SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 11
Baixar para ler offline
American International Journal of Business Management (AIJBM)
ISSN- 2379-106X, www.aijbm.com Volume 5, Issue 07 (July-2022), PP 40-50
*Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
www.aijbm.com 40 | Page
Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital
Wallet
Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
, Prawira Fajarindra Belgiawan2
1
School of Business and Management / Bandung Institute of Technology, Indonesia
2
School of Business and Management / Bandung Institute of Technology, Indonesia
ABSTRACT: Indonesia has been actively doing digitalization, marked by the increase in mobile connections
and internet users. In 2020, more people were using them due to the spread of the COVID-19. Because of the
pandemic, government encourages the public to make transactions using cashless payments. One of the cashless
payment methods that are growing is digital wallet. PT Pos Indonesia saw this as an opportunity to develop its
digital wallet called Pospay. Since its launch, on 13th
April 2021, Pospay has faced several challenges. 98.5% of
Pospay’s users are an employee of PT Pos Indonesia. It shows that brand awareness and intention to use of
Pospay are still relatively low outside the company. This study will focus on how Pospay could increase its
brand awareness and intention to use. The analysis was conducted using consumer analysis by distributing the
questionnaire to the potential consumers. The quantitative data is processed using Smart PLS software with the
SEM-PLS method. Then, the qualitative data will be used to analyze Value Proposition Canvas. The results
show that Pospay can create a discount or cashback program and develop a new feature to help users transfer
between digital wallets to increase brand awareness and intention to use.
KEYWORDS -marketing strategy, brand awareness, intention to use, digital wallet, SEM-PLS
I. INTRODUCTION
The global industry is experiencing a new digital era 4.0, and Indonesia is no exception. In this digital
era, almost all public activities have shifted to digitalization, including payment activities that shifted to cashless
payment methods from the conventional. One of the cashless methods that are growing in Indonesia is the
digital wallet industry [1]. In 2020, there is COVID-19 that occurred in Indonesia and even in all parts of the
world. The WHO warned the world's citizens that the COVID-19 virus could live and stick to inanimate objects,
including money. This virus can live and survive for days on paper money. Therefore, WHO urges the public to
use non-cash payment instruments when making transactions. Based on the statement of WHO, the Governor of
Bank Indonesia, Perry Warjiyo, appealed to the public to transact using cashless payment when paying in-store,
paying bills, or making purchases on delivery food, online transport, e-commerce, websites, or online shopping.
This situation has led to a growth in the use of digital wallets.
As one of the financial service providers, Pos Indonesia saw this as an opportunity to develop. Pos
Indonesia created a digital- based payment service that categorizes as a digital wallet called “Pospay” to make
transactions easier for everyone, and it launched on April 13, 2021. Pospay offers several features payment such
as QRIS, transfer, sharia services (BAZNAS and Rumah Zakat), bpjs, bpjstk, online shopping (mnc shop,
Mataharimall, blibli.com, tokopedia, elevenia, and Bukalapak), multi-finance, cable tv, taxes, insurance,
teacher's room, electricity, PDAM, gas, credit, data, and telco.
Since its launch, Pospay has faced several challenges competing in the digital wallet industry. Based on
the number of accounts (NOA) data, 98.5% of Pospay’s users are an employee of PT Pos Indonesia. It shows
that Pospay's brand awareness and intention to use are still relatively low outside the company. Meanwhile,
Pospay has the goal to be the top of mind of digital wallet in Indonesia. Curently, Pospay has reached 1.535.218
number of accounts (NOA) and planning to increase its number of accounts to 5 million users and target a new
target market of people between 12-24 years old. In order to achieve its goal, the company needs to develop
improved business and marketing strategies to increase its brand awareness and intention to use of Pospay
applications.
II. LITERATURE REVIEW
Pospay was launch its applications on April 2022, it is counted as late if we compare to the
competitors. Since its launch, Pospay has already operationing for one year and 2 months. In order to know the
position of Pospay in the potential customer minds, we have to measuring the brand awareness. Brand
awareness can be assessed on several levels such as unaware of brand, brand recognition, brand recall, top of
mind and brand dominance (the only brand remembered). Brand awareness is the first and most important facet
of the overall brand knowledge system[2].
Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet…
*Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
www.aijbm.com 41 | Page
In order to create brand awareness, we must enhance brand familiarity through repeated exposure to
create brand awareness. The more a consumer "experiences" a brand through seeing, hearing, or thinking about
it, the more likely they are to remember it strongly. The brand's elements, advertising and promotion,
sponsorship and event marketing, publicity and public relations, and outdoor advertising are all things that the
customer experiences[3].According to what has been done by Pospay, the factors of brand elements, advertising
and promotion, and event marketing will be used in this study.
Besides lacking on brand awareness, the intention to use of Pospay also still relatively low. According
to Davis (1989), the cause of people using or not using an application is related to perceived usefulness and the
extent they believe it will help their job perform better. Also, even though an application is helpful for potential
users, it doesn't mean they would use it. Because at the same time, the potential users may believe that the
application is not easy to use and the effort of using the app is not comparable with the benefits they get [4].
This is how usage is influenced by perceived ease of use.
Based on the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM), perceived usefulness and ease of use are the keys
to technology acceptance or adoption. An extension of the classic TAM model by Leiva et al (2016) and Shalini
Chandra et al (2010) show how trust is also considered a decisive factor in application adoption [5][6].
Furthermore, perceived security also influence the intention to use an application [7]. According to several
literature, there are four factors that can influence the intention to use an applications which are perceived
usefulness, perceived ease of use, trust and perceived security.
This study discusses how to create the most suitable business and marketing strategy for a company or
a brand. In that case, we can't just look at the factors that affect brand awareness and intention to use the
application. This study also uses Value Proposition Canvas to consider other factors such as the customer’s
gains and pains in using digital wallets. Value Proposition Canvas analysis is a tool to help ensure customer
needs and wants are aligned with the products or services offered. In other words, it helps us to create value for
the customers. This analysis consists of two sides which are the customer profile and the value map. Customer
profile is used to clarify the understanding of the customer. Meanwhile, value map describes how we intend to
create value for customers[8].
III. RESEARCH METHOD
This study uses a mixed-methods approach, in which qualitative and quantitative data will be collected
and analyzed in parallel or sequential phases. Quantitative data is often closed-ended, as seen on surveys or
psychological instruments, but qualitative data is frequently open-ended, with no predefined responses [9].
Qualitative data were collected to analyze the value proposition canvas and measuring the brand awareness.
Meanwhile, quantitative data were collected to analyze the factors that influnces brand awareness and intention
to use the application. The quantitative carried out using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) and using Partial
Least Square (PLS) as a tool. The results of both analysis can be combine in order to find the best business and
marketing strategy to increase brand awareness and its intention to use.
IV. RESULT AND DISCUSSION
According to the calculation, the questionnaires must to distributed to the 151 respondents using the
unknown population. The limitations of respondents are people in 12-24 years old and have made transaction
used digital wallet. The author distributed the questionnaire and obtained 155 respondents. The questionnaire
using short answers and likert scale with the intervals of 1 to 5.
A. Results of Measuring Brand Awareness
B.
Figure1. Brand recognition of Pospay
