SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 3
-1Case One

                                Court of Appeals of Texas,
                                      San Antonio.

           NORTH EAST INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT, Appellant,
                                    v.
                         John KELLEY, Appellee
                           No. 04-08-00162-CV.


                                       LITIGANTS

Plaintiff’s-Appellant: John Kelly

Defendant-Appellees: North East Independent School District

                                     BACKGROUND

        Former school teacher filed suit against school district asserting claims for breach
of contract, quantum meriut, declaratory relief, and injunctive relief, after Commissioner
of Education denied his grievance seeking an additional day's pay. School district filed
plea to the jurisdiction, and parties filed competing motions for summary judgment. The
County Court at Law No. 7, Bexar County, David Rodriguez, J., granted summary
judgment to teacher. District appealed.

                                          FACTS

       Kelley was employed by the District pursuant to a written one-year probationary
contract. The contract provided that Kelley would be employed "on a 10-month basis for
the school year 2000-01, according to the hours and dates set by the district as they exist
or may hereafter be amended." The District adopted a teacher salary schedule that was
based on 187 working days and a work schedule that required teachers to work 187 days
during the 2000-2001 school year. The District required Kelley to attend a graduation
ceremony in addition to the 187 days he was required to work. Kelley filed a grievance
seeking an additional day's pay and appealed the District's decision to the Commissioner
of Education.

        The Commissioner of Education concluded that Kelley's contract required him
*444 to work only 187 days; therefore, the contract did not require Kelley to work an
additional day by attending the graduation ceremony. The Commissioner also concluded,
however, that the District did not violate the contract by requiring Kelley to work an
additional day; instead, Kelley's claim would be a claim for quantum meruit over which
the Commissioner had no jurisdiction. Therefore, the Commissioner dismissed the appeal
for lack of jurisdiction.
Kelley then proceeded on two fronts. First, Kelley filed the underlying lawsuit in
Bexar County alleging claims for breach of contract, quantum meruit, declaratory relief,
and injunctive relief and requesting attorney's fees and costs. Kelley also filed an
administrative appeal of the Commissioner's decision in Travis County.

        In the Bexar County lawsuit, the District filed a plea to the jurisdiction. The
parties also filed competing motions for summary judgment. The district court in Travis
County abated its case pending the outcome of the Bexar County lawsuit. The trial court
in Bexar County subsequently granted summary judgment in favor of Kelley, awarding
him: (1) damages for his breach of contract claim; (2) declaratory relief that the District
violated the contract; and (3) injunctive relief prohibiting the District from "illegal
conduct (as occurred in this case) in the future." The Bexar County trial court also
awarded Kelley attorney's fees and costs.

                                        DECISION

         The District contends that required Kelley to appeal the Commissioner's decision
to a district court in Travis County; therefore, the Bexar County court did not have
jurisdiction to consider Kelley's breach of contract claim. See Section 7.057(d) provides:
A person aggrieved by an action of the agency or decision of the commissioner may
appeal to the district court in Travis County. Kelley responds that the Bexar County court
had jurisdiction because the Commissioner dismissed his appeal for lack of jurisdiction.
Kelley's assertion ignores the basis for the dismissal by the Commissioner as stated in the
Commissioner's written decision. The Commissioner dismissed the appeal based on his
conclusion that the only claim available to Kelley was a quantum meruit claim. Any
complaint by Kelley that he had viable breach of contract claim had to be appealed to the
district court in Travis County pursuant to section 7.057. No other court had jurisdiction
to *445 consider the breach of contract claim. Similarly, a declaratory judgment action
seeking to determine whether the District's actions violated the contract could not be
brought in Bexar County because such a claim challenges the Commissioner's decision
that no such complaint existed Because the Bexar County court was without jurisdiction
to consider Kelley's breach of contract and declaratory judgment claims, it also was
without jurisdiction to award Kelley attorney's fees based on the judgment it entered on
those claims.

