1. Internationaler
Controller Verein
Controller-Statements
Instrumente
4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN
*VU[YVSSPUN ¶ ARUM[ NLZ[HS[LU

2. Inhalt
0TWYLZZT 7YPUaPW LY[ZJO€WMUN HIIPSKLU
.LZJOpM[ZTVKLSS HIIPSKLU
=VY^VY[ 6[W[MVRZ MVYJPLYLU
1. +LY LN aY 4VKLYULU 9LSH[P]L APLSL LYNpUaLUK
)KNL[PLYUN LPUZL[aLU
7SHUUN PZ[ =VYILYLP[UN UPJO[ 6YNHUPZH[PVU HIIPSKLU
=VYILZ[PTTUN KLY ARUM[ 7SpUL ]LY[PRHS UK OVYPaVU[HS
HIZ[PTTLU
HZ ZPUK )KNL[ UK 4HNLISPJOL PU[LYUL
)KNL[PLYUN 3LPZ[UNLU ]LYYLJOULU
+PL .YLUaLU KLY )KNL[PLYUN (IZPJO[LU RSpYLU UK
)PZOLYPNL (UZp[aL PU KLY RVTTUPaPLYLU
)KNL[PLYUN 4P[HYILP[LY LPUIPUKLU
(KYLZZH[LUVYPLU[PLYUN
2. 4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN ZPJOLYZ[LSSLU
/LYHZMVYKLYUNLU M…Y KPL
4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN 4. 0; UK 4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN
(U[^VY[LU KLY 4VKLYULU ,PUSLP[UN
)KNL[PLYUN +HZ (Z^HOS]LYMHOYLU
+PL 4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN (Z^HOSMHR[VYLU
PT lILYISPJR ,PUMSZZ KLY PU[LYULU UK
L_[LYULU TMLSKMHR[VYLU HM
3. +PL 7YPUaPWPLU KLY 4VKLYULU KPL (Z^HOSMHR[VYLU
)KNL[PLYUN
,PUZJOp[aUN KLY
7YPUaPW ,PUMHJOOLP[ LYRaLNRSHZZLU
+L[HPSSPLYUN ]LYYPUNLYU ;HILSSLURHSRSH[PVUZIHZPLY[L
(MIH UK (ISHM KLY 7SHUUNZZ`Z[LTL
)KNL[PLYUN ]LYLPUMHJOLU 2SHZZPZJOL ,97IHZPLY[L
7SHUUNZWYVaLZZ RVUZLXLU[ 7SHUUNZZ`Z[LTL
LPUOHS[LU ;HILSSLURHSRSH[PVU,97
+PL YPJO[PNLU 0UZ[YTLU[L IHZPLY[L 7SHUUNZZ`Z[LTL
LPUZL[aLU ,97 TP[ ZWLaPMPZJOLY
7YPUaPW -SL_PIPSP[p[ 7SHUUNZMUR[PVUHSP[p[
U[LYQpOYPNL 9LHR[PVUZ +H[H^HYLOVZLIHZPLY[L
MpOPNRLP[ ZJOHMMLU 7SHUUNZZ`Z[LTL
-VYLJHZ[PUN RVU[PUPLYSPJO 63(7IHZPLY[L 7SHUUNZ
KYJOM…OYLU Z`Z[LTL
:LUZP[P]P[p[LU UK :aLUHYPLU :WLaPMPZJOL
ILY…JRZPJO[PNLU 7SHUUNZZ`Z[LTL
7YPUaPW 0U[LNYH[PVU .LULYPZJOL 7SHUUNZZ`Z[LTL
7SHUUNZLILULU ]LYRU…WMLU
(UYLPaZ`Z[LT HZIHSHUJPLYLU 5. *VU[YVSSLYZ :TTHY`
0;:`Z[LTL U[LYZ[…[aLUK
LPUZL[aLU 6. =LY^LUKL[L 3P[LYH[Y

3. Impressum Vorwort
Herausgeber ,PU )SPJR PU KPL U[LYULOTLU KLY …ILY 4P[NSPLKLY KLZ 0U[LYUH[PVUHSLU *VU
0U[LYUH[PVUHSLY *VU[YVSSLY =LYLPU L= [YVSSLY =LYLPUZ VKLY HM LPUZJOSpNPNL (UHS`ZLU UK LTWPYPZJOL :[KPLU IL^LPZ[!
