2. PROBLEM STATEMENT
Dwindling loyalty from the top retailers of Asian Paints
Low consumer involvement in the category- given the fact that the decision making is now becoming family
oriented than being only carried out by the Chief Wage Earner (CWE)
Poor customer servicing at the dealer outlets- poor ambience and disinterest of the dealers to spend time with the
customers
Changing trade scenarios- macroeconomic policies and entry of big retailers like WalMart into the Indian market
Changing consumer habits with the rising retail trend in India- customer exposure to professional servicing
Exodus of a number of middle and junior level managers to global retailers like Wal-Mart and Carrefour
OBJECTIVES
Increasing loyalty of Asian Paints’ top retailers by devising a creative strategy
To decide whether to break the old “open network” or craft an alternative strategy for the same
Increasing customer involvement- specially emphasizing on attracting women for final decision making
Making the customer’s interaction with Asian Paints an experience that stays back with him and leads to the start
of a new long lasting relationship with Asian Paints
Aligning Asian Paints with the modern trade scenarios of changing macroeconomic parameters and policies
TRANSPARENCY EQUITY FAIRNESS
Alignment with
Principles of transparency, equity and fairness have been AP’s long held competitive advantage. Any strategy
decided should make sure that loyalty of the top retailers should be increased but not at the cost of AP’s
competitive advantage and its long held strong dealer base
They may be small in size but the importance of the other 90% dealers (contributing close to 50% sales )is no
less in scripting Asian Paints’ success story of having one of the strongest networks in the country
3. Asian Paints’ Strength Withheld Strategy
1. Strong dealer network 1. Strategy of transparency, equity and
2. Giving equal status to all the dealers- fairness to all the dealers- creating a dealer
benchmark for competitive advantage of pull to join the illustrious Asian Paints
Asian Paints over decades network- long lasting expansion strategy
3. Market leader with its span across all for Asian Paints
major cities and towns 2. Top 10% dealers (close to 2000)
4. Customization at the customer’s end- contributing to around 40-50% sales of
successful tinting systems installed across Asian Paints through its long lasting
dealers relationship
5. Long held relationship with all its major 3. Majority stores in the top 10% dealers are
dealers of exclusive nature- contributing to
6. Number of exclusive stores driving major Strategy majority of sales of Asian Paints
sales
10% 10%
differential indirect
benefits to the top
Equal Status but
90%
90% 10% retailers
Strategy 2: Rectangular Structure for
dealers
Strategy 1: Pyramid Structure for
dealers Aligns with the long held Strategy of
Asian Paints
4. TRENDS IN PAINTS INDUSTRY IN INDIA
Insights and Trends in the industry 60
51.7
*Reportlinker Industry forecast (2015) 50
Unorganised
•Forecasted CAGR of around 13% during FY 2012 to Sector 38
FY 2015 in the paints industry 35% Organised Sector
40
•Paint industry is dominated by decorative paints 30 25.8
•Emulsion, which constitutes the majority share of 65% 20
decorative paints, is the fastest growing segment of
the paint industry 10
2.5 3.5
1.25
•Presently, the growth of the Indian paint industry is 0
% Share as in 2011
being witnessed from new demand India China US Singapore Sri Lanka Qatar
pockets, especially in Tier-II and Tier-III decorative
cities, thus, signalling the growing acceptance of paints Per Capita Consumption of Paint in Kg around the world as in 2011
quality products among the masses 25% Industrial
•The industry has a positive correlation with the Paints
country’s gross domestic product (GDP) as both have
the same growth drivers 1600.00 1466.78
•According to ACA report, the leftover paints in the 75% 1400.00 1315.49
1179.82
annual sales is approx 10% in US, we assume this to 1200.00 1058.13
be more than 10% in India. (Scope for a Green Idea) 1000.00
949
843.5
800.00
749.83
666.51
592.46
600.00 526.63
468.11
400.00
200.00
0.00
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
Growth rate in the paints industry in million liters in India
*Source:http://www.coatingsindia.com/newsletter2011/vol5iss1_article.htm
A Green Idea has the highest potential
to add value to the customer to create
Indian consumers’ demand for green products is the highest in the world the product pull
5. TRENDS AND INSIGHTS IN PAINTS INDUSTRY IN INDIA- CONTD
41 42 DIAL DEALER: OUR CONVERSATION
Most influential age group is 25-34.Gap
33 34
between average age of home buyer and DEALER INSIGHT
26
24 the paint buyer is 5 years. It is still likely to “We are exclusive dealers for Asian paints
2005 be in the mid 30’s going forward since 40 years. We have developed very
2010 good relations with painters as they are our
Average age of the paint buyer in 2005: 41
frequent customers. Our sales depend on
Yrs and 38 Yrs in 2010 the referrals provided by painters for Asian
Paints. In some cases customers directly
25-34 35-44 45-55 approach us to decorate their home. We
Contribution to paint sales in terms of advise them on the colours they can use
and suggest painter for them. We get
average age of the paint buyer in India commission from the painter for providing
*Source: Indian Readership Survey 2005,2010 (sample 2.4 his reference. But all this process has never
lacs). Age 25+
been done in more structured manner”
In 2011, women accounted for 23% of the total Working women have a major say in terms of paint -G.J Patel, Baroda
employed population in India. buying – a tipping point to decide on to a strategy
*Source: Gender Diversity Benchmark for Asia 2011 report to include women in paint purchase.
