SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 15
Baixar para ler offline
New frontiers
Mining the data for our
next copper discovery
Copper the the World, June 18th 2019
Holly Bridgwater, Industry Lead
holly@unearthed.solutions
We know we need to increase our
discovery rate.
How do we increase our confidence in
the targets we generate?
How do we make the right bet?
Geologists love bias!
Targets
Interpretation
Data
Deposit Models
‘Geology’
+Uncertainty
+ Bias
Data
Science!!!
But we could do this….
Just not by ourselves
• The Mount Woods Project is an
area ~ 5000km2 near the
Prominent Hill Mine in South
Australia
• Participants in the competition had
access to the OZ Minerals private
exploration database of >5TB
• The challenge was to use the data
to predict the location of economic
mineralisation of any kind, not just
another Prominent Hill
Crowdsourcing Exploration at Mount Woods
What was in the data?
• 621 datasets
• 678 drillholes with 115,000 assay
results
• 2.7TB of geophysics data in 62
datasets
• 60 prospect datasets
• Magnetics, gravity, seismic,
radiometrics, IP, EM and MT
• Petrology
• Geological maps and reports
Crowdsourcing Exploration at Mount Woods
The Explorer Challenge
• >5TB of data instantly accessible online
around the world
• >1000 participants
• >10,000 data downloads
• >60 countries
• Geologists, data scientists, startups, students,
consultants, universities, research
organisations
The Crowd and Exploration
Open and accessible data creates conditions
for:
• Multiple results to be developed in parallel
• Independent approaches – no group think,
no bias!
• Consensus = Confidence – statistically
relevant consensus due to independence
and diversity
• Speed, new knowledge, new workflows
and << cost are an additional bonus.
We did this!
Explorer Challenge Outcomes
• Multiple approaches never before imagined
internally
• Applications of robust leading edge machine
learning, data science and geological
techniques
• New ways of extracting data, fusing and
analysing multiple data layers
• >400 targets – robust new targets generated,
confidence increased in known targets
Data Science and Exploration:
What did we learn?
• Multidisciplinary teams rule!
• DS enables state, national and global
datasets to be trained on and pulled into
local problems, a great way to reduce
bias
• Explainable/interpretable machine
learning is key for it to be added to the
geologists toolkit
• Geoscience data is not friendly for data
scientists
The Startup Ecosystem in Exploration Data Science
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/startups-leveraging-machine-learning-
improve-holly-bridgwater/
Key takeaways
• CONSENSUS = CONFIDENCE,
geology is complex: search for
consensus not the best
• Open, accessible data creates an
environment where you can achieve
consensus.
• Data scientists + geologists = success!
• Internal – 1yr, 2-3 models max
• Crowd – 3 months, 40 models
Thank you
Holly Bridgwater
holly@unearthed.solutions

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Semelhante a New Frontiers - Mining the data for our next copper discovery

Unlocking the geospatial potential of survey data
Unlocking the geospatial potential of survey dataUnlocking the geospatial potential of survey data
Unlocking the geospatial potential of survey datatomensom
 
Load webinar deposit.final
Load webinar deposit.finalLoad webinar deposit.final
Load webinar deposit.finalSue Hodge
 
Grampian safe haven, research data network
Grampian safe haven, research data networkGrampian safe haven, research data network
Grampian safe haven, research data networkJisc RDM
 
Collaborate, Automate, Prepare, Prioritize: Creating Metadata for Legacy Rese...
Collaborate, Automate, Prepare, Prioritize: Creating Metadata for Legacy Rese...Collaborate, Automate, Prepare, Prioritize: Creating Metadata for Legacy Rese...
Collaborate, Automate, Prepare, Prioritize: Creating Metadata for Legacy Rese...Jennifer Liss
 
Developing core common outcomes for tropical peatland research and management
Developing core common outcomes for tropical peatland research and managementDeveloping core common outcomes for tropical peatland research and management
Developing core common outcomes for tropical peatland research and managementMark Reed
 
Accessing data for research: data publishing pathways and the Five Safes
Accessing data for research: data publishing pathways and the Five SafesAccessing data for research: data publishing pathways and the Five Safes
Accessing data for research: data publishing pathways and the Five SafesLouise Corti
 
Big Data Brown Bag
Big Data Brown BagBig Data Brown Bag
Big Data Brown Bagusmanqureshi
 
The Rise of the Data Journal
The Rise of the Data JournalThe Rise of the Data Journal
The Rise of the Data JournalMarieke Guy
 
