NOTE: BE SURE TO DOWNLOAD THE DECK - THERE ARE A TON OF SPEAKER NOTES INCLUDING REFERENCES!
How will Bitcoin achieve mainstream adoption in 2016-2017? Here is our thesis.
By: Sean Walsh, Partner, Redwood City Ventures, 2016
Twitter: @SeanWalshBTC
www.redwoodcityventures.com
logistics industry development power point ppt.pdf
Bitcoins Killer App - Achieving Mainstream Adoption - Sean Walsh - DOWNLOAD FOR SPEAKER NOTES
1. Bitcoin’s Killer App
How We’ll Achieve Mainstream Adoption
BTC Miami – January 2016
Sean M. Walsh - sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
2. Sean M. Walsh
Background:
• Redwood City Ventures
• Bitcoin/Blockchain Investments (e.g. - BlockC.co)
• China/US Business & Investment Partnerships
• Previously Vice President at Bertram Capital ($1B
Silicon Valley Private Equity firm)
Contact Information:
• sean@RedwoodCityVentures.com
• Twitter: @SeanWalshBTC
• www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
3. Bitcoin – A Fascinating Intersection
Ecommerce
Monetary
Factors
Social
Networking
1. Ecommerce/Online User
Acquisition
2. Social Networking / Viral
Marketing
3. Monetary/Economic Factors
1. Monetary History
2. Market speculation
3. Foreign exchange
4. Global trade
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
4. Question…
What if Bitcoin’s “Killer App”
is not an app at all?
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
5. My Objective
1. Propose my thesis on how we can achieve mainstream
adoption for Bitcoin (in 17 minutes, or less).
Note: I see this as a product Go To Market strategy challenge
2. Walk you through my thought process for narrowing down
and identifying the most effective tactics to achieve our
goal.
My process:
1. Ask Root Questions
2. Find Key Evidence
3. Draw Actionable Conclusions
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
6. Where To Start? First Principles
1. What is the product? What is Bitcoin?
2. What is the current market situation?
3. What is our goal?
4. What is Product-Market fit?
5. What transactions can Bitcoin improve?
6. Who are the target users?
7. What resources do we have?
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
7. 1st Principle – The Current Situation?
• About 400k people with 1+ BTC
To me, these are our “Users”
• $400 per BTC (and about 100k new BTC per month until Aug.)
• 180k+ transactions per day
• 2+ Million BTC traded per month on Top 10 exchanges
• Developer turmoil (let’s ignore that for now)
• What metrics should we measure for success?
“That which is measured will improve”
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
8. 1st Principle – What Is Our Goal?
1. Reach 1 million people owning 1+ BTC
2. Add 100k new Users per month
• This requires giving people enough reason to go through the
trouble of buying $400 in BTC.
• What are those reasons going to be? We need to elicit
emotional motives that will inspire our desired actions.
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
9.
10. 1st Principle – What Is Product-Market Fit?
MP
A product that meets some burning needs of the target market(s)
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
11. 1st Principle – What Is Bitcoin?
• The best form of money ever invented
• But… what is money?
1. Unit of Account
2. Means of Exchange
3. Store of Value
• How to compare different monies? SDDRFT
1. Scarcity
2. Durability
3. Divisibility
4. Reconizability
5. Fungability
6. Transportability
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
12. 1. Scarcity: limited, predictable supply
2. Durability: won’t decay
3. Divisibility: easy to subdivide
4. Recognizability:difficult to counterfeit
5. Fungibility: units is exchangeable
6. Transportability:easy to move
They all boil down to trustworthiness of the money.
1st Principle – “Moneyness”- The 6 Characteristics of Money
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
14. S
Dur.
Div.
R
F
T
Gold = 18
S
Dur.
Div.
R
F
T
USD = 13
S
Dur.
Div.
R
F
T
Arg Peso = 10
S
Dur.
Div.
R
F
T
Frequent Flier Miles = 5
S
Dur.
Div.
R
F
T
Starbucks Cards = 6
S
Dur.
Div.
R
F
T
Cowry Shells = 11
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
16. 1st Principle – What Transactions Can Bitcoin Improve?
For now…
– forget about scalability
concerns
– focus on Go-To-Market
– focus on financial services
What are the use cases?
