SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 10
AS THE TEAMS HEAD BRASS
- EDWARD THOMAS
Page 180
Katia Scarpignato
EDWARD THOMAS
   Phillip Edward Thomas was an Anglo-Welsh
    writer of prose and poetry. He is commonly
    considered a war poet, although few of his
    poems deal directly with his war experiences.
    Already an accomplished writer, Thomas turned
    to poetry only in 1914. He enlisted in the army
    in 1915, and was killed in action during the
    Battle of Arras in 1917, soon after he arrived in
    France.
   In three years, he had written a lifetime's
    poetry. The unusual shape of Thomas's poetic
    career - at once belated and tragically up-to-
    date - has made it difficult for critics to place
    him.
   Thomas wrote „As the team‟s head brass‟ when
    he was on the cusp of deciding to finish his
    working with maps and to enlist in the army to
    fight in France.
                                                        1878-
                                                        1917
CONTEXT AND INITIAL IMPRESSION

   What the poem is about:

   As a couple walk together into the woods beyond, a walker rests at the
    edge of a field. There, a farmer is methodically ploughing his fields with a
    team of horses, and the narrator and farmer fall into conversation about
    the war.
   As the Team‟s Head Brass: The „team‟ are a pair of horses led by the
    farmer, pulling a plough. The farmer is preparing his land for the sowing
    of crops; in some ways, this seems to be a timeless agricultural scene.
    The “head brass” are the metal bridles around the horses‟ heads that
    allow the horses to be led.
   Initial Impression
   The readers first impression was that Thomas was recalling this event.
    The poem tells story, the realism is depicted by adding intricate details
    such as the „lovers disappeared into the woods‟. The first person
    narrative used here enriches the poets recollection, it also adds realism
    to the event. As the teams head Brass boarder's the questions of human
    existence, survival, memory, and 'home' - which accounts for its
    continuing influence today.
THEMES
   The use of Nature

   Indifference of War

   Futility of War

   Love

   Memory

   Human existence
ANALYSIS- STRUCTURE
   This is a narrative poem— it tells a short story. It is written in
    Iambic Pentameter, and has a Shakespearian feel to it: everyday
    events and dialogue are elevated to high poetry by Thomas‟ feel
    for the significance of small things.

   “As the team‟s head brass flashed out on the turn”: Time is
    important in this poem. The poem throws us into events
    immediately occurring.. “I sat… and watched”: the peaceful
    watching of the narrator as time passes by gives this poem a
    thoughtful, ponderous(without liveliness) tone.

   The use of enjambment (running lines) is used as though
    Thomas is unravelling his story, each line is a continuation. The
    use of narrative is cathartic as though Thomas is revealing a
    story that he feels is an important story to tell.
   The blizzard felled the elm…”: Thomas preserves the iambic
    pentameter here as he moves forward in his narrative, beginning
    a new line below. There is a sense of time having passed, but
    also of continuity.
ANALYSIS- IMAGERY
   “Watched the plough narrowing a yellow square of charlock”:
    charlock, or wild mustard, is a weed that must be cleared on
    land for farming. Thomas‟ description of the “yellow square” of
    weed is precise and vivid. Thomas suggests at first the peace
    of the country as opposed to the cataclysm of World War One
    but only does so to subvert(undermine) those conventions
    through a realistic depiction of the effects of the war. English
    agriculture had been in a long, steep decline since the mid-
    Victorian age. The countryside was a difficult place to live in
    1916: This fact the reader feels, is rather than an idealisation
    of the country life which comes through in Thomas‟ poem.
   “The lovers disappeared into the wood.”: Lovers appear again
    as key figures in a Thomas poem. We only see them at the
    beginning and the end of the poem, but they are important
    symbols of love, life and importantly rebirth.
ANALYSIS- LANGUAGE
   Now if he had stayed here we should have moved the tree.”
    (referring the friend the famer lost)The irony is really at the
    heart of the poem‟s narrative. The tragedy of the farmer‟s
    friend‟s death is dominant in the poem, but is overcast by the
    tragedy of the War.
   “Then the lovers came out of the wood again‟‟. The repetition
    of the „lovers‟ seems to reinforce a sense of hope at the end of
    the poem.
   „The blizzard‟ This is significant because the use of pathetic
    fallacy demonstrates that catastrophe that is the War
    surrounding them. The blizzard becomes symbolic and linked
    to the devastating to the effects of the fighting on the front.
   „I watched the clods crumble and topple over‟ . The narrator in
    the action of the plough now seems linked to change of the
    war. The crumbling clods of earth and their toppling as they
    fall from the plough suggest the change in the world by
    humans; perhaps also suggesting the falling of men to earth in
    fields abroad.
ANALYSIS
   One minute and an interval of ten…”: The rhythm of the
    encounter is slow. The repetition emphasises this.

