SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 17
Baixar para ler offline
Table of contents


1. Introduction                                                 2


2. International organisations propagating globalisation        3


       2.1 Introduction: Joseph Stiglitz                        3


       2.2 The IMF: the right organisation on the wrong track   4


                2.2.1 An ideology gone haywire                  4


                2.2.2 The Washington Consensus                  4


                2.2.3 Western hypocrisy                         5


                2.2.4 Theory versus practice                    6


                2.2.5 The democratic deficit                    8


                2.2.6 Power relations                           9


       2.3 Case study – Argentina                               11


3. Impact of globalisation on industrialised countries          13


                3.1. Larger markets but lower employment        13


                3.2. Looking beyond the economy                 14


4. Conclusion                                                   16


5. Bibliography                                                 17



                                                                     1
1. Introduction


Globalisation can be defined as a political and economic term indicating the continuous
process of the global division of labour. Production takes place in those countries that are
most advantageous in terms of overall costs. This process is only possible because of the
removal of state-imposed trade limitations, new communication technologies and the
worldwide mobility of capital. The search for the lowest costs not only takes place on the
level of the final product, but also on the level of each individual part of this final product.
Therefore globalisation increases the pressure on individual companies to produce as cost-
effective as possible. What this can lead to will be discussed in this paper.


A paper on the negative aspects of globalisation can not be complete without sufficient
attention given to the international organisations propelling us all into a more globalised
world. The focus will lie on the International Monetary Fund because of its impact on the
countries who are left out of the benefits of globalisation. I will discuss the role of the IMF
and the criticism it receives from the prominent economist Joseph Stiglitz. Moreover I will
give a case study of Argentina, one of the IMF’s worst interventions.


The second chapter will shift the focus to the negative aspects of globalisation for the
industrialised countries. We will see how globalisation can cause a severe backlash even in
those countries which in monetary terms gain the most from globalisation.




                                                                                                   2
2. International organisations propagating globalisation


This chapter deals with the institutions at the heart of globalisation. The last few years they
have been subjected to a huge amount of criticism. I have chosen to focus on the issues put
forth by Joseph Stiglitz as he is a recognized authority on the subject.
First I will briefly discuss why Joseph Stiglitz’ book “Globalisation and its Discontents”
caused so much uproar. For the first time the IMF saw its actions criticised by someone whom
they could not designate as an uneducated anti-globalist.


2.1 Introduction: Joseph Stiglitz


Joseph Stiglitz was a member on the advisory board of president Bill Clinton. Later Stiglitz
joined the World Bank as chief economist and vice-president. This position gave him the
opportunity to witness firsthand the difficult coordination between the IMF, World Bank and
World Trade Organization. Stiglitz often felt that the efforts of the World Bank were
“sabotaged” by the IMF. In 1997 Stiglitz could no longer deny his feelings toward the IMF.
He openly criticized the way the Fund was handling the Asian crisis. The IMF did not tolerate
his behaviour and exerted a great deal of pressure on the head of the World Bank, James
Wolfensohn, to fire Stiglitz. Just a few months before his contract was to end the World Bank
did fire Stiglitz. Since then he has been teaching at Colombia University. In 2001 Stiglitz and
two colleagues were awarded the Nobel price for economy for their work on the information
economy.


It is important to note that Stiglitz is not against globalization as such. He believes that it can
be used as a force to do much good in the world. According to him it has the potential to make
everyone in the world better off. However : he strongly criticizes the way globalization is
implemented today. In his book “Globalization and its Discontents” ( a pun on Sigmund
Freud’s “Civilization and its Discontents” ? ) he calls for a fundamental reform of the
institutions which are the instruments of globalisation : IMF, World Bank and World Trade
Organization. Stiglitz’ aim is to remove the mistakes from the neoliberal system. While
working for the World Bank Stiglitz was often appalled by the fact that its sister organization
the IMF did more harm than good.




                                                                                                      3
2.2 The IMF: the right organisation on the wrong track


2.2.1 An ideology gone haywire


Stiglitz points out the shift in ideology which the IMF underwent. Originally the ideas from
Keynes were implemented in IMF policy decisions. This economist stressed the need for the
government to stimulate national expenditure using monetary or fiscal policy. If a monetary
policy is ineffective the government can always lower taxes or increase government
expenditure. The eighties changed the ideology of the IMF. Ronald Reagan and Margaret
Thatcher were at the head of the most powerful nations on earth. Both were convinced of the
marvels of a free market approach to society. By replacing the people at the highest level in
both the IMF and the World Bank both institutions propagated the same neoliberal message.


The impact of neoliberalism led to marketfundamentalism. Markets were thought to be able to
solve all problems. The government needed to tighten its belt. This approach lead to
devastating effects on the economies of developing nations as they were forced to cut down
on expenditure while at the same time increase the taxes and the interest. Keynes would be
heartbroken if he saw the policies which the IMF advocates and which go directly against his
theories!


According to Stiglitz the neoliberal belief in the wonders of the market is fundamentally
flawed when adapted to the economies of developing countries. Adam Smith’s invisible hand
will be of no use in situations where his assumptions have not been fulfilled. Developing
countries struggle with two of the most important assumptions of Smith : consumers do not
have access to complete information and markets are not fully developed. Therefore basing
policy decisions on Smith’s inaccurate ( for developing countries ) model is sheer madness.


2.2.2 The Washington Consensus


Under heavy fire from Stiglitz is the Washington Consensus. This is a policy formed by the
IMF, World Bank and the American Ministry of Finance originally designed to bail out the
Latin-American countries during the disastrous eighties. The Washington Consensus rests on
3 pillars: deregulation, privatisation and liberalisation. Theoretically speaking these measures
assure that consumers can benefit from increased competition which brings the prices down.


                                                                                                4
Moreover, the government is no longer encouraged to maintain a structure of public
enterprises which often operate inefficiently. Stiglitz doesn’t contest the value of these
policies. He criticises two factors. First of all he points out that the Washington Consensus
was not used as a blueprint for setting goals and the means by which to reach them. Instead
the conditions worked out to help the Latin-American countries were plainly and
unashamedly copied to other struggling countries without taking into account the diversity
which exists between countries! A second point of criticism centres around the speed with
which countries were forced to adopt the measures contained in the Consensus.


For many developing countries this one-size-fits-all-procedure has had devastating effects.
The particular needs and problems of these countries were never properly addressed.


According to Stiglitz the underlying, fundamental problem leading to this “copy-paste”policy
of the Washington Consensus is that certain indicators are seen to be an end in itself instead of
a means to a higher end. Let us take the example of inflation. Traditional macroeconomics
teaches us that high inflation leads to low growth and low growth leads to high
unemployment. Therefore we can deduct that combating high inflation is in fact a means of
lowering unemployment. Stiglitz shows how the IMF has been responsible for focussing to
such an absurd degree on the factor “inflation” that for years it has awarded an “A-rating” to
Argentina for its work on tackling inflation…at a time when unemployment was reaching
dramatic heights!


The Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung is very clear when it comes to assessing the
Washington Consensus : “Allerdings ist es kaum gelungen, die wichtigsten Ziele des
"Konsens von Washington" zu erreichen: Weder gelang eine deutliche Senkung der
weltweiten Armut noch hat er wenigstens zu einer Steigerung des Wirtschaftswachstums in
den Entwicklungs- und Schwellenländern geführt”


2.2.3 Western hypocrisy


Stiglitz also criticises the way industrialised countries forget their own gradual development
process. Moreover, these countries tend to ignore the role their government played in securing
durable economic growth. The US for example could never have reached their current state of
dominant economic power if the federal government had not intervened efficiently.


                                                                                                 5
During the 19th century the US went through a transition which can be compared to the
globalisation process taking place for the last decennia. The communication and
transportation costs decreased, markets expanded and new companies emerged intent on
doing business at a national level. Stiglitz reminds the reader that the American government
did not automatically assume that markets produced the best possible outcome. For certain
market failures the government intervened and installed for example rules regarding minimal
working conditions, safety precautions and wages. Moreover, during the 19th century
transition the American government supported the agricultural industry and installed a wide
scale of programmes to raise the productivity of other sectors. How strange it is to witness the
way the United States treat developing countries! Policy measures are copied without taking
into account the diversity between countries and are rashly implemented at a rate unsuitable
for developing countries.


As was mentioned before, the market fundamentalism contained in the Washington
Consensus pours out in three processes: deregulation, privatisation and liberalisation. The
IMF advocates that developing countries throw open their borders and accept competition on
local markets from the most efficient world players. The IMF insists that the government
reduces and eventually abolishes any measures designed to protect certain sectors of the
economy. The IMF promotes the privatisation of state-owned enterprises. In the vision of
market fundamentalism these measures will lead to durable growth. We should look beyond
the fairy tales of the market ideology. Liberalisation favours the efficient companies from the
industrialised countries; local “competitors” are wiped out. Without protective – even
protectionist – measures certain key industries of the developing countries will wither away
when confronted with dominant outsiders. The social cost of privatisation can be so high that
the efficiency-gain is almost immediately destroyed.


In the following paragraphs I will further explain the objections one can raise when
confronted with the common theories of market fundamentalism.


2.2.4 Theory versus practice


The theory according to market fundamentalism is that liberalisation will lead to new jobs
with a higher productivity. In practice liberalisation does not create enough new jobs to
compensate for the amount of lost jobs! Local producers in developing countries invariably


                                                                                                6
have to admit their defeat when a multinational imposes itself on local markets. Those who
lose their jobs can not easily find a new one because of two reasons. First of all there can be a
shortage of entrepreneurship caused by insufficient educational opportunities. Secondly,
starting up a new company does not only depend on qualified personnel but also on the
availability of capital. When for example IMF programmes stimulate the raising of the
interest then taking out a loan is no longer an option.