3L[Z[L[[LULY :[YHL + .H[PUN 7SHUUN UK )KNL[PLYUN NLO€YLU ^LP[LYOPU a KLU ^PJO[PNZ[LU ;OLTLU UK
;LS 0UZ[YTLU[LU PT *VU[YVSSPUN ;YV[a KPLZLY )LKL[UN RVTT[ LZ PTTLY ^PLKLY a
-H_ +PZRZZPVULU …ILY ,MMPaPLUa UK ,MMLR[P]P[p[ KLY )KNL[PLYUN +PL KHYHZ LU[Z[L
]LYLPU'JVU[YVSSLY]LYLPUKL
^^^JVU[YVSSLY]LYLPUJVT OLUKL 2YP[PR HU KLY 7SHUUN UK )KNL[PLYUN ^PYK KYJO ZPJO ]PLSLYVY[Z ]LYpU
KLY[L T^LS[ILKPUNUNLU ¶ ]VY HSSLT KPL +`UHTPZPLYUN KLY 4pYR[L ¶ ]LYZJOpYM[
Schriftleitung! +PL HZ KPLZLY :P[H[PVU LU[Z[HUKLULU 3€ZUNZHUZp[aL ZPUK LPULYZLP[Z UY
4HY[PU ;ZJOHUKS 7L[LY :JOLU[SLY ILKPUN[ NLLPNUL[ ^LPS ZPL RLPU NLZJOSVZZLULZ 2VUaLW[ ZVUKLYU UY LPULU
6ILYILNYPMM M…Y LPUL =PLSaHOS HU =LYILZZLYUNZPKLLU UK PUZ[YTLU[LU HUIPL[LU
0U =LYIPUKUN TP[
(UKLYLYZLP[Z ZL[aLU ZPL ZPJO WYHR[PZJO RHT KYJO UK POY ,PUZH[a PZ[ M…Y KLU
9( *VUYHK .…U[OLY .H[PUN
.LZJOpM[ZM…OYLY 0U[LYUH[PVUHSLY *VU[YVSSLY =LYLPU L= .YV[LPS KLY U[LYULOTLU MYHNSPJO ,Z MLOS[L HSZV LPU WYVISLTHKpXH[LZ 2VUaLW[
UK :PLNMYPLK .pUSLU KHZ HJO PU KLY 7YH_PZ HU^LUKIHY PZ[
=VYZ[HUKZ]VYZP[aLUKLY 0U[LYUH[PVUHSLY *VU[YVSSLY =LYLPU L=
+LY 0U[LYUH[PVUHSL *VU[YVSSLY =LYLPU OH[ KHOLY PT 5V]LTILY LPULU -HJOHY
Inhaltliche Mitarbeit: ILP[ZRYLPZ TP[ …ILY 4P[NSPLKLYU HZ PZZLUZJOHM[ )LYH[UN UK 7YH_PZ ]LY
ZJOPLKLUZ[LY )YHUJOLU UK U[LYULOTLUZNY€LU NLZ[HY[L[ KLY PU KLU SL[a[LU
,STHY +^VYZRP *OYPZ[VWO ,PZS 7H[YPJPH -YL`
]PLY 1HOYLU LPU ^PZZLUZJOHM[SPJO MUKPLY[LZ Z[PTTPNLZ UK WYH_PZ[HNSPJOLZ 2VU
:PLNMYPLK .pUSLU 9VUHSK .SLPJO /HUZSYPJO /VSZ[
4PJOHLS 2HWWLZ KV 2YHZ ^L 4PJOLS 2HYZ[LU 6LOSLY aLW[ LU[^PJRLS[L! KPL É4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN¸ +PL =VYHYILP[LU aY 4VKLYULU
9VILY[ 9PLN :[LMMLU :PUKS /LST[ PSSTHUU )KNL[PLYUN ILYO[LU HM UHJOZ[LOLUKLU (R[P]P[p[LU!
(UHS`ZL ILZ[LOLUKLY 2VUaLW[L )L[[LY (K]HUJLK )L`VUK )KNL[PUN
Herstellung 7Y…MUN LTWPYPZJOLY ,YRLUU[UPZZL KYJO 0TWSZL HZ KLY PZZLUZJOHM[
:H[a UK NYHMPZJOL (ZM…OYUN! 5LNLUIVYU2VTTUPRH[PVU +YJOM…OYUN LPULY )LUJOTHYRPUN:[KPL TP[ TLOY HSZ U[LYULOTLU
6Z[MPSKLYU PUMV'ULNLUIVYURVTKL =LYHYILP[UN ]VU 0UW[ KLY PU[LYKPZaPWSPUpYLU (YILP[ZRYLPZTP[NSPLKLY PZZLU
+YJR UK =LYHYILP[UN! ZJOHM[SLY 7YHR[PRLY aR…UM[PNL (U^LUKLY HZ U[LYULOTLU UK )LYH[LY
SVNV 7YPU[ .TI/ 9PLKLYPJO 3HMLUKL ,Y^LP[LYUN KYJO (UYLNUNLU UK 0KLLU HZ KLY 7YH_PZ ¶ KPLZLY
7UR[ ISLPI[ PT :PUUL LPULY RVU[PUPLYSPJOLU =LYILZZLYUN UVJO VMMLU
4P[ KLT ]VYSPLNLUKLU *VU[YVSSPUN :[H[LTLU[ ^LYKLU KPL NLZHT[LU ,YNLIUPZZL