compiled by Community Business A general study about women observes them to be
more inclined towards colors and shades. They
believe that the décor of the house is a direct
DEALER INSIGHT refection of their identity and personality
-Anupam Das, New Hindustan
Hardware, Durgapur, 2.5 yrs Asian paints, 8 yrs Main Customers – Males and Painters.
total Painters: Some dealers recommend painters to customers Seed of our Idea
and get a commission, but this has never been done in a
•Over the past 6 years, he does not sell anything else formal way
through the stores- such as adhesives
•Has been extensively using Visualization software and
Consumer involvement in the choice of paints is increasing day by day which in turn
photographers
makes a color scheme or a job of professionals more important.
•Has gone with the market leader or the paint
The emerging trend of exclusive Franchise shops with an opportunity provided to the
manufacturer which is in demand in the locality
consumers to touch and feel is increasing consumers' interest to pick up what he or she
*Our conversation with the dealers was with
thinks is best suited for their needs.
respect to the issues over the years-2005 Today, Customer is looking for value for money. Thus you see products being offered at
onwards- including the year case talks about different price points to suit the needs of the consumers & meeting their budgets
*Source: ProjectVendor.com, Anuj Jain
6. STRATEGY SUGGESTED TO MAKE TOP DEALERS MORE LOYAL TO ASIAN PAINTS
STUDIO (EXCLUSIVE)
CONCEPT (INVOLVEMENT OF DEALER, CUSTOMER AND PAINTER IN A CHAIN NETWORK)
Only applicable for the top 10% retailers of Asian Paints
•Dealer operated exclusive Asian paints store, will operate as the interaction point for the customers with Asian Paints.
•The cost of revamping the store will be borne entirely by Asian Paints while the cost of management (including employees and staff) will be handled by the Dealer
•For already existing exclusive dealers of Asian Paints, their old shops will be revamped under a standard model designed by AP
•The selection criteria for a dealer also includes minimum shop space available
•The dealer will install dynamic software and latest technology inside the studio.
•Each studio will have 2- one male and one female (rest dependent on need for a particular studio) AP Consultant. The job of the consultant will be to educate all
the employees of the studio for standard practices of customer handling and servicing as well as an interface between AP and its customers in the shop
•Asian paints will help in setting up the Studio by providing guidance and timely workshops for painters and colour experts.
•The Studio will have standard walls showing different shades of colours to the customers to make them have a real feel of their house
The dealer will be encouraged to develop a chain of painters so that the dealer can provide end to end painting solutions to the customer
Key differentiator:
End to End Solution Provider: The dealer will provide an entire painting service to the customer including consulting, advising about methods involved and
appointing a trained AP painter (included in the network), calculating the amount of paint required and most importantly getting back the leftover paint from the
customer’s house to the dealer shop . The painter will use standard methods as suggested by AP. He will be donning an Asian Paints attire during his stay at the
customer’s house to increase the visibility of the idea
The studio will be an entire personalized service provider to the customer
Consulting service to the Appointing one of the The entire job of Leftover paint sent back
customer about shades and painters in the network painting done to the dealer shop for
colors, modern methods used by from painter’s recycling (Green
AP’s painters, total cost end solution)
calculated for the project (Value
*Cost Structure for Asian Paints India studios has been shown in the excel attached
proposition)
7. Dealer Customer will have the
END option of just buying the
Paint Recycler paint and not going through
the entire service chain
Asian Paints
consultant ASIAN PAINTS SERVICE CHAIN
STUDIO Customer
START
GREEN CHAIN
Dealer
Painter
Value to the customer Value to the Dealer Value to Asian Paints
•End to end professional service provided by AP •Value addition in the service solution will create a •Opportunity to build a GREEN BRAND
•Less overhead cost as the entire process of customer pull for Asian Paints’ service solution •The entire problem of poor servicing at the
painting is managed by AP Professionals •This will push for higher sales that will give higher dealer’s end is solved
•Storage of leftover paint taken care of (Green margin multiples for the total value created for •This store is a perfect medium to attract women-
Solution) dealers ambiance and other offerings in the studio
•One stop studio for the entire painting solution- •Sense of control and ownership of Asian Paints (a •Providing service solution as a package to the
does not need to look for different threads in the huge intangible for the dealer) customer will give higher scope for paint sales
painting process •This is a long term strategy so the dealer has all •Pull created will create higher demand in the
•Cost savings as the paint calculator will calculate the incentives market for Asian Paints products
the exact amount needed (with additional buffer •Professionalism created in the staff employed by •Perfect platform to initiate a long tem
paint- which may lead to the leftover paint ) him with the help of Asian Paints consultant relationship with the customer
•Value added servicing and ambience of the studio •Association with a GREEN COMPANY •Awareness and visibility created by branding
these studios on a PAN India basis
8. VALUE OFFERING OF AN ASIAN PAINTS STUDIO
Studio walls showing color Trained employees of the Kids Zone- with unlimited
patterns and shades to make dealer inside the studio- crayons and sheets to let the
the customer have a real feel specially trained under set kids run their imagination on a
standards of Asian Paints The Final AP Solution
piece of paper
Trained professional The Final AP Solution
Latest IT and Visualization And at the end of
painter appointed by Softwares installed all, it is a paint
the dealer for the
purchase shop too.