1. Non-correlated asset class
for storing value
2. Digital money for retail
discounts
3. Global P2P Money
Transmission
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
17. 1st Principle – What Transactions Can Bitcoin
Improve?
Note: there are thousands of use-case archetypes across these Categories.
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
Consumer
to
Business
Consumer
to
Consumer
Business
to
Business
"Financial
Transcations"
18. 1st Principle – Who Are The Target Users?
1. Investors / Savers
2. International Workers (from ~10 Countries)
3. Coupon Clippers
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
19. Target #1 – Investors / Savers
Why Bitcoin?
1. Store of Value
2. Non correlated asset class
3. Incredibly asymmetric return profile
4. SDDRFT, best form of money ever
5. Portfolio diversification: 1% - 5% target
6. Almost inconceivably scarce
7. Value is up over 5,000% in 3 years
Note: There are also over
250 Million people around
the world who own Gold
as a Store of Value.
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
24. Target #1 – The Investing Public
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
25. Target #2 – International Workers
From: USA, UK, China, Philippines, Mexico, Colombia, India,
Brazil, Argentina
Elevator Pitch:
1. Use Bitcoin to get money home quickly
2. Easily divide up your remittances among family members
3. Bitcoin is an interesting Store of Value, and is probably clobbering your home currency
4. Easy to sell Bitcoin and deposit into your home bank
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
27. Target #2 – International Workers
Graphics courtesy of http://www.visualcapitalist.com/its-official-bitcoin-was-the-top-performing-currency-of-2015/
28. Target #3 – USA Coupon Clippers
http://www.slideshare.net/InmarInc/2015-inmar-coupontrends-presentation-2014-yearendreport
29. 1st Principle – What Resources Do We
Have?
1. $400 million in annual miner revenue
2. A team of evangelists (maybe 10,000 of us?)
3. 400k people with at least 1 BTC
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
30. sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
Total TTM Miner Expense + OpEx $409,000,000
Total TTM Revenue, $ $360,000,000
% of the Industry Participants that Contribute 50%
15% of disposable expenditures $30,000,000
Target number of new users 600,000
Available User Acqusition Expense $51
Resultant Upward Price Movement 50%
Incremental Mining Industry Revenue $190,000,000
Incremental Revenue to Participants $95,000,000
Breakeven BTC Price Increase 17%
Profit to Participants $75,000,000
32. Strategies For Growth?
1. Refine the message / accelerate Word of
Mouth
- Think “Ashton Kutcher tweet”
2. People love games and contests (gamification)
3. Direct Referrals (Selling) is very scalable
4. Starting in a small geography is proven
(Boiling the ocean is difficult / quicker solution to empty-room problem)
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
33. Strategies For Growth?
STEPPS:
1. Social Currency
Koreatown bar’s nightly code word
2. Trigger Moments
Budweiser “wazzap?” campaign
3. Emotional Stimulation Level
Emotion’s polarity is secondary
4. Public Displays
Apple’s white headphones
5. Practical Value
How-to Youtube videos
6. Stories
Fundamental to humanity
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
34. Strategies For Growth
We need to think like so-called “Growth Hackers”
We need K > 1.0
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
35. User Acquisition Campaign Details
1. Can be seen as a typical user acquisition play, except that the benefits to the
industry are wildly amplified by the effect on BTC prices.
2. Funding Sources:
1. 5%-10% of mining equipment sales / mining revenue (over $30 million)
2. 2%-4% of BTC holdings of ~1,700 largest holders (over $70 million)
3. User Acquisition Channels:
1. Direct Sales
2. Online advertising
3. Sweepstakes
4. Games of Skill
4. The poetic beauty is that much of the compensation could be automated via
Blockchain applications themselves to ensure fairness and execution.
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
36. Review: What Are The “Killer Apps”?
1. A Federated User Acquisition Campaign
2. The ongoing regional monetary weakness that is likely to
intensify and spread over the next 12-months
3. Discounts for using BTC (e.g. – Fold, Purse.io)
4. A Direct Sales Execution
5. [Electronic money for 1 billion unbanked people in South America, Asia, and Africa]
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
37. Our Biggest Risks Ahead
1. Regulatory Crackdown
1. Renewed attempts at regulatory circumvention (illegal activities)
1. It’s terrible publicity to our target Users
2. It intensifies regulatory scrutiny and crackdown risk
2. Developer infighting and stalemate?
I think this is a bit of a false risk
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
38. Private Blockchains Are Not A Risk
1. There are plenty of use cases to go around
2. Refer to the early days of the World Wide Web.
3. Refer to the early days of telephone networks
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
39. Conclusion
1. Bitcoin already has a number of killer apps in the bag.
2. Let’s act like a single company seeking mainstream
adoption for our product.