UVJOTHSZ aZHTTLUMHZZLUK KHYNLZ[LSS[
(U KPLZLY :[LSSL T€JO[LU ^PY UZ NHUa OLYaSPJO ILP HSSLU )L[LPSPN[LU KLZ -HJO
RYLPZLZ 4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN ZV^PL HSSLU KPL a KPLZLT :[H[LTLU[ ZV^PL KLU
(MSHNL (WYPS aHOSYLPJOLU =LY€MMLU[SPJOUNLU ILPNL[YHNLU OHILU ILKHURLU
0:)5
:PLNMYPLK .pUSLU

4. 1. Der Weg zur Modernen Budgetierung
Mitglieder des Facharbeitskreises 1.1 Planung ist Vorbereitung, nicht Vorbestimmung der Zukunft
Prof. Dr. Ronald Gleich ¶ ,): UP]LYZP[p[ M…Y PY[ZJOHM[ UK 9LJO[ :WLaPLSS *VU[YVSSLY ILZJOpM[PNLU ZPJO PU[LUZP] TP[ KLY 7SHUUN POYLU 4L[OVKLU
-HJOHYILP[ZRYLPZSLP[LY UK 0UZ[YTLU[LU PZ[ KVJO KPL 7SHUUN LPU aLU[YHSLZ 0UZ[YTLU[ aY :[LLYUN
Udo Kraus ¶ /HUZNYVOL :, -HJOHYILP[ZRYLPZSLP[LY:[LSS]LY[YL[LY ]VU U[LYULOTLU UK KHZ VI^VOS LZ NLYHKL *VU[YVSSLYU RSHY PZ[ KHZZ 7SpUL
Dr. Uwe Michel ¶ /VY]m[O
7HY[ULYZ -HJOHYILP[ZRYLPZSLP[LY:[LSS]LY[YL[LY ZLS[LU ZV LPU[YLMMLU ^PL NLKHJO[ +PLZL :PJOLYOLP[ …ILY KHZ É5PJO[[YLMMLU¸ SPLN[
LPULYZLP[Z HU KLY .YUKZ[YR[Y KLY PY[ZJOHM[ HSZ LPU L]VS[PVUpYLY 7YVaLZZ TP[
Uwe Becking ¶ (NLU[Y M…Y (YILP[ c Petra Bohn ¶ 7YLUH .TI/ c Bernhard UNL^PZZLT (ZNHUN ¶ aR…UM[PNL ,YLPNUPZZL SHZZLU ZPJO UPJO[ ]VYOLYZHNLU
Bücker ¶ )…JRLY *VUZS[PUN c Dr. Elmar Dworski ¶ UP]LYZP[p[ :[[[NHY[ +PLZL Z[pUKPNL =LYpUKLYUN KPL U…ILYZJOHIHYL AHOS HU ,PUMSZZMHR[VYLU UK
+LSVP[[L c Prof. Dr. Christoph Eisl ¶ -/ 6ILY€Z[LYYLPJO c Stefan Erlenbach KPL UT€NSPJORLP[ ILZ[PTT[L 0UMVYTH[PVULU ^PL [H[ZpJOSPJOL 2HM,U[ZJOLP
¶ ,U) c Dr. Patricia Frey ¶ ,): UP]LYZP[p[ M…Y PY[ZJOHM[ UK 9LJO[ /HUZ KUNLU PT ]VYUOLYLPU a RLUULU LYSHILU RLPUL L_HR[LU 7YVNUVZLU (UKLYLY
NYVOL :, c Siegfried Gänßlen ¶ /HUZNYVOL :, c Matthias Handrich ¶ ,): ZLP[Z LU[Z[LOLU SHMLUK ULL 0KLLU 7YVKR[L UK U[LYULOTLU U[LY KPLZLU
UP]LYZP[p[ M…Y PY[ZJOHM[ UK 9LJO[ c Markus Happe )LU[LSLY (. c Lars )LKPUNUNLU RHUU KLY 5[aLU KLY 7SHUUN NHUa VMMLUZPJO[SPJO UPJO[ KHYPU
Hartje ¶ +LTH[PJ c Stefan Hirsch ¶ 6KL^HSK
*VTWHUPL c Prof. Dr. Hans- SPLNLU NLUH MLZ[aSLNLU ^HZ PU KLY ARUM[ WHZZPLYLU ^PYK
Ulrich Holst ¶ -/ 6ZUHIY…JR c Axel Israel ¶ YLU[ H JVU[YVSSLY c Christian Jan-
ßen ¶ MIT N.TI/ c Michael Kappes ¶ /VY]m[O
7HY[ULYZ c Matthias Koch HZ PZ[ KHUU KLY A^LJR KLY 7SHUUN
¶ 7YVJ[LY
.HTISL c Bernd Koschitzki ¶ *:: .TI/ c Claudia Maron ¶ 7SpUL ZPUK UPJO[ …ILYMS…ZZPN VKLY U[aSVZ É7SHUUN LYZL[a[ KLU AMHSS
+H[L] L. c Dr. Martin Mayr ¶ *VU9VVT 6. c Alexandra Meidl ¶ *VU9VVT ZVUKLYU ]PLSTLOY U€[PN T 9LZZVYJLU 2H KYJO KLU 0YY[T ¶ UK HZ