Those who are indoctrinated in the market ideology would use this very moment to remind us
of the theory of comparative advantage from David Ricardo. The Bundeszentrale für
politische Bildung points out that for too long Ricardo’s theory was thought to indicate how
international trade was always beneficial to all parties. The theory holds its validity when two
countries of approximately the same economic level trade with each other. The
Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung gives the example of Germany and France who in their
mutual trading in the context of the European Union have both reaped benefits. Much more
controversial is whether the theory of comparative advantage still holds its own in trading
between an industrialised country and a developing country. Trade between Germany and
Burkina Faso could leave the latter with a huge amount of external debt. Burkina Faso needs
to pay more for the consumer goods and machines from Germany than it receives from
Germany for the sale of its raw materials.


Moreover, developing countries can often not benefit from the ideas expressed in this theory
because of the way industrialised countries prevent them from utilising their comparative
advantages. At trade negotiations the industrialised countries endeavour to lower trade
barriers on for example cars and machines. However, they strongly resist the abolishment of
these types of barriers for agricultural products and textile. These are two sectors in which
developing countries often have such a comparative advantage! Thus, the theory of
comparative advantage looses its significance when faced with Western hypocrisy. A country
such as Brazil pays on average 30 percent customs toll for its 15 mayor export-products. The
United States on the other hand only pay 14 percent customs toll for their 15 mayor export-
products!


This hypocrisy is all the more evident in the way industrialised countries continue to subsidize
certain industries whereas they boldly exclaim that developing countries should refrain from
giving such aid, all in the spirit of honest competition!


                                                                                                7
It can be enlightening to see just how significant these subsidies are. Every day the
industrialised countries grant their farmers subsidies for a value of about one billion US-
dollars. On a yearly basis this brings us to about 350 billion US-dollars, or seven times the
expenditure of these countries on development aid.


Privatisation is another pillar of market fundamentalism which can have a devastating
outcome. It is assumed that privatisation leads to more efficiency in the economy of a country.
The government no longer wastes its resources on a structure of badly managed state-owned
enterprises but can instead dedicate those resources to providing essential public facilities.
Moreover, unproductive employees are fired which makes the companies more efficient and
eventually profitable. This is a very narrow view of efficiency! The efficiency of individual
companies may be raised through privatisation, but the high social costs negatively effect the
total efficiency of the country concerned. Here we get a prime example of what happens if for
example the IMF insists on privatisation at a rapid pace. If the government of a developing
country has not been given enough time to install a sufficient level of social security in its
country, then the ensuing costs of a rash privatisation can be very high. Examples of social
costs can clarify what is meant. If only one relative manages to keep his or her job after mass-
dismissals a huge burden rests on his or her shoulders. Even more catastrophic is the decision
to remove children from school in order for them to go and work to supplement the family
income.


2.2.5 The democratic deficit


An important criticism levelled at the IMF is its built-in democratic deficit. The IMF is a
public institution yet never reports directly to its financers, you and me. Even the inhabitants
of the countries for which the IMF develops a set of programmes and the conditions to be
fulfilled are never directly approached. The IMF only reports to the finance ministers and to
the presidents of the central banks. There are other elements which also demand a more
democratic input-process. First of all the IMF makes most of its decisions behind closed
doors. Secondly, the way these decisions get voted is also highly undemocratic: the impact of
a country on the voting process depends on that country’s economic importance at the end of
the Second World War. Thus the United States have a veto-right! Moreover, this system
makes it impossible for the developing countries to work together and get a decision pushed


                                                                                                   8
through as the industrialized countries always have a larger voting impact. One could wonder
when developing countries on the fast track of industrialisation such as China and India will
finally be awarded a larger share of the voting weights.


We could turn a blind eye towards these shortcomings if for example the IMF-employees
would work for a long time in a certain country in order to familiarize themselves with the
specific needs of that country. Unfortunately IMF-employees usually get sent to these
countries for about three weeks. In this short period the Ministry of Finance and the Central
Bank of that specific country present them large sets of data. The number-crunching can begin
and on returning the IMF-employees are supposed to take sound policy decisions! I am sure it
is needless to say that the input of local, higher-educated citizens should be valued much
higher than a set of figures provided by the ruling classes. Locals have a better knowledge of
the case specifics. Including them creates a broad social basis leading to the necessary support
for measures collectively agreed upon.


2.2.6 Power relations


One of the largest problems with globalisation is that a single institution – the IMF –
dominates the way official government aid is distributed towards developing countries. This
monopoly creates the unhealthy situation that complying with what the IMF enforces has
nothing to do with free will, but more with common sense and a desperate need for survival.
Most developing countries do not only receive funds directly from the IMF, but also from the
European Union, the World Bank and private investors. However, all these sources of loans
pass directly or indirectly through the IMF! Both the European Union as well as the World
Bank base their decisions whether or not to provide loans to a certain country on the advice
given by the IMF. When faced with a negative assessment by the IMF, private investors too
will reconsider their options. Therefore a country often does not have the choice whether or
not it accepts the conditions posed by the IMF in order to lend money. Refusing would lead to
total economic isolation.




                                                                                                 9
This photograph caused quite some commotion a few years ago. We see the managing
director of the International Monetary Fund, Michael Camdessus, with his arms crossed and
towering above the Indonesian president Suharto who saw himself forced to sign the IMF-
documents. Many considered this to be the perfect illustration of how the lending country is in
a powerless situation compared to the IMF.


Many countries see no other choice but to accept the term the IMF poses in order to get at the
necessary funds. These terms are often collected under the heading “conditionality” and
represent the three pillars of the Washington Consensus and all the problems connected to
them which I have extensively discussed. Intuitively we can all agree that when someone
borrows money there are certain conditions that need to be fulfilled. A contract needs to be
signed which includes – among other things – the instalments that need to be paid and the
period over which the payments will be spread. The conditions which the IMF imposes
however are – for all the reasons discussed in previous paragraphs – entirely
counterproductive; the repayment of the loans by the developing country is often impeded
because the economy of the country has taken a turn for the worse.


Stiglitz proposes that globalisation should get a more human face. Institutions such as IMF,
World Bank and the World Trade Organization need to be reformed. Of equal importance is
the need to involve inhabitants in the decision-making process.




                                                                                               10
2.3 Case study – Argentina


Until the beginning of the 20th century Argentina was one of the richest countries on earth. At
the beginning of the nineties however the country was faced with a disastrous economic
outlook. There was the huge budgetary deficit. Protectionist measures had been taken, but for
all the wrong reasons. Instead of supporting key industries to protect them from devastating
international competition we can safely say that these measures were a covert way of making
the consumers pay far too much for their goods. Adding to these problems was the issue of
hyperinflation menacing the country. The inflation rate between 1983 and 1992 was on
average a whopping 350 percent per year. The national economic policy had failed to correct
the shortcomings and durable economic growth looked impossible.


The Washington Consensus seemed to have all the answers.Faced with the absolute
bankruptcy of their country Argentinean officials saw no other option but to adhere to the
measures from the Washington Consensus. In 1991 they agreed to implement the policy. The
Argentinean peso was put in a system of fixed exchange rates with the US-dollar and state-
owned enterprises were privatised at an alarming rate. Nevertheless the IMF was obliged to
lend 45 billion US-dollars to Argentina at the beginning of 2002 in order to avert bankruptcy
of the country. Hardly a few weeks later it became clear that the fixed exchange rate with the
US-dollar could no longer be sustained. A devaluation of 75 percent of the Argentinean peso
was the result when the system was finally dropped. The country was unable to repay off its
huge debt as it had a shortage of US-dollars, the currency of its debts. To put the situation in
perspective : Hamburg in Germany with 1,8 million inhabitants produced a higher level of
GDP than the 37 million Argentineans.


Where does that bring the country today? Based on GDP per capita we can say that Argentina
can be considered as one of the poorest “industrialised” countries. Many young Argentineans
flee the country in the hope of finding better opportunities and a better life. Both Spain and
Italy have seen a steady influx of Argentineans since the crisis in their home country.




                                                                                                 11
Perhaps we should look at the future more positively and consider that through recent
adaptations such mistakes will not be made anymore. In 1999 for example the IMF began its
Poverty Reduction And Growth Facility ( PRGF ). This partially answers some of the
criticism levelled at the IMF. Inhabitants are now consulted in order to put together a so-
called Poverty Reduction and Strategy Paper ( PRSP ). It remains to be seen though if enough
attention is paid to the input of the locals, but it is a step in the right direction.


The former chapter dealt with the international institutions in particular the IMF. I gave an
overview of the criticism surrounding these institutions. The following chapter will throw
some light on the claim that globalisation always benefits industrialised countries even if it
should harm developing countries.




                                                                                                 12
3. Impact of globalisation on industrialised countries


3.1. Larger markets but lower employment


On one hand the global market has the advantage that large companies, the world players,
have access to new and larger markets. On the other hand these companies need to accept
inevitable competition on the traditional markets. This leads to pressure in two distinct
domains. First of all there is the constant need to deliver efficient, high-quality goods to the
consumer. Secondly this needs to be combined with a consistent lowering of production costs
whenever possible. Therefore global competition can have far-reaching consequences for the
industrialised countries.


Let us take a closer look at Germany. At the beginning of the globalisation process Germany
managed to increase the number of jobs through a higher level of exports. Currently however
the country is struggling with the fact that more jobs are lost because of the migration of
production facilities to low cost countries than there are created through the rise of exports!
The explanation can be found in the fact that the German export-industry is mostly
technology-based whereas the migration occurs in labour-intensive sectors. If we take a look
at the Rhine-Main-region we see that the last ten years thousands have lost their jobs. This
leaves them with one of three options: seek work in another region, further educate
themselves in order to improve their value on the job market or plainly accept that they are
unemployed if one can call that an option.


The globalisation process owns its existence to continuous growth, not only of the entire
economy but also of individual companies at micro-level. Therefore more and more
companies decide to merge. The labour market suffers most from these mergers. The new
head office quickly realises that certain tasks such as accounting, repairs and maintenance are
performed twice. In the spirit of overall efficiency this boils down to cutting the unnecessary
jobs.