The author asked the respondents with two statements “I have seen Pospay brand before” and “I
have heard Pospay brand before”. Based on the results of Fig. 1, the result from the first statement is 80.7%
of the respondents said they are disagree and strongly disagree that they have seen Pospay brand before.
Then, the result from the second statement is 76.8% of the respondents said they are disagree and strongly
disagree that they have hard Pospay brand before. This indicates that most of the respondents are they do not
know about Pospay. Based on this surveyed, Pospay in brand awareness pyramid is categorize as unaware of
the brand.
Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet…
*Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
www.aijbm.com 42 | Page
Figure 2. Potential customer respond on advertisement of Pospay
The author asked the respondents with the statement “I often see Pospay ads”. Based on the Fig. 2,
77.4% of respondents disagreed and 11.6% of respondents said netral with the statements. It shows that
respondents rarely see the advertisements of Pospay and the digital marketing that already done by Pospay not
reach the potential customer yet.
C. Results of Value Proposition Canvas Analysis
Customer Profile
Figure 3. Customer’s gains of digital wallet users
Gains tell what customers want or the benefit they are looking for from products or services. The
question in this research for gain analysis is “What benefits do you get from using a digital wallet other than
making payments?”. The question is related to the desired gains, these gains describe beyond what we expected
from a solution but would love to have if we could. Based on the survey conducted, three main gains that
customers expect are getting points or discounts or cashback, transfer to the bank and saving money.
Figure 4. Customer’s pains of digital wallet users
Pains tell what annoys the customer before, during and after trying to use the products or services. The
question in this research for pain analysis is “Is there something you need that the digital wallets you've tried
haven't been able to fulfill?”. Based on the survey conducted, there are several different answers from the
customers. The main pains that customers feel when using digital wallets are it has fees for top-up balance, can
not transfer between digital wallets and can not withdraw the cash.
The last is about customer jobs that explain about the task hey are attempting to accomplish, the
problems to solve, or the needs to satisfy. The question in this research for customer job analysis is “As a digital
wallet user, what services or payments do you usually use?”. Based on the survey conducted, the main customer
jobs that respondent willing to do are payment in merchant (QRIS), transfer, shopping, bills (electricity, water,
tax, bpjs, internet), food delivery, top-up phone credit and e-money.
Value Map
 Gain Creators
Based on the customer profile, Pospay has all the customer gains such as getting points, transfer to the bank,
saving money, no need to carry cash, manage finances and withdrawing cash except that pospay does not
have discount or cashback for making a payment in merchants or it’s payment channels.
 Pain Relievers
Based on the customer profile, the pains for the customers of digital wallets are fees for top-up balance, can
not transfer between digital wallets, can not withdraw the cash, can not making payment for parking, can not
making payment on overseas e-commerce, there is no deposito feature, can not act as credit card, there is a
minimum transfer, there is no join accounts feature, can not top-up e-money, there is no investment feature,
Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet…
*Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
www.aijbm.com 43 | Page
and there is no split bill feature. Among all the customer pains, there are just two pains that can be relived by
Pospay which are withdrawing the cash and top-up e-money.
 Products and Services
Based on the gain creators and pain relievers, we can see that there are several customer’s needs in digital
payment services that can be fulfill yet by Pospay. There are discount or cashback for making a payment in
merchants or it’s payment channels, fees for top-up balance, can not transfer between digital wallets, can not
making payment for parking, can not making payment on overseas e-commerce, there is no deposito feature,
can not act as credit card, there is a minimum transfer, there is no join accounts feature, there is no
investment feature, and there is no split bill feature. This can be use as new starategy in order to attract the
potential customers.
D. Results of Quantitative Data Analysis
Figure 5. Brand awareness and intention to use path model
The results of analysis reliability and validity using Smart PLS on brand awareness shows that some
indicators and variables are not reliable to include in this model. Therefore some variables and indicators have
to be eliminated, the variable that has been eliminated is advertising. The indicators that have been eliminated
are BE3, BE4, BE5, BE6, and BE 9. So the result of the path model for brand awareness is the figure above
(left). Meanwhile, all of the indicators and variables on intention to use are reliable to include in this model. It
can be seen on the right figure above.
Construct Reliability (Composite Reliability & Cronbach’s Alpha)
Table 1. Composite Reliability and Cronbach’s Alpha of Brand Awareness
Cronbach’s Alpha Rho A Composite Reliability
Brand Elements 0.827 1.180 0.861
Event Marketing 0.912 0.941 0.944
Sales Promotion 0.852 0.927 0.929
Brand Awareness 0.935 0.945 0.954
Table 2. Composite Reliability and Cronbach’s Aplha of Intention to Use
Cronbach’s Alpha Rho A Composite Reliability
Perceived Usefulness 0.971 0.971 0.978
Perceived Ease of Use 0.935 0.938 0.959
Trust 0.904 0.915 0.939
Perceived Security 0.909 0.910 0.943
Intention to Use 0.950 0.952 0.964
Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet…
*Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
www.aijbm.com 44 | Page
Based on the result show above in the Table 1 and Table 2, it can be seen that the Cronbach alpha and
composite reliability in each construct value is greater than 0,7. It shows that the the internal consistency value
of reliability in this research model is reliable.
Convergent Validity
Table 3. Outer Loading of Brand Awareness
Brand Elements Event Marketing Sales Promotion Brand Awareness
BE 1 0.898
BE 2 0.752
BE 7 0.746
BE 8 0.716
EM1 0.955
EM2 0.954
EM3 0.854
SP1 0.907
SP2 0.955
BA1 0.908
BA2 0.933
BA3 0.947
BA4 0.871
Table 4. Outer Loading of Intention to Use
Perceived
Usefulness
Perceived Ease of
Use
Trust Perceived
Security
Intention to Use
PU1 0.927
PU2 0.954
PU3 0.944
PU4 0.955
PU5 0.956
PEU1 0.944
PEU2 0.935
PEU3 0.944
T1 0.893
T2 0.941
T3 0.912
Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet…
*Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
www.aijbm.com 45 | Page
Perceived
Usefulness
Perceived Ease of
Use
Trust Perceived
Security
Intention to Use
PS1 0.915
PS2 0.926
PS3 0.919
IU1 0.927
IU2 0.940
IU3 0.933
IU4 0.928
Based on the results of outer loading value in table above, it shows that the value of outer loading is
more than 0.708. It indicates that all the indicators have high outer loading. High outer loading indicates that the
indicators have much in common with the construct. In other words, the indicators are works on its
measurement model.
Table 5. Average Variance Extracted (AVE) of Brand Awareness
Average Variance Extracted (AVE)
Brand Elements 0.610
Event Marketing 0.850
Sales Promotion 0.867
Brand Awareness 0.838
Table 6. Average Variance Extracted (AVE) of Intention to Use
Average Variance Extracted (AVE)
Perceived Usefulness 0.898
Perceived Ease of Use 0.886
Trust 0.838
Perceived Security 0.846
Intention to Use 0.869
Based on the Table 5 and Table 6, it show that the value of average variance extracted (AVE) on all
construct is greater than 0.5. It indicates that the model that use in this research is a good model.
Discriminant Validity
Table 7. Cross Loading of Brand Awareness
Brand Elements Event Marketing Sales Promotion Brand Awareness
BE 1 0.898 0.231 0.342 0.371
BE 2 0.752 0.240 0.409 0.133
BE 7 0.746 0.300 0.434 0.147
BE 8 0.716 0.244 0.346 0.089
Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet…
*Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
www.aijbm.com 46 | Page
Brand Elements Event Marketing Sales Promotion Brand Awareness
EM1 0.265 0.955 0.332 0.269
EM2 0.252 0.954 0.261 0.299
EM3 0.342 0.854 0.338 0.211
SP1 0.378 0.285 0.907 0.025
SP2 0.459 0.326 0.955 0.035
BA1 0.285 0.191 0.080 0.908
BA2 0.315 0.242 0.028 0.933
BA3 0.283 0.332 0.050 0.947
BA4 0.230 0.263 0.031 0.871
Table 8. Cross Loading of Intention to Use
Perceived
Usefulness
Perceived Ease
of Use
Trust Perceived
Security
Intention to Use
PU1 0.927 0.758 0.580 0.552 0.719
PU2 0.954 0.752 0.612 0.569 0.721
PU3 0.944 0.753 0.584 0.551 0.705
PU4 0.955 0.760 0.576 0.546 0.700
PU5 0.956 0.776 0.581 0.563 0.726
