2. âThe solution of all
adult problems
tomorrow depends
in large measure
upon the way our
children grow up
today.â
~ Margaret Mead,
Anthropologist
3. âThe solution of all adult
problems tomorrow
depends in large
measure upon the way
our children grow up
today.â
~ Margaret Mead,
Anthropologist
4. What Are ACEs?
Adverse Childhood Experiences
⢠Traumatic experiences in
childhood
⢠Sometimes referred to as
toxic stress or childhood
trauma
5. ACEs Often Last a Lifetime . . .
But They Donât Have To
⢠Healing can occur
⢠The cycle can be
broken
⢠Safe, stable,
nurturing
relationships heal
parent and child
6. Quick Survey
Rate Your Awareness of the ACE Study:
- No Knowledge of ACE Research
- Some Knowledge
- More Than Most
- Expert
7. Complete ACE Questionnaire
⢠What does it make you think about?
⢠Keep in mind your thoughts as we present
the ACE Study
8. Two Categories of ACEs
1) Growing up (prior to age 18) in a
household with abuse:
⢠Recurrent physical abuse
⢠Recurrent emotional abuse
⢠Sexual abuse
⢠Emotional or physical neglect
12. Two Categories of ACEs, cont.
2) Growing up with Household Dysfunction:
⢠Alcohol or drug abuser
⢠Incarcerated household
member.
⢠Someone chronically depressed,
suicidal, institutionalized or mentally ill.
⢠Mother being treated violently.
⢠One or no parents.
13. Why is This Important?
Because ACEs are:
⢠Surprisingly common
⢠Occur in clusters
⢠Basis for common public health problems
⢠Strong predictors of later social functioning,
well-being, health risks, disease, and death
14. Question
How do you see ACEs
manifested in kids and families
in your community?
18. Study Participants
⢠26,000 adults invited to participate;
17,337 accepted
⢠Solidly middle class
⢠Average age = 57
19. Demographics
Gender Female 54% Male 46%
Race White 74.8% Hispanic/Latino 11.2% Asian/Pacific
Islander 7.2% African-American 4.6% Other 1.9%
Age (years) 19-29 5.3% 30-39 9.8% 40-49 18.6%
50-59 19.9% 60 and over 46.4%
Education Not High School Graduate 7.2%
High School Graduate 17.6%
Some College 35.9%
College Graduate or Higher 39.3%
20. ACE Scores
⢠1/3 of adults have an ACE score of 0
⢠Majority of adults with
ACE score of 0 have few,
if any, risk factors for
diseases that are common
causes of death in the US.
21. ACE Scores
⢠Women are 50% more likely than men to
have an ACE Score >5
⢠If any one ACE is present, there is 87%
chance at least one other ACE is present,
and a 50% chance of 3 others
⢠This combination makes ACEs the leading
determinant of the health and social
well-being of our nation
22. AZ Data
⢠Children â Natl. Childrenâs Health Survey
⢠Adults â St. Lukeâs Health Survey
26. All the world is full of suffering, it is also full of overcoming.
-Helen Keller
27. Aces are Interrelated, Self-Perpetuating,
& Have a Cumulative Stressor Effect
⢠Number of different categories of ACEs (ACE
score) - determine health outcomes, not
intensity or frequency of a single category
⢠Without interruption, ACEs
escalate across generations
28. Aces are interrelated, self-perpetuating,
& have a cumulative stressor effect
⢠Number of different categories of
ACEs (ACE score) - determine
health outcomes, not intensity or
frequency of a single category
⢠Without interruption, ACEs
escalate across generations
29. ACEâs are Highly Interrelated
Alcohol Abuse in the Home and the Risk of Other
Household Exposures During Childhood
30. ⢠ACE score of 4 or more may result in multiple risk factors
for these diseases or the disease themselves
⢠ACE score of 6 or more may result in a 20 year decrease
in life expectancy
31. Evidence Suggests
⢠Many chronic diseases in adults are
determined decades earlier, by
experiences in childhood
⢠Risk factors/behaviors for these diseases
are initiated during childhood or
adolescence and continue into adult life.
