 ❤CALL GIRLS IN Tamluk ESCORT SERVICE❤CALL GIRL
 
Genuine 9332606886 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Bilaspur Escorts call Girls
Genuine 9332606886 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Bilaspur Escorts call GirlsGenuine 9332606886 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Bilaspur Escorts call Girls
Genuine 9332606886 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Bilaspur Escorts call Girls
 
Genuine 8250077686 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Chennai Escorts call Girls
Genuine 8250077686 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Chennai Escorts call GirlsGenuine 8250077686 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Chennai Escorts call Girls
Genuine 8250077686 Hot and Beautiful 💕 Chennai Escorts call Girls
 
Are Vatican Museum Tickets and Private Tours Worth It
Are Vatican Museum Tickets and Private Tours Worth ItAre Vatican Museum Tickets and Private Tours Worth It
Are Vatican Museum Tickets and Private Tours Worth It
 
sample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample samplesample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample sample
 
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
 
Ooty call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Ooty call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment BookingOoty call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Ooty call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
 
sample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample samplesample sample sample sample sample sample
sample sample sample sample sample sample
 

GRI TOUR OPERATORS SECTOR SUPPLEMENT

  • 1. Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement For use with the GRI 2002 Sustainability Reporting Guidelines November 2002 GRI (2002)
  • 2. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Primary Authors The Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement was developed by a multi-stakeholder working group convened by the United Nations Environment Programme’s Tour Operators’ Initiative (TOI) in partnership with the GRI. The Tour Operators’ Initiative (TOI) is a network of tour operators committed to introducing sustainability into their business practices. The Initiative has been developed by tour operators for tour operators with the support of the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) and the World Tourism Organization (WTO/OMT), who are also full members of the Initiative. Under this international umbrella, tour operators who are members of the Initiative are able to respond to international agendas while creating a platform to develop ideas and projects to address the environmental, social, economic and cultural aspects of sustainable development within the tourism sector. The Initiative is voluntary, non-profit, and open to all tour operators, regardless of their size and geographical location. The main requirement for membership is to sign a commitment to adopt the principles of sustainable tourism and to implement these principles through a corporate sustainable tourism policy. As part of this commitment, members also agree to monitor and report their progress. Contact For any questions or comments about this supplement and its use as part of the GRI framework, please contact: GRI Secretariat Phone: +31(0)20 531 00 00 E-mail: guidelines@globalreporting.org Web: www.globalreporting.org 6 NOVEMBER 2002 i GRI (2002)
  • 3. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Preface The GRI is pleased to release the pilot version of the Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement. This document offers a set of supplemental sustainability performance indicators for use in conjunction with the GRI 2002 Sustainability Reporting Guidelines (‘the Guidelines’). The indicators were identified as specifically relevant to the tour operators’ sector through an extensive multi-stakeholder process convened by GRI and the Tour Operators Initiative (TOI). In 2001, the GRI launched its supplement programme in response to consistent feedback on the importance of sector-specific guidance built on the foundation of the Guidelines. These supplements capture issues unique and essential to reporting in a specific sector, but which may not appear in the Guidelines since they are relevant primarily for a particular range of reporting organisations. Combining the Guidelines and the supplements, such as the Tour Operators supplement , will support comparison of reporting organisations both across sectors and within the context of their own sector. This supplement adds to, but does not replace, the Guidelines’ section on performance indicators. The release of this document, and the Financial Services Sector Supplement, represents the first step in GRI’s development of a complete set of sector-specific guidance. These supplements will be developed over the next few years using multi-stakeholder processes convened through GRI. The supplements are designed as complements to the Guidelines, and outline performance measures of specific importance to a given sector The Guidelines remain the starting point for any organisation seeking to use the GRI reporting framework. The conditions for reporting “in accordance” as outlined in the 2002 Guidelines remain unchanged and are independent of whether or not supplements are applied. Over the longer-term, the GRI Board of Directors will pursue the continued integration of GRI products in a manner that maximises utility and efficiency for users of the GRI reporting framework. In keeping with the new due process structure for GRI documents approved by the GRI Board of Directors, this supplement is being released as a pilot version. Under GRI due process, documents under preparation by working groups are first released as exposure drafts for consultation and testing. Next, when the document has reached an advanced state of maturity (typically following up to a year or more of exposure drafts, consultation, and testing), the document is reviewed for release as a pilot version. Such a release signifies that a document has passed a serious review of its technical merits (both the content and the process of development), and is ready for use by companies. Following release of a pilot, the GRI will establish a structured feedback process under the supervision of its Technical Advisory Council to capture the new learning that emerges through actual use. This process will engage report makers and users to monitor the reaction in the marketplace as the supplement receives active use. The structured feedback process will focus heavily on the interaction between the Guidelines and the 6 NOVEMBER 2002 ii GRI (2002)
