1. Headquarters U.S. Air Force
Key Air Force Research Priorities
Dr. Werner J.A. Dahm
Chief Scientist of the U.S. Air Force
Air Force Pentagon (4E130)
Washington, D.C.
28 June 2010
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation UNCLASSIFIED 28 June 2010 1
2. The Air Force is Critically Dependent
on Science & Technology Advances
The Air Force is in the capabilities business; achieving superior capabilities requires a
continual source of science and technology advances, with occasional breakthroughs 2
3. Science & Technology Has Top-Level
Representation in the Air Force
Headquarters U.S. Air Force Since shortly after its formation from the Army Air
Corps, the Air Force has maintained an independent
Secretary Chief of Staff
full-time Chief Scientist in the Pentagon as a direct
of the Air Force Air Force
(SecAF) (AF/CC) scientific and technical advisor to the Chief of Staff
Commander, Air Force
Materiel Command
Air Force (AFMC/CC)
Chief Scientist
(AF/ST)
Commander, Air Force
Research Laboratory
Office of the USAF Chief Scientist (AFRL/CC)
The Chief Scientist is the full-time scientific and technical Air Space
Propulsion Munitions
advisor to the AF Chief of Staff and Secretary of the AF Vehicles Vehicles
Holds 3-star equivalent rank; is a full member of the
Directed Materials
Air Staff, the AF Council, and Headquarters Air Force Sensors
Energy & Manuf.
Information
Provides independent technical advice on all existing and
planned programs, and on technical opportunities Human Basic Res.
Perform. (AFOSR)
Has unrestricted access to all information and programs; AFOSR
can address any topics of interest or opportunity NA NE NL
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 3
4. The Path from Science and Technology
to New Air Force Capabilities
Research & Development Acquisition
Materiel Development
Decision (MDD)
Milestone A Milestone B Milestone C
Universities Air Force Research Laboratory
Advanced System Production,
Basic Applied Concept Advanced
Technology Development & Fielding,
Research Research Refinement Development
Development Demonstration Sustainment
Budget Activity 1 Budget Activity 2 Budget Activity 3 BA 5 BA 6,7
Budget Activity 4
(6.1) (6.2) (6.3)
Technology Readiness Level (TRL): Definitions
• Low Rate Initial Production (LRIP)
• Initial Operational Test & Eval. (IOT&E)
TRL 1: Basic principles observed and reported • Full Rate Production (FRP)
TRL 2: Technology concept and/or application formulated • Initial Operational Capability (IOC)
• Field
TRL 3: Analytical or experimental proof of concept
• Sustain
TRL 4: Component validation in laboratory environment
TRL 5: Component validation in relevant environment
TRL 6: System/subsystem demonstration in relevant environment
TRL 7: System prototype demonstration in an operational environment
TRL 8: Actual system completed and qualified through test and demo
TRL 9: Actual system proven through successful mission operations
4
5. Overall Air Force RDT&E Investments
Basic Research (6.1) Applied Research (6.2)
Advanced Technology
2% 4%
Development (6.3)
2%
Concept Refinement
and Advanced Dev.
9%
System Development
and Demonstration
18%
RDT&E Management
4%
Operational Systems Development
61% $28.06B FY09 Air Force RDT&E
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 5
6. USAF S&T Core Investment in 6.1-6.3
6.1: Basic
6.3: Advanced Technology Research $310M
Development $541M 16%
29% $1.9B Direct AFRL funds
+ $2.2B Customer funds
+ 324M Congress adds
$4.5B total AFRL
6.1, 6.2, 6.3
Amounts shown are
$2B/yr Air Force core
funds; does not include
$2B/yr customer funds
6.2: Applied
Research $1029M
Total FY09 Core/External $4.5B 55%
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 6
7. USAF S&T Core Investment Distribution
Across Air, Space, and Cyber Domains
Cyber Domain
24%
$541M
$862M
Air Domain
46%
$566M
Space Domain
30%
Nearly one-quarter of all Air Force S&T investment now goes into the cyber domain
7
8. Ten Technical Directorates Comprise
the Air Force Research Laboratory
Directed
Energy Materials &
Manufacturing
AFOSR
Space Munitions
Vehicles
Sensors Human Air Vehicles
Effectiveness
Information
Propulsion
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 8
9. Total Annual Air Force S&T Enterprise
Amounts to $4.5B/yr (6.1-6.3)
$1.9B Direct AFRL funds
+ $2.2B Customer funds
+ 324M Congress adds
$4.5B total AFRL
6.1, 6.2, 6.3
Amounts shown are
$2B/yr Air Force core
funds; does not include
$2B/yr customer funds
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 9
10. What New S&T Advances Will Create the
Next Generation of USAF Capabilities?