6. c Andreas Nebe ¶ +L[ZJOL ;LSLRVT (. c Dr. Karsten Oehler ¶ 0)4 c WHaP[p[LU 7LYZVUHS -PUHUaLU a[LPSLU UK 0YY[T RHUU THU SLYULU¸
Peter Pfeiffer ¶ .25 +YP]LSPUL .TI/ c Gunter Piotrowski ¶ (_LS :WYPUNLY HMa[LPSLU ILaPLOUNZ^LPZL HMLPUHUKLY
(. c Prof. Dr. Robert Rieg ¶ /VJOZJOSL (HSLU c Jenoe Rosenthal ¶ +L[ HIZ[PTTLU a R€UULU +HZ OPSM[ KPL LPUaLS
ZJOL ;LSLRVT (. c Lars Riemer ¶ /VY]m[O
7HY[ULYZ c Dr. Peter Schentler ULU ;LPSL LPULY 6YNHUPZH[PVU HM NLTLPUZHTL APLSL HZaYPJO[LU 9LZZVYJLU
¶ ,): UP]LYZP[p[ M…Y PY[ZJOHM[ UK 9LJO[ /VY]m[O
7HY[ULYZ c Christian ZPUK PTTLY ILNYLUa[ UK ]LYZJOPLKLUL =LY^LUKUNLU RVURYYPLYLU T ZPL
Schmahl ¶ +L[ZJOL ;LSLRVT (. c Dr. Matthias Schmitt ¶ U[LYULOTLUZ +YJO LPUL MY…OaLP[PNL lILYSLNUN ^HZ NLZJOLOLU R€UU[L ILYLP[LU ZPJO U
ILYH[UN c Jürgen Schnöbel ¶ /0+ .SVIHS c Thomas Schulze ¶ :(7 +L[ZJO [LYULOTLU ILZZLY HM KPL ARUM[ ]VY :PL NL^PUULU U[LY TZ[pUKLU ^PJO[P
SHUK c Steffen Sindl ¶ :PUKS *VU[YVSSPUNZ`Z[LTL c Markus Steiner ¶ +L[LJVU NL aLP[SPJOL =VYZWY…UNL UK ILYLP[LU ZPJO NLKHURSPJO HM fUKLYUNLU VKLY ULL
c Gregoris Theisen ¶ /0+ .SVIHS c Prof. Dr. Martin Tschandl ¶ -/ 1VHUUL ,U[^PJRSUNLU ]VY
T c Mathias Walter ¶ ;LSLRVT (. c Dr. Matthias Weiß ¶ 2€SULY=LYRLOYZ
)L[YPLIL (. c Helmut Willmann ¶ :0*2 (. +PL 7SHUUN PZ[ PTTLY U[LYULOTLUZZWLaPMPZJO UK RHUU QH TZZ ZPJO ]VU
U[LYULOTLU a U[LYULOTLU U[LYZJOLPKLU ZLSIZ[ ^LUU ZPL PU KLYZLSILU
)YHUJOL [p[PN UK pOUSPJO NYV VKLY pOUSPJO VYNHUPZPLY[ ZPUK ,Z NPI[ HILY
LPUPNL .YUKZp[aL UK 7YPUaPWPLU KPL M…Y HSSL U[LYULOTLU NLS[LU ZVSS[LU UK
KPL NLUH KLU 2LYU KLY 7SHUUN HZTHJOLU ¶ ZPL ZPUK PU KLY 4VKLYULU )K
NL[PLYUN ILZJOYPLILU (ILY ]VY^LN ZPUK LPU WHHY 2SHYZ[LSSUNLU …ILY KPL
]LY^LUKL[LU )LNYPMML UK 2VUaLW[L a [YLMMLU

5. 1.2 Was sind Budget und Budgetierung? 0T ^LP[LYLU :PUU PZ[ KPL )KNL[PLYUN ;LPS KLZ 7LYMVYTHUJL4HUHNLTLU[7YV
aLZZLZ +PLZLY ILPUOHS[L[ ;LPSWYVaLZZL ]VU KLY 7YVNUVZL aR…UM[PNLY ,U[^PJR
0U LPULY =PLSaHOS ]VU U[LYULOTLU UK 6YNHUPZH[PVULU U[LYZJOPLKSPJOZ[LY )YHU SUNLU …ILY KPL =LYLPUIHYUN UK -LZ[SLNUN ]VU APLSLU (UYLPaLU (R[PVUZ
JOLU UK .Y€LU Z[HY[L[ QpOYSPJO KLY 7YVaLZZ KLY ÉRYaMYPZ[LU ,YMVSNZWSHUUN¸ WSpULU UK 9LZZVYJLU IPZ a KLYLU T
,NNLYPU[LYOLSSLY M…Y KHZ UpJOZ[L .LZJOpM[ZQHOY LZLU[SPJOLY )LZ[HUK ZL[aUN 2VU[YVSSL UK :[LLYUN +Ha ]LY
[LPS UK TVUL[pYLZ ,YNLIUPZ LPULY ZVSJOLU HU[^VY[LU *VU[YVSSLY …ISPJOLY^LPZL KYLP aLU +PL U[LYQpOYPNL :[LLYUN