                                                                                                   13
3.2. Looking beyond the economy


I have discussed the negative points of globalisation on companies and the effect on
employment. Nevertheless it is equally important to look beyond a mere economic evaluation
of globalisation and to take a closer look at the impact of globalisation on society in general.


We can observe that the single has become the prototype of globalised humanity. Long term
relationships are out of the question if one wants to stay competitive in today’s job market.
We can see a sharp rise in the amount of LAT-relationships ( Living Apart Together ) and
weekend-affairs. We do not need to see our significant other all too often; that would only get
in the way of all the work we have to do! Children become the ultimate obstacle of the
flexible employee. This leads to a decline in the amount of newborns, but also to the
phenomenon that people are older before they seriously consider having children. Initiatives
such as day care centres at companies confirm this increasing difficulty of combining work
and family.


I personally attribute much of the current success of right-wing parties to certain aspects of
globalisation. Many people fear the impact of globalisation on tradition and local culture.
Many have the impression that important political decisions are taken by anonymous
international organisations. Many are confronted with unemployment when a far-away head
office decides to let people go on a massive scale. People feel powerless to turn the tide and
direct their anger at scapegoats such as immigrants who “steal our jobs”. Others seek to
counter the globalisation process by demanding rights for their region; the need for autonomy
rears its head. Some desperately seek a return to what they call “traditional values”. These are
all themes which we can easily find back in the programmes of many right-wing parties
across the globe. When for example the Belgian government is unable to secure over one
thousand jobs in Brussels in the context of the DHL-case, many loose their faith in the
traditional parties and turn their attention to those who offer simple solutions to complex
issues. I believe democracy is at the heart of what we are loosing with far-reaching
globalisation.


Yet it is not the only valuable asset of society that seems to be under considerable strain as a
result of globalisation. The last few years expenses for social security have skyrocketed.



                                                                                                 14
There are two reasons compelling many to debate whether or not the current social security
system needs to be reformed. First of all people get consistently older and society’s birth rate (
as discussed previously ) diminishes. Therefore there will be less and less people working
who have to support the social security system for more and more older, retired people. A
second factor is the wage costs. These are incredibly high. If we have a look for example at
Germany then we can see that where these costs represented 55,6 percent of gross wages in
1972, this figure had risen to 81,2 percent in 2001. This means that for every Euro an
employer pays his employee the former also needs to pay 81,2 Eurocent for social security.
Possible reforms include pressing people to pursue private means of securing a prosperous old
age or forcing people to pay higher contributions to the current system. Whatever path is
chosen it will be the socially weakest layers of the population who will suffer the most.


Maybe we should accept a slight loss of social security if on a worldwide scale globalisation
leads to better social norms? This is often advocated by the supporters of globalisation. They
point, for example, to the incorporation of minimal social norms and work ethics into the
WTO-treaty. This could put a stop to many sweatshop practices around the world. They forget
to mention that many governments of developing countries themselves are against such
regulations as they fear it might undermine the country’s competitivity. In globalisation’s
pursuit of lower prices everything seems to be permitted.




                                                                                               15
4. Conclusion
Globalisation requires companies to provide consumers with high quality goods and services
in order to secure sufficient market share and thus protect the many jobs at stake. Therefore
companies need to be continuously on the lookout for new opportunities. Yet the economy
alone is unable to confront the challenges which globalisation poses. An active government
policy should stimulate the ongoing development of the skills and qualifications which
employees need to survive in the globalised labour market. An active social policy to prevent
people from becoming victims of globalisation is another necessity.


The need for better international intervention is clear when we look at the problems
developing countries and Newly Industrialized Countries ( NIC ) are confronted with. The
three largest international organisations with which we readily associate globalisation are the
International Monetary Fund, the World Bank and the World Trade Organisation. These
institutions should take into account the diversity between countries. The Washington
Consensus failed to do so and the case study of Argentina shows what the disastrous result of
such an approach can be. Furthermore it would be refreshing if the international community
of industrialized countries at the helm of the aforementioned organisations would admit the
large disparity between the neoliberal theory and practice. They should also revise their
policies towards developing countries by taking a good, long look at their own gradual
development process. Last but definitely not least the power relations need to be more equal.
One way of achieving this is solving the democratic deficit.


It is of the utmost necessity to fine-tune the free market ideology currently being used by the
followers of neoliberalism. There are far too many discrepancies between theory and practice
for any well-educated being to promote market fundamentalism.


Finally, it is important to include non-economic elements in the globalisation debate.
Changing demographic patterns, outrage at decisions by largely anonymous organisations, a
feeling of isolation and a reaction against migratory influx are just the tip of the iceberg. The
glorification of tradition, the search for regional autonomy and the success of right-wing
parties are visible manifestations of what the current form of globalisation produces. Solving
its negative aspects could not be higher on our to-do list. The deconstruction of social
security, the polarisation within the multicultural society and the demise of democracy are at
hand.


                                                                                                16
5. Bibliography


Heribert, D., Chancen und Risiken für Entwicklungsländer, Bundeszentrale für politische
Bildung
<http://www.bpb.de/publikationen/KAF4FQ,0,0,Chancen_und_Risiken_f%FCr_Entwicklung
sl%E4nder.html>


Kathinka Dittrich van Weringh, Kulturen zwischen Globalisierung und Regionalisierung,
Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung
<http://www.bpb.de/publikationen/F011A2,0,0,Kulturen_zwischen_Globalisierung_und_Regi
onalisierung.html>


Kessler, W., Gesellschaften unter Globalisierungsdruck, Bundeszentrale für politische
Bildung
<http://www.bpb.de/publikationen/SN187N,0,0,Gesellschaften_unter_Globalisierungsdruck.h
tml>


Stiglitz, J., Globalization and its Discontents, 2002, W.W. Norton & Company, New York


Suharto and Camdessus photograph
<http://www2.correioweb.com.br/cw/EDICAO_20020519/fotos/p7.jpg>




                                                                                          17

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

La Historia Del Consenso De Washington Por John Williamson
La Historia Del Consenso De Washington Por John  WilliamsonLa Historia Del Consenso De Washington Por John  Williamson
La Historia Del Consenso De Washington Por John Williamsonneiracar
 
Global recession towards world economic depression
Global recession towards world economic depressionGlobal recession towards world economic depression
Global recession towards world economic depressionFernando Alcoforado
 
In defense of rational economic planning
In defense of rational economic planningIn defense of rational economic planning
In defense of rational economic planningFernando Alcoforado
 
Essay on Neoliberalism
Essay on NeoliberalismEssay on Neoliberalism
Essay on NeoliberalismJames Pevreal
 
Reimposing imperial domination in the global south through the mechanism of p...
Reimposing imperial domination in the global south through the mechanism of p...Reimposing imperial domination in the global south through the mechanism of p...
Reimposing imperial domination in the global south through the mechanism of p...Alexander Decker
 
An afro arab spring - socio-political trajectories in stemming the tide of th...
An afro arab spring - socio-political trajectories in stemming the tide of th...An afro arab spring - socio-political trajectories in stemming the tide of th...
An afro arab spring - socio-political trajectories in stemming the tide of th...Costy Costantinos
 
Tasa presentation flew nov 2012
Tasa presentation flew nov 2012Tasa presentation flew nov 2012
Tasa presentation flew nov 2012Terry Flew
 
De ocampo presentation 3rd singapore global dialogue sep 12 (2)
De ocampo presentation 3rd singapore global dialogue sep 12 (2)De ocampo presentation 3rd singapore global dialogue sep 12 (2)
De ocampo presentation 3rd singapore global dialogue sep 12 (2)Manu Bhaskaran
 
Neoliberalism, Financialization, and Globalization: An Intrinsically Unstable...
Neoliberalism, Financialization, and Globalization: An Intrinsically Unstable...Neoliberalism, Financialization, and Globalization: An Intrinsically Unstable...
Neoliberalism, Financialization, and Globalization: An Intrinsically Unstable...pkconference
 
Presentazione inglese
Presentazione inglese Presentazione inglese
Presentazione inglese cliobul
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1Sayotters
 
The future-of-the-imf-wolf
The future-of-the-imf-wolfThe future-of-the-imf-wolf
The future-of-the-imf-wolfstratmen
 
Its Always Something
Its Always SomethingIts Always Something
Its Always SomethingBobby Cherry
 

Mais procurados (16)

Neoliberalism
NeoliberalismNeoliberalism
Neoliberalism
 
La Historia Del Consenso De Washington Por John Williamson
La Historia Del Consenso De Washington Por John  WilliamsonLa Historia Del Consenso De Washington Por John  Williamson
La Historia Del Consenso De Washington Por John Williamson
 
Global recession towards world economic depression
Global recession towards world economic depressionGlobal recession towards world economic depression
Global recession towards world economic depression
 
In defense of rational economic planning
In defense of rational economic planningIn defense of rational economic planning
In defense of rational economic planning
 
Essay on Neoliberalism
Essay on NeoliberalismEssay on Neoliberalism
Essay on Neoliberalism
 
Reimposing imperial domination in the global south through the mechanism of p...
Reimposing imperial domination in the global south through the mechanism of p...Reimposing imperial domination in the global south through the mechanism of p...
Reimposing imperial domination in the global south through the mechanism of p...
 
An afro arab spring - socio-political trajectories in stemming the tide of th...
An afro arab spring - socio-political trajectories in stemming the tide of th...An afro arab spring - socio-political trajectories in stemming the tide of th...
An afro arab spring - socio-political trajectories in stemming the tide of th...
 