Maintaining superior capabilities over its adversaries requires the Air Force to continually seek
new science and technology advances and integrate these into fieldable systems 10
11. U.S. Air Force “Technology Horizons”
1 3 6 7
Toward New Project New World Technology
Horizons Forecast Vistas Horizons
1945 1964 1995 2010
High-impact studies
2 4 5
Woods Hole New Project
Summer Study Horizons II Forecast II
1958 1975 1986
Low-impact studies
1940s 1950s 1960s 1970s 1980s 1990s 2000s 2010+
“Technology Horizons” is the next in a succession of major S&T
vision studies conducted at the Headquarters Air Force level to
define the key Air Force S&T investments over the next decade
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 11
12. Air Force S&T Vision for 2010-2030
from “Technology Horizons”
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 12
13. New Types of Remotely-Piloted and/or
Autonomous Air Vehicle Systems
Unmanned airborne platforms with large sensor
suite capable of long-endurance loiter on station
Requires substantial advances in numerous
technologies (e.g., multifunctional structures,
propulsion integration, affordable LO, etc.)
Air Force Sensorcraft concept
Passive laminar flow control technologies may
be essential to provide needed loiter times
Thermal management will be challenging; large
sensor heat loads with few ram air openings
Special fuels may be needed to manage extreme
heat and cold at various operating conditions Air Force Sensorcraft concept
General Atomics “Predator C” Unmanned combat air vehicle concept Air Force Sensorcraft concept
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 13
14. High-Altitude Long-Endurance (HALE)
Air Vehicle Systems
New unmanned aircraft systems (VULTURE)
and airships (ISIS) can remain aloft for years
Delicate lightweight structures can survive
low-altitude winds if launch can be chosen
Enabled by solar cells powering lightweight
batteries or regenerative fuel cell systems
Large airships containing football field size
radars give extreme resolution/persistence
DARPA VULTURE HALE Aircraft Concept
DARPA VULTURE HALE Aircraft Concept
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 14
15. Airship-Based HALE ISR Systems
HALE airship platforms are being examined for Examples of Current DoD
numerous ISR and comm relay applications HALE Airship Programs
Current DoD HALE Airship programs include: HALE-D
Long-Endurance Multi-INT Vehicle (LEMV)
HALE Demonstrator (HALE-D)
Blue Devil (Polar 400 airship + King Air A-90)
Integrated Sensor is Structure (ISIS)
Potential fuel cost savings over traditional ISR
aircraft; speed and vulnerability are concerns
Blue Devil “Polar 400” DARPA “ISIS”
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 15
16. Medium-Altitude Global ISR &
Communications (MAGIC) Platform
Medium altitude allows platform One example of a possible MAGIC long-endurance platform
more similar to traditional aircraft
More rapid repositioning than is
achievable with airship platforms
Can serve as ISR platform and as
airborne communications relay
Designs could potentially allow
far greater endurance than MQ-1/9
MAGIC-like JCTD may be used to
assess technology readiness
Comparison with MQ-1 Predator and MQ-9 Reaper
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 16
17. Hybrid Wing-Body (HWB) Aircraft
Hybrid wing-body with blended juncture has
greater fuel efficiency than tube-and-wing
Body provides significant fraction of total lift;
resulting volumetric efficiency is improved
Potential Air Force uses as airborne tanker
or as cargo transport aircraft
Fabrication of pressurized body sections is
enabled by PRSEUS technology
X-48B flight tests (NASA / AFRL / Boeing)
have examined aerodynamic performance