  • 4. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT supplements. The early experiences in using pilot versions will provide invaluable feedback on the effective and practical integration of the family of GRI documents. At the end of the structured feedback process, the Technical Advisory Council will present its recommendations to the GRI Board of Directors and the supplement will be released in its final version. GRI anticipates that this process will extend into 2004. This due process is based on common practices used for setting other international standards, and reflects the basic steps that have been applied to the development of the GRI Guidelines since 1999. It should be noted, however, that even “final” versions will continue to follow the cycle of review, testing, and improvement that is required of all GRI documents, including the Guidelines. At the same time, GRI recognises the need for stability and predictability in such products and will ensure that these objectives are properly balanced with innovation. GRI strongly encourages the uptake and use of this pilot supplement. Learning by doing has been the key force driving continued improvement in the GRI reporting framework, and the supplements will be no exception. This document represents the best thinking to date, developed through the GRI multi-stakeholder process, on sustainability performance indicators specific to the tour operators’ sector, and the culmination of almost a year of work by the TOI and its many collaborators. The GRI expresses its deep appreciation to the TOI members and all the stakeholders who participated in the development of this supplement. The GRI looks forward to continued engagement with the participants in this process and welcomes new opportunities for developing supplements for other sectors. 6 NOVEMBER 2002 iii GRI (2002)
  • 5. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Table of Contents Preface................................................................................................................................ ii Introduction....................................................................................................................... 1 Reporting Using the GRI Framework................................................................................. 1 Applicability of This Supplement....................................................................................... 2 The Process for Developing This Supplement.................................................................... 2 Comments from the Multi-Stakeholder Working Group.................................................... 4 Next Steps........................................................................................................................... 4 Supplement Content ......................................................................................................... 7 Overview of the Indicator Framework................................................................................ 7 Linkages Between GRI 2002 Guidelines and the Tour Operators’ Supplement................ 8 Performance Indicators.................................................................................................. 10 Product Management and Development (PMD)............................................................... 10 Internal Management (IM)................................................................................................ 11 Labour practices........................................................................................................ 11 Health and safety....................................................................................................... 11 Training and education.............................................................................................. 11 Materials.................................................................................................................... 11 Waste.......................................................................................................................... 12 Supply Chain Management (SCM)................................................................................... 12 Customer Relations (CR).................................................................................................. 14 Cooperation with Destinations (D)................................................................................... 15 Partnerships............................................................................................................... 15 Community development............................................................................................ 15 Philanthropy and charitable donations..................................................................... 15 Table 1: Correlation of Guidelines and Tour Operators’ Supplement Indicators............. 17 Table 2: Analysis of Linkages: Guidelines and Tour Operators’ Specific Indicators...... 18 Annex 1: Members of the Multi-Stakeholder Working Group......................................... 19 Annex 2: Tour Operators’ Suppliers................................................................................. 20 Annex 3: Tour Operators’ Stakeholders ........................................................................... 22 6 NOVEMBER 2002 iv GRI (2002)