   “Only two teams work on the farm this year…”: The
    significance of the single farmer working this large field
    made it clear the shortage caused by the war. This
    practical aspect is made immediately personal by the
    farmer‟s dead friend.
   “…the stumbling team.”: The last line of the poem is
    significant because the “stumbling” of the team suggest
    the difficulty the farmer continues to face, and the loose
    footing of life itself.
   „„One of my mates is dead. The second day
    In France they killed him‟‟. The use of clipped syntax
    stops the flow of the poem which suggests the farmer is
    remembering the tragic death of his friend.
A PHASE THAT STANDS OUT TO THE
READER:


‘‘Then the lovers came out of the woods again’’. The
repetition of the ‘lovers’ seems to reinforce a sense of
hope at the end of the poem.
However it could also suggest how the youth were
blissfully unaware of the destruction that was
occurring around them. In times of havoc, the ‘lovers’
are continuing with their normal rituals and the reader
feels as though how did people continue in such a
normal fashion when a War is surrounding them. ?
Perhaps this is the heart of the message that Thomas
conveys, life goes on and whatever happens we must
try to move on and continue with our lives as best we
can.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Charles Dickens's Life and Works
Charles Dickens's Life and WorksCharles Dickens's Life and Works
Charles Dickens's Life and WorksDevangibagohil
 
Romeo and juliet introduction powerpoint
Romeo and juliet introduction powerpointRomeo and juliet introduction powerpoint
Romeo and juliet introduction powerpointLisa
 
William shakespeare
William shakespeareWilliam shakespeare
William shakespeareRahila Khan
 
Diana, Princess of Wales
Diana, Princess of WalesDiana, Princess of Wales
Diana, Princess of Walesmsanz126
 
Edgar Allan Poe by Mike Cress
Edgar Allan Poe by Mike CressEdgar Allan Poe by Mike Cress
Edgar Allan Poe by Mike Cressmikecress
 
Pride & Prejudice by Nish
Pride & Prejudice by NishPride & Prejudice by Nish
Pride & Prejudice by Nishnishiraa24
 
The Legend Of King Arthur
The Legend Of King ArthurThe Legend Of King Arthur
The Legend Of King ArthurLaurieMoody
 
Henry VIII
Henry VIIIHenry VIII
Henry VIIIneni
 
Introduction to Elizabethan Era
Introduction to Elizabethan EraIntroduction to Elizabethan Era
Introduction to Elizabethan EraJenny Smith
 
Proiectul meu despre Iancu de Hunedoara
Proiectul meu despre Iancu de HunedoaraProiectul meu despre Iancu de Hunedoara
Proiectul meu despre Iancu de HunedoaraAnton Beatrice
 
WHO IS APHRODITE
WHO IS APHRODITEWHO IS APHRODITE
WHO IS APHRODITEEcemAteci
 

Mais procurados (20)

Charles Dickens's Life and Works
Charles Dickens's Life and WorksCharles Dickens's Life and Works
Charles Dickens's Life and Works
 
Romeo and juliet introduction powerpoint
Romeo and juliet introduction powerpointRomeo and juliet introduction powerpoint
Romeo and juliet introduction powerpoint
 
William shakespeare
William shakespeareWilliam shakespeare
William shakespeare
 
Aphrodite
AphroditeAphrodite
Aphrodite
 
King Tut
King TutKing Tut
King Tut
 
Diana, Princess of Wales
Diana, Princess of WalesDiana, Princess of Wales
Diana, Princess of Wales
 
The Restoration age
The Restoration ageThe Restoration age
The Restoration age
 
Jane Austen
Jane AustenJane Austen
Jane Austen
 
Medieval drama
Medieval dramaMedieval drama
Medieval drama
 
Alfred, Lord Tennyson
Alfred, Lord TennysonAlfred, Lord Tennyson
Alfred, Lord Tennyson
 
Edgar Allan Poe by Mike Cress
Edgar Allan Poe by Mike CressEdgar Allan Poe by Mike Cress
Edgar Allan Poe by Mike Cress
 
Pride & Prejudice by Nish
Pride & Prejudice by NishPride & Prejudice by Nish
Pride & Prejudice by Nish
 
The Legend Of King Arthur
The Legend Of King ArthurThe Legend Of King Arthur
The Legend Of King Arthur
 
Le morte darthur
Le morte darthurLe morte darthur
Le morte darthur
 
Henry VIII
Henry VIIIHenry VIII
Henry VIII
 
King Henry VIII
King Henry VIIIKing Henry VIII
King Henry VIII
 
Introduction to Elizabethan Era
Introduction to Elizabethan EraIntroduction to Elizabethan Era
Introduction to Elizabethan Era
 
Proiectul meu despre Iancu de Hunedoara
Proiectul meu despre Iancu de HunedoaraProiectul meu despre Iancu de Hunedoara
Proiectul meu despre Iancu de Hunedoara
 
WHO IS APHRODITE
WHO IS APHRODITEWHO IS APHRODITE
WHO IS APHRODITE
 
Lake poets
Lake poetsLake poets
Lake poets
 

Semelhante a The Ploughman's Tragic Conversation

The Falling Leaves by Margaret Postgate Cole
The Falling Leaves by Margaret Postgate ColeThe Falling Leaves by Margaret Postgate Cole
The Falling Leaves by Margaret Postgate Colewww.MrSedani.co.uk
 
Five parts of waste land Poem.
Five parts of waste land Poem.Five parts of waste land Poem.
Five parts of waste land Poem.Hitesh Galthariya
 
Come On, Come Back’ by Stevie Smith
Come On, Come Back’ by Stevie SmithCome On, Come Back’ by Stevie Smith
Come On, Come Back’ by Stevie Smithwww.MrSedani.co.uk
 
"Waste Land" poem by T.S Eliot
 "Waste Land" poem by T.S Eliot  "Waste Land" poem by T.S Eliot
"Waste Land" poem by T.S Eliot AnjaliTrivedi14
 
Mametz wood revision information
Mametz wood   revision informationMametz wood   revision information
Mametz wood revision informationJon Bradshaw
 
A wife in london by thomas hardy
A wife in london by thomas hardyA wife in london by thomas hardy
A wife in london by thomas hardyPato_Ch
 
. Marcus CarlssonJohnér I.docx
. Marcus CarlssonJohnér I.docx. Marcus CarlssonJohnér I.docx
. Marcus CarlssonJohnér I.docxmercysuttle
 
Falling leaves revision information
Falling leaves   revision informationFalling leaves   revision information
Falling leaves revision informationJon Bradshaw
 
Cyranode bergeracintroduction
Cyranode bergeracintroductionCyranode bergeracintroduction
Cyranode bergeracintroductionjforster3
 
First world war poetry (con animaciones)
First world war poetry (con animaciones)First world war poetry (con animaciones)
First world war poetry (con animaciones)Jouhkien
 
W H Auden's poetry themes
W H Auden's poetry themesW H Auden's poetry themes
W H Auden's poetry themesSamiulhaq32
 
'My sweet old etcetera' by e.e cummings
'My sweet old etcetera' by e.e cummings'My sweet old etcetera' by e.e cummings
'My sweet old etcetera' by e.e cummingsTaylor-Mae
 

Semelhante a The Ploughman's Tragic Conversation (15)

The Falling Leaves by Margaret Postgate Cole
The Falling Leaves by Margaret Postgate ColeThe Falling Leaves by Margaret Postgate Cole
The Falling Leaves by Margaret Postgate Cole
 
Five parts of waste land Poem.
Five parts of waste land Poem.Five parts of waste land Poem.
Five parts of waste land Poem.
 