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 17
18. Partially-Buoyant Cargo Airlifters
Hybrid airships achieve part of their lift from buoyancy and
part aerodynamically from forward flight
Could provide fuel-efficiency benefits for large cargo airlifter
in certain applications (e.g., relatively unprepared sites)
Lockheed Martin “Project 791” using tri-hull design flew in
2006; short manned flight
System-level studies must determine potential DoD utility
Flight experiments needed to assess handling performance
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 18
19. Versatile Affordable Advanced Turbine
Engines (VAATE) Program
VAATE is the nation’s current major
collaborative effort to develop a new
generation of advanced turbine
engine technologies
Adaptive Versatile Engine Technology (ADVENT)
Highly Efficient Embedded Turbine Engine (HEETE)
Efficient Small Scale Propulsion (ESSP)
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 19
20. Key Efforts Within VAATE Program
MODEL-BASED,
ROBUST, DAMAGE – NON-LINEAR,
INTEGRATED TOLERANT DESIGN ADAPTIVE CONTROL
COMPACT,
THERMAL EFFICIENT, SYSTEM
MANAGEMENT CONTROLLED
SYSTEM EMISSIONS INTEGRATED
VERSATILE HEALTH
COMBUSTOR
WIDE-FLOW MANAGEMENT
LINE-OF-SIGHT RANGE SYSTEM
BLOCKAGE/ FLOW COMPRESSOR
CONTROLLED INLET
ADVANCED FUEL
ADDITIVES/
THERMALLY STABLE
HIGH HEAT SINK FUELS
INTEGRATED
POWER INTEGRATED
GENERATION LIGHTWEIGHT, REAR FRAME &
DISTORTION AUGMENTOR DURABLE,
TOLERANT FAN EFFICIENT,
VECTORING
FULL-LIFE,
EXHAUST
EXTENDED HOT-
SYSTEM
TIME TURBINES
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 20
21. Adaptive Versatile Engine Technologies
(ADVENT) Program
Constant mass flow of ADVENT engine
provide large new heat sink capacity
Additional heat exchanger located in
relatively low-temperature third stream
Provides heat sink for fuel-cooled cooling
air (FCCA) or air-cooled cooling air (ACCA)
May be especially important for large heat
loads in airborne directed energy systems
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 21
22. Highly Efficient Embedded Turbine
Engine (HEETE) Program
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 22
23. Airbreathing Propulsion Integration
Serpentine inlets and nozzles to provide engine
obscuration and embedding in airframe
Significant challenge to minimize flow distortion
at aerodynamic interface plane (AIP)
Seeking to develop bleedless inlet technologies
to avoid performance losses from bleed air
Passive and active flow control approaches
being explored to avoid flow separation
Must allow for wide range of mass flow rates;
nozzles, thrust vectoring, actuation
Passive or active flow control to avoid separation in serpentine inlet/nozzle
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 23
24. Supersonic Propulsion Integration:
Combined-Cycle Scramjet Systems
AEDC APTU tests under FaCET of common turbo-ramjet/scramjet flowpath
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 24
25. Supersonic Inlets: Shock-Boundary
Layer Interaction (SBLI) Control
Bleedless mixed-compression inlets
need methods to avoid BL separation
Maximize inlet pressure recovery
Shock-boundary layer interaction (SBLI)
can trigger separation at or after shocks
AFRL using experiments and numerical
simulations to develop suitable control
Passive sub-boundary layer vortex
generator micro-ramps
Alternative passive control elements
Shock-boundary layer interaction measurements (Lapsa & Dahm 2009)
Simulations of passive control of shock-boundary layer interaction
control using micro-ramps (Galbraith et al. 2009)
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 25
26. Advanced Diagnostics for SBLI Data
Stereo Particle Imaging Velocimetry Data for Shock Boundary Layer Interactions
