1. Samsung v. Apple ITC MARKMAN Disputation
Alex Lee, Principal, TechIPm LLC
US7706348
Disputed Claim Terms Samsung Apple ITC
Claims 75 and 82- Should be Hardware encoding Plain and ordinary
“controller for interpreted pursuant structure meaning
outputting” to 35 U.S.C. § 112, ¶
6.
Claims 75, 76, 82, and Final, fully-encoded Plain and ordinary coded information
83-“codeword” string of bits meaning
5. Claim 75-“fromamong From more than one Selecting one 30 bit From more than
a plurality of 30 bit 30 bit codeword codeword from an one 30 bit
codewords”; and Claim (claim 75) encoding table of codeword” (claim
82-“from among a From more than one multiple 30 bit 75)
plurality of 32 bit 32 bit codeword codewords (claim 75) From more than one
codewords” (claim 82) Selecting one 32 bit 32 bit codeword
codeword from an (claim 82)
encoding table of
multiple 32 bit
codewords (claim 82)
Claims 75 and 82- Plain and ordinary The result of Plain and ordinary
“ equivalent” meaning puncturing meaning
symbols #0 and #16
Claim 76-“punctured 32 bit codeword that The result of 32 bit codeword that
equivalents” has been puncturing has been punctured
punctured such that symbols #0 and #16 such that it
it corresponds to TFCI
corresponds to TFCI information in the
information in the same way that a 30
same way bit codeword
that a 30 bit corresponds to TFCI
codeword information
corresponds to TFCI
information
Claim 82- Hardware and/or Hardware and/or Plain and ordinary
“puncturer”/“puncturing” software for software for meaning (“hardware
removing of bits deleting/removing of or software for
bits puncturing)
Claim 82- Plain and ordinary Bit positions #0 and Plain and ordinary
“predetermined position” meaning #16 meaning
1

2. US7486644
Disputed Claim Terms Samsung Apple ITC
Claims 9 and l3-“rate- A set of bits after A set of contiguous A block of channel-
matched block” removing a bits Node B created coded bits that have
portion of bits so through rate-matching been matched to
that the set has transmittable bits on a
an appropriate size physical channel by
for transmission puncturing or
repeating bits at
predetermined
positions
Claims 9 and 13- Decoding bits that Converting the 90 Decoding bits that
“decoding the coded bits were encoded [coded] bits into 30 were encoded
at a coding rate of 1/3” according to a bits according to a coding
coding rate that rate that outputs one
outputs three bits bit for every three
for every one input input bits
bit
2

3. US6771980
Disputed Claim Terms Samsung Apple ITC
Claims 5, 10-“PDA A function A function performed A function performed
function” performed by a by a personal digital by a personal digital
personal digital assistant assistant
assistant
A PDA function does Rejected Apple’s
not include proposed limitations
a web page-based
function or a mobile
phone function
Claims 5, 10-“mobile A telephone A telephone function A telephone function
phone function” function of a of a mobile phone of a mobile phone
mobile phone
A mobile phone Rejected Apple’s
function does proposed limitation
not include a PDA
function
Claim 5-“a phone Phone program: Plain and ordinary Plain and ordinary
program”; and Claim “program capable meaning (a program meaning
10-“a dialing program” of placing phone that performs the
calls” mobile phone
Dialing program: “a functions of the smart
program capable of phone)
editing and dialing
a phone number”
Claims 5, 9, 10-“phone Plain meaning: A screen displayed by A user interface that
editor” graphical user the phone program allows the user to edit
interface for a after the user selects a phone number prior
program for the dialing icon, to dialing
inputting and which allows
editing phone the user to edit the
numbers selected phone
number prior to
dialing
Claim 5-“loading” Moving software Plain meaning: Copying or
code to random copying into transferring into
access memory or memory memory
the equivalent for
execution.
Claims 5, 10- Any combination of Plain meaning: a A name associated
“identifying name” letters or numbers name for the with the selected
that can be used to person or entity number
identify a phone associated with
number the selected number
3

4. Claims 6, 10-“dialing A state from which A mode that occurs A mode in which the
state” the smart phone can after termination of smart phone can dial a
dial a phone the PDA function, in phone number
number which the smart
phone attempts to dial
the selected phone
number
4

5. US7450114
Disputed Claim Terms Samsung Apple ITC
Claim 1-“rate based on Rate calculated Speed of the last Rate calculated from
the determined velocity from the measured velocity the determined
vector” determined velocity vector velocity vector
vector
Claims 2 and 3-“rate Rate calculated Speed of the last Rate calculated from
based on the determined from the measured velocity the determined
velocity vector and a determined velocity vector velocity vector
page inertia” vector and a page reduced by a page and a page inertia
inertia inertia, which is a
simulated
constant force that
decreases velocity
Claims 1, 3, and 5-“air A process that This term should be A process that handles
interface process” handles a user construed a user interface
interface pursuant to 35 U.S.C.
§ 112, ¶ 6
Claims 1, 2, 3, 4, and 5- A process that This term should be A process that
“a display monitor” monitors the construed monitors the display
display pursuant to 35 U.S.C.
§ 112, ¶ 6
Claims 1, 3, and 5- Plain and ordinary Indefinite because Plain and ordinary
“wherein” meaning includes meaning
method-of-use steps
in an apparatus claim
5

6. Final Score
No. of Patents No. of disputed claim No. of claim No. of claim
terms constructions in favor constructions in favor
of Samsung of Apple
4 21 11 3
6