Mametz Wood by Owen Sheers
Mametz Wood by Owen SheersMametz Wood by Owen Sheers
Mametz Wood by Owen Sheers
 
Come On, Come Back’ by Stevie Smith
Come On, Come Back’ by Stevie SmithCome On, Come Back’ by Stevie Smith
Come On, Come Back’ by Stevie Smith
 
"Waste Land" poem by T.S Eliot
 "Waste Land" poem by T.S Eliot  "Waste Land" poem by T.S Eliot
"Waste Land" poem by T.S Eliot
 
Mametz wood revision information
Mametz wood   revision informationMametz wood   revision information
Mametz wood revision information
 
A wife in london by thomas hardy
A wife in london by thomas hardyA wife in london by thomas hardy
A wife in london by thomas hardy
 
. Marcus CarlssonJohnér I.docx
. Marcus CarlssonJohnér I.docx. Marcus CarlssonJohnér I.docx
. Marcus CarlssonJohnér I.docx
 
Falling leaves revision information
Falling leaves   revision informationFalling leaves   revision information
Falling leaves revision information
 
Poetry
PoetryPoetry
Poetry
 
Cyranode bergeracintroduction
Cyranode bergeracintroductionCyranode bergeracintroduction
Cyranode bergeracintroduction
 
First world war poetry (con animaciones)
First world war poetry (con animaciones)First world war poetry (con animaciones)
First world war poetry (con animaciones)
 
W H Auden's poetry themes
W H Auden's poetry themesW H Auden's poetry themes
W H Auden's poetry themes
 
'My sweet old etcetera' by e.e cummings
'My sweet old etcetera' by e.e cummings'My sweet old etcetera' by e.e cummings
'My sweet old etcetera' by e.e cummings
 