Tasa presentation flew nov 2012
Tasa presentation flew nov 2012Tasa presentation flew nov 2012
Tasa presentation flew nov 2012
 
De ocampo presentation 3rd singapore global dialogue sep 12 (2)
De ocampo presentation 3rd singapore global dialogue sep 12 (2)De ocampo presentation 3rd singapore global dialogue sep 12 (2)
De ocampo presentation 3rd singapore global dialogue sep 12 (2)
 
Global Risk Report 2008
Global Risk Report 2008Global Risk Report 2008
Global Risk Report 2008
 
Neoliberalism, Financialization, and Globalization: An Intrinsically Unstable...
Neoliberalism, Financialization, and Globalization: An Intrinsically Unstable...Neoliberalism, Financialization, and Globalization: An Intrinsically Unstable...
Neoliberalism, Financialization, and Globalization: An Intrinsically Unstable...
 
Presentazione inglese
Presentazione inglese Presentazione inglese
Presentazione inglese
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
 
Financial Crisis - Thinkline
Financial Crisis - ThinklineFinancial Crisis - Thinkline
Financial Crisis - Thinkline
 
The future-of-the-imf-wolf
The future-of-the-imf-wolfThe future-of-the-imf-wolf
The future-of-the-imf-wolf
 
Its Always Something
Its Always SomethingIts Always Something
Its Always Something
 

Destaque

28mei nas
28mei nas28mei nas
28mei nasepaper
 
Openeveningpresentation2011 (reduced)
Openeveningpresentation2011 (reduced)Openeveningpresentation2011 (reduced)
Openeveningpresentation2011 (reduced)douglasgreig
 
Binder19 September Aceh
Binder19 September AcehBinder19 September Aceh
Binder19 September Acehepaper
 
18 mar aceh
18 mar aceh18 mar aceh
18 mar acehepaper
 
7 уроков управления developers.org.ua
7 уроков управления developers.org.ua7 уроков управления developers.org.ua
7 уроков управления developers.org.uaMax Ischenko
 
English 5 Part Lesson Example
English 5 Part Lesson ExampleEnglish 5 Part Lesson Example
English 5 Part Lesson Exampledouglasgreig
 
Developing questioning for learning
Developing questioning for learningDeveloping questioning for learning
Developing questioning for learningdouglasgreig
 
Networking tools for startups
Networking tools for startupsNetworking tools for startups
Networking tools for startupsMax Ischenko
 
15 sep 11 bt property 2011_still a case for transitional offices
15 sep 11 bt property 2011_still a case for transitional offices15 sep 11 bt property 2011_still a case for transitional offices
15 sep 11 bt property 2011_still a case for transitional officesJohn Tan Yi Shin
 
Journalism Platforms - Online - slideshare
Journalism Platforms - Online - slideshareJournalism Platforms - Online - slideshare
Journalism Platforms - Online - slideshareJill Falk
 
Working in News - Slideshare
Working in News - SlideshareWorking in News - Slideshare
Working in News - SlideshareJill Falk
 
Pembelajaran berbantukan web
Pembelajaran berbantukan webPembelajaran berbantukan web
Pembelajaran berbantukan webRohaidi Othman
 
Presentación Congreso ISPIM 2010
Presentación Congreso ISPIM 2010Presentación Congreso ISPIM 2010
Presentación Congreso ISPIM 2010Javier Ruiz
 
Diagrama de fuerza cortante y momento flector
Diagrama de fuerza cortante y momento flectorDiagrama de fuerza cortante y momento flector
Diagrama de fuerza cortante y momento flectorAntonio Mogollon
 
Karraker, Strand Digital Portfolio 2011
Karraker, Strand Digital Portfolio 2011Karraker, Strand Digital Portfolio 2011
Karraker, Strand Digital Portfolio 2011GregKarraker
 
The Publishers - Ch 9 and 10
The Publishers  - Ch 9 and 10  The Publishers  - Ch 9 and 10
The Publishers - Ch 9 and 10 Jill Falk
 
Habits of mind launch
Habits of mind launchHabits of mind launch
Habits of mind launchdouglasgreig
 

Destaque (20)

28mei nas
28mei nas28mei nas
28mei nas
 
Openeveningpresentation2011 (reduced)
Openeveningpresentation2011 (reduced)Openeveningpresentation2011 (reduced)
Openeveningpresentation2011 (reduced)
 
Binder19 September Aceh
Binder19 September AcehBinder19 September Aceh
Binder19 September Aceh
 
18 mar aceh
18 mar aceh18 mar aceh
18 mar aceh
 
Bahan ajar
Bahan ajarBahan ajar
Bahan ajar
 
7 уроков управления developers.org.ua
7 уроков управления developers.org.ua7 уроков управления developers.org.ua
7 уроков управления developers.org.ua
 
English 5 Part Lesson Example
English 5 Part Lesson ExampleEnglish 5 Part Lesson Example
English 5 Part Lesson Example
 
Developing questioning for learning
Developing questioning for learningDeveloping questioning for learning
Developing questioning for learning
 
Networking tools for startups
Networking tools for startupsNetworking tools for startups
Networking tools for startups
 
15 sep 11 bt property 2011_still a case for transitional offices
15 sep 11 bt property 2011_still a case for transitional offices15 sep 11 bt property 2011_still a case for transitional offices
15 sep 11 bt property 2011_still a case for transitional offices
 
Journalism Platforms - Online - slideshare
Journalism Platforms - Online - slideshareJournalism Platforms - Online - slideshare
Journalism Platforms - Online - slideshare
 
Working in News - Slideshare
Working in News - SlideshareWorking in News - Slideshare
Working in News - Slideshare
 
Pembelajaran berbantukan web
Pembelajaran berbantukan webPembelajaran berbantukan web
Pembelajaran berbantukan web
 
Presentación Congreso ISPIM 2010
Presentación Congreso ISPIM 2010Presentación Congreso ISPIM 2010
Presentación Congreso ISPIM 2010
 
Fontlist
FontlistFontlist
Fontlist
 
Diagrama de fuerza cortante y momento flector
Diagrama de fuerza cortante y momento flectorDiagrama de fuerza cortante y momento flector
Diagrama de fuerza cortante y momento flector
 
Karraker, Strand Digital Portfolio 2011
Karraker, Strand Digital Portfolio 2011Karraker, Strand Digital Portfolio 2011
Karraker, Strand Digital Portfolio 2011
 
Rm3-A Device
Rm3-A DeviceRm3-A Device
Rm3-A Device
 
The Publishers - Ch 9 and 10
The Publishers  - Ch 9 and 10  The Publishers  - Ch 9 and 10
The Publishers - Ch 9 and 10
 
Habits of mind launch
Habits of mind launchHabits of mind launch
Habits of mind launch
 

Semelhante a University Of Antwerp Seminar Diversity In The Third World Ken Lawrence

Locating Oneself in Global Learning- First 4 Readings
Locating Oneself in Global Learning- First 4 ReadingsLocating Oneself in Global Learning- First 4 Readings
Locating Oneself in Global Learning- First 4 ReadingsOslo
 
1. IBF Chapter-1 Glonalization1.ppt
1. IBF Chapter-1 Glonalization1.ppt1. IBF Chapter-1 Glonalization1.ppt
1. IBF Chapter-1 Glonalization1.pptProfDrAnbalaganChinn
 
International business management essay globalization
International business management essay globalizationInternational business management essay globalization
International business management essay globalizationBobby Darmawan
 
A Critical Analysis Of The Transformationalist View Of Globalisation
A Critical Analysis Of The Transformationalist View Of GlobalisationA Critical Analysis Of The Transformationalist View Of Globalisation
A Critical Analysis Of The Transformationalist View Of GlobalisationMichele Thomas
 
anti-globalization-movement-MwA2.ppt
anti-globalization-movement-MwA2.pptanti-globalization-movement-MwA2.ppt
anti-globalization-movement-MwA2.pptShahid Soomro
 
The Impact Of Economic Globalization
The Impact Of Economic GlobalizationThe Impact Of Economic Globalization
The Impact Of Economic GlobalizationJamie Boyd
 
Global Business Practice Assignment - The changing relationships between Tran...
Global Business Practice Assignment - The changing relationships between Tran...Global Business Practice Assignment - The changing relationships between Tran...
Global Business Practice Assignment - The changing relationships between Tran...Amany Hamza
 
Alston poverty-report-final
Alston poverty-report-finalAlston poverty-report-final
Alston poverty-report-finalsabrangsabrang
 
Bretton Woods Conference
Bretton Woods ConferenceBretton Woods Conference
Bretton Woods ConferenceGilroy ECA
 
UIMP Visiones Internacionales desde España y Nuevos escenarios estrategicos s...
UIMP Visiones Internacionales desde España y Nuevos escenarios estrategicos s...UIMP Visiones Internacionales desde España y Nuevos escenarios estrategicos s...
UIMP Visiones Internacionales desde España y Nuevos escenarios estrategicos s...Ed Fernandez
 
CASE STUDY CAPITALISM This case views the global, capitalist
CASE STUDY CAPITALISM This case views the global, capitalistCASE STUDY CAPITALISM This case views the global, capitalist
CASE STUDY CAPITALISM This case views the global, capitalistMaximaSheffield592
 
Copyright © UNU-WIDER 2009 UNU-WIDER, Helsinki, Finl.docx
Copyright  ©  UNU-WIDER 2009  UNU-WIDER, Helsinki, Finl.docxCopyright  ©  UNU-WIDER 2009  UNU-WIDER, Helsinki, Finl.docx
Copyright © UNU-WIDER 2009 UNU-WIDER, Helsinki, Finl.docxmaxinesmith73660
 
FINANCE AND LABOR PERSPECTIVES ONRISK, INEQUALITY, AND DEMO.docx
FINANCE AND LABOR PERSPECTIVES ONRISK, INEQUALITY, AND DEMO.docxFINANCE AND LABOR PERSPECTIVES ONRISK, INEQUALITY, AND DEMO.docx
FINANCE AND LABOR PERSPECTIVES ONRISK, INEQUALITY, AND DEMO.docxericn8
 