32. Top 10 Risk Factors for
Death in USA
ďźsmoking
ďźsevere obesity
ďźphysical inactivity
ďźdepression
ďźsuicide attempt
ďźalcoholism
ďźillicit drug use
ďźinjected drug use
ďź50+ sexual partners
ďźhistory of STD
33. Top 10 Risk
Factors for
Death in USA
ďźsmoking
ďźsevere obesity
ďźphysical inactivity
ďźdepression
ďźsuicide attempt
ďźalcoholism
ďźillicit drug use
ďźinjected drug use
ďź50+ sexual partners
ďźhistory of STD
34. Life Long Physical, Mental &
Behavioral Outcomes of
ACEs
⢠Alcoholism & alcohol
abuse
⢠Chronic obstructive
pulmonary disease &
ischemic heart disease
⢠Depression
⢠Fetal death
⢠High risk sexual activity
⢠Illicit drug use
⢠Intimate partner violence
⢠Liver disease
⢠Obesity
⢠Sexually transmitted
disease
⢠Smoking
⢠Suicide attempts
⢠Unintended pregnancy
*** The higher the ACE Score,
the greater the incidence of co-
occurring conditions from this
list.
35. Lifelong physical, mental &
behavioral outcomes of ACEs
⢠Alcoholism & alcohol abuse
⢠Chronic obstructive pulmonary
disease & ischemic heart disease
⢠Depression
⢠Fetal death
⢠High risk sexual activity
⢠Illicit drug use
⢠Intimate partner violence
⢠Liver disease
⢠Obesity
⢠Sexually transmitted disease
⢠Smoking
⢠Suicide attempts
⢠Unintended pregnancy
âThe ACE health outcomes read like
A âwhoâs whoâ list of the top major
health problems in the United States.â
Dr. Robert Anda
Co-principal researcher on the ACE
study
36. Dr. David McCollum, retired ED physician and co-founder of the Academy on Violence & Abuse
(organization aimed at health professionals - provides education and research on the effects of
violence and abuse on health).
37. Seeking to Cope
⢠Risk factors/behaviors
underlying adult diseases are
effective coping devices.
⢠What is viewed as a problem is
actually a solution to bad
experiences.
⢠Dismissing these coping devices
as âbad habitsâ or âself
destructive behaviorâ misses
their functionality.
38. Coping Solutions
⢠What are conventionally
viewed as Public Health
problems are often
personal solutions to
long concealed adverse
childhood experiences.
39. ACEs and Addiction
âItâs hard to get enough of
something that almost
works.â
ACE findings suggest that
a major factor, if not the
main factor, underlying
addiction is ACEs that
have not healed and are
concealed from awareness
by shame, secrecy, and
social taboo.
40. ACE findings suggest
that:
a major factor, if not the
main factor, underlying
addiction is
ACEs that have not
healed and are
concealed from
awareness by shame,
secrecy, and social
taboo.
âItâs hard to get enough
of something that
almost works.â
41. ADVERSE CHILDHOOD EXPERIENCE
Adverse Childhood
Experiences
⢠ACEs are the greatest single predictor for health,
attendance and behavior.
⢠ACEs are the second strongest predictor, after special
education status, for academic failure.
⢠The relationship between academic achievement and
health status appears much less related to income than
to ACEs.
42. ACEs in the
classroom
⢠ACEs are the greatest single predictor
for health, attendance and behavior.
⢠ACEs are the second strongest
predictor, after special education status,
for academic failure.
⢠The relationship between academic
achievement and health status appears
much less related to income than to
ACEs.
43. ACEs in the
classroom
⢠ACEs are the greatest single predictor
for health, attendance and behavior.
⢠ACEs are the second strongest
predictor, after special education status,
for academic failure.
⢠The relationship between academic
achievement and health status appears
much less related to income than to
ACEs.