A Data Scientist Perspective on Data Curation in the Digital Era
A Data Scientist Perspective on Data Curation in the Digital EraA Data Scientist Perspective on Data Curation in the Digital Era
A Data Scientist Perspective on Data Curation in the Digital EraVicki Ferrini
 
Data Facilties Workshop - Panel on Global Data Sharing Exemplars
Data Facilties Workshop - Panel on Global Data Sharing ExemplarsData Facilties Workshop - Panel on Global Data Sharing Exemplars
Data Facilties Workshop - Panel on Global Data Sharing ExemplarsEarthCube
 
Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013
Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013
Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013University of Washington
 
APLIC 2012: Discovering & Dealing with Data
APLIC 2012: Discovering & Dealing with DataAPLIC 2012: Discovering & Dealing with Data
APLIC 2012: Discovering & Dealing with DataHamilton Public Library
 
How and Why to Share Your Data
How and Why to Share Your DataHow and Why to Share Your Data
How and Why to Share Your Datakfear
 
MEDEAnet webinar Big Data & Learning Analytics Resources
MEDEAnet webinar Big Data & Learning Analytics ResourcesMEDEAnet webinar Big Data & Learning Analytics Resources
MEDEAnet webinar Big Data & Learning Analytics ResourcesMEDEA Awards
 
Introduction to Big Data and Learning Analytics – Resources
Introduction to Big Data and Learning Analytics – Resources Introduction to Big Data and Learning Analytics – Resources
Introduction to Big Data and Learning Analytics – Resources Joasia van Kooten
 
Improving Access to Research Data: What does changing legislation mean for y...
Improving Access to Research Data:  What does changing legislation mean for y...Improving Access to Research Data:  What does changing legislation mean for y...
Improving Access to Research Data: What does changing legislation mean for y...Marieke Guy
 
Incentivising the uptake of reusable metadata in the survey production process
Incentivising the uptake of reusable metadata in the survey production processIncentivising the uptake of reusable metadata in the survey production process
Incentivising the uptake of reusable metadata in the survey production processLouise Corti
 
Use of data in safe havens: ethics and reproducibility issues
Use of data in safe havens: ethics and reproducibility issuesUse of data in safe havens: ethics and reproducibility issues
Use of data in safe havens: ethics and reproducibility issuesLouise Corti
 
COBWEB Smart Technology = Smart Data? Citizen Science in the Dyfi Biosphere R...
COBWEB Smart Technology = Smart Data? Citizen Science in the Dyfi Biosphere R...COBWEB Smart Technology = Smart Data? Citizen Science in the Dyfi Biosphere R...
COBWEB Smart Technology = Smart Data? Citizen Science in the Dyfi Biosphere R...COBWEB Project
 

Semelhante a New Frontiers - Mining the data for our next copper discovery (20)

Unlocking the geospatial potential of survey data
Unlocking the geospatial potential of survey dataUnlocking the geospatial potential of survey data
Unlocking the geospatial potential of survey data
 
Load webinar deposit.final
Load webinar deposit.finalLoad webinar deposit.final
Load webinar deposit.final
 
Grampian safe haven, research data network
Grampian safe haven, research data networkGrampian safe haven, research data network
Grampian safe haven, research data network
 
Collaborate, Automate, Prepare, Prioritize: Creating Metadata for Legacy Rese...
Collaborate, Automate, Prepare, Prioritize: Creating Metadata for Legacy Rese...Collaborate, Automate, Prepare, Prioritize: Creating Metadata for Legacy Rese...
Collaborate, Automate, Prepare, Prioritize: Creating Metadata for Legacy Rese...
 
Developing core common outcomes for tropical peatland research and management
Developing core common outcomes for tropical peatland research and managementDeveloping core common outcomes for tropical peatland research and management
Developing core common outcomes for tropical peatland research and management
 
Accessing data for research: data publishing pathways and the Five Safes
Accessing data for research: data publishing pathways and the Five SafesAccessing data for research: data publishing pathways and the Five Safes
Accessing data for research: data publishing pathways and the Five Safes
 
Big Data Brown Bag
Big Data Brown BagBig Data Brown Bag
Big Data Brown Bag
 
The Rise of the Data Journal
The Rise of the Data JournalThe Rise of the Data Journal
The Rise of the Data Journal
 
A Data Scientist Perspective on Data Curation in the Digital Era
A Data Scientist Perspective on Data Curation in the Digital EraA Data Scientist Perspective on Data Curation in the Digital Era
A Data Scientist Perspective on Data Curation in the Digital Era
 
