SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 2
Baixar para ler offline
Silicon Valley Agile Development & Manufacturing Case Study Series
BESTRONICS & WOWCLOWD:
A Unique Product, An Aggressive Budget and A Lot of Uncertainty
How Early Stage Partnership with Agile Manufacturing Partners Achieved
Time-to-Market Goals to Develop a Highly Innovative Solution for Network Testing
Silicon Valley Regional Economic Development Initiative
WowClowd was built around a game-changing concept that could
transform network cable installation and testing from a “coffee
stained paper process” to a secure and cloud-based process en-
abled by a purpose-built, hand-held Bluetooth device.
Chris Gille, Operations VP for of WowClowd, describes his company
as software savvy and deeply experienced in the design and inte-
gration of cable systems. They had no experience however, in the
development and manufacturing of a physical device. With no viable
manufacturing options near their headquarters in Nebraska, Gille
opted to partner with Silicon Valley-based contract manufacturer
Bestronics at an unusually early stage, the idea and concept phase,
to help bring the WowClowd product to market.
“WowClowd has extensive entrepreneurial product development
experience,” said Gille. “We can identify customer needs, determine
how to solve them, validate them, and then field test to tweak and
refine a solution feature set. What we didn’t have was the ability to
understand how design decisions would impact manufacturing cost
or time trade-offs or add complexity to critical trade testing require-
ments.”
Gille explained that the product would require a particularly sophisti-
“Silicon Valley
offers unique access
to an extraordinary
breadth of
technology skills...
You can get the right
product to market in-
finitely faster.”
- Ron Menigoz, CTO
at Bestronics
cated, rugged design. “It’s a small form factor device housing expensive electronics that an operator may toss
in with a box of tools, or hang from a belt loop as he or she climbs a ladder in the course of their daily work.
This product needed to be able to take a beating.” Not only was the WowClowd product new to the market,
it required some unique components. One key element was highly sophisticated testers that would leverage
the power of smartphones and the cloud. To accomplish this effectively, the design specs called for a techni-
cal solution that did yet exist in the market.
Leveraging Silicon Valley’s Agile Development & Manufacturing Network
Bestronics quickly engaged industrial design company JDID product design + development and electronic
engineering company Ansync Labs at the design specification stage to collaborate on research and develop-
ment. These partners in turn brought in additional expertise, i.e. low volume injection molders, tooling shops,
etc. as needed. With the full concept to production development schedule in mind, Bestronics coordinated
collaboration between the engineering groups, external supply chain component providers and test partners
involved at each stage of the development process.
Silicon Valley Agile Development & Manufacturing Case Study Series
Silicon Valley Regional Economic Development Initiative
Gille contrasted the quicker time to market process he experienced through early collaboration with the Be-
stronics team with more typical manufacturing processes. “We didn’t move from design documentation to
quality testing to production to customer shipment, as usual. We went from concept to alpha to beta, then to
pre-production while getting and responding to feedback from customers throughout the process. We even
went through a couple of different board spins that were driven by functional changes we would prototype.” He
continued, “using the input of each partner right from the R&D phase, we could balance each feature decision
or customer input based on its impact to cost or time delays in manufacturing. This required exceptional com-
munication and fluidity between all team members.”
Jubal DeLong, Principal, JDID product design + development describes one such example. “WowClowd called
for a specification change at a later stage in the product development. Bestronics informed us that the part
would be difficult to get and might impact the production timeline. With this foreknowledge we were able to
swap out the difficult part for one that was more readily accessible, long before the product hit the assembly
line.” He described an additional cost-savings example that resulted from tight collaboration. “WowClowd
significantly increased its beta product quantity based on huge customer interest,” said DeLong. “We realized
that the volume difference made an alternate production option more cost efficient. I made a call and within 30
minutes had saved WowClowd five figures in beta production costs.”
Ansync provided electronic engineering feedback from concept stages as well, focusing on a means of pro-
ducing electronics that used low labor assembly along with the right mechanical strategy. Ansync has an SMT
line onsite. This capability enabled them to debug early stage prototypes on a live line while constantly com-
municating progress to Bestronics, in what Ansync CEO Sam Miller describes as a “seamless process.”
“The team used Agile methodology, working in sprints with short time iterations, smaller sets of deliverables,
quick feedback on the sprints and then immediate changes in response. Each decision involved the input of
ID and manufacturing. The tight collaboration resulted in a “one-pass implementation,” said Miller. The Wow-
Clowd tester electronics fit and performed perfectly in the model, the first time off the line.
To date, the WowClowd tester is in active production, although it is still iterating as the company receives
ongoing customer feedback. “Bestronics didn’t ask us for volume commitments or a timeline when we began
this project,” said Gille. “That immediate spirit of cooperation impressed us, as does their continued willingness
to re-kit our solution as necessary and in a very quick timeframe. Bestronics has done an extraordinary job of
project management within the confines of a tight budget and time to market pressure.“
“Innovation and Agile manufacturing go hand in hand,” said Ron Menigoz, Chief Technology Officer at Bestron-
ics. “Having been involved in multiple hardware startups as well as large OEMs where we pushed the technol-
ogy boundaries, I realize that no one company has all the answers. When you can leverage a network, immedi-
ately and accessibly, you gain options. And when you can cherry pick just the right team around a very specific
product, you become very nimble. This is important at the beginning of product development when so much is
unknown as well as at the very end of a product’s life when supply chains become spotty or volumes decrease.
The Silicon Valley offers unique access to an extraordinary breadth of technology skills, and significant value in
taking advantage of that network in the conception stages of new product design. You can get the right prod-
uct to market infinitely faster.”
Faster to Market, Cost Savings and “One-Pass Implementation”
Tight collaboration resulted in “one-pass implementation”;
WowClowd electronics performed perfectly, the first time off the line

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Cuelogic technologies
Cuelogic technologiesCuelogic technologies
Cuelogic technologiesnikhilambekar
 
How proof of concept development can be the stepping stone of success
How proof of concept development can be the stepping stone of successHow proof of concept development can be the stepping stone of success
How proof of concept development can be the stepping stone of successEmbitel Technologies (I) PVT LTD
 
Applied tactics for your transformation
Applied tactics for your transformationApplied tactics for your transformation
Applied tactics for your transformationStuart Charlton
 
Customer-centric innovation enabled by cloud
 Customer-centric innovation enabled by cloud Customer-centric innovation enabled by cloud
Customer-centric innovation enabled by cloudThoughtworks
 
The Disciplines of Continuous innovation
The Disciplines of Continuous innovationThe Disciplines of Continuous innovation
The Disciplines of Continuous innovationBrad Power
 
Developer Experience
Developer ExperienceDeveloper Experience
Developer ExperienceThoughtworks
 
The Art of Discovering Bounded Contexts
The Art of Discovering Bounded ContextsThe Art of Discovering Bounded Contexts
The Art of Discovering Bounded ContextsNick Tune
 
Integrated project delivery case studies
Integrated project delivery   case studiesIntegrated project delivery   case studies
Integrated project delivery case studiesrosaangelicaportalat1
 
Rapid Solutions with Salesforce Flows
Rapid Solutions with Salesforce FlowsRapid Solutions with Salesforce Flows
Rapid Solutions with Salesforce FlowstheCodery
 
Moritz Heiber - Your dashboard sucks
Moritz Heiber  - Your dashboard sucksMoritz Heiber  - Your dashboard sucks
Moritz Heiber - Your dashboard sucksThoughtworks
 
Mendix learning by Sunil Kumar
Mendix learning by Sunil KumarMendix learning by Sunil Kumar
Mendix learning by Sunil KumarSunilKumar706490
 
"Show me the ROI" – concrete results from process improvement
"Show me the ROI" – concrete results from process improvement"Show me the ROI" – concrete results from process improvement
"Show me the ROI" – concrete results from process improvementAconex
 
Qlik project methodology handbook v 1.0 docx
Qlik project methodology handbook v 1.0 docxQlik project methodology handbook v 1.0 docx
Qlik project methodology handbook v 1.0 docxAntonino Barbaro ©
 
DevOps - The Future of Application Lifecycle Automation
DevOps - The Future of Application Lifecycle Automation DevOps - The Future of Application Lifecycle Automation
DevOps - The Future of Application Lifecycle Automation Gunnar Menzel
 
Business Value of Agile Methods: Benefits of Testing Early & Often
Business Value of Agile Methods: Benefits of Testing Early & OftenBusiness Value of Agile Methods: Benefits of Testing Early & Often
Business Value of Agile Methods: Benefits of Testing Early & OftenDavid Rico
 
Integrated project delivery for more effective development
Integrated project delivery for more effective developmentIntegrated project delivery for more effective development
Integrated project delivery for more effective developmentAllen Matkins
 
Scott Aldridge (CDM Smith): Leveraging MR to Transform Design & Engineering o...
Scott Aldridge (CDM Smith): Leveraging MR to Transform Design & Engineering o...Scott Aldridge (CDM Smith): Leveraging MR to Transform Design & Engineering o...
Scott Aldridge (CDM Smith): Leveraging MR to Transform Design & Engineering o...AugmentedWorldExpo
 
When we design together
When we design togetherWhen we design together
When we design togetherThoughtworks
 

Mais procurados (19)

SQLI GROUP - presentation
SQLI GROUP - presentationSQLI GROUP - presentation
SQLI GROUP - presentation
 
Cuelogic technologies
Cuelogic technologiesCuelogic technologies
Cuelogic technologies
 
How proof of concept development can be the stepping stone of success
How proof of concept development can be the stepping stone of successHow proof of concept development can be the stepping stone of success
How proof of concept development can be the stepping stone of success
 
Applied tactics for your transformation
Applied tactics for your transformationApplied tactics for your transformation
Applied tactics for your transformation
 
Customer-centric innovation enabled by cloud
 Customer-centric innovation enabled by cloud Customer-centric innovation enabled by cloud
Customer-centric innovation enabled by cloud
 
The Disciplines of Continuous innovation
The Disciplines of Continuous innovationThe Disciplines of Continuous innovation
The Disciplines of Continuous innovation
 
Developer Experience
Developer ExperienceDeveloper Experience
Developer Experience
 
The Art of Discovering Bounded Contexts
The Art of Discovering Bounded ContextsThe Art of Discovering Bounded Contexts
The Art of Discovering Bounded Contexts
 
Integrated project delivery case studies
Integrated project delivery   case studiesIntegrated project delivery   case studies
Integrated project delivery case studies
 
Rapid Solutions with Salesforce Flows
Rapid Solutions with Salesforce FlowsRapid Solutions with Salesforce Flows
Rapid Solutions with Salesforce Flows
 
Moritz Heiber - Your dashboard sucks
Moritz Heiber  - Your dashboard sucksMoritz Heiber  - Your dashboard sucks
Moritz Heiber - Your dashboard sucks
 
Mendix learning by Sunil Kumar
Mendix learning by Sunil KumarMendix learning by Sunil Kumar
Mendix learning by Sunil Kumar
 
"Show me the ROI" – concrete results from process improvement
"Show me the ROI" – concrete results from process improvement"Show me the ROI" – concrete results from process improvement
"Show me the ROI" – concrete results from process improvement
 
Qlik project methodology handbook v 1.0 docx
Qlik project methodology handbook v 1.0 docxQlik project methodology handbook v 1.0 docx
Qlik project methodology handbook v 1.0 docx
 
DevOps - The Future of Application Lifecycle Automation
DevOps - The Future of Application Lifecycle Automation DevOps - The Future of Application Lifecycle Automation
DevOps - The Future of Application Lifecycle Automation
 
Business Value of Agile Methods: Benefits of Testing Early & Often
Business Value of Agile Methods: Benefits of Testing Early & OftenBusiness Value of Agile Methods: Benefits of Testing Early & Often
Business Value of Agile Methods: Benefits of Testing Early & Often
 
Integrated project delivery for more effective development
Integrated project delivery for more effective developmentIntegrated project delivery for more effective development
Integrated project delivery for more effective development
 
Scott Aldridge (CDM Smith): Leveraging MR to Transform Design & Engineering o...
Scott Aldridge (CDM Smith): Leveraging MR to Transform Design & Engineering o...Scott Aldridge (CDM Smith): Leveraging MR to Transform Design & Engineering o...
Scott Aldridge (CDM Smith): Leveraging MR to Transform Design & Engineering o...
 
When we design together
When we design togetherWhen we design together
When we design together
 

Semelhante a bestronics_wow_final - Copy

ASSIGNMENT  From Chapter 3, pages 89-90, WEB-BASED CASE.  Rea.docx
ASSIGNMENT  From Chapter 3, pages 89-90, WEB-BASED CASE.  Rea.docxASSIGNMENT  From Chapter 3, pages 89-90, WEB-BASED CASE.  Rea.docx
ASSIGNMENT  From Chapter 3, pages 89-90, WEB-BASED CASE.  Rea.docxedmondpburgess27164
 
2014 Future of Cloud Computing Study
2014 Future of Cloud Computing Study2014 Future of Cloud Computing Study
2014 Future of Cloud Computing StudyNorth Bridge
 
IBM Blockchain Labs Explained v1.0
IBM Blockchain Labs Explained v1.0IBM Blockchain Labs Explained v1.0
IBM Blockchain Labs Explained v1.0Matt Lucas
 
The Digital Lab for Manufacturing: How Digital Design & Digital Manufacturing...
The Digital Lab for Manufacturing: How Digital Design & Digital Manufacturing...The Digital Lab for Manufacturing: How Digital Design & Digital Manufacturing...
The Digital Lab for Manufacturing: How Digital Design & Digital Manufacturing...Decision Lens
 
2014 Future of Cloud Computing - 4th Annual Survey Results
2014 Future of Cloud Computing - 4th Annual Survey Results2014 Future of Cloud Computing - 4th Annual Survey Results
2014 Future of Cloud Computing - 4th Annual Survey ResultsMichael Skok
 
Pump Studios Overview
Pump Studios OverviewPump Studios Overview
Pump Studios OverviewKevin Keller
 
How Bekaert leverages digital to go beyond steel.pptx
How Bekaert leverages digital to go beyond steel.pptxHow Bekaert leverages digital to go beyond steel.pptx
How Bekaert leverages digital to go beyond steel.pptxstraighttalk283
 
Why we should consider Open Hybrid Cloud.pdf
Why we should  consider Open Hybrid Cloud.pdfWhy we should  consider Open Hybrid Cloud.pdf
Why we should consider Open Hybrid Cloud.pdfMasahiko Umeno
 
BIMStorm BIG BIM Bang White Paper
BIMStorm BIG BIM Bang White PaperBIMStorm BIG BIM Bang White Paper
BIMStorm BIG BIM Bang White PaperMike Bordenaro
 
Control and Risk Mitigation Whitepaper
Control and Risk Mitigation WhitepaperControl and Risk Mitigation Whitepaper
Control and Risk Mitigation WhitepaperGreg Fry
 
Reimagine project delivery with Oracle Industries Innovation Lab UK
Reimagine project delivery with Oracle Industries Innovation Lab UKReimagine project delivery with Oracle Industries Innovation Lab UK
Reimagine project delivery with Oracle Industries Innovation Lab UKAssociation for Project Management
 
Mobile order management
Mobile order managementMobile order management
Mobile order managementEliot Freed
 
Connected Futures Podcast: The Digital Manufacturer – Resolving the Service D...
Connected Futures Podcast: The Digital Manufacturer – Resolving the Service D...Connected Futures Podcast: The Digital Manufacturer – Resolving the Service D...
Connected Futures Podcast: The Digital Manufacturer – Resolving the Service D...Connected Futures
 
Build in Blockchain
Build in BlockchainBuild in Blockchain
Build in BlockchainSanket Parab
 
CodeIT company presentation
CodeIT company presentationCodeIT company presentation
CodeIT company presentationSergiy Mavrov
 

Semelhante a bestronics_wow_final - Copy (20)

ASSIGNMENT  From Chapter 3, pages 89-90, WEB-BASED CASE.  Rea.docx
ASSIGNMENT  From Chapter 3, pages 89-90, WEB-BASED CASE.  Rea.docxASSIGNMENT  From Chapter 3, pages 89-90, WEB-BASED CASE.  Rea.docx
ASSIGNMENT  From Chapter 3, pages 89-90, WEB-BASED CASE.  Rea.docx
 
2014 Future of Cloud Computing Study
2014 Future of Cloud Computing Study2014 Future of Cloud Computing Study
2014 Future of Cloud Computing Study
 
Value Stories - 2nd issue - October 2018
Value Stories - 2nd issue - October 2018Value Stories - 2nd issue - October 2018
Value Stories - 2nd issue - October 2018
 
IBM Blockchain Labs Explained v1.0
IBM Blockchain Labs Explained v1.0IBM Blockchain Labs Explained v1.0
IBM Blockchain Labs Explained v1.0
 
Azure Biz
Azure BizAzure Biz
Azure Biz
 
The Digital Lab for Manufacturing: How Digital Design & Digital Manufacturing...
The Digital Lab for Manufacturing: How Digital Design & Digital Manufacturing...The Digital Lab for Manufacturing: How Digital Design & Digital Manufacturing...
The Digital Lab for Manufacturing: How Digital Design & Digital Manufacturing...
 
2014 Future of Cloud Computing - 4th Annual Survey Results
2014 Future of Cloud Computing - 4th Annual Survey Results2014 Future of Cloud Computing - 4th Annual Survey Results
2014 Future of Cloud Computing - 4th Annual Survey Results
 
Pump Studios Overview
Pump Studios OverviewPump Studios Overview
Pump Studios Overview
 
How Bekaert leverages digital to go beyond steel.pptx
How Bekaert leverages digital to go beyond steel.pptxHow Bekaert leverages digital to go beyond steel.pptx
How Bekaert leverages digital to go beyond steel.pptx
 
Cloud native enterprise
Cloud native enterpriseCloud native enterprise
Cloud native enterprise
 
Why we should consider Open Hybrid Cloud.pdf
Why we should  consider Open Hybrid Cloud.pdfWhy we should  consider Open Hybrid Cloud.pdf
Why we should consider Open Hybrid Cloud.pdf
 
BIMStorm BIG BIM Bang White Paper
BIMStorm BIG BIM Bang White PaperBIMStorm BIG BIM Bang White Paper
BIMStorm BIG BIM Bang White Paper
 
Control and Risk Mitigation Whitepaper
Control and Risk Mitigation WhitepaperControl and Risk Mitigation Whitepaper
Control and Risk Mitigation Whitepaper
 
Reimagine project delivery with Oracle Industries Innovation Lab UK
Reimagine project delivery with Oracle Industries Innovation Lab UKReimagine project delivery with Oracle Industries Innovation Lab UK
Reimagine project delivery with Oracle Industries Innovation Lab UK
 
Mobile order management
Mobile order managementMobile order management
Mobile order management
 
Marc perillo
Marc perilloMarc perillo
Marc perillo
 
Connected Futures Podcast: The Digital Manufacturer – Resolving the Service D...
Connected Futures Podcast: The Digital Manufacturer – Resolving the Service D...Connected Futures Podcast: The Digital Manufacturer – Resolving the Service D...
Connected Futures Podcast: The Digital Manufacturer – Resolving the Service D...
 
Greetings david cutler inform and connect
Greetings   david cutler inform and connectGreetings   david cutler inform and connect
Greetings david cutler inform and connect
 
Build in Blockchain
Build in BlockchainBuild in Blockchain
Build in Blockchain
 
CodeIT company presentation
CodeIT company presentationCodeIT company presentation
CodeIT company presentation
 

bestronics_wow_final - Copy

  • 1. Silicon Valley Agile Development & Manufacturing Case Study Series BESTRONICS & WOWCLOWD: A Unique Product, An Aggressive Budget and A Lot of Uncertainty How Early Stage Partnership with Agile Manufacturing Partners Achieved Time-to-Market Goals to Develop a Highly Innovative Solution for Network Testing Silicon Valley Regional Economic Development Initiative WowClowd was built around a game-changing concept that could transform network cable installation and testing from a “coffee stained paper process” to a secure and cloud-based process en- abled by a purpose-built, hand-held Bluetooth device. Chris Gille, Operations VP for of WowClowd, describes his company as software savvy and deeply experienced in the design and inte- gration of cable systems. They had no experience however, in the development and manufacturing of a physical device. With no viable manufacturing options near their headquarters in Nebraska, Gille opted to partner with Silicon Valley-based contract manufacturer Bestronics at an unusually early stage, the idea and concept phase, to help bring the WowClowd product to market. “WowClowd has extensive entrepreneurial product development experience,” said Gille. “We can identify customer needs, determine how to solve them, validate them, and then field test to tweak and refine a solution feature set. What we didn’t have was the ability to understand how design decisions would impact manufacturing cost or time trade-offs or add complexity to critical trade testing require- ments.” Gille explained that the product would require a particularly sophisti- “Silicon Valley offers unique access to an extraordinary breadth of technology skills... You can get the right product to market in- finitely faster.” - Ron Menigoz, CTO at Bestronics cated, rugged design. “It’s a small form factor device housing expensive electronics that an operator may toss in with a box of tools, or hang from a belt loop as he or she climbs a ladder in the course of their daily work. This product needed to be able to take a beating.” Not only was the WowClowd product new to the market, it required some unique components. One key element was highly sophisticated testers that would leverage the power of smartphones and the cloud. To accomplish this effectively, the design specs called for a techni- cal solution that did yet exist in the market. Leveraging Silicon Valley’s Agile Development & Manufacturing Network Bestronics quickly engaged industrial design company JDID product design + development and electronic engineering company Ansync Labs at the design specification stage to collaborate on research and develop- ment. These partners in turn brought in additional expertise, i.e. low volume injection molders, tooling shops, etc. as needed. With the full concept to production development schedule in mind, Bestronics coordinated collaboration between the engineering groups, external supply chain component providers and test partners involved at each stage of the development process.
  • 2. Silicon Valley Agile Development & Manufacturing Case Study Series Silicon Valley Regional Economic Development Initiative Gille contrasted the quicker time to market process he experienced through early collaboration with the Be- stronics team with more typical manufacturing processes. “We didn’t move from design documentation to quality testing to production to customer shipment, as usual. We went from concept to alpha to beta, then to pre-production while getting and responding to feedback from customers throughout the process. We even went through a couple of different board spins that were driven by functional changes we would prototype.” He continued, “using the input of each partner right from the R&D phase, we could balance each feature decision or customer input based on its impact to cost or time delays in manufacturing. This required exceptional com- munication and fluidity between all team members.” Jubal DeLong, Principal, JDID product design + development describes one such example. “WowClowd called for a specification change at a later stage in the product development. Bestronics informed us that the part would be difficult to get and might impact the production timeline. With this foreknowledge we were able to swap out the difficult part for one that was more readily accessible, long before the product hit the assembly line.” He described an additional cost-savings example that resulted from tight collaboration. “WowClowd significantly increased its beta product quantity based on huge customer interest,” said DeLong. “We realized that the volume difference made an alternate production option more cost efficient. I made a call and within 30 minutes had saved WowClowd five figures in beta production costs.” Ansync provided electronic engineering feedback from concept stages as well, focusing on a means of pro- ducing electronics that used low labor assembly along with the right mechanical strategy. Ansync has an SMT line onsite. This capability enabled them to debug early stage prototypes on a live line while constantly com- municating progress to Bestronics, in what Ansync CEO Sam Miller describes as a “seamless process.” “The team used Agile methodology, working in sprints with short time iterations, smaller sets of deliverables, quick feedback on the sprints and then immediate changes in response. Each decision involved the input of ID and manufacturing. The tight collaboration resulted in a “one-pass implementation,” said Miller. The Wow- Clowd tester electronics fit and performed perfectly in the model, the first time off the line. To date, the WowClowd tester is in active production, although it is still iterating as the company receives ongoing customer feedback. “Bestronics didn’t ask us for volume commitments or a timeline when we began this project,” said Gille. “That immediate spirit of cooperation impressed us, as does their continued willingness to re-kit our solution as necessary and in a very quick timeframe. Bestronics has done an extraordinary job of project management within the confines of a tight budget and time to market pressure.“ “Innovation and Agile manufacturing go hand in hand,” said Ron Menigoz, Chief Technology Officer at Bestron- ics. “Having been involved in multiple hardware startups as well as large OEMs where we pushed the technol- ogy boundaries, I realize that no one company has all the answers. When you can leverage a network, immedi- ately and accessibly, you gain options. And when you can cherry pick just the right team around a very specific product, you become very nimble. This is important at the beginning of product development when so much is unknown as well as at the very end of a product’s life when supply chains become spotty or volumes decrease. The Silicon Valley offers unique access to an extraordinary breadth of technology skills, and significant value in taking advantage of that network in the conception stages of new product design. You can get the right prod- uct to market infinitely faster.” Faster to Market, Cost Savings and “One-Pass Implementation” Tight collaboration resulted in “one-pass implementation”; WowClowd electronics performed perfectly, the first time off the line