  • 6. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Introduction Reporting Using the GRI Framework The GRI reporting framework comprises three sets of documents. Together, this family of documents represents a comprehensive framework for measuring and reporting on economic, environmental, and social reporting at an organizational level. • The GRI Sustainability Reporting Guidelines (the “Guidelines”) • Sector and Issue supplements • Technical protocols The Guidelines represent the foundation upon which all other GRI reporting documents are based, and outline core content that is broadly relevant to all organisations regardless of size, sector, or location. All organisations seeking to report using the GRI framework should use the Guidelines as the basis for their report, supported by the other GRI documents as applicable. In addition to the Guidelines, the GRI family of documents will also include a growing number of sector supplements. While GRI believes that establishing a core set of Guidelines is essential to achieve consistent and comparable reporting across diverse organisations, GRI also recognises that a generic set of indicators may fail to capture aspects of sustainability performance that are unique and crucial to a given industry sector (e.g., mining, automotive, pharmaceuticals). The sector supplements will be designed to provide indicators for use in conjunction with the Guidelines that highlight the specific issues that characterise a given industry sector. Lastly, GRI is also drafting technical protocols that offer specific guidance on various technical aspects of reporting within the GRI framework, including expectations related to measurement of specific indicators. For more information on GRI or to obtain a copy of the 2002 GRI Guidelines or other GRI documents, please visit the GRI website at: www.globalreporting.org. Use of the GRI framework is voluntary. 6 NOVEMBER 2002 1 GRI (2002)
  • 7. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Applicability of This Supplement This sector supplement applies only to businesses dedicated to organising holiday packages1 . This supplement was not designed to capture sector-specific aspects of the various service industries associated with a package, such as transport, accommodation, and other tourism services. The Process for Developing This Supplement The development of the tour operators’ sector-specific performance indicators had to take into account three main considerations. First, the supplemental indicators had to complement the performance indicators contained in the 2002 Guidelines. Therefore, the supplement aimed to capture issues that were either: • Essential components of sustainability unique to tour operators; or • Relevant to numerous sectors, but of critical importance to tour operators’ sustainability performance. The second consideration was the recognition of the ‘middle man’ role of tour operators in the tourism industry. Tour operators don’t deliver services or produce physical products. Clearly defining the boundaries of responsibility was therefore considered a necessary first step in the process. Lastly, a final consideration was that the lack of examples of sustainability reports in the sector meant that the performance indicators could not be based on existing practices. The Multi-Stakeholder Working Group (MSWG) that revised the performance indicators, included representatives from: • Civil society organisations (non-profit advocacy groups, consumers’ and trade unions); • Local authorities and tourism boards; • Tour operators’ suppliers (accommodation, cruise liners, airlines, ground transport); and 1 According to the European Commission, a package is a pre-arranged combination of not fewer than two of the following when sold or offered for sale at an inclusive price and when the service covers a period of more than twenty-four hours or includes overnight accommodation: a) transport b) accommodation c) other tourism services not ancillary to transport or accommodation and accounting for a significant proportion of the package. 6 NOVEMBER 2002 2 GRI (2002)
  • 8. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT • Tour operators selected from among the members of the Tour Operators’ Initiative. Two co-chairs—one business and one non-business representative—were elected to ensure that all perspectives were equally and properly integrated during the development of the supplement. The two co-chairs, Nico Visser of Travel Unie Nederland and Graham Gordon of Tearfund, facilitated the meetings of the MSWG. A GRI-TOI Reporting Committee consisting of a GRI liaison, a TOI representative, the two MSWG Co-Chairs, and a UNEP representative oversaw the process. The work of the MSWG was co- ordinated by UNEP, which also acts as the TOI Secretariat. The process began with an advisory meeting in September 2001 in Paris that brought together tour operators and their direct stakeholders to agree on which actions and decisions in the preparation and delivery of the holiday package have an environmental, social, and/or economic influence or impact, thereby setting the boundaries of responsibility for reporting. The participants in the advisory meeting recognised that a clear and shared agreement on ‘how far’ a tour operator could go in improving the sustainability of its product was a necessary pre-requisite to beginning a discussion on performance indicators. Following the meeting, UNEP and GRI invited a number of tour operators and stakeholders to form the MSWG. Each member was selected based on their demonstrated interest and competence in this subject, and readiness to engage in the process. Efforts were also made to ensure geographical balance amongst the participants. See Annex 1 for a complete list of the members of the MSWG. The indicators were developed over the course of three meetings of the MSWG (16 November 2001, 18-19 February and 25-26 April 2002). During the first consultation the group focused on identifying the sustainability issues specific to the tour operators’ sector, and not sufficiently addressed by the Guidelines. This ‘gap analysis’ brought to light a number of suggestions for indicators to supplement those in the 2002 Guidelines. The meeting resulted in the first draft of the sector specific indicators for tour operators. The draft was further discussed and developed at the second meeting of the MSWG in February 2002. Following the third meeting in April 2002, the MSWG agreed to the content of the final draft for submission to the GRI Board of Directors. The final document was submitted in June 2002 for review at the 20 June meeting of the GRI Board of Directors. The drafting process was also designed to encourage input from other stakeholders and tour operators. Each draft of the supplement was posted on the TOI website with a direct link from the GRI web site for two months. In addition, copies were sent to key organisations and individuals with requests for comments. All comments received were discussed during the consultations, as well as posted on the TOI website. 6 NOVEMBER 2002 3 GRI (2002)