PEU1 0.750 0.944 0.594 0.552 0.641
PEU2 0.745 0.935 0.605 0.597 0.592
PEU3 0.768 0.944 0.606 0.531 0.663
T1 0.520 0.542 0.893 0.647 0.532
T2 0.548 0.587 0.941 0.671 0.628
T3 0.623 0.620 0.912 0.633 0.672
PS1 0.556 0.530 0.631 0.915 0.610
PS2 0.549 0.576 0.657 0.926 0.636
PS3 0.513 0.531 0.669 0.919 0.589
IU1 0.712 0.628 0.665 0.628 0.927
IU2 0.740 0.645 0.680 0.668 0.940
IU3 0.685 0.601 0.536 0.576 0.933
IU4 0.670 0.633 0.615 0.605 0.928
Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet…
*Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
www.aijbm.com 47 | Page
Based on the Table 7 and Table 8, it shows that the value of interrelated constructions is greater than
other constructions. It can be concluded that there is no discriminant validity problem in the model on this study.
Comparing AVE Root and Latent Variable Correlation
Table 9. Latent Variable Correlation of Brand Awareness
Brand
Elements
Event
Marketing
Sales
Promotion
Brand
Awareness
Brand Elements 1.000 0.303 0.455 0.304
Event Marketing 0.303 1.000 0.330 0.286
Sales Promotion 0.455 0.330 1.000 0.033
Brand Awareness 0.304 0.286 0.033 1.000
Table 10. Latent Variable Correlation of Intention to Use
Perceived
Usefulness
Perceived
Ease of Use
Trust Perceived
Security
Intention
to Use
Perceived
Usefulness
1.000 0.802 0.619 0.587 0.754
Perceived Ease
of Use
0.802 1.000 0.639 0.594 0.673
Trust 0.619 0.639 1.000 0.709 0.672
Perceived
Security
0.587 0.594 0.709 1.000 0.666
Intention to Use 0.754 0.673 0.672 0.666 1.000
Table 11, AVE Root of Brand Awareness
Average Variance Extracted (AVE) Root
Brand Elements 0.781
Event Marketing 0.922
Sales Promotion 0.931
Brand Awareness 0.915
Table 12. AVE Root of Intention to Use
Average Variance Extracted (AVE) Root
Perceived Usefulness 0.948
Perceived Ease of Use 0.941
Trust 0.915
Perceived Security 0.920
Intention to Use 0.932
Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet…
*Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
www.aijbm.com 48 | Page
Based on the table above, the author compare the value of AVE root and latent variable correlation.
The result is all the value of AVE root is higher than latent variable correlation. For example, the correlation
between perceived usefulness and intention to use is 0.754. Then, the AVE root of perceived usefulness is
0.948. It can be concluded that the construct in this study has good discriminant validity.
Value of Variance Inflation Factor (VIF)
Table 13. VIF Value of Brand Awareness
Brand Elements Event Marketing Sales Promotion Brand Awareness
Brand Elements 1.304
Event Marketing 1.161
Sales Promotion 1.330
Brand Awareness
Table 14. VIF Value of Intention to Use
Perceived
Usefulness
Perceived Ease
of Use
Trust Perceived
Security
Intention to Use
Perceived
Usefulness
3.014
Perceived Ease of
Use
3.126
Trust 2.404
Perceived Security 2.193
Intention to Use
Based on the Table 13 and Table 14, it shows that all the value of Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) is
below 05.00. It indicates that this structural model has no collinearity, so there is no need to eliminate the
construct, and the model can proceed to the next step.
Significance and Relevance of Structural Model
Table 15. Mean, STDEV, T-Values, P-Values of Brand Awareness
Original
Sample
(O)
Sample
Mean (M)
Standard
Deviation
(|O/STDEV|)
T Statistics
(0/STDEV)
P Values
Brand Elements ->
Brand Awareness
0.316 0.323 0.065 4.588 0.041 Accepted
Event Marketing ->
Brand Awareness
0.254 0.245 0.065 4.065 0.000 Accepted
Sales Promotion ->
Brand Awareness
-0.195 -0.168 0.112 1.796 0.000 Accepted
Based on the analysis results in the Table 15, it shows that the P value has a smaller number than the
level significance 0.5. It indicates that brand elements, event marketing and sales promotion have a significant
effect on brand awareness. Then, the T values can be compare with the T table at significance level of 5% (one
tailed=1.645). The table results show that all the T values has a higher number than 1.645. It indicates that brand
elements, event marketing and sales promotion are influence the brand awareness positively. Overall, if the list
if being rank the variable that most influence the brand awareness are brand elements, event marketing and sales
promotion.
Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet…
*Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
www.aijbm.com 49 | Page
Table 16. Mean, STDEV, T-Values, P-Values of Intention to Use
Original
Sample
(O)
Sample
Mean (M)
Standard
Deviation
(STDEV)
T Statistics
(|0/STDEV|)
P Values
Perceived Usefulness ->
Intention to Use
0.470 0.473 0.095 4.929 0.000 Accepted
Perceived Ease of Use -
> Intention to Use
0.034 0.035 0.108 0.312 0.378 Rejected
Trust -> Intention to Use 0.196 0.178 0.088 2.232 0.013 Accepted
Perceived Security ->
Intention to Use
0.231 0.243 0.095 2.422 0.008 Accepted
Based on the analysis results in the Table 16, it shows that perceived usefulness, trust and perceived
security have a significant effect on intention to use because the p values is smaller than the level significance
0.05. The same results also show when comparing the T values and T table. The T values of perceived
usefulness, trust and perceived security have a higher number that 1.645. It indicates that perceived usefulness,
trust and perceived security are influence on intention to use positively.
Meanwhile, the p values of perceived ease of use is 0.378 bigger than 0.05. It indicates that perceived
ease of use do not have a significant effect on intention to use. The same result also show when comparing the T
values and T table. The T values of perceived ease of use are smaller than T table of 1.654. It indicates that
perceived ease of use do not influence on intention to use. Overall, if the list if being rank the variable that most
influence the intention to use are perceived usefulness, perceived security and trust.
R Square
Table 17. Coefficient Determinacy (R2) of Brand Awareness
R Square R Square Adjusted
Brand Awareness 0.162 0.146
Based on the Table 17, it can be seen that R2 value of variable brand awareness in this model is 0.146.
It indicates that the model of questionnaire for brand awareness in this research is classified as weak.
Table 18. Coefficient Determinacy (R2) of Intention to Use
R Square R Square Adjusted
Intention to Use 0.662 0.653
Based on the table 18, it can be seen that R2 value of intention to use in this model is 0.653. It
indicates that the model of questionnaire for intention to use in this research is classified as moderate.
V. CONCLUSION
Pospay needs to develop its business and marketing strategy. To increase brand awareness, Pospay
must be concerned about its brand elements, event marketing and sales promotion. Perceived usefulness,
perceived security and trust are the factors that should be a concern to increase the intention to use Pospay
applications. More specifically, based on the Value Proposition Canvas, there are several alternative strategies to
attract potential customers of digital wallet users based on their gains and pains. Pospay can create a discount or
cashback program for payment in merchants or its payment channels to develop its sales promotion. Then,
Pospay can develop a new feature to help users transfer between digital wallets. It is related and can expand
Pospay usefulness for users.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This paper is an essemce of the thesis entitled “Proposed Marketing Strategy for Pospay to Increase Brand
Awareness and Intention to Use, School of Business and Management, Bandung Institute of Technology
Indonesia.
Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet…
*Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1
www.aijbm.com 50 | Page
REFERENCES
[1] Departemen Statistik Moneter dan Fiskal. (2021). Analisis Perkembangan Uang Beredar (M2) -
Desember 2021. Jakarta: Bank Indonesia.
[2] Keller, K. L. (2013). Strategic Brand Management. Pearson Education, Inc.
[3] Davis, F. D. (1989). Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use and User Acceptance of Information
Technology. MIS Quarterly, 319-340.
[4] Chandra, S., Srivastava, S. C., & Theng, Y. L. (2010). Evaluating The Role of Trust in Consumer
Adoption of Mobile Payment Systems: An Empirical Anlysis. Communications of the Association for
Information Systems, 561-588.
[5] Cadel, J., Paul, D., & Turner, P. (2014). Business Analysis Techniques: 99 Essential Tools for Success.
United Kingdom: BCS Learning & Development Ltd.
[6] Hitt, M. A., Hoskisson, R. E., & Ireland, R. D. (2016). Strategic Management: Concepts and Cases:
Competitiveness and Globalization. Cengage Learning.
[7] Kotler, P., & Keller, K. L. (2012). Marketing Management. Prentice Hall.
[8] Pigneur, Y., Osterwalder, A., & Clark, T. (2010). Business Model Generation: A Handbook for
Visionaries, Game Changers, and Challengers. Wiley.
[9] Tashakkori, A., & Teddlie, C. (2003). Handbook of Mixed Methods in Social and Behavioral Research.
Sage Publications.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Semelhante a F574050.pdf

