The Facility, together with its partners FSDA and AFD, organized a webinar on "Improving claims management".
In this webinar we offered guidelines on how to manage claims efficiently and improve operations. Claims is the moment of truth in insurance - it is when the promise of insurance becomes a reality. For low-income households, client satisfaction hinges on receiving the insured benefit as the settled claim offers tangible evidence of the value of an insurance policy.
The webinar featured insights from two innovation partners on claims process improvements and better claims data management. Presenters: Patrick Kihuria (Britam) and Frida Mwaura (MicroEnsure). Moderator: Aparna Dalal (the ILO's Impact Insurance Facility)
4. Analyse each of the categories of claims
procedures:
‒ Consider the impact of product type and program
design/structure
‒ Identify any specific tools or strategies that you are
using to improve client value, business value, or both
‒ Are there any areas where procedures could be
improved?
• Why? What change would you make?
• Does it fit under one of the guiding principles?
Program review – processes
6. BRITAM MICROINSURANCE PRODUCTS
PRODUCT TARGET MARKET COVERAGE CLAIMS TYPES
KINGA YA
MKULIMA
TEA FARMERS
ASSOCIATION
INPATIENT &
LAST EXPENSE
HOSPITAL,
REIMBURSEMENT
& DEATH CLAIMS
AFYA TELE REGISTERED
GROUPS
(Corporates, clubs,
SHGs etc,)
INPATIENT,
OUTPATIENT &
LAST EXPENSE
HOSPITAL,
REIMBURSEMENT
& DEATH CLAIMS
SACCO
SOLUTION
SAVINGS &
CREDIT
COOPERATIVES
INPATIENT,
PERSONAL
ACCIDENT &
LAST EXPENSE
HOSPITAL,
REIMBURSEMENT
& DEATH CLAIMS
7. OBJECTIVES
• Map claim process & team structure
• Calculate average processing time
• Identify pain points
RATIONALE FOR THE REVIEW
• CLIENT SATISFACTION: Ensuring timely claim payments to hospitals and clients
• ADAPTING TO NEW MIS: Ensuring challenges from legacy systems are not taken
forward
8. CLAIMS REVIEW: APPROACH
PROCESS
MAPPING
MEASURE STEP
WISE TATs
‘AS-IS’ TO
‘SHOULD-BE’ MAPS
LIST TYPES OF CLAIMS
IDENTIFY PEOPLE & RECORDS
CHECK FOR DOUBLE DATA
ENTRY & MULTIPLE APPROVALS
ACTIVE/DEAD TIME
FROM TIME OF EVENT
ALERT FOR OUTLIERS
RATIONALIZE STEPS
IDEAL TATs
DEFINE ROLES
9. HOSPITAL QUALITY ASSURANCE CONTROLLER CLAIMASSISTANT
ye
PRE-AUTHORIZED
AMOUNT COVERS THE
TREATMENT COST
CHECKS IF
BENEFIT ARE
REMAINING
PATIENT PAYS THE
BALANCEAMOUNT
EXTENSION OF
COVERAGEIS
APPROVED
REQUESTS FOR
EXTENSION OF
COVERAGE
PATIENT IS
DISCHARGED
CLAIM FORM
(ONLY FOR OP)
INVOICEDISCHARGE
DOCUMENTS
SENDS PHYSICAL CLAIM
DOCUMENTS THROUGH POST,
COURIER OR RUNNERS
CLAIMDOCUMENTS
ARE RECIEVED &
STAMPED
PHYSICAL
DOCUMENTS ARE
SCANNED &
UPLOADED TO DMS-
FORTIS
VETS CLAIMS BY
REVIEWING
AMOUNT, VALIDITIY
OF DIAGNOSIS &
EXCLUSIONS
SCANNED
CLAIMFORMS
CONFIRMS CLAIMS
ENTRY & CHECKS
PAYMENT IN MAJMED
UPDATES DATAIN
MAJMED BASED ON
DISCHARGE
VOUCHER
PREPARES A
HOSPITAL WISE
EXCEL SHEET OF
CLAIMS
PRINTS BATCH TO
FORTIS DIRECTLY
FROMEXCEL SHEET
INDEXES BATCH OF
CLAIMS BYPUTTING
BATCH NUMBER,
AMOUNT, HOSPITAL
NAME
INDEXED BATCH OF
CLAIMS MOVES TO
PAYMENT SCHEDULE
FOLDER IN DMS
PRINTS BATCH OF
CLAIMS FROM
PAYMENT SCHEDULE
ENTERS DETAILS OF
PRE-
AUTHORIZATIONS
INTO MAJMED (KYM)
ROW WISEDETAIL IN
MAJMED
DOCTOR PRESCRIBES
INPATIENT ADMISSION
VERIFIES TEA
GROWER/POLICY NO. IN
PREMIUM DATATBASE/AIMS
VERIFIES IF THERE ARE
ANY PREVIOUS CLAIMS
IN EMAIL HISTORY
PREPARES THE LETTER FOR
UNDERTAKING AND SENDS
VIA EMAIL
UNDERTAKING
LETTER
BATCH OF CLAIMS
FOR VERIFICATION
PRINTED COPY OF
BATCHED CLAIMS
(See: Documents!B3)
VERIFIES INDIVIDUAL
CLAIMS FROMBATCH TO
CLAIMINVOICES IN
CLAIMS ARE
MATCHED
SENDS PRE-
AUTHORIZATION
REQUEST LETTER
BY EMAIL PRE-AUTH
REQUEST LETTER
CLAIMS ARE
CONSISTENT
NOYES
NO YES
YES
NO
YESNO
YES
VERIFIES BENEFIT LEVEL,
NUMBER OF MEMBERS
COVERED IN FORTIS/AIMS
REJECTS PRE-
AUTHORIZATION
NO
NO
VERIFIES IF SUM
ASSURED IS
AVAILABLE
YES
YES
REJECTS PRE-
AUTHORIZATION