– 1 million Users ( people owning 1+ BTC)
3. Let’s think more creatively about how to use our
resources (like mining revenue) to hit 1 million Users.
sean@redwoodcityventures.com - @SeanWalshBTC - www.linkedin.com/in/SeanWalsh
40. Recent Breakdown of Wallet Balances
https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/1-bitcoin-community-controls-99-bitcoin-wealth/
41. Annual Mining Industry Expenditures
Input Variables
Global Network, January, 2016 (PH) 811
Global Network, January 2015 (PH) 314
TTM Miners Retired/Failed, PH 250
Net Miners Produced, PH 747
Miner Design/Production Cost, per PH $200,000
PSU Cost, per PH $50,000
Subtotal $186,750,000
Datacenter Expansion, MW 200
Datacenter Expansion Cost, per MW $150,000
Subtotal $30,000,000
Power Cost, per MW per Year $525,600
Operating Cost, per MW per Year $262,800
TTM Average Miner Efficiency, MW/PH 0.5
TTM Average Miner Power Draw, MW 281.25
TTM Total Opex Expense, Global Network $221,737,500
Total TTM Miner + Opex Expense $408,487,500
Total TTM BTC Generated 1,200,000
TTM Average $ per BTC $300
Total TTM Revenue, $ $360,000,000
% of the industry participants that contribute 50%
15% of disposable expenditures $30,636,563
Target number of new users 600,000
Available User Acqusition Expense $51.06
Resultant upward price movement 100.00%
Incremental Mining Industry Revenue $360,000,000
Incremental Revenue to Participants $180,000,000
Breakeven BTC Price Increase 17.02%
Profit to Participants $149,363,438
Mining
Expenditure
Breakdown
K. Can you make a print view of this deck which is dark text on a white background? If not, please create a 2nd version that we can distribute to people for printing.
Note: you can make a white version of this deck for printing by clicking “Theme” in the top ribbon, and then selecting the basic white theme in your PowerPoint, like this… http://d.pr/i/10fsb
Main Points:
Part of Bitcoin’s novelty is that it’s a phenomenon that incorporates so many different movements and sub cultures. Here are 10: Politics, Monetary History, Financial/Banking Systems, Economic Theory, Market Speculation, Cryptography, Open Source Software, Peer to Peer Networking, Ecommerce, Social Networking
Without detracting form any of these fascinating dimensions, these are the 3 that resonate most strongly with me, and convinced me to focus my investment activities here.
I think the complementary interaction between these 3 dimensions is what makes Bitcoin such a captivating and explosive phenomenon.
Also, I think these three dimension are likely to contribute dramatically to mainstream adption
Main Points:
So, a funny thing… virtually all the talk you hear of “killer apps” refers to some new app, but what if it’s not an app for us this time?
What does killer app even mean? Google AdWords? Am I hot or not? Email? Tinder? Snapchat? WeChat?
To me, it means a product achieving mainstream adoption, or at least rapidly approaching it.
There are some great Bitcoin apps for after you have decided to purchase bitcoin: Coinbase, Xapo, the exchanges, ChangeTip, wallets, Fold App, Purse.io, etc, etc
A killer app convinces “the world” to adopt your product.
I see Bitcoin adoption as a 3 step process:
You reach the emotional tipping point and decide you want to buy BTC.
You buy BTC
You begin using BTC in various ways.
The obstacle is #1
Main Points:
Now, I’ve done a lot of Product Marketing over the years, so I am looking Bitcoin adoption from a Product Marketer’s perspective.
In this deck, I’ve focused on uncovering strategies and tactics to accelerate User adoption for Bitcoin.
3. My thought process here is meant to uncover some easy and efficient ways to achieve mainstream adoption.
4. It’s sort of a narrowing down process. So many things about Bitcoin are too broad, from a Product Marketing perspective. I want to get to a manageably small number of actions we can take to achieve mainstream adoption quickly.