KLZ U[LYULOTLUZ PZ[ ]VU
VWLYH[P]LU 7SHUUN PZ[ KHZ )KNL[ [YHSL 2LYULSLTLU[L KLZ *VU[YVSSPUN2YLPZ
7SHUUN )KNL[PLYUN UK
+PL VWLYH[P]L 7SHUUN UK KHZ )KNL[ ZPUK )KNL[Z ZPUK LOLY RYaMYPZ[PN SHMZ! KHZ 7SHUUNZ KHZ 2VU[YVSS UK KHZ
UK TP[ LPULT Z[HYRLU (I^LPJOUNZHUHS`ZL HIOpUNPN
0UZ[YTLU[L ÉaY LY[YHNZ RVZ[LU SLPZ[UNZ 9LWVY[PUNZ`Z[LT )KNL[PLYUN HSZ ^LZLU[ ¶ KHZ PZ[ LPUL )HZPZSLPZ[UN KLZ
=LYIPUKSPJORLP[ZNYHK HZNL
UK SPXPKP[p[ZVYPLU[PLY[LU :[LLYUN KLZ U SPJOLY ;LPS KLZ 7SHUUNZZ`Z[LTZ PZ[ PUMVSNL *VU[YVSSPUNZ
Z[H[[L[L MVYTHSaPLSVYPLU[PLY[L
[LYULOTLUZ¸ 0*=:[H[LTLU[ É6WLYH[P]L 7SH 7SpUL È1HOYLZIKNL[BZD» KPL )HZPZ M…Y RSHZZPZJOL *VU[YVSSLY(YILP[
UUN %)KNL[#¸ :PL Z[LOLU HT )LNPUU KLZ /VY]m[O
RSHZZPZJOLU *VU[YVSSPUN2YLPZSHMZ UK MVYKLYU 6OUL 7SHUUN UK )KNL[Z NPI[ LZ RLPUL (I^LPJOUNZPUMVYTH[PVULU M…Y :[LL
aT /HUKLSU UK :[LLYU HM ZPUK ZVTP[ )H YUNZLU[ZJOLPKUNLU UK ZVTP[ RLPUL U[LYQpOYPNL :[LLYUN KLZ U[LYULO
ZPZ KLZ *VU[YVSSPUNRYLPZSHMZ +LY 7YVaLZZ aY )KNL[LYZ[LSSUN ^PYK HSZ )KNL TLUZ …ILY KHZ *VU[YVSSPUN +LY )KNL[PLYUNZWYVaLZZ SpM[ PT 0KLHSMHSS PU[L
[PLYUN ILaLPJOUL[ UK ILPUOHS[L[ KPL -LZ[SLNUN KLY -VYTHS UK )KNL[aPLSL NYPLY[ HI! ALYZ[ ^LYKLU Z[YH[LNPZJOL APLSL UK :[YH[LNPLU a KLYLU ,YYLPJOUN
-VSNLUKL ,SLTLU[L KLY )KNL[PLYUN ^LYKLU U[LYZJOPLKLU! MLZ[NLSLN[ KHUHJO )KNL[PLYUNZYHOTLU KLMPUPLY[ UK HM KPLZL ILPKLU LYZ[LU
:JOYP[[L HMIHLUK VWLYH[P]L 7SHUUNLU M…Y 4pYR[L 7YVKR[L )LZJOHMMUN
Budgetfahrplan :JOYPM[SPJOL 9PJO[SPUPLU aY :[HUKHYKPZPLYUN KLY (MIHZ[YR[Y UK 7YVKR[PVU 3VNPZ[PR :VUKLY7YVQLR[L ZV^PL 7LYZVUHS UK .LTLPURVZ[LU
KLZ )KNL[PLYUNZWYVaLZZLZ!
‹ :[HUKHYKPZPLY[L )LNYPMML UK AZHTTLUOpUNL
‹ =LYHU[^VY[UNLU WLYZVULSS APLSL HZ TP[[LSSHUNMYPZ[PNLY 7SHUUN
‹ HSSNLTLPULY UK HR[LSSLY ALP[WSHU )LY…JRZPJO[PNUN =VYQHOYLZLYNLIUPZZL
‹ 2VZ[LUHY[LU UK 2VZ[LUZ[LSSLUWSHU PURS 2VZ[LUHY[LUNYWWLU )LY…JRZPJO[PNUN 9HOTLUILKPUNUNLU
‹ (U^LPZUNLU aY ,YTP[[SUN KLY MUR[PVUHSLU 7SpUL a ) :[HUKHYKP
ZPLYUN KLY 7LYZVUHSWSHUUN KLY 2HSRSH[PVUZZ[UKLULYTP[[SUN
‹ 0UZ[YTLU[L a ) -VYTSHYL +H[LPLU =VYNHILU 7SHUUN
=VYQHOYLZLYNLIUPZZL
/VJOYLJOUUNLU L[J (IZH[a UK TZH[aWSHUUN
4HYRL[PUNWSHUUN PURS :VY[PTLU[ )KNL[LU[ZJOLPKUN
Funktionale Pläne 7SpUL KLY LPUaLSULU -UR[PVUZILYLPJOL(I[LPSUNLU aY ,YYLPJOUN
KLY ZLSIZ[[VWKV^U KLÄUPLY[LU APLSL TLUNLUVYPLU[PLY[
Erfolgsplan (M .=+LJRUNZILP[YHNZYLJOUUN IHZPLYLUKL ,YMVSNZWSHUUN )LY…JRZPJO[PNUN KLY )LZ[pUKL
(Leistungsbudget) QL (M^HUKZ2VZ[LUHY[ UK 2VZ[LUZ[LSSL 7YVKR[PVUZWSHUUN PURS 4LUNLU =LYOHUKSUNZZJOSHMLU