  • 9. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Comments from the Multi-Stakeholder Working Group In preparing the Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement, it was necessary to elaborate on certain aspects of reporting that are not fully developed within the core Guidelines. This is particularly true for the category of Supply Chain Management. These differences have significant bearing on the possibility of effectively comparing reports from companies that use only the core GRI Guidelines, to tour operators that also use this sector supplement. Early in the process, members of the MSWG agreed to include qualitative performance indicators as well as quantitative indicators. A number of the indicators chosen for the supplement are qualitative measures that provide detailed information on implementation of the reporting organisation’s policies. This is consistent with the approach taken to numerous performance indicators in the 2002 Guidelines. Lastly, it should be noted that the indicators in this supplement are the product of a multi- stakeholder consultative process. Therefore, while each indicator represents a commonly agreed upon position, it does not necessarily reflect the specific position of each individual participant. The MSWG acknowledges that both the process for developing this supplement and the selected indicators do not fully cover the expectations of each and every stakeholder. This sector supplement was undertaken based on the understanding that virtually all dimensions of the tour operating business have environmental, economic, and social impacts. Next Steps This supplement is the result of a nine-month process that included numerous meetings and on-line exchanges. All participants in the process recognised that there are some limitations to this process and in particular the difficulty of bringing into the discussion feedback generated through experience, as this requires a much longer time. Furthermore, all participants recognise that understanding of sustainable development and sustainable performance continuously evolves. The members of the MSWG were unanimous in calling for regular revisions to the tour operators’ sector-specific performance indicators. Future revisions should also incorporate practical experience gained in using this first set as well as evolving understanding of sustainable development and performance. Most participants indicated (through a questionnaire circulated during the third consultation) that indicators should be reviewed in two to three years’ time. Key in this revision process will be the experience gained by tour operators in using the GRI 2002 Sustainability Reporting Guidelines and the sector-specific indicators. 6 NOVEMBER 2002 4 GRI (2002)
  • 10. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT It was therefore proposed to initiate a pilot test of the GRI 2002 Sustainability Reporting Guidelines and the Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement, involving members of the Tour Operators’ Initiative. Many of the stakeholders involved in the process confirmed their interest in supporting this effort. The pilot test would build awareness and know-how of reporting principles. Secondly, it would facilitate the revisions and improvement of the indicators through the generation of various outputs, among which may be: • Structured feedback for revision of the indicators based on a common survey to be developed with the Global Reporting Initiative. • A user’s manual containing guidance notes to a number of indicators based on collected best practices, as well as measurement protocols. • Recommendations on most effective reporting formats for the sector. • A proposed model suitable to the tour operators’ sector for organising the internal flow of information to support reporting efforts. • Recommendations of the links between the core Guidelines and tour operator- specific indicators. • A proposed classification of core and advanced indicators for the tour operators’ sector. 6 NOVEMBER 2002 5 GRI (2002)
  • 11. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Where to send feedback on this supplement: Any comments and suggestions on how to improve this current version of the Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement should be addressed to BOTH the: TOI Secretariat c/o United Nations Environment Programme Division of Technology, Industry and Economics Tour Mirabeau - 39-43, quai André Citroën 75739 Paris Cedex 15 - France Fax: +33-1-44371474 E-mail: unep.tie@unep.fr Global Reporting Initiative Secretariat Keizersgracht 209 P.O. Box 10039 1001 EA Amsterdam The Netherlands Tel: +31 (0) 20 531 00 00 Fax: +31 (0) 20 531 00 31 E-mail: guidelines@globalreporting.org 6 NOVEMBER 2002 6 GRI (2002)
  • 12. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Supplement Content General Notes A number of general issues should be taken into account when using this supplement: 1. Definitions of the term “social” vary widely amongst different groups. In the context of tour operators, it is important to give specific consideration to the role of culture in social sustainability, and ensure that reporting on “social performance” reflects tour operators’ impacts and contributions to the cultures in which they operate. 2. The supplement does not include a definition of “destination.” The MSWG was unable to reach agreement on this question, and specifically the geographical scope implied in the term. The definition not only varies among tour operators, but the same tour operator uses the term “destination” to refer to a town, a country, a region, or a continent interchangeably. It is therefore requested that reporting organisations clearly state the definition of ‘destination’ as used in the preparation of their report. 