The nature of globalization
The nature of globalizationThe nature of globalization
The nature of globalizationrony duclosel
 
World poverty what will not cure the problem
World poverty what will not cure the problemWorld poverty what will not cure the problem
World poverty what will not cure the problemPatricia Khashayar
 
Uneven devt ec
Uneven devt ecUneven devt ec
Uneven devt ecyahui_tan
 

Semelhante a University Of Antwerp Seminar Diversity In The Third World Ken Lawrence (20)

Locating Oneself in Global Learning- First 4 Readings
Locating Oneself in Global Learning- First 4 ReadingsLocating Oneself in Global Learning- First 4 Readings
Locating Oneself in Global Learning- First 4 Readings
 
1. IBF Chapter-1 Glonalization1.ppt
1. IBF Chapter-1 Glonalization1.ppt1. IBF Chapter-1 Glonalization1.ppt
1. IBF Chapter-1 Glonalization1.ppt
 
International business management essay globalization
International business management essay globalizationInternational business management essay globalization
International business management essay globalization
 
A Critical Analysis Of The Transformationalist View Of Globalisation
A Critical Analysis Of The Transformationalist View Of GlobalisationA Critical Analysis Of The Transformationalist View Of Globalisation
A Critical Analysis Of The Transformationalist View Of Globalisation
 
Ipe21
Ipe21Ipe21
Ipe21
 
anti-globalization-movement-MwA2.ppt
anti-globalization-movement-MwA2.pptanti-globalization-movement-MwA2.ppt
anti-globalization-movement-MwA2.ppt
 
The Impact Of Economic Globalization
The Impact Of Economic GlobalizationThe Impact Of Economic Globalization
The Impact Of Economic Globalization
 
Global Business Practice Assignment - The changing relationships between Tran...
Global Business Practice Assignment - The changing relationships between Tran...Global Business Practice Assignment - The changing relationships between Tran...
Global Business Practice Assignment - The changing relationships between Tran...
 
Liz
LizLiz
Liz
 
Alston poverty-report-final
Alston poverty-report-finalAlston poverty-report-final
Alston poverty-report-final
 
Bretton Woods Conference
Bretton Woods ConferenceBretton Woods Conference
Bretton Woods Conference
 
Can Monetary Policy Prevent Financial Crises?
Can Monetary Policy Prevent Financial Crises?Can Monetary Policy Prevent Financial Crises?
Can Monetary Policy Prevent Financial Crises?
 
UIMP Visiones Internacionales desde España y Nuevos escenarios estrategicos s...
UIMP Visiones Internacionales desde España y Nuevos escenarios estrategicos s...UIMP Visiones Internacionales desde España y Nuevos escenarios estrategicos s...
UIMP Visiones Internacionales desde España y Nuevos escenarios estrategicos s...
 
Economic Globalization
Economic GlobalizationEconomic Globalization
Economic Globalization
 
CASE STUDY CAPITALISM This case views the global, capitalist
CASE STUDY CAPITALISM This case views the global, capitalistCASE STUDY CAPITALISM This case views the global, capitalist
CASE STUDY CAPITALISM This case views the global, capitalist
 
Copyright © UNU-WIDER 2009 UNU-WIDER, Helsinki, Finl.docx
Copyright  ©  UNU-WIDER 2009  UNU-WIDER, Helsinki, Finl.docxCopyright  ©  UNU-WIDER 2009  UNU-WIDER, Helsinki, Finl.docx
Copyright © UNU-WIDER 2009 UNU-WIDER, Helsinki, Finl.docx
 
FINANCE AND LABOR PERSPECTIVES ONRISK, INEQUALITY, AND DEMO.docx
FINANCE AND LABOR PERSPECTIVES ONRISK, INEQUALITY, AND DEMO.docxFINANCE AND LABOR PERSPECTIVES ONRISK, INEQUALITY, AND DEMO.docx
FINANCE AND LABOR PERSPECTIVES ONRISK, INEQUALITY, AND DEMO.docx
 
The nature of globalization
The nature of globalizationThe nature of globalization
The nature of globalization
 
World poverty what will not cure the problem
World poverty what will not cure the problemWorld poverty what will not cure the problem
World poverty what will not cure the problem
 
Uneven devt ec
Uneven devt ecUneven devt ec
Uneven devt ec
 

Mais de Thisco

A backup strategy for photographers
A backup strategy for photographersA backup strategy for photographers
A backup strategy for photographersThisco
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Klassieke Amerikaanse Filmauteurs Ken Lawrence Paper H...
Universiteit Antwerpen Klassieke Amerikaanse Filmauteurs Ken Lawrence Paper H...Universiteit Antwerpen Klassieke Amerikaanse Filmauteurs Ken Lawrence Paper H...
Universiteit Antwerpen Klassieke Amerikaanse Filmauteurs Ken Lawrence Paper H...Thisco
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Paper Cultuurkritiek
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Paper CultuurkritiekUniversiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Paper Cultuurkritiek
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Paper CultuurkritiekThisco
 
Wuxia Presentatie
Wuxia PresentatieWuxia Presentatie
Wuxia PresentatieThisco
 
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Lights Camera Interaction
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Lights Camera InteractionUniversity Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Lights Camera Interaction
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Lights Camera InteractionThisco
 
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Contemporary Film Auteurs Haute Tension
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Contemporary Film Auteurs Haute TensionUniversity Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Contemporary Film Auteurs Haute Tension
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Contemporary Film Auteurs Haute TensionThisco
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Non Fictie Beeldculturen The Corporation
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Non Fictie Beeldculturen The CorporationUniversiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Non Fictie Beeldculturen The Corporation
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Non Fictie Beeldculturen The CorporationThisco
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Narratologie Van De Film Sin City
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Narratologie Van De Film Sin CityUniversiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Narratologie Van De Film Sin City
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Narratologie Van De Film Sin CityThisco
 
Ken Lawrence Paper Kiss Me Deadly
Ken Lawrence Paper Kiss Me DeadlyKen Lawrence Paper Kiss Me Deadly
Ken Lawrence Paper Kiss Me DeadlyThisco
 
Ken Lawrence Minipaper Georges Melies
Ken Lawrence Minipaper Georges MeliesKen Lawrence Minipaper Georges Melies
Ken Lawrence Minipaper Georges MeliesThisco
 
University Of Antwerp The Uk Digital Television Landscape Ken Lawrence
University Of Antwerp The Uk Digital Television Landscape Ken LawrenceUniversity Of Antwerp The Uk Digital Television Landscape Ken Lawrence
University Of Antwerp The Uk Digital Television Landscape Ken LawrenceThisco
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Seminarie Geschiedenis Van Het Economisch Denken Paper...
Universiteit Antwerpen Seminarie Geschiedenis Van Het Economisch Denken Paper...Universiteit Antwerpen Seminarie Geschiedenis Van Het Economisch Denken Paper...
Universiteit Antwerpen Seminarie Geschiedenis Van Het Economisch Denken Paper...Thisco
 
University Of Antwerp Paper International Business Environment Ken Lawrence
University Of Antwerp Paper International Business Environment Ken LawrenceUniversity Of Antwerp Paper International Business Environment Ken Lawrence
University Of Antwerp Paper International Business Environment Ken LawrenceThisco
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Handelspartners Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Handelspartners Ken LawrenceUniversiteit Antwerpen Europese Handelspartners Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Handelspartners Ken LawrenceThisco
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Eindverhandeling Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Eindverhandeling Ken LawrenceUniversiteit Antwerpen Eindverhandeling Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Eindverhandeling Ken LawrenceThisco
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Case Arbeids En Sociale Zekerheidsrecht Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Case Arbeids En Sociale Zekerheidsrecht Ken LawrenceUniversiteit Antwerpen Case Arbeids En Sociale Zekerheidsrecht Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Case Arbeids En Sociale Zekerheidsrecht Ken LawrenceThisco
 
Galbraith Presentatie
Galbraith PresentatieGalbraith Presentatie
Galbraith PresentatieThisco
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Politieke Integratie Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Politieke Integratie Ken LawrenceUniversiteit Antwerpen Europese Politieke Integratie Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Politieke Integratie Ken LawrenceThisco
 
Presentatie Eindverhandeling
Presentatie EindverhandelingPresentatie Eindverhandeling
Presentatie EindverhandelingThisco
 
Ken Lawrence - Photography portfolio
Ken Lawrence - Photography portfolioKen Lawrence - Photography portfolio
Ken Lawrence - Photography portfolioThisco
 

Mais de Thisco (20)

A backup strategy for photographers
A backup strategy for photographersA backup strategy for photographers
A backup strategy for photographers
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Klassieke Amerikaanse Filmauteurs Ken Lawrence Paper H...
Universiteit Antwerpen Klassieke Amerikaanse Filmauteurs Ken Lawrence Paper H...Universiteit Antwerpen Klassieke Amerikaanse Filmauteurs Ken Lawrence Paper H...
Universiteit Antwerpen Klassieke Amerikaanse Filmauteurs Ken Lawrence Paper H...
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Paper Cultuurkritiek
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Paper CultuurkritiekUniversiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Paper Cultuurkritiek
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Paper Cultuurkritiek
 
Wuxia Presentatie
Wuxia PresentatieWuxia Presentatie
Wuxia Presentatie
 
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Lights Camera Interaction
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Lights Camera InteractionUniversity Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Lights Camera Interaction
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Lights Camera Interaction
 
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Contemporary Film Auteurs Haute Tension
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Contemporary Film Auteurs Haute TensionUniversity Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Contemporary Film Auteurs Haute Tension
University Of Antwerp Ken Lawrence Contemporary Film Auteurs Haute Tension
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Non Fictie Beeldculturen The Corporation
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Non Fictie Beeldculturen The CorporationUniversiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Non Fictie Beeldculturen The Corporation
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Non Fictie Beeldculturen The Corporation
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Narratologie Van De Film Sin City
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Narratologie Van De Film Sin CityUniversiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Narratologie Van De Film Sin City
Universiteit Antwerpen Ken Lawrence Narratologie Van De Film Sin City
 
Ken Lawrence Paper Kiss Me Deadly
Ken Lawrence Paper Kiss Me DeadlyKen Lawrence Paper Kiss Me Deadly
Ken Lawrence Paper Kiss Me Deadly
 
Ken Lawrence Minipaper Georges Melies
Ken Lawrence Minipaper Georges MeliesKen Lawrence Minipaper Georges Melies
Ken Lawrence Minipaper Georges Melies
 
University Of Antwerp The Uk Digital Television Landscape Ken Lawrence
University Of Antwerp The Uk Digital Television Landscape Ken LawrenceUniversity Of Antwerp The Uk Digital Television Landscape Ken Lawrence
University Of Antwerp The Uk Digital Television Landscape Ken Lawrence
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Seminarie Geschiedenis Van Het Economisch Denken Paper...
Universiteit Antwerpen Seminarie Geschiedenis Van Het Economisch Denken Paper...Universiteit Antwerpen Seminarie Geschiedenis Van Het Economisch Denken Paper...
Universiteit Antwerpen Seminarie Geschiedenis Van Het Economisch Denken Paper...
 