Kstart Digital Marketing Survey Report_June 2016
Kstart Digital Marketing Survey Report_June 2016Kstart Digital Marketing Survey Report_June 2016
Kstart Digital Marketing Survey Report_June 2016Deepan Siddhu
 
A study an awareness on digital marketing
A study an awareness on digital marketingA study an awareness on digital marketing
A study an awareness on digital marketingBhavik Parmar
 
The Impact of Social Media Marketing Activities on Consumer Purchase Intentio...
The Impact of Social Media Marketing Activities on Consumer Purchase Intentio...The Impact of Social Media Marketing Activities on Consumer Purchase Intentio...
The Impact of Social Media Marketing Activities on Consumer Purchase Intentio...ijtsrd
 
(107) digital marketing emerging trends
(107) digital marketing emerging trends(107) digital marketing emerging trends
(107) digital marketing emerging trendsHariharanAmutha1
 
A580108.pdf
A580108.pdfA580108.pdf
A580108.pdfaijbm
 
Study of Marketing and Communication Strategy used by Digital Marketing Porta...
Study of Marketing and Communication Strategy used by Digital Marketing Porta...Study of Marketing and Communication Strategy used by Digital Marketing Porta...
Study of Marketing and Communication Strategy used by Digital Marketing Porta...Shubham Singh
 
Social_Media_Optimization
Social_Media_OptimizationSocial_Media_Optimization
Social_Media_Optimizationsfghh
 
Training on Digital Strategy & Planning
Training on Digital Strategy & PlanningTraining on Digital Strategy & Planning
Training on Digital Strategy & PlanningMadhura Chaudhuri
 
Aditya Raj ntcc Research paper - for merge.docx
Aditya Raj ntcc Research paper - for merge.docxAditya Raj ntcc Research paper - for merge.docx
Aditya Raj ntcc Research paper - for merge.docxAditya Raj
 
Utilization of “Word of Mouth” based on Unique Selling Point on Beauty Produc...
Utilization of “Word of Mouth” based on Unique Selling Point on Beauty Produc...Utilization of “Word of Mouth” based on Unique Selling Point on Beauty Produc...
Utilization of “Word of Mouth” based on Unique Selling Point on Beauty Produc...AJHSSR Journal
 
digital marketing
digital marketingdigital marketing
digital marketingSrideviHV
 
A STUDY ON LITERATURE REVIEW FOR IDENTIFYING THE FACTORS IMPACTING DIGITAL MA...
A STUDY ON LITERATURE REVIEW FOR IDENTIFYING THE FACTORS IMPACTING DIGITAL MA...A STUDY ON LITERATURE REVIEW FOR IDENTIFYING THE FACTORS IMPACTING DIGITAL MA...
A STUDY ON LITERATURE REVIEW FOR IDENTIFYING THE FACTORS IMPACTING DIGITAL MA...Claire Webber
 
Increasing Purchase Intention through Brand Awareness and Brand Trust A Study...
Increasing Purchase Intention through Brand Awareness and Brand Trust A Study...Increasing Purchase Intention through Brand Awareness and Brand Trust A Study...
Increasing Purchase Intention through Brand Awareness and Brand Trust A Study...ijtsrd
 
Marketing Plan submission for Tala India - Lending company
Marketing Plan submission for Tala India - Lending companyMarketing Plan submission for Tala India - Lending company
Marketing Plan submission for Tala India - Lending companyVartika Verma
 
Thailand digital advertising spend 2016-2017
Thailand digital advertising spend 2016-2017Thailand digital advertising spend 2016-2017
Thailand digital advertising spend 2016-2017Jirawat Jivacate
 
3 ijaems sept-2015-4-mining consumer knowledge from shopping experience a ca...
3 ijaems sept-2015-4-mining consumer knowledge from shopping experience  a ca...3 ijaems sept-2015-4-mining consumer knowledge from shopping experience  a ca...
3 ijaems sept-2015-4-mining consumer knowledge from shopping experience a ca...INFOGAIN PUBLICATION
 

Semelhante a F574050.pdf (20)

Kstart Digital Marketing Survey Report_June 2016
Kstart Digital Marketing Survey Report_June 2016Kstart Digital Marketing Survey Report_June 2016
Kstart Digital Marketing Survey Report_June 2016
 
A study an awareness on digital marketing
A study an awareness on digital marketingA study an awareness on digital marketing
A study an awareness on digital marketing
 
The Impact of Social Media Marketing Activities on Consumer Purchase Intentio...
The Impact of Social Media Marketing Activities on Consumer Purchase Intentio...The Impact of Social Media Marketing Activities on Consumer Purchase Intentio...
The Impact of Social Media Marketing Activities on Consumer Purchase Intentio...
 
(107) digital marketing emerging trends
(107) digital marketing emerging trends(107) digital marketing emerging trends
(107) digital marketing emerging trends
 
A580108.pdf
A580108.pdfA580108.pdf
A580108.pdf
 
Study of Marketing and Communication Strategy used by Digital Marketing Porta...
Study of Marketing and Communication Strategy used by Digital Marketing Porta...Study of Marketing and Communication Strategy used by Digital Marketing Porta...
Study of Marketing and Communication Strategy used by Digital Marketing Porta...
 
Apurv Joshi MRP
Apurv Joshi MRPApurv Joshi MRP
Apurv Joshi MRP
 
Social_Media_Optimization
Social_Media_OptimizationSocial_Media_Optimization
Social_Media_Optimization
 
Training on Digital Strategy & Planning
Training on Digital Strategy & PlanningTraining on Digital Strategy & Planning
Training on Digital Strategy & Planning
 
Aditya Raj ntcc Research paper - for merge.docx
Aditya Raj ntcc Research paper - for merge.docxAditya Raj ntcc Research paper - for merge.docx
Aditya Raj ntcc Research paper - for merge.docx
 
Utilization of “Word of Mouth” based on Unique Selling Point on Beauty Produc...
Utilization of “Word of Mouth” based on Unique Selling Point on Beauty Produc...Utilization of “Word of Mouth” based on Unique Selling Point on Beauty Produc...
Utilization of “Word of Mouth” based on Unique Selling Point on Beauty Produc...
 
digital marketing
digital marketingdigital marketing
digital marketing
 
A STUDY ON LITERATURE REVIEW FOR IDENTIFYING THE FACTORS IMPACTING DIGITAL MA...
A STUDY ON LITERATURE REVIEW FOR IDENTIFYING THE FACTORS IMPACTING DIGITAL MA...A STUDY ON LITERATURE REVIEW FOR IDENTIFYING THE FACTORS IMPACTING DIGITAL MA...
A STUDY ON LITERATURE REVIEW FOR IDENTIFYING THE FACTORS IMPACTING DIGITAL MA...
 
Rai octane report2014
Rai octane report2014Rai octane report2014
Rai octane report2014
 
Increasing Purchase Intention through Brand Awareness and Brand Trust A Study...
Increasing Purchase Intention through Brand Awareness and Brand Trust A Study...Increasing Purchase Intention through Brand Awareness and Brand Trust A Study...
Increasing Purchase Intention through Brand Awareness and Brand Trust A Study...
 
