SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 19
Baixar para ler offline
D 8.6 – Position paper for standardization and legislation – First version
Project acronym CarE-service
Project Title Circular Economy oriented services for re-use
and remanufacturing of hybrid and electric
vehicles components through smart and
movable module
Call H2020-CIRC-2017 Two Stage (IA)
Grant Agreement n. 776851
Relative Number in WP D8.6
Deliverable Title Position paper for standardization and
legislation – First version
Lead Beneficiary COBSER
Deliverable Type Report
Dissemination level Public
Due date M18
Submission date 30/11/2019
This project has received funding from the European Horizon 2020
research and innovation programme under the grant agreement No
776851
Ref. Ares(2019)7388059 - 30/11/2019
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 1
Additional document information
Authors: Luigi De Rocchi (COBSER)
Contributing
partners:
CNR-STIIMA (Nicoletta Picone, Elena Mossali, Giacomo Copani), FCA (Alessandro
Levizzari, Silvia Lazzari, Envirobat (Juan Manuel Perez), JRC (Franco Di Persio), C-
ECO (Michael Bolech, Konstantinos Georgopoulos).
Keywords: EV batteries, de-manufacturing, testing and certification, re-manufacturing,
recycling, extended producer responsibility (EPR), legislation, standardization.
Versioning and contribution history
Version Organization Comment Date
1.0 COBSER 1st draft 21/11/2019
2.0 ENVIROBAT 2nd draft 25/11/2019
3.0 JRC 3rd draft 25/11/2019
4.0 FCA Deliverable Review by FCA 25/11/2019
5.0 C-ECO Deliverable Review by C-ECO 27/11/2019
Executive Summary
This deliverable is directly consequential to D8.5 - Standardization and legislation plans and actions,
consisting on the analysis of the state of the art of the current legislation and standard regulations in
general concerning technical and legal requirements, together with safety issues, relative to disassembly
and re-manufacturing, transportation and storage of reusable/recyclable parts and components, extended
producer responsibility (EPR) regarding new parts and products put on the market. These topics were
mainly focused on the batteries value chain by identifying limits and barriers of the current legislation and
standard regulations for the development of CarE Service project, and furthermore by elaborating
proposals to remove these limits and barriers with the clear indications of potential benefit associated.
The contents of D8.5 were used to elaborate this deliverable as a formal position paper with proposals on
legislation and standard regulations to be submitted to the relevant European stakeholders (CEN-
CENELEC, Standardization Committee, National and Regional Authorities, European Commission).
D8.6 is a living and dynamic document due to the upcoming changes in the EU regulations for the revision
of the Battery Directive, the ELV Directive and the battery sustainability initiatives.
Thus, this is the first version of D8.6, potentially upgradeable up to the end of the CarE-Service project
(M36).
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 2
Table of Contents
List of Acronyms 3
1 INTRODUCTION AND OBJECT 4
2 PROPOSALS TO REMOVE LIMITS AND BARRIERS 5
2.1 Proposals to remove legal and administrative gaps........................................................................ 5
2.1.1 EPR (Extended Producer Responsibility) transferability 5
2.1.2 “End of Waste” regulation 6
2.1.3 Harmonization required between ELV Directive, new Battery Directive, Directive
2005/64/EC and REACH regulations 7
2.2 Proposals to remove technical gaps................................................................................................ 8
2.2.1 Requirements for the manufacturing phase 8
2.2.2 Requirements for “End of Waste” status and second use 8
2.2.3 Requirements for improved efficiency in the recovery of materials 9
3 CONCLUSIONS 10
Review of the Deliverable by FCA ............................................................................................................11
Review of the Deliverable by C-ECO.........................................................................................................15
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 3
List of Acronyms
ACEA European Automobile Manufacturers' Association (French: Association des Constructeurs
Européens d'Automobiles)
ANSI American National Standards Institute
BD Battery Directive 2006/66/EU
BMS Battery Management System
CE Conformité Européenne (Certification mark applicable in the European Economic Area)
CEN European Committee for Standardization (French: Comité Européen de Normalisation)
CENELEC European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization (French: Comité Européen de
Normalisation Électrotechnique)
E&HEV Electric and Hybrid electric vehicles
EC European Commission
ELV End-of-life Vehicle
EoL End-of-Life
EoW End-of-Waste
EPR Extended Producer responsibility
EU European Union
EV Electric vehicle
GTR(s) Global Technical Regulations
HV Hybrid Vehicle
IEC International Electrotechnical Commission
IMDS International Material Data System
LFP Lithium Iron Phosphate(LiFePO4)
Li-batteries Lithium batteries
Li-Ion Lithium-Ion
NCA Lithium Nickel Cobalt Aluminium Oxide (LiNiCoAlO2)
Ni-Cd Nickel- Cadmium
Ni-MH Nickel metal hydride battery
NMC Lithium Nickel Manganese Cobalt Oxide (LiNiMnCoO2)
OEM Original Equipment Manufacturer
RE Recycling Efficiency
REACH Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals
SoH State-of-Health
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 4
1 INTRODUCTION AND OBJECT
Deliverable 8.5 focused on the analysis of the current legislation and standards (concerning legal, safety
and technical requirements about de-manufacturing and re-manufacturing, transportation and storage of
reusable/recyclable parts and components, extended producer responsibility (EPR) for new parts and
products put on the market), in order to identify limits and barriers for the development of CarE Service
project and to exploit the potentials of circular economy of E&HEVs.
Considering the three main streams of CarE Service project (batteries, metal parts and techno-polymers),
the real criticalities concerned mainly the batteries stream; this is the reason why D8.5 focused exclusively
on the batteries value chain.
In D8.5 precise limitations and barriers posed by the existing standardization and regulatory framework for
the implementation of the most important targets regarding batteries in the CarE Service project were
identified, with the aim of proposing solutions to remove them.
Two main frameworks were in general identified to highlight existing limits and barriers:
• Legal and administrative: relative to important lack of 'design and use' requirements to enhance
battery sustainability, lack of coherence between different regulatory instruments, to ensure
smooth functioning of the internal market for batteries, waste batteries and materials obtained
from recycled batteries and how to facilitate the use of batteries in second-life applications.
• Technical: relative to significant gaps regarding manufacturing requirements in order to maximize
re-use and second-life applications, and also gaps regarding requirements for second-life
applications. Furthermore, very important gaps were also identified for the final recycling and
recovery of waste batteries.
This deliverable, by using the contents and results of D.8.5, is an official position paper with specific
proposals on legislation and standard regulations to be submitted to the relevant European stakeholders
(CEN-CENELEC, Standardization Committee, National and Regional Authorities, ACEA, European
Commission), in order to remove limits and barriers for the development of some basic processes along
the batteries value chain in CarE-Service project.
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 5
2 PROPOSALS TO REMOVE LIMITS AND BARRIERS
2.1 Proposals to remove legal and administrative gaps
2.1.1 EPR (Extended Producer Responsibility) transferability
EPR is the principle according to which producers are responsible for the correct management of waste
generated by the put on the market of their products.
Currently, the responsibility for the correct management of an end-of-life battery is laying on the first
producer which put it on the market (where “first producer”, according to the law, is any person in a
Member State that, irrespective of the selling technique used, places batteries or accumulators, including
those incorporated into appliances or vehicles, on the market for the first time); EPR isn’t transferable, and
no one can get it.
The actor who is putting on the market a second-life battery pack, should bear obligations pertinent to
their responsibility as a producer, including the possibility of full or partial transfer of the EPR from the first
producer to the second one.
The original assumptions are the following:
• in the National Register, together with the other information requested, it should be provided (at
least for industrial and automotive batteries) the declaration of the serial number of the battery
• the legislation in force should introduce the concept of the “Authorized representative” for foreign
producer
Starting from these original assumptions, we can have two different scenarios:
1- Reuse of the battery as product (no end-of-life)
The battery can be addressed to second applications without becoming waste.
The different options can be the following:
a) The battery is sold/delivered by the first producer (for instance the car manufacturer) to a second
producer in the same country
The second producer indicates in the National Register the serial number of the battery that he received
from the first producer, also with the percentage of the weight of the battery concretely re-used.
The first producer must confirm in the National Register its agreement to the EPR transferring (total or
partial).
1. The joint declaration between the first and second producer validate the EPR transfer (total or
partial);
2. The second producer must declare on the National Register the new second-life battery put on the
market, attributing to it a new brand and a new serial number and becoming totally responsible for its
end-of-life management (new EPR).
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 6
b) The battery is sold/delivered by the first producer (for instance the car manufacturer) to a second
producer in a foreign country
1. The first producer must indicate in its National Register the serial number of the battery to be
sold/delivered through its “Authorized Representative” to a second producer in a new country. Then
the first producer must report in the foreign National Register (to which is obliged to enroll through
its “Authorized Representative”) the battery put on the market, with its serial number. In that way,
the record with all the information regarding the battery put on the market moves from the National
Register in the original country to the National Register in the foreign country. EPR moves from the
first country to the second one being assumed by the “Authorized Representative”, which assumes in
the new country the role of first producer.
2. The following steps are the same of the previous point “a”.
For the “reusers”, i.e. actors willing to work with batteries for a second life, a “license” should be
required that guarantees equal conditions for handling the batteries (e.g. electrical safety of the
facilities, staff well instructed, fire extinguish controls, user warranties) with a “EU manufactured
Stamp” as a sign of high quality.
2- Re-use of the battery declared waste (end-of-life)
If the battery has been declared waste, for instance by a car’s dismantler, it cannot be re-used without
applying to it the End-of-Waste status (see the following paragraph).
If the battery respects all the technical and safety requirements to be reclassified from waste to good,
the EPR transfer will follow the steps of the points “a” and “b” described above.
2.1.2 “End of Waste” regulation
The possibility of reusing (totally or partially) an end-of-life battery coming from an electrified vehicle,
which is a waste, for a different application, should provide the application of the “end-of-waste” status.
Second use of batteries fulfils the End-of-Waste criteria (as they defined in Article 6, §1 of Waste
Framework Directive 2008/98/EC) which are described as follows:
a. the substance or object is commonly used for specific purposes: Several studies and analysis
indicate that end-of-life HEV-EVs batteries may still have residual charge capacity (75-80%) to be
suitable for new second-life applications, for instance in energy storage. The intrinsic lower
capacity of the batteries/modules/cells isn’t a critical gap for energy storage applications in which
the need of space is not a fundamental issue (unlike in automotive applications) and the residual
gap can be easily solved with the implementation of more battery packs.
b. there is an existing market or demand for the substance or object: The strong development of
renewable sources, firmly sustained in Europe by specific programs and energy politics, already
needs new big systems to store the produced energy, and forecasts show exponential increasing
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 7
for the future. The growth in demand for electrical storage systems can be supplied by end-of-life
batteries coming from the growing market of electrified mobility, in a virtuosic circular economy
perspective.
c. the use is lawful (substance or object fulfils the technical requirements for the specific purposes
and meets the existing legislation and standards applicable to products): Even if the original
battery is de-manufactured, the original cells are left intact and they have to be checked and
tested before being re-manufactured in a new battery pack. Technical and safety standards in
second-life batteries must be compliant with the same requirements foreseen for a new battery
d. the use will not lead to overall adverse environmental or human health impacts: Cells or modules
correctly checked and tested, then re-manufactured in new second-life batteries in accordance to
the same technical and safety standards of a new battery, should not pose any risk for the
environment or human health.
These assumptions had been adopted in The Netherlands by the Ministry of Infrastructure and
Environment, specifically with the “Legal judgement End-of-Waste status lithium-ion cells” of 22
September 2017, Reference IENM/BSK-2017/215501.
2.1.3 Harmonization required between ELV Directive, new Battery Directive, Directive
2005/64/EC and REACH regulations
Regulations concerning reusability of batteries involve different legislative frameworks.
In End-of-life Vehicle Directive and Waste Framework Directive some definitions of “re-use are provided”,
however in the Battery Directive is missed as in any other waste legislations.
It is also of utmost importance to clarify the meaning of some terms often used as synonymous like re-use,
second use, repurposing, refurbishment, reconditioning, redesigning etc.; for each of them, specific
regulations should be provided.
Regarding the International Material Data System (the automobile industry's material data system used by
almost all the global OEMs), the information and calculation required for the recycling type approval
process and the corresponding recycling targets should be harmonized with the Battery Directive
requirements.
And referring to the hazardous substances eventually included in the EV battery, they should be
exclusively dealt within the REACH regulation.
Furthermore, the dismantling documentation required by the ELV Directive should include the dismantling
information of the EV battery pack.
In addition to these, it’s useful to highlight that ELV Directive 2000/53/EC regulates all recycling relevant
items around the design/production, use/repair and EoL-phase of vehicles and its components: all
batteries and accumulators used in a vehicle are included.
On another hand the current Battery Directive includes again batteries used in vehicles and it regulates
identical items like recycling quotas, takeback obligations, labeling and the restricted use of hazardous
substances.
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 8
Having this regulated twice does not add value for the environment, but leads to confusion in practice
where still clarity is lacking and harmonization would be important.
2.2 Proposals to remove technical gaps
2.2.1 Requirements for the manufacturing phase
Reusability of batteries, including the possibility of reusing single modules or cells, is more technical and
economical sustainable the easier can be the disassembling of the battery and the testing of its parts and
components.
Regarding design for easy disassembling, testing, repairing, repurposing of EV batteries, the following
technical issues could be highlighted with suggestions on how to address them:
• The assembly of the battery pack should follow a modular approach with a ubiquitous access to all the
modules, cells and electric/electronic components to ensure easy testing and dismantling.
• To allow an easy disassembly of modules and cells it is suggested to use screws or other Plug-&-Play
systems for easy electrical disconnection instead of welding.
• Improved information and coding (e.g. type of screws, HV components, steps to follow in the
dismantling process).
• The supporting systems should not hinder the dismantling operations (e.g. cooling system, low voltage
hardware, cabling and feedthroughs).
• Easiness of dismantling should not hinder safety and functional aspects (e.g. gas tightness, location of
the pressure release valve, location and easy access to the main HV disconnection plug, structural
strength and integrity of the battery pack, efficient thermal management)
• Ensure a clear labelling containing information on chemistries and other relevant features of the pack
(e.g. nominal voltage, capacity, weight). Currently the standard IEC 62902 is limited to mark only the
main battery technologies (e.g. lead-acid, Ni-MH, Li-ion, Li-metal, Ni-Cd); the marking should also
include the Li-ion cathode (e.g. LFP, NxMyCz, NCA) and anode (e.g. Graphite, Si content) chemistries.
• Ensure a BMS partial open access for retrieving of SoH and battery lifetime relevant information
including the usage of the EV battery.
The European Commission promoted an “Ecodesign” preparatory Study for Batteries, which started in
September 2018 (ref: https://ecodesignbatteries.eu/welcome) and expected to be completed by middle
2020, remembering that regulation of electric vehicle batteries under the Ecodesign Directive should not
be applied as the same Ecodesign Directive is not applicable to products that are designed only for use in a
means of transport for persons or goods.
All the proposals hereby suggested above could be included in the aforementioned study.
2.2.2 Requirements for “End of Waste” status and second use
In order to correctly apply the “End of Waste” status on batteries for re-using purposes, safety and
technical standard regulations need to be adopted, and specifically:
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 9
1) Standard procedures for the “state of health” evaluation of EoL batteries, modules and cells to
be re-used in second-life applications.
2) The production of second-life battery packs shall meet the same requirements of the new
industrial batteries, especially in terms of safety.
The only existing standard that specifically cover the second use option is the ANSI/CAN/UL 1974, however
may be resource and time consuming; a faster/more reliable check it may be necessary.
The impedance-based measurements and evaluation methods should be considered (see LibForSecUse
project1
). Once tested, a proper labelling for SoH classification for repurposed battery may be necessary to
be developed, both for getting cheaper transportation costs and for more precise assignment to a specific
second use application.
The regulatory framework defined in the context of Health and Safety at Work and Fire Safety measures in
buildings and industrial activity should allow a safe operation for the dismantling of EV battery packs.
Once the EV battery (either the full pack, modules or cells) is repurposed for a stationary storage second
use application there are some concern regarding safety of the stationary storage systems. The process for
a clear regulatory mandatory framework (e.g. equivalent to the EV safety GTR) for the stationary energy
storage system, especially addressing the lithium-ion technology should be initiated.
2.2.3 Requirements for improved efficiency in the recovery of materials
A circular economy approach to secure access to secondary raw materials through recycling may give
strategic leverage to the future EU cell manufacturing industry.
In this sense, a clear decision of fostering those processes that look for recovering compounds to be used
again in battery manufacturing would be fostered.
A RE measured in terms of recovery rate of the different materials composing the batteries entering the
recycling facility seems more appropriate.
However, in this point it has to be very taken with careful the idea that “the higher RE the best”.
Sometimes, a higher RE in terms of recovered materials does not warranty the best environmental
protection and, it can be at the same time much more dangerous in terms of resources needed for
recycling.
On the other hand, the recycling industry is looking for higher recovery rate only for those materials that
can maximize their benefit (e.g. cobalt, nickel, copper), since usually higher recovery rate come with
higher cost.
Therefore, RE should address mentioned concepts:
• Number of chemical compounds ready to be used in Battery Manufacturing Industry.
1
https://www.ptb.de/empir2018/libforsecuse/project/overview/ (accessed November 2019)
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page10
• Environmental impact of the process in terms of energy consuming, emissions and waste
generation.
• Promote the recovery of many compounds and materials as possible.
• The possibility of reusing directly some compounds of the batteries (e.g. casing, BMS, etc.)
The possibility to include a minimum recycled content in the manufacturing of new cells. However, a big
barrier could be the difficulties in the traceability for battery’s secondary raw materials and the technical
challenge to have an economically viable recycling processes to allow the production of battery grade
secondary raw materials.
3 CONCLUSIONS
The different solutions proposed in this position paper aim to remove legal and technical barriers for the
development of the CarE-Service project, in particular to increase the opportunity to reuse end-of-life
batteries, coming from electrified vehicles, for second life applications.
The illustrated solutions have been defined thinking of their concrete applicability depending, above all, on
the various regulatory revisions in progress, some of which already containing updates and new
regulations in line with these proposals.
Precisely this last aspect gives hope that these proposals can be more easily accepted by the reference
institutional stakeholders to whom this position paper is addressed.
As legislative revisions are imminent and will evolve in the coming months, this is the first version of the
position paper that could potentially be upgradeable until the end of the CarE-Service project.
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page11
Review of the Deliverable
D 8.6 – Position paper for standardization and legislation
Reviewer Name Levizzari Alessandro
Reviewer Organization FCA
Deliverable lead beneficiary Luigi De Rocchi (COBSER)
Due date of the deliverable 30/11/2019
Received date of the deliverable by the
lead beneficiary
25/11/2019
Submission date of the review 25/11/2018
Overall Assessment of
the deliverable
⃝ The required level of quality is met and the deliverable put forward
additional insights which can be beneficial for the progress of the
project.
X The required level of quality is met perfectly and no major
improvement is needed. I suggested some minor improvements.
⃝ The required level of quality is met but there are major
improvements to be made before submission of the deliverable.
⃝ In order to meet the required level of quality of the deliverable, I
have major concerns that may delay the submission of the
deliverable.
This project has received funding from the European Horizon 2020
research and innovation programme under the grant agreement No
776851
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page12
Review assessment
1. Is the information contained in the deliverable technically sound and complete?
X Yes ⃝ Can be improved
Comments/suggestion/specifications:
2. Is any critical information missing in the content of the deliverable?
X No ⃝ Yes
Comments/suggestion/specifications:
3. Does the deliverable compliant with the relevant project objectives, targets and KPIs related
to its topic?
X Clearly stated and compliant ⃝ Clearly stated but compliancy can be improved
⃝ Not clearly stated but compliant ⃝ Not clearly stated and compliancy can be improved
⃝ Other responses, please state:
Comments/suggestion/specifications:
4. Does the objective of the deliverable is clearly stated and compliant with the relevant project
objectives, targets and KPIs related to its topic?
X Clearly stated and compliant ⃝ Clearly stated but compliancy can be improved
⃝ Not clearly stated but compliant ⃝ Not clearly stated and compliancy can be improved
⃝ Other responses, please state:
Comments/suggestion/specifications:
5. Does the method of the deliverable is clearly stated and appropriate for the scope and
objective of the deliverable?
X Clearly stated and appropriate ⃝ Clearly stated but can be improved
⃝ Not clearly stated but appropriate ⃝ Not clearly stated and can be improved
⃝ Other responses, please state:
Comments/suggestion/specifications:
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page13
6. Does the key messages and results of the deliverable are clearly stated and compliant with
the relevant project objectives, targets and KPIs related to its topic?
X Clearly stated and compliant ⃝ Clearly stated but compliancy can be improved
⃝ Not clearly stated but compliant ⃝ Not clearly stated and compliancy can be improved
⃝ Other responses, please state:
Comments/suggestion/specifications:
7. Does the layout of the deliverable is compliant with the project template?
X Compliant ⃝ Can be improved
Comments/suggestion/specifications:
8. Does the language style of the deliverable meet the required quality level?
⃝ Yes X Can be improved
Comments/suggestion/specifications:
The style can be improved and, above all, some general conclusions have to be added.
9. Can the deliverable benefit from additional stakeholder expectations (consortium or external
stakeholder expectations such e.g. consumers or other value chain stakeholders)?
⃝ The deliverable is completely aligned with both consortium and external expectations
X The relevance of additional expectations can be added to the deliverable
Comments/suggestion/specifications:
10. Does the illustrations, drawing and tables of the deliverable clear and comprehensive?
X Yes ⃝ Can be improved
Comments/suggestion/specifications:
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page14
11. Does the abbreviations, references and/or formulas of the deliverable clear and
comprehensive?
X Yes ⃝ Can be improved
Comments/suggestion/specifications:
Additional comments/suggestions: e.g.
o any other concept is too generically described and requires details and specifications.
o non-homogeneity of the approach with other project activities
o lack of clarity in how the task feeds the demonstrators
o lack of hints on contribution to future tasks of the project
o lack of innovation sources of a tool/method
o lack of differentiation of previous projects and new developments
o lack of potential exploitation routes
o The approach is disconnected from the overall project rationale
o The extendibility of the results to other scenarios is not discussed
o The difference from the initial situation and the output KPIs are not properly measured.
o The implementations are only weakly connected to the overall project objectives and
targets.
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page15
Review of the Deliverable
D 8.6 – Position paper for standardization and legislation – First version
Reviewer Name Konstantinos Georgopoulos
Reviewer Organization C-ECO
Deliverable lead beneficiary COBSER
Due date of the deliverable 29.11.2019
Received date of the deliverable by
the lead beneficiary
25.11.2019
Submission date of the review 27.11.2019
Overall
Assessment
of the
deliverable
☒ The required level of quality is met and the deliverable put
forward additional insights which can be beneficial for the progress
of the project.
☐ The required level of quality is met perfectly and no major
improvement is needed. I suggested some minor improvements.
☐ The required level of quality is met but there are major
improvements to be made before submission of the deliverable.
☐ In order to meet the required level of quality of the deliverable, I
have major concerns that may delay the submission of the
deliverable.
This project has received funding from the European Horizon 2020
research and innovation programme under the grant agreement No
776851
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page16
Review assessment
1. Is the information contained in the deliverable technically sound and complete?
☒ Yes
☐ Can be improved
Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text.
2. Is any critical information missing in the content of the deliverable?
☒ No
☐ Yes
Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text.
3. Does the deliverable compliant with the relevant project objectives, targets and KPIs related to its
topic?
☒ Clearly stated and compliant
☐ Clearly stated but compliancy can be improved
☐ Not clearly stated but compliant
☐ Not clearly stated and compliancy can be improved
☐ Other responses, please state:Click or tap here to enter text.
Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text.
4. Does the objective of the deliverable is clearly stated and compliant with the relevant project
objectives, targets and KPIs related to its topic?
☒ Clearly stated and compliant
☐ Clearly stated but compliancy can be improved
☐ Not clearly stated but compliant
☐ Not clearly stated and compliancy can be improved
☐ Other responses, please state:Click or tap here to enter text.
Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text.
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page17
5. Does the method of the deliverable is clearly stated and appropriate for the scope and objective of
the deliverable?
☒ Clearly stated and appropriate
☐ Clearly stated but can be improved
☐ Not clearly stated but appropriate
☐ Not clearly stated and can be improved
☐ Other responses, please state:Click or tap here to enter text.
Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text.
6. Does the key messages and results of the deliverable are clearly stated and compliant with the
relevant project objectives, targets and KPIs related to its topic?
☒ Clearly stated and appropriate
☐ Clearly stated but can be improved
☐ Not clearly stated but appropriate
☐ Not clearly stated and can be improved
☐ Other responses, please state:Click or tap here to enter text.
Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text.
7. Does the layout of the deliverable is compliant with the project template?
☐ Compliant
☒ Can be improved
Comments/suggestion/specifications: Changes on the layout has been proposed.
8. Does the language style of the deliverable meet the required quality level?
☒ Yes
☐ Can be improved
Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text.
9. Can the deliverable benefit from additional stakeholder expectations (consortium or external
stakeholder expectations such e.g. consumers or other value chain stakeholders)?
☒ The deliverable is completely aligned with both consortium and external expectations
☐ The relevance of additional expectations can be added to the deliverable
Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text.
[30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page18
10. Does the illustrations, drawing and tables of the deliverable clear and comprehensive?
☐ Yes
☐ Can be improved
Comments/suggestion/specifications: N/A
11. Does the abbreviations, references and/or formulas of the deliverable clear and comprehensive?
☒Yes
☐ Can be improved
Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text.
Additional comments:
• Conclusion should be added at the end of the document with the main key results
and recommendation.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

CarE-Service Project Introduction and Conclusion by CNR
CarE-Service Project Introduction and Conclusion by CNRCarE-Service Project Introduction and Conclusion by CNR
CarE-Service Project Introduction and Conclusion by CNROlgaRodrguezLargo
 
CarE-Service Project: Introduction general overview and objectives
CarE-Service Project: Introduction general overview and objectives CarE-Service Project: Introduction general overview and objectives
CarE-Service Project: Introduction general overview and objectives OlgaRodrguezLargo
 
CarE-Service presentation in GoMobility2020
CarE-Service presentation in GoMobility2020CarE-Service presentation in GoMobility2020
CarE-Service presentation in GoMobility2020OlgaRodrguezLargo
 
Closing the loop: Disassembly, Testing, Remanufacturing, Second Life and Recy...
Closing the loop: Disassembly, Testing, Remanufacturing, Second Life and Recy...Closing the loop: Disassembly, Testing, Remanufacturing, Second Life and Recy...
Closing the loop: Disassembly, Testing, Remanufacturing, Second Life and Recy...OlgaRodrguezLargo
 
Requirements for innovative services and business models
Requirements for innovative services and business modelsRequirements for innovative services and business models
Requirements for innovative services and business modelsOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
Circular Economy holistic approach for used batteries of electric and hybrid-...
Circular Economy holistic approach for used batteries of electric and hybrid-...Circular Economy holistic approach for used batteries of electric and hybrid-...
Circular Economy holistic approach for used batteries of electric and hybrid-...OlgaRodrguezLargo
 
Requirements for innovative services and business models
Requirements for innovative services and business modelsRequirements for innovative services and business models
Requirements for innovative services and business modelsOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
Innovative community platform for the re-use, re-manufacturing and recycling ...
Innovative community platform for the re-use, re-manufacturing and recycling ...Innovative community platform for the re-use, re-manufacturing and recycling ...
Innovative community platform for the re-use, re-manufacturing and recycling ...OlgaRodrguezLargo
 
CarE-Service Training on Techno-polymers Recycling by Radici Group
CarE-Service Training on Techno-polymers Recycling by Radici GroupCarE-Service Training on Techno-polymers Recycling by Radici Group
CarE-Service Training on Techno-polymers Recycling by Radici GroupOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
Battery Circular Economy approaches for redesign, reuse and regulation
Battery Circular Economy approaches for redesign, reuse and regulationBattery Circular Economy approaches for redesign, reuse and regulation
Battery Circular Economy approaches for redesign, reuse and regulationOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
A circular economy model for electric vehicles batteries by Stellantis
A circular economy model for electric vehicles batteries by StellantisA circular economy model for electric vehicles batteries by Stellantis
A circular economy model for electric vehicles batteries by StellantisOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
Automotive polyamide circularity? Yes it’s feasible! Techno-polymers Recyclin...
Automotive polyamide circularity? Yes it’s feasible! Techno-polymers Recyclin...Automotive polyamide circularity? Yes it’s feasible! Techno-polymers Recyclin...
Automotive polyamide circularity? Yes it’s feasible! Techno-polymers Recyclin...OlgaRodrguezLargo
 
CarE-Service Project Introduction by FCA
CarE-Service Project Introduction by FCACarE-Service Project Introduction by FCA
CarE-Service Project Introduction by FCAOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
CarE-Service Sharing Mobility Services by E-VAI
CarE-Service Sharing Mobility Services by E-VAICarE-Service Sharing Mobility Services by E-VAI
CarE-Service Sharing Mobility Services by E-VAIOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Final Paper (2014)
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Final Paper (2014)European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Final Paper (2014)
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Final Paper (2014)Andrew Gelston
 
Analysis and specifications of re use value-chains
Analysis and specifications of re use value-chainsAnalysis and specifications of re use value-chains
Analysis and specifications of re use value-chainsOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
Data policy and management plan (First version)
Data policy and management plan (First version)Data policy and management plan (First version)
Data policy and management plan (First version)OlgaRodrguezLargo
 
The point of view of automotive remanufacturing operators by APRA Europe
The point of view of automotive remanufacturing operators by APRA EuropeThe point of view of automotive remanufacturing operators by APRA Europe
The point of view of automotive remanufacturing operators by APRA EuropeOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
Analytics and specifications of re-use value chain
Analytics and specifications of re-use value chainAnalytics and specifications of re-use value chain
Analytics and specifications of re-use value chainOlgaRodrguezLargo
 

Mais procurados (20)

Car e service-uclm
Car e service-uclmCar e service-uclm
Car e service-uclm
 
CarE-Service Project Introduction and Conclusion by CNR
CarE-Service Project Introduction and Conclusion by CNRCarE-Service Project Introduction and Conclusion by CNR
CarE-Service Project Introduction and Conclusion by CNR
 
CarE-Service Project: Introduction general overview and objectives
CarE-Service Project: Introduction general overview and objectives CarE-Service Project: Introduction general overview and objectives
CarE-Service Project: Introduction general overview and objectives
 
CarE-Service presentation in GoMobility2020
CarE-Service presentation in GoMobility2020CarE-Service presentation in GoMobility2020
CarE-Service presentation in GoMobility2020
 
Closing the loop: Disassembly, Testing, Remanufacturing, Second Life and Recy...
Closing the loop: Disassembly, Testing, Remanufacturing, Second Life and Recy...Closing the loop: Disassembly, Testing, Remanufacturing, Second Life and Recy...
Closing the loop: Disassembly, Testing, Remanufacturing, Second Life and Recy...
 
Requirements for innovative services and business models
Requirements for innovative services and business modelsRequirements for innovative services and business models
Requirements for innovative services and business models
 
Circular Economy holistic approach for used batteries of electric and hybrid-...
Circular Economy holistic approach for used batteries of electric and hybrid-...Circular Economy holistic approach for used batteries of electric and hybrid-...
Circular Economy holistic approach for used batteries of electric and hybrid-...
 
Requirements for innovative services and business models
Requirements for innovative services and business modelsRequirements for innovative services and business models
Requirements for innovative services and business models
 
Innovative community platform for the re-use, re-manufacturing and recycling ...
Innovative community platform for the re-use, re-manufacturing and recycling ...Innovative community platform for the re-use, re-manufacturing and recycling ...
Innovative community platform for the re-use, re-manufacturing and recycling ...
 
CarE-Service Training on Techno-polymers Recycling by Radici Group
CarE-Service Training on Techno-polymers Recycling by Radici GroupCarE-Service Training on Techno-polymers Recycling by Radici Group
CarE-Service Training on Techno-polymers Recycling by Radici Group
 
Battery Circular Economy approaches for redesign, reuse and regulation
Battery Circular Economy approaches for redesign, reuse and regulationBattery Circular Economy approaches for redesign, reuse and regulation
Battery Circular Economy approaches for redesign, reuse and regulation
 
A circular economy model for electric vehicles batteries by Stellantis
A circular economy model for electric vehicles batteries by StellantisA circular economy model for electric vehicles batteries by Stellantis
A circular economy model for electric vehicles batteries by Stellantis
 
Automotive polyamide circularity? Yes it’s feasible! Techno-polymers Recyclin...
Automotive polyamide circularity? Yes it’s feasible! Techno-polymers Recyclin...Automotive polyamide circularity? Yes it’s feasible! Techno-polymers Recyclin...
Automotive polyamide circularity? Yes it’s feasible! Techno-polymers Recyclin...
 
CarE-Service Project Introduction by FCA
CarE-Service Project Introduction by FCACarE-Service Project Introduction by FCA
CarE-Service Project Introduction by FCA
 
CarE-Service Sharing Mobility Services by E-VAI
CarE-Service Sharing Mobility Services by E-VAICarE-Service Sharing Mobility Services by E-VAI
CarE-Service Sharing Mobility Services by E-VAI
 
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Final Paper (2014)
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Final Paper (2014)European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Final Paper (2014)
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Final Paper (2014)
 
Analysis and specifications of re use value-chains
Analysis and specifications of re use value-chainsAnalysis and specifications of re use value-chains
Analysis and specifications of re use value-chains
 
Data policy and management plan (First version)
Data policy and management plan (First version)Data policy and management plan (First version)
Data policy and management plan (First version)
 
The point of view of automotive remanufacturing operators by APRA Europe
The point of view of automotive remanufacturing operators by APRA EuropeThe point of view of automotive remanufacturing operators by APRA Europe
The point of view of automotive remanufacturing operators by APRA Europe
 
Analytics and specifications of re-use value chain
Analytics and specifications of re-use value chainAnalytics and specifications of re-use value chain
Analytics and specifications of re-use value chain
 

Semelhante a Position paper for standardization and legislation of battery value chain of CarE-Service Project

Hydrogen policy regulations and standards
Hydrogen policy regulations and standardsHydrogen policy regulations and standards
Hydrogen policy regulations and standardsDr. Pradip Chanda
 
Bonafede aeeg ev_recharging_infrastructure_in_italy_2010 oct-19th_milano_mobi...
Bonafede aeeg ev_recharging_infrastructure_in_italy_2010 oct-19th_milano_mobi...Bonafede aeeg ev_recharging_infrastructure_in_italy_2010 oct-19th_milano_mobi...
Bonafede aeeg ev_recharging_infrastructure_in_italy_2010 oct-19th_milano_mobi...Dabon
 
Real-drive emissions and the impact of the VW scandal on the future of the au...
Real-drive emissions and the impact of the VW scandal on the future of the au...Real-drive emissions and the impact of the VW scandal on the future of the au...
Real-drive emissions and the impact of the VW scandal on the future of the au...Leonardo ENERGY
 
IRJET- Emission Effeciency of Diesel Oxidation Catalyst on a Nonroad Diesel E...
IRJET- Emission Effeciency of Diesel Oxidation Catalyst on a Nonroad Diesel E...IRJET- Emission Effeciency of Diesel Oxidation Catalyst on a Nonroad Diesel E...
IRJET- Emission Effeciency of Diesel Oxidation Catalyst on a Nonroad Diesel E...IRJET Journal
 
Development of India's Carbon Credit Market.pptx
Development of India's Carbon Credit Market.pptxDevelopment of India's Carbon Credit Market.pptx
Development of India's Carbon Credit Market.pptxmsounak95
 
Lösungen für die Klimawende // Climate Change and TransportThe potential role...
Lösungen für die Klimawende // Climate Change and TransportThe potential role...Lösungen für die Klimawende // Climate Change and TransportThe potential role...
Lösungen für die Klimawende // Climate Change and TransportThe potential role...Fachschaftsteam, TU Berlin
 
THE RACE FOR END-OF-LIFE BATTERIES AND EFFECTS OF NEW EU BATTERY REGULATIONS
THE RACE FOR END-OF-LIFE BATTERIES AND EFFECTS OF NEW EU BATTERY REGULATIONSTHE RACE FOR END-OF-LIFE BATTERIES AND EFFECTS OF NEW EU BATTERY REGULATIONS
THE RACE FOR END-OF-LIFE BATTERIES AND EFFECTS OF NEW EU BATTERY REGULATIONSiQHub
 
Requirements for generalization of the approach to EU industry
Requirements for generalization of the approach to EU industryRequirements for generalization of the approach to EU industry
Requirements for generalization of the approach to EU industryOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
White certificates: news and opportunities after 2018 review
White certificates: news and opportunities after 2018 reviewWhite certificates: news and opportunities after 2018 review
White certificates: news and opportunities after 2018 reviewDario Di Santo
 
FD 3-2021-Transport, electric transport
FD 3-2021-Transport, electric transportFD 3-2021-Transport, electric transport
FD 3-2021-Transport, electric transportUlyanaMakhova
 
Life cycle analysis for hybrid and electric vehicles
Life cycle analysis for hybrid and electric vehiclesLife cycle analysis for hybrid and electric vehicles
Life cycle analysis for hybrid and electric vehiclesRicardo Energy & Environment
 
Exploring future CO2 emission targets for cars and vans
Exploring future CO2 emission targets for cars and vansExploring future CO2 emission targets for cars and vans
Exploring future CO2 emission targets for cars and vansRicardo Energy & Environment
 
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Proposal Paper (July 2012)
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Proposal Paper (July 2012)European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Proposal Paper (July 2012)
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Proposal Paper (July 2012)Andrew Gelston
 
High energy lithium ion storage solutions
High energy lithium ion storage solutionsHigh energy lithium ion storage solutions
High energy lithium ion storage solutionsAndrew Gelston
 
Capacity charging mechanism for shared CO2 transportation and storage infrast...
Capacity charging mechanism for shared CO2 transportation and storage infrast...Capacity charging mechanism for shared CO2 transportation and storage infrast...
Capacity charging mechanism for shared CO2 transportation and storage infrast...Global CCS Institute
 
Ricardo aea comm vehs
Ricardo   aea comm vehsRicardo   aea comm vehs
Ricardo aea comm vehsRoger Atkins
 
White certificates in industry at ECEEE conference - paper
White certificates in industry at ECEEE conference - paperWhite certificates in industry at ECEEE conference - paper
White certificates in industry at ECEEE conference - paperDario Di Santo
 
The white certificates scheme in Italy: how it works
The white certificates scheme in Italy: how it worksThe white certificates scheme in Italy: how it works
The white certificates scheme in Italy: how it worksDario Di Santo
 

Semelhante a Position paper for standardization and legislation of battery value chain of CarE-Service Project (20)

Hydrogen policy regulations and standards
Hydrogen policy regulations and standardsHydrogen policy regulations and standards
Hydrogen policy regulations and standards
 
Bonafede aeeg ev_recharging_infrastructure_in_italy_2010 oct-19th_milano_mobi...
Bonafede aeeg ev_recharging_infrastructure_in_italy_2010 oct-19th_milano_mobi...Bonafede aeeg ev_recharging_infrastructure_in_italy_2010 oct-19th_milano_mobi...
Bonafede aeeg ev_recharging_infrastructure_in_italy_2010 oct-19th_milano_mobi...
 
Real-drive emissions and the impact of the VW scandal on the future of the au...
Real-drive emissions and the impact of the VW scandal on the future of the au...Real-drive emissions and the impact of the VW scandal on the future of the au...
Real-drive emissions and the impact of the VW scandal on the future of the au...
 
IRJET- Emission Effeciency of Diesel Oxidation Catalyst on a Nonroad Diesel E...
IRJET- Emission Effeciency of Diesel Oxidation Catalyst on a Nonroad Diesel E...IRJET- Emission Effeciency of Diesel Oxidation Catalyst on a Nonroad Diesel E...
IRJET- Emission Effeciency of Diesel Oxidation Catalyst on a Nonroad Diesel E...
 
Development of India's Carbon Credit Market.pptx
Development of India's Carbon Credit Market.pptxDevelopment of India's Carbon Credit Market.pptx
Development of India's Carbon Credit Market.pptx
 
Lösungen für die Klimawende // Climate Change and TransportThe potential role...
Lösungen für die Klimawende // Climate Change and TransportThe potential role...Lösungen für die Klimawende // Climate Change and TransportThe potential role...
Lösungen für die Klimawende // Climate Change and TransportThe potential role...
 
THE RACE FOR END-OF-LIFE BATTERIES AND EFFECTS OF NEW EU BATTERY REGULATIONS
THE RACE FOR END-OF-LIFE BATTERIES AND EFFECTS OF NEW EU BATTERY REGULATIONSTHE RACE FOR END-OF-LIFE BATTERIES AND EFFECTS OF NEW EU BATTERY REGULATIONS
THE RACE FOR END-OF-LIFE BATTERIES AND EFFECTS OF NEW EU BATTERY REGULATIONS
 
Requirements for generalization of the approach to EU industry
Requirements for generalization of the approach to EU industryRequirements for generalization of the approach to EU industry
Requirements for generalization of the approach to EU industry
 
Transformers
TransformersTransformers
Transformers
 
White certificates: news and opportunities after 2018 review
White certificates: news and opportunities after 2018 reviewWhite certificates: news and opportunities after 2018 review
White certificates: news and opportunities after 2018 review
 
FD 3-2021-Transport, electric transport
FD 3-2021-Transport, electric transportFD 3-2021-Transport, electric transport
FD 3-2021-Transport, electric transport
 
Life cycle analysis for hybrid and electric vehicles
Life cycle analysis for hybrid and electric vehiclesLife cycle analysis for hybrid and electric vehicles
Life cycle analysis for hybrid and electric vehicles
 
Exploring future CO2 emission targets for cars and vans
Exploring future CO2 emission targets for cars and vansExploring future CO2 emission targets for cars and vans
Exploring future CO2 emission targets for cars and vans
 
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Proposal Paper (July 2012)
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Proposal Paper (July 2012)European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Proposal Paper (July 2012)
European Green Cars Initiative Projects HELIOS Proposal Paper (July 2012)
 
High energy lithium ion storage solutions
High energy lithium ion storage solutionsHigh energy lithium ion storage solutions
High energy lithium ion storage solutions
 
Capacity charging mechanism for shared CO2 transportation and storage infrast...
Capacity charging mechanism for shared CO2 transportation and storage infrast...Capacity charging mechanism for shared CO2 transportation and storage infrast...
Capacity charging mechanism for shared CO2 transportation and storage infrast...
 
Ricardo aea comm vehs
Ricardo   aea comm vehsRicardo   aea comm vehs
Ricardo aea comm vehs
 
Market Mechanisms for White Certificates
Market Mechanisms for White CertificatesMarket Mechanisms for White Certificates
Market Mechanisms for White Certificates
 
White certificates in industry at ECEEE conference - paper
White certificates in industry at ECEEE conference - paperWhite certificates in industry at ECEEE conference - paper
White certificates in industry at ECEEE conference - paper
 
The white certificates scheme in Italy: how it works
The white certificates scheme in Italy: how it worksThe white certificates scheme in Italy: how it works
The white certificates scheme in Italy: how it works
 

Mais de OlgaRodrguezLargo

Innovative business model EVs end-of-life management by C-ECO, CNR and PROD
Innovative business model EVs end-of-life management by C-ECO, CNR and PRODInnovative business model EVs end-of-life management by C-ECO, CNR and PROD
Innovative business model EVs end-of-life management by C-ECO, CNR and PRODOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
Technologies for circular economy for metal sheets and structural parts by Fr...
Technologies for circular economy for metal sheets and structural parts by Fr...Technologies for circular economy for metal sheets and structural parts by Fr...
Technologies for circular economy for metal sheets and structural parts by Fr...OlgaRodrguezLargo
 
CarE-Service Introduction by Stellantis
CarE-Service Introduction by StellantisCarE-Service Introduction by Stellantis
CarE-Service Introduction by StellantisOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
New solutions for disassembly, remanufacturing and testing automotive metal p...
New solutions for disassembly, remanufacturing and testing automotive metal p...New solutions for disassembly, remanufacturing and testing automotive metal p...
New solutions for disassembly, remanufacturing and testing automotive metal p...OlgaRodrguezLargo
 
CarE-Service Battery Disassembling, Remanufacturing and Recycling techniques ...
CarE-Service Battery Disassembling, Remanufacturing and Recycling techniques ...CarE-Service Battery Disassembling, Remanufacturing and Recycling techniques ...
CarE-Service Battery Disassembling, Remanufacturing and Recycling techniques ...OlgaRodrguezLargo
 
CarE-Service Metals Reuse Solutions by Fraunhofer
CarE-Service Metals Reuse Solutions by FraunhoferCarE-Service Metals Reuse Solutions by Fraunhofer
CarE-Service Metals Reuse Solutions by FraunhoferOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
CarE-Service Techno-polymer recycling by Radici Group
CarE-Service Techno-polymer recycling by Radici GroupCarE-Service Techno-polymer recycling by Radici Group
CarE-Service Techno-polymer recycling by Radici GroupOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
CarE-Service ICT Platform Market Place by C-ECO and PROD
CarE-Service ICT Platform Market Place by C-ECO and PRODCarE-Service ICT Platform Market Place by C-ECO and PROD
CarE-Service ICT Platform Market Place by C-ECO and PRODOlgaRodrguezLargo
 
Analysis and specifications of re-use value chains
Analysis and specifications of re-use value chainsAnalysis and specifications of re-use value chains
Analysis and specifications of re-use value chainsOlgaRodrguezLargo
 

Mais de OlgaRodrguezLargo (9)

Innovative business model EVs end-of-life management by C-ECO, CNR and PROD
Innovative business model EVs end-of-life management by C-ECO, CNR and PRODInnovative business model EVs end-of-life management by C-ECO, CNR and PROD
Innovative business model EVs end-of-life management by C-ECO, CNR and PROD
 
Technologies for circular economy for metal sheets and structural parts by Fr...
Technologies for circular economy for metal sheets and structural parts by Fr...Technologies for circular economy for metal sheets and structural parts by Fr...
Technologies for circular economy for metal sheets and structural parts by Fr...
 
CarE-Service Introduction by Stellantis
CarE-Service Introduction by StellantisCarE-Service Introduction by Stellantis
CarE-Service Introduction by Stellantis
 
New solutions for disassembly, remanufacturing and testing automotive metal p...
New solutions for disassembly, remanufacturing and testing automotive metal p...New solutions for disassembly, remanufacturing and testing automotive metal p...
New solutions for disassembly, remanufacturing and testing automotive metal p...
 
CarE-Service Battery Disassembling, Remanufacturing and Recycling techniques ...
CarE-Service Battery Disassembling, Remanufacturing and Recycling techniques ...CarE-Service Battery Disassembling, Remanufacturing and Recycling techniques ...
CarE-Service Battery Disassembling, Remanufacturing and Recycling techniques ...
 
CarE-Service Metals Reuse Solutions by Fraunhofer
CarE-Service Metals Reuse Solutions by FraunhoferCarE-Service Metals Reuse Solutions by Fraunhofer
CarE-Service Metals Reuse Solutions by Fraunhofer
 
CarE-Service Techno-polymer recycling by Radici Group
CarE-Service Techno-polymer recycling by Radici GroupCarE-Service Techno-polymer recycling by Radici Group
CarE-Service Techno-polymer recycling by Radici Group
 
CarE-Service ICT Platform Market Place by C-ECO and PROD
CarE-Service ICT Platform Market Place by C-ECO and PRODCarE-Service ICT Platform Market Place by C-ECO and PROD
CarE-Service ICT Platform Market Place by C-ECO and PROD
 
Analysis and specifications of re-use value chains
Analysis and specifications of re-use value chainsAnalysis and specifications of re-use value chains
Analysis and specifications of re-use value chains
 

Último

Spermiogenesis or Spermateleosis or metamorphosis of spermatid
Spermiogenesis or Spermateleosis or metamorphosis of spermatidSpermiogenesis or Spermateleosis or metamorphosis of spermatid
Spermiogenesis or Spermateleosis or metamorphosis of spermatidSarthak Sekhar Mondal
 
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptx
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptxPhysiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptx
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptxAArockiyaNisha
 
Call Us ≽ 9953322196 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar(Delhi) |
Call Us ≽ 9953322196 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar(Delhi) |Call Us ≽ 9953322196 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar(Delhi) |
Call Us ≽ 9953322196 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar(Delhi) |aasikanpl
 
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​ ​
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​  ​Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​  ​
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​ ​kaibalyasahoo82800
 
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdf
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdfA relative description on Sonoporation.pdf
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdfnehabiju2046
 
Formation of low mass protostars and their circumstellar disks
Formation of low mass protostars and their circumstellar disksFormation of low mass protostars and their circumstellar disks
Formation of low mass protostars and their circumstellar disksSérgio Sacani
 
Labelling Requirements and Label Claims for Dietary Supplements and Recommend...
Labelling Requirements and Label Claims for Dietary Supplements and Recommend...Labelling Requirements and Label Claims for Dietary Supplements and Recommend...
Labelling Requirements and Label Claims for Dietary Supplements and Recommend...Lokesh Kothari
 
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroids
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroidsHubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroids
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroidsSérgio Sacani
 
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43b
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43bNightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43b
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43bSérgio Sacani
 
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Availa...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Availa...Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Availa...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Availa...anilsa9823
 
Natural Polymer Based Nanomaterials
Natural Polymer Based NanomaterialsNatural Polymer Based Nanomaterials
Natural Polymer Based NanomaterialsAArockiyaNisha
 
Recombination DNA Technology (Nucleic Acid Hybridization )
Recombination DNA Technology (Nucleic Acid Hybridization )Recombination DNA Technology (Nucleic Acid Hybridization )
Recombination DNA Technology (Nucleic Acid Hybridization )aarthirajkumar25
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Kesar Bagh Lucknow best Night Fun service 🪡
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Kesar Bagh Lucknow best Night Fun service  🪡CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Kesar Bagh Lucknow best Night Fun service  🪡
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Kesar Bagh Lucknow best Night Fun service 🪡anilsa9823
 
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCE
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCESTERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCE
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCEPRINCE C P
 
G9 Science Q4- Week 1-2 Projectile Motion.ppt
G9 Science Q4- Week 1-2 Projectile Motion.pptG9 Science Q4- Week 1-2 Projectile Motion.ppt
G9 Science Q4- Week 1-2 Projectile Motion.pptMAESTRELLAMesa2
 
Bentham & Hooker's Classification. along with the merits and demerits of the ...
Bentham & Hooker's Classification. along with the merits and demerits of the ...Bentham & Hooker's Classification. along with the merits and demerits of the ...
Bentham & Hooker's Classification. along with the merits and demerits of the ...Nistarini College, Purulia (W.B) India
 
Biopesticide (2).pptx .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...
Biopesticide (2).pptx  .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...Biopesticide (2).pptx  .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...
Biopesticide (2).pptx .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...RohitNehra6
 
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptx
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptxGFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptx
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptxAleenaTreesaSaji
 

Último (20)

Spermiogenesis or Spermateleosis or metamorphosis of spermatid
Spermiogenesis or Spermateleosis or metamorphosis of spermatidSpermiogenesis or Spermateleosis or metamorphosis of spermatid
Spermiogenesis or Spermateleosis or metamorphosis of spermatid
 
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptx
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptxPhysiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptx
Physiochemical properties of nanomaterials and its nanotoxicity.pptx
 
Call Us ≽ 9953322196 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar(Delhi) |
Call Us ≽ 9953322196 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar(Delhi) |Call Us ≽ 9953322196 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar(Delhi) |
Call Us ≽ 9953322196 ≼ Call Girls In Mukherjee Nagar(Delhi) |
 
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​ ​
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​  ​Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​  ​
Nanoparticles synthesis and characterization​ ​
 
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdf
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdfA relative description on Sonoporation.pdf
A relative description on Sonoporation.pdf
 
Formation of low mass protostars and their circumstellar disks
Formation of low mass protostars and their circumstellar disksFormation of low mass protostars and their circumstellar disks
Formation of low mass protostars and their circumstellar disks
 
Labelling Requirements and Label Claims for Dietary Supplements and Recommend...
Labelling Requirements and Label Claims for Dietary Supplements and Recommend...Labelling Requirements and Label Claims for Dietary Supplements and Recommend...
Labelling Requirements and Label Claims for Dietary Supplements and Recommend...
 
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroids
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroidsHubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroids
Hubble Asteroid Hunter III. Physical properties of newly found asteroids
 
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43b
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43bNightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43b
Nightside clouds and disequilibrium chemistry on the hot Jupiter WASP-43b
 
CELL -Structural and Functional unit of life.pdf
CELL -Structural and Functional unit of life.pdfCELL -Structural and Functional unit of life.pdf
CELL -Structural and Functional unit of life.pdf
 
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Availa...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Availa...Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Availa...
Lucknow 💋 Russian Call Girls Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 8923113531 Availa...
 
Natural Polymer Based Nanomaterials
Natural Polymer Based NanomaterialsNatural Polymer Based Nanomaterials
Natural Polymer Based Nanomaterials
 
Recombination DNA Technology (Nucleic Acid Hybridization )
Recombination DNA Technology (Nucleic Acid Hybridization )Recombination DNA Technology (Nucleic Acid Hybridization )
Recombination DNA Technology (Nucleic Acid Hybridization )
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Kesar Bagh Lucknow best Night Fun service 🪡
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Kesar Bagh Lucknow best Night Fun service  🪡CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Kesar Bagh Lucknow best Night Fun service  🪡
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Kesar Bagh Lucknow best Night Fun service 🪡
 
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCE
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCESTERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCE
STERILITY TESTING OF PHARMACEUTICALS ppt by DR.C.P.PRINCE
 
G9 Science Q4- Week 1-2 Projectile Motion.ppt
G9 Science Q4- Week 1-2 Projectile Motion.pptG9 Science Q4- Week 1-2 Projectile Motion.ppt
G9 Science Q4- Week 1-2 Projectile Motion.ppt
 
Bentham & Hooker's Classification. along with the merits and demerits of the ...
Bentham & Hooker's Classification. along with the merits and demerits of the ...Bentham & Hooker's Classification. along with the merits and demerits of the ...
Bentham & Hooker's Classification. along with the merits and demerits of the ...
 
9953056974 Young Call Girls In Mahavir enclave Indian Quality Escort service
9953056974 Young Call Girls In Mahavir enclave Indian Quality Escort service9953056974 Young Call Girls In Mahavir enclave Indian Quality Escort service
9953056974 Young Call Girls In Mahavir enclave Indian Quality Escort service
 
Biopesticide (2).pptx .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...
Biopesticide (2).pptx  .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...Biopesticide (2).pptx  .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...
Biopesticide (2).pptx .This slides helps to know the different types of biop...
 
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptx
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptxGFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptx
GFP in rDNA Technology (Biotechnology).pptx
 

Position paper for standardization and legislation of battery value chain of CarE-Service Project

  • 1. D 8.6 – Position paper for standardization and legislation – First version Project acronym CarE-service Project Title Circular Economy oriented services for re-use and remanufacturing of hybrid and electric vehicles components through smart and movable module Call H2020-CIRC-2017 Two Stage (IA) Grant Agreement n. 776851 Relative Number in WP D8.6 Deliverable Title Position paper for standardization and legislation – First version Lead Beneficiary COBSER Deliverable Type Report Dissemination level Public Due date M18 Submission date 30/11/2019 This project has received funding from the European Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the grant agreement No 776851 Ref. Ares(2019)7388059 - 30/11/2019
  • 2. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 1 Additional document information Authors: Luigi De Rocchi (COBSER) Contributing partners: CNR-STIIMA (Nicoletta Picone, Elena Mossali, Giacomo Copani), FCA (Alessandro Levizzari, Silvia Lazzari, Envirobat (Juan Manuel Perez), JRC (Franco Di Persio), C- ECO (Michael Bolech, Konstantinos Georgopoulos). Keywords: EV batteries, de-manufacturing, testing and certification, re-manufacturing, recycling, extended producer responsibility (EPR), legislation, standardization. Versioning and contribution history Version Organization Comment Date 1.0 COBSER 1st draft 21/11/2019 2.0 ENVIROBAT 2nd draft 25/11/2019 3.0 JRC 3rd draft 25/11/2019 4.0 FCA Deliverable Review by FCA 25/11/2019 5.0 C-ECO Deliverable Review by C-ECO 27/11/2019 Executive Summary This deliverable is directly consequential to D8.5 - Standardization and legislation plans and actions, consisting on the analysis of the state of the art of the current legislation and standard regulations in general concerning technical and legal requirements, together with safety issues, relative to disassembly and re-manufacturing, transportation and storage of reusable/recyclable parts and components, extended producer responsibility (EPR) regarding new parts and products put on the market. These topics were mainly focused on the batteries value chain by identifying limits and barriers of the current legislation and standard regulations for the development of CarE Service project, and furthermore by elaborating proposals to remove these limits and barriers with the clear indications of potential benefit associated. The contents of D8.5 were used to elaborate this deliverable as a formal position paper with proposals on legislation and standard regulations to be submitted to the relevant European stakeholders (CEN- CENELEC, Standardization Committee, National and Regional Authorities, European Commission). D8.6 is a living and dynamic document due to the upcoming changes in the EU regulations for the revision of the Battery Directive, the ELV Directive and the battery sustainability initiatives. Thus, this is the first version of D8.6, potentially upgradeable up to the end of the CarE-Service project (M36).
  • 3. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 2 Table of Contents List of Acronyms 3 1 INTRODUCTION AND OBJECT 4 2 PROPOSALS TO REMOVE LIMITS AND BARRIERS 5 2.1 Proposals to remove legal and administrative gaps........................................................................ 5 2.1.1 EPR (Extended Producer Responsibility) transferability 5 2.1.2 “End of Waste” regulation 6 2.1.3 Harmonization required between ELV Directive, new Battery Directive, Directive 2005/64/EC and REACH regulations 7 2.2 Proposals to remove technical gaps................................................................................................ 8 2.2.1 Requirements for the manufacturing phase 8 2.2.2 Requirements for “End of Waste” status and second use 8 2.2.3 Requirements for improved efficiency in the recovery of materials 9 3 CONCLUSIONS 10 Review of the Deliverable by FCA ............................................................................................................11 Review of the Deliverable by C-ECO.........................................................................................................15
  • 4. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 3 List of Acronyms ACEA European Automobile Manufacturers' Association (French: Association des Constructeurs Européens d'Automobiles) ANSI American National Standards Institute BD Battery Directive 2006/66/EU BMS Battery Management System CE Conformité Européenne (Certification mark applicable in the European Economic Area) CEN European Committee for Standardization (French: Comité Européen de Normalisation) CENELEC European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization (French: Comité Européen de Normalisation Électrotechnique) E&HEV Electric and Hybrid electric vehicles EC European Commission ELV End-of-life Vehicle EoL End-of-Life EoW End-of-Waste EPR Extended Producer responsibility EU European Union EV Electric vehicle GTR(s) Global Technical Regulations HV Hybrid Vehicle IEC International Electrotechnical Commission IMDS International Material Data System LFP Lithium Iron Phosphate(LiFePO4) Li-batteries Lithium batteries Li-Ion Lithium-Ion NCA Lithium Nickel Cobalt Aluminium Oxide (LiNiCoAlO2) Ni-Cd Nickel- Cadmium Ni-MH Nickel metal hydride battery NMC Lithium Nickel Manganese Cobalt Oxide (LiNiMnCoO2) OEM Original Equipment Manufacturer RE Recycling Efficiency REACH Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals SoH State-of-Health
  • 5. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 4 1 INTRODUCTION AND OBJECT Deliverable 8.5 focused on the analysis of the current legislation and standards (concerning legal, safety and technical requirements about de-manufacturing and re-manufacturing, transportation and storage of reusable/recyclable parts and components, extended producer responsibility (EPR) for new parts and products put on the market), in order to identify limits and barriers for the development of CarE Service project and to exploit the potentials of circular economy of E&HEVs. Considering the three main streams of CarE Service project (batteries, metal parts and techno-polymers), the real criticalities concerned mainly the batteries stream; this is the reason why D8.5 focused exclusively on the batteries value chain. In D8.5 precise limitations and barriers posed by the existing standardization and regulatory framework for the implementation of the most important targets regarding batteries in the CarE Service project were identified, with the aim of proposing solutions to remove them. Two main frameworks were in general identified to highlight existing limits and barriers: • Legal and administrative: relative to important lack of 'design and use' requirements to enhance battery sustainability, lack of coherence between different regulatory instruments, to ensure smooth functioning of the internal market for batteries, waste batteries and materials obtained from recycled batteries and how to facilitate the use of batteries in second-life applications. • Technical: relative to significant gaps regarding manufacturing requirements in order to maximize re-use and second-life applications, and also gaps regarding requirements for second-life applications. Furthermore, very important gaps were also identified for the final recycling and recovery of waste batteries. This deliverable, by using the contents and results of D.8.5, is an official position paper with specific proposals on legislation and standard regulations to be submitted to the relevant European stakeholders (CEN-CENELEC, Standardization Committee, National and Regional Authorities, ACEA, European Commission), in order to remove limits and barriers for the development of some basic processes along the batteries value chain in CarE-Service project.
  • 6. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 5 2 PROPOSALS TO REMOVE LIMITS AND BARRIERS 2.1 Proposals to remove legal and administrative gaps 2.1.1 EPR (Extended Producer Responsibility) transferability EPR is the principle according to which producers are responsible for the correct management of waste generated by the put on the market of their products. Currently, the responsibility for the correct management of an end-of-life battery is laying on the first producer which put it on the market (where “first producer”, according to the law, is any person in a Member State that, irrespective of the selling technique used, places batteries or accumulators, including those incorporated into appliances or vehicles, on the market for the first time); EPR isn’t transferable, and no one can get it. The actor who is putting on the market a second-life battery pack, should bear obligations pertinent to their responsibility as a producer, including the possibility of full or partial transfer of the EPR from the first producer to the second one. The original assumptions are the following: • in the National Register, together with the other information requested, it should be provided (at least for industrial and automotive batteries) the declaration of the serial number of the battery • the legislation in force should introduce the concept of the “Authorized representative” for foreign producer Starting from these original assumptions, we can have two different scenarios: 1- Reuse of the battery as product (no end-of-life) The battery can be addressed to second applications without becoming waste. The different options can be the following: a) The battery is sold/delivered by the first producer (for instance the car manufacturer) to a second producer in the same country The second producer indicates in the National Register the serial number of the battery that he received from the first producer, also with the percentage of the weight of the battery concretely re-used. The first producer must confirm in the National Register its agreement to the EPR transferring (total or partial). 1. The joint declaration between the first and second producer validate the EPR transfer (total or partial); 2. The second producer must declare on the National Register the new second-life battery put on the market, attributing to it a new brand and a new serial number and becoming totally responsible for its end-of-life management (new EPR).
  • 7. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 6 b) The battery is sold/delivered by the first producer (for instance the car manufacturer) to a second producer in a foreign country 1. The first producer must indicate in its National Register the serial number of the battery to be sold/delivered through its “Authorized Representative” to a second producer in a new country. Then the first producer must report in the foreign National Register (to which is obliged to enroll through its “Authorized Representative”) the battery put on the market, with its serial number. In that way, the record with all the information regarding the battery put on the market moves from the National Register in the original country to the National Register in the foreign country. EPR moves from the first country to the second one being assumed by the “Authorized Representative”, which assumes in the new country the role of first producer. 2. The following steps are the same of the previous point “a”. For the “reusers”, i.e. actors willing to work with batteries for a second life, a “license” should be required that guarantees equal conditions for handling the batteries (e.g. electrical safety of the facilities, staff well instructed, fire extinguish controls, user warranties) with a “EU manufactured Stamp” as a sign of high quality. 2- Re-use of the battery declared waste (end-of-life) If the battery has been declared waste, for instance by a car’s dismantler, it cannot be re-used without applying to it the End-of-Waste status (see the following paragraph). If the battery respects all the technical and safety requirements to be reclassified from waste to good, the EPR transfer will follow the steps of the points “a” and “b” described above. 2.1.2 “End of Waste” regulation The possibility of reusing (totally or partially) an end-of-life battery coming from an electrified vehicle, which is a waste, for a different application, should provide the application of the “end-of-waste” status. Second use of batteries fulfils the End-of-Waste criteria (as they defined in Article 6, §1 of Waste Framework Directive 2008/98/EC) which are described as follows: a. the substance or object is commonly used for specific purposes: Several studies and analysis indicate that end-of-life HEV-EVs batteries may still have residual charge capacity (75-80%) to be suitable for new second-life applications, for instance in energy storage. The intrinsic lower capacity of the batteries/modules/cells isn’t a critical gap for energy storage applications in which the need of space is not a fundamental issue (unlike in automotive applications) and the residual gap can be easily solved with the implementation of more battery packs. b. there is an existing market or demand for the substance or object: The strong development of renewable sources, firmly sustained in Europe by specific programs and energy politics, already needs new big systems to store the produced energy, and forecasts show exponential increasing
  • 8. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 7 for the future. The growth in demand for electrical storage systems can be supplied by end-of-life batteries coming from the growing market of electrified mobility, in a virtuosic circular economy perspective. c. the use is lawful (substance or object fulfils the technical requirements for the specific purposes and meets the existing legislation and standards applicable to products): Even if the original battery is de-manufactured, the original cells are left intact and they have to be checked and tested before being re-manufactured in a new battery pack. Technical and safety standards in second-life batteries must be compliant with the same requirements foreseen for a new battery d. the use will not lead to overall adverse environmental or human health impacts: Cells or modules correctly checked and tested, then re-manufactured in new second-life batteries in accordance to the same technical and safety standards of a new battery, should not pose any risk for the environment or human health. These assumptions had been adopted in The Netherlands by the Ministry of Infrastructure and Environment, specifically with the “Legal judgement End-of-Waste status lithium-ion cells” of 22 September 2017, Reference IENM/BSK-2017/215501. 2.1.3 Harmonization required between ELV Directive, new Battery Directive, Directive 2005/64/EC and REACH regulations Regulations concerning reusability of batteries involve different legislative frameworks. In End-of-life Vehicle Directive and Waste Framework Directive some definitions of “re-use are provided”, however in the Battery Directive is missed as in any other waste legislations. It is also of utmost importance to clarify the meaning of some terms often used as synonymous like re-use, second use, repurposing, refurbishment, reconditioning, redesigning etc.; for each of them, specific regulations should be provided. Regarding the International Material Data System (the automobile industry's material data system used by almost all the global OEMs), the information and calculation required for the recycling type approval process and the corresponding recycling targets should be harmonized with the Battery Directive requirements. And referring to the hazardous substances eventually included in the EV battery, they should be exclusively dealt within the REACH regulation. Furthermore, the dismantling documentation required by the ELV Directive should include the dismantling information of the EV battery pack. In addition to these, it’s useful to highlight that ELV Directive 2000/53/EC regulates all recycling relevant items around the design/production, use/repair and EoL-phase of vehicles and its components: all batteries and accumulators used in a vehicle are included. On another hand the current Battery Directive includes again batteries used in vehicles and it regulates identical items like recycling quotas, takeback obligations, labeling and the restricted use of hazardous substances.
  • 9. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 8 Having this regulated twice does not add value for the environment, but leads to confusion in practice where still clarity is lacking and harmonization would be important. 2.2 Proposals to remove technical gaps 2.2.1 Requirements for the manufacturing phase Reusability of batteries, including the possibility of reusing single modules or cells, is more technical and economical sustainable the easier can be the disassembling of the battery and the testing of its parts and components. Regarding design for easy disassembling, testing, repairing, repurposing of EV batteries, the following technical issues could be highlighted with suggestions on how to address them: • The assembly of the battery pack should follow a modular approach with a ubiquitous access to all the modules, cells and electric/electronic components to ensure easy testing and dismantling. • To allow an easy disassembly of modules and cells it is suggested to use screws or other Plug-&-Play systems for easy electrical disconnection instead of welding. • Improved information and coding (e.g. type of screws, HV components, steps to follow in the dismantling process). • The supporting systems should not hinder the dismantling operations (e.g. cooling system, low voltage hardware, cabling and feedthroughs). • Easiness of dismantling should not hinder safety and functional aspects (e.g. gas tightness, location of the pressure release valve, location and easy access to the main HV disconnection plug, structural strength and integrity of the battery pack, efficient thermal management) • Ensure a clear labelling containing information on chemistries and other relevant features of the pack (e.g. nominal voltage, capacity, weight). Currently the standard IEC 62902 is limited to mark only the main battery technologies (e.g. lead-acid, Ni-MH, Li-ion, Li-metal, Ni-Cd); the marking should also include the Li-ion cathode (e.g. LFP, NxMyCz, NCA) and anode (e.g. Graphite, Si content) chemistries. • Ensure a BMS partial open access for retrieving of SoH and battery lifetime relevant information including the usage of the EV battery. The European Commission promoted an “Ecodesign” preparatory Study for Batteries, which started in September 2018 (ref: https://ecodesignbatteries.eu/welcome) and expected to be completed by middle 2020, remembering that regulation of electric vehicle batteries under the Ecodesign Directive should not be applied as the same Ecodesign Directive is not applicable to products that are designed only for use in a means of transport for persons or goods. All the proposals hereby suggested above could be included in the aforementioned study. 2.2.2 Requirements for “End of Waste” status and second use In order to correctly apply the “End of Waste” status on batteries for re-using purposes, safety and technical standard regulations need to be adopted, and specifically:
  • 10. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page 9 1) Standard procedures for the “state of health” evaluation of EoL batteries, modules and cells to be re-used in second-life applications. 2) The production of second-life battery packs shall meet the same requirements of the new industrial batteries, especially in terms of safety. The only existing standard that specifically cover the second use option is the ANSI/CAN/UL 1974, however may be resource and time consuming; a faster/more reliable check it may be necessary. The impedance-based measurements and evaluation methods should be considered (see LibForSecUse project1 ). Once tested, a proper labelling for SoH classification for repurposed battery may be necessary to be developed, both for getting cheaper transportation costs and for more precise assignment to a specific second use application. The regulatory framework defined in the context of Health and Safety at Work and Fire Safety measures in buildings and industrial activity should allow a safe operation for the dismantling of EV battery packs. Once the EV battery (either the full pack, modules or cells) is repurposed for a stationary storage second use application there are some concern regarding safety of the stationary storage systems. The process for a clear regulatory mandatory framework (e.g. equivalent to the EV safety GTR) for the stationary energy storage system, especially addressing the lithium-ion technology should be initiated. 2.2.3 Requirements for improved efficiency in the recovery of materials A circular economy approach to secure access to secondary raw materials through recycling may give strategic leverage to the future EU cell manufacturing industry. In this sense, a clear decision of fostering those processes that look for recovering compounds to be used again in battery manufacturing would be fostered. A RE measured in terms of recovery rate of the different materials composing the batteries entering the recycling facility seems more appropriate. However, in this point it has to be very taken with careful the idea that “the higher RE the best”. Sometimes, a higher RE in terms of recovered materials does not warranty the best environmental protection and, it can be at the same time much more dangerous in terms of resources needed for recycling. On the other hand, the recycling industry is looking for higher recovery rate only for those materials that can maximize their benefit (e.g. cobalt, nickel, copper), since usually higher recovery rate come with higher cost. Therefore, RE should address mentioned concepts: • Number of chemical compounds ready to be used in Battery Manufacturing Industry. 1 https://www.ptb.de/empir2018/libforsecuse/project/overview/ (accessed November 2019)
  • 11. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page10 • Environmental impact of the process in terms of energy consuming, emissions and waste generation. • Promote the recovery of many compounds and materials as possible. • The possibility of reusing directly some compounds of the batteries (e.g. casing, BMS, etc.) The possibility to include a minimum recycled content in the manufacturing of new cells. However, a big barrier could be the difficulties in the traceability for battery’s secondary raw materials and the technical challenge to have an economically viable recycling processes to allow the production of battery grade secondary raw materials. 3 CONCLUSIONS The different solutions proposed in this position paper aim to remove legal and technical barriers for the development of the CarE-Service project, in particular to increase the opportunity to reuse end-of-life batteries, coming from electrified vehicles, for second life applications. The illustrated solutions have been defined thinking of their concrete applicability depending, above all, on the various regulatory revisions in progress, some of which already containing updates and new regulations in line with these proposals. Precisely this last aspect gives hope that these proposals can be more easily accepted by the reference institutional stakeholders to whom this position paper is addressed. As legislative revisions are imminent and will evolve in the coming months, this is the first version of the position paper that could potentially be upgradeable until the end of the CarE-Service project.
  • 12. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page11 Review of the Deliverable D 8.6 – Position paper for standardization and legislation Reviewer Name Levizzari Alessandro Reviewer Organization FCA Deliverable lead beneficiary Luigi De Rocchi (COBSER) Due date of the deliverable 30/11/2019 Received date of the deliverable by the lead beneficiary 25/11/2019 Submission date of the review 25/11/2018 Overall Assessment of the deliverable ⃝ The required level of quality is met and the deliverable put forward additional insights which can be beneficial for the progress of the project. X The required level of quality is met perfectly and no major improvement is needed. I suggested some minor improvements. ⃝ The required level of quality is met but there are major improvements to be made before submission of the deliverable. ⃝ In order to meet the required level of quality of the deliverable, I have major concerns that may delay the submission of the deliverable. This project has received funding from the European Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the grant agreement No 776851
  • 13. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page12 Review assessment 1. Is the information contained in the deliverable technically sound and complete? X Yes ⃝ Can be improved Comments/suggestion/specifications: 2. Is any critical information missing in the content of the deliverable? X No ⃝ Yes Comments/suggestion/specifications: 3. Does the deliverable compliant with the relevant project objectives, targets and KPIs related to its topic? X Clearly stated and compliant ⃝ Clearly stated but compliancy can be improved ⃝ Not clearly stated but compliant ⃝ Not clearly stated and compliancy can be improved ⃝ Other responses, please state: Comments/suggestion/specifications: 4. Does the objective of the deliverable is clearly stated and compliant with the relevant project objectives, targets and KPIs related to its topic? X Clearly stated and compliant ⃝ Clearly stated but compliancy can be improved ⃝ Not clearly stated but compliant ⃝ Not clearly stated and compliancy can be improved ⃝ Other responses, please state: Comments/suggestion/specifications: 5. Does the method of the deliverable is clearly stated and appropriate for the scope and objective of the deliverable? X Clearly stated and appropriate ⃝ Clearly stated but can be improved ⃝ Not clearly stated but appropriate ⃝ Not clearly stated and can be improved ⃝ Other responses, please state: Comments/suggestion/specifications:
  • 14. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page13 6. Does the key messages and results of the deliverable are clearly stated and compliant with the relevant project objectives, targets and KPIs related to its topic? X Clearly stated and compliant ⃝ Clearly stated but compliancy can be improved ⃝ Not clearly stated but compliant ⃝ Not clearly stated and compliancy can be improved ⃝ Other responses, please state: Comments/suggestion/specifications: 7. Does the layout of the deliverable is compliant with the project template? X Compliant ⃝ Can be improved Comments/suggestion/specifications: 8. Does the language style of the deliverable meet the required quality level? ⃝ Yes X Can be improved Comments/suggestion/specifications: The style can be improved and, above all, some general conclusions have to be added. 9. Can the deliverable benefit from additional stakeholder expectations (consortium or external stakeholder expectations such e.g. consumers or other value chain stakeholders)? ⃝ The deliverable is completely aligned with both consortium and external expectations X The relevance of additional expectations can be added to the deliverable Comments/suggestion/specifications: 10. Does the illustrations, drawing and tables of the deliverable clear and comprehensive? X Yes ⃝ Can be improved Comments/suggestion/specifications:
  • 15. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page14 11. Does the abbreviations, references and/or formulas of the deliverable clear and comprehensive? X Yes ⃝ Can be improved Comments/suggestion/specifications: Additional comments/suggestions: e.g. o any other concept is too generically described and requires details and specifications. o non-homogeneity of the approach with other project activities o lack of clarity in how the task feeds the demonstrators o lack of hints on contribution to future tasks of the project o lack of innovation sources of a tool/method o lack of differentiation of previous projects and new developments o lack of potential exploitation routes o The approach is disconnected from the overall project rationale o The extendibility of the results to other scenarios is not discussed o The difference from the initial situation and the output KPIs are not properly measured. o The implementations are only weakly connected to the overall project objectives and targets.
  • 16. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page15 Review of the Deliverable D 8.6 – Position paper for standardization and legislation – First version Reviewer Name Konstantinos Georgopoulos Reviewer Organization C-ECO Deliverable lead beneficiary COBSER Due date of the deliverable 29.11.2019 Received date of the deliverable by the lead beneficiary 25.11.2019 Submission date of the review 27.11.2019 Overall Assessment of the deliverable ☒ The required level of quality is met and the deliverable put forward additional insights which can be beneficial for the progress of the project. ☐ The required level of quality is met perfectly and no major improvement is needed. I suggested some minor improvements. ☐ The required level of quality is met but there are major improvements to be made before submission of the deliverable. ☐ In order to meet the required level of quality of the deliverable, I have major concerns that may delay the submission of the deliverable. This project has received funding from the European Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the grant agreement No 776851
  • 17. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page16 Review assessment 1. Is the information contained in the deliverable technically sound and complete? ☒ Yes ☐ Can be improved Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text. 2. Is any critical information missing in the content of the deliverable? ☒ No ☐ Yes Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text. 3. Does the deliverable compliant with the relevant project objectives, targets and KPIs related to its topic? ☒ Clearly stated and compliant ☐ Clearly stated but compliancy can be improved ☐ Not clearly stated but compliant ☐ Not clearly stated and compliancy can be improved ☐ Other responses, please state:Click or tap here to enter text. Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text. 4. Does the objective of the deliverable is clearly stated and compliant with the relevant project objectives, targets and KPIs related to its topic? ☒ Clearly stated and compliant ☐ Clearly stated but compliancy can be improved ☐ Not clearly stated but compliant ☐ Not clearly stated and compliancy can be improved ☐ Other responses, please state:Click or tap here to enter text. Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text.
  • 18. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page17 5. Does the method of the deliverable is clearly stated and appropriate for the scope and objective of the deliverable? ☒ Clearly stated and appropriate ☐ Clearly stated but can be improved ☐ Not clearly stated but appropriate ☐ Not clearly stated and can be improved ☐ Other responses, please state:Click or tap here to enter text. Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text. 6. Does the key messages and results of the deliverable are clearly stated and compliant with the relevant project objectives, targets and KPIs related to its topic? ☒ Clearly stated and appropriate ☐ Clearly stated but can be improved ☐ Not clearly stated but appropriate ☐ Not clearly stated and can be improved ☐ Other responses, please state:Click or tap here to enter text. Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text. 7. Does the layout of the deliverable is compliant with the project template? ☐ Compliant ☒ Can be improved Comments/suggestion/specifications: Changes on the layout has been proposed. 8. Does the language style of the deliverable meet the required quality level? ☒ Yes ☐ Can be improved Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text. 9. Can the deliverable benefit from additional stakeholder expectations (consortium or external stakeholder expectations such e.g. consumers or other value chain stakeholders)? ☒ The deliverable is completely aligned with both consortium and external expectations ☐ The relevance of additional expectations can be added to the deliverable Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text.
  • 19. [30.11.2019] [CarE-Service GA No.: 776851] Page18 10. Does the illustrations, drawing and tables of the deliverable clear and comprehensive? ☐ Yes ☐ Can be improved Comments/suggestion/specifications: N/A 11. Does the abbreviations, references and/or formulas of the deliverable clear and comprehensive? ☒Yes ☐ Can be improved Comments/suggestion/specifications: Click or tap here to enter text. Additional comments: • Conclusion should be added at the end of the document with the main key results and recommendation.