                                          DICTA

       Kelley contends that because he pled a quantum meruit claim in the alternative,
we can affirm the trial court's judgment on that basis. A party may recover under quantum
meruit only when there is no express contract covering the services rendered.

        Accordingly, the trial court necessarily rejected the quantum meruit claim in
granting relief on the breach of contract claim. Because the existence of Kelley's quantum
meruit claim hinges on the non-existence of his breach of contract claim, and his breach
of contract claim is within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Commissioner under appeal in
Travis County, the Bexar County trial court was required to abate that claim until the
appeal of the administrative proceedings was concluded.

                                     IMPLICATIONS

        The trial court's judgment is reversed. Kelley's claims for breach of contract and
declaratory judgment are dismissed. The *446 cause is remanded to the trial court with
instructions to abate its proceedings with regard to Kelley's quantum meruit and
injunction claims pending the final resolution of Kelley's appeal of the Commissioner's
decision in Travis County.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Destaque

Destaque (20)

Joshua, Monday Conceptualization And Perceptions Of Teaching As An Artistic Form
Joshua, Monday Conceptualization And Perceptions Of Teaching As An Artistic FormJoshua, Monday Conceptualization And Perceptions Of Teaching As An Artistic Form
Joshua, Monday Conceptualization And Perceptions Of Teaching As An Artistic Form
 
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Editor-in-Chief, NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - www.n...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Editor-in-Chief, NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - www.n...Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Editor-in-Chief, NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - www.n...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Editor-in-Chief, NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS - www.n...
 
Plagiarism: A Guide for Students by William Allan Kritsonis, PhD
Plagiarism: A Guide for Students by William Allan Kritsonis, PhDPlagiarism: A Guide for Students by William Allan Kritsonis, PhD
Plagiarism: A Guide for Students by William Allan Kritsonis, PhD
 
Chapter 1[1] Dr. Kritsonis
Chapter 1[1] Dr. KritsonisChapter 1[1] Dr. Kritsonis
Chapter 1[1] Dr. Kritsonis
 
NATIONAL FORUM OF EDUCATIONAL ADMINISTRATION AND SUPERVISION JOURNAL, Volume ...
NATIONAL FORUM OF EDUCATIONAL ADMINISTRATION AND SUPERVISION JOURNAL, Volume ...NATIONAL FORUM OF EDUCATIONAL ADMINISTRATION AND SUPERVISION JOURNAL, Volume ...
NATIONAL FORUM OF EDUCATIONAL ADMINISTRATION AND SUPERVISION JOURNAL, Volume ...
 
Philosophical
PhilosophicalPhilosophical
Philosophical
 
Curriculum Instruction
Curriculum InstructionCurriculum Instruction
Curriculum Instruction
 
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Mary Ann Springs, Dissert...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Mary Ann Springs, Dissert...Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Mary Ann Springs, Dissert...
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Dissertation Chair for Mary Ann Springs, Dissert...
 
Cabell's Directory - Features NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS, www.nationalforum.com,...
Cabell's Directory - Features NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS, www.nationalforum.com,...Cabell's Directory - Features NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS, www.nationalforum.com,...
Cabell's Directory - Features NATIONAL FORUM JOURNALS, www.nationalforum.com,...
 
Kritsonis (philosophy inventory)
Kritsonis (philosophy inventory)Kritsonis (philosophy inventory)
Kritsonis (philosophy inventory)
 
Copy Of Court Case 2
Copy Of  Court  Case 2Copy Of  Court  Case 2
Copy Of Court Case 2
 
Brown skinner trust
Brown skinner trustBrown skinner trust
Brown skinner trust
 
William Allan Kritsonis, PhD, EDUCATIONAL PHILOSOPHY
William Allan Kritsonis, PhD, EDUCATIONAL PHILOSOPHYWilliam Allan Kritsonis, PhD, EDUCATIONAL PHILOSOPHY
William Allan Kritsonis, PhD, EDUCATIONAL PHILOSOPHY
 