customer
Customers can skip
to choose the end to
end service of Asian
STUDIO Paints and just buy
the paints as well
9. RATIONALE BEHIND THE STRATEGY SUGGESTED
Loyalty created for the top dealers Value created in the chain suggested
•Value as suggested in the previous slide is a huge incentive for Total value of the chain will be much more as compared to the
the dealer to go for this partnership disintegrated units of the chain
•Huge returns generated and loyal customers Huge Synergies generated in the chain
•Sense of ownership created for the dealer
No need to push the product
GREEN SOLUTION- A GREEN COMPANY
The entire value solution (service offered) provided by Asian
Paints will create a pull for its products •Perfect platform for Asian Paints for a CSR initiative
AP will no longer get trapped in the dilemma to find ideas to •Higher awareness created by brand positive reinforcement
push the products
Customer doesn’t need to store hazardous
paints
Huge Sludge generated in the paints industry
Huge Value addition to the customer by elimination of need to
store hazardous paints (from huge wastage to leading to huge Total of about 48000 tons/year of paint sludge was being
cost saving for the customer) generated in India in the year 2008-09 (total sludge was huge in
2006 too). This number is rising sharply at a rate of 10-15% on
Higher Customer Involvement an annual basis
The ambience, a complete customer experience, incentives *Source cKinetics Consulting
(offers), platform for kids inside the Studio (Kids
Zone), presence of a female AP consultant plays a role in higher
customer involvement
From a pure product offering company to
Standards created by Asian Paints a product + service solution offering
•This strategy will lead to standards in the industry, leading to company will lead to a differentiating
huge Asian Paints awareness and hence creating a pull advantage for Asian Paints
•The Studio will be a one stop solution to customer’s need of
painting his house
STUDIO
10. STRATEGY SUGGESTED FOR MODERN TRADE: WHY NOT TO GO TO THE BIG RETAILERS ROUTE
*Source: Outlook for retailing in India, euro monitor, 2011 Channel Conflict with AP Studio
Consumers can buy paint at the Under the sourcing and minimum The strong dealer network is the core competency of
Asian paints. If Asian Paints decides to go with big
big box stores and mega chain investments criteria in retailing, stores retailers, there will be channel conflict between the
stores, but they just can’t buy the like Wal-mart will not be successful in existing dealers /Studio of Asian paints and mega stores
quality finishes nor can they get selling furniture or home furnishing operated by big players such as Wal-Mart. Asian paints
retailers’ expert advice and products. Rather 100% owned stores has made huge efforts in the past to gain the loyalty of
personalized service. have a moderate chance of success dealers and it can’t afford to lose it.
Low level of car ownership to hold back big box retailing including products like paint STUDIO
The paint industry is evolving from product to service industry. It will be transformed from commodity to customized product. The
format of company owned retail stores will be required to cater to these needs.
Why Retail route for paints is not a profit deal
•Currently 4 % of Indian household have four-wheeler vehicles, so
‘big-box’ stores model does not possess a potent threat to company
owned small retail stores .
•This will prove to be a major challenge to foreign companies, like
Wal-Mart, aiming to set up “big box” stores in India.
•Two-wheeled vehicles, on the other hand, are a more common
sight. This means that to address the mass market, grocery retailers
will have to take into account how much consumers can carry by
motorcycle, and make adjustments to both store and pack sizes
accordingly.