Data Facilties Workshop - Panel on Global Data Sharing Exemplars
Data Facilties Workshop - Panel on Global Data Sharing ExemplarsData Facilties Workshop - Panel on Global Data Sharing Exemplars
Data Facilties Workshop - Panel on Global Data Sharing Exemplars
 
Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013
Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013
Big Data Curricula at the UW eScience Institute, JSM 2013
 
APLIC 2012: Discovering & Dealing with Data
APLIC 2012: Discovering & Dealing with DataAPLIC 2012: Discovering & Dealing with Data
APLIC 2012: Discovering & Dealing with Data
 
How and Why to Share Your Data
How and Why to Share Your DataHow and Why to Share Your Data
How and Why to Share Your Data
 
MEDEAnet webinar Big Data & Learning Analytics Resources
MEDEAnet webinar Big Data & Learning Analytics ResourcesMEDEAnet webinar Big Data & Learning Analytics Resources
MEDEAnet webinar Big Data & Learning Analytics Resources
 
Introduction to Big Data and Learning Analytics – Resources
Introduction to Big Data and Learning Analytics – Resources Introduction to Big Data and Learning Analytics – Resources
Introduction to Big Data and Learning Analytics – Resources
 
Better Data for a Better World
Better Data for a Better WorldBetter Data for a Better World
Better Data for a Better World
 
Improving Access to Research Data: What does changing legislation mean for y...
Improving Access to Research Data:  What does changing legislation mean for y...Improving Access to Research Data:  What does changing legislation mean for y...
Improving Access to Research Data: What does changing legislation mean for y...
 
Incentivising the uptake of reusable metadata in the survey production process
Incentivising the uptake of reusable metadata in the survey production processIncentivising the uptake of reusable metadata in the survey production process
Incentivising the uptake of reusable metadata in the survey production process
 
Use of data in safe havens: ethics and reproducibility issues
Use of data in safe havens: ethics and reproducibility issuesUse of data in safe havens: ethics and reproducibility issues
Use of data in safe havens: ethics and reproducibility issues
 
COBWEB Smart Technology = Smart Data? Citizen Science in the Dyfi Biosphere R...
COBWEB Smart Technology = Smart Data? Citizen Science in the Dyfi Biosphere R...COBWEB Smart Technology = Smart Data? Citizen Science in the Dyfi Biosphere R...
COBWEB Smart Technology = Smart Data? Citizen Science in the Dyfi Biosphere R...
 

Último

Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune WaterworldsBiogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune WaterworldsSérgio Sacani
 
CURRENT SCENARIO OF POULTRY PRODUCTION IN INDIA
CURRENT SCENARIO OF POULTRY PRODUCTION IN INDIACURRENT SCENARIO OF POULTRY PRODUCTION IN INDIA
CURRENT SCENARIO OF POULTRY PRODUCTION IN INDIADr. TATHAGAT KHOBRAGADE
 
Reboulia: features, anatomy, morphology etc.
Reboulia: features, anatomy, morphology etc.Reboulia: features, anatomy, morphology etc.
Reboulia: features, anatomy, morphology etc.Silpa
 
Human & Veterinary Respiratory Physilogy_DR.E.Muralinath_Associate Professor....
Human & Veterinary Respiratory Physilogy_DR.E.Muralinath_Associate Professor....Human & Veterinary Respiratory Physilogy_DR.E.Muralinath_Associate Professor....
Human & Veterinary Respiratory Physilogy_DR.E.Muralinath_Associate Professor....muralinath2
 
Atp synthase , Atp synthase complex 1 to 4.
Atp synthase , Atp synthase complex 1 to 4.Atp synthase , Atp synthase complex 1 to 4.
Atp synthase , Atp synthase complex 1 to 4.Silpa
 
Selaginella: features, morphology ,anatomy and reproduction.
Selaginella: features, morphology ,anatomy and reproduction.Selaginella: features, morphology ,anatomy and reproduction.
Selaginella: features, morphology ,anatomy and reproduction.Silpa
 
THE ROLE OF BIOTECHNOLOGY IN THE ECONOMIC UPLIFT.pptx
THE ROLE OF BIOTECHNOLOGY IN THE ECONOMIC UPLIFT.pptxTHE ROLE OF BIOTECHNOLOGY IN THE ECONOMIC UPLIFT.pptx
THE ROLE OF BIOTECHNOLOGY IN THE ECONOMIC UPLIFT.pptxANSARKHAN96
 
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdfZoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdfSumit Kumar yadav
 
Use of mutants in understanding seedling development.pptx
Use of mutants in understanding seedling development.pptxUse of mutants in understanding seedling development.pptx
Use of mutants in understanding seedling development.pptxRenuJangid3
 