E X T R A C U R R I C U L A R A C T I V I T I E S
E X T R A  C U R R I C U L A R  A C T I V I T I E SE X T R A  C U R R I C U L A R  A C T I V I T I E S
E X T R A C U R R I C U L A R A C T I V I T I E S
 
R E G U L A R S T U D E N T D I S I P L I N E E X P L U S I O N A N D S ...
R E G U L A R  S T U D E N T  D I S I P L I N E  E X P L U S I O N  A N D  S ...R E G U L A R  S T U D E N T  D I S I P L I N E  E X P L U S I O N  A N D  S ...
R E G U L A R S T U D E N T D I S I P L I N E E X P L U S I O N A N D S ...
 
Copy Of Court Case 3
Copy Of Court Case 3Copy Of Court Case 3
Copy Of Court Case 3
 
Copy Of F E R P A P P T
Copy Of  F E R P A  P P TCopy Of  F E R P A  P P T
Copy Of F E R P A P P T
 
S T U D E N T S E A R C H E S P P T
S T U D E N T  S E A R C H E S  P P TS T U D E N T  S E A R C H E S  P P T
S T U D E N T S E A R C H E S P P T
 
C H A P T E R O N E O V E R V I E W
C H A P T E R  O N E  O V E R V I E WC H A P T E R  O N E  O V E R V I E W
C H A P T E R O N E O V E R V I E W
 
Copy Of Court Case 4
Copy Of  Court  Case 4Copy Of  Court  Case 4
Copy Of Court Case 4
 

Último

Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfMaking and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Chris Hunter
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
QucHHunhnh
 

Último (20)

Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdf
Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdfWeb & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdf
Web & Social Media Analytics Previous Year Question Paper.pdf
 
Sociology 101 Demonstration of Learning Exhibit
Sociology 101 Demonstration of Learning ExhibitSociology 101 Demonstration of Learning Exhibit
Sociology 101 Demonstration of Learning Exhibit
 
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docx
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docxPython Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docx
Python Notes for mca i year students osmania university.docx
 
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptxUnit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
Unit-V; Pricing (Pharma Marketing Management).pptx
 
Class 11th Physics NEET formula sheet pdf
Class 11th Physics NEET formula sheet pdfClass 11th Physics NEET formula sheet pdf
Class 11th Physics NEET formula sheet pdf
 
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfMaking and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
 
TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...
TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...
TỔNG ÔN TẬP THI VÀO LỚP 10 MÔN TIẾNG ANH NĂM HỌC 2023 - 2024 CÓ ĐÁP ÁN (NGỮ Â...
 
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The BasicsIntroduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
 
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
 
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
 
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptxUnit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
 
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfHoldier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
 
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.
This PowerPoint helps students to consider the concept of infinity.
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
 
ComPTIA Overview | Comptia Security+ Book SY0-701
ComPTIA Overview | Comptia Security+ Book SY0-701ComPTIA Overview | Comptia Security+ Book SY0-701
ComPTIA Overview | Comptia Security+ Book SY0-701
 
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
Explore beautiful and ugly buildings. Mathematics helps us create beautiful d...
 
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptxINDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
 
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptxUnit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
Unit-IV- Pharma. Marketing Channels.pptx
 