Instantaneous (u, v, w) across 2D spanwise Mean Strain Rate Sxx (x, y)
planes Fields
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 26
27. Computational Modeling & Simulation
(M&S) to Support Air Force Needs
Computational aeromechanics support to Air Force Seek Eagle
Properly integrated M&S can give large aircraft/stores compatibility and weapons integration
reductions in cost of physical testing
Continued improvements needed in CFD
methods (incl. numerics and physics)
E.g., USAF Seek Eagle use of CFD to
assess aircraft/stores compatibility
6-DOF time-accurate trajectory codes
using dynamic offset grids
Platform/stores configurations exceed
what can be tested directly
Massive Ordnance Penetrator (MOP) Miniature Air Launched Decoy (MALD)
Stores Separation from B-52 B-52 Heavy Stores Adapter
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 27
28. Hypersonic International Flight Research
and Experimentation (HIFiRE) Program
HIFiRE flights use sounding rocket descent trajectories
to explore fundamental hypersonics technologies
AFRL and Australian DSTO with NASA; rocket flights at
Woomera, White Sands, and Pacific Missile Range
Primary focus on aerosciences and propulsion areas;
also stability & control and sensors & instrumentation
Propulsion experiments on Flights 2 (US), 3 (AUS), and
6-9 (US/AUS)
Scramjet fueling/combustion, integration, performance
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 28
29. Scramjet Engine Development
Hydrocarbon-fueled dual-mode ram/scramjet
combustor allows operation over Mach range
Thermal management, ignition, flameholding
GDE-1 was flight weight hydrocarbon fuel-
cooled but with open-loop fuel system
GDE-2 was closed-loop hydrocarbon fuel-
cooled system intended for NASA X-43C
SJX61-1,2 were closed-loop HC fuel-cooled
development/clearance engines for X-51A
Ground Demo Engine (GDE-2) SJX61-1 Development Engine SJX61-2 Flight Clearance Engine
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 29
30. X-51A Scramjet Engine Demonstrator
First Flight on 26 May 2010
240-sec of continuous JP-fueled scramjet
combustion in fuel-cooled combustor
Four flight experiments beginning late 2009
B-52 underwing launch; ATACMS booster to
separation and scramjet ignition
Actual first flight performance:
Total mission time = 210 sec
Time on scramjet = 143 sec
Total distance traveled = 170 mi
Scramjet ethylene start and JP-7 transition
Scramjet fuel control and cooling
Fuel setting for 4.7 ≤ Mach ≤ 5.25
Actual scramjet Mach achieved was 4.9
TM lost before fuel setting for high Mach
Possible seal leak at nozzle junction
Nearly all other test objectives were met
on this initial flight experiment
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 30
31. X-51A Scramjet Engine Demonstrator
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 31
32. X-51A Scramjet Engine Demonstrator
Cleared for Public Release:
WPAFB 08-2865
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 32
33. X-51A Scramjet Engine Demonstrator
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 33
34. X-51A Scramjet Engine Demonstrator
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 34
35. X-51A Scramjet Engine Demonstrator
300-sec of continuous JP-fueled scramjet
combustion in fuel-cooled combustor
Four flight experiments beginning in 2010
B-52 underwing launch; ATACMS booster
~30 sec to separation and scramjet ignition
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 35
36. Robust Scramjet Scale-Up Program
X-51A uses small-scale combustor AFRL Robust Scramjet program
Possible follow-on flights Scale-up and combustor
Large-scale
to test navigation and reconfiguration for
vehicle
inert strike on 3X, 10X, 100X
target scales?
