SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 16
Single Payer Universal Health Insurance for the USA William C. Hsiao, Ph.D. FSA K.T. Li Professor of Economics Harvard School of Public Health PNHP 2009 Annual Meeting October 24, 2009 Cambridge, MA
Single Payer ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Single-payer and Non-Single Payer-Advanced Nations Canada, UK, Taiwan, New Zealand,   Germany, Japan USA Singapore Single Payer Non-Single Payer Australia
A Closer Examination of Single Payer ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
An Example: Taiwan ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Taiwanses Single-Payer Organized ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
 
Advantages of Single-Payer  (Bend the Curve) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Behind The Bill: Who Pays What UCLA Medical  Center (Los Angeles) Oregon Health  and Science  University (Portland) Jamaica  Hospital (Queens, NY) Johns  Hopkins Hospital (Baltimore) Grinnell Regional Medical Center (Grinnell, Iowa)
 
 
Disadvantages of Single-Payer  (USA) Patients Fewer choice of insurance plans Physicians • Income • Monitor medical practice Hospitals Revenue  Pharmaceutical and Medical Devise Companies Rate of diffusion for new products Profits Society: Technological Advancement ?
Technological Advancements ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Political and Technical Feasibility of Single-Payer in the USA ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
A Simple Fact: One Person’s Expense Is Another’s Income ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
THANK YOU

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Cortese/Korsmo Presentation
Cortese/Korsmo PresentationCortese/Korsmo Presentation
Cortese/Korsmo PresentationLee Aase
 
Data Governance for Real-World Evidence: Cross-country differences and recomm...
Data Governance for Real-World Evidence: Cross-country differences and recomm...Data Governance for Real-World Evidence: Cross-country differences and recomm...
Data Governance for Real-World Evidence: Cross-country differences and recomm...Office of Health Economics
 
Transitioning to Value Based Care: Tennessee Oncology, A Case Study
Transitioning to Value Based Care: Tennessee Oncology, A Case StudyTransitioning to Value Based Care: Tennessee Oncology, A Case Study
Transitioning to Value Based Care: Tennessee Oncology, A Case StudyWes Chapman
 
Will There Be a Productivity Revolution in Health Care? - David Cutler
Will There Be a Productivity Revolution in Health Care? - David CutlerWill There Be a Productivity Revolution in Health Care? - David Cutler
Will There Be a Productivity Revolution in Health Care? - David CutlerWSU
 
Idea hour Kindred Healthcare
Idea hour Kindred HealthcareIdea hour Kindred Healthcare
Idea hour Kindred HealthcareInnovateLTC
 
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Integration of Medical and Behavioral Health (IBMH) ...
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Integration of Medical and Behavioral Health (IBMH) ...Telehealth Secrets 2019: Integration of Medical and Behavioral Health (IBMH) ...
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Integration of Medical and Behavioral Health (IBMH) ...VSee
 
Deloitte innovacion health
Deloitte innovacion healthDeloitte innovacion health
Deloitte innovacion healthgbra80
 
Dr. Kapoor Tallahassee Democrat op-ed - Jan. 2013
Dr. Kapoor Tallahassee Democrat op-ed - Jan. 2013Dr. Kapoor Tallahassee Democrat op-ed - Jan. 2013
Dr. Kapoor Tallahassee Democrat op-ed - Jan. 2013Rebecca Sage
 
Jay Crosson on integrated care - lessons from the US
Jay Crosson on integrated care - lessons from the USJay Crosson on integrated care - lessons from the US
Jay Crosson on integrated care - lessons from the USThe King's Fund
 
Integrated Clinical Engagement Model To Improve Quality Of Care
Integrated Clinical Engagement Model To Improve Quality Of CareIntegrated Clinical Engagement Model To Improve Quality Of Care
Integrated Clinical Engagement Model To Improve Quality Of CareSaji Salam MD,MBA
 
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Why Patients Don't Want Telehealth - Gregory Truex, ...
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Why Patients Don't Want Telehealth - Gregory Truex, ...Telehealth Secrets 2019: Why Patients Don't Want Telehealth - Gregory Truex, ...
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Why Patients Don't Want Telehealth - Gregory Truex, ...VSee
 
Martin Gaynor: "Supersized: The Rise of the Hospital Giants," 5.19.15
Martin Gaynor: "Supersized: The Rise of the Hospital Giants," 5.19.15Martin Gaynor: "Supersized: The Rise of the Hospital Giants," 5.19.15
Martin Gaynor: "Supersized: The Rise of the Hospital Giants," 5.19.15reportingonhealth
 
Moving Toward an Accountable Care Organization
Moving Toward an Accountable Care OrganizationMoving Toward an Accountable Care Organization
Moving Toward an Accountable Care OrganizationNASHP HealthPolicy
 
Hca 305 week 5 discussion questions
Hca 305 week 5 discussion questionsHca 305 week 5 discussion questions
Hca 305 week 5 discussion questionssiodeslochab1975
 
Physican payment options power point 07-18-16
Physican payment options power point   07-18-16Physican payment options power point   07-18-16
Physican payment options power point 07-18-16Singlepayerhawaii
 
MetroHealth presentation
MetroHealth presentationMetroHealth presentation
MetroHealth presentationmedcitynews
 

Mais procurados (20)

Cortese/Korsmo Presentation
Cortese/Korsmo PresentationCortese/Korsmo Presentation
Cortese/Korsmo Presentation
 
Trends In Healthcare
Trends In HealthcareTrends In Healthcare
Trends In Healthcare
 
Data Governance for Real-World Evidence: Cross-country differences and recomm...
Data Governance for Real-World Evidence: Cross-country differences and recomm...Data Governance for Real-World Evidence: Cross-country differences and recomm...
Data Governance for Real-World Evidence: Cross-country differences and recomm...
 
Transitioning to Value Based Care: Tennessee Oncology, A Case Study
Transitioning to Value Based Care: Tennessee Oncology, A Case StudyTransitioning to Value Based Care: Tennessee Oncology, A Case Study
Transitioning to Value Based Care: Tennessee Oncology, A Case Study
 
Will There Be a Productivity Revolution in Health Care? - David Cutler
Will There Be a Productivity Revolution in Health Care? - David CutlerWill There Be a Productivity Revolution in Health Care? - David Cutler
Will There Be a Productivity Revolution in Health Care? - David Cutler
 
Idea hour Kindred Healthcare
Idea hour Kindred HealthcareIdea hour Kindred Healthcare
Idea hour Kindred Healthcare
 
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Integration of Medical and Behavioral Health (IBMH) ...
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Integration of Medical and Behavioral Health (IBMH) ...Telehealth Secrets 2019: Integration of Medical and Behavioral Health (IBMH) ...
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Integration of Medical and Behavioral Health (IBMH) ...
 
Deloitte innovacion health
Deloitte innovacion healthDeloitte innovacion health
Deloitte innovacion health
 
Dr. Kapoor Tallahassee Democrat op-ed - Jan. 2013
Dr. Kapoor Tallahassee Democrat op-ed - Jan. 2013Dr. Kapoor Tallahassee Democrat op-ed - Jan. 2013
Dr. Kapoor Tallahassee Democrat op-ed - Jan. 2013
 
Jay Crosson on integrated care - lessons from the US
Jay Crosson on integrated care - lessons from the USJay Crosson on integrated care - lessons from the US
Jay Crosson on integrated care - lessons from the US
 
Ev 20141028 c01_en
Ev 20141028 c01_enEv 20141028 c01_en
Ev 20141028 c01_en
 
Community Health Work: Financing & Sustainability
Community Health Work: Financing & SustainabilityCommunity Health Work: Financing & Sustainability
Community Health Work: Financing & Sustainability
 
Integrated Clinical Engagement Model To Improve Quality Of Care
Integrated Clinical Engagement Model To Improve Quality Of CareIntegrated Clinical Engagement Model To Improve Quality Of Care
Integrated Clinical Engagement Model To Improve Quality Of Care
 
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Why Patients Don't Want Telehealth - Gregory Truex, ...
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Why Patients Don't Want Telehealth - Gregory Truex, ...Telehealth Secrets 2019: Why Patients Don't Want Telehealth - Gregory Truex, ...
Telehealth Secrets 2019: Why Patients Don't Want Telehealth - Gregory Truex, ...
 
Martin Gaynor: "Supersized: The Rise of the Hospital Giants," 5.19.15
Martin Gaynor: "Supersized: The Rise of the Hospital Giants," 5.19.15Martin Gaynor: "Supersized: The Rise of the Hospital Giants," 5.19.15
Martin Gaynor: "Supersized: The Rise of the Hospital Giants," 5.19.15
 
Moving Toward an Accountable Care Organization
Moving Toward an Accountable Care OrganizationMoving Toward an Accountable Care Organization
Moving Toward an Accountable Care Organization
 
Hca 305 week 5 discussion questions
Hca 305 week 5 discussion questionsHca 305 week 5 discussion questions
Hca 305 week 5 discussion questions
 
Physican payment options power point 07-18-16
Physican payment options power point   07-18-16Physican payment options power point   07-18-16
Physican payment options power point 07-18-16
 
Challenges of Health IT
Challenges of Health ITChallenges of Health IT
Challenges of Health IT
 
MetroHealth presentation
MetroHealth presentationMetroHealth presentation
MetroHealth presentation
 

Destaque

Saha Single Payer 101 NURSING Final
Saha Single Payer 101 NURSING FinalSaha Single Payer 101 NURSING Final
Saha Single Payer 101 NURSING FinalAnand Saha
 
Rob Stone On Single Payer 10 24 09
Rob Stone On Single Payer 10 24 09Rob Stone On Single Payer 10 24 09
Rob Stone On Single Payer 10 24 09Christopher Toal
 
Obamacare to Trumpcare: Where are We Going?
Obamacare to Trumpcare: Where are We Going?Obamacare to Trumpcare: Where are We Going?
Obamacare to Trumpcare: Where are We Going?Charles McLauchlin
 
Future of Certain ACA Taxes and Fees
Future of Certain ACA Taxes and FeesFuture of Certain ACA Taxes and Fees
Future of Certain ACA Taxes and FeesKelley M. Bendele
 
Medicare Reform and Single Payer
Medicare Reform and Single PayerMedicare Reform and Single Payer
Medicare Reform and Single Payermasscare
 
Single Payer System
Single Payer SystemSingle Payer System
Single Payer Systemviviewu
 
Single Payer Systems: Equity in Access to Care
Single Payer Systems: Equity in Access to CareSingle Payer Systems: Equity in Access to Care
Single Payer Systems: Equity in Access to Caresoder145
 
Compare and contrast
Compare and contrastCompare and contrast
Compare and contrastSarah Heaton
 
The Future of Health Care: A Prognosis for 2016
The Future of Health Care: A Prognosis for 2016The Future of Health Care: A Prognosis for 2016
The Future of Health Care: A Prognosis for 2016athenahealth
 
Single Payer Health Care Systems - FINAL
Single Payer Health Care Systems - FINALSingle Payer Health Care Systems - FINAL
Single Payer Health Care Systems - FINALsoder145
 
ACA After The Election: What Now?
ACA After The Election: What Now?ACA After The Election: What Now?
ACA After The Election: What Now?Jhane Wilcox, MBA
 
Health care napkin 4
Health care napkin 4Health care napkin 4
Health care napkin 4Dan Roam
 
Healthcare slide show
Healthcare slide showHealthcare slide show
Healthcare slide showgeoffb48
 
Health system models-an overview
Health system models-an overviewHealth system models-an overview
Health system models-an overviewAhmed-Refat Refat
 
Overview and Implications of the House Republican Bill
Overview and Implications of the House Republican BillOverview and Implications of the House Republican Bill
Overview and Implications of the House Republican BillEpstein Becker Green
 
Healthcare Napkins All
Healthcare Napkins AllHealthcare Napkins All
Healthcare Napkins AllDan Roam
 

Destaque (19)

Saha Single Payer 101 NURSING Final
Saha Single Payer 101 NURSING FinalSaha Single Payer 101 NURSING Final
Saha Single Payer 101 NURSING Final
 
Business case for single payer
Business case for single payerBusiness case for single payer
Business case for single payer
 
Rob Stone On Single Payer 10 24 09
Rob Stone On Single Payer 10 24 09Rob Stone On Single Payer 10 24 09
Rob Stone On Single Payer 10 24 09
 
Obamacare to Trumpcare: Where are We Going?
Obamacare to Trumpcare: Where are We Going?Obamacare to Trumpcare: Where are We Going?
Obamacare to Trumpcare: Where are We Going?
 
Future of Certain ACA Taxes and Fees
Future of Certain ACA Taxes and FeesFuture of Certain ACA Taxes and Fees
Future of Certain ACA Taxes and Fees
 
Health Reform 201
Health Reform 201Health Reform 201
Health Reform 201
 
Medicare Reform and Single Payer
Medicare Reform and Single PayerMedicare Reform and Single Payer
Medicare Reform and Single Payer
 
Single Payer System
Single Payer SystemSingle Payer System
Single Payer System
 
Single Payer Systems: Equity in Access to Care
Single Payer Systems: Equity in Access to CareSingle Payer Systems: Equity in Access to Care
Single Payer Systems: Equity in Access to Care
 
Compare and contrast
Compare and contrastCompare and contrast
Compare and contrast
 
Single Payer Health Care
Single Payer Health CareSingle Payer Health Care
Single Payer Health Care
 
The Future of Health Care: A Prognosis for 2016
The Future of Health Care: A Prognosis for 2016The Future of Health Care: A Prognosis for 2016
The Future of Health Care: A Prognosis for 2016
 
Single Payer Health Care Systems - FINAL
Single Payer Health Care Systems - FINALSingle Payer Health Care Systems - FINAL
Single Payer Health Care Systems - FINAL
 
ACA After The Election: What Now?
ACA After The Election: What Now?ACA After The Election: What Now?
ACA After The Election: What Now?
 
Health care napkin 4
Health care napkin 4Health care napkin 4
Health care napkin 4
 
Healthcare slide show
Healthcare slide showHealthcare slide show
Healthcare slide show
 
Health system models-an overview
Health system models-an overviewHealth system models-an overview
Health system models-an overview
 
Overview and Implications of the House Republican Bill
Overview and Implications of the House Republican BillOverview and Implications of the House Republican Bill
Overview and Implications of the House Republican Bill
 
Healthcare Napkins All
Healthcare Napkins AllHealthcare Napkins All
Healthcare Napkins All
 

Semelhante a Single Payer Universal Health Insurance 10 24 09

health insurance in germany and indonesia
health insurance in germany and indonesiahealth insurance in germany and indonesia
health insurance in germany and indonesianivtrip
 
InternationalHealthCareSystems.ppt
InternationalHealthCareSystems.pptInternationalHealthCareSystems.ppt
InternationalHealthCareSystems.pptAabizerPlumber1
 
Health Care Reform Summer 2009
Health Care Reform Summer 2009Health Care Reform Summer 2009
Health Care Reform Summer 2009GlennMclaurin
 
Prof. Martin Gaynor: Competition in Health Care and Health Insurance - Lesson...
Prof. Martin Gaynor: Competition in Health Care and Health Insurance - Lesson...Prof. Martin Gaynor: Competition in Health Care and Health Insurance - Lesson...
Prof. Martin Gaynor: Competition in Health Care and Health Insurance - Lesson...VATT Institute for Economic Research
 
Onc july atlanta 2011
Onc  july atlanta 2011 Onc  july atlanta 2011
Onc july atlanta 2011 Paul Grundy
 
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVU
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVUPatient Centered Medical home talk at WVU
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVUPaul Grundy
 
[Auditorio Paralelo -CADE Ejecutivos 2018] Ivy Teh: Tendencias globales en sa...
[Auditorio Paralelo -CADE Ejecutivos 2018] Ivy Teh: Tendencias globales en sa...[Auditorio Paralelo -CADE Ejecutivos 2018] Ivy Teh: Tendencias globales en sa...
[Auditorio Paralelo -CADE Ejecutivos 2018] Ivy Teh: Tendencias globales en sa...IPAE
 
Salud, casos de éxito global
Salud, casos de éxito globalSalud, casos de éxito global
Salud, casos de éxito globalIPAE
 
Access, quality and cost the three pillars of health policy
Access, quality and cost  the three pillars of health policyAccess, quality and cost  the three pillars of health policy
Access, quality and cost the three pillars of health policyNancy Short DrPH, MBA, BSN, FAAN
 
The Impact Global Pharma Cost Containment Methods in APAC
The Impact Global Pharma Cost Containment Methods in APACThe Impact Global Pharma Cost Containment Methods in APAC
The Impact Global Pharma Cost Containment Methods in APACQuintilesIMS Asia Pacific
 
013 Am09 Presentations Harris
013 Am09 Presentations  Harris013 Am09 Presentations  Harris
013 Am09 Presentations HarrisSimon Prince
 
Foreign Health Policy
Foreign Health PolicyForeign Health Policy
Foreign Health Policymimgomberg
 
Linde Wilson
Linde WilsonLinde Wilson
Linde WilsonHealthegy
 
American Medical Home Runs (1)
American Medical Home Runs (1)American Medical Home Runs (1)
American Medical Home Runs (1)Jeffrey Kang
 
2 tool to estimate patient costs literature review_final
2 tool to estimate patient costs literature review_final2 tool to estimate patient costs literature review_final
2 tool to estimate patient costs literature review_finalAira Bhabe
 
DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docx
DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docxDQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docx
DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docxelinoraudley582231
 
Healthcare
HealthcareHealthcare
HealthcareDWRandle
 

Semelhante a Single Payer Universal Health Insurance 10 24 09 (20)

health insurance in germany and indonesia
health insurance in germany and indonesiahealth insurance in germany and indonesia
health insurance in germany and indonesia
 
InternationalHealthCareSystems.ppt
InternationalHealthCareSystems.pptInternationalHealthCareSystems.ppt
InternationalHealthCareSystems.ppt
 
Health Care Reform Summer 2009
Health Care Reform Summer 2009Health Care Reform Summer 2009
Health Care Reform Summer 2009
 
Prof. Martin Gaynor: Competition in Health Care and Health Insurance - Lesson...
Prof. Martin Gaynor: Competition in Health Care and Health Insurance - Lesson...Prof. Martin Gaynor: Competition in Health Care and Health Insurance - Lesson...
Prof. Martin Gaynor: Competition in Health Care and Health Insurance - Lesson...
 
Onc july atlanta 2011
Onc  july atlanta 2011 Onc  july atlanta 2011
Onc july atlanta 2011
 
HEALT CARE
HEALT CAREHEALT CARE
HEALT CARE
 
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVU
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVUPatient Centered Medical home talk at WVU
Patient Centered Medical home talk at WVU
 
[Auditorio Paralelo -CADE Ejecutivos 2018] Ivy Teh: Tendencias globales en sa...
[Auditorio Paralelo -CADE Ejecutivos 2018] Ivy Teh: Tendencias globales en sa...[Auditorio Paralelo -CADE Ejecutivos 2018] Ivy Teh: Tendencias globales en sa...
[Auditorio Paralelo -CADE Ejecutivos 2018] Ivy Teh: Tendencias globales en sa...
 
Salud, casos de éxito global
Salud, casos de éxito globalSalud, casos de éxito global
Salud, casos de éxito global
 
Access, quality and cost the three pillars of health policy
Access, quality and cost  the three pillars of health policyAccess, quality and cost  the three pillars of health policy
Access, quality and cost the three pillars of health policy
 
The Impact Global Pharma Cost Containment Methods in APAC
The Impact Global Pharma Cost Containment Methods in APACThe Impact Global Pharma Cost Containment Methods in APAC
The Impact Global Pharma Cost Containment Methods in APAC
 
National Health Care Reform 2009
National Health Care Reform 2009National Health Care Reform 2009
National Health Care Reform 2009
 
013 Am09 Presentations Harris
013 Am09 Presentations  Harris013 Am09 Presentations  Harris
013 Am09 Presentations Harris
 
Foreign Health Policy
Foreign Health PolicyForeign Health Policy
Foreign Health Policy
 
Where Is Healthcare Going? And How Will We Get There?
Where Is Healthcare Going? And How Will We Get There? Where Is Healthcare Going? And How Will We Get There?
Where Is Healthcare Going? And How Will We Get There?
 
Linde Wilson
Linde WilsonLinde Wilson
Linde Wilson
 
American Medical Home Runs (1)
American Medical Home Runs (1)American Medical Home Runs (1)
American Medical Home Runs (1)
 
2 tool to estimate patient costs literature review_final
2 tool to estimate patient costs literature review_final2 tool to estimate patient costs literature review_final
2 tool to estimate patient costs literature review_final
 
DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docx
DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docxDQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docx
DQ 3-2Integrated health care delivery systems (IDS) was develope.docx
 
Healthcare
HealthcareHealthcare
Healthcare
 

Single Payer Universal Health Insurance 10 24 09

  • 1. Single Payer Universal Health Insurance for the USA William C. Hsiao, Ph.D. FSA K.T. Li Professor of Economics Harvard School of Public Health PNHP 2009 Annual Meeting October 24, 2009 Cambridge, MA
  • 2.
  • 3. Single-payer and Non-Single Payer-Advanced Nations Canada, UK, Taiwan, New Zealand, Germany, Japan USA Singapore Single Payer Non-Single Payer Australia
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.  
  • 8.
  • 9. Behind The Bill: Who Pays What UCLA Medical Center (Los Angeles) Oregon Health and Science University (Portland) Jamaica Hospital (Queens, NY) Johns Hopkins Hospital (Baltimore) Grinnell Regional Medical Center (Grinnell, Iowa)
  • 10.  
  • 11.  
  • 12. Disadvantages of Single-Payer (USA) Patients Fewer choice of insurance plans Physicians • Income • Monitor medical practice Hospitals Revenue Pharmaceutical and Medical Devise Companies Rate of diffusion for new products Profits Society: Technological Advancement ?
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.