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
 

Court Case 3 - William Allan Kritsonis, PhD

  • 1. -1Case One Court of Appeals of Texas, San Antonio. NORTH EAST INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT, Appellant, v. John KELLEY, Appellee No. 04-08-00162-CV. LITIGANTS Plaintiff’s-Appellant: John Kelly Defendant-Appellees: North East Independent School District BACKGROUND Former school teacher filed suit against school district asserting claims for breach of contract, quantum meriut, declaratory relief, and injunctive relief, after Commissioner of Education denied his grievance seeking an additional day's pay. School district filed plea to the jurisdiction, and parties filed competing motions for summary judgment. The County Court at Law No. 7, Bexar County, David Rodriguez, J., granted summary judgment to teacher. District appealed. FACTS Kelley was employed by the District pursuant to a written one-year probationary contract. The contract provided that Kelley would be employed "on a 10-month basis for the school year 2000-01, according to the hours and dates set by the district as they exist or may hereafter be amended." The District adopted a teacher salary schedule that was based on 187 working days and a work schedule that required teachers to work 187 days during the 2000-2001 school year. The District required Kelley to attend a graduation ceremony in addition to the 187 days he was required to work. Kelley filed a grievance seeking an additional day's pay and appealed the District's decision to the Commissioner of Education. The Commissioner of Education concluded that Kelley's contract required him *444 to work only 187 days; therefore, the contract did not require Kelley to work an additional day by attending the graduation ceremony. The Commissioner also concluded, however, that the District did not violate the contract by requiring Kelley to work an additional day; instead, Kelley's claim would be a claim for quantum meruit over which the Commissioner had no jurisdiction. Therefore, the Commissioner dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction.
  • 2. Kelley then proceeded on two fronts. First, Kelley filed the underlying lawsuit in Bexar County alleging claims for breach of contract, quantum meruit, declaratory relief, and injunctive relief and requesting attorney's fees and costs. Kelley also filed an administrative appeal of the Commissioner's decision in Travis County. In the Bexar County lawsuit, the District filed a plea to the jurisdiction. The parties also filed competing motions for summary judgment. The district court in Travis County abated its case pending the outcome of the Bexar County lawsuit. The trial court in Bexar County subsequently granted summary judgment in favor of Kelley, awarding him: (1) damages for his breach of contract claim; (2) declaratory relief that the District violated the contract; and (3) injunctive relief prohibiting the District from "illegal conduct (as occurred in this case) in the future." The Bexar County trial court also awarded Kelley attorney's fees and costs. DECISION The District contends that required Kelley to appeal the Commissioner's decision to a district court in Travis County; therefore, the Bexar County court did not have jurisdiction to consider Kelley's breach of contract claim. See Section 7.057(d) provides: A person aggrieved by an action of the agency or decision of the commissioner may appeal to the district court in Travis County. Kelley responds that the Bexar County court had jurisdiction because the Commissioner dismissed his appeal for lack of jurisdiction. Kelley's assertion ignores the basis for the dismissal by the Commissioner as stated in the Commissioner's written decision. The Commissioner dismissed the appeal based on his conclusion that the only claim available to Kelley was a quantum meruit claim. Any complaint by Kelley that he had viable breach of contract claim had to be appealed to the district court in Travis County pursuant to section 7.057. No other court had jurisdiction to *445 consider the breach of contract claim. Similarly, a declaratory judgment action seeking to determine whether the District's actions violated the contract could not be brought in Bexar County because such a claim challenges the Commissioner's decision that no such complaint existed Because the Bexar County court was without jurisdiction to consider Kelley's breach of contract and declaratory judgment claims, it also was without jurisdiction to award Kelley attorney's fees based on the judgment it entered on those claims. DICTA Kelley contends that because he pled a quantum meruit claim in the alternative, we can affirm the trial court's judgment on that basis. A party may recover under quantum meruit only when there is no express contract covering the services rendered. Accordingly, the trial court necessarily rejected the quantum meruit claim in granting relief on the breach of contract claim. Because the existence of Kelley's quantum meruit claim hinges on the non-existence of his breach of contract claim, and his breach of contract claim is within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Commissioner under appeal in Travis County, the Bexar County trial court was required to abate that claim until the
  • 3. appeal of the administrative proceedings was concluded. IMPLICATIONS The trial court's judgment is reversed. Kelley's claims for breach of contract and declaratory judgment are dismissed. The *446 cause is remanded to the trial court with instructions to abate its proceedings with regard to Kelley's quantum meruit and injunction claims pending the final resolution of Kelley's appeal of the Commissioner's decision in Travis County.