Main Points:
As I said I start with root questions. I call them First Principles, items we probably don’t need to deconstruct any further. Here are 7 that I think matter.
It’s interesting to note that these First Principles start from 7 roughly independent directions.
However, they converge on each other, and we need to unify them with our conclusions and action plan. That’s what I’ve tried to do.
Main Points:
Here are some data points that I think matter. They capture some of the key aspects of our opportunity (to achieve mainstream adoption)
From a Product Marketing perspective, these stats are great! They’re a sign of MVP validity and much, much more.
The density of our User base is uncomfortably low, but we’ll get to that later.
Which metrics should we measure? I think these are 4 great ones. By the way, if you’re a blockchain analytics company, I want to talk to you about a project.
Note: see Appendix for further detail
Source: https://www.cryptocoinsnews.com/1-bitcoin-community-controls-99-bitcoin-wealth/
Note: there are another 400k wallets with 0.1 > 1 BTC, but most of these balances are probably not an indication of full adoption
Over 70 million per month traded in China, but fees are zero and numbers are unreliable
Main Points:
Of course, we want mainstream adoption, our proof of a killer app, but let’s quantify that.
How about 1 million people owning 1+ BTC? That’s a great psychological milestone, but also meaningful for BTC price and network density. We’ll get to that.
Note that we’ll probably want to update our goals once we hit our first milestone.
For example, the number of people owning 1+ BTC will inevitably decline as price continues to climb. So, we’d be well served to change the goal to, say $400 worth of BTC.
So, if these are the goals, what is required? We’ve got to give people enough reason to go through the trouble of buying 1 BTC.
In order for someone to take our desired actions, we need to elicit the emotional motives that will inspire said actions.
S. Skip this slide
Main Points:
This is Maslow’s Pyramid. It deals with the best way to elicit emotions, and desired actions.
But, we don’t have time for it now. Talk to me after.
Abraham Maslow (1900’s psychologist)
What are those reasons going to be? We need to elicit emotional motives that will inspire the desired actions.
Insert Maslow’s Hierarcy of Needs (https://storify.com/CLAU88HOTMAIL/maslow-s-hierarchy-of-needs)
I would argue that many of Bitcoin’s value propositions to date have been in Self-Actualization (doing the right thing for humanity, creative solutions to technical problems, political ideology).
But, we need to be selling in the SAFETY layer much lower on the pyramid (Bitcoin will protect your savings, Bitcoin will save you money, Bitcoin will protect your identity) and even Physiological (Bitcoin will save you money)
To be sure, we’ve pitched a combination of these messages, but I propose a shift in the balance toward SAFETY.
Main Points:
Moving on to our next Root Question, what is product-market fit?
Typically, a product team creates an MVP to try to hit the market need, and then rapidly iterates on it to hit PM Fit.
However, the market can evolve to appreciate the products value proposition, and achieve the same comfortable PM Fit.
Personally, I believe that we’re on the cusp of just this sort of Market evolution, one that will quickly move the Market to appreciate and adopt the Products we already have.
I will illustrate some specific ways that is likely to transpire in subsequent slides.
In other words, I believe we’ve already built a couple of “killer apps” in Bitcoin.
We just need two factors to fall into place for explosive growth:
Distill the Bitcoin sales pitch so it resonates with the mainstream audience
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUVnnJX2VjE – tutorial used
Main Points:
Yes, of course we all know what Bitcoin is.
But, let’s take a deeper look at it.
I think there are some characteristics that don’t receive enough emphasis, but that are particularly influential in our mainstream adoption thesis.
Main Points:
These are the 6 characteristics most commonly used to measure the “quality” of money, and to compare different types of money.
They range from how predictable the supply is, to counterfeit risk, to ease of transport.
Essentially, they all boil down to the trustworthiness of the money. People need to trust their money.
Main Points:
1. Score Meaning…
0 = Non existent
1 = Low
2 = Medium
3 = High
4 = Near-Perfect
2. These scores are obviously subjective, and I’ve assigned them myself. That’s why I kept each dimension limited to a 0-4 range.
3. In my analysis, 24 is the maximum score.
4. Bitcoin does pretty well. Let’s see how it compares with some other forms of money.
Main Points:
I compared Bitcoin to 6 other forms of money: USD, Starbucks Cards, Frequent Flier Miles, Cowry Shells, the Argentinian Peso, and Gold
Of course, the larger the area, the higher the quality of the money.
Don’t worry too much about this eye chart, let’s look at the next slide.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_money – Cowry Shells
Main Points:
Relatively few people in the world care, or even really think about Moneyness right now.
However, I think we’re at a global turning point, and events of 2016 are likely to inspire hundreds of millions of people to begin asking questions about money.
Some of them are going to find Bitcoin.
Let’s move on from “What is Bitcoin” to our next Root Question
Main Points:
1. I recognize there is some technical debt with the various pieces of Bitcoin software (and developer turmoil is high), but let’s set those aside.
I think progress will accelerate soon, and more importantly we simply can’t worry too much about those challenges while developing a successful Go To Market strategy.
So, let’s take a look at the spectrum of thousands of financial services use cases.
To be sure Bitcoin can be used for non-financial use cases like real-estate title transfers, document verification, birth records, etc. but let’s limit our scope for this discussion.
Main Points:
1. Here’s a pie chart representing the spectrum of financial services use cases. I’ve divided them into four broad categories…
Consumer to Business = 30% Consumer to Consumer = 20%
Business to Business = 30% “Financial Transactions” = 20%
2. In my view, we should focus on Bitcoin’s application to B2C and P2P.
3. As a side note, this is also where Bitcoin’s public blockchain makes the most sense, just like the public WWW made more sense than the countless walled-gardens and Intranets back in the early days of the internet. In both cases, the value of the, and low barriers to entry for network participants, are absolutely critical for success.
4. That said, I see plenty of space for public and private blockchains to co-exist. They naturally apply to different use cases, and frankly I think that each will help the other as they progress through stages of growth and popularity.
Even R3 (Todd McDaniel?) recently articulated this very point, that public and private blockchains are not “enemies” or even “frenemies”, they are allies addressing complimentary financial services use cases
There are many use cases for both types of blockchain systems, but I predict a single dominant public blockchain just like the WWW.
Main Points:
I propose focusing on these three target markets until we reach 600k new Users
The Countries: Mexico, USA, UK, China, Philippines, India, Brazil, Argentina, Columbia. More on that in a minute.
Let’s dig into the first target, investors / savers
Important dimensions to consider when defining a target market:
Country of residence?
Were you born in a different country?
Have a credit card?
Have a bank account?
Have a dangerous local currency?
How many people fall into this cohort? How many of them have internet access?
Have a smartphone?
Main Points:
We all know what a investor / saver is.
Here is the value proposition to them, imo.
Let’s look at some details behind these items…
Note: see Appendix for further detail
K. Also, please calculate the exact growth rate Jan 1 2013 to Jan 1 2016
calculate the growth % of the “market capitalization”
exclude 4 million coins for those that are “dead” meaning lost of inactive for over 3 years because they are not a useful part of the monetary base
roughly, this should be 6M*$14 to 11M*$400 which is a growth rate of 5,100% (52 times growth)
www.bitcoinwatch.com lists total BTC outstanding
Bitcoin is basically a tech stock, and we should pursue all tech stock investors
Main Points:
This is John Exter. He was president of the New York Federal Reserve Bank in the mid-1990’s
He was very focused on “Moneyness”, though I doubt he used the same term.
He produced this inverted pyramid to compare different forms of value, sort of like the SDDRFT I previously mentioned.
I seem him as sort of a “ghost of Christmas past” that will be paying visits to global investors with increasing frequency in the coming months
OK. That’s investors/savers. A killer app just dying to happen in then next year, or so. Next target – International workers…
John Exter and a modern adaptation of his pyramid of assets
He was president of the New York Federal Reserve Bank in the mid 1900’s
Main Points:
Here’s another target market that I believe can help us hit mainstream penetration, International Workers.
We actually have been targeting these people, but maybe we can refine our message to be more persuasive…
Store of value vs. home currency
Transportability of money
Tax advantages
3. Let’s take a closer look at this target market.
Sources: http://www.oecd.org/els/mig/World-Migration-in-Figures.pdf (page 6 of 6 of PDF) and http://www.oecd.org/els/mig/dioc.htm
Sidenote: countries w/ most people living overseas – nice premade chart http://blogs-images.forbes.com/niallmccarthy/files/2016/01/20160113__Living_Abroad_Forbes.jpg
Main Points:
OK. It’s about 30million adults. Where are these people from?
This is about 10% of the global total. The Total emigrant worker population is about 250 million globally
I think there is an interesting correlation between this emigrant workforce population and weakness in home currencies
http://www.outline-world-map.com/map-images-original/political-white-transparent-thin-world-map-b5a.png
http://www.oecd.org/els/mig/World-Migration-in-Figures.pdf
Main Points:
I don’t want to get caught up in the short term trends of Bitcoin prices, but let’s take a broader look at a number of global currencies and how they performed in 2015.
Look at the weakness of these currencies from my target markets. Forget about Bitcoin. Let’s just say BTC stays flat in USD terms…. They’re getting crushed vs USD.
These people are starving for ways to preserve their purchasing power.
OK. Let’s move on to Coupon Clippers…
Graphics courtesy of http://www.visualcapitalist.com/its-official-bitcoin-was-the-top-performing-currency-of-2015/
Main Points:
OK. Here’s my third target. It has Bitcoin written all over it.
100 million US adults use coupons frequently. They redeem an average of 28 coupons every year.
Look at this coupon redemption total… that’s almost 3 BILLION coupons per year.
This seems like a no-brainer target for Bitcoin products like Fold and Purse.io.
Try to relate adecdote about couponer woman on my flight down to Miami. “I’m in Starbucks CONSTANTLY!”. Interestingly, she thought it was too good to be true.
Let’s move on to our final 1st Principle...
Per http://retailfeedback.com/storeservery.html , 32 million American adults shop at a grocery store every day, that’s 1 in 7 adults. And, 50% of them clip coupons of one type or another.
I don’t know if this is limited to the US, or not
So, if 50% of American adults clip coupons, that is about 100 million adults. According to chart above, the average adult coupon user redeems 28 coupons per year.
What’s more, according to http://blog.accessdevelopment.com/ultimate-collection-coupon-statistics , coupon use is steady through time and through younger demographics.
Going after this target internationally will require countries that also have a secondary market for gift cards
http://www.slideshare.net/InmarInc/2015-inmar-coupontrends-presentation-2014-yearendreport
Source: http://go.inmar.com/rs/inmar/images/Inmar_2014_Coupon_Trends_Report.pdf
Main Points:
What resources do we have to achieve our goal?
Of course we have many collective resources, but these are the most valuable of them with respect to our objective here.
There’s another big resource which is the approximately 1,700 people that collectively own 6 million BTC
And another, which is the Negative Elasticity Curve that Bitcoin exhibits
But what I want to show you next is a simple model that we ran regarding annual miner revenue…
Main Points:
The mining industry actually makes an astonishing amount of money for such a young industry.
But, all that equipment and mining revenue is getting dumped right back into more mining gear.
This is quite destructive to the value of pre-existing hardware. The marginal ROI is actually quite low because of this.
Now, I understand that we’ve spent the last couple years catching up to the latest chip technology (16nm).
But, looking forward, is there something else that we could invest all this revenue into that would have a better ROI.
I think there is.
This is how we fund a federated User acquisition campaign.
How would that work? Let me explain the basics.
Why would Bitcoin prices go up in this scenario? Because we’re currently in dynamic equilibrium with about 400k 1+ BTC owners. Plus, we’ve got negative elacticity, and a thinly traded market. Plus, the halving.
Now, let’s take a look at an ROI analysis...
Coupled with the upcoming halving and the thinly traded market and the negative elacticity curve for Bitcoin prices, I think a a conservative effect of a $30 Million User Acquisition campaign is 100% increase in BTC price
Note: see Appendix for further detail and exact figures
Main Points:
Here are six ROI scenarios based on the resultant increase in Bitcoin price (from the 600k new users)
Break-even is at 17%, but if you believe prices double (which I don’t think is unreasonable), then investors’ make $150million net profit.
So, what would this user acquisition campaign look like? Let’s cover a couple of prerequisite User acquisition considerations first…
ROI of Marginal User Growth
What does a new user cost? We have over $50 per user to play with
Is it linear for 600k users? Let’s conservatively assume so
What is a new user worth?
Depends on how steep the elasticity curve is, but even 50k new users/month would easily drive prices up 10% month
Marginal ROI of $100 worth of mining power vs. $100 worth of user acquisition.
User acquisition will increase BTC value, and thereby all of your previously manufactured miners.
Miner production creates more capex that someone is going to sell BTC to repay (putting a downward pressure on price), plus it dilutes the value (earning potential) of all your preexisting miners.
It’s vicious cycle vs. a virtuous cycle.
http://www.extendoffice.com/documents/excel/2353-excel-format-axis-millions.html - formating axis for thousands and millions
Bitcoin jumped to “Global” very quickly after Satoshi sent that first transaction to Hal Finney. This is very good in many ways, as it supports the decentralized nature of Bitcoin, etc. But, it makes achieving a meaningful network density any any single geographic area difficult. It’s that network density that achieves critical mass, increases the viral growth coefficient, and leads to large-scale exponential growth. This is a problem with online/mobile dating businesses, social networks, and online marketplaces. The empty room problem must be solved immediately to allow for continued growth. The well established go to market strategy by these startups is to greatly limit their geographic range until a threshold user density is reached. All company efforts go into a tiny area of the company’s desired TAM.
I believe we need to focus on the social network aspects of Bitcoin and work to stimulate more rapid viral growth, probably through new incentive structures.
The mining incentive was/is a brilliant design element for ensuring Blockchain security proportional to market capitalization, but mainstream Users will not buy and operate miners.
I see Bitcoin’s growth as a bit of an ocean boiling attempt. We’re a bit stuck out in the Atlantic right now. Bitcoin has so many use cases, to so many different target markets, it has been difficult for us to limit our focus, and figure out where to focus our efforts first.
Look at how Facebook started:
Harvard
Ivy League Schools
A few more schools
All Colleges
USA
Global
Published in 2013
These are the characteristics that determine how effectively a message (of any kind be it marketing, joke, rumor, policy guideline) will be transmitted
We need to refine our value proposition, and figure out the right combination of talking points that will increase the viral coefficient of our message, allowing it to propagate effectively and productively through our target markets.
How many people have you convinced to use Bitcoin? Show of hands… how many people have convinced at least 2 people? 10 people? 20 people? Have any of your converts brought in new users? What can we learn from the direct sales business model here?
Direct Selling could easily become a Bitcoin killer app. The reason is that a large part of the necessary incentive structure is inherently in place… it’s the value of Bitcoin. As more people are introduced to BTC and begin to buy it, the value will increase rewarding “upstream sales agents” that are previous buyers of BTC.
Main Points:
This is the key to viral growth (social networks, marketplaces, etc)
I suspect that our “# of Invites” is adequate, but the “Conversion %” is low because our sales pitch is confusing to the mainstream and because they don’t quite yet see the profound value of diversification and sound money.
Now, let’s look a the User acquisition campaign…
What are a couple of the most successful open-source, decentralized applications and what drove their mainstream adoption? Mozilla, Wikipedia
Main Points:
There are over 6 million BTC owned by those 1,700 large holders, or $2.4B worth
3% of the 6 million BTC is 180,000 BTC, or about $72 million at current prices
This yields $100 million for User Acquisition campaign…
if we budget $50 per new User, that’s 2 million new Users
I think the halving earns a killer-app honorable mention, as it is/will undoubtedly stimulate a virtuous cycle of price appreciation, positive publicity, and User adoption.
This is further accentuated by the negative elasticity curve that Bitcoin exhibits.
I couldn’t delete #5, but in reality it’s just not a “killer app” by most definitions as it lacks the immediate motive force to drive explosive adoption in the near-term
It’s epic “moneyness” as the world continues to lose purchasing power in their local fiat currencies.
I think developer stalemate is a false risk because of the industry-wide mobilized action that I have seen in the past week in response to a single developer quitting Bitcoin in frustration.
I believe the quiet majority is powerful, and has awakened.
(see Veritaseum paper on AT&T early days)
#2 means designing and executing a federated Go To Market Campaign
This deck is essentially an introduction to what could be our winning strategies.
The next step is to drill into the execution details, and get busy.
Appendix for slide – “1st Principle – The Current Situation?”
Appendix for slide – Annual Mining Calculations
Appendix for slide – “Target #1 – The Investing Public”
Further, I believe that Bitcoin’s average market capitalization appreciation exceeds 1,000% annually. Need to run the numbers on this.