Factors Affecting Customer Trustand Customer Loyaltyin the Online Shopping: a...
Factors Affecting Customer Trustand Customer Loyaltyin the Online Shopping: a...Factors Affecting Customer Trustand Customer Loyaltyin the Online Shopping: a...
Factors Affecting Customer Trustand Customer Loyaltyin the Online Shopping: a...
 
FULLTEXT01.pdf
FULLTEXT01.pdfFULLTEXT01.pdf
FULLTEXT01.pdf
 
Marketing Plan submission for Tala India - Lending company
Marketing Plan submission for Tala India - Lending companyMarketing Plan submission for Tala India - Lending company
Marketing Plan submission for Tala India - Lending company
 
Thailand digital advertising spend 2016-2017
Thailand digital advertising spend 2016-2017Thailand digital advertising spend 2016-2017
Thailand digital advertising spend 2016-2017
 
3 ijaems sept-2015-4-mining consumer knowledge from shopping experience a ca...
3 ijaems sept-2015-4-mining consumer knowledge from shopping experience  a ca...3 ijaems sept-2015-4-mining consumer knowledge from shopping experience  a ca...
3 ijaems sept-2015-4-mining consumer knowledge from shopping experience a ca...
 

Mais de aijbm

E582740.pdf
E582740.pdfE582740.pdf
E582740.pdfaijbm
 
F584145.pdf
F584145.pdfF584145.pdf
F584145.pdfaijbm
 
B580914.pdf
B580914.pdfB580914.pdf
B580914.pdfaijbm
 
H585357.pdf
H585357.pdfH585357.pdf
H585357.pdfaijbm
 
G584652.pdf
G584652.pdfG584652.pdf
G584652.pdfaijbm
 
D582026.pdf
D582026.pdfD582026.pdf
D582026.pdfaijbm
 
C581519.pdf
C581519.pdfC581519.pdf
C581519.pdfaijbm
 
M5799113.pdf
M5799113.pdfM5799113.pdf
M5799113.pdfaijbm
 
O57120129.pdf
O57120129.pdfO57120129.pdf
O57120129.pdfaijbm
 
R57139145.pdf
R57139145.pdfR57139145.pdf
R57139145.pdfaijbm
 
J577177.pdf
J577177.pdfJ577177.pdf
J577177.pdfaijbm
 
Q57136138.pdf
Q57136138.pdfQ57136138.pdf
Q57136138.pdfaijbm
 
C572126.pdf
C572126.pdfC572126.pdf
C572126.pdfaijbm
 
E573539.pdf
E573539.pdfE573539.pdf
E573539.pdfaijbm
 
I576670.pdf
I576670.pdfI576670.pdf
I576670.pdfaijbm
 
S57146154.pdf
S57146154.pdfS57146154.pdf
S57146154.pdfaijbm
 
K577886.pdf
K577886.pdfK577886.pdf
K577886.pdfaijbm
 
L578798.pdf
L578798.pdfL578798.pdf
L578798.pdfaijbm
 
G575157.pdf
G575157.pdfG575157.pdf
G575157.pdfaijbm
 
N57114119.pdf
N57114119.pdfN57114119.pdf
N57114119.pdfaijbm
 

Mais de aijbm (20)

E582740.pdf
E582740.pdfE582740.pdf
E582740.pdf
 
F584145.pdf
F584145.pdfF584145.pdf
F584145.pdf
 
B580914.pdf
B580914.pdfB580914.pdf
B580914.pdf
 
H585357.pdf
H585357.pdfH585357.pdf
H585357.pdf
 
G584652.pdf
G584652.pdfG584652.pdf
G584652.pdf
 
D582026.pdf
D582026.pdfD582026.pdf
D582026.pdf
 
C581519.pdf
C581519.pdfC581519.pdf
C581519.pdf
 
M5799113.pdf
M5799113.pdfM5799113.pdf
M5799113.pdf
 
O57120129.pdf
O57120129.pdfO57120129.pdf
O57120129.pdf
 
R57139145.pdf
R57139145.pdfR57139145.pdf
R57139145.pdf
 
J577177.pdf
J577177.pdfJ577177.pdf
J577177.pdf
 
Q57136138.pdf
Q57136138.pdfQ57136138.pdf
Q57136138.pdf
 
C572126.pdf
C572126.pdfC572126.pdf
C572126.pdf
 
E573539.pdf
E573539.pdfE573539.pdf
E573539.pdf
 
I576670.pdf
I576670.pdfI576670.pdf
I576670.pdf
 
S57146154.pdf
S57146154.pdfS57146154.pdf
S57146154.pdf
 
K577886.pdf
K577886.pdfK577886.pdf
K577886.pdf
 
L578798.pdf
L578798.pdfL578798.pdf
L578798.pdf
 
G575157.pdf
G575157.pdfG575157.pdf
G575157.pdf
 
N57114119.pdf
N57114119.pdfN57114119.pdf
N57114119.pdf
 

Último

B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptxB.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptxpriyanshujha201
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756dollysharma2066
 
John Halpern sued for sexual assault.pdf
John Halpern sued for sexual assault.pdfJohn Halpern sued for sexual assault.pdf
John Halpern sued for sexual assault.pdfAmzadHosen3
 
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan CommunicationsPharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communicationskarancommunications
 
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsValue Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsP&CO
 
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bangalore
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service BangaloreCall Girls Hebbal Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bangalore
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bangaloreamitlee9823
 
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...anilsa9823
 
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...Paul Menig
 
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...Aggregage
 
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageInsurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageMatteo Carbone
 
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...Roland Driesen
 
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...Any kyc Account
 
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...lizamodels9
 
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room ServiceCall Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Servicediscovermytutordmt
 
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...lizamodels9
 
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayIt will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayNZSG
 
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒anilsa9823
 
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Neil Kimberley
 

Último (20)

B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptxB.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
B.COM Unit – 4 ( CORPORATE SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY ( CSR ).pptx
 
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
FULL ENJOY Call Girls In Majnu Ka Tilla, Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
 
unwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabi
unwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabiunwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabi
unwanted pregnancy Kit [+918133066128] Abortion Pills IN Dubai UAE Abudhabi
 
John Halpern sued for sexual assault.pdf
John Halpern sued for sexual assault.pdfJohn Halpern sued for sexual assault.pdf
John Halpern sued for sexual assault.pdf
 
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan CommunicationsPharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
Pharma Works Profile of Karan Communications
 
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and painsValue Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
Value Proposition canvas- Customer needs and pains
 
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bangalore
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service BangaloreCall Girls Hebbal Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bangalore
Call Girls Hebbal Just Call 👗 7737669865 👗 Top Class Call Girl Service Bangalore
 
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...
Lucknow 💋 Escorts in Lucknow - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 8923113531 Neha Th...
 
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
7.pdf This presentation captures many uses and the significance of the number...
 
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
The Path to Product Excellence: Avoiding Common Pitfalls and Enhancing Commun...
 
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usageInsurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
Insurers' journeys to build a mastery in the IoT usage
 
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
Boost the utilization of your HCL environment by reevaluating use cases and f...
 
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pillsMifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
Mifty kit IN Salmiya (+918133066128) Abortion pills IN Salmiyah Cytotec pills
 
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
KYC-Verified Accounts: Helping Companies Handle Challenging Regulatory Enviro...
 
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
Call Girls In DLf Gurgaon ➥99902@11544 ( Best price)100% Genuine Escort In 24...
 
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room ServiceCall Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116  - With room Service
Call Girls in Gomti Nagar - 7388211116 - With room Service
 
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
Russian Call Girls In Gurgaon ❤️8448577510 ⊹Best Escorts Service In 24/7 Delh...
 