Finanzplan +PYLR[LPUKPYLR[L ,YTP[[SUN KLZ AHOSUNZTP[[LS…ILYZJOZZLZILKHYMZ )LZJOHMMUNZ UK 0U]LZ[P[PVUZWSHUUN UK 7SHUHUWHZZUNLU
*HZO-SV^9LJOUUN A^PZJOLU-LY[PN^HYLU3HNLYWSHUUN
Planbilanz .LWSHU[L =LYT€NLUZ UK 2HWP[HSSHNL HZ 3LPZ[UNZIKNL[
UK -PUHUaWSHU 7YVQLR[ UK (R[P]P[p[LUWSHUUN AZHTTLUM…OYLU KLY
Investitionsplan .LWSHU[L 0U]LZ[P[PVULU ;LPSWSpUL a U[LYULOTLUZ
ZTTPLY[ HJO PT -PUHUaWSHU UK PU KLY 7SHUIPSHUa .LZHT[IKNL[
7LYZVUHSWSHUUN
Budget- ,PU IPZ TLOYLYL É=LYOHUKSUNZZJOSHMLU¸ aY (IZ[PTTUN Ia^
verhandlungen 2VVYKPUPLYUN KLY ;LPSWSpULIKNL[Z UK ,YYLPJOUN ]VU LY^…UZJO[LU
.LZHT[aPLSLUIKNL[Z .LTLPURVZ[LUWSHUUN QL 2VZ[LUZ[LSSL
;HILSSL ! +PL ,SLTLU[L KLY )KNL[PLYUN
]NS ;ZJOHUKS-YL`.SLPJO/VMTHUU +HTIYV^ZRP (IIPSKUN ! +PL PU[LNYPLY[L 7SHUUN HSZ ZJOYP[[^LPZL =VYNLOLUZ^LPZL

6. KYJONLM…OY[ )LP KLT PU KLY 7YH_PZ PU KLY =LYNHUNLUOLP[ VM[ HUNL^HUK[LU .L 1.3 Die Grenzen der Budgetierung
NLUZ[YVT]LYMHOYLU =VYNHILU ]VU VILU 7SHUUN ]VU U[LU =LYOHUKSUNLU
aY ,PUPNUN ^LYKLU ZJOSPLSPJO UHJO TLOY VKLY ^LUPNLY HM^LUKPNLU ;YV[a KLZ PU (IIPSKUN KHYNLZ[LSS[LU 5[
+PL WYVaLZZHIOpUNPNLU
=LYOHUKSUNZZJOSHMLU HSSL ;LPSWSpUL PU LPULT TVUL[pYLU LUKN…S[PNLU 7SHU ¶ aLUZ NPI[ LZ ZLP[ 1HOYLU LPUL +PZRZZPVU …ILY
2YP[PRWUR[L HU KLY
KLT )KNL[ ¶ aZHTTLUNLM…OY[ KPL 5HJO[LPSL Ia^ a^LJRTpPNL (ZNLZ[HS
)KNL[PLYUN ILYNLU LPU
[UN ]VU 7SHUUN UK )KNL[PLYUN +PL YLSH[P] KPYLR[ ILLPUMSZZIHYLZ
)LP KPLUZ[SLPZ[UNZVYPLU[PLY[LU U[LYULOTLU OHILU KPL :JOYP[[L TP[ )LZ[pUKLU 7YVISLTL KLY U[LYULOTLU TP[ KLY )KNL 6W[PTPLYUNZWV[LUaPHS PU ZPJO
)LZJOHMMUN0U]LZ[P[PVU 3HNLY UK 7YVKR[PVU RLPUL VKLY LPUL NLYPUNLYL [PLYUN UK KHTP[ KPL 2YP[PR HT 7YVaLZZ
)LKL[UN UK HU KLU 0UOHS[LU KLY )KNL[PLYUN
ZPUK ILRHUU[!
,U[^PJRLS[ ^YKLU )KNL[Z ]VY …ILY 1HOYLU aY RVVYKPUPLY[LU -…OYUN
KLaLU[YHSLY Ia^ RVUaLYUHSLY U[LYULOTLUZZ[YR[YLU (UZ[H[[ WLYZ€USPJOLY ‹ +PL 7SHUUN RHUU a KL[HPSSPLY[ UK …ILY]VSSZ[pUKPN NLYH[LU KHZ LYO€O[ KLU
-…OYUN KLY YpTSPJO NL[YLUU[LU -HIYPRLU ]LY^LUKL[L THU 7SHUUNZ UK 9LZZVYJLUHM^HUK UK KPL 2VZ[LU KLY )KNL[PLYUN ]LYZJOSLJO[LY[ HILY
2VU[YVSSZ`Z[LTL aY :[LLYUN +HZZ KPL )KNL[PLYUN …ILY LPULU ZV SHUNLU NSLPJOaLP[PN KPL -SL_PIPSP[p[ UK +H[LUHR[HSP[p[
ALP[YHT ILP LPULT NYVLU ;LPS KLY U[LYULOTLU ^LS[^LP[ HUNL^HUK[ ^PYK ‹ 3HUN^PLYPNL (IZ[PTTUNZWYVaLZZL M…OYLU a ^LUPN OLYHZMVYKLYUKLU 2VT
SPLN[ HU POYLT ]PLSMpS[PNLU 5[aLU ]NS (IIPSKUN UK ;€WMLY ! WYVTPZZS€ZUNLU
‹ +PL 7V[LUaPHSL PT 4P[HYILP[LYILYLPJO ^LYKLU UY THUNLSOHM[ NLU[a[ ^LPS U
