SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 1
Baixar para ler offline
Issues from the U.S. Perspective – Summary, Panel Discussion – Nov 18, 2013 –
Elan Journo
American policy toward Iran is predicated not merely on an accidental misreading, but
rather on an active disregard of Iran's militant character and ideological goals. The long
history of Iran's anti-West aggression and its attacks on American interests should dispel
the notion that it is a peace-loving regime like any other. Far from it. Not even the Obama
administration's vigorous attempt at whitewashing can change that.
Engaging the regime diplomatically is destructive of our interests. Contrary to a widely
held belief, such engagement is not costless. Two of many underappreciated costs: Iran
gains time to advance its nuclear technology. Further, merely taking part, and stretching
out the talks, enables Iran to portray itself as seeking a peaceful resolution. That can serve
as a check-mate to any prospect of a U.S. or Israeli military option: if Iran's sitting at the
negotiating table, that fact works to discredit advocacy of military coercion.
What's even more damaging: the sheer fact that Iran’s negotiators are now sitting down
with American representatives is a considerable advantage for Tehran. A premise of these
talks is that, despite Iran’s well documented nuclear deceptions, despite its brutality and
murder of Iranian citizens, despite its decades of sponsoring terrorism globally, despite its
menacing ideological goals, despite the factual evidence of the regime’s character and
goals, it is welcomed to a negotiating table as a regime of good moral standing. Is there a
murderer who doesn’t want to be known as a law-abiding citizen? A fraud who doesn’t
crave to pass himself off as scrupulously honest? So it is, on a far more momentous scale,
with oppressive regimes: They would have us believe in their probity. A consequence of
these talks—like President Obama’s recent good-will gesture of a phone call to Iran’s
leader—is to hand Teheran the gift of unearned respectability.
Our policy to Iran is fundamentally flawed, and that severely undercuts our ability to
secure our national self-interest: the protection of the lives and freedom of Americans -and the safety of our close regional ally, Israel.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

SGrant Writing Sample - Stump Speech Analysis
SGrant Writing Sample - Stump Speech AnalysisSGrant Writing Sample - Stump Speech Analysis
SGrant Writing Sample - Stump Speech Analysis
sgrant1099
 
Final Bloods Presentation
Final Bloods PresentationFinal Bloods Presentation
Final Bloods Presentation
afederman
 
312378915-Time-to-Attack-Iran-Discussion
312378915-Time-to-Attack-Iran-Discussion312378915-Time-to-Attack-Iran-Discussion
312378915-Time-to-Attack-Iran-Discussion
Agha A
 

Mais procurados (8)

SGrant Writing Sample - Stump Speech Analysis
SGrant Writing Sample - Stump Speech AnalysisSGrant Writing Sample - Stump Speech Analysis
SGrant Writing Sample - Stump Speech Analysis
 
Gangs And The Military 4of7
Gangs And The Military 4of7Gangs And The Military 4of7
Gangs And The Military 4of7
 
Obama Strategies; What Lies Beneath; Stupid or Subversive?
Obama Strategies; What Lies Beneath; Stupid or Subversive?Obama Strategies; What Lies Beneath; Stupid or Subversive?
Obama Strategies; What Lies Beneath; Stupid or Subversive?
 
Chapter 12 - Getting the Story Right and Being Fair - JNL-2105 - Journalism E...
Chapter 12 - Getting the Story Right and Being Fair - JNL-2105 - Journalism E...Chapter 12 - Getting the Story Right and Being Fair - JNL-2105 - Journalism E...
Chapter 12 - Getting the Story Right and Being Fair - JNL-2105 - Journalism E...
 