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 MayIt will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
It will be International Nurses' Day on 12 May
 
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow  ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝  Cash Payment (COD) 👒
VIP Call Girls In Saharaganj ( Lucknow ) 🔝 8923113531 🔝 Cash Payment (COD) 👒
 
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
Mondelez State of Snacking and Future Trends 2023
 

F574050.pdf

  • 1. American International Journal of Business Management (AIJBM) ISSN- 2379-106X, www.aijbm.com Volume 5, Issue 07 (July-2022), PP 40-50 *Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 www.aijbm.com 40 | Page Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 , Prawira Fajarindra Belgiawan2 1 School of Business and Management / Bandung Institute of Technology, Indonesia 2 School of Business and Management / Bandung Institute of Technology, Indonesia ABSTRACT: Indonesia has been actively doing digitalization, marked by the increase in mobile connections and internet users. In 2020, more people were using them due to the spread of the COVID-19. Because of the pandemic, government encourages the public to make transactions using cashless payments. One of the cashless payment methods that are growing is digital wallet. PT Pos Indonesia saw this as an opportunity to develop its digital wallet called Pospay. Since its launch, on 13th April 2021, Pospay has faced several challenges. 98.5% of Pospay’s users are an employee of PT Pos Indonesia. It shows that brand awareness and intention to use of Pospay are still relatively low outside the company. This study will focus on how Pospay could increase its brand awareness and intention to use. The analysis was conducted using consumer analysis by distributing the questionnaire to the potential consumers. The quantitative data is processed using Smart PLS software with the SEM-PLS method. Then, the qualitative data will be used to analyze Value Proposition Canvas. The results show that Pospay can create a discount or cashback program and develop a new feature to help users transfer between digital wallets to increase brand awareness and intention to use. KEYWORDS -marketing strategy, brand awareness, intention to use, digital wallet, SEM-PLS I. INTRODUCTION The global industry is experiencing a new digital era 4.0, and Indonesia is no exception. In this digital era, almost all public activities have shifted to digitalization, including payment activities that shifted to cashless payment methods from the conventional. One of the cashless methods that are growing in Indonesia is the digital wallet industry [1]. In 2020, there is COVID-19 that occurred in Indonesia and even in all parts of the world. The WHO warned the world's citizens that the COVID-19 virus could live and stick to inanimate objects, including money. This virus can live and survive for days on paper money. Therefore, WHO urges the public to use non-cash payment instruments when making transactions. Based on the statement of WHO, the Governor of Bank Indonesia, Perry Warjiyo, appealed to the public to transact using cashless payment when paying in-store, paying bills, or making purchases on delivery food, online transport, e-commerce, websites, or online shopping. This situation has led to a growth in the use of digital wallets. As one of the financial service providers, Pos Indonesia saw this as an opportunity to develop. Pos Indonesia created a digital- based payment service that categorizes as a digital wallet called “Pospay” to make transactions easier for everyone, and it launched on April 13, 2021. Pospay offers several features payment such as QRIS, transfer, sharia services (BAZNAS and Rumah Zakat), bpjs, bpjstk, online shopping (mnc shop, Mataharimall, blibli.com, tokopedia, elevenia, and Bukalapak), multi-finance, cable tv, taxes, insurance, teacher's room, electricity, PDAM, gas, credit, data, and telco. Since its launch, Pospay has faced several challenges competing in the digital wallet industry. Based on the number of accounts (NOA) data, 98.5% of Pospay’s users are an employee of PT Pos Indonesia. It shows that Pospay's brand awareness and intention to use are still relatively low outside the company. Meanwhile, Pospay has the goal to be the top of mind of digital wallet in Indonesia. Curently, Pospay has reached 1.535.218 number of accounts (NOA) and planning to increase its number of accounts to 5 million users and target a new target market of people between 12-24 years old. In order to achieve its goal, the company needs to develop improved business and marketing strategies to increase its brand awareness and intention to use of Pospay applications. II. LITERATURE REVIEW Pospay was launch its applications on April 2022, it is counted as late if we compare to the competitors. Since its launch, Pospay has already operationing for one year and 2 months. In order to know the position of Pospay in the potential customer minds, we have to measuring the brand awareness. Brand awareness can be assessed on several levels such as unaware of brand, brand recognition, brand recall, top of mind and brand dominance (the only brand remembered). Brand awareness is the first and most important facet of the overall brand knowledge system[2].
  • 2. Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet… *Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 www.aijbm.com 41 | Page In order to create brand awareness, we must enhance brand familiarity through repeated exposure to create brand awareness. The more a consumer "experiences" a brand through seeing, hearing, or thinking about it, the more likely they are to remember it strongly. The brand's elements, advertising and promotion, sponsorship and event marketing, publicity and public relations, and outdoor advertising are all things that the customer experiences[3].According to what has been done by Pospay, the factors of brand elements, advertising and promotion, and event marketing will be used in this study. Besides lacking on brand awareness, the intention to use of Pospay also still relatively low. According to Davis (1989), the cause of people using or not using an application is related to perceived usefulness and the extent they believe it will help their job perform better. Also, even though an application is helpful for potential users, it doesn't mean they would use it. Because at the same time, the potential users may believe that the application is not easy to use and the effort of using the app is not comparable with the benefits they get [4]. This is how usage is influenced by perceived ease of use. Based on the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM), perceived usefulness and ease of use are the keys to technology acceptance or adoption. An extension of the classic TAM model by Leiva et al (2016) and Shalini Chandra et al (2010) show how trust is also considered a decisive factor in application adoption [5][6]. Furthermore, perceived security also influence the intention to use an application [7]. According to several literature, there are four factors that can influence the intention to use an applications which are perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, trust and perceived security. This study discusses how to create the most suitable business and marketing strategy for a company or a brand. In that case, we can't just look at the factors that affect brand awareness and intention to use the application. This study also uses Value Proposition Canvas to consider other factors such as the customer’s gains and pains in using digital wallets. Value Proposition Canvas analysis is a tool to help ensure customer needs and wants are aligned with the products or services offered. In other words, it helps us to create value for the customers. This analysis consists of two sides which are the customer profile and the value map. Customer profile is used to clarify the understanding of the customer. Meanwhile, value map describes how we intend to create value for customers[8]. III. RESEARCH METHOD This study uses a mixed-methods approach, in which qualitative and quantitative data will be collected and analyzed in parallel or sequential phases. Quantitative data is often closed-ended, as seen on surveys or psychological instruments, but qualitative data is frequently open-ended, with no predefined responses [9]. Qualitative data were collected to analyze the value proposition canvas and measuring the brand awareness. Meanwhile, quantitative data were collected to analyze the factors that influnces brand awareness and intention to use the application. The quantitative carried out using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) and using Partial Least Square (PLS) as a tool. The results of both analysis can be combine in order to find the best business and marketing strategy to increase brand awareness and its intention to use. IV. RESULT AND DISCUSSION According to the calculation, the questionnaires must to distributed to the 151 respondents using the unknown population. The limitations of respondents are people in 12-24 years old and have made transaction used digital wallet. The author distributed the questionnaire and obtained 155 respondents. The questionnaire using short answers and likert scale with the intervals of 1 to 5. A. Results of Measuring Brand Awareness B. Figure1. Brand recognition of Pospay The author asked the respondents with two statements “I have seen Pospay brand before” and “I have heard Pospay brand before”. Based on the results of Fig. 1, the result from the first statement is 80.7% of the respondents said they are disagree and strongly disagree that they have seen Pospay brand before. Then, the result from the second statement is 76.8% of the respondents said they are disagree and strongly disagree that they have hard Pospay brand before. This indicates that most of the respondents are they do not know about Pospay. Based on this surveyed, Pospay in brand awareness pyramid is categorize as unaware of the brand.