University Of Antwerp Paper International Business Environment Ken Lawrence
University Of Antwerp Paper International Business Environment Ken LawrenceUniversity Of Antwerp Paper International Business Environment Ken Lawrence
University Of Antwerp Paper International Business Environment Ken Lawrence
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Handelspartners Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Handelspartners Ken LawrenceUniversiteit Antwerpen Europese Handelspartners Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Handelspartners Ken Lawrence
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Eindverhandeling Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Eindverhandeling Ken LawrenceUniversiteit Antwerpen Eindverhandeling Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Eindverhandeling Ken Lawrence
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Case Arbeids En Sociale Zekerheidsrecht Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Case Arbeids En Sociale Zekerheidsrecht Ken LawrenceUniversiteit Antwerpen Case Arbeids En Sociale Zekerheidsrecht Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Case Arbeids En Sociale Zekerheidsrecht Ken Lawrence
 
Galbraith Presentatie
Galbraith PresentatieGalbraith Presentatie
Galbraith Presentatie
 
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Politieke Integratie Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Politieke Integratie Ken LawrenceUniversiteit Antwerpen Europese Politieke Integratie Ken Lawrence
Universiteit Antwerpen Europese Politieke Integratie Ken Lawrence
 
Presentatie Eindverhandeling
Presentatie EindverhandelingPresentatie Eindverhandeling
Presentatie Eindverhandeling
 
Ken Lawrence - Photography portfolio
Ken Lawrence - Photography portfolioKen Lawrence - Photography portfolio
Ken Lawrence - Photography portfolio
 

Último

How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?
How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?
How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?FlyFairTravels
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Chirag Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chirag Enclave Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Chirag Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chirag Enclave Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyNitya salvi
 
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236Sherazi Tours
 
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdfbest weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdftour guide
 
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh HaldighatiApsara Of India
 
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptx
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptxchar Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptx
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptxpalakdigital7
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...Apsara Of India
 
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday SafarisKibera Holiday Safaris Safaris
 
Genesis 1:6 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:6  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verseGenesis 1:6  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:6 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by versemaricelcanoynuay
 
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptxBERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptxseribangash
 
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236Sherazi Tours
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultant
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultantvisa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultant
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa ConsultantSherazi Tours
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 

Último (20)

How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?
How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?
How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?
 
Rohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No AdvanceRohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
 
Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VV...
Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VV...Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VV...
Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VV...
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Chirag Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chirag Enclave Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Chirag Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chirag Enclave Women Seeking Men
 
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
 
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236
 
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdfbest weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
 
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati
 
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptx
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptxchar Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptx
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptx
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men
 
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...
 
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris
 
Call Girls In Munirka 📱 9999965857 🤩 Delhi 🫦 HOT AND SEXY VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
Call Girls In Munirka 📱  9999965857  🤩 Delhi 🫦 HOT AND SEXY VVIP 🍎 SERVICECall Girls In Munirka 📱  9999965857  🤩 Delhi 🫦 HOT AND SEXY VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
Call Girls In Munirka 📱 9999965857 🤩 Delhi 🫦 HOT AND SEXY VVIP 🍎 SERVICE
 
Genesis 1:6 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:6  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verseGenesis 1:6  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:6 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
 
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptxBERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
 
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
 
Call Girls 🫤 Connaught Place ➡️ 9999965857 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Russian Escorts FULL ...
Call Girls 🫤 Connaught Place ➡️ 9999965857  ➡️ Delhi 🫦  Russian Escorts FULL ...Call Girls 🫤 Connaught Place ➡️ 9999965857  ➡️ Delhi 🫦  Russian Escorts FULL ...
Call Girls 🫤 Connaught Place ➡️ 9999965857 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Russian Escorts FULL ...
 
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultant
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultantvisa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultant
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultant
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
 