(May 9, 2024) Enhanced Ultrafast Vector Flow Imaging (VFI) Using Multi-Angle ...
(May 9, 2024) Enhanced Ultrafast Vector Flow Imaging (VFI) Using Multi-Angle ...(May 9, 2024) Enhanced Ultrafast Vector Flow Imaging (VFI) Using Multi-Angle ...
(May 9, 2024) Enhanced Ultrafast Vector Flow Imaging (VFI) Using Multi-Angle ...Scintica Instrumentation
 
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.Silpa
 
LUNULARIA -features, morphology, anatomy ,reproduction etc.
LUNULARIA -features, morphology, anatomy ,reproduction etc.LUNULARIA -features, morphology, anatomy ,reproduction etc.
LUNULARIA -features, morphology, anatomy ,reproduction etc.Silpa
 
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx .
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx       .Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx       .
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx .Poonam Aher Patil
 
Genome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptx
Genome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptxGenome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptx
Genome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptxSilpa
 
Cyanide resistant respiration pathway.pptx
Cyanide resistant respiration pathway.pptxCyanide resistant respiration pathway.pptx
Cyanide resistant respiration pathway.pptxSilpa
 
TransientOffsetin14CAftertheCarringtonEventRecordedbyPolarTreeRings
TransientOffsetin14CAftertheCarringtonEventRecordedbyPolarTreeRingsTransientOffsetin14CAftertheCarringtonEventRecordedbyPolarTreeRings
TransientOffsetin14CAftertheCarringtonEventRecordedbyPolarTreeRingsSérgio Sacani
 
FAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Analytical Science
FAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Analytical ScienceFAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Analytical Science
FAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Analytical ScienceAlex Henderson
 
Chemistry 5th semester paper 1st Notes.pdf
Chemistry 5th semester paper 1st Notes.pdfChemistry 5th semester paper 1st Notes.pdf
Chemistry 5th semester paper 1st Notes.pdfSumit Kumar yadav
 

Último (20)

Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune WaterworldsBiogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
 
CURRENT SCENARIO OF POULTRY PRODUCTION IN INDIA
CURRENT SCENARIO OF POULTRY PRODUCTION IN INDIACURRENT SCENARIO OF POULTRY PRODUCTION IN INDIA
CURRENT SCENARIO OF POULTRY PRODUCTION IN INDIA
 
Reboulia: features, anatomy, morphology etc.
Reboulia: features, anatomy, morphology etc.Reboulia: features, anatomy, morphology etc.
Reboulia: features, anatomy, morphology etc.
 
Human & Veterinary Respiratory Physilogy_DR.E.Muralinath_Associate Professor....
Human & Veterinary Respiratory Physilogy_DR.E.Muralinath_Associate Professor....Human & Veterinary Respiratory Physilogy_DR.E.Muralinath_Associate Professor....
Human & Veterinary Respiratory Physilogy_DR.E.Muralinath_Associate Professor....
 
Atp synthase , Atp synthase complex 1 to 4.
Atp synthase , Atp synthase complex 1 to 4.Atp synthase , Atp synthase complex 1 to 4.
Atp synthase , Atp synthase complex 1 to 4.
 
Selaginella: features, morphology ,anatomy and reproduction.
Selaginella: features, morphology ,anatomy and reproduction.Selaginella: features, morphology ,anatomy and reproduction.
Selaginella: features, morphology ,anatomy and reproduction.
 
THE ROLE OF BIOTECHNOLOGY IN THE ECONOMIC UPLIFT.pptx
THE ROLE OF BIOTECHNOLOGY IN THE ECONOMIC UPLIFT.pptxTHE ROLE OF BIOTECHNOLOGY IN THE ECONOMIC UPLIFT.pptx
THE ROLE OF BIOTECHNOLOGY IN THE ECONOMIC UPLIFT.pptx
 
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdfZoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
Zoology 5th semester notes( Sumit_yadav).pdf
 
PATNA CALL GIRLS 8617370543 LOW PRICE ESCORT SERVICE
PATNA CALL GIRLS 8617370543 LOW PRICE ESCORT SERVICEPATNA CALL GIRLS 8617370543 LOW PRICE ESCORT SERVICE
PATNA CALL GIRLS 8617370543 LOW PRICE ESCORT SERVICE
 
Use of mutants in understanding seedling development.pptx
Use of mutants in understanding seedling development.pptxUse of mutants in understanding seedling development.pptx
Use of mutants in understanding seedling development.pptx
 
(May 9, 2024) Enhanced Ultrafast Vector Flow Imaging (VFI) Using Multi-Angle ...
(May 9, 2024) Enhanced Ultrafast Vector Flow Imaging (VFI) Using Multi-Angle ...(May 9, 2024) Enhanced Ultrafast Vector Flow Imaging (VFI) Using Multi-Angle ...
(May 9, 2024) Enhanced Ultrafast Vector Flow Imaging (VFI) Using Multi-Angle ...
 