NLWSHU[L *OHUJLU HMNYUK KLY NLZL[a[LU )KNL[NYLUaLU UY LPUNLZJOYpUR[
Checkliste zur Selbsteinschätzung: ^HOYULOTIHY ZPUK
LSJOLU 5[aLU IYPUN[ UZ KPL )KNL[PLYUN ‹ +PL MLOSLUKL ,PUIPUKUN KLY )L[YVMMLULU ILP KLY )KNL[LYZ[LSSUN M…OY[ [LU
KLUaPLSS a MLOSLUKLY 0KLU[PMPRH[PVU TP[ KLU )KNL[aPLSLU +HZ TPUKLY[ KPL =LY
; :PL a^PUN[ UZ a LPULY RSHYLU APLSMVYTSPLYUN HU[^VY[SPJORLP[
; :PL M…OY[ aT +LURLU PU AZHTTLUOpUNLU UK (S[LYUH[P]LU 7SpUL ‹ +PL 6YPLU[PLYUN HU PU[LYULU =VYNHILU UK 4HJO[WYVaLZZLU ]LYOPUKLY[ LPUL
; :PL RVVYKPUPLY[ UZLYL U[LYZJOPLKSPJOLU ;LPSL)LYLPJOL KLZ HZYLPJOLUKL )LY…JRZPJO[PNUN KLY fUKLYUNLU KLY T^LS[ ZV^PL KLY 4HYR[
U[LYULOTLUZ 0U[LNYH[PVU HUMVYKLYUNLU
; :PL ZJOHMM[ 2SHYOLP[ KYJO +VRTLU[H[PVU ‹ ,PU …ILY^PLNLUK TVUL[pYLY -VRZ SpZZ[ UPJO[TVUL[pYL LY[L ^PL ILPZWPLSZ
; :PL ZJOHMM[ 2SHYOLP[ KYJO 0UMVYTH[PVU KLY KVRTLU[PLY[LU 0UOHS[L ^LPZL KLU 2UKLUZ[HTT UILY…JRZPJO[PN[
; :PL M€YKLY[ KPL =LYHU[^VY[SPJORLP[ UHJO PUULU APLSZL[aUN ‹ :[H[PZJOL APLSZL[aUNLU ]LYOPUKLYU LPUL YLSH[P]L Ia^ ^L[[IL^LYIZVYPLU[PLY[L
; :PL LYO€O[ KPL (UWHZZUNZ UK 9LHR[PVUZMpOPNRLP[ UZLYLZ (ZYPJO[UN ILPZWPLSZ^LPZL HIOpUNPN ]VU KLY ,U[^PJRSUN KLY 2VURYYLUa
U[LYULOTLUZ ‹ :[YH[LNPZJOL (ZWLR[L ^LYKLU UPJO[ Ia^
; :PL LYO€O[ UZLYL 0UUV]H[PVUZRYHM[ 9LHR[PVU:[LLYUN ILP a ^LUPN ILY…JRZPJO[PN[
(I^LPJOUNLU ‹ +PL 0U[LNYH[PVU KLY Z[YH[LNPZJOLU UK VWL ,PUNLZJOYpUR[ ]LYpUKLYIHY
; :PL ]LYILZZLY[ KPL =LYHU[^VY[UN UK (YNTLU[H[PVUZRYHM[ UHJO YH[P]LU 7SHUUN PZ[ ILP KLT …ILY^PLNLUK ZPUK KPL TP[ KLY )KNL[PL
ÉHLU¸ NLNLU…ILY ,PNLU-YLTKRHWP[HSNLILY HUNL^HUK[LU ALP[MVRZ HM LPU 1HOY THU YUN ]LYIUKLULU PUOHS[
NLSOHM[ ,PU 1HOY ^PLKLYT PZ[ a SHUN M…Y SPJOLU 2YP[PRWUR[L
LPUL YLPU VWLYH[P]L :[LLYUN
(IIPSKUN ! *OLJRSPZ[L É5[aLU KLY )KNL[PLYUN¸

7. ‹ +`ZMUR[PVUHSLZ =LYOHS[LU ^PYK [LUKLUaPLSS NLM€YKLY[! +YJO KPL 2VWWLSUN 1.4 Bisherige Ansätze in der Budgetierung
]VU 7YVNUVZL7SHUUN UK 4V[P]H[PVU RHUU LZ PU KLY 7SHUUN a LPULY 4PUP
TPLYUN KLY ,Y[YHNZaPLSL Ia^ LPULY 4H_PTPLYUN KLY 2VZ[LU KLU ,PUIH ]VU (SZ ,YNLIUPZ KLY +PZRZZPVU …ILY KPL .YLUaLU KLY )KNL[PLYUN ZPUK ULL (U
7MMLYU VKLY a UHJO[YpNSPJOLU 4HUPWSH[PVULU RVTTLU Zp[aL LU[Z[HUKLU KPL LPULYZLP[Z LPUL ZJOYP[[^LPZL RSLPUL =LYILZZLYUN KLY )K
NL[PLYUN ]VYZJOSHNLU )L[[LY )KNL[PUN
;YV[a KLY VM[ a[YLMMLUKLU 2YP[PR HZ KLY 7YH_PZ! :V THUJOLT *VU[YVSSLY UK HUKLYLYZLP[Z M…Y KLYLU ]VSSZ[pUKPNL (IZJOHM
9LZS[H[ KLY 2YP[PR ¶