University Of Antwerp Seminar Diversity In The Third World Ken Lawrence

  • 1. Table of contents 1. Introduction 2 2. International organisations propagating globalisation 3 2.1 Introduction: Joseph Stiglitz 3 2.2 The IMF: the right organisation on the wrong track 4 2.2.1 An ideology gone haywire 4 2.2.2 The Washington Consensus 4 2.2.3 Western hypocrisy 5 2.2.4 Theory versus practice 6 2.2.5 The democratic deficit 8 2.2.6 Power relations 9 2.3 Case study – Argentina 11 3. Impact of globalisation on industrialised countries 13 3.1. Larger markets but lower employment 13 3.2. Looking beyond the economy 14 4. Conclusion 16 5. Bibliography 17 1
  • 2. 1. Introduction Globalisation can be defined as a political and economic term indicating the continuous process of the global division of labour. Production takes place in those countries that are most advantageous in terms of overall costs. This process is only possible because of the removal of state-imposed trade limitations, new communication technologies and the worldwide mobility of capital. The search for the lowest costs not only takes place on the level of the final product, but also on the level of each individual part of this final product. Therefore globalisation increases the pressure on individual companies to produce as cost- effective as possible. What this can lead to will be discussed in this paper. A paper on the negative aspects of globalisation can not be complete without sufficient attention given to the international organisations propelling us all into a more globalised world. The focus will lie on the International Monetary Fund because of its impact on the countries who are left out of the benefits of globalisation. I will discuss the role of the IMF and the criticism it receives from the prominent economist Joseph Stiglitz. Moreover I will give a case study of Argentina, one of the IMF’s worst interventions. The second chapter will shift the focus to the negative aspects of globalisation for the industrialised countries. We will see how globalisation can cause a severe backlash even in those countries which in monetary terms gain the most from globalisation. 2
  • 3. 2. International organisations propagating globalisation This chapter deals with the institutions at the heart of globalisation. The last few years they have been subjected to a huge amount of criticism. I have chosen to focus on the issues put forth by Joseph Stiglitz as he is a recognized authority on the subject. First I will briefly discuss why Joseph Stiglitz’ book “Globalisation and its Discontents” caused so much uproar. For the first time the IMF saw its actions criticised by someone whom they could not designate as an uneducated anti-globalist. 2.1 Introduction: Joseph Stiglitz Joseph Stiglitz was a member on the advisory board of president Bill Clinton. Later Stiglitz joined the World Bank as chief economist and vice-president. This position gave him the opportunity to witness firsthand the difficult coordination between the IMF, World Bank and World Trade Organization. Stiglitz often felt that the efforts of the World Bank were “sabotaged” by the IMF. In 1997 Stiglitz could no longer deny his feelings toward the IMF. He openly criticized the way the Fund was handling the Asian crisis. The IMF did not tolerate his behaviour and exerted a great deal of pressure on the head of the World Bank, James Wolfensohn, to fire Stiglitz. Just a few months before his contract was to end the World Bank did fire Stiglitz. Since then he has been teaching at Colombia University. In 2001 Stiglitz and two colleagues were awarded the Nobel price for economy for their work on the information economy. It is important to note that Stiglitz is not against globalization as such. He believes that it can be used as a force to do much good in the world. According to him it has the potential to make everyone in the world better off. However : he strongly criticizes the way globalization is implemented today. In his book “Globalization and its Discontents” ( a pun on Sigmund Freud’s “Civilization and its Discontents” ? ) he calls for a fundamental reform of the institutions which are the instruments of globalisation : IMF, World Bank and World Trade Organization. Stiglitz’ aim is to remove the mistakes from the neoliberal system. While working for the World Bank Stiglitz was often appalled by the fact that its sister organization the IMF did more harm than good. 3
  • 4. 2.2 The IMF: the right organisation on the wrong track 2.2.1 An ideology gone haywire Stiglitz points out the shift in ideology which the IMF underwent. Originally the ideas from Keynes were implemented in IMF policy decisions. This economist stressed the need for the government to stimulate national expenditure using monetary or fiscal policy. If a monetary policy is ineffective the government can always lower taxes or increase government expenditure. The eighties changed the ideology of the IMF. Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher were at the head of the most powerful nations on earth. Both were convinced of the marvels of a free market approach to society. By replacing the people at the highest level in both the IMF and the World Bank both institutions propagated the same neoliberal message. The impact of neoliberalism led to marketfundamentalism. Markets were thought to be able to solve all problems. The government needed to tighten its belt. This approach lead to devastating effects on the economies of developing nations as they were forced to cut down on expenditure while at the same time increase the taxes and the interest. Keynes would be heartbroken if he saw the policies which the IMF advocates and which go directly against his theories! According to Stiglitz the neoliberal belief in the wonders of the market is fundamentally flawed when adapted to the economies of developing countries. Adam Smith’s invisible hand will be of no use in situations where his assumptions have not been fulfilled. Developing countries struggle with two of the most important assumptions of Smith : consumers do not have access to complete information and markets are not fully developed. Therefore basing policy decisions on Smith’s inaccurate ( for developing countries ) model is sheer madness. 2.2.2 The Washington Consensus Under heavy fire from Stiglitz is the Washington Consensus. This is a policy formed by the IMF, World Bank and the American Ministry of Finance originally designed to bail out the Latin-American countries during the disastrous eighties. The Washington Consensus rests on 3 pillars: deregulation, privatisation and liberalisation. Theoretically speaking these measures assure that consumers can benefit from increased competition which brings the prices down. 4
  • 5. Moreover, the government is no longer encouraged to maintain a structure of public enterprises which often operate inefficiently. Stiglitz doesn’t contest the value of these policies. He criticises two factors. First of all he points out that the Washington Consensus was not used as a blueprint for setting goals and the means by which to reach them. Instead the conditions worked out to help the Latin-American countries were plainly and unashamedly copied to other struggling countries without taking into account the diversity which exists between countries! A second point of criticism centres around the speed with which countries were forced to adopt the measures contained in the Consensus. For many developing countries this one-size-fits-all-procedure has had devastating effects. The particular needs and problems of these countries were never properly addressed. According to Stiglitz the underlying, fundamental problem leading to this “copy-paste”policy of the Washington Consensus is that certain indicators are seen to be an end in itself instead of a means to a higher end. Let us take the example of inflation. Traditional macroeconomics teaches us that high inflation leads to low growth and low growth leads to high unemployment. Therefore we can deduct that combating high inflation is in fact a means of lowering unemployment. Stiglitz shows how the IMF has been responsible for focussing to such an absurd degree on the factor “inflation” that for years it has awarded an “A-rating” to Argentina for its work on tackling inflation…at a time when unemployment was reaching dramatic heights! The Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung is very clear when it comes to assessing the Washington Consensus : “Allerdings ist es kaum gelungen, die wichtigsten Ziele des "Konsens von Washington" zu erreichen: Weder gelang eine deutliche Senkung der weltweiten Armut noch hat er wenigstens zu einer Steigerung des Wirtschaftswachstums in den Entwicklungs- und Schwellenländern geführt” 2.2.3 Western hypocrisy Stiglitz also criticises the way industrialised countries forget their own gradual development process. Moreover, these countries tend to ignore the role their government played in securing durable economic growth. The US for example could never have reached their current state of dominant economic power if the federal government had not intervened efficiently. 5
  • 6. During the 19th century the US went through a transition which can be compared to the globalisation process taking place for the last decennia. The communication and transportation costs decreased, markets expanded and new companies emerged intent on doing business at a national level. Stiglitz reminds the reader that the American government did not automatically assume that markets produced the best possible outcome. For certain market failures the government intervened and installed for example rules regarding minimal working conditions, safety precautions and wages. Moreover, during the 19th century transition the American government supported the agricultural industry and installed a wide scale of programmes to raise the productivity of other sectors. How strange it is to witness the way the United States treat developing countries! Policy measures are copied without taking into account the diversity between countries and are rashly implemented at a rate unsuitable for developing countries. As was mentioned before, the market fundamentalism contained in the Washington Consensus pours out in three processes: deregulation, privatisation and liberalisation. The IMF advocates that developing countries throw open their borders and accept competition on local markets from the most efficient world players. The IMF insists that the government reduces and eventually abolishes any measures designed to protect certain sectors of the economy. The IMF promotes the privatisation of state-owned enterprises. In the vision of market fundamentalism these measures will lead to durable growth. We should look beyond the fairy tales of the market ideology. Liberalisation favours the efficient companies from the industrialised countries; local “competitors” are wiped out. Without protective – even protectionist – measures certain key industries of the developing countries will wither away when confronted with dominant outsiders. The social cost of privatisation can be so high that the efficiency-gain is almost immediately destroyed. In the following paragraphs I will further explain the objections one can raise when confronted with the common theories of market fundamentalism. 2.2.4 Theory versus practice The theory according to market fundamentalism is that liberalisation will lead to new jobs with a higher productivity. In practice liberalisation does not create enough new jobs to compensate for the amount of lost jobs! Local producers in developing countries invariably 6
  • 7. have to admit their defeat when a multinational imposes itself on local markets. Those who lose their jobs can not easily find a new one because of two reasons. First of all there can be a shortage of entrepreneurship caused by insufficient educational opportunities. Secondly, starting up a new company does not only depend on qualified personnel but also on the availability of capital. When for example IMF programmes stimulate the raising of the interest then taking out a loan is no longer an option. Those who are indoctrinated in the market ideology would use this very moment to remind us of the theory of comparative advantage from David Ricardo. The Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung points out that for too long Ricardo’s theory was thought to indicate how international trade was always beneficial to all parties. The theory holds its validity when two countries of approximately the same economic level trade with each other. The Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung gives the example of Germany and France who in their mutual trading in the context of the European Union have both reaped benefits. Much more controversial is whether the theory of comparative advantage still holds its own in trading between an industrialised country and a developing country. Trade between Germany and Burkina Faso could leave the latter with a huge amount of external debt. Burkina Faso needs to pay more for the consumer goods and machines from Germany than it receives from Germany for the sale of its raw materials. Moreover, developing countries can often not benefit from the ideas expressed in this theory because of the way industrialised countries prevent them from utilising their comparative advantages. At trade negotiations the industrialised countries endeavour to lower trade barriers on for example cars and machines. However, they strongly resist the abolishment of these types of barriers for agricultural products and textile. These are two sectors in which developing countries often have such a comparative advantage! Thus, the theory of comparative advantage looses its significance when faced with Western hypocrisy. A country such as Brazil pays on average 30 percent customs toll for its 15 mayor export-products. The United States on the other hand only pay 14 percent customs toll for their 15 mayor export- products! This hypocrisy is all the more evident in the way industrialised countries continue to subsidize certain industries whereas they boldly exclaim that developing countries should refrain from giving such aid, all in the spirit of honest competition! 7
  • 8. It can be enlightening to see just how significant these subsidies are. Every day the industrialised countries grant their farmers subsidies for a value of about one billion US- dollars. On a yearly basis this brings us to about 350 billion US-dollars, or seven times the expenditure of these countries on development aid. Privatisation is another pillar of market fundamentalism which can have a devastating outcome. It is assumed that privatisation leads to more efficiency in the economy of a country. The government no longer wastes its resources on a structure of badly managed state-owned enterprises but can instead dedicate those resources to providing essential public facilities. Moreover, unproductive employees are fired which makes the companies more efficient and eventually profitable. This is a very narrow view of efficiency! The efficiency of individual companies may be raised through privatisation, but the high social costs negatively effect the total efficiency of the country concerned. Here we get a prime example of what happens if for example the IMF insists on privatisation at a rapid pace. If the government of a developing country has not been given enough time to install a sufficient level of social security in its country, then the ensuing costs of a rash privatisation can be very high. Examples of social costs can clarify what is meant. If only one relative manages to keep his or her job after mass- dismissals a huge burden rests on his or her shoulders. Even more catastrophic is the decision to remove children from school in order for them to go and work to supplement the family income. 2.2.5 The democratic deficit An important criticism levelled at the IMF is its built-in democratic deficit. The IMF is a public institution yet never reports directly to its financers, you and me. Even the inhabitants of the countries for which the IMF develops a set of programmes and the conditions to be fulfilled are never directly approached. The IMF only reports to the finance ministers and to the presidents of the central banks. There are other elements which also demand a more democratic input-process. First of all the IMF makes most of its decisions behind closed doors. Secondly, the way these decisions get voted is also highly undemocratic: the impact of a country on the voting process depends on that country’s economic importance at the end of the Second World War. Thus the United States have a veto-right! Moreover, this system makes it impossible for the developing countries to work together and get a decision pushed 8
