SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 16
Private Video
Marketplaces
The New Gateway to Ad Budgets?



Digital Publishing Summit
March 18, 2013
There is a shift happening.
Content used to be the proxy for audience…
…but audiences are becoming fragmented
and migrating to new platforms.
61.6%




                                                                                                                                 12.9%




                                                                                                                       2003



                                                                                                                                     2009

                                                                                                                                            2012
                                                                                                                              2006
                                                                      1982

                                                                             1985



                                                                                           1991



                                                                                                         1997

                                                                                                                2000
1952

       1955

              1958

                     1961

                            1964

                                   1967

                                          1970

                                                 1973

                                                        1976

                                                               1979




                                                                                    1988



                                                                                                  1994
                                                                                                                              Source: Nielsen
So where is the audience?

            Time Spent on Mobile Devices
                       (min/day)
            80


            60


            40


            20


            0
                 2009   2010   2011    2012
                                  eMarketer, 2013
So where is the audience?
                   Time Spent Per Week
                     with Online Video
                          (hrs:min)
                                                       4:20


                                          3:26

                            2:53

                 2:20




                2009       2010          2011          2012
               Source: Arbitron and Edison Research,
               “The Infinite Dial”, 2012
How are advertisers buying video?

2011   2012

TV Upfront                    44%
                      19%

Trading Desks         19%

                11%
DSPs
                             36%

                11%
Exchanges
                            32%

                                                    61%
Ad Networks
                                                                               81%

Direct from                                                               78%
Publishers                                   52%

                              Source: Adap.tv/Digiday Video State of the Industry Survey
Programmatic buying has

                    tripled
2011   2012




                       11%
DSPs
                                                                             36%



                       11%
Exchanges
                                                                    32%


                             Source: Adap.tv/Digiday Video State of the Industry Survey
Manual video buying is declining


 manual




2012                                                         2017
                Digital Media Buying Forecast, 2012 To 2017
                Joanna O’Connell, Niki Scevak and Anthony Mullen, October 9, 2012
Programmatic Video buying is growing
                                                                            > 65%
                 a compound annual
                     rate of 17%
        manual




< 30%




   2012                                                          2017
                    Digital Media Buying Forecast, 2012 To 2017
                    Joanna O’Connell, Niki Scevak and Anthony Mullen, October 9, 2012
The drums are beating!
“Ford Embraces Programmatic Buying” - MediaPost
   “Programmatic Buying is Taking Over the Media-Buying Space”
          – Bob Arnold, Global Strategy Director, Kellogg’s

“Nielsen, ComScore
                                “Top-tier Marketers See a
Battle for Online
                                Future in Programmatic
Audience Ratings” –             Buys” - SmartBrief
Social Times

   “Group M: Programmatic Surges”- AdExchanger

“The Next Big Thing In Digital Marketing: Programmatic” – ClickZ
Private marketplace
your ability to sell your
audience at scale,
programmatically,
  across all of your content
channels and devices
8%                      28%   Publishers Using Private
                                          Marketplaces for Video
Currently        Within 12 Months
What does a private marketplace look like?

 Proprietary   3rd party       Audience          Rich media        Brand
                              auditing and
    data         data         verification         vendor      Study/survey’s


    Demand                                                    Supply
    Sources                                                   Sources

Invited buyers                                                 O&O
 - committed                   Private                    Syndicated
                                                            player
Invited buyers
     – spot
                                Video
                                                          Publisher
Invited buyers                Marketplace                partnerships
   – RTB API


                                  API


                           Back office systems
PRESENTED BY



             Henk Van Niekerk
                       VP, Platform




One Waters Park Drive, Suite 250
San Mateo, CA 94403                   www.adap.tv
You can find this data and
 more industry insights at
     The Video Wire
      www.blog.adap.tv

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Semelhante a DPS: Adap.tv Presents: Private Video Marketplaces – The New Gateway to Ad Budgets?

05.05.2011 monetizing content on mobile final miguel lópez quesada
05.05.2011 monetizing content on mobile final  miguel lópez quesada05.05.2011 monetizing content on mobile final  miguel lópez quesada
05.05.2011 monetizing content on mobile final miguel lópez quesadaMiguel López-Quesada
 
Slush 2012 david gardner
Slush 2012 david gardnerSlush 2012 david gardner
Slush 2012 david gardnerDavid Gardner
 
Clipperton Finance - Ad tech conference, oct 23, 2012
Clipperton Finance - Ad tech conference, oct 23, 2012Clipperton Finance - Ad tech conference, oct 23, 2012
Clipperton Finance - Ad tech conference, oct 23, 2012Nicolas von Bulow
 
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event - London -2012/10/23
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event - London -2012/10/23Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event - London -2012/10/23
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event - London -2012/10/23Stephane Valorge
 
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event London 121023
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event London 121023Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event London 121023
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event London 121023Clipperton Finance
 
The internet as a social phenomenon
The internet as a social phenomenonThe internet as a social phenomenon
The internet as a social phenomenonMads Holmen
 
Engagement Everywhere :: The Future of Digital
Engagement Everywhere :: The Future of DigitalEngagement Everywhere :: The Future of Digital
Engagement Everywhere :: The Future of DigitalRyan Manchee
 
Advocate Consulting - Tangoe Summit Keynote Presentation 2012
Advocate Consulting - Tangoe Summit Keynote Presentation 2012Advocate Consulting - Tangoe Summit Keynote Presentation 2012
Advocate Consulting - Tangoe Summit Keynote Presentation 2012Advocate Consulting
 
The CEO’s Dilemma - How to drive efficient innovation in the organization
The CEO’s Dilemma - How to drive efficient innovation in the organizationThe CEO’s Dilemma - How to drive efficient innovation in the organization
The CEO’s Dilemma - How to drive efficient innovation in the organizationJoeBarkai
 
Mobile Marketing 2009 D2C
Mobile Marketing 2009 D2CMobile Marketing 2009 D2C
Mobile Marketing 2009 D2CKuan Wu
 
Lecture 1 - Knowledge, technological change and Innovation Studies
Lecture 1 - Knowledge, technological change and Innovation StudiesLecture 1 - Knowledge, technological change and Innovation Studies
Lecture 1 - Knowledge, technological change and Innovation StudiesUNU.MERIT
 
Online Video: Threat or Opportunity (2012 NAB Show)
Online Video: Threat or Opportunity (2012 NAB Show)Online Video: Threat or Opportunity (2012 NAB Show)
Online Video: Threat or Opportunity (2012 NAB Show)Andrew Taylor
 
Mobile megatrends 2012
Mobile megatrends 2012Mobile megatrends 2012
Mobile megatrends 2012SlashData
 
Congratulations, your brand is about to be obsolete
Congratulations, your brand is about to be obsoleteCongratulations, your brand is about to be obsolete
Congratulations, your brand is about to be obsoletewilliam charnock
 
2012 the year we changed banking by resurgent performance
2012 the year we changed banking by resurgent performance2012 the year we changed banking by resurgent performance
2012 the year we changed banking by resurgent performanceNatalie Hall
 
Mkt deparz - presentation - group j
Mkt   deparz - presentation - group jMkt   deparz - presentation - group j
Mkt deparz - presentation - group jDaniel Missri
 
Branding Aquí y Ahora - Ponencia Kodak
Branding Aquí y Ahora - Ponencia KodakBranding Aquí y Ahora - Ponencia Kodak
Branding Aquí y Ahora - Ponencia Kodakazk
 
The World Goes Mobile
The World Goes MobileThe World Goes Mobile
The World Goes MobileInMobi
 

Semelhante a DPS: Adap.tv Presents: Private Video Marketplaces – The New Gateway to Ad Budgets? (20)

05.05.2011 monetizing content on mobile final miguel lópez quesada
05.05.2011 monetizing content on mobile final  miguel lópez quesada05.05.2011 monetizing content on mobile final  miguel lópez quesada
05.05.2011 monetizing content on mobile final miguel lópez quesada
 
Slush 2012 david gardner
Slush 2012 david gardnerSlush 2012 david gardner
Slush 2012 david gardner
 