Gangs And The Military 5of7
Gangs And The Military 5of7Gangs And The Military 5of7
Gangs And The Military 5of7
 
Elc commentary nur diana
Elc commentary nur dianaElc commentary nur diana
Elc commentary nur diana
 
Final Bloods Presentation
Final Bloods PresentationFinal Bloods Presentation
Final Bloods Presentation
 
312378915-Time-to-Attack-Iran-Discussion
312378915-Time-to-Attack-Iran-Discussion312378915-Time-to-Attack-Iran-Discussion
312378915-Time-to-Attack-Iran-Discussion
 

Destaque

Revisiting the Voyage of the Damned by Rafael Medoff | Prism
Revisiting the Voyage of the Damned by Rafael Medoff  | Prism Revisiting the Voyage of the Damned by Rafael Medoff  | Prism
Revisiting the Voyage of the Damned by Rafael Medoff | Prism
cjhs
 
Iran and the Bomb - Strategic Considerations in the MIddle East - J.E. (Jenn...
Iran and the Bomb -  Strategic Considerations in the MIddle East - J.E. (Jenn...Iran and the Bomb -  Strategic Considerations in the MIddle East - J.E. (Jenn...
Iran and the Bomb - Strategic Considerations in the MIddle East - J.E. (Jenn...
cjhs
 
Shariah Compliant Finance and Jihad with Money with Christopher Holton, Cente...
Shariah Compliant Finance and Jihad with Money with Christopher Holton, Cente...Shariah Compliant Finance and Jihad with Money with Christopher Holton, Cente...
Shariah Compliant Finance and Jihad with Money with Christopher Holton, Cente...
cjhs
 
One Thousand Children - Jewish Refugee Children in the USA (1934-1945) by Jud...
One Thousand Children - Jewish Refugee Children in the USA (1934-1945) by Jud...One Thousand Children - Jewish Refugee Children in the USA (1934-1945) by Jud...
One Thousand Children - Jewish Refugee Children in the USA (1934-1945) by Jud...
cjhs
 

Destaque (7)

SOVEREIGNTY: The Zionist Alternative (English version)
SOVEREIGNTY: The Zionist Alternative (English version)SOVEREIGNTY: The Zionist Alternative (English version)
SOVEREIGNTY: The Zionist Alternative (English version)
 
Armed resistance-to-the-holocaust by David B. Kopel
Armed resistance-to-the-holocaust by David B. KopelArmed resistance-to-the-holocaust by David B. Kopel
Armed resistance-to-the-holocaust by David B. Kopel
 
Iran and the Bomb – Summary, Panel Discussion – Nov 18, 2013 – Rick Richman
Iran and the Bomb – Summary, Panel Discussion – Nov 18, 2013 – Rick RichmanIran and the Bomb – Summary, Panel Discussion – Nov 18, 2013 – Rick Richman
Iran and the Bomb – Summary, Panel Discussion – Nov 18, 2013 – Rick Richman
 
Revisiting the Voyage of the Damned by Rafael Medoff | Prism
Revisiting the Voyage of the Damned by Rafael Medoff  | Prism Revisiting the Voyage of the Damned by Rafael Medoff  | Prism
Revisiting the Voyage of the Damned by Rafael Medoff | Prism
 
Iran and the Bomb - Strategic Considerations in the MIddle East - J.E. (Jenn...
Iran and the Bomb -  Strategic Considerations in the MIddle East - J.E. (Jenn...Iran and the Bomb -  Strategic Considerations in the MIddle East - J.E. (Jenn...
Iran and the Bomb - Strategic Considerations in the MIddle East - J.E. (Jenn...
 
Shariah Compliant Finance and Jihad with Money with Christopher Holton, Cente...
Shariah Compliant Finance and Jihad with Money with Christopher Holton, Cente...Shariah Compliant Finance and Jihad with Money with Christopher Holton, Cente...
Shariah Compliant Finance and Jihad with Money with Christopher Holton, Cente...
 
One Thousand Children - Jewish Refugee Children in the USA (1934-1945) by Jud...
One Thousand Children - Jewish Refugee Children in the USA (1934-1945) by Jud...One Thousand Children - Jewish Refugee Children in the USA (1934-1945) by Jud...
One Thousand Children - Jewish Refugee Children in the USA (1934-1945) by Jud...
 

