1. The State of CSR in the
United States
Larry Catá Backer (白 轲)
W. Richard and Mary Eshelman Faculty Scholar Professor of Law and International Affairs
Pennsylvania State University
239 Lewis Katz Building, University Park, PA 16802
Workshop on Corporate Social Responsibility
and Regulation: Comparative Perspectives
City University of Hong Kong
December 14, 2015
2. Presentation Roadmap
• Historical Context
• Current Legal Foundations
• Current Legal Structures
• Beyond Legality
• Contradictions and Battlegrounds
• Conclusion
3. Historical Context
• Corporate Purpose
• Shareholder
• Stakeholder
• State
• Corporate Personality
• Property in the hands of shareholders
• Autonomous institutional actor
• Creature of the state
4. Foundation of Current Legal Approaches
• Relationship between enterprises and the state
• Corporate autonomy
• Legality as the basic framework
• Compliance
• Fiduciary duty (but to whom?)
• Territoriality
5. Current Legal Structures of CSR
• Charity
• Embedded in tax code
• Tied to shareholder/enterprise welfare maximization
• Ethics
• Corruption
• Surveillance
• Operational codes of conduct tied to director fiduciary obligations
• Sustainability
• Tied to the ·”business case”
6. Beyond Legality
• Soft Law Frameworks
• International (OECD, UNGP)
• Proprietary (Ethics Codes Codes)
• Private third party standards (Certification)
• Obligations Within Supply Chains
• Supplier Codes
• International (OECD, UNGP)
• Incorporation into Surveillance and Anti-Terror networks
7. Current Contradictions and Battlegrounds
• The Business and Human Rights Project
• Changing nature/sources of the CSR obligations of corporations
• Internationalization of U.S. Courts as new global CSR remedial mechanism
• Alien Tort Claims Act
• Legalization of CSR
• Disclosure regimes
• Benefit corporations
• Internationalization of legalization movement
• Treaty
• Remedial mechanisms
• Supply chains
• Veil piercing
• Enterprise law
8. Conclusion
• Still large gap between
international CSR community
and US national context
• Premises of US legal structures
substantially constrain
legalization of CSR
• Internationalization faces large
hurdles within US legal
framework
• US willingness to ratify and
transpose unclear
• Societal frameworks changing
much more rapidly
• Remedial mechanisms still
grounded in legal-national
obligation
• Taste for extraterritoriality
mixed
• Statutes broader
• Judicial reticence