  • 9. through as the industrialized countries always have a larger voting impact. One could wonder when developing countries on the fast track of industrialisation such as China and India will finally be awarded a larger share of the voting weights. We could turn a blind eye towards these shortcomings if for example the IMF-employees would work for a long time in a certain country in order to familiarize themselves with the specific needs of that country. Unfortunately IMF-employees usually get sent to these countries for about three weeks. In this short period the Ministry of Finance and the Central Bank of that specific country present them large sets of data. The number-crunching can begin and on returning the IMF-employees are supposed to take sound policy decisions! I am sure it is needless to say that the input of local, higher-educated citizens should be valued much higher than a set of figures provided by the ruling classes. Locals have a better knowledge of the case specifics. Including them creates a broad social basis leading to the necessary support for measures collectively agreed upon. 2.2.6 Power relations One of the largest problems with globalisation is that a single institution – the IMF – dominates the way official government aid is distributed towards developing countries. This monopoly creates the unhealthy situation that complying with what the IMF enforces has nothing to do with free will, but more with common sense and a desperate need for survival. Most developing countries do not only receive funds directly from the IMF, but also from the European Union, the World Bank and private investors. However, all these sources of loans pass directly or indirectly through the IMF! Both the European Union as well as the World Bank base their decisions whether or not to provide loans to a certain country on the advice given by the IMF. When faced with a negative assessment by the IMF, private investors too will reconsider their options. Therefore a country often does not have the choice whether or not it accepts the conditions posed by the IMF in order to lend money. Refusing would lead to total economic isolation. 9
  • 10. This photograph caused quite some commotion a few years ago. We see the managing director of the International Monetary Fund, Michael Camdessus, with his arms crossed and towering above the Indonesian president Suharto who saw himself forced to sign the IMF- documents. Many considered this to be the perfect illustration of how the lending country is in a powerless situation compared to the IMF. Many countries see no other choice but to accept the term the IMF poses in order to get at the necessary funds. These terms are often collected under the heading “conditionality” and represent the three pillars of the Washington Consensus and all the problems connected to them which I have extensively discussed. Intuitively we can all agree that when someone borrows money there are certain conditions that need to be fulfilled. A contract needs to be signed which includes – among other things – the instalments that need to be paid and the period over which the payments will be spread. The conditions which the IMF imposes however are – for all the reasons discussed in previous paragraphs – entirely counterproductive; the repayment of the loans by the developing country is often impeded because the economy of the country has taken a turn for the worse. Stiglitz proposes that globalisation should get a more human face. Institutions such as IMF, World Bank and the World Trade Organization need to be reformed. Of equal importance is the need to involve inhabitants in the decision-making process. 10
  • 11. 2.3 Case study – Argentina Until the beginning of the 20th century Argentina was one of the richest countries on earth. At the beginning of the nineties however the country was faced with a disastrous economic outlook. There was the huge budgetary deficit. Protectionist measures had been taken, but for all the wrong reasons. Instead of supporting key industries to protect them from devastating international competition we can safely say that these measures were a covert way of making the consumers pay far too much for their goods. Adding to these problems was the issue of hyperinflation menacing the country. The inflation rate between 1983 and 1992 was on average a whopping 350 percent per year. The national economic policy had failed to correct the shortcomings and durable economic growth looked impossible. The Washington Consensus seemed to have all the answers.Faced with the absolute bankruptcy of their country Argentinean officials saw no other option but to adhere to the measures from the Washington Consensus. In 1991 they agreed to implement the policy. The Argentinean peso was put in a system of fixed exchange rates with the US-dollar and state- owned enterprises were privatised at an alarming rate. Nevertheless the IMF was obliged to lend 45 billion US-dollars to Argentina at the beginning of 2002 in order to avert bankruptcy of the country. Hardly a few weeks later it became clear that the fixed exchange rate with the US-dollar could no longer be sustained. A devaluation of 75 percent of the Argentinean peso was the result when the system was finally dropped. The country was unable to repay off its huge debt as it had a shortage of US-dollars, the currency of its debts. To put the situation in perspective : Hamburg in Germany with 1,8 million inhabitants produced a higher level of GDP than the 37 million Argentineans. Where does that bring the country today? Based on GDP per capita we can say that Argentina can be considered as one of the poorest “industrialised” countries. Many young Argentineans flee the country in the hope of finding better opportunities and a better life. Both Spain and Italy have seen a steady influx of Argentineans since the crisis in their home country. 11
  • 12. Perhaps we should look at the future more positively and consider that through recent adaptations such mistakes will not be made anymore. In 1999 for example the IMF began its Poverty Reduction And Growth Facility ( PRGF ). This partially answers some of the criticism levelled at the IMF. Inhabitants are now consulted in order to put together a so- called Poverty Reduction and Strategy Paper ( PRSP ). It remains to be seen though if enough attention is paid to the input of the locals, but it is a step in the right direction. The former chapter dealt with the international institutions in particular the IMF. I gave an overview of the criticism surrounding these institutions. The following chapter will throw some light on the claim that globalisation always benefits industrialised countries even if it should harm developing countries. 12
  • 13. 3. Impact of globalisation on industrialised countries 3.1. Larger markets but lower employment On one hand the global market has the advantage that large companies, the world players, have access to new and larger markets. On the other hand these companies need to accept inevitable competition on the traditional markets. This leads to pressure in two distinct domains. First of all there is the constant need to deliver efficient, high-quality goods to the consumer. Secondly this needs to be combined with a consistent lowering of production costs whenever possible. Therefore global competition can have far-reaching consequences for the industrialised countries. Let us take a closer look at Germany. At the beginning of the globalisation process Germany managed to increase the number of jobs through a higher level of exports. Currently however the country is struggling with the fact that more jobs are lost because of the migration of production facilities to low cost countries than there are created through the rise of exports! The explanation can be found in the fact that the German export-industry is mostly technology-based whereas the migration occurs in labour-intensive sectors. If we take a look at the Rhine-Main-region we see that the last ten years thousands have lost their jobs. This leaves them with one of three options: seek work in another region, further educate themselves in order to improve their value on the job market or plainly accept that they are unemployed if one can call that an option. The globalisation process owns its existence to continuous growth, not only of the entire economy but also of individual companies at micro-level. Therefore more and more companies decide to merge. The labour market suffers most from these mergers. The new head office quickly realises that certain tasks such as accounting, repairs and maintenance are performed twice. In the spirit of overall efficiency this boils down to cutting the unnecessary jobs. 13
  • 14. 3.2. Looking beyond the economy I have discussed the negative points of globalisation on companies and the effect on employment. Nevertheless it is equally important to look beyond a mere economic evaluation of globalisation and to take a closer look at the impact of globalisation on society in general. We can observe that the single has become the prototype of globalised humanity. Long term relationships are out of the question if one wants to stay competitive in today’s job market. We can see a sharp rise in the amount of LAT-relationships ( Living Apart Together ) and weekend-affairs. We do not need to see our significant other all too often; that would only get in the way of all the work we have to do! Children become the ultimate obstacle of the flexible employee. This leads to a decline in the amount of newborns, but also to the phenomenon that people are older before they seriously consider having children. Initiatives such as day care centres at companies confirm this increasing difficulty of combining work and family. I personally attribute much of the current success of right-wing parties to certain aspects of globalisation. Many people fear the impact of globalisation on tradition and local culture. Many have the impression that important political decisions are taken by anonymous international organisations. Many are confronted with unemployment when a far-away head office decides to let people go on a massive scale. People feel powerless to turn the tide and direct their anger at scapegoats such as immigrants who “steal our jobs”. Others seek to counter the globalisation process by demanding rights for their region; the need for autonomy rears its head. Some desperately seek a return to what they call “traditional values”. These are all themes which we can easily find back in the programmes of many right-wing parties across the globe. When for example the Belgian government is unable to secure over one thousand jobs in Brussels in the context of the DHL-case, many loose their faith in the traditional parties and turn their attention to those who offer simple solutions to complex issues. I believe democracy is at the heart of what we are loosing with far-reaching globalisation. Yet it is not the only valuable asset of society that seems to be under considerable strain as a result of globalisation. The last few years expenses for social security have skyrocketed. 14
  • 15. There are two reasons compelling many to debate whether or not the current social security system needs to be reformed. First of all people get consistently older and society’s birth rate ( as discussed previously ) diminishes. Therefore there will be less and less people working who have to support the social security system for more and more older, retired people. A second factor is the wage costs. These are incredibly high. If we have a look for example at Germany then we can see that where these costs represented 55,6 percent of gross wages in 1972, this figure had risen to 81,2 percent in 2001. This means that for every Euro an employer pays his employee the former also needs to pay 81,2 Eurocent for social security. Possible reforms include pressing people to pursue private means of securing a prosperous old age or forcing people to pay higher contributions to the current system. Whatever path is chosen it will be the socially weakest layers of the population who will suffer the most. Maybe we should accept a slight loss of social security if on a worldwide scale globalisation leads to better social norms? This is often advocated by the supporters of globalisation. They point, for example, to the incorporation of minimal social norms and work ethics into the WTO-treaty. This could put a stop to many sweatshop practices around the world. They forget to mention that many governments of developing countries themselves are against such regulations as they fear it might undermine the country’s competitivity. In globalisation’s pursuit of lower prices everything seems to be permitted. 15
  • 16. 4. Conclusion Globalisation requires companies to provide consumers with high quality goods and services in order to secure sufficient market share and thus protect the many jobs at stake. Therefore companies need to be continuously on the lookout for new opportunities. Yet the economy alone is unable to confront the challenges which globalisation poses. An active government policy should stimulate the ongoing development of the skills and qualifications which employees need to survive in the globalised labour market. An active social policy to prevent people from becoming victims of globalisation is another necessity. The need for better international intervention is clear when we look at the problems developing countries and Newly Industrialized Countries ( NIC ) are confronted with. The three largest international organisations with which we readily associate globalisation are the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank and the World Trade Organisation. These institutions should take into account the diversity between countries. The Washington Consensus failed to do so and the case study of Argentina shows what the disastrous result of such an approach can be. Furthermore it would be refreshing if the international community of industrialized countries at the helm of the aforementioned organisations would admit the large disparity between the neoliberal theory and practice. They should also revise their policies towards developing countries by taking a good, long look at their own gradual development process. Last but definitely not least the power relations need to be more equal. One way of achieving this is solving the democratic deficit. It is of the utmost necessity to fine-tune the free market ideology currently being used by the followers of neoliberalism. There are far too many discrepancies between theory and practice for any well-educated being to promote market fundamentalism. Finally, it is important to include non-economic elements in the globalisation debate. Changing demographic patterns, outrage at decisions by largely anonymous organisations, a feeling of isolation and a reaction against migratory influx are just the tip of the iceberg. The glorification of tradition, the search for regional autonomy and the success of right-wing parties are visible manifestations of what the current form of globalisation produces. Solving its negative aspects could not be higher on our to-do list. The deconstruction of social security, the polarisation within the multicultural society and the demise of democracy are at hand. 16
  • 17. 5. Bibliography Heribert, D., Chancen und Risiken für Entwicklungsländer, Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung <http://www.bpb.de/publikationen/KAF4FQ,0,0,Chancen_und_Risiken_f%FCr_Entwicklung sl%E4nder.html> Kathinka Dittrich van Weringh, Kulturen zwischen Globalisierung und Regionalisierung, Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung <http://www.bpb.de/publikationen/F011A2,0,0,Kulturen_zwischen_Globalisierung_und_Regi onalisierung.html> Kessler, W., Gesellschaften unter Globalisierungsdruck, Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung <http://www.bpb.de/publikationen/SN187N,0,0,Gesellschaften_unter_Globalisierungsdruck.h tml> Stiglitz, J., Globalization and its Discontents, 2002, W.W. Norton & Company, New York Suharto and Camdessus photograph <http://www2.correioweb.com.br/cw/EDICAO_20020519/fotos/p7.jpg> 17