Semelhante a Iran and the Bomb – Summary, Panel Discussion – Nov 18, 2013 – Elan Journo

FailureofDiplomacy-Iran
FailureofDiplomacy-IranFailureofDiplomacy-Iran
FailureofDiplomacy-Iran
Neal Young
 
To Sanction or Not to Sanction?
To Sanction or Not to Sanction?To Sanction or Not to Sanction?
To Sanction or Not to Sanction?
UFRJ
 
Research paper us foreign policy and iran 2 3
Research paper us foreign policy and iran 2 3Research paper us foreign policy and iran 2 3
Research paper us foreign policy and iran 2 3
Syeda Rizvi
 

Semelhante a Iran and the Bomb – Summary, Panel Discussion – Nov 18, 2013 – Elan Journo (15)

FailureofDiplomacy-Iran
FailureofDiplomacy-IranFailureofDiplomacy-Iran
FailureofDiplomacy-Iran
 
ss-cnn-iran-071415
ss-cnn-iran-071415ss-cnn-iran-071415
ss-cnn-iran-071415
 
To Sanction or Not to Sanction?
To Sanction or Not to Sanction?To Sanction or Not to Sanction?
To Sanction or Not to Sanction?
 
Iran In Context
Iran In ContextIran In Context
Iran In Context
 
The International Crisis Group’s top 10 conflicts to watch in 2018
The International Crisis Group’s top 10 conflicts to watch in 2018 The International Crisis Group’s top 10 conflicts to watch in 2018
The International Crisis Group’s top 10 conflicts to watch in 2018
 
File
FileFile
File
 
Attempts To Define Terrorism Terrorist Or Freedom Fighter
Attempts To Define Terrorism  Terrorist Or Freedom FighterAttempts To Define Terrorism  Terrorist Or Freedom Fighter
Attempts To Define Terrorism Terrorist Or Freedom Fighter
 
Rank presidents by their humanitarian records
Rank presidents by their humanitarian recordsRank presidents by their humanitarian records
Rank presidents by their humanitarian records
 
CONFLICTS WATCH LIST 2018 AND MYANMAR
CONFLICTS WATCH LIST 2018 AND MYANMARCONFLICTS WATCH LIST 2018 AND MYANMAR
CONFLICTS WATCH LIST 2018 AND MYANMAR
 
The Ticking Iran Time Bomb _ Andy Blumenthal _ The Blogs.pdf
The Ticking Iran Time Bomb _ Andy Blumenthal _ The Blogs.pdfThe Ticking Iran Time Bomb _ Andy Blumenthal _ The Blogs.pdf
The Ticking Iran Time Bomb _ Andy Blumenthal _ The Blogs.pdf
 
Time to attack iran 2016 -centre for study of intel ops
Time to attack iran  2016 -centre for study of intel opsTime to attack iran  2016 -centre for study of intel ops
Time to attack iran 2016 -centre for study of intel ops
 
Terrorism | Types of Terrorism | Impacts of terrorism
Terrorism | Types of Terrorism | Impacts of terrorism Terrorism | Types of Terrorism | Impacts of terrorism
Terrorism | Types of Terrorism | Impacts of terrorism
 
Iran - a new power on the rise
Iran - a new power on the riseIran - a new power on the rise
Iran - a new power on the rise
 
Essay On Terrorism In World
Essay On Terrorism In WorldEssay On Terrorism In World
Essay On Terrorism In World
 
Research paper us foreign policy and iran 2 3
Research paper us foreign policy and iran 2 3Research paper us foreign policy and iran 2 3
Research paper us foreign policy and iran 2 3
 

Mais de cjhs

The four sons by Ze'ev Jabotinsky - 1911
The four sons by Ze'ev Jabotinsky - 1911The four sons by Ze'ev Jabotinsky - 1911
The four sons by Ze'ev Jabotinsky - 1911
cjhs
 
Teaching antisemitism 2
Teaching antisemitism 2Teaching antisemitism 2
Teaching antisemitism 2
cjhs
 
The Arab-Israeli Conflict
The Arab-Israeli ConflictThe Arab-Israeli Conflict
The Arab-Israeli Conflict
cjhs
 
Guns in America - Eugene Volokh
Guns in America - Eugene VolokhGuns in America - Eugene Volokh
Guns in America - Eugene Volokh
cjhs
 