3. During the process of developing the supplement, the participants began to develop ‘guidance notes’ listing recommended best practices for specific indicators, as well as more specific instruction on the sustainability issues to be taken into account. The members of the MSWG felt that these guidance notes should be further developed based on experience, and therefore were not included in this supplement. The draft notes are posted on the TOI web site at www.toinitiative.org/reporting/reporting.htm. It should be noted that these guidance notes have not been officially reviewed and approved as part of the GRI framework and represent the experience and recommendations of the TOI. For technical guidance related to reporting within the GRI framework, please see the GRI website (www.globalreporting.org) or contact the GRI Secretariat. Overview of the Indicator Framework The performance indicators drafted by the MSWG request information on tour operators’ performance both in terms of policies and management systems as well as areas of impact. The indicators are divided into categories that reflect the life cycle of the holiday product: from the planning stage, to the development and delivery of the product. The indicators have been grouped under five categories: 6 NOVEMBER 2002 7 GRI (2002)
  • 13. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT • Product management and development (PMD) includes actions related to the choice of the destination as well as the type of services to be included (e.g., the use of train vs. plane). • Internal management (IM) reflects all the operations and activities that take place in the headquarters or country offices (e.g., use of office supplies, production of brochures, direct employment). • Supply chain management (SCM) addresses actions related to the selection and contracting of service providers. • Customer relations (CR) summarises the actions taken to deal with customers, not only with regards to the responsibility to serve them and reply to their comments, but also the opportunity to provide information and raise consumer awareness regarding sustainability. • Co-operation with destination (D) includes all activities and decisions related to destinations that tour operators make beyond the production and delivery of their holiday package. This mainly includes efforts made by tour operators to engage in dialogues with destination operators about the impacts of tour packages, and philanthropic activities. The first four categories cover actions and decisions that tour operators make in preparation of the holiday package. Through these actions and decisions, tour operators have either a direct impact on sustainability (e.g., managing office supplies), or a significant influence on sustainability (e.g., through the supply chain). The fifth area covers efforts to address product impacts at the destination. Within these five categories, the indicators have been further grouped in the three sustainability headings where the MSWG felt relatively clear boundaries between environmental, social, and economic performance exist (e.g., internal management). In some categories, the indicators have not been separated into economic, environmental, and social, since the operators could not make a distinction between these issues within their business operations. Linkages Between GRI 2002 Guidelines and the Tour Operators’ Supplement When using the indicators in the Guidelines, tour operators should take into account that some overlaps exist between the general set of indicators in the Guidelines and those in the Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement. In many cases, the sector supplement represents a more specific dimension of a general indicator that appears in the Guidelines. The 6 NOVEMBER 2002 8 GRI (2002)
  • 14. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT overlapping and complementary areas are highlighted in Table 1. An analysis of those linkages and suggested approaches for use of the indicators are provided in Table 2. Specific points to note in the use of this supplement are: • This supplement contains a number of indicators that request specific information on policies and procedures that overlap with elements in the Guidelines section on Governance Structure and Management Systems (Part C, Section 3). The general subject of the inquiries is the same, but the indicators in this supplement are more directly focused on the policy and procedural concerns important to measuring sustainability performance in the tour operators’ sector. • To facilitate responding to the supply chain management indicators, this supplement includes a classification of suppliers specific to tour operators (see Annex 2). • When reporting on stakeholder involvement (Guidelines, Part C, Section 2.9) reporting companies should refer to the stakeholders listed in this supplement (see Annex 3). This list is consistent with the general stakeholder structure presented in the Guidelines, but is further refined to reflect the specific range of stakeholders relevant to the tour operators’ sector. 6 NOVEMBER 2002 9 GRI (2002)
  • 15. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Performance Indicators PRODUCT MANAGEMENT AND DEVELOPMENT (PMD) PMD1. Indicate percentage of reporting organisation’s business (by passengers carried) and market share in operating destinations. PMD2. Describe policies on selecting, developing and deselecting destinations based on environmental, social and economic issues. PMD3. Describe key environmental, economic and social issues identified in destinations and types of information gathered2. Issues may include: Environment: water, wastewater, energy, and transport infrastructures; hazardous and solid waste disposal; air and water quality; land-use and biodiversity conservation; local environmental management structures. Socio-economic: respect for human rights (including indigenous and tribal people); compliance with International Labour Organization (ILO) conventions on child and forced labour; freedom of association; non- discrimination; programmes to combat sexual exploitation of children and to combat and mitigate the social impacts of HIV/AIDS; citizen participation in planning process. PMD4. Indicate percentage of destinations in which organisation operates for which issues (PMD3) have been identified, and percentage of reporting organisation’s business this represents (by passengers carried). PMD5. Describe types of approaches taken in gathering information (PMD3) and rationale for applying an approach to a given destination. Approaches include own research, third party report, customer feedback, destination self-assessment, stakeholders’ consultation, dialogue with competitors. Specify stakeholders approached. PMD6. Indicate length of time over which this information (PMD3) has been collected, and the frequency with which it is updated. PMD7. Quantify overall economic, environmental, and social impacts of typical holiday products. 2 A draft guidance note providing additional information is available for reporting companies on the Tour Operators’ Initiative web site: www.toinitiative.org 6 NOVEMBER 2002 10 GRI (2002)