NO
PRINTED &
RETURNED
PRINTED DOCS
CORRECTION
CLAIMREQUISITON
RAISED
CLAIM REQUISITION
FOR APPROVAL
CLAIMS
APPROVAL
YES
NO
MOVES TO
FINANCE FOR
PAYMENT
CLAIMS PROCESS MAP
11. FINDINGS: FROM THE TIME OF EVENT
KYM Death
KYM Reimbursement
Hospital
STEP WISE BREAK DOWN OF TATs
Customer document submission Factory document transfer
Majani document transfer Hospital submission
Internal processing
12. TRANSLATING FINDINGS INTO ACTION
• ONE STEP AT A TIME
• SEPARATE IT AND NON-IT INTERVENTIONS
• DATA MANAGEMENT IS KEY
– REDUCE DATA FRAGMENTATION
– DATA ANALYSIS FOR SMART PROVIDER MANAGEMENT
• PROCESS AUTOMATION
– AUTHORIZATIONS
– CLAIM SUBMISSION AND NOTIFICATIONS (SMSes)
• TEAM STRUCTURE
– DATA BACKED WORK FLOWS
14. Immediate requirement is to collect sufficient
date to evaluate and pay the claim
Collecting detailed historical claims data can add
additional value to a microinsurance program:
‒ Evaluate trends in underlying claims drivers
• Utilisation / frequency of claims
• Average claim amounts
• Primary causes or types of claims
• Claim volumes
‒ Analysis by different factors such as
• Age and gender
• Location / service provider
Program review – data management
16. MicroEnsure is a specialist in designing,
delivering, and operating insurance
products for the emerging consumer.
50 million registered customers
200 products launched
25 countries
15 years in business
Shareholders:
MicroEnsure: Who we are
18. Our Key Insight:
People actually love insurance when it really works.
Especially emerging consumers, who frequently face risk.
Earn free hospital cash, life
and accident cover up to
$2,500 when you top up $2
The more you top up, the
more you earn
Pay $1 per month & double
the free cover you earn
Earn up to $5,000 in life,
accident and hospital
insurance
Buy additional cover for
your family
Buy higher-impact health
products: telemedicine, info
MicroEnsure Freemium Product Lifecycle:
19. Claims: The Ultimate Selling Point
Claimant TV Ad, Ghana:
• “I received my money in 2
hours”
• “This is not a fabrication; this
product is real”
Micro insurance Myth: The more claims I
pay, the less money I make.
Emerging customers need proof that a
product works, and then they will buy it;
claims management is essential for
growing the market to scale.
Watch the ad “Hafiz Baba Testimonial on Airtel
Insurance” on
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vX6TySibSU8
20. Why Delaying Claims is Poor Strategy
Loss incurred
First claim
report
Claim
documents
received
Claim paid
MicroEnsure
Typical claims
experience
1-2 days 3-5 days 1-2 hours
10-15 days 40-45 days 72 hours
Policy terms aren’t clear,
report has to be made in
person at insurer office
Claimants go through many
rounds of document review
and keeps being asked for
additional documents
Clock only starts when ALL
documents received; claims
processed through multiple
departments
Customer knows exactly
what cover she has, with no
fine print, and claims are
reported easily via phone
A proactive customer
service process and clear
directions on document/s
required allows for faster
claims submission
MicroEnsure performs most
claims analysis before final
document receipt, earns
payment authority from
insurer
50-70 days from loss to payment
4-7 days from loss to payment
Claimant tells
everyone
about your
product
Claimant is
tired of your
company
21. • Start from claim event (customer perspective), not from notification (insurer’s perspective)
• Track every step, every sub-step, every contact
• Maintain direct contact with claimants through process
• Adaptive process and documentation requirements
• Follow up pro-actively with claimants until closure
Claims Management: Guiding Principles
Validate Validate Validate
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
Event
Reporting Contact Review
Closure
22. • Claim volumes per Product, Partner, Country, etc.