Avi Bell - Beyond the UN: The Shape of Lawfare to Come
Avi Bell - Beyond the UN:  The Shape of Lawfare to ComeAvi Bell - Beyond the UN:  The Shape of Lawfare to Come
Avi Bell - Beyond the UN: The Shape of Lawfare to Come
cjhs
 
Rick Richman - Beyond the Two-State Non-Solution: One State, Three States, o...
Rick Richman - Beyond the Two-State Non-Solution:  One State, Three States, o...Rick Richman - Beyond the Two-State Non-Solution:  One State, Three States, o...
Rick Richman - Beyond the Two-State Non-Solution: One State, Three States, o...
cjhs
 

Mais de cjhs (7)

The four sons by Ze'ev Jabotinsky - 1911
The four sons by Ze'ev Jabotinsky - 1911The four sons by Ze'ev Jabotinsky - 1911
The four sons by Ze'ev Jabotinsky - 1911
 
Teaching antisemitism 2
Teaching antisemitism 2Teaching antisemitism 2
Teaching antisemitism 2
 
The Arab-Israeli Conflict
The Arab-Israeli ConflictThe Arab-Israeli Conflict
The Arab-Israeli Conflict
 
Guns in America - Eugene Volokh
Guns in America - Eugene VolokhGuns in America - Eugene Volokh
Guns in America - Eugene Volokh
 
The Fabrication of the Palestinian People - How we swallowed the Bluff
The Fabrication of the Palestinian People - How we swallowed the BluffThe Fabrication of the Palestinian People - How we swallowed the Bluff
The Fabrication of the Palestinian People - How we swallowed the Bluff
 
Avi Bell - Beyond the UN: The Shape of Lawfare to Come
Avi Bell - Beyond the UN:  The Shape of Lawfare to ComeAvi Bell - Beyond the UN:  The Shape of Lawfare to Come
Avi Bell - Beyond the UN: The Shape of Lawfare to Come
 
Rick Richman - Beyond the Two-State Non-Solution: One State, Three States, o...
Rick Richman - Beyond the Two-State Non-Solution:  One State, Three States, o...Rick Richman - Beyond the Two-State Non-Solution:  One State, Three States, o...
Rick Richman - Beyond the Two-State Non-Solution: One State, Three States, o...
 

Iran and the Bomb – Summary, Panel Discussion – Nov 18, 2013 – Elan Journo

  • 1. Issues from the U.S. Perspective – Summary, Panel Discussion – Nov 18, 2013 – Elan Journo American policy toward Iran is predicated not merely on an accidental misreading, but rather on an active disregard of Iran's militant character and ideological goals. The long history of Iran's anti-West aggression and its attacks on American interests should dispel the notion that it is a peace-loving regime like any other. Far from it. Not even the Obama administration's vigorous attempt at whitewashing can change that. Engaging the regime diplomatically is destructive of our interests. Contrary to a widely held belief, such engagement is not costless. Two of many underappreciated costs: Iran gains time to advance its nuclear technology. Further, merely taking part, and stretching out the talks, enables Iran to portray itself as seeking a peaceful resolution. That can serve as a check-mate to any prospect of a U.S. or Israeli military option: if Iran's sitting at the negotiating table, that fact works to discredit advocacy of military coercion. What's even more damaging: the sheer fact that Iran’s negotiators are now sitting down with American representatives is a considerable advantage for Tehran. A premise of these talks is that, despite Iran’s well documented nuclear deceptions, despite its brutality and murder of Iranian citizens, despite its decades of sponsoring terrorism globally, despite its menacing ideological goals, despite the factual evidence of the regime’s character and goals, it is welcomed to a negotiating table as a regime of good moral standing. Is there a murderer who doesn’t want to be known as a law-abiding citizen? A fraud who doesn’t crave to pass himself off as scrupulously honest? So it is, on a far more momentous scale, with oppressive regimes: They would have us believe in their probity. A consequence of these talks—like President Obama’s recent good-will gesture of a phone call to Iran’s leader—is to hand Teheran the gift of unearned respectability. Our policy to Iran is fundamentally flawed, and that severely undercuts our ability to secure our national self-interest: the protection of the lives and freedom of Americans -and the safety of our close regional ally, Israel.