  • 16. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT PMD8. Describe changes in design of holiday packages and other actions to address key environmental, economic and social issues (see PMD3) of destinations. PMD9. Describe Measures to maximise economic benefits to destinations. INTERNAL MANAGEMENT (IM) Labour practices: IM1. Provide evidence of recruiting local residents (including destination nationals) for destination posts including management positions. Health and safety: IM2. Describe existence of policies and programmes to address the physical and mental well-being of staff at headquarters and destinations. Training and education: IM3. Describe types and mechanisms of training on environmental, social and economic issues by category of employee. Include destination representatives, senior management, middle management, professional, technical, administrative, production, and maintenance. IM4. Describe policies and actions in place to accommodate cultural customs, traditions and practices of staff throughout the organisation. Materials: IM5. Describe policies to minimise the environmental impacts associated with the production, distribution and use of promotional materials and customer documentation. IM6. Indicate total quantity (tonnes or kg) of material used by type (e.g., paper, plastic) and environmental quality (e.g., recycled content), for the production of promotional materials and customer documentation. IM7. Indicate percentage of promotional materials and customer documentation that are produced in accordance with an environmental standard. Specify standard. 6 NOVEMBER 2002 11 GRI (2002)
  • 17. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Waste: IM8. Describe policies and targets for redistribution, reuse and recycling of promotional materials. IM9. Indicate percentage of total travel retailers that agree to adopt policies and practices on reuse and recycling of promotional materials. Also refer to Supply Chain Management section. SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT (SCM) SCM1. Describe the supply chain management policy, objectives and targets on environmental, social, and economic performance. State the use of supplier prioritisation and screening criteria. SCM2. Describe processes through which suppliers, by type, are consulted during development and implementation of the supply chain management policy, described in SCM1. SCM3. Describe issues identified through supplier consultation and actions to address them. SCM4. Describe processes through which suppliers, by type, are engaged in the implementation of the supply chain management policy, described in SCM1. Processes include: One way communication (e.g., questionnaires), two-way communication (e.g., information exchange), active co-operation (e.g., supplier training), rewards and recognition for high performers. SCM5. State joint actions taken with suppliers, by type, to support improvements in suppliers own environmental and social performance. SCM6. Describe progress in achieving objectives and targets related to supply chain policy. SCM7. Indicate percentage of suppliers, by type, subject to supply chain management policy. SCM8. Indicate percentages of suppliers, by type, subject to supply chain policy that have a published sustainability policy, implemented a 6 NOVEMBER 2002 12 GRI (2002)
  • 18. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT sustainability management system and/or have a staff person with management responsibility for corporate sustainability. SCM9. State types of information requested from suppliers, by type, on their3 : (a) Environmental practices and performance. Include: Materials, water, energy, purchasing, solid waste, hazardous waste, effluents, emissions, transport, land-use and biodiversity. (b) Social practices and performance. Include: Community and staff development, indigenous and tribal people’s rights, formal employment contracts, social security, working conditions according to ILO Convention 172, equal treatment, non-discrimination, recognition of independent trade unions and application of collective bargaining agreements, health and safety committees, policies excluding child labour as defined by ILO, programmes to combat commercial sexual exploitation of children, and to combat and mitigate the social impacts of HIV/AIDS. SCM10. Indicate percentage of suppliers, by type, subject to supply chain management policy that provided the requested information. SCM11. Indicate percentage of suppliers, by type, subject to supply chain management policy whose environmental, social and economic performance has been reported. Through, for example: • Supplier self declaration; • Spot checks by reporting organization; • Environmental and social audits; • Certification schemes (including eco labels); • Third party verification (state if verifier is accredited, and by whom). SCM12. State actions taken by the reporting organisation in response to suppliers reported performance (as per SCM 11), by type of suppliers. Include incentives and rewards. SCM13. State actions to inform suppliers of customers’ requirements. SCM14. State contracting policy and how it is communicated to suppliers. Include negotiating terms and conditions for payment, cancellation and compensation of contracts with suppliers. 3 A draft guidance note providing additional information is available for reporting companies on the Tour Operators’ Initiative web site www.toinitiative.org 6 NOVEMBER 2002 13 GRI (2002)