45. Jim Sporleder of Lincoln High School tried a new
approach with his students. Using a more
trauma sensitive approach, Mr. Sporleder and
staff changed the entire culture of the school.
ACEs in Action!
46. âPyramid of Hopeâ
âBefore we can get our students prepared for learning, we have to focus on their
wounds and history of failuresâ
Jim Sporleder (principal of Lincoln High School)
48. 3 Things you should know
about Brain Development
⢠We are hard wired to
survive.
⢠Brain architecture is
established early in life.
⢠Healthy brain architecture is
the necessary foundation
required for optimal future
learning, behavior and
health.
49. 3 Core Concepts in Early Brain Development
Harvard Center for The Developing Child
56. Stress and the Brain
Excessive and repeated stress:
(Neglect, violence, chaos, hostility,
unpredictability, rejection)
Causes disruption of brain architecture:
â Impairs cell growth
â Interferes with healthy neural circuits (fries
brain with overdose of stress hormones)
57. Stress and the Brain
Excessive and repeated stress:
⢠Neglect, Violence
⢠Chaos, unpredictability
⢠Hostility, rejection
Causes disruption of brain architecture:
⢠Impairs cell growth
⢠Interferes with healthy neural circuits
⢠Strains brain with overdose of stress
hormones
58. Toxic Stress
⢠Causes children to live in fight, flight or fright
(freeze) mode.
⢠Short attention span
⢠Struggle learning; fall behind in school
⢠Respond to world as constant danger
⢠Distrustful of adults
⢠Unable to develop healthy
peer relationships
⢠Feel failure, despair,
shame and frustration
59. ⢠Causes children to live in
fight, flight or fright (freeze)
mode.
⢠Short attention span
⢠Struggle learning; fall behind in
school
⢠Respond to world as constant
danger
⢠Distrustful of adults
⢠Unable to develop healthy
peer relationships
⢠Feel failure, despair,
shame and frustration
Toxic Stress impacts
children in the
Following ways:
60. Toxic Stress
It is fact not opinion that âToxic Stress/ACEâsâ
has a severe impact on the brain development
and a personâs future. It is a strong predictor
with negative outcomes without the
intervention of a positive adult relationship(s).
You can choose not to accept the findings, but
you canât deny them.
Stressed
Canât:
Brains
⢠Respond
⢠Learn or
⢠Process effectively
Allow time to de-
61. âIt is fact not opinion that âToxic Stress/ACEâsâ has a severe
impact on the brain development and a personâs future. It
is a strong predictor with negative outcomes without the
intervention of a positive adult relationship(s).â
Jim Sporleder
⢠Respond
⢠Learn
⢠Process
effectively
62.
63. By adolescence, children
seek relief through:
⢠Drinking alcohol*
⢠Smoking tobacco
⢠Sexual promiscuity
⢠Using drugs*
⢠Overeating/eating disorders
⢠Delinquent behavior, violence
⢠High-risk sports, etc.
* Note: nicotine and methamphetamines are
anti-depressants
64. Behavior is Predictable
All behavior (both good and bad) has meaning
We need to look closely
at what preceded the
behavior
What happened
first that is causing this
behavior?
65. All behavior (both good and bad) has meaning
We need to ask ourselves what might be going
on going on beneath the surface.
67. High Risk Teen Behaviors
⢠May not be the core problem
⢠They may be coping devices
⢠A way to feel safe or just feel better
68. Trauma and Ongoing Stress
in Infants and Toddlers
⢠Increased arousal, elevated stress
hormones and other biochemical changes
in the body and the brain, altering brain
development
⢠Long-term effects on physical, mental, and
emotional development
69. What Does This Look Like?
⢠Changes in eating or sleeping routines
⢠Changes in growth and development
⢠Changes in relationships
⢠Regressions in developmental abilities
71. The 4th
Vital Sign
⢠Respiration, heart rate, blood pressure and
relationships
⢠Behaviors are childrenâs means of expression
⢠Caregivers often unable to understand
connection between traumatic event and
childrenâs behaviors
⢠To heal, children need recognition and
understanding from their caregivers
83. Pay Now or Pay Later
⢠Pay now for programs proven to buffer theÂ
stress, or pay later in rising health costs.