11. THE BIG STRATEGY TO INVOLVE THE END CUSTOMER IN DECISION MAKING
Handled By
Antecedents to consumer behavior in involvement
•I have a strong interest in paint.
Scope of Consumer involvement STUDIO
•I love playing with colours. •Color/Shades •Today, women influence more than 85% of the
•I attach a great importance to painting. •Quality (Durability, Weather shield, Patches etc.) consumer purchasing decisions and complete eight out
•I get pleasure by selecting paint colour for my house. of 10 customer satisfaction index (CSI) surveys
•When one buys paint, it is like giving gift to one-self •Women want to do business with companies that are
•The paint you buy tells little bit about you “good community citizens” and local contributors
•The paint colour you chose tells little bit about you •Women appreciate any effort made to educate them
•You can tell about a person by the colour he/she selects for his house. about the product
•When you buy a wrong paint it is not a big deal if you make a mistake
*Source: Jean-Noel •Providing women with educational content to empower
•It is really annoying to purchase a paint which is not suitable
Kapferer, Gillies them in traditional venues, like local radio and TV, as
•When I purchase paint for my house, I am never sure of my choice
Laurent, Journal of Advertising well as new mediums such as Facebook and Twitter, will
Research, Jan 1986 drive more business to your shop’s door.
5 factors for consumer involvement •Women largely admire any Green initiatives carried out
by the company
INTEREST PLEASURE SIGN VALUE RISK IMPORTANCE RISK PROBABILITY *Source: TireReview.com
Increase in any of these factors leads to increase in consumer involvement Insights from Women purchasing Behavior
Paints category includes -> majorly Pleasure and sign value ASIAN PAINTS STUDIO: ONE STOP, ALL SOLUTIONS
(customer’s association of identity with the brand) as the driving
factors to increase consumer involvement
STUDIO
Interest Pleasure Sign Value Risk Importance Risk Probability
Ambiance, women The experience made Color patterns shown Educating consumers Risk probability high
Asian Paints Studio
incentives- pull pleasurable by AP by on walls of the studio about ill effect of poor without the Asian
providing an end to will create a sign value quality paints Paints end to end
end solution and to the intangible added service solutions
providing excellent identity of the
customer services customer
12. CONSUMER INVOLVEMENT FRAMEWORK
Pleasure
Revamping the brand
communication
STUDIO
Sign Value
To educate the consumers about different paints and the process of
INTEREST painting
Pleasure of the paint purchasing process is increased through
PLEASURE excellent customer services at the Asian Paints Studio
Linking the customer’s identity to the color combinations used for
SIGN VALUE home décor- including painting the walls
Communicating to the customers the need to go for quality paints
RISK (like Asian Paints) as lesser quality paints can sabotage the image of
the customer
MAKING PAINT PURCHASE This will automatically create a pull for women-
A FAMILY DECISION creating incentives for all the threads of the family to
be a part of the decision making
13. ATTRACTING WOMEN IN DECISION MAKING: A FAMILY INCENTIVE
Miss Casting Shades “Paint your imagination” FB Ambiance inside AP Studio
•This is an online and an offline Contest “It’s a lovely place”
project to educate customers •Specially crafted walls to show the
specially women about basics of •Facebook contest to post color
combinations (only for woman) combinations of shades and colors
interior décor and color •The structure of the Studio will
combinations •Monthly an entry will be shortlisted and
winner will be provided Exclusive Asian provide a feeling of a decorative home
•As a part of it, an internet portal
will be created to interact and Paints Studio Goodies
educate customers. The role of Asian Paints
•Offline workshops with major KIDS COLOR ZONE Woman Consultant in the
Resident Welfare Associations
(RWAs) A special zone inside the Asian Paints studio
Studio- where crayons and color sheets
will be available for kids accompanying •Women find it easier to interact with
other women, hence the role of woman
MY SHADES. MY IDENTITY their parents to draw the picture of their
imagination consultant in the studio could be
•Communication strategy showing important
that colors are a reflection of one’s •She will specifically cater to any female
identity THE RIGHT CHOICE customer entering the studio and will act
•Choosing the right color is hence •Campaigns showing the damages that as Asian Paints’ interaction point with her
important to show the right can be caused by choosing the bad
personality that you possess quality paints PAINT A GIRL CHILD’S FUTURE
•Nail polish stocks inside the Studio •High Risk- as choosing paints is a one
where the woman will be allowed to •Social campaign/community initiative to
off decision that is not made regularly
mix the nail paint shades and a lucky empower the girl child by providing free
winner will be given a nail paints education, helping her to gain a society
stock status
SOLUTIONS