How to automate tax compliance along the procure to pay process to ensure compliance. Various semi-automated and automated real-time and batch options included.
2. 2
Agenda
Agenda
Introductions
Common issues in the AP Process
Process issues
Disparate systems
Data and insight
Taking Control
Creating a process
Vendor Review
Integrating Systems
Automation Options
Determination
Analytics/reporting
6. 6
Proprietary and Confidential the information and materials in this document are not for use or disclosure outside of Sovos Compliance, LLC. except under express written consent.
Use Tax Issues
The burden of consumer’s use tax is on businesses within the US
Companies are responsible for tracking, accruing, reporting and demonstrating the
appropriate use tax has been paid for all major purchases
Businesses must have the ability to trace and reconcile asset purchases and the
corresponding tax paid from their General Ledger, and provide evidence of
payment to an auditor
Tax compliance is only complete when you can prove that you did the right thing!
Business must provide demonstrable proof that an item is being used outside the
auditing jurisdiction to successfully exclude the review of a particular good or
service from an audit
Challenging when a digital product or service
Challenging when you acquire assets
7. Challenges:
Manufacturing
Manufacturing is challenging because the rules as to
what items are eligible to be purchased pursuant to
special manufacturing rules (exemptions, special rates,
etc.) vary substantially from jurisdiction to jurisdiction
Type of Item: Raw Material, Machinery and Equipment,
Tools, Replacement Parts, Energy, Lubricants, etc.
Part of Manufacturing Process: R&D, Pollution Control,
Packaging, Conveyancing
Type of Facility: New, Existing, Expanding
Usage: Exclusively, Substantially, Primarily
Failure to understand the exact boundaries of these
rules and how they impact your purchase can lead to
substantial use tax audit risk!
8. Challenges: Retailers
Store build-out – software systems
Tracking movement of physical of assets
across jurisdictions
Promotional items / damaged items
Give away items and samples
Displays
Advertising and fliers
9. 9
Proprietary and Confidential the information and materials in this document are not for use or disclosure outside of Sovos Compliance, LLC. except under express written consent.
Challenges: Purchasing Org
Centralized vs decentralized
purchasing organization
Generally tax experts not involved
in the process
Manages all purchases and
payment approvals
A/P clerks making/assessing tax
outcomes
May sit outside the U.S.
High volumes with goals of quickly
processing and paying invoices
12. “A successful tax professional
of the future will be highly
proficient in data analysis,
statistics, and technology, as
well as process improvement and
change management.”
PwC – The Tax Professional of the Future
No Process Manual Process
Varying
Processes
Lack of Data
Insight
AP
Challenges
13. The Risky Approach
Multiple purchasing avenues
Multiple groups/people making
purchasing decisions
No review process or oversight
Multiple, continuing issues on audit
No Process Manual Process
Varying
Processes
Lack of Data
Insight
AP
Challenges
14. Taking some control
Pulling purchase info, using Excel or
something similar to review data
The review is ad hoc (perhaps some
parameters, e.g. invoice amount, tax
amount or no tax, etc)
Inconsistent
Doesn’t provide upstream controls
No Process Manual Process
Varying
Processes
Lack of Data
Insight
AP
Challenges
15. Recurring – processed through
standard AP flow
• Software subscriptions
• Raw materials
• Recurring services/maintenance
One Time – non-standard AP flow
• P-Cards
• Office Supplies
• Employee Expense Accounts
Disparate systems
• Multiple ERPs
• Purchasing systems outside ERP
No Process Manual Process
Varying
Processes
Lack of Data
Insight
AP
Challenges
16. Multiple systems where data is isolated
No consistency in available data
Data lacks sufficient details
Teams unwilling to “share” data or
information
No review of available data
Lack of sufficient tools to analyze and
mine information
No Process Manual Process
Varying
Processes
Lack of Data
Insight
AP
Challenges
17. www.sovos.com
17
Polling Question 3
Which group in your organization manages your AP tax compliance process?
A. The AP team
B. The Tax department
C. Finance
D. Multiple departments
E. I don’t know
19. 19
Accounts Payable
Automation
Tax Matrix
Look Up Tool
Invoice
Verification
Automated Tax
Tolerance
Processing
Evaluate Receipts
Settlement (ERS)
Tax Matrix:
Internal tool that puts tax
information in the hands of the AP
team
Advantages
• Inserts a process/logic flow
• Removes some of the guess work out
of the AP process
• Ensures the tax dept has influence on
AP decisions
Concerns/Limitations
• Static tool – must be continually
reviewed and updated to remain useful
• Human intervention and decision is still
required with each invoice
20. 20
Proprietary and Confidential the information and materials in this document are not for use or disclosure outside of Sovos Compliance, LLC. except under express written consent.
Taking Manual Decisions out of Purchasing Process
21. 21
Accounts Payable
Determination
Tax Matrix
Look Up Tool
Invoice Review
Automated Tax
Tolerance
Processing
Evaluate Receipts
Settlement (ERS)
Invoice Review:
A process of manually verifying the tax
calculation made on the invoice by your
vendor
Advantages
• Not a very complicated procedure
• Flexible, allows the you to determine which invoices
to review
• Inserts some review by the tax dept
• Can focus on problem areas or big dollar invoices
Concerns/Limitations
• Manual process
• Labor intensive
• Doesn’t review all invoices
• Review occurs after invoices paid
• Still leaves room for large differences over many
invoices
22. 22
Accounts Payable
Determination
Tax Matrix
Look Up Tool
Invoice
Verification
Automated Tax
Tolerance
Processing
Evaluate Receipts
Settlement (ERS)
Automated Tolerance Processing:
• Automated process of verifying the tax calculation
made on the invoice by your vendor;
• Utilizes a tax determination engine with current tax
rules and rates
Advantages
• Real time, batch process, or both
• Flexible, allows you to manage specific
business scenarios
• Allows all invoices to be reviewed
• Tax dept determines acceptable variances
• Robust approach that can help you identify
problem areas; vendor, cost ctr, jurisdictions,
etc
Concerns/Limitations
• The initial set up is critical
• Real time could slow AP process
• Must still set up a self-assessment process
23. 23
Accounts Payable
Determination
Tax Matrix
Look Up Tool
Invoice
Verification
Automated Tax
Tolerance
Processing
Evaluate Receipts
Settlement (ERS)
Evaluated Receipts Settlement:
• Automated process of determining tax due
and payable to seller;
• Assess vendors nexus profile
• Evaluates invoice determines taxes paid to
seller and use taxes to be accrued
Advantages
• Assures you are paying/accruing the right tax
• Has immediate positive effect on cash flow
• Puts tax determination in your hands
• Very robust approach
Concerns/Limitations
• The initial set up is critical
• Managing vendor nexus settings continually
• Not all vendors will be able to be included in
the system
24. www.sovos.com
24
Polling Question 4
What type of AP process automation do you have?
A. Full automated purchase process validation and review
B. Partial automation with some tools
C. Thank goodness for MS Excel
D. We have no AP review process
E. I don’t know
26. 26
Proprietary and Confidential the information and materials in this document are not for use or disclosure outside of Sovos Compliance, LLC. except under express written consent.
Global Tax Determination Engine
Tax Content:
• 5500 Goods/Service Codes,
• 300+ Entity/Use Codes with Exemption Logic
• Place of Supply & Situs Rule Determination
Geographic Coverage:
• 14,000 US Taxing Jurisdictions
• SST & Colorado DOR Certified Jurisdiction Look-up
• Up to Seven Jurisdictions per location (State, City, County, Districts, PIF/PUF)
• VAT determination for over 180 countries
Flexibility
• Flexible Data Editor tool for Input, Output and Allocation Rules
• Ability to Create/Modify GSCs, E/U Codes, Taxing Jurisdictions
27. 27
Proprietary and Confidential the information and materials in this document are not for use or disclosure outside of Sovos Compliance, LLC. except under express written consent.
Process automation and control options
• Real-time Automation
A direct integration between ERP/purchasing system
and Third Party tax engine for PO and A/P modules
Tax is included on purchase orders
Vendor tax is evaluated and can be short-paid
• Advantages/Disadvantages
Provides immediate tax information for forecasting
Can withhold tax amounts overcharged by vendor
improving cash flow
Requires multiple integrations if utilizing more than one
ERP/Financial engine
Implementations can be more costly
Can slow the A/P process
28. 28
Proprietary and Confidential the information and materials in this document are not for use or disclosure outside of Sovos Compliance, LLC. except under express written consent.
Batch Automation
Purchases are evaluated by tax engine at defined intervals (weekly, monthly,
other) outside of the ERP
Use tax calculations completed by tax engine, utilizing full functionality
Use tax accrual expenses are loaded back into ERP
Advantages/Disadvantages
More control of process by the Tax Dept.
Simplified cost effective and extremely flexible method for evaluating use tax
Simplified management of files from multiple ERP/financial systems
Can be combined with a real time process as well – supporting all AP systems
Does not interrupt the A/P process
Can evaluate vendor tax, but invoice has most likely been paid
Batch Determination
29. Tax Tolerance Processing
Complete a tax evaluation (tax quote)
• Validate what the vendor charged on the issued invoice. These transactions get
run as sales tax transactions through the tax engine.
• User interface then displays the original tax from the invoice as well as the
calculated value the tax engine returns, along with the $ variance and %
variance.
30. Tax Tolerance Processing
The user will then be able to filter based on their own business rules to
determine which transaction the business would want to accrue use tax on.
• (For example, some businesses may only want to look at transactions where the
tax amount is over $100 and the variance is >10%)
31. Tax Tolerance Processing (Cont.)
Determine which transaction to post back to the tax engine. The user may
select to post all transactions back to the engine, or just a subset of the
transactions that meet certain criteria.
(These transactions are then re-run as use tax transactions in the engine and
written to audit.)
After the transactions have been posted to the tax engine, the user will be able
to go back and reverse the accrual after the fact if needed.
32. 32
Tax Tolerance Processing
Creating journal entries to be uploaded back into the financial system.
The tool provides flexibility in the output format for upload.
33. 33
Proprietary and Confidential the information and materials in this document are not for use or disclosure outside of Sovos Compliance, LLC. except under express written consent.
Process Automation and Control Options
Evaluated Receipts
Settlement
Robust purchasing system;
more than tax
Eliminates vendor invoicing
and ensures correct tax
charged
Pricing determined, tax rules applied
automatically to invoice, vendor only paid for
taxes they are owed. Use tax accrued as
needed
Invoice is then sent to the tax engine real-
time
Purchaser creates the “invoice”
Electronic orders placed directly to vendor via
automated system
34. www.sovos.com
34
Polling Question 5
What are your biggest concerns for your AP tax compliance?
A. We don’t have a process
B. Under accruing taxes due
C. Overpaying tax to vendors
D. Both B & C
36. Take Away
1. Manual processes cost business both
in over payments to vendors and
interest/penalty issues during audit
2. A/P processes and use tax review is
an area where the tax dept. can
directly contribute to the bottom line
3. Automation allows resources to be
focused on strategic initiatives
4. Multiple options for process
automation available, can be tailored
to specific needs