• Claim incidence rates per Product
• Claim ratios
• TATs per Month, Product, Partner, Insurer, etc.
• Contact (number, mode & frequency to get to closure)
• Proportion of payable claims by product & partner
• Reasons for rejection
• Open vs. closed claims per Product, Partner, Country, etc.
• Proportion of Claims paid on time per Product, Partner, Country, Insurer, etc.
Claims Management: Data Analytics
23. • Reasons for rejection show us potential to enhance product in a way that meets
customer demand
• Claim incidence rates: low = enhance benefits; high = increase premium, change policy
terms
• Time taken for notification: being able to demonstrate how quickly claims are processed
when we have direct contact with claimants and claim settlement authority vs. when
we don’t
Claims Management: Insights
CLAIM PROCESSING TAT ANALYSIS
SCHEME
Average of
Time -
Incident to
ME
Notification
(Days)
Average of
Time - ME
Notification
to initial Docs
(Days)
Average of
Time -
Initial to
Complete
Docs (Days)
Average of
Time - Comp
Docs to ME
Comp
Verification
Average
of Time -
ME Verif
to Insurer
Average of
Time -
Insurer to
Payment
TOTAL
TURN-
AROUND
TIME:
Incident to
Payment
SCHEME 1 (M.E. DIRECT) 1.54 0.50 0.08 0.08 0.09 0.64 2.93
SCHEME 2 (MFI – DIRECT CONTACT,
CLAIM SETTLEMENT AUTHORITY)
13.85 0.26 2.73 2.51 0.02 2.87 22.24
SCHEME 3 (MFI – NO CONTACT, NO
CLAIM SETTLEMENT AUTHORITY)
29.85 4.88 4.60 3.69 1.23 11.69 55.94
24. Total settlement time is key for clients
Inefficient workflow contributes to higher expense levels
Focus on improving the step that creates the biggest
problem or bottleneck first
Test workflow process before “hard-wiring” it into an
automated system
Reporting claims ratios and other performance indicators
can be used to improve program sustainability, product
design and pricing
Coordinate data requirements and reporting with
department(s) responsible for setting premiums and
reserves
Key points to remember
25. 1. Claims management needs to be considered in the context of
overall program design.
‒ Existing social capital and distribution channels can be
leveraged to create a one-stop process for clients’
insurance needs.
2. The claims notification and submission processes need to be
simple and easy to understand
‒ For clients, intermediaries AND claims managers.
3. Claims documentation requirements should not be too
onerous
‒ Requirements should be sufficient to manage fraud, but
not excessive.
Guiding principles
26. 4. Turnaround time is a key factor both for client satisfaction and
cost-effectiveness.
‒ From the client’s point of view, the total time from loss to
payment is what matters.
5. Efficient and streamlined workflow processes should be
implemented.
‒ And workflow should be evaluated on a regular basis.
6. A loss event is a difficult time for the client:
‒ The process should be fast and simple.
‒ Claims settlement should be transparent and provide
multiple contact points for communication.
‒ Benefits should be provided in a convenient form.
Guiding principles
27. 7. It is important to maintain control over data and processes,
including appropriate fraud control mechanisms.
‒ Use of third party service providers involves additional
controls and service standards.
‒ Investments in technology should be well thought out
prior to development.
8. Clear management objectives are necessary in order to
balance appropriate trade-offs between business and client
perspectives.
Guiding principles
28. Microinsurance Paper No. 28: Claims Management in
Microinsurance
‒ http://www.impactinsurance.org/publications/mp28
Le Roy, P., & Holtz, J.; Third Party Payment Mechanisms in Health
Insurance.
‒ http://www.ilo.org/public/english/employment/mifacility/do
wnload/mpaper13_payment.pdf
Steinmann, R.; Process mapping for microinsurance operations: A
toolkit for understanding and improving business processes and
client value.
‒ http://www.ifad.org/ruralfinance/pub/toolkit.pdf
References and Resources