SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 63
Baixar para ler offline
Stavros Vassos, University of Athens, Greece   stavrosv@di.uoa.gr   May 2012




INTRODUCTION TO AI
STRIPS PLANNING
.. and Applications to Video-games!
Course overview
2


       Lecture 1: Game-inspired competitions for AI research,
        AI decision making for non-player characters in games
       Lecture 2: STRIPS planning, state-space search
       Lecture 3: Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL),
        using an award winning planner to solve Sokoban
       Lecture 4: Planning graphs, domain independent
        heuristics for STRIPS planning
       Lecture 5: Employing STRIPS planning in games:
        SimpleFPS, iThinkUnity3D, SmartWorkersRTS
       Lecture 6: Planning beyond STRIPS
STRIPS planning
3


       Given:
         Initial   state
STRIPS planning
4


       Given:
         Initial   state

         Goal
STRIPS planning
5


       Given:
         Initial   state

         Goal


         Available     actions
STRIPS planning
6


       Given:
         Initial   state

         Goal


         Available     actions


       Find:
        A  sequence of actions that achieves the goal
         E.g.: [Left, Down, Left, Up, …]
Planning Domain Description Language
7


       Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL)
         Formal  language for specifying planning problems
         Formal syntax similar to a programming language

         Includes STRIPS and ADL, and many more features



         Provides  the ground for performing a direct comparison
          between planning techniques and evaluating against
          classes of problems
Planning Domain Description Language
8


       Blocks world domain

         Initial   state: s0                                  Α
                                                               Β
                                        Α   Β     C            C
         Goal:     g
                                            s0                 g

         Available     actions: moving a block
           from the table to the top of another block
           from the top of another block to the table
           from the top of one block to the top of another block
Planning Domain Description Language
9


       Init( On(Α,Table)  On(Β,Table)  On(C,Table)
               Clear(Α)  Clear(Β)  Clear(C) )
       Goal( On(Α,Β)  On(Β,C) )
       Action( Move(b,x,y),
            PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b)  Clear(y)
            EFFECTS: On(b,y)  Clear(x)  On(b,x)
              Clear(y) )
       Action( MoveToTable(b,x),
            PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b)
            EFFECTS: On(b,Table)  Clear(x)  On(b,x) )
Planning Domain Description Language
10


        Init( On(Α,Table)  On(Β,Table)  On(C,Table) …)
                                                (:init
                Clear(Α)  Clear(Β)  Clear(C) )
                                                (:goal …)
        Goal( On(Α,Β)  On(Β,C) )
                                                (:action …)
        Action( Move(b,x,y),
             PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b)(:action …)
                                               Clear(y)
             EFFECTS: On(b,y)  Clear(x)  On(b,x)
               Clear(y) )
        Action( MoveToTable(b,x),
             PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b)
             EFFECTS: On(b,Table)  Clear(x)  On(b,x) )
Planning Domain Description Language
11


        Init( On(Α,Table)  On(Β,Table)  On(C,Table) …)
                                                (:init
                Clear(Α)  Clear(Β)  Clear(C) )
                                                (:goal …)
        Goal( On(Α,Β)  On(Β,C) )
                                                (:action …)
        Action( Move(b,x,y),
             PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b)(:action …)
                                               Clear(y)
             EFFECTS: On(b,y)  Clear(x)  On(b,x)
               Clear(y) )
                                             (:objects …)
        Action( MoveToTable(b,x),
             PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b)(:predicates …)
                                           
             EFFECTS: On(b,Table)  Clear(x)  On(b,x) )
Planning Domain Description Language
12


      (:init …)
      (:goal …)

      (:action …)          DOMAIN
      (:action …)

                            PROBLEM
      (:objects …)
      (:predicates …)
Planning Domain Description Language
13


      (:init …)
      (:goal …)

      (:action …)          DOMAIN
      (:action …)

                            PROBLEM
      (:objects …)
      (:predicates …)
Planning Domain Description Language
14


      (:init …)
      (:goal …)

      (:action …)          DOMAIN
      (:action …)

                            PROBLEM
      (:objects …)
      (:predicates …)
Planning Domain Description Language
15


      (:predicates …)
      (:action …)         DOMAIN
      (:action …)




      (:objects …)
      (:init …)         PROBLEM
      (:goal …)
Planning Domain Description Language
16


        On(A,B)              (on a b)

        On(A,B)             (not (on a b))

        On(A,B)  On(B,C)    (and (on a b) (on b c))

        On(x,y)              (on ?x ?y)
The blocks world example in PDDL
17


        Blocks world domain


          Available   predicates   (:predicates …)

          Available   actions      (:action …)
The blocks world example in PDDL
18


        Blocks world domain


          Available   predicates   (:predicates
                                        (on ?x ?y) (clear ?x)
                                    )
The blocks world example in PDDL
19


        Blocks world domain


          Available   action   (:action move
                                     :parameters (?b ?x ?y)
                                     :precondition (and
                                             (on ?b ?x) (clear ?b)
                                             (clear ?y))
                                     :effect (…)
                                )
The blocks world example in PDDL
20


        Blocks world domain


          Available   action   (:action move-to-table
                                     :parameters (?b ?x)
                                     :precondition (…)
                                     :effect (…)
                                )
The blocks world example in PDDL
21


        Blocks world problem


          Available     objects   (:objects …)

          Initial   state         (:init …)

          Goal                    (:goal …)
The blocks world example in PDDL
22


        Blocks world domain


          Available   objects   (:objects
                                     a b c table
                                 )
The blocks world example in PDDL
23