⢠âEarly childhood investments of highÂ
quality have a lasting effect.â Â
                           â$10 return on investment   Â
                                   Â
                            for every $1 spent.âÂ
(James Heckman, Noble Laureate, Economics)Â
84. Pay Now or Pay Later
⢠Pay now for programs proven toÂ
buffer the stress, or pay later inÂ
rising health costs.
⢠âEarly childhood investments ofÂ
high quality have a lasting effect.â
 Â
 â$10 return on investment
for every $1 spent.â
(James Heckman, Noble
86. ACEsACEs are theare the Pipeline toPipeline to
PrisonPrison
⢠1 in 104 American adults is behind bars
⢠1 in 33 American adults is under correctional control
⢠1 in 4 of the worldâs inmates is in a US prison or jail
⢠1 in 8 state employees works in corrections
⢠1 in 14 state general fund dollars is spent onÂ
corrections
HIGH COST, LOW RETURN: 1 in 2.3 inmates returns
to prison within 3 years of release
                                                                                                                                                ( - ACES TOO HIGH)
87. ACEsACEs are theare the Pipeline toPipeline to
PrisonPrison
⢠1 in 104 American adults is behind bars
⢠1 in 33 American adults is under correctional control
⢠1 in 4 of the worldâs inmates is in a US prison or jail
⢠1 in 8 state employees works in corrections
⢠1 in 14 state general fund dollars is spent on corrections
HIGH COST, LOW RETURN: 1 in 2.3 inmates returns
to prison within 3 years of release
                                                                                                                                                ( - ACES TOO HIGH)
118. The power of resilience
moderates the effects of
serious life challenges
and provides hope and
healing
119. The power of resilience moderates
the effects of serious life
challenges and provides hope and
healing.
120. Parental Resilience
Good outcomes in spite of
serious threats, toxic stress
Resilient people:
â are prepared to be
effective in the world
â can adapt to challenges
â are mentally healthy
121. Resilience is
⢠Feeling connected to
caring family and
community
⢠Self-regulation skills
⢠Positive view of self
⢠Motivation to be
effective in your
environment
122. Begin with yourself
⢠Take care of own mental health
⢠Develop healthy coping devices
(regular exercise, reading, listening to
music, etc.)
⢠Seek out healthy family and
friends for support
⢠Use community supports
(counseling, substance abuse
treatment, self-help programs, etc.)
123. Building Resilience
⢠Recognize early signs
of stress and connect
people to resources
⢠Develop a trusting
relationship and
provide support
⢠Be a good neighbor
⢠Look for and point out
inner strengths
124. Teach the
Seven Câs You didnât CAUSE it
You canât CURE it
You canât CONTROL it
You can help take CARE of yourself
By COMMUNICATING your
feelings,
Making health CHOICES, and
CELEBRATING being yourself
125. ⢠Teach skills to
youth
⢠Plan activities
focusing on
nutrition,
exercising or
relaxation
techniques
⢠Help children
develop healthy
relationships
126. ⢠Volunteer â reach out and help others
⢠Be a mentor
⢠Start a Community Circle of Care
⢠Model/teach problem solving
skills, planning ahead, goals
127. Social Connections
Network of emotionally supportive friends, family and
neighbors
Important to:
â Ease burden of parenting
â Decrease isolation
â Offer children broader access to supportive adults and
positive role models
â Provide opportunities to help
128. Building Social Connections
⢠Identify what parents have in place; build on it
⢠Provide opportunities for parents to get together
- use parents skills, abilities and interests
⢠Look for community opportunities â faith based,
schools, community centers, support groups
⢠Provide encouragement and support to try new
groups
⢠Teach social skills
129. Concrete Supports
in Time of Need
⢠Food, shelter, basic
services critical to child
well-being
⢠Link caregivers to
community resources and
extended family
⢠Work on sustainability
130. Social and Emotional
Competence of Children
⢠Relate/interact with others
⢠Regulate own emotions
⢠Communicate feelings
Delays increase childâs risk for abuse
131. Building Social/Emotional
Competence
⢠Teach social skills
⢠Educate parents on importance of
social/emotional skills
⢠Provide healthy outlets â arts, sensory,
exercise, etc.