  • 3. Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet… *Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 www.aijbm.com 42 | Page Figure 2. Potential customer respond on advertisement of Pospay The author asked the respondents with the statement “I often see Pospay ads”. Based on the Fig. 2, 77.4% of respondents disagreed and 11.6% of respondents said netral with the statements. It shows that respondents rarely see the advertisements of Pospay and the digital marketing that already done by Pospay not reach the potential customer yet. C. Results of Value Proposition Canvas Analysis Customer Profile Figure 3. Customer’s gains of digital wallet users Gains tell what customers want or the benefit they are looking for from products or services. The question in this research for gain analysis is “What benefits do you get from using a digital wallet other than making payments?”. The question is related to the desired gains, these gains describe beyond what we expected from a solution but would love to have if we could. Based on the survey conducted, three main gains that customers expect are getting points or discounts or cashback, transfer to the bank and saving money. Figure 4. Customer’s pains of digital wallet users Pains tell what annoys the customer before, during and after trying to use the products or services. The question in this research for pain analysis is “Is there something you need that the digital wallets you've tried haven't been able to fulfill?”. Based on the survey conducted, there are several different answers from the customers. The main pains that customers feel when using digital wallets are it has fees for top-up balance, can not transfer between digital wallets and can not withdraw the cash. The last is about customer jobs that explain about the task hey are attempting to accomplish, the problems to solve, or the needs to satisfy. The question in this research for customer job analysis is “As a digital wallet user, what services or payments do you usually use?”. Based on the survey conducted, the main customer jobs that respondent willing to do are payment in merchant (QRIS), transfer, shopping, bills (electricity, water, tax, bpjs, internet), food delivery, top-up phone credit and e-money. Value Map  Gain Creators Based on the customer profile, Pospay has all the customer gains such as getting points, transfer to the bank, saving money, no need to carry cash, manage finances and withdrawing cash except that pospay does not have discount or cashback for making a payment in merchants or it’s payment channels.  Pain Relievers Based on the customer profile, the pains for the customers of digital wallets are fees for top-up balance, can not transfer between digital wallets, can not withdraw the cash, can not making payment for parking, can not making payment on overseas e-commerce, there is no deposito feature, can not act as credit card, there is a minimum transfer, there is no join accounts feature, can not top-up e-money, there is no investment feature,
  • 4. Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet… *Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 www.aijbm.com 43 | Page and there is no split bill feature. Among all the customer pains, there are just two pains that can be relived by Pospay which are withdrawing the cash and top-up e-money.  Products and Services Based on the gain creators and pain relievers, we can see that there are several customer’s needs in digital payment services that can be fulfill yet by Pospay. There are discount or cashback for making a payment in merchants or it’s payment channels, fees for top-up balance, can not transfer between digital wallets, can not making payment for parking, can not making payment on overseas e-commerce, there is no deposito feature, can not act as credit card, there is a minimum transfer, there is no join accounts feature, there is no investment feature, and there is no split bill feature. This can be use as new starategy in order to attract the potential customers. D. Results of Quantitative Data Analysis Figure 5. Brand awareness and intention to use path model The results of analysis reliability and validity using Smart PLS on brand awareness shows that some indicators and variables are not reliable to include in this model. Therefore some variables and indicators have to be eliminated, the variable that has been eliminated is advertising. The indicators that have been eliminated are BE3, BE4, BE5, BE6, and BE 9. So the result of the path model for brand awareness is the figure above (left). Meanwhile, all of the indicators and variables on intention to use are reliable to include in this model. It can be seen on the right figure above. Construct Reliability (Composite Reliability & Cronbach’s Alpha) Table 1. Composite Reliability and Cronbach’s Alpha of Brand Awareness Cronbach’s Alpha Rho A Composite Reliability Brand Elements 0.827 1.180 0.861 Event Marketing 0.912 0.941 0.944 Sales Promotion 0.852 0.927 0.929 Brand Awareness 0.935 0.945 0.954 Table 2. Composite Reliability and Cronbach’s Aplha of Intention to Use Cronbach’s Alpha Rho A Composite Reliability Perceived Usefulness 0.971 0.971 0.978 Perceived Ease of Use 0.935 0.938 0.959 Trust 0.904 0.915 0.939 Perceived Security 0.909 0.910 0.943 Intention to Use 0.950 0.952 0.964
  • 5. Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet… *Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 www.aijbm.com 44 | Page Based on the result show above in the Table 1 and Table 2, it can be seen that the Cronbach alpha and composite reliability in each construct value is greater than 0,7. It shows that the the internal consistency value of reliability in this research model is reliable. Convergent Validity Table 3. Outer Loading of Brand Awareness Brand Elements Event Marketing Sales Promotion Brand Awareness BE 1 0.898 BE 2 0.752 BE 7 0.746 BE 8 0.716 EM1 0.955 EM2 0.954 EM3 0.854 SP1 0.907 SP2 0.955 BA1 0.908 BA2 0.933 BA3 0.947 BA4 0.871 Table 4. Outer Loading of Intention to Use Perceived Usefulness Perceived Ease of Use Trust Perceived Security Intention to Use PU1 0.927 PU2 0.954 PU3 0.944 PU4 0.955 PU5 0.956 PEU1 0.944 PEU2 0.935 PEU3 0.944 T1 0.893 T2 0.941 T3 0.912
  • 6. Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet… *Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 www.aijbm.com 45 | Page Perceived Usefulness Perceived Ease of Use Trust Perceived Security Intention to Use PS1 0.915 PS2 0.926 PS3 0.919 IU1 0.927 IU2 0.940 IU3 0.933 IU4 0.928 Based on the results of outer loading value in table above, it shows that the value of outer loading is more than 0.708. It indicates that all the indicators have high outer loading. High outer loading indicates that the indicators have much in common with the construct. In other words, the indicators are works on its measurement model. Table 5. Average Variance Extracted (AVE) of Brand Awareness Average Variance Extracted (AVE) Brand Elements 0.610 Event Marketing 0.850 Sales Promotion 0.867 Brand Awareness 0.838 Table 6. Average Variance Extracted (AVE) of Intention to Use Average Variance Extracted (AVE) Perceived Usefulness 0.898 Perceived Ease of Use 0.886 Trust 0.838 Perceived Security 0.846 Intention to Use 0.869 Based on the Table 5 and Table 6, it show that the value of average variance extracted (AVE) on all construct is greater than 0.5. It indicates that the model that use in this research is a good model. Discriminant Validity Table 7. Cross Loading of Brand Awareness Brand Elements Event Marketing Sales Promotion Brand Awareness BE 1 0.898 0.231 0.342 0.371 BE 2 0.752 0.240 0.409 0.133 BE 7 0.746 0.300 0.434 0.147 BE 8 0.716 0.244 0.346 0.089