  • 19. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT SCM15. Describe joint initiatives with suppliers to improve environmental, social and economic conditions in destinations. SCM16. State benefits for the reporting organisation from implementing the sustainable supply chain policy. CUSTOMER RELATIONS (CR) CR1. Describe tools and measures used by reporting organisation to raise the awareness of consumers of suppliers’ environmental, social and economic performance. Indicate joint efforts with suppliers, NGOs, national tourism organisations (NTOs), and authorities in destinations; main themes communicated; and specify the moment of the holiday experience, from selection to return, at which communication took place. CR2. Describe tools and measures used by reporting organisation to raise the awareness of consumers of destinations’ environmental, social and economic issues. Indicate joint efforts with suppliers, NGOs, NTOs, and authorities in destinations; main themes communicated; and specify the moment of the holiday experience, from selection to return, at which communication took place. CR3. Describe tools and measures used by reporting organisation to raise the awareness of consumers of sustainable holiday-making. Indicate joint efforts with suppliers, NGOs, NTOs, and authorities in destinations; main themes communicated; and specify the moment of the holiday experience, from selection to return, at which communication took place. CR4. Describe means to invite customers’ feedback on economic, environmental, and social issues related to the holiday product and actions taken to respond to feedback. CR5. Indicate percentage of total feedback received, related to economic, environmental and social issues. Break down feedback in terms of positive and negative and main issues covered. 6 NOVEMBER 2002 14 GRI (2002)
  • 20. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT CR6. Provide evidence of consultation with destination stakeholders and suppliers on how the destination and services are portrayed to customers. CR7. Indicate number of complaints from destinations’ stakeholders and holiday-makers regarding misleading and inaccurate representation of destinations. Indicate actions taken to address complaints. COOPERATION WITH DESTINATIONS (D) Partnerships: D1. Describe ways reporting organisation engages with destination stakeholders to address issues, including those identified in PMD34 . Include information exchange, awareness raising, consultation, dialogues and incentives provided. Community development: D2. Describe measures taken to identify and offer commercial opportunities and assistance to non-contracted suppliers that support community development. Philanthropy and charitable donations: D3. Describe procedures and criteria for selecting projects and organisations to which philanthropic and charitable donations are made. D4. Indicate total funds (in cash and estimated value of in-kind contributions) for conservation and social development projects. Identify: • Sources (corporate budget, consumers’ contributions); • Type (cash, in-kind); • Distribution of funds to conservation and community development projects and organisations; • Location of projects/organisations receiving the funds (in operating destinations, headquarters and international). 4 A draft guidance note providing additional information is available for reporting companies on the Tour Operators’ Initiative web site, www.toinitiative.org 6 NOVEMBER 2002 15 GRI (2002)
  • 21. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT D5. Describe programmes for philanthropic and charitable donations in relation to conservation and community development projects. D6. Provide evidence of benefits generated (in D4 and D5), particularly at destinations, in support of community development, biodiversity conservation and other social, economic and environmental improvements at destinations. 6 NOVEMBER 2002 16 GRI (2002)
  • 22. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Table 1: Correlation of Guidelines and Tour Operators’ Supplement Indicators Product Management and Development GRI 2002 Guidelines Tour Operators’ Supplement Economic Environmental Social PMD1, PMD2, PMD3, PMD4, PMD5, PMD6, PMD7, PMD8, PMD9 EC13* EN7, EN14, EN15, EN18*, EN25*, EN26* , EN27*, EN28*, EN30*, EN35* HR2, HR12*, HR13*, HR14* SO1 Internal Management GRI 2002 GuidelinesTour Operators’ Supplement Economic Environmental Social IM1, IM2, IM3, IM4, IM5, IM6, IM7, IM8, IM9 EC1, EC2, EC5, EC6, EC7, EC8, EC9, EC12*, EN1, EN2, EN3, EN4, EN5, EN6, , EN7, EN8, EN9, EN10, EN11, EN12, EN13, EN16, EN17*, EN19*, EN20*, EN21*, EN22*, EN23*, EN24*, EN27*, EN29*, EN31*, EN32*, EN34*, EN35* LA1, LA2, LA3, LA4, LA5, LA6, LA7, LA8, LA9, LA10, LA11, LA12*, LA13*, LA14*, LA15*, LA16*, LA17* HR1, HR4, HR5, HR6, HR7, HR8*, HR9*, HR10*, HR11*, HR12*, SO2, SO3, SO4*, SO5*, SO6* SO7* Supply Chain Management GRI 2002 Guidelines Tour Operators’ Supplement Economic Environmental Social SCM1, SCM2, SCM3, SCM4, SCM5, SCM6, SCM7, SCM8, SCM9, SCM10, SCM11, SCM12, SCM13, SCM14, SCM15, SCM16 EC3, EC4, EC11* EN 30*, EN33*, EN35* HR2, HR3 Customer Relations GRI 2002 GuidelinesTour Operators’ Supplement Economic Environmental Social CR1, CR2, CR3, CR4, CR5, CR6, CR7 PR1, PR2, PR3, PR4*, PR5*, PR6*, PR7* PR8*, PR9*, PR10*, PR11* Co-operation with Destination GRI 2002 Guidelines Tour Operators’ Supplement Economic Environmental Social D1, D2, D3, D4, D5, D6 EC10 * Denotes an additional (rather than core) indicator in the 2002 Guidelines. Note: Some Guidelines indicators correspond with more than one Tour Operators' Category 6 NOVEMBER 2002 17 GRI (2002)