Possible ISR Potential step to
or global strike vehicle a future airbreathing
TSTO access-to-space system
Dual flowpaths, mode
Combined TBCC nozzle
transitions, cocooning
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 36
37. Hypersonic Global ISR Vehicles
JP-fueled scramjet propulsion system could potentially enable a medium-size
rapid-response ISR vehicle having operationally relevant range capability
Mach 6 limit avoids complex thermal management penalties at higher Mach
Vertical takeoff / horizontal landing (VTHL) enables single-stage rocket-based
combined-cycle (RBCC) system having 5000 nmi range with 2000 lbs payload
Integral rocket boost to Mach 3.5 with ram-scram acceleration to Mach 6
Resulting notional vehicle is 80 ft long with 42,000 lbs empty weight
Notional Mach 6 single-stage reusable VTHL ISR vehicle with 5000 nmi range (Astrox)
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 37
38. Airbreathing Two-Stage-to-Orbit
(TSTO) Access to Space Vehicles
Airbreathing systems offer enormous advantages
for TSTO access-to-space; reusable space access
with aircraft-like operations
Air Force / NASA conducting joint configuration
option assessments using Level 1 & 2 analyses
Reusable rockets (RR), turbine-based (TBCC) and
rocket-based (RBCC) combined cycles
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 38
39. Laser-Based Directed Energy Systems
Laser-based directed energy systems approaching
operationally useful power, size, and beam quality
Distinction between tactical DE (e.g., ATL in C-130)
vs. strategic DE (e.g., ABL in B747)
Tactical-scale systems enabled ultra-low collateral
damage strike and airborne self-defense AFRL Fiber Laser Testbed
Technology path from COIL lasers to bulk solid
state (e.g., HELLADS) to fiber lasers to DPALs
Demonstration path leads to airborne test (ELLA)
General North Oscura Peak (NOP) ELLA Flight Demonstration AFRL Rubidium DPAL Experiment
Atomics White Sands Missile Range
Unit Cells Textron
2010 2012 2017
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 39
40. Electric Laser on a Large Aircraft
(ELLA): Integration of Laser DE in B-1B
USAF Chief Scientist Conducting ELLA
ELLA seeks to integrate and demonstrate tactically Integration Assessment in B-1B
relevant high-power laser DE in airborne platform
C-130 and B-1B platforms were considered; B-1B
selected as most challenging (aero-optics)
Will integrated fully modular HELLADS-derived
laser in forward weapons bay of B-1B
Thermal management integrates with existing PAO
lines in weapons bay; full beam control
Current FY17 tests and demonstration planned
3 Weapons Bays
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 40
41. Emerging Roles and New Concepts for
Large and Medium Size UAVs
UAS moving beyond traditional
surveillance and kinetic strike roles
Longer-endurance missions require
high-efficiency engine technologies
In-flight automated refueling will be
key for expanding UAS capabilities
May include ISR functions beyond
traditional electro-optic surveillance
LO may allow ops in contested or
denied (non-permissive) areas
Electronic warfare (EW) by stand-in
jamming is a possible future role
Wide-area airborne surveillance
(WAAS) is increasingly important
Directed energy strike capability is
likely to grow (laser and HPM)
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 41
42. Current Unmanned Aircraft Systems
of the U.S. Air Force and DoD
U.S. Air Force
RQ-4 Global Hawk
MQ-1 Predator
MQ-9 Reaper
RQ-11 Raven
Wasp III BATMAV
RQ-170
Sentinel
U.S. Army U.S. Navy / Marines
RQ-7 Shadow MQ-1C Warrior RQ-11 Raven Scan Eagle
RQ-11 Raven RQ-8 Fire Scout
Wasp III BATMAV RQ-2 Pioneer
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 42
43. MAVs Involve New Aerodynamic Regimes
With Strong Fluid-Structure Coupling
Micro UAVs open up new opportunities
for close-in sensing in urban areas
Low-speed, high-maneuverability, and
hovering not suited even to small UAVs
Size and speed regime creates low-Re
aerodynamic effects; fixed-wing UAVs
become impractical as size decreases
Rotary-wing and biomimetic flapping-
wing configurations are best at this size
Requires lightweight flexible structures
and unsteady aero-structural coupling
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 43
44. Low Reynolds Number Flow Associated
with Flapping-Wing Micro Air Vehicles
Unsteady aerodynamics w/ strong coupling
to flexible structures is poorly understood
AFRL water tunnel with large pitch-plunge
mechanism allows groundbreaking studies
Advanced diagnostics (SPIV) combined with
CFD are giving insights on effective designs
MAV aerodynamics, structures, and control
are accessible to university-scale studies
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Cleared for Public Release 28 June 2010 44
45. Concluding Remarks
Air Force S&T priorities span across a
wide range of technical areas
Technology Horizons gives the vision
for key USAF S&T over next decade
Remote-piloted and autonomous air
vehicle systems will play a central role
RPAs, HALE aircraft and airships
Technologies for reducing fuel costs
will become increasingly important
Airships, HWB, VAATE programs
High-speed systems for strike, ISR,
and access-to-space are advancing
Laser-based directed-energy systems
are approaching operational utility
AIAA Combined Conferences Keynote Presentation Unclassified 28 June 2010 45