  • 7. Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet… *Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 www.aijbm.com 46 | Page Brand Elements Event Marketing Sales Promotion Brand Awareness EM1 0.265 0.955 0.332 0.269 EM2 0.252 0.954 0.261 0.299 EM3 0.342 0.854 0.338 0.211 SP1 0.378 0.285 0.907 0.025 SP2 0.459 0.326 0.955 0.035 BA1 0.285 0.191 0.080 0.908 BA2 0.315 0.242 0.028 0.933 BA3 0.283 0.332 0.050 0.947 BA4 0.230 0.263 0.031 0.871 Table 8. Cross Loading of Intention to Use Perceived Usefulness Perceived Ease of Use Trust Perceived Security Intention to Use PU1 0.927 0.758 0.580 0.552 0.719 PU2 0.954 0.752 0.612 0.569 0.721 PU3 0.944 0.753 0.584 0.551 0.705 PU4 0.955 0.760 0.576 0.546 0.700 PU5 0.956 0.776 0.581 0.563 0.726 PEU1 0.750 0.944 0.594 0.552 0.641 PEU2 0.745 0.935 0.605 0.597 0.592 PEU3 0.768 0.944 0.606 0.531 0.663 T1 0.520 0.542 0.893 0.647 0.532 T2 0.548 0.587 0.941 0.671 0.628 T3 0.623 0.620 0.912 0.633 0.672 PS1 0.556 0.530 0.631 0.915 0.610 PS2 0.549 0.576 0.657 0.926 0.636 PS3 0.513 0.531 0.669 0.919 0.589 IU1 0.712 0.628 0.665 0.628 0.927 IU2 0.740 0.645 0.680 0.668 0.940 IU3 0.685 0.601 0.536 0.576 0.933 IU4 0.670 0.633 0.615 0.605 0.928
  • 8. Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet… *Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 www.aijbm.com 47 | Page Based on the Table 7 and Table 8, it shows that the value of interrelated constructions is greater than other constructions. It can be concluded that there is no discriminant validity problem in the model on this study. Comparing AVE Root and Latent Variable Correlation Table 9. Latent Variable Correlation of Brand Awareness Brand Elements Event Marketing Sales Promotion Brand Awareness Brand Elements 1.000 0.303 0.455 0.304 Event Marketing 0.303 1.000 0.330 0.286 Sales Promotion 0.455 0.330 1.000 0.033 Brand Awareness 0.304 0.286 0.033 1.000 Table 10. Latent Variable Correlation of Intention to Use Perceived Usefulness Perceived Ease of Use Trust Perceived Security Intention to Use Perceived Usefulness 1.000 0.802 0.619 0.587 0.754 Perceived Ease of Use 0.802 1.000 0.639 0.594 0.673 Trust 0.619 0.639 1.000 0.709 0.672 Perceived Security 0.587 0.594 0.709 1.000 0.666 Intention to Use 0.754 0.673 0.672 0.666 1.000 Table 11, AVE Root of Brand Awareness Average Variance Extracted (AVE) Root Brand Elements 0.781 Event Marketing 0.922 Sales Promotion 0.931 Brand Awareness 0.915 Table 12. AVE Root of Intention to Use Average Variance Extracted (AVE) Root Perceived Usefulness 0.948 Perceived Ease of Use 0.941 Trust 0.915 Perceived Security 0.920 Intention to Use 0.932
  • 9. Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet… *Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 www.aijbm.com 48 | Page Based on the table above, the author compare the value of AVE root and latent variable correlation. The result is all the value of AVE root is higher than latent variable correlation. For example, the correlation between perceived usefulness and intention to use is 0.754. Then, the AVE root of perceived usefulness is 0.948. It can be concluded that the construct in this study has good discriminant validity. Value of Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) Table 13. VIF Value of Brand Awareness Brand Elements Event Marketing Sales Promotion Brand Awareness Brand Elements 1.304 Event Marketing 1.161 Sales Promotion 1.330 Brand Awareness Table 14. VIF Value of Intention to Use Perceived Usefulness Perceived Ease of Use Trust Perceived Security Intention to Use Perceived Usefulness 3.014 Perceived Ease of Use 3.126 Trust 2.404 Perceived Security 2.193 Intention to Use Based on the Table 13 and Table 14, it shows that all the value of Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) is below 05.00. It indicates that this structural model has no collinearity, so there is no need to eliminate the construct, and the model can proceed to the next step. Significance and Relevance of Structural Model Table 15. Mean, STDEV, T-Values, P-Values of Brand Awareness Original Sample (O) Sample Mean (M) Standard Deviation (|O/STDEV|) T Statistics (0/STDEV) P Values Brand Elements -> Brand Awareness 0.316 0.323 0.065 4.588 0.041 Accepted Event Marketing -> Brand Awareness 0.254 0.245 0.065 4.065 0.000 Accepted Sales Promotion -> Brand Awareness -0.195 -0.168 0.112 1.796 0.000 Accepted Based on the analysis results in the Table 15, it shows that the P value has a smaller number than the level significance 0.5. It indicates that brand elements, event marketing and sales promotion have a significant effect on brand awareness. Then, the T values can be compare with the T table at significance level of 5% (one tailed=1.645). The table results show that all the T values has a higher number than 1.645. It indicates that brand elements, event marketing and sales promotion are influence the brand awareness positively. Overall, if the list if being rank the variable that most influence the brand awareness are brand elements, event marketing and sales promotion.
  • 10. Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet… *Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 www.aijbm.com 49 | Page Table 16. Mean, STDEV, T-Values, P-Values of Intention to Use Original Sample (O) Sample Mean (M) Standard Deviation (STDEV) T Statistics (|0/STDEV|) P Values Perceived Usefulness -> Intention to Use 0.470 0.473 0.095 4.929 0.000 Accepted Perceived Ease of Use - > Intention to Use 0.034 0.035 0.108 0.312 0.378 Rejected Trust -> Intention to Use 0.196 0.178 0.088 2.232 0.013 Accepted Perceived Security -> Intention to Use 0.231 0.243 0.095 2.422 0.008 Accepted Based on the analysis results in the Table 16, it shows that perceived usefulness, trust and perceived security have a significant effect on intention to use because the p values is smaller than the level significance 0.05. The same results also show when comparing the T values and T table. The T values of perceived usefulness, trust and perceived security have a higher number that 1.645. It indicates that perceived usefulness, trust and perceived security are influence on intention to use positively. Meanwhile, the p values of perceived ease of use is 0.378 bigger than 0.05. It indicates that perceived ease of use do not have a significant effect on intention to use. The same result also show when comparing the T values and T table. The T values of perceived ease of use are smaller than T table of 1.654. It indicates that perceived ease of use do not influence on intention to use. Overall, if the list if being rank the variable that most influence the intention to use are perceived usefulness, perceived security and trust. R Square Table 17. Coefficient Determinacy (R2) of Brand Awareness R Square R Square Adjusted Brand Awareness 0.162 0.146 Based on the Table 17, it can be seen that R2 value of variable brand awareness in this model is 0.146. It indicates that the model of questionnaire for brand awareness in this research is classified as weak. Table 18. Coefficient Determinacy (R2) of Intention to Use R Square R Square Adjusted Intention to Use 0.662 0.653 Based on the table 18, it can be seen that R2 value of intention to use in this model is 0.653. It indicates that the model of questionnaire for intention to use in this research is classified as moderate. V. CONCLUSION Pospay needs to develop its business and marketing strategy. To increase brand awareness, Pospay must be concerned about its brand elements, event marketing and sales promotion. Perceived usefulness, perceived security and trust are the factors that should be a concern to increase the intention to use Pospay applications. More specifically, based on the Value Proposition Canvas, there are several alternative strategies to attract potential customers of digital wallet users based on their gains and pains. Pospay can create a discount or cashback program for payment in merchants or its payment channels to develop its sales promotion. Then, Pospay can develop a new feature to help users transfer between digital wallets. It is related and can expand Pospay usefulness for users. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This paper is an essemce of the thesis entitled “Proposed Marketing Strategy for Pospay to Increase Brand Awareness and Intention to Use, School of Business and Management, Bandung Institute of Technology Indonesia.
  • 11. Increasing Brand Awareness and Intention to Use Pospay Digital Wallet… *Corresponding Author: Gessan Kurnia Dewi1 www.aijbm.com 50 | Page REFERENCES [1] Departemen Statistik Moneter dan Fiskal. (2021). Analisis Perkembangan Uang Beredar (M2) - Desember 2021. Jakarta: Bank Indonesia. [2] Keller, K. L. (2013). Strategic Brand Management. Pearson Education, Inc. [3] Davis, F. D. (1989). Perceived Usefulness, Perceived Ease of Use and User Acceptance of Information Technology. MIS Quarterly, 319-340. [4] Chandra, S., Srivastava, S. C., & Theng, Y. L. (2010). Evaluating The Role of Trust in Consumer Adoption of Mobile Payment Systems: An Empirical Anlysis. Communications of the Association for Information Systems, 561-588. [5] Cadel, J., Paul, D., & Turner, P. (2014). Business Analysis Techniques: 99 Essential Tools for Success. United Kingdom: BCS Learning & Development Ltd. [6] Hitt, M. A., Hoskisson, R. E., & Ireland, R. D. (2016). Strategic Management: Concepts and Cases: Competitiveness and Globalization. Cengage Learning. [7] Kotler, P., & Keller, K. L. (2012). Marketing Management. Prentice Hall. [8] Pigneur, Y., Osterwalder, A., & Clark, T. (2010). Business Model Generation: A Handbook for Visionaries, Game Changers, and Challengers. Wiley. [9] Tashakkori, A., & Teddlie, C. (2003). Handbook of Mixed Methods in Social and Behavioral Research. Sage Publications.