4HUHNLY PZ[ UPJO[ RSHY KHZZ -…OYUN ò UK KPL KHM…Y LPUNLZL[a[LU 0UZ[YTLU[L MUN WSpKPLYLU )L`VUK )KNL[PUN (SSLY
ULL (UZp[aL
HSZV HJO )KNL[PLYUN ò PTTLY KHZ :WHUUUNZMLSK a^PZJOLU TLOYLYLU KPUNZ OHILU ZPJO KPL IPZOLYPNLU (U[^VY[LU
]VU )L[[LY )KNL[PUN
/LYHZMVYKLYUNLU HZNSLPJOLU T…ZZLU ,Z R€UULU UPJO[ HSSL APLSL NSLPJOaLP[PN HM KPL 2YP[PR HU KLY )KNL[PLYUN UY IL IPZ )L`VUK )KNL[PUN
LYYLPJO[ ^LYKLU ]PLSTLOY ZPUK 2VTWYVTPZZL UV[^LUKPN +PL UaMYPLKLUOLP[ KPUN[ HSZ NLLPNUL[ LY^PLZLU ZPLOL ;HILSSL
]PLSLY (U^LUKLY TP[ KLY )KNL[PLYUN YLZS[PLY[ OpMPN HZ KLT MLOSLUKLU
=LYZ[pUKUPZ M…Y KPL UT€NSPJORLP[ HSSL APLSL NSLPJOaLP[PN LYM…SSLU a R€UULU )L[[LY )KNL[PUN (K]HUJLK )KNL[PUN )L`VUK )KNL[PUN
9PLN.SLPJO:JOLU[SLY ,Z LU[Z[LOLU APLSRVUMSPR[L! Ziel 6W[PTPLYUN LPUaLSULY 6W[PTPLYUN KLZ =LYpUKLYUN KLZ
)LYLPJOL KLY 7SHUUN NLZHT[LU NLZHT[LU 4HUHNL
7SHUUNZZ`Z[LTZ TLU[Z`Z[LTZ
‹ ,PU )LPZWPLS M…Y ZVSJOL APLSHU[PUVTPLU PZ[ KLY Spagat zwischen Genauig-
Absicht )LPILOHS[UN KLY AY…JRKYpUNUN (IZJOHMMUN ]VU
keit und Einfachheit. :VSS ILPZWPLSZ^LPZL LPUL U[LYQpOYPNL KL[HPSSPLY[L )KNL[PLYUN KLY )LKL[UN ]VU )KNL[Z HSZ Ä_PLY[L
(I^LPJOUNZHUHS`ZL HSSLY 2VZ[LUZ[LSSLU T€NSPJO ZLPU TZZ HJO LPUL LU[ )KNL[Z 3LPZ[UNZ]LY[YpNL
ZWYLJOLUKL 7SHUUN LYMVSNLU +PL )KNL[PLYUN PZ[ KHUU a^HY ]VSSZ[pUKPN UK Ergebnis =LYILZZLYUN ]VU ,YO€OUN KLY )LZZLYL U[LYULOTLUZ
WUR[LSSLU 7SHUUNZXHSP[p[ Z[LLYUN KYJO
NLUH HILY UPJO[ LPUMHJO UK PU KLY 9LNLS HJO UPJO[ MSL_PILS HUWHZZIHY :JO^HJOWUR[LU UK =LYYPUNLYUN 9…JRILZPUUUN HM
‹ fOUSPJOLZ PZ[ HJO ILPT 7SHUUNZa^LJR a ILVIHJO[LU -…Y KPL 4V[P]H[PVU KLY 7SHUUN KLZ )KNL[PLYUNZ TP[HYILP[LYVYPLU[PLY[L
,MÄaPLUaZ[LPNLYUN HM^HUKZ WHY[PaPWH[P]L
KLY -…OYUNZRYpM[L UK 4P[HYILP[LY ZPUK Ziele in herausfordernder HILY (M^HUKZZLURUN -…OYUNZRVUaLW[L
LYYLPJOIHYLY /€OL U€[PN M…Y KPL U[LYQpOYPNL 2HWHaP[p[ZILYLP[Z[LSSUN UK Planung =LYLPUMHJOUN UK =LYLPUMHJOUN UK 9VSSPLYLUKL HM
Z[LLYUN T€NSPJOZ[ ^HOYZJOLPUSPJO LPU[YL[LUKL 7YVNUVZLU 2VUaLU[YH[PVU HM 2VUaLU[YH[PVU HM TVUL[pYL UK UPJO[
LYMVSNZRYP[PZJOL LYMVSNZRYP[PZJOL TVUL[pYL 2LYUNY€LU
7YVaLZZL ]LYZ[pYR[L 7YVaLZZL ]LYZ[pYR[L MVRZZPLYLUKL
+PLZL UK aHOSYLPJOL ^LP[LYL )LPZWPLSL LYSp[LYU RVUMSPR[pYL APLSL KPL PU KLY 7SH )LY…JRZPJO[PNUN )LY…JRZPJO[PNUN 7SHUUN PU[LNYPLY[L
UUN HM[YL[LU UK KYJO RLPU )KNL[PLYUNZRVUaLW[ NLS€Z[ ^LYKLU R€UULU Z[YH[LNPZJOLY 0UOHS[L UPJO[ TVUL[pYLY VWLYH[P]L UK
PU KLY VWLYH[P]LU .Y€LU ,PUZH[a ULLY Z[YH[LNPZJOL 7SHUUN
+LY .YUK! KPL 2VUMSPR[L ZPUK PUOpYLU[ TