This document provides an overview of a Collections Trust seminar held in Brighton in December 2014. It includes:
- Welcome and introductions by Nick Poole, CEO of the Collections Trust since 2004.
- Objectives for the seminar which are to introduce the work of the Collections Trust, explore how collections management supports audience needs, and highlight tools/resources/services.
- An overview of the Collections Trust's programs and products including standards, training, digital development, policy influence, and knowledge sharing networks. Specific programs on security, energy efficiency, pests, insurance, participation, digitization and copyright are highlighted.
3. I’m Nick Poole
CEO of the Collections Trust
since 2004, involved in the
development of national
standards & funding
programmes for museums.
4. Getting started
• Please do:
• Be an active participant
• Ask questions
• Respect information shared in confidence
• Take the opportunity to network!
5. Resources
• In your delegate pack, you have:
• Copies of these slides
• Information sheets about today’s resources
• Information about further Collections Trust events
• A Feedback & Evaluation Form
• Today’s slides can be downloaded from www.slideshare.net/collectionstrust
• All other resources available from www.collectionstrust.org.uk
6. Objectives for today
• Our objectives are to:
• Introduce you to the work of the Collections Trust
• Explore how collections management supports the needs of audiences
• Introduce the Excellence in Collections Management model
• Highlight our tools, resources and services to support your work
• Please write down 2-3 things that you want to get out of today (we’ll refer
back to these at the end of the day)
8. The Collections Trust is...
...the professional association
for people who work in
Collections Management
9. Established 1977
• To promote the education of the public by the development of museums
and similar organisations by all appropriate methods;
• To develop, promote, maintain and improve standards of collections and
information management in museums, art galleries, heritage organisations
and other collections institutions;
• To provide services and resources which improve the standards and
methods of collections management and use.
11. Our work
• Publish and make available standards, reports and resources
• Run events and training
• Support digital development
• Represent the sector and influence policy makers
• Help you network and share knowledge
12. Our programmes
• We focus on issues that are relevant to Collections Management:
• Documentation
• Digital development
• Systems development (DAMS, CMS, Web, Mobile)
• Governance
• Security
• Insurance
• Pest Management
• Copyright & IPR
• Cultural property
• Participation & engagement
13. Special programmes
• Recently we have developed resources, guidelines, factsheets and interactives
around a series of special programmes:
– Security www.collectionstrust.org.uk/security
– Energy efficiency www.collectionstrust.org.uk/energy-efficiency
– Pests! www.collectionstrust.org.uk/pest-management
– Insurance www.collectionstrust.org.uk/insurance
– Participation www.collectionstrust.org.uk/participation
– Going Digital www.collectionstrust.org.uk/going-digital
– Copyright & licensing www.collectionstrust.org.uk/copyright-and-licensing
14. Going Digital
• New three year ‘back to basics’ programme on IT in museums
• Covering:
– Basic IT audit and planning
– Photography and scanning
– Buying equipment
– Copyright
– Collections Management Systems
– Digital Asset Management Systems
– Sharing collections online
15. Going Digital
• Free tools and resources including:
– IT Audit toolkit
– Digital Strategy interactive
– Beginners Guide to Digitisation
– How-to copyright factsheets
• www.collectionstrust.org.uk/going-digital
16. Copyright and licensing
We provide free resources to help museums with copyright issues and we’re
addressing how recent legal reforms to copyright affect museums.
• Free resources at www.collectionstrust.org.uk/copyright-and-licensing
• A Copyright Seminar with expert Naomi Korn (18 February 2015, London)
www.collectionstrust.org.uk/copyright-seminar
• Copyright: A Practical Guide - updated edition available beginning of 2015
www.collectionstrust.org.uk/shop
17. Food and Drink Project
• Working with museums and creative organisations to:
– Digitise collections relating to food and drink
– Share digital records through online platforms (Culture Grid and Wikimedia)
– Develop commercial products: book and eBook; mobile app; social game;
exhibition; virtual exhibition
– Encourage collaboration between museums, the
commercial sector and creative industries
– Help museums find a new source of revenue!
• http://foodanddrinkeurope.eu/
18. The Collections Trust website
• Re-launched in July 2014
• Hundreds of practical, free resources
• The latest news from the sector
• Blog posts
• Online shop (forms and registers, publications, eBooks)
• Comprehensive listing of sector events www.collectionstrust.org.uk/upcoming-
events
• Register to receive a fortnightly e-newsletter
19.
20. Practical Guides
• Simple practical guides to key areas of Collections Management:
• Titles:
– Collections Management: A Practical Guide
– Documentation: A Practical Guide
– Copyright: A Practical Guide
– Governance & Collections: A Practical Guide
– Integrated Pest Management: A Practical Guide
• Available from www.collectionstrust.org.uk/shop
(RRP £24.99 and ebook £20.00)
21. Forms and registers
• Leading supplier of museum forms and registers
– Object Entry Forms
– Object Cards
– Exit Forms
– Simple Catalogue Cards
– Object Movement Tickets
– Transfer of Title Forms
– Accession Registers
• Available from www.collectionstrust.org.uk/shop
22. Keep in touch
• We offer several ways of keeping in touch with our work and with each
other
– Collections Management LinkedIn community (8,200 members)
– Fortnightly email newsletter
– www.twitter.com/collectiontrust
– www.facebook.com/collectionstrust
– www.slideshare.net/collectionstrust
23. About today’s seminar
This seminar is intended to
provide an overview of
current best practice in
Collections Management
24. Structure for this seminar
• Session 1: Understanding the changing expectations of audiences
• Session 2: Introducing Excellence in Collections Management
• Session 3: Collections Standards and competencies
• Session 4: The relationship between your collection and your Mission
12.40 – 13.35 LUNCH
• Session 5: How collections can drive engagement
• Session 6: Developing Digital as part of your strategy
• Session 7: Collections Management and Museum Accreditation
• Session 8: Collections & Digital Asset Management
14.45 – 15.05 BEST PRACTICE CASE STUDY
15.15 WRAPUP & CONCLUSIONS
27. Discussion
• How do you develop an understanding of the needs and expectations of your
audience?
• Are ‘millennials’ your audience, or are you catering for a completely different
set of expectations?
• How are the expectations and behaviours of your visitors changing?
32. It’s about finding the fastest,
simplest way of giving people
meaningful, emotional experiences
Not about partitioning peoples lives,
but about letting them express the
kind of connection they want to
make (including being left alone &
not having to connect to anything!)
I am...
A mum
A
teacher
A casual
gamer
Cold
Bored
An
expert
33. Discussion
• What can you do to engage different competencies/areas of interest across
your museum and help them to understand what you do?
• Does the working culture and practice in your museum make everyone feel
part of the development & use of the collection?
• How do your museum’s goals for engagement and income generation
intersect with the development & use of the collection?
• Is the collection regarded as an asset or a liability?
35. Key questions
• What does ‘excellence’ look like in managing and using a collection?
• How does this framework correspond to the minimum requirement of
Accreditation?
• What are SPECTRUM and BSI PAS 197 and how can they support excellence?
54. Key points
• Good collections management is the foundation of great museum
experiences
• Having a well-managed foundation promotes flexibility rather than
constraining it
• Any kind of development – audience participation, income generation, brand
development, outreach or digital – depends on having the basics of good
collections practice in place
• Collections management drives both accountability and creativity
55. Key questions
• How does your museum review and improve its work?
• How could ‘plan’, ‘do’, ‘review’ be applied in your work?
• Do you already measure ‘performance’ – if so, how?
57. Key topics
• The role of professional standards
• The Collections Trust Collections Standards Toolkit
• Collections Link standards resources
• Collections Management Competencies
• Structure & role of SPECTRUM
59. Legal frameworks
• Museums & Libraries Act
• Equalities Act
• Charities Act
• Cultural Property Law
• Copyright Law
• Civil rights & protections
60. Codes of Ethics
• MA Code of Ethics for Museums
• ICOM Code of Ethics
• Ethical principles associated with Charitable Status
61. Professional Standards
• Museums Accreditation Scheme
• SPECTRUM Standard
• BSI Publicly Available Specification 197 Code of Practice for Collections
Management
• BSI Publicly Available Specification 198 Environmental Management
• GIS Guidelines
62. Standards Toolkit
• Produced by Collections Trust with support from Arts Council England
• http://www.collectionstrust.org.uk/standards-toolkit/introduction
• Structured around four sections:
– Collections Development standards
– Collections Information standards
– Collections Access standards
– Collections Care & Conservation standards
65. SPECTRUM Facts & Figures
• 23,000 licensed users
• 40 countries
• 8 languages
• 17 SPECTRUM Partner systems
• Adoption as a national quality standard in 4 countries
• Interest from 5 new territories
70. Uses of SPECTRUM
• Not a mandatory standard
• A ‘recipe book’ for developing or reviewing practices in your museum
• Useful for the development of your Procedural Manual
• Promotes accountability & good practice
• Primary procedures are a requirement of Accreditation
74. Why a Competency Framework?
• Informing the teaching and training of core collections management skills
and competencies
• Promoting investment in CPD
• Raising awareness of the value and impact of CM skills on the wider
delivery of museum services
• Advocating for investment in CM competencies
• Providing a structure to engage with other industry partners eg. CC Skills,
MA, CILIP
75. Professional development
• Ensuring that museums have access to the Collections Management skills
& competencies they need:
– Teaching on University Museum Studies courses
– Providing a Competency Framework for employers
– Delivering a Collections Management Traineeships programme
– Promoting practical apprenticeships
– Free Collections Trust Seminars across England
76. Traineeships programme
• Runs between October 2014 & September 2015
• Cohort of 20 trainees
• Combination of practical workplace-based training, CPD, mentoring and
peer support
• Aimed at enabling new entrants to the profession to build their collections
management skills and confidence
• www.collectionstrust.org.uk/traineeships
80. Objects Experiences
Facts Narratives
“Our first duties are to collect,
conserve and display material
culture, to protect the nation’s
treasures and to showcase the
high points of human
creativity”
81. Objects Experiences
Facts Stories
“Our first duty is to create an
open, welcoming environment
in which people can come and
enjoy the experience of
beautiful, inspiring things”
82. Objects Experiences
Facts Stories
“It is not the objects
themselves, but the
connections between them
and the stories they can tell.
Our duty is to weave stories
and objects together to help
people understand the world
around them”
83. Objects Experiences
Facts Narratives
“Our first duty is to provide an
authoritative record of the
development of the natural
and man-made world. We
must collect and preserve
type specimens and objects
based on our authoritative
and scientific knowledge.”
85. Mission
• Mission matters more than people think!
• Two commons types of museum Mission Statement
– “We are going to change the world,” or
– “We will collect and preserve the history and heritage of [insert name
of town] and interpret it for the benefit of the public to support
education”
• It doesn’t really matter what the words are. It matters whether you
believe them, whether they inspire you and whether you are proud to say
it out loud
86. Brand
• Your museum’s ‘brand’ is the expression of who you are, what you care
about, how your museum feels about itself and the relationship you want
to have with your audience
• The brand of your museum is what people identify with, volunteer to be
part of, have in their mind when planning a visit
• Every member of staff should be a champion for the brand – if its
controlled through the marketing team, you’ll never achieve reach and
scale
• What is your museum’s brand proposition?
87. Culture
• Your museum’s working culture will get you through times of no strategy
(or money) better than a strategy will get you through times of no culture
• How well does the way your museum looks to the outside world reflect
your culture?
• Different types of museum culture:
– Evangelist
– Protectionist
– Progressive
– Bruised
– Feudal
– Collegiate
88. Culture change
• Unfreeze/disrupt the existing culture
• Introduce new ideas about how things ought to be done
• Systematically apply the new paradigm/way of working
• Re-freeze the new organisational culture*
* Repeat as required every 5-10 years...
90. Metrics
• How do you measure the value and impact of what you do?
• What kind of ‘value culture’ do you have?
– None
– Count what we can count
– Visitor numbers
– Measure visitor impact
– Measure performance
– Numbers for advocacy
– Planning with data
• Do you use your numbers for internal (planning) use or external advocacy?
91. Key points
• Museums need to be able to respond and adapt to the changing needs and
expectations of audiences
• Collections management has a fundamental role to play in supporting
managed and positive change in your museum
• The more proactively you can position collections management as an enabler
of growth, audience development and sustainability, the more central and
valuable it (and you!) become to your museum
• Not about front of house vs. back of house, conservation vs. use – it’s about
positive, managed change
94. Crowds & buzz!
How can collections
management help deliver
crowds and buzz for your
Director?
95. The ‘user journey’...
...describes how people
discover your museum, what
they do while they’re there
and how you maintain the
connection after they leave.
99. Pre-visit
(discovery)
Visit
(engagement)
Post-visit
(relationship)
‘Snackable’ content – quick, shareable,
interesting, quirky & fun, shared as widely as
possible with as many people as possible
Location-specific (iBeacon!) content
that is relevant – enabling people to
explore, discover, socialise and
promote to their networks
Deep, relevant, personal and
engaging stories, targeted
events and experiences, fresh
ideas and offers
100. Key questions
• Does your museum have profiles or personas for your key audience
segments?
• How can collections support, enhance and extend the user journey?
• Is there more collections and audience development people could be doing
to share insight?
102. Key questions
• How is your museum using technology to engage audiences?
• Do you have a Digital Strategy?
• How do you plan for the implementation of IT/digital in your museum?
• What is the role of the collection in your strategy?
103. Digital Design Principles
• Start with needs*
• Do less
• Design with data
• Do the hard work to make it simple
• Iterate. Then iterate again
• Build for inclusion
• Understand context
• Build digital services, not websites
• Be consistent, not uniform
• Make things open – it makes things better
• www.gov.uk/design-principles
(* Other people’s needs, that is...)
104. Tate Digital Strategy
• Implicitly linked to the Strategic Plan
• ‘Digital as a Dimension of Everything’
• Aligning the development of:
• Content
• IT infrastructure
• Social media
• Publishing & distribution
• Retail & income generation
105. HRP Strategic Planning
• No separate ‘Digital Strategy’
• 4 principles:
• Guardianship
• Discovery
• Showmanship
• Independence
• Digital underpins and supports the achievement of these principles, rather
than acting as a standalone priority
106. HRP Strategic Planning
VISITOR JOURNEY
7 ‘personas’
ANALYTICS & CUSTOMER DATA ASSET MANAGEMENT
IT INFRASTRUCTURE
CHANGE PROGRAMME
107. Digital Benchmarks
• A simple diagnostic tool
• Mapping progress
• Celebrating success
• Planning development
• An integrated approach
108.
109. Digital Benchmark “Range Statements”
Strategy
Level Description
0 The organisation has no strategic plan or statement of mission or purpose *
1 The organisation has a strategic plan or mission which does not reference engagement
through technology
2 The organisation has a strategic plan, which includes projects and programmes, some of
which make use of technology.
Digital is not fully integrated into the strategy, which is not regularly reviewed.
3 The organisation has a strategic plan, which includes projects and programmes, some of
which make use of technology.
Digital is integrated into the strategy, which is regularly reviewed.
4 The organisation has a strategic plan/mission in place which references the use of digital
technologies to support core delivery, or it has a separate (but connected) digital strategy
in place.
There is at least one digital champion within the senior management of the organisation.
The strategic plan is regularly reviewed and updated.
5 The organisation has a strategic plan/mission in place which integrates the use of digital
technologies to support core delivery.
The digital elements of the plan are owned and championed at a senior (Board &
management) level and supported by appropriate budgets.
Digital technologies are embedded across all teams/departments of the organisation.
Digital delivery and engagement through technology are embedded within the
organisation’s performance framework.
The strategic plan is regularly reviewed and updated.
113. Content-based marketing
• From ‘sales’ to ‘add value’
• People are drawn to platforms and content which add value
for them in their daily lives
• 3 connected strategies:
– ‘Snackable’ content
– Content-as-a-service (to support visits, education & engagement)
– ‘Vertical’ or niche content
114. Collections online
• Having things online does not automatically lead to access
• It is a significant investment of time and effort
• The 90/8/2 rule:
– 90% of your content acts as marketing for the museum
– 8% might make money if you invested heavily in it
– 2% of most collections will be a solid, bankable revenue stream
115. What people want from online collections…
CONTENT
METADATA
A BIT A LOT
118. CONTENT
METADATA
A BIT A LOT
FUN
RESEARCH
LEARNING
OUTREACH
What people want from online collections…
119. 119
CONTENT
METADATA
A BIT A LOT
FUN
RESEARCH
LEARNING
DATA MINING
COLLECTIONS
MANAGEMENT
AGGREGATION
OUTREACH
What people want from online collections…
120. 120
CONTENT
METADATA
A BIT A LOT
FUN
RESEARCH
LEARNING
DATA MINING
COLLECTIONS
MANAGEMENT
AGGREGATION
OUTREACH
Digitize relatively few things & spend your
money on quality and context
What people want from online collections…
121. CONTENT
METADATA
A BIT A LOT
FUN
RESEARCH
LEARNING
DATA MINING
COLLECTIONS
MANAGEMENT
AGGREGATION
OUTREACH
Digitize relatively few things & spend your
money on quality and context
Digitize lots of things, use standards and
don’t worry too much about promotion
What people want from online collections…
122. Defining terms: reuse
• Describes a wide spectrum of activities and applications of digital cultural
content undertaken by 3rd parties
123. Degrees of ‘open’
• Attitudes and approaches to ‘open’ reuse of museum content exist along a
sliding scale:
‘Radically’
open
Fully
commercial
124. Degrees of ‘open’
• Attitudes and approaches to ‘open’ reuse of museum content exist along a
sliding scale:
‘Radically’
open
Fully
commercial
Toe in the
water
125. Degrees of ‘open’
• Attitudes and approaches to ‘open’ reuse of museum content exist along a
sliding scale:
‘Radically’
open
Fully
commercial
Toe in the
water
Mission
driven
126. Degrees of ‘open’
• Attitudes and approaches to ‘open’ reuse of museum content exist along a
sliding scale:
‘Radically’
open
Fully
commercial
Toe in the
water
Mission
driven
Steady
state
127. Degrees of ‘open’
• Attitudes and approaches to ‘open’ reuse of museum content exist along a
sliding scale:
‘Radically’
open
Fully
commercial
Thinking
about it
Toe in the
water
Mission
driven
Steady
state
128. Perceived benefits of open
• Perceived benefits for the museum include:
– Improved public awareness of content (PR, reputation & brand equity)
– Improved discoverability of content (re-use & promotional value)
– Improved opportunities for audience participation (audience development)
– Secondary improvements in quality of content (internal use value)
• The jury’s still out – compelling evidence of significantly higher traffic through
eg. Wikipedia, but we tend to lack the metrics to assess impact of referrals on
core business
129. Perceived benefits of open
• Perceived broader/societal benefits include:
– Stimulating innovation & creativity (economic value)
– Increased educational use (delivering on mission)
– Increased use for research/scholarship (utility & economic value)
– Inter-cultural dialogue and understanding (utility value)
• Quantification of these wider benefits tends to attribute to intermediary/3rd-
party platforms, hence not always acknowledged in calculus of ROI
130. Practical steps to ‘going open’
1. Define your terms/read around the subject
2. Identify a suitable collection or sub-collection
3. Choose an appropriate license for your aims
4. Prepare your data for sharing
5. Write a blog
6. Add your data to an online repository
7. Track and evaluate impact
8. Share good news with colleagues/management
www.p2pu.org/he/groups/open-glam
131. The investment gap
• There is a critical lack of investment in content generation, staff capacity,
infrastructure, enrichment, delivery platforms, marketing and promotion and
organisational development to support income generation
• An increasing number of museums are adopting an ‘open by default’ strategy
because they lack the capacity effectively to monetise the digital content
• Lack of cost-recovery results in declining reinvestment in further activity
• A lack of clear and coherent policy results in a culture of case-by-case decision-
making, inconsistency and a lack of clarity about the business case for
reinvestment
132. Learning to COPE
Developing practical steps to
ensure that your collections
and systems are fit-for-
purpose to support your
museum
134. ‘Create Once, Publish Everywhere’
• If collections and collections-based information are to play their part in
enhancing and extending the visitor experience, they need to be discoverable
and usable outside the museum and its website
• ‘COPE’ is the Collections Trust’s strategy for developing collections
information and collections-related content that supports:
• Collections care
• Collections discovery & re-use
• Learning and intepretation
• Visitor engagement
135. COPE in practice, from this...
COLLECTIONS
DOCUMENTATION
DIGITAL ASSET
MANAGEMENT
INFORMATION /
RECORDS
SYSTEMS OF RECORD
SYSTEMS OF
ENGAGEMENT
USER CHANNELS &
PLATFORMSBYOD
Museum
website
Gallery
interactives
Social
media
Aggregators
140. Guiding principle
Collections are central to the function of a
museum.
The management of the collections within an
Accredited museum is consistent with the
statement of purpose, policies and strategic vision
for the organisation.
To do this effectively, and to allow for regular
review and improvement, a coherent set of policy
statements, plans and procedures should be put in
place – a collections management framework.
This will address collections development,
information, access, care and conservation.
141. Accreditation Requirements
• 2.1 Satisfactory arrangements for ownership of collections
• 2.2 Collections Development
• 2.3 Documentation policy
• 2.4 Care & conservation policy
• 2.5 Documentation plan
• 2.6 Care & conservation plan
• 2.7 Documentation procedures
• 2.7 Expert assessment of security arrangements
142. ‘Primary’ procedures
Requirement 2.7: “The primary SPECTRUM procedures must be in place in the
form of a documentation procedural manual that is available for inspection on
request.”
• Object entry
• Acquisition
• Location and movement control
• Marking and/or labelling
• Cataloguing
• Object exit
• Loans in
• Loans out
143. Accreditation support
We can
• Publish standards and guidelines
• Share case studies
• Work with partner museums in the regions
• Share questions & answers with our networks
• Provide statements of support
We can’t
• Answer questions directly over the phone or by email
145. Key topics
• What is a ‘Collections Management System’?
• How to develop effective systems for Collections & Digital Asset Management
• Integration with other systems
146. ‘Choose a CMS’ database
http://www.collectionstrust.org.uk/choose-a-cms
147. Digital Asset Management
• Launched SPECTRUM DAM in 2013
• Providing guidance on how to manage photographs, scans and recordings
alongside the collection
• Launched SPECTRUM DAM Partners Scheme in 2014, validating software
providers who can demonstrate they work with collections systems
• Free guide ‘How to Buy a Digital Asset Management System for your
Museum’
• http://www.collectionstrust.org.uk/spectrum/spectrum-digital-asset-
management
149. Wrap up & conclusions
• Great collections management is at the heart of every successful museum
• You can help your museum be more resilient and adapt to the current and
future needs and expectations of visitors
• Collections management can help make your museum more sustainable,
both by finding opportunities to reduce costs and opening up primary
income and secondary revenue through audience engagement
• We need to provide evidence of the value and impact of collections
management to secure reinvestment
150. Keep in touch
• We offer several ways of keeping in touch with our work and with each
other
– Collections Management LinkedIn community (8,200 members)
– Fortnightly email newsletter
– www.twitter.com/collectiontrust
– www.facebook.com/collectionstrust
– www.slideshare.net/collectionstrust