Clipperton Finance - Ad tech conference, oct 23, 2012
Clipperton Finance - Ad tech conference, oct 23, 2012Clipperton Finance - Ad tech conference, oct 23, 2012
Clipperton Finance - Ad tech conference, oct 23, 2012
 
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event - London -2012/10/23
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event - London -2012/10/23Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event - London -2012/10/23
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event - London -2012/10/23
 
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event London 121023
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event London 121023Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event London 121023
Clipperton Finance Ad Tech Event London 121023
 
Enterprise Web 2.0
Enterprise Web 2.0Enterprise Web 2.0
Enterprise Web 2.0
 
The internet as a social phenomenon
The internet as a social phenomenonThe internet as a social phenomenon
The internet as a social phenomenon
 
Engagement Everywhere :: The Future of Digital
Engagement Everywhere :: The Future of DigitalEngagement Everywhere :: The Future of Digital
Engagement Everywhere :: The Future of Digital
 
Advocate Consulting - Tangoe Summit Keynote Presentation 2012
Advocate Consulting - Tangoe Summit Keynote Presentation 2012Advocate Consulting - Tangoe Summit Keynote Presentation 2012
Advocate Consulting - Tangoe Summit Keynote Presentation 2012
 
The CEO’s Dilemma - How to drive efficient innovation in the organization
The CEO’s Dilemma - How to drive efficient innovation in the organizationThe CEO’s Dilemma - How to drive efficient innovation in the organization
The CEO’s Dilemma - How to drive efficient innovation in the organization
 
Mobile Marketing 2009 D2C
Mobile Marketing 2009 D2CMobile Marketing 2009 D2C
Mobile Marketing 2009 D2C
 
Lecture 1 - Knowledge, technological change and Innovation Studies
Lecture 1 - Knowledge, technological change and Innovation StudiesLecture 1 - Knowledge, technological change and Innovation Studies
Lecture 1 - Knowledge, technological change and Innovation Studies
 
Online Video: Threat or Opportunity (2012 NAB Show)
Online Video: Threat or Opportunity (2012 NAB Show)Online Video: Threat or Opportunity (2012 NAB Show)
Online Video: Threat or Opportunity (2012 NAB Show)
 
Mobile megatrends 2012
Mobile megatrends 2012Mobile megatrends 2012
Mobile megatrends 2012
 
Congratulations, your brand is about to be obsolete
Congratulations, your brand is about to be obsoleteCongratulations, your brand is about to be obsolete
Congratulations, your brand is about to be obsolete
 
Printed Newspaper Innovation
Printed Newspaper InnovationPrinted Newspaper Innovation
Printed Newspaper Innovation
 
2012 the year we changed banking by resurgent performance
2012 the year we changed banking by resurgent performance2012 the year we changed banking by resurgent performance
2012 the year we changed banking by resurgent performance
 
Mkt deparz - presentation - group j
Mkt   deparz - presentation - group jMkt   deparz - presentation - group j
Mkt deparz - presentation - group j
 
Branding Aquí y Ahora - Ponencia Kodak
Branding Aquí y Ahora - Ponencia KodakBranding Aquí y Ahora - Ponencia Kodak
Branding Aquí y Ahora - Ponencia Kodak
 
The World Goes Mobile
The World Goes MobileThe World Goes Mobile
The World Goes Mobile
 

Mais de Digiday

Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Sellwin
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | SellwinAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Sellwin
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | SellwinDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | OneSpace
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | OneSpaceAmazon Strategies January 2019 | OneSpace
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | OneSpaceDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Tatari
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | TatariAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Tatari
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | TatariDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | 23andme
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | 23andmeAmazon Strategies January 2019 | 23andme
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | 23andmeDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Booyah
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | BooyahAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Booyah
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | BooyahDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Publicis
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | PublicisAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Publicis
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | PublicisDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Perpetua
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | PerpetuaAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Perpetua
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | PerpetuaDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Podean
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | PodeanAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Podean
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | PodeanDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | eos
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | eosAmazon Strategies January 2019 | eos
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | eosDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | iCrossing
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | iCrossingAmazon Strategies January 2019 | iCrossing
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | iCrossingDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Dash Hudson
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Dash HudsonAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Dash Hudson
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Dash HudsonDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Direct Agents & Carhartt
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Direct Agents & CarharttAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Direct Agents & Carhartt
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Direct Agents & CarharttDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | WellPath
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | WellPathAmazon Strategies January 2019 | WellPath
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | WellPathDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Tinuiti
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | TinuitiAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Tinuiti
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | TinuitiDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Belkin
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | BelkinAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Belkin
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | BelkinDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Stella Rising
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Stella RisingAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Stella Rising
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Stella RisingDigiday
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Moroccanoil
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | MoroccanoilAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Moroccanoil
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | MoroccanoilDigiday
 
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | NASCAR
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | NASCARDigiday Brand Summit December 2019 | NASCAR
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | NASCARDigiday
 
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | Recess
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | RecessDigiday Brand Summit December 2019 | Recess
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | RecessDigiday
 
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | LipLove
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | LipLoveDigiday Brand Summit December 2019 | LipLove
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | LipLoveDigiday
 

Mais de Digiday (20)

Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Sellwin
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | SellwinAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Sellwin
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Sellwin
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | OneSpace
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | OneSpaceAmazon Strategies January 2019 | OneSpace
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | OneSpace
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Tatari
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | TatariAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Tatari
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Tatari
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | 23andme
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | 23andmeAmazon Strategies January 2019 | 23andme
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | 23andme
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Booyah
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | BooyahAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Booyah
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Booyah
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Publicis
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | PublicisAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Publicis
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Publicis
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Perpetua
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | PerpetuaAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Perpetua
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Perpetua
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Podean
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | PodeanAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Podean
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Podean
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | eos
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | eosAmazon Strategies January 2019 | eos
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | eos
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | iCrossing
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | iCrossingAmazon Strategies January 2019 | iCrossing
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | iCrossing
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Dash Hudson
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Dash HudsonAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Dash Hudson
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Dash Hudson
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Direct Agents & Carhartt
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Direct Agents & CarharttAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Direct Agents & Carhartt
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Direct Agents & Carhartt
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | WellPath
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | WellPathAmazon Strategies January 2019 | WellPath
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | WellPath
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Tinuiti
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | TinuitiAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Tinuiti
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Tinuiti
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Belkin
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | BelkinAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Belkin
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Belkin
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Stella Rising
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Stella RisingAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Stella Rising
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Stella Rising
 
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Moroccanoil
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | MoroccanoilAmazon Strategies January 2019 | Moroccanoil
Amazon Strategies January 2019 | Moroccanoil
 
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | NASCAR
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | NASCARDigiday Brand Summit December 2019 | NASCAR
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | NASCAR
 
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | Recess
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | RecessDigiday Brand Summit December 2019 | Recess
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | Recess
 
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | LipLove
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | LipLoveDigiday Brand Summit December 2019 | LipLove
Digiday Brand Summit December 2019 | LipLove
 

DPS: Adap.tv Presents: Private Video Marketplaces – The New Gateway to Ad Budgets?

  • 1. Private Video Marketplaces The New Gateway to Ad Budgets? Digital Publishing Summit March 18, 2013
  • 2. There is a shift happening. Content used to be the proxy for audience…
  • 3. …but audiences are becoming fragmented and migrating to new platforms. 61.6% 12.9% 2003 2009 2012 2006 1982 1985 1991 1997 2000 1952 1955 1958 1961 1964 1967 1970 1973 1976 1979 1988 1994 Source: Nielsen
  • 4. So where is the audience? Time Spent on Mobile Devices (min/day) 80 60 40 20 0 2009 2010 2011 2012 eMarketer, 2013
  • 5. So where is the audience? Time Spent Per Week with Online Video (hrs:min) 4:20 3:26 2:53 2:20 2009 2010 2011 2012 Source: Arbitron and Edison Research, “The Infinite Dial”, 2012
  • 6. How are advertisers buying video? 2011 2012 TV Upfront 44% 19% Trading Desks 19% 11% DSPs 36% 11% Exchanges 32% 61% Ad Networks 81% Direct from 78% Publishers 52% Source: Adap.tv/Digiday Video State of the Industry Survey
  • 7. Programmatic buying has tripled 2011 2012 11% DSPs 36% 11% Exchanges 32% Source: Adap.tv/Digiday Video State of the Industry Survey
  • 8. Manual video buying is declining manual 2012 2017 Digital Media Buying Forecast, 2012 To 2017 Joanna O’Connell, Niki Scevak and Anthony Mullen, October 9, 2012
  • 9. Programmatic Video buying is growing > 65% a compound annual rate of 17% manual < 30% 2012 2017 Digital Media Buying Forecast, 2012 To 2017 Joanna O’Connell, Niki Scevak and Anthony Mullen, October 9, 2012
  • 10. The drums are beating! “Ford Embraces Programmatic Buying” - MediaPost “Programmatic Buying is Taking Over the Media-Buying Space” – Bob Arnold, Global Strategy Director, Kellogg’s “Nielsen, ComScore “Top-tier Marketers See a Battle for Online Future in Programmatic Audience Ratings” – Buys” - SmartBrief Social Times “Group M: Programmatic Surges”- AdExchanger “The Next Big Thing In Digital Marketing: Programmatic” – ClickZ
  • 11. Private marketplace your ability to sell your audience at scale, programmatically, across all of your content channels and devices
  • 12.
  • 13. 8% 28% Publishers Using Private Marketplaces for Video Currently Within 12 Months
  • 14. What does a private marketplace look like? Proprietary 3rd party Audience Rich media Brand auditing and data data verification vendor Study/survey’s Demand Supply Sources Sources Invited buyers O&O - committed Private Syndicated player Invited buyers – spot Video Publisher Invited buyers Marketplace partnerships – RTB API API Back office systems
  • 15. PRESENTED BY Henk Van Niekerk VP, Platform One Waters Park Drive, Suite 250 San Mateo, CA 94403 www.adap.tv
  • 16. You can find this data and more industry insights at The Video Wire www.blog.adap.tv

Notas do Editor

  1. What ’s happening now… brands still want to be next to content, but their audiences are everywhere. Why are we seeing this growing trend in programmatic video buying? 15 years ago, it was easy to buy an audience. Working with a few broadcast networks enabled you to reach 80% of your target market.
  2. Why are we seeing this growing trend in programmatic video buying? 15 years ago, it was easy to buy an audience. Working with a few broadcast networks enabled you to reach 80% of your target market.
  3. Jason Bazinet , Citigroup Change in Same Day ratings
  4. When advertisers were asked where they buy their online video ad inventory, the most common answer was ad networks at 73 percent. However, the growth in use of ad networks remained relatively flat. The more interesting story is the substantial rise in inventory sourcing via automated environments. It would appear that advertisers are demanding pricing efficiency and are finding it from a mix of suppliers including exchanges (29 percent vs. 15 percent in 2011), demand-side platforms or DSPs (32 percent vs. 15 percent in 2011) and trading desks (27 percent). Trading desks were included for the first time as a choice in this year ’s study but came out of the gate right from the start.
  5. When advertisers were asked where they buy their online video ad inventory, the most common answer was ad networks at 73 percent. However, the growth in use of ad networks remained relatively flat. The more interesting story is the substantial rise in inventory sourcing via automated environments. It would appear that advertisers are demanding pricing efficiency and are finding it from a mix of suppliers including exchanges (29 percent vs. 15 percent in 2011), demand-side platforms or DSPs (32 percent vs. 15 percent in 2011) and trading desks (27 percent). Trading desks were included for the first time as a choice in this year ’s study but came out of the gate right from the start.
  6. When advertisers were asked where they buy their online video ad inventory, the most common answer was ad networks at 73 percent. However, the growth in use of ad networks remained relatively flat. The more interesting story is the substantial rise in inventory sourcing via automated environments. It would appear that advertisers are demanding pricing efficiency and are finding it from a mix of suppliers including exchanges (29 percent vs. 15 percent in 2011), demand-side platforms or DSPs (32 percent vs. 15 percent in 2011) and trading desks (27 percent). Trading desks were included for the first time as a choice in this year ’s study but came out of the gate right from the start.