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
 
Clean In Place(CIP).pptx .
Clean In Place(CIP).pptx                 .Clean In Place(CIP).pptx                 .
Clean In Place(CIP).pptx .
 
LUNULARIA -features, morphology, anatomy ,reproduction etc.
LUNULARIA -features, morphology, anatomy ,reproduction etc.LUNULARIA -features, morphology, anatomy ,reproduction etc.
LUNULARIA -features, morphology, anatomy ,reproduction etc.
 
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx .
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx       .Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx       .
Factory Acceptance Test( FAT).pptx .
 
Genome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptx
Genome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptxGenome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptx
Genome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptx
 
Cyanide resistant respiration pathway.pptx
Cyanide resistant respiration pathway.pptxCyanide resistant respiration pathway.pptx
Cyanide resistant respiration pathway.pptx
 
TransientOffsetin14CAftertheCarringtonEventRecordedbyPolarTreeRings
TransientOffsetin14CAftertheCarringtonEventRecordedbyPolarTreeRingsTransientOffsetin14CAftertheCarringtonEventRecordedbyPolarTreeRings
TransientOffsetin14CAftertheCarringtonEventRecordedbyPolarTreeRings
 
FAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Analytical Science
FAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Analytical ScienceFAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Analytical Science
FAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Analytical Science
 
Chemistry 5th semester paper 1st Notes.pdf
Chemistry 5th semester paper 1st Notes.pdfChemistry 5th semester paper 1st Notes.pdf
Chemistry 5th semester paper 1st Notes.pdf
 

New Frontiers - Mining the data for our next copper discovery

  • 1. New frontiers Mining the data for our next copper discovery Copper the the World, June 18th 2019 Holly Bridgwater, Industry Lead holly@unearthed.solutions
  • 2. We know we need to increase our discovery rate. How do we increase our confidence in the targets we generate? How do we make the right bet?
  • 3. Geologists love bias! Targets Interpretation Data Deposit Models ‘Geology’ +Uncertainty + Bias Data Science!!!
  • 4. But we could do this…. Just not by ourselves
  • 5.
  • 6. • The Mount Woods Project is an area ~ 5000km2 near the Prominent Hill Mine in South Australia • Participants in the competition had access to the OZ Minerals private exploration database of >5TB • The challenge was to use the data to predict the location of economic mineralisation of any kind, not just another Prominent Hill Crowdsourcing Exploration at Mount Woods
  • 7. What was in the data? • 621 datasets • 678 drillholes with 115,000 assay results • 2.7TB of geophysics data in 62 datasets • 60 prospect datasets • Magnetics, gravity, seismic, radiometrics, IP, EM and MT • Petrology • Geological maps and reports Crowdsourcing Exploration at Mount Woods
  • 8. The Explorer Challenge • >5TB of data instantly accessible online around the world • >1000 participants • >10,000 data downloads • >60 countries • Geologists, data scientists, startups, students, consultants, universities, research organisations
  • 9. The Crowd and Exploration Open and accessible data creates conditions for: • Multiple results to be developed in parallel • Independent approaches – no group think, no bias! • Consensus = Confidence – statistically relevant consensus due to independence and diversity • Speed, new knowledge, new workflows and << cost are an additional bonus.
  • 11. Explorer Challenge Outcomes • Multiple approaches never before imagined internally • Applications of robust leading edge machine learning, data science and geological techniques • New ways of extracting data, fusing and analysing multiple data layers • >400 targets – robust new targets generated, confidence increased in known targets
  • 12. Data Science and Exploration: What did we learn? • Multidisciplinary teams rule! • DS enables state, national and global datasets to be trained on and pulled into local problems, a great way to reduce bias • Explainable/interpretable machine learning is key for it to be added to the geologists toolkit • Geoscience data is not friendly for data scientists
  • 13. The Startup Ecosystem in Exploration Data Science https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/startups-leveraging-machine-learning- improve-holly-bridgwater/
  • 14. Key takeaways • CONSENSUS = CONFIDENCE, geology is complex: search for consensus not the best • Open, accessible data creates an environment where you can achieve consensus. • Data scientists + geologists = success! • Internal – 1yr, 2-3 models max • Crowd – 3 months, 40 models