  • 23. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Table 2: Analysis of Linkages: Guidelines and Tour Operators’ Specific Indicators Guidelines Indicators Tour Operators Indicators Comments Suggestions EC1 and EC2 PMD1 EC1 and EC2 are an extension of PMD1. The tour operators’ specific indicator uses the traditional tour operators’ unit measure ‘passenger/destination’ rather than turnover. Combine the three indicators. EC12 PMD9 The tour operators’ specific indicator PMD9 reflects the pro-active actions taken by tour operators to maximise and enhance their positive economic benefits at the destination level. Cross-link the replies to the two indicators. EC12 PMD7 and PMD9 EC12 is partially included in PMD7 and PMD9. Focus on the two aspects highlighted by PMD7 and PMD9. EN1 and EN2 IM5, IM6 and IM7 Tour operators specific indicators IM5, IM6 and IM7 address specifically the material used related to the production and distribution of tour operators’ promotional material and customer documentation, that represent a major source of solid waste. Complement the replies to EN1 and EN2 with the specific answers addressing promotional material and customer documentation. EN11 IM8 and IM9 Tour operators’ specific indicators IM8 and IM9 address specifically waste management practices related to the production and distribution of tour operators’ promotional material and customer documentation that represent a major source of solid waste. Complement the information provided in EN11 with the specific data addressing promotional material and customer documentation, in IM8 and IM9. EN33 and HR3 SCM1 to SCM16 The Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement provides a more detailed and sector-specific set of indicators addressing environmental, social and economic aspects of supply chain management. Focus on SCM1 to SCM16 and indicate the links with EN33 and HR3 HR2 and HR3 SCM9 SCM9 provides the opportunity to report on all types of information requested from suppliers on environmental and social issues, while HR2 and HR3 focus more specifically on suppliers’ human rights performance. Complement information provided in SCM9 with information provided in HR2 and HR3. HR2 PMD2 PMD2 provides tour operators the opportunity to report on their general destination selection policy, while HR2 focuses in particular on human rights issues. Complement information provided in PMD2 with information provided in HR2. SO1 PMD1 to PMD9 The Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement provides a more detailed set of indicators reflecting tour operators’ performance in stakeholder engagement and actions taken to minimise negative impacts and influence on destinations through product development and management. Focus on PMD1 to PMD9, and indicate the links with SO1. EC13, EN14, and HR3 PMD7 EC13, EN14 and HR3 are covered under PMD 7 Cross reference responses. EC10, EC12, HR2 and SO1 D1 to D6 The Tour Operators’ Sector Supplement provides a more specific set of indicators that facilitate the illustration of conservation and philanthropic investments to benefit the destination, beyond the company. Focus on D1 to D6, and indicate the links with EC10, EC12, HR2 and SO1. 6 NOVEMBER 2002 18 GRI (2002)
  • 24. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Annex 1: Members of the Multi-Stakeholder Working Group Last First Organisation Ashton Jane First Choice Holidays Austria Gregorio City of Puerto Princesa Bah Adama Gambia Tourism Concern Belau Dirk International Labour Organization (Observer) Bermann Ellen Viaggi del Ventaglio Botet i Pont Ramon Lloret de Mar (Spain – Costa Brava) Carroll-Simon Elizabeth International Hotel & Restaurant Association Cresswell Carolyn P&O Princess Cruises plc Dietsch Klaus Studiosus Reisen Fletcher Karen International Hotel Environment Initiative (Observer) Gordon Graham Tearfund Guglielmi Gabriele Filcams CGIL Nazionale (Italy) Hess Kaspar Hotelplan Hügel Jens Union International des Transports Routier (IRU) Hustache Bennani Isabelle Dynamic Tours Jackson Jan British Airways Holidays Le Dantec Alexandre Accor Tours Lotta Sand Thomson Travel Museler Andreas LTU-Touristik GmbH (formerly ITS Reisen) Nawaz Homar Tourist Board of Sri Lanka Newton Victoria British Airways Nico Visser Travel Unie Nederland Őrnek Yusuh Vasco Travel Orsoni Pierre Telefono Blu, SOS Turismo Consumatori Paul Matell Scandinavian Leisure Group Richards Keith Association of British Travel Agents Selanniemi Tom Aurinkomatkat-Suntours Sweeting Jamie Conservation International van Beurden Jan Lions Dive & Beach Resort Wilson James Six Continents/BASS Woolford Justin WWF UK 6 NOVEMBER 2002 19 GRI (2002)
  • 25. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Annex 2: Tour Operators’ Suppliers “Packaging” Holiday Services Transport Services Transport to and from embarkation and disembarkation points: • Transport terminals: airports, stations, terminals etc. • Pickup services: taxi, coach Transport to and from destinations and transfers within destinations: • Inbound Tour Operator services • Air • Rail • Coach • Taxi • Ferry Accommodation Services • Hotels • Self-catering • Pension/Bed & Breakfast • Holiday house/villa/chalet • Campsites Leisure Services • Inbound tour operators and/or local agents offering natural and cultural excursions • Sport and adventure tourism service providers • Guiding Services • Catering Services • Retailers Cruise Lines Producing Holiday Brochures, Promotion Material and Travel Documents Graphic Designers Printing Services Distribution Services and Promotions Mailing Houses Retailing Holidays Travel Agencies (continued) 6 NOVEMBER 2002 20 GRI (2002)
  • 26. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Internal Corporate Management Obtaining Office Space • Building design and construction services • Building material suppliers • Real estate agents and rental services Daily Business Processes • Water supply and waste water disposal services • Energy suppliers • Waste disposal services • Telecommunication and IT services • Suppliers of office equipment, furniture, paper and other supplies • Cleaning services • Catering services • Gardening/landscaping services • Couriers • Vehicle renting and parking services • Management and financial consultants • PR and communication agencies • Financial institutions 6 NOVEMBER 2002 21 GRI (2002)
  • 27. PILOT VERSION 1.0 TOUR OPERATORS’ SECTOR SUPPLEMENT Annex 3: Tour Operators’ Stakeholders Tour Operators’ Stakeholders in Countries of Origin and Destinations Employees Shareholders Financial and Insurance Institutions Local population Customers Suppliers of Leisure and Tourism Services/Products Suppliers of Office supplies and Services Buyers and Representatives based overseas and in destinations Management Consultants and Auditors Marketing and PR Consultants and Advertising Agencies Legislators Local and National Governments Trade Unions Trade and Employers’ Associations National and Regional Tourism Boards/Authorities/Organisations Non Government Organisations (NGOs) Civil Society Organisations (CSOs) Press and Media 6 NOVEMBER 2002 22 GRI (2002)