66 Ways to improve your direct marketing/fundraising

1. 0!
0
r1
e
v66 ways to improve
O
your direct marketing
Damian O’Broin – Ask Direct

2. More
www.askdirect.ie
www.slideshare.net/damianob
damian@askdirect.ie

3. 1
Say ‘Thank You’ personally
& promptly.

4. What happens when you
make a donation...
Speed of thank you % of charities
• Only 83% sent an email < 2 working days 28%
thank you
• 2-5 working days 22%
Only 72% posted a thank
you 6-10 working days 17%
> 10 working days 5%
*mystery shopping August 2008
No written thank
28%
you

7. 2
Tell stories.
Real, vivid, memorable ones.

8. Mark’s mum doesn’t
know he’s sleeping rough,
and that’s not the worst of it...

9. “...For Mark it all started when he went into care aged just 11.
Of course there have been plenty of struggles along the way,
and frankly, he doesn’t blame anyone but himself. He’s in his
thirties now, and only became homeless three years ago after
returning to Ireland from the UK, reluctantly leaving his two
children and broken marriage behind him...”
“...As if things weren’t bad enough, Mark’s life took an even
worse turn shortly afterwards. He was knocked down by a
vehicle that mounted the pavement and came to rest on his leg,
badly injuring his ankle. While in hospital having his injuries
treated, Mark’s leg wound became infected with the MRSA
virus...”

10. 3
Write a longer letter.
And long doesn’t mean 2 pages.

12. David Ogilvy
“All my experience says that for a great many products, long copy sells more than
short. ... I could give you countless ... examples of long copy which has made the cash
register ring, notably for Mercedes cars. Not only in the United States, but all over the
world.
I believe, without any research to support me, that advertisements with long copy
convey the impression that you have something important to say, whether people read the
copy or not.
Direct response advertisers know that short copy doesn’t sell. In split run tests, long
copy invariably outsells short copy.”
“Only amateurs use short copy”

13. 4
Personalise. And, <firstname>, not
just by using my name here & there.

14. 4 things to personalise
‣ Ask amount
‣ Theme or topic
‣ Giving history
‣ Survey data

15. 5
How much to ask for?
The right amount.

16. 6
Don’t be scared.
Ask for more money.

18. Ask for more!
Ask Amount % Response Average Gift
Last gift -50% 5.5% €72
Last gift +20% 8.4% €83

19. 7
Ask more often.

20. 8
In fact, make sure you do actually
ask for money.

21. 9
Don’t ask for money.
Sometimes.

23. 10
Make it different. Please.

26. 11
Envelopes have two sides.

27. Women’s Aid outer envelope
Irish Heart Foundation reply envelope
Cork Simon outer envelope

28. 12
Always have a PS.

29. 90% of recipients read the PS first.
The PS is the lead.

30. 13
Use a serif typeface for body copy.
Not a sans serif.

31. Sans vs Serif
Comprehension levels: Good Fair Poor
Serif type 67% 19% 14%
Sans serif type 12% 23% 65%
from Colin Wheildon, Type & Layout

32. 14
Make the type bigger.
We don’t all have perfect eyesight.

34. 15
And while you’re at it, make the
forms bigger.

36. 16
... And the boxes. Don’t forget the
boxes.

37. Typography Checklist
‣ Serif face for body copy
‣ Avoid quirky faces and large amounts of italics
‣ 12pt type with at least 2pts of leading
‣ Lines between paragraphs
‣ Indent paragraphs
‣ Big tick boxes & plenty of room on forms

38. 17–25
Read these books.

39. Read these books
‣ Why I Write - George Orwell
‣ Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion -
Robert B. Cialdini
‣ Made to Stick - Chip & Dan Heath
‣ The Elements of Style - Strunk & White
‣ The IDM Marketing Guide

40. Read these books
‣ The Political Brain - Drew Westen
‣ Good to Great and the Social Sectors - Jim
Collins
‣ Type & Layout - Jim Wheildon
‣ Who will run the frog hospital? - Lorrie Moore

41. 26
And read this one too...
(*recommended by Conor Byrne)

42. Read this book too
‣ Common Sense Direct Marketing
- Drayton Bird

43. 27
It’s not about you.
It’s about the donor.

44. 28
Invite your donors over for a nice
cup of tea.

47. 29
Don’t forget your lapsed donors.

48. Lapsed vs Cold
Average Cold Lapsed
Campaign (A) 0.30% 0.67%
Campaign (B) 0.80% 2.17%
Campaign (C) 2.66% 6.95%

49. 30
Call and say hi.

51. 31
Don’t personalise.
In fact, drop the address completely.

52. 32
Be smart about your door drops.

53. 33
Add an envelope.

54. Enveloped door drops will double response.
At least.

55. 34
Use a celebrity.
Just make sure it’s the right one.

57. 35
Use an involvement device.

59. 36
If you’ve got the photos,
flaunt ‘em.

63. 37
Ask your donors to recommend you.

65. 38
Ask your donors to
ask their friends.

66. 39
Watch Mad Men.
(BBC 4, Tuesday, 10pm).

68. 40
Say ‘thank you’ again.
And again.

70. 41–45
Subscribe to these blogs

71. Blogs
‣ The Agitator
www.theagitator.net
‣ Fundraising Recession Watch
recessionwatch.blogspot.com
‣ Conor Byrne
conorbyrne.wordpress.com
‣ Donor Power
www.donorpowerblog.com
‣ Sean Triner
seantriner.blogspot.com

72. 46
Email your donors.

74. 47
Use personalised landing pages.

75. 48
Pay for search.
(Yes, people do click on the ads).

76. Recruiting with Adwords
‣ Cost per click: < €0.50
‣ 7% of click-throughs signed-up
(entered email address)
‣ Cost per new email address of €6.70
Campaign example 2008

77. 49
Make the most of video.

79. 50
Optimise your SEO.
(Can I find you online?)

80. Google Ireland only search: “third world charities”

81. 51
Use Twitter to engage your donors.
(*hat tip to Howard Lake).

82. “Try out the newer channels like Twitter. Some of your supporters will already be using it, so will love the
opportunity to engage with you in this way. Twitter is a good way of building up an opt-in list, but don't use
it for plain fundraising asks. It's more of a conversation - use it to listen and learn from your supportersquot;
– Howard Lake, fundraising.co.uk

83. 52
Audience comes first.

84. 53
Use subscription & mail order lists
before demographic ones.

85. 54
Apply as many relevant selectors to
cold mailing lists as you can.

87. 55–64
Our top 10 copywriting tips.

88. Copywriting Top 10
‣ Use ‘I’ and ‘You’. Especially ‘You’
‣ Use simple English.
‣ Use short sentences and vary the lengths.
‣ Use short paragraphs and vary the lengths.
‣ Avoid jargon.

89. Copywriting Top 10
‣ Use active rather than passive language.
‣ Make sure it sounds like someone talking.
‣ Ask for money, not support.
‣ Make it urgent.
‣ Be concise and to the point. But make it as long
as it needs to be to convince the reader.

90. 65
Designate funds. Donors don’t want
to pay for the paperclips.

92. 66
Test stuff.
In fact, test lots of stuff.

93. Things to test
‣ Ask amounts
‣ Additions - leaflet, car sticker, postcard...
‣ Stamp vs Ceadúnas
‣ Cash vs direct debit
‣ New pack vs control
‣ Plain envelope vs photo or teaser

94. 67
Get set up for direct debit. Now.
(And apply for DD Plus tomorrow).

95. 68
Offer your monthly givers a holiday.

96. 69
We’re in a recession.
So SPEND MORE MONEY!

97. Prioritise donor care & retention.
‣
Don’t forget about recruitment.
‣
Be realistic. Plan for lower returns.
‣
Invest in the areas that give you the best return.
‣
All our data over the last six months suggests direct
marketing is holding it’s own or increasing.

98. 70
Really get to know your data.

99. 71
Segment by recency, frequency
& value.

100. Recency Value
< 12 months €1000+
Frequency
12-24
€250-€999
months 1 gift
24-36
€100-€249
months 2+ gifts
36-48
€50-99
months
> 4 years < €50

101. 72
Spend the most time and money on
your best donors.

102. Pareto Principle
80% of your income will come from
20% of your donors.

103. 73–82
10 more tips.
(*suggested by George in TW CAT)

104. George’s tips
‣ Authenticity. ‣ Stamp on outer envelope.
‣ Ask volunteers for a ‣ Ask your trustees for their
donation. address books.
‣ Hand-sign high value ‣ Tell your donors what their
donors. donations have achieved.
‣ Hide the matching codes. ‣ Use some thank you letters
to recruit direct debits.
‣ Variable tax copy - how
‣ Use reminder mailings to
much the extra will
achieve. boost income.

105. 83
Forget ROI.
It’s net income that matters.

106. Which would you prefer?
(and which would your donors prefer?)
Net
Cost Income ROI
Income
Campaign
€25,000 €100,000 4:1 €75,000
(A)
Campaign
€50,000 €150,000 3:1 €100,000
(B)

107. 84–89
Use the six levers of influence.

108. The psychology of
persuasion
‣ Reciprocation
...do your donors a favour.
‣ Commitment & consistency
...encourage donors to make a public commitment &
remind them why they supported you in the first place.
‣ Social proof
...if everyone else is doing it then why aren’t we?

109. The psychology of
persuasion
‣ Liking
...is your organisation likable?
‣ Authority
...look and sound like you know what you’re talking
about.
‣ Scarcity
...what’s limited is valuable

110. 90
Add stuff.
But only if it makes sense.

112. 91
Visit SOFII regularly.
(www.sofii.org)

114. 92
You don’t have to reinvent the
wheel every time.

116. 93
Donate to loads of charities.
Especially your own.

117. 94
Include an ask in your newsletter.
(Or even just an reply envelope).

118. 95
Don’t forget to make the most of
tax-efficient giving.

119. 96-101
George Orwell’s six commands for
better writing.

120. Orwell’s Rules
‣ Never use a metaphor, simile or other figure of speech
which you are used to seeing in print.
‣ Never use a long word when a short one will do.
‣ If it is possible to cut a word out, always cut it out.
‣ Never use the passive where you can use the active.
‣ Never use a foreign phrase, a scientific word or a jargon
word if you can think of an everyday English equivalent.
‣ Break any of these rules sooner than say anything
outright barbarous.

121. Thank You
www.askdirect.ie
www.slideshare.net/damianob
damian@askdirect.ie