        Blocks world domain


          Initial   state       (:init
                                          (on a table) (clear a)
                                          (on b table) (clear b)
                     Α   Β   Γ
                                          (on c table) (clear c)
                                 )
The blocks world example in PDDL
24


        Blocks world domain


          Goal                (:goal
                  Α
                                   (and (on a b) (on b c) )
                  Β
                  Γ
                               )
The blocks world example in PDDL
25


     blocks-domain.txt:                                     blocks-problem1.txt:
     (define (domain gripper)                               (define (problem gripper1)
     (:requirements :strips)                                (:domain gripper)
     (:predicates (on ?x ?y) (clear ?x))                    (:objects a b c table)


     (:action move                                          (:init
     :parameters (?b ?x ?y)                                     (on a table) (on b table) (on c table)
     :precondition (and (on ?b ?x) (clear ?b) (clear ?y))       (clear a) (clear b) (clear c)
     :effect (and (not (on ?b ?x))                          )
             (not (clear ?y))
             (on ?b ?y)                                     (:goal (and (on a b) (on b c)))
             (clear ?x)))                                   )
     …
Using PDDL planners
26


        Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL)
          International   Planning Competition 1998 – today

          SAT  Plan
          TL Plan             Planning problems in
                                 PDDL, e.g., Blocks
          FF                 world, Storage, Trucks,
                                        …
          BlackBox

          SHOP2

          TALPlanner
                             Direct comparison between
         …                  planning techniques! E.g.,
                             evaluation of heuristics, …
Using PDDL planners: Blocks world
27


        blackbox –o blocks-domain.txt –f blocks-problem1.txt

         ----------------------------------------------------
         Begin plan
                                                                Α   Β   C
         1 (move b table c)
         2 (move a table b)
         End plan
         ----------------------------------------------------       Α
                                                                    Β
                                                                    C
Using PDDL planners: Blocks world
28


        blackbox –o blocks-domain.txt –f blocks-problem2.txt
         ----------------------------------------------------
         Begin plan                                                     G
         1 (move e b d)                                         D   E   F
         2 (move b table e)                                     Α   Β   C
         3 (move g f table)
         4 (move f c g)
         5 (move b e c)                                             Α
         6 (move e d f)                                             Β
         7 (move d a e)                                             C
         8 (move b c a)                                             D
                                                                    E
         9 (move c table d)
                                                                    F
         10 (move b a c)
                                                                    G
         11 (move a table b)
         End plan
Using PDDL planners
29


        We can use blackbox (or any other off-the-self PDDL
         planner) for any problem we can write in PDDL!
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
30


        We can use blackbox (or any other off-the-self PDDL
         planner) for any problem we can write in PDDL!




        Let’s do this for Sokoban
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
31




      Available predicates
      Available actions



      Available   objects
      Initial state

      Goal
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
32




      Available   predicates
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
33




      Available     predicates
        (robot-at ?loc)
        (object-at ?b ?loc)
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
34




      Available     predicates
        (robot-at ?loc)
        (object-at ?b ?loc)                     c4-4 c5-4 c6-4

                                  c1-3 c2-3 c3-3 c4-3 c5-3 c6-3
      Available     objects      c1-2 c2-2 c3-2 c4-2 c5-2
        c1-1,c1-2, c2-1, …
                                  c1-1 c2-1
        box1, box2
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
35




      Initial   state
        (robot-at c5-4)
        (object-at box1 c3-3)                  c4-4        c6-4

        (object-at box2 c4-3)   c1-3 c2-3             c5-3 c6-3

                                 c1-2 c2-2 c3-2 c4-2 c5-2

                                 c1-1 c2-1
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
36




      Available   actions
        move(?from   ?to ?dir)

       :precondition (




       )
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
37




      Available   actions
        move(?from   ?to ?dir)

       :precondition (and
         (robot-at ?from)
         (adjacent ?from ?to ?dir)
         (empty ?to)
       )
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
38




      Available   actions
        move(?from   ?to ?dir)

       :effect (and




       )
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
39




      Available   actions
        move(?from   ?to ?dir)

       :effect (and
         (empty ?from)
         (robot-at ?to)
         (not (empty ?to))
         (not (robot-at ?from))
       )
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
40




      Available     predicates
        (robot-at ?loc)
        (object-at ?b ?loc)
        (adjacent ?from ?to ?dir)
        (empty ?to)
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
41




      Initial   state
        (robot-at c5-4)
        (object-at box1 c3-3)
        (object-at box2 c4-3)        c2-3

                                 c1-2 c2-2 c3-2
        (empty c1-1)
                                      c2-1
        (empty c2-1)
        (empty c1-2)
        (empty c2-2)
       …
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
42




      Initial   state
        (robot-at c5-4)
        (object-at box1 c3-3)
        (object-at box2 c4-3)             c2-3

                                      c1-2 c2-2 c3-2
        (adjacent c2-2 c3-2 right)
                                           c2-1
        (adjacent c2-2 c1-2 left)
        (adjacent c2-2 c2-3 up)
        (adjacent c2-2 c2-1 down)
       …
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
43




      Available   actions
        push(?rloc   ?bloc ?floc ?dir ?b)
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
44




      Available   actions
        push(?rloc   ?bloc ?floc ?dir ?b)

       :precondition (and
         (robot-at ?rloc)
         (object-at ?b ?bloc)
         (adjacent ?rloc ?bloc ?dir)
         (adjacent ?bloc ?floc ?dir)
         (empty ?floc)
       )
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
45




      Available   actions
        push(?rloc   ?bloc ?floc ?dir ?b)

       :effect (and
         (robot-at ?bloc)
         (object-at ?b ?floc)
         (empty ?rloc)
         (not (robot-at ?rloc))
         (not (object-at ?b ?bloc))
         (not (empty ?floc))
       )
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
46




      Goal
        (object-at box1 c4-3)
        (object-at box2 c5-3)                  c4-4        c6-4

                                 c1-3 c2-3                  c6-3

                                 c1-2 c2-2 c3-2 c4-2 c5-2

                                 c1-1 c2-1
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
47


        blackbox –o sokoban-domain.txt –f sokoban-problem.txt
         ----------------------------------------------------
         Begin plan
         1 (push c4-4 c4-3 c4-2 down box1)
         2 (push c4-3 c3-3 c2-3 left box2)
         3 (move c3-3 c3-2 down)
         4 (move c3-2 c2-2 left)
         5 (move c2-2 c1-2 left)
         …
         27 (move c2-2 c1-2 left)
         28 (move c1-2 c1-3 up)
         29 (push c1-3 c2-3 c3-3 right box1)
         30 (push c2-3 c3-3 c4-3 right box1)
         End plan
         ----------------------------------------------------
Using PDDL planners: SimpleGame
48


        SimpleGame domain

                                turn(?fromd ?tod)
                                move(?froml ?tol
                                 ?dir)
                                pickup(?o ?l)
                                stab(?l ?knife)
                                shoot(?locn ?locp
                                 ?dir ?gun )
Building your own PDDL planner
49


       Pyperplan
         Lightweight STRIPS planner written in Python. Developed during
          the planning course at Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg
          2010/2011, GNU General Public License 3
         https://bitbucket.org/malte/pyperplan
       Source   code of academic planners
         BlackBox:
          http://www.cs.rochester.edu/u/kautz/satplan/blackbox/
         FastForward: http://www.loria.fr/~hoffmanj/ff.html
         FastDownward: http://www.fast-downward.org/
       ANTLR    Parser Generator
         http://www.antlr.org/
         http://www.antlr.org/grammar/1222962012944/Pddl.g
Building your own PDDL planner
50


        Quick overview of the provided PROLOG code
        Good for quick prototyping ;-)
Building your own PDDL planner
51


        Quick overview of the provided PROLOG code
        Works with SWI Prolog 6.x (tested with 6.0.2)
        Predicates provided
          parsePDDL(+DomainFile,        +ProblemFile)
          get_init(-InitialState)

          get_goal(-Goal)

          satisfies_goal(+State)

          progress(+State,      -Action, -NextState)
          h(+State,   -Value)
        {dfs,astar}planner(+DomainFile, +ProblemFile)
Planning Domain Description Language
52


        Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL)
          International   Planning Competition 1998 – today

          SAT  Plan
          TL Plan

          FF                    Sokoban
          BlackBox

          SHOP2

          TALPlanner
                             Direct comparison between
         …                  planning techniques! E.g.,
                             evaluation of heuristics, …
Using PDDL planners
53


        FastDownward [Helmert 2006]
          Introduced  a new type of heuristic that is not based on
           an empty list of negative actions
          Efficient implementation of all notable forward search
           methods and heuristics (including the more recent ones)
          Requires a number of preprocessing steps that
           transforms the STRIPS planning problem…
Using PDDL planners
54


        FastDownward [Helmert 2006]
          Introduced  a new type of heuristic that is not based on
           an empty list of negative actions
          Efficient implementation of all notable forward search
           methods and heuristics (including the more recent ones)
          Requires a number of preprocessing steps that
           transforms the STRIPS planning problem…

          Can be used as a framework to evaluate forward
           search planning methods
Using PDDL planners
55


        FastDownward [Helmert 2006]
          translate/translate.py   sokoban-domain.txt 
           sokoban.problem.txt
          preprocess/preprocess < output.sas

          search/downward --search SearchConfiguration < output



        http://www.fast-downward.org
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
56


        search/downward --search "astar(blind())" <output
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
57


        search/downward --search "astar(goalcount())"
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
58


        search/downward --search "astar(hmax())" <output
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
59


        search/downward --search "astar(add())" <output
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
60


        search/downward --search "lazy_greedy(ff())" <output
Using PDDL planners: Sokoban
61


        Notice that the planner does not know anything
         about the planning problem we are solving
        The heuristics we tried are domain independent
          goal   count
          hmax

          hadd

          FF

        We will see how each one works in Lecture 4 (after
         we first go over planning graphs that are needed)
Next lecture
62


        Lecture 1: Game-inspired competitions for AI research,
         AI decision making for non-player characters in games
        Lecture 2: STRIPS planning, state-space search
        Lecture 3: Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL),
         using an award winning planner to solve Sokoban
        Lecture 4: Planning graphs, domain independent
         heuristics for STRIPS planning
        Lecture 5: Employing STRIPS planning in games:
         SimpleFPS, iThinkUnity3D, SmartWorkersRTS
        Lecture 6: Planning beyond STRIPS
Bibliography
63


        Material
            Artificial Intelligence: A Modern Approach 2nd Ed. Stuart Russell, Peter
             Norvig. Prentice Hall, 2003 Section 11.4


        References
          PDDL - The Planning Domain Definition Language. Drew McDermott,
           Malik Ghallab, Adele Howe, Craig Knoblock, Ashwin Ram, Manuela
           Veloso, Daniel Weld, David Wilkins. Technical report, Yale Center for
           Computational Vision and Control, TR-98-003, 1998.
          Unifying SAT-Based and Graph-Based Planning. Henry Kautz, Bart
           Selman. In Proceedings of the International Joint Conference on
           Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI), 1999
          The Fast Downward Planning System. Malte Helmert. Artificial
           Intelligence Research (JAIR), Vol. 26, 2006

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

CptS 440 / 540 Artificial Intelligence
CptS 440 / 540 Artificial IntelligenceCptS 440 / 540 Artificial Intelligence
CptS 440 / 540 Artificial Intelligence
butest
 

Mais procurados (20)

Principles of Data Visualization
Principles of Data VisualizationPrinciples of Data Visualization
Principles of Data Visualization
 
Bayes Classification
Bayes ClassificationBayes Classification
Bayes Classification
 
3.4 deterministic pda
3.4 deterministic pda3.4 deterministic pda
3.4 deterministic pda
 
lattice
 lattice lattice
lattice
 
Visualising Multi Dimensional Data
Visualising Multi Dimensional DataVisualising Multi Dimensional Data
Visualising Multi Dimensional Data
 
Artificial Intelligence 1 Planning In The Real World
Artificial Intelligence 1 Planning In The Real WorldArtificial Intelligence 1 Planning In The Real World
Artificial Intelligence 1 Planning In The Real World
 
AI 9 | Bayesian Network and Probabilistic Inference
AI 9 | Bayesian Network and Probabilistic InferenceAI 9 | Bayesian Network and Probabilistic Inference
AI 9 | Bayesian Network and Probabilistic Inference
 
Machine learning Lecture 1
Machine learning Lecture 1Machine learning Lecture 1
Machine learning Lecture 1
 
Kruskal's algorithm
Kruskal's algorithmKruskal's algorithm
Kruskal's algorithm
 
CptS 440 / 540 Artificial Intelligence
CptS 440 / 540 Artificial IntelligenceCptS 440 / 540 Artificial Intelligence
CptS 440 / 540 Artificial Intelligence
 
PCA and LDA in machine learning
PCA and LDA in machine learningPCA and LDA in machine learning
PCA and LDA in machine learning
 
MIT 6.S091: Introduction to Deep Reinforcement Learning (Deep RL) by Lex Fridman
MIT 6.S091: Introduction to Deep Reinforcement Learning (Deep RL) by Lex FridmanMIT 6.S091: Introduction to Deep Reinforcement Learning (Deep RL) by Lex Fridman
MIT 6.S091: Introduction to Deep Reinforcement Learning (Deep RL) by Lex Fridman
 
Branch and bound technique
Branch and bound techniqueBranch and bound technique
Branch and bound technique
 
Bayesian Networks - A Brief Introduction
Bayesian Networks - A Brief IntroductionBayesian Networks - A Brief Introduction
Bayesian Networks - A Brief Introduction
 
Lecture 21 problem reduction search ao star search
Lecture 21 problem reduction search ao star searchLecture 21 problem reduction search ao star search
Lecture 21 problem reduction search ao star search
 
Ai lecture 7(unit02)
Ai lecture  7(unit02)Ai lecture  7(unit02)
Ai lecture 7(unit02)
 
Planning
PlanningPlanning
Planning
 
Air Cargo transport
 Air Cargo transport Air Cargo transport
Air Cargo transport
 
Reinforcement learning, Q-Learning
Reinforcement learning, Q-LearningReinforcement learning, Q-Learning
Reinforcement learning, Q-Learning
 
Ada boost
Ada boostAda boost
Ada boost
 

Semelhante a Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture3-Part1

The SimpleFPS Planning Domain: A PDDL Benchmark for Proactive NPCs
The SimpleFPS Planning Domain: A PDDL Benchmark for Proactive NPCsThe SimpleFPS Planning Domain: A PDDL Benchmark for Proactive NPCs
The SimpleFPS Planning Domain: A PDDL Benchmark for Proactive NPCs
Stavros Vassos
 
09 logic programming
09 logic programming09 logic programming
09 logic programming
saru40
 
Mathematical sciences-paper-ii
Mathematical sciences-paper-iiMathematical sciences-paper-ii
Mathematical sciences-paper-ii
knowledgesociety
 
스코프와 실행문맥
스코프와 실행문맥스코프와 실행문맥
스코프와 실행문맥
우영 주
 

Semelhante a Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture3-Part1 (20)

Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture2-Part2
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture2-Part2Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture2-Part2
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture2-Part2
 
Planning
PlanningPlanning
Planning
 
Orsi Vldb11
Orsi Vldb11Orsi Vldb11
Orsi Vldb11
 
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture4-Part1
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture4-Part1Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture4-Part1
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture4-Part1
 
Query Rewriting and Optimization for Ontological Databases
Query Rewriting and Optimization for Ontological DatabasesQuery Rewriting and Optimization for Ontological Databases
Query Rewriting and Optimization for Ontological Databases
 
Gottlob ICDE 2011
Gottlob ICDE 2011Gottlob ICDE 2011
Gottlob ICDE 2011
 
The SimpleFPS Planning Domain: A PDDL Benchmark for Proactive NPCs
The SimpleFPS Planning Domain: A PDDL Benchmark for Proactive NPCsThe SimpleFPS Planning Domain: A PDDL Benchmark for Proactive NPCs
The SimpleFPS Planning Domain: A PDDL Benchmark for Proactive NPCs
 
Sets, maps and hash tables (Java Collections)
Sets, maps and hash tables (Java Collections)Sets, maps and hash tables (Java Collections)
Sets, maps and hash tables (Java Collections)
 
Scala Collections : Java 8 on Steroids
Scala Collections : Java 8 on SteroidsScala Collections : Java 8 on Steroids
Scala Collections : Java 8 on Steroids
 
Classical Planning
Classical PlanningClassical Planning
Classical Planning
 
Classical Planning
Classical PlanningClassical Planning
Classical Planning
 
21CSC206T_UNIT 5.pptx artificial intelligence
21CSC206T_UNIT 5.pptx artificial intelligence21CSC206T_UNIT 5.pptx artificial intelligence
21CSC206T_UNIT 5.pptx artificial intelligence
 
Classical And Htn Planning
Classical And Htn PlanningClassical And Htn Planning
Classical And Htn Planning
 
TR tabling presentation_2010_09
TR tabling presentation_2010_09TR tabling presentation_2010_09
TR tabling presentation_2010_09
 
09 logic programming
09 logic programming09 logic programming
09 logic programming
 
Parametric surface visualization in Directx 11 and C++
Parametric surface visualization in Directx 11 and C++Parametric surface visualization in Directx 11 and C++
Parametric surface visualization in Directx 11 and C++
 
Mathematical sciences-paper-ii
Mathematical sciences-paper-iiMathematical sciences-paper-ii
Mathematical sciences-paper-ii
 
스코프와 실행문맥
스코프와 실행문맥스코프와 실행문맥
스코프와 실행문맥
 
Good functional programming is good programming
Good functional programming is good programmingGood functional programming is good programming
Good functional programming is good programming
 
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture5-Part1
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture5-Part1Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture5-Part1
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture5-Part1
 

Mais de Stavros Vassos

Mais de Stavros Vassos (7)

Pathfinding - Part 3: Beyond the basics
Pathfinding - Part 3: Beyond the basicsPathfinding - Part 3: Beyond the basics
Pathfinding - Part 3: Beyond the basics
 
Pathfinding - Part 2: Examples in Unity
Pathfinding - Part 2: Examples in UnityPathfinding - Part 2: Examples in Unity
Pathfinding - Part 2: Examples in Unity
 
Pathfinding - Part 1: Α* heuristic search
Pathfinding - Part 1: Α* heuristic searchPathfinding - Part 1: Α* heuristic search
Pathfinding - Part 1: Α* heuristic search
 
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture1-Part1
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture1-Part1Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture1-Part1
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture1-Part1
 
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture4-Part2
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture4-Part2Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture4-Part2
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture4-Part2
 
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture1-Part2
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture1-Part2Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture1-Part2
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture1-Part2
 
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture6-Part2
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture6-Part2Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture6-Part2
Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture6-Part2
 

Último

Architecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native ApplicationsArchitecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native Applications
WSO2
 
Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024
Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024
Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024
Victor Rentea
 
+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
?#DUbAI#??##{{(☎️+971_581248768%)**%*]'#abortion pills for sale in dubai@
 
Why Teams call analytics are critical to your entire business
Why Teams call analytics are critical to your entire businessWhy Teams call analytics are critical to your entire business
Why Teams call analytics are critical to your entire business
panagenda
 

Último (20)

Architecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native ApplicationsArchitecting Cloud Native Applications
Architecting Cloud Native Applications
 
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemkeProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
ProductAnonymous-April2024-WinProductDiscovery-MelissaKlemke
 
EMPOWERMENT TECHNOLOGY GRADE 11 QUARTER 2 REVIEWER
EMPOWERMENT TECHNOLOGY GRADE 11 QUARTER 2 REVIEWEREMPOWERMENT TECHNOLOGY GRADE 11 QUARTER 2 REVIEWER
EMPOWERMENT TECHNOLOGY GRADE 11 QUARTER 2 REVIEWER
 
DBX First Quarter 2024 Investor Presentation
DBX First Quarter 2024 Investor PresentationDBX First Quarter 2024 Investor Presentation
DBX First Quarter 2024 Investor Presentation
 
Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024
Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024
Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024
 
FWD Group - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
FWD Group - Insurer Innovation Award 2024FWD Group - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
FWD Group - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
 
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
2024: Domino Containers - The Next Step. News from the Domino Container commu...
 
[BuildWithAI] Introduction to Gemini.pdf
[BuildWithAI] Introduction to Gemini.pdf[BuildWithAI] Introduction to Gemini.pdf
[BuildWithAI] Introduction to Gemini.pdf
 
+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
+971581248768>> SAFE AND ORIGINAL ABORTION PILLS FOR SALE IN DUBAI AND ABUDHA...
 
Biography Of Angeliki Cooney | Senior Vice President Life Sciences | Albany, ...
Biography Of Angeliki Cooney | Senior Vice President Life Sciences | Albany, ...Biography Of Angeliki Cooney | Senior Vice President Life Sciences | Albany, ...
Biography Of Angeliki Cooney | Senior Vice President Life Sciences | Albany, ...
 
"I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ...
"I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ..."I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ...
"I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ...
 
ICT role in 21st century education and its challenges
ICT role in 21st century education and its challengesICT role in 21st century education and its challenges
ICT role in 21st century education and its challenges
 
Apidays New York 2024 - Passkeys: Developing APIs to enable passwordless auth...
Apidays New York 2024 - Passkeys: Developing APIs to enable passwordless auth...Apidays New York 2024 - Passkeys: Developing APIs to enable passwordless auth...
Apidays New York 2024 - Passkeys: Developing APIs to enable passwordless auth...
 
Apidays New York 2024 - APIs in 2030: The Risk of Technological Sleepwalk by ...
Apidays New York 2024 - APIs in 2030: The Risk of Technological Sleepwalk by ...Apidays New York 2024 - APIs in 2030: The Risk of Technological Sleepwalk by ...
Apidays New York 2024 - APIs in 2030: The Risk of Technological Sleepwalk by ...
 
Exploring Multimodal Embeddings with Milvus
Exploring Multimodal Embeddings with MilvusExploring Multimodal Embeddings with Milvus
Exploring Multimodal Embeddings with Milvus
 
Why Teams call analytics are critical to your entire business
Why Teams call analytics are critical to your entire businessWhy Teams call analytics are critical to your entire business
Why Teams call analytics are critical to your entire business
 
Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...
Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...
Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...
 
Exploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone Processors
Exploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone ProcessorsExploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone Processors
Exploring the Future Potential of AI-Enabled Smartphone Processors
 
Cyberprint. Dark Pink Apt Group [EN].pdf
Cyberprint. Dark Pink Apt Group [EN].pdfCyberprint. Dark Pink Apt Group [EN].pdf
Cyberprint. Dark Pink Apt Group [EN].pdf
 
MS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectors
MS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectorsMS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectors
MS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectors
 

Intro to AI STRIPS Planning & Applications in Video-games Lecture3-Part1

  • 1. Stavros Vassos, University of Athens, Greece stavrosv@di.uoa.gr May 2012 INTRODUCTION TO AI STRIPS PLANNING .. and Applications to Video-games!
  • 2. Course overview 2  Lecture 1: Game-inspired competitions for AI research, AI decision making for non-player characters in games  Lecture 2: STRIPS planning, state-space search  Lecture 3: Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL), using an award winning planner to solve Sokoban  Lecture 4: Planning graphs, domain independent heuristics for STRIPS planning  Lecture 5: Employing STRIPS planning in games: SimpleFPS, iThinkUnity3D, SmartWorkersRTS  Lecture 6: Planning beyond STRIPS
  • 3. STRIPS planning 3  Given:  Initial state
  • 4. STRIPS planning 4  Given:  Initial state  Goal
  • 5. STRIPS planning 5  Given:  Initial state  Goal  Available actions
  • 6. STRIPS planning 6  Given:  Initial state  Goal  Available actions  Find: A sequence of actions that achieves the goal  E.g.: [Left, Down, Left, Up, …]
  • 7. Planning Domain Description Language 7  Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL)  Formal language for specifying planning problems  Formal syntax similar to a programming language  Includes STRIPS and ADL, and many more features  Provides the ground for performing a direct comparison between planning techniques and evaluating against classes of problems
  • 8. Planning Domain Description Language 8  Blocks world domain  Initial state: s0 Α Β Α Β C C  Goal: g s0 g  Available actions: moving a block  from the table to the top of another block  from the top of another block to the table  from the top of one block to the top of another block
  • 9. Planning Domain Description Language 9  Init( On(Α,Table)  On(Β,Table)  On(C,Table)  Clear(Α)  Clear(Β)  Clear(C) )  Goal( On(Α,Β)  On(Β,C) )  Action( Move(b,x,y), PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b)  Clear(y) EFFECTS: On(b,y)  Clear(x)  On(b,x)  Clear(y) )  Action( MoveToTable(b,x), PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b) EFFECTS: On(b,Table)  Clear(x)  On(b,x) )
  • 10. Planning Domain Description Language 10  Init( On(Α,Table)  On(Β,Table)  On(C,Table) …)  (:init  Clear(Α)  Clear(Β)  Clear(C) )  (:goal …)  Goal( On(Α,Β)  On(Β,C) )  (:action …)  Action( Move(b,x,y), PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b)(:action …)   Clear(y) EFFECTS: On(b,y)  Clear(x)  On(b,x)  Clear(y) )  Action( MoveToTable(b,x), PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b) EFFECTS: On(b,Table)  Clear(x)  On(b,x) )
  • 11. Planning Domain Description Language 11  Init( On(Α,Table)  On(Β,Table)  On(C,Table) …)  (:init  Clear(Α)  Clear(Β)  Clear(C) )  (:goal …)  Goal( On(Α,Β)  On(Β,C) )  (:action …)  Action( Move(b,x,y), PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b)(:action …)   Clear(y) EFFECTS: On(b,y)  Clear(x)  On(b,x)  Clear(y) ) (:objects …)  Action( MoveToTable(b,x), PRECONDITIONS: On(b,x)  Clear(b)(:predicates …)  EFFECTS: On(b,Table)  Clear(x)  On(b,x) )
  • 12. Planning Domain Description Language 12  (:init …)  (:goal …)  (:action …) DOMAIN  (:action …) PROBLEM  (:objects …)  (:predicates …)
  • 13. Planning Domain Description Language 13  (:init …)  (:goal …)  (:action …) DOMAIN  (:action …) PROBLEM  (:objects …)  (:predicates …)
  • 14. Planning Domain Description Language 14  (:init …)  (:goal …)  (:action …) DOMAIN  (:action …) PROBLEM  (:objects …)  (:predicates …)
  • 15. Planning Domain Description Language 15  (:predicates …)  (:action …) DOMAIN  (:action …)  (:objects …)  (:init …) PROBLEM  (:goal …)
  • 16. Planning Domain Description Language 16  On(A,B)  (on a b)  On(A,B)  (not (on a b))  On(A,B)  On(B,C)  (and (on a b) (on b c))  On(x,y)  (on ?x ?y)
  • 17. The blocks world example in PDDL 17  Blocks world domain  Available predicates (:predicates …)  Available actions (:action …)
  • 18. The blocks world example in PDDL 18  Blocks world domain  Available predicates (:predicates (on ?x ?y) (clear ?x) )
  • 19. The blocks world example in PDDL 19  Blocks world domain  Available action (:action move :parameters (?b ?x ?y) :precondition (and (on ?b ?x) (clear ?b) (clear ?y)) :effect (…) )
  • 20. The blocks world example in PDDL 20  Blocks world domain  Available action (:action move-to-table :parameters (?b ?x) :precondition (…) :effect (…) )
  • 21. The blocks world example in PDDL 21  Blocks world problem  Available objects (:objects …)  Initial state (:init …)  Goal (:goal …)
  • 22. The blocks world example in PDDL 22  Blocks world domain  Available objects (:objects a b c table )
  • 23. The blocks world example in PDDL 23  Blocks world domain  Initial state (:init (on a table) (clear a) (on b table) (clear b) Α Β Γ (on c table) (clear c) )
  • 24. The blocks world example in PDDL 24  Blocks world domain  Goal (:goal Α (and (on a b) (on b c) ) Β Γ )
  • 25. The blocks world example in PDDL 25 blocks-domain.txt: blocks-problem1.txt: (define (domain gripper) (define (problem gripper1) (:requirements :strips) (:domain gripper) (:predicates (on ?x ?y) (clear ?x)) (:objects a b c table) (:action move (:init :parameters (?b ?x ?y) (on a table) (on b table) (on c table) :precondition (and (on ?b ?x) (clear ?b) (clear ?y)) (clear a) (clear b) (clear c) :effect (and (not (on ?b ?x)) ) (not (clear ?y)) (on ?b ?y) (:goal (and (on a b) (on b c))) (clear ?x))) ) …
  • 26. Using PDDL planners 26  Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL)  International Planning Competition 1998 – today  SAT Plan  TL Plan Planning problems in PDDL, e.g., Blocks  FF world, Storage, Trucks, …  BlackBox  SHOP2  TALPlanner Direct comparison between … planning techniques! E.g., evaluation of heuristics, …
  • 27. Using PDDL planners: Blocks world 27  blackbox –o blocks-domain.txt –f blocks-problem1.txt ---------------------------------------------------- Begin plan Α Β C 1 (move b table c) 2 (move a table b) End plan ---------------------------------------------------- Α Β C
  • 28. Using PDDL planners: Blocks world 28  blackbox –o blocks-domain.txt –f blocks-problem2.txt ---------------------------------------------------- Begin plan G 1 (move e b d) D E F 2 (move b table e) Α Β C 3 (move g f table) 4 (move f c g) 5 (move b e c) Α 6 (move e d f) Β 7 (move d a e) C 8 (move b c a) D E 9 (move c table d) F 10 (move b a c) G 11 (move a table b) End plan
  • 29. Using PDDL planners 29  We can use blackbox (or any other off-the-self PDDL planner) for any problem we can write in PDDL!
  • 30. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 30  We can use blackbox (or any other off-the-self PDDL planner) for any problem we can write in PDDL!  Let’s do this for Sokoban
  • 31. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 31  Available predicates  Available actions  Available objects  Initial state  Goal
  • 32. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 32  Available predicates
  • 33. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 33  Available predicates  (robot-at ?loc)  (object-at ?b ?loc)
  • 34. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 34  Available predicates  (robot-at ?loc)  (object-at ?b ?loc) c4-4 c5-4 c6-4 c1-3 c2-3 c3-3 c4-3 c5-3 c6-3  Available objects c1-2 c2-2 c3-2 c4-2 c5-2  c1-1,c1-2, c2-1, … c1-1 c2-1  box1, box2
  • 35. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 35  Initial state  (robot-at c5-4)  (object-at box1 c3-3) c4-4 c6-4  (object-at box2 c4-3) c1-3 c2-3 c5-3 c6-3 c1-2 c2-2 c3-2 c4-2 c5-2 c1-1 c2-1
  • 36. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 36  Available actions  move(?from ?to ?dir) :precondition ( )
  • 37. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 37  Available actions  move(?from ?to ?dir) :precondition (and (robot-at ?from) (adjacent ?from ?to ?dir) (empty ?to) )
  • 38. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 38  Available actions  move(?from ?to ?dir) :effect (and )
  • 39. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 39  Available actions  move(?from ?to ?dir) :effect (and (empty ?from) (robot-at ?to) (not (empty ?to)) (not (robot-at ?from)) )
  • 40. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 40  Available predicates  (robot-at ?loc)  (object-at ?b ?loc)  (adjacent ?from ?to ?dir)  (empty ?to)
  • 41. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 41  Initial state  (robot-at c5-4)  (object-at box1 c3-3)  (object-at box2 c4-3) c2-3 c1-2 c2-2 c3-2  (empty c1-1) c2-1  (empty c2-1)  (empty c1-2)  (empty c2-2) …
  • 42. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 42  Initial state  (robot-at c5-4)  (object-at box1 c3-3)  (object-at box2 c4-3) c2-3 c1-2 c2-2 c3-2  (adjacent c2-2 c3-2 right) c2-1  (adjacent c2-2 c1-2 left)  (adjacent c2-2 c2-3 up)  (adjacent c2-2 c2-1 down) …
  • 43. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 43  Available actions  push(?rloc ?bloc ?floc ?dir ?b)
  • 44. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 44  Available actions  push(?rloc ?bloc ?floc ?dir ?b) :precondition (and (robot-at ?rloc) (object-at ?b ?bloc) (adjacent ?rloc ?bloc ?dir) (adjacent ?bloc ?floc ?dir) (empty ?floc) )
  • 45. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 45  Available actions  push(?rloc ?bloc ?floc ?dir ?b) :effect (and (robot-at ?bloc) (object-at ?b ?floc) (empty ?rloc) (not (robot-at ?rloc)) (not (object-at ?b ?bloc)) (not (empty ?floc)) )
  • 46. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 46  Goal  (object-at box1 c4-3)  (object-at box2 c5-3) c4-4 c6-4 c1-3 c2-3 c6-3 c1-2 c2-2 c3-2 c4-2 c5-2 c1-1 c2-1
  • 47. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 47  blackbox –o sokoban-domain.txt –f sokoban-problem.txt ---------------------------------------------------- Begin plan 1 (push c4-4 c4-3 c4-2 down box1) 2 (push c4-3 c3-3 c2-3 left box2) 3 (move c3-3 c3-2 down) 4 (move c3-2 c2-2 left) 5 (move c2-2 c1-2 left) … 27 (move c2-2 c1-2 left) 28 (move c1-2 c1-3 up) 29 (push c1-3 c2-3 c3-3 right box1) 30 (push c2-3 c3-3 c4-3 right box1) End plan ----------------------------------------------------
  • 48. Using PDDL planners: SimpleGame 48  SimpleGame domain  turn(?fromd ?tod)  move(?froml ?tol ?dir)  pickup(?o ?l)  stab(?l ?knife)  shoot(?locn ?locp ?dir ?gun )
  • 49. Building your own PDDL planner 49  Pyperplan  Lightweight STRIPS planner written in Python. Developed during the planning course at Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg 2010/2011, GNU General Public License 3  https://bitbucket.org/malte/pyperplan  Source code of academic planners  BlackBox: http://www.cs.rochester.edu/u/kautz/satplan/blackbox/  FastForward: http://www.loria.fr/~hoffmanj/ff.html  FastDownward: http://www.fast-downward.org/  ANTLR Parser Generator  http://www.antlr.org/  http://www.antlr.org/grammar/1222962012944/Pddl.g
  • 50. Building your own PDDL planner 50  Quick overview of the provided PROLOG code  Good for quick prototyping ;-)
  • 51. Building your own PDDL planner 51  Quick overview of the provided PROLOG code  Works with SWI Prolog 6.x (tested with 6.0.2)  Predicates provided  parsePDDL(+DomainFile, +ProblemFile)  get_init(-InitialState)  get_goal(-Goal)  satisfies_goal(+State)  progress(+State, -Action, -NextState)  h(+State, -Value)  {dfs,astar}planner(+DomainFile, +ProblemFile)
  • 52. Planning Domain Description Language 52  Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL)  International Planning Competition 1998 – today  SAT Plan  TL Plan  FF Sokoban  BlackBox  SHOP2  TALPlanner Direct comparison between … planning techniques! E.g., evaluation of heuristics, …
  • 53. Using PDDL planners 53  FastDownward [Helmert 2006]  Introduced a new type of heuristic that is not based on an empty list of negative actions  Efficient implementation of all notable forward search methods and heuristics (including the more recent ones)  Requires a number of preprocessing steps that transforms the STRIPS planning problem…
  • 54. Using PDDL planners 54  FastDownward [Helmert 2006]  Introduced a new type of heuristic that is not based on an empty list of negative actions  Efficient implementation of all notable forward search methods and heuristics (including the more recent ones)  Requires a number of preprocessing steps that transforms the STRIPS planning problem…  Can be used as a framework to evaluate forward search planning methods
  • 55. Using PDDL planners 55  FastDownward [Helmert 2006]  translate/translate.py sokoban-domain.txt sokoban.problem.txt  preprocess/preprocess < output.sas  search/downward --search SearchConfiguration < output  http://www.fast-downward.org
  • 56. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 56  search/downward --search "astar(blind())" <output
  • 57. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 57  search/downward --search "astar(goalcount())"
  • 58. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 58  search/downward --search "astar(hmax())" <output
  • 59. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 59  search/downward --search "astar(add())" <output
  • 60. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 60  search/downward --search "lazy_greedy(ff())" <output
  • 61. Using PDDL planners: Sokoban 61  Notice that the planner does not know anything about the planning problem we are solving  The heuristics we tried are domain independent  goal count  hmax  hadd  FF  We will see how each one works in Lecture 4 (after we first go over planning graphs that are needed)
  • 62. Next lecture 62  Lecture 1: Game-inspired competitions for AI research, AI decision making for non-player characters in games  Lecture 2: STRIPS planning, state-space search  Lecture 3: Planning Domain Definition Language (PDDL), using an award winning planner to solve Sokoban  Lecture 4: Planning graphs, domain independent heuristics for STRIPS planning  Lecture 5: Employing STRIPS planning in games: SimpleFPS, iThinkUnity3D, SmartWorkersRTS  Lecture 6: Planning beyond STRIPS
  • 63. Bibliography 63  Material  Artificial Intelligence: A Modern Approach 2nd Ed. Stuart Russell, Peter Norvig. Prentice Hall, 2003 Section 11.4  References  PDDL - The Planning Domain Definition Language. Drew McDermott, Malik Ghallab, Adele Howe, Craig Knoblock, Ashwin Ram, Manuela Veloso, Daniel Weld, David Wilkins. Technical report, Yale Center for Computational Vision and Control, TR-98-003, 1998.  Unifying SAT-Based and Graph-Based Planning. Henry Kautz, Bart Selman. In Proceedings of the International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI), 1999  The Fast Downward Planning System. Malte Helmert. Artificial Intelligence Research (JAIR), Vol. 26, 2006