Waste Land.docx
Waste Land.docxWaste Land.docx
Waste Land.docx
 

The Ploughman's Tragic Conversation

  • 1. AS THE TEAMS HEAD BRASS - EDWARD THOMAS Page 180 Katia Scarpignato
  • 2.
  • 3. EDWARD THOMAS  Phillip Edward Thomas was an Anglo-Welsh writer of prose and poetry. He is commonly considered a war poet, although few of his poems deal directly with his war experiences. Already an accomplished writer, Thomas turned to poetry only in 1914. He enlisted in the army in 1915, and was killed in action during the Battle of Arras in 1917, soon after he arrived in France.  In three years, he had written a lifetime's poetry. The unusual shape of Thomas's poetic career - at once belated and tragically up-to- date - has made it difficult for critics to place him.  Thomas wrote „As the team‟s head brass‟ when he was on the cusp of deciding to finish his working with maps and to enlist in the army to fight in France. 1878- 1917
  • 4. CONTEXT AND INITIAL IMPRESSION  What the poem is about:  As a couple walk together into the woods beyond, a walker rests at the edge of a field. There, a farmer is methodically ploughing his fields with a team of horses, and the narrator and farmer fall into conversation about the war.  As the Team‟s Head Brass: The „team‟ are a pair of horses led by the farmer, pulling a plough. The farmer is preparing his land for the sowing of crops; in some ways, this seems to be a timeless agricultural scene. The “head brass” are the metal bridles around the horses‟ heads that allow the horses to be led.  Initial Impression  The readers first impression was that Thomas was recalling this event. The poem tells story, the realism is depicted by adding intricate details such as the „lovers disappeared into the woods‟. The first person narrative used here enriches the poets recollection, it also adds realism to the event. As the teams head Brass boarder's the questions of human existence, survival, memory, and 'home' - which accounts for its continuing influence today.
  • 5. THEMES  The use of Nature  Indifference of War  Futility of War  Love  Memory  Human existence
  • 6. ANALYSIS- STRUCTURE  This is a narrative poem— it tells a short story. It is written in Iambic Pentameter, and has a Shakespearian feel to it: everyday events and dialogue are elevated to high poetry by Thomas‟ feel for the significance of small things.  “As the team‟s head brass flashed out on the turn”: Time is important in this poem. The poem throws us into events immediately occurring.. “I sat… and watched”: the peaceful watching of the narrator as time passes by gives this poem a thoughtful, ponderous(without liveliness) tone.  The use of enjambment (running lines) is used as though Thomas is unravelling his story, each line is a continuation. The use of narrative is cathartic as though Thomas is revealing a story that he feels is an important story to tell.  The blizzard felled the elm…”: Thomas preserves the iambic pentameter here as he moves forward in his narrative, beginning a new line below. There is a sense of time having passed, but also of continuity.
  • 7. ANALYSIS- IMAGERY  “Watched the plough narrowing a yellow square of charlock”: charlock, or wild mustard, is a weed that must be cleared on land for farming. Thomas‟ description of the “yellow square” of weed is precise and vivid. Thomas suggests at first the peace of the country as opposed to the cataclysm of World War One but only does so to subvert(undermine) those conventions through a realistic depiction of the effects of the war. English agriculture had been in a long, steep decline since the mid- Victorian age. The countryside was a difficult place to live in 1916: This fact the reader feels, is rather than an idealisation of the country life which comes through in Thomas‟ poem.  “The lovers disappeared into the wood.”: Lovers appear again as key figures in a Thomas poem. We only see them at the beginning and the end of the poem, but they are important symbols of love, life and importantly rebirth.
  • 8. ANALYSIS- LANGUAGE  Now if he had stayed here we should have moved the tree.” (referring the friend the famer lost)The irony is really at the heart of the poem‟s narrative. The tragedy of the farmer‟s friend‟s death is dominant in the poem, but is overcast by the tragedy of the War.  “Then the lovers came out of the wood again‟‟. The repetition of the „lovers‟ seems to reinforce a sense of hope at the end of the poem.  „The blizzard‟ This is significant because the use of pathetic fallacy demonstrates that catastrophe that is the War surrounding them. The blizzard becomes symbolic and linked to the devastating to the effects of the fighting on the front.  „I watched the clods crumble and topple over‟ . The narrator in the action of the plough now seems linked to change of the war. The crumbling clods of earth and their toppling as they fall from the plough suggest the change in the world by humans; perhaps also suggesting the falling of men to earth in fields abroad.
  • 9. ANALYSIS  One minute and an interval of ten…”: The rhythm of the encounter is slow. The repetition emphasises this.  “Only two teams work on the farm this year…”: The significance of the single farmer working this large field made it clear the shortage caused by the war. This practical aspect is made immediately personal by the farmer‟s dead friend.  “…the stumbling team.”: The last line of the poem is significant because the “stumbling” of the team suggest the difficulty the farmer continues to face, and the loose footing of life itself.  „„One of my mates is dead. The second day In France they killed him‟‟. The use of clipped syntax stops the flow of the poem which suggests the farmer is remembering the tragic death of his friend.
  • 10. A PHASE THAT STANDS OUT TO THE READER: ‘‘Then the lovers came out of the woods again’’. The repetition of the ‘lovers’ seems to reinforce a sense of hope at the end of the poem. However it could also suggest how the youth were blissfully unaware of the destruction that was occurring around them. In times of havoc, the ‘lovers’ are continuing with their normal rituals and the reader feels as though how did people continue in such a normal fashion when a War is surrounding them. ? Perhaps this is the heart of the message that Thomas conveys, life goes on and whatever happens we must try to move on and continue with our lives as best we can.