⢠Encourage parents to exchange ideas on
what works
⢠Take timely action when there is concern
133. Provide Information
⢠Educational workshops
⢠Radio announcements
⢠Community meetings
⢠Web-based
⢠Written material
⢠Conversations
134. Enhance Skills
Offer workshops/activities designed to
increase skills of participant:
â Training
â Classes
â Consultation
â Counseling
â Team sports,
scouting, 4H
135. Provide Support
⢠Be a good neighbor
⢠Offer mentoring or
support groups
⢠Offer to help
⢠Spend quality and
quantity time with a
child; read a book,
share a meal
136. Enhance Access and
Reduce Barriers
⢠Seek grants, build local
collaborations
⢠Offer food, shelter, seek
professional help if needed
⢠Link clients to effective faith
based activities, recreation,
parenting classes, domestic
violence shelters/education
137. Change Consequences
⢠Thank someone for their hard work
⢠Publicly recognize a community group that
helps strengthen families
⢠Publish newspaper article highlighting
someone in the community
⢠Give rewards to individuals or businesses
for helping in the community
138. Change the Physical Design
⢠Lead/participate in clean-up
effort
⢠Initiate change to make your
community safer
⢠Set up place where parents
can gather and get information
⢠Volunteer to paint a home
⢠Support your local Child Abuse
Prevention Council
139. Modify/Change
Policy
⢠Talk to legislators and
philanthropists about
supporting effective programs
⢠Contribute to child abuse
prevention programs via a tax
check off
⢠Support positive parenting
programs, and services for
domestic violence and mental
health education
140. Question
⢠How can we build protective factors in
the families we serve?
⢠How can we help build resiliency in the
families we impact?
141. If our society is to prosper in the future, we
need to make sure that all children have the
opportunity to develop intellectually, socially
and emotionally.
142. In Summary
⢠âIt is easier to build strong children than to
repair broken menâ ~Frederick Douglass (1817-1895)
⢠âChildren make up 25% of our population,
but 100% of our future.â ~Ian Jukes
⢠Now what?
143. In Summary
âIt is easier to build strong children than to
repair broken menâ ~ Frederick Douglass (1817-1895)
144. Now What?
⢠Questions?
⢠Ideas for utilizing ACE
research in your community?
⢠What resources do you need?
⢠What challenges do you foresee?
145. Turn to Your Neighbor
⢠Share what resonated the most with you
today.
⢠How are you going to use this
information?
146. To Get Involved Contact
Marcia Stanton, Child Abuse Prevention Coordinator,
Phoenix Childrenâs Hospital
mstanto@phoenixchildrens.com
Joan Shaffer, Program Manager,
Southwest Human Development
jshaffer@swhd.org
147.
148.
149. Parenting Resources
⢠1-877-705-KIDS (5437) - Birth to Five Parenting
Questions Helpline
⢠1-800-4-A-CHILD (422-4453) - Crisis Line for
emotional needs, info on child abuse/neglect
Also go to: www.childhelp.org
⢠www.azpbs.org/strongkids
⢠www.apa.org/books
⢠www.pbs.org/parents/childdevelopment
⢠www.cdc.gov/parents
150. Information & Resources
⢠ACE Study findings and information
- www.acestudy.org or www.cdc.gov
⢠ACEs Too High â www.acestoohigh.com
⢠National Scientific Council on the
Developing Child at Harvard University
- www.developingchild.net
⢠SAHMSA â Early Childhood Trauma Resources
http://www.samhsa.gov/children/earlychildhood
mat.asp
151. More Information & Resources
⢠National Center for Trauma-Informed Care â
www.mentalhealth.samhsa.gov/nctic
⢠National Child Traumatic Stress Network â
www.nctsnet.org
⢠Center for Study of Social Policy - strengthening
families and protective factors â www.cssp.org
⢠Center for Injury Prevention and Control â
www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention
⢠American Psychological Assn â Resilience
Guide - http://www.apa.org/helpcenter/road-
resilience.aspx
153. Works Cited
ACE Study:
The CDC Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study homepage presents a wealth of
information on the ACE Study including a complete bibliography of ACE Study
publications by topic area (http://www.cdc.gov/ace/index.html).
Safe, Stable, Nurturing Relationships:
The CDC National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, Violence Prevention has
many resources on the prevention of child maltreatment
(http://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/) and promoting nurturing relationships
between children and caregivers
(http://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/pdf/CM_Strategic_Direction--Long-a.pdf ).
Early Brain Development:
The Center for the Developing Child at Harvard University has a wealth of the latest
research and resources on the science of early childhood
(http://developingchild.harvard.edu/ ).
The Zero to Three Institute has many resources on the impact of trauma and building
resiliency in young children
(http://www.zerotothree.org/maltreatment/trauma/trauma.html ).
First Things First has great info on the science of early brain development
(http://www.azftf.gov/why/evidence/pages/brainscience.aspx ).
154. Works Cited
Economic Costs:
CDC Injury Prevention Center includes well-researched articles on the cost of child abuse
(http://www.cdc.gov/ViolencePrevention/childmaltreatment/EconomicCost.html ).
The Heckman Equation has compelling resources for upstream solutions to societal
problems by investing in early and equal development of human potential
(http://www.heckmanequation.org/content/heckman-101).
Protective Factors:
The Child Welfare Information Gateway has a wealth of well-researched resources for
protecting children and strengthening families
(http://www.childwelfare.gov/can/factors/protective.cfm ).
Environmental Prevention Strategies:
The Community Anti-Drug Coalitions of America website includes resources for effective
community problem-solving strategies
(http://www.cadca.org/files/Beyond_the_Basics_EnvironmentalStrategies.pdf ).
The 7 Cs Creed:
National Association for Children of Alcoholics has a downloadable kit for professionals
on tips for working with children of alcoholics (http://www.nacoa.org).
Scientific discoveries about how experience effects lifelong physical, mental, behavioral health are emerging rapidly. The technologies available to study brain development and population health have improved dramatically in the last decade. In the fall of 2009, the Institute of Medicine published a report on preventing mental, emotional and behavioral disorders in youth. In that publication they explained that much of what is discussed in this latest book simply was not known at the time of the Institute of Medicineâs last publication fifteen years ago. Just as scientific knowledge has changed, so has our understanding of the challenges we face together,. We rightly have a sense of urgency in our interest in taking major strides toward a healthier, safer and more just world. We ask questions that donât have simple answers: Why do some people come into adulthood with abundant opportunities and capabilities, and others arrive at adulthood without equal opportunity for success and fulfillment? How do we work collectively to make dramatic improvements to health, safety, school and work success and well-being? How do we balance high expectations and appropriate accommodation so that we achieve equity in our society? Answering questions like these will require us to look beyond the everyday events that are easily observed, and see driving forces and complex causal pathways to the reality we experience. Our values and vision for the future, and our beliefs about the way the world works are powerful filters in our minds. People cannot realize what we canât imagine. â and we donât imagine possibilities that fall outside of our mental models about how the world works. Because we want to achieve big strides toward a time when all people thrive, we will need to develop the skill and habit of challenging the thoughts and mental models that may be holding us back. People who study problem solving in very complex systems teach that when we are challenging our own mental models, itâs helpful to point it out. That way our brain is more open to the new message. Mental model challenges will be identified as we go along. Letâs see our first one.
Credit Jim
Embed video
he most basic and powerful way to connect to another person is to listen. Just listen. Perhaps the most important thing we ever give each other is our attention.... A loving silence often has far more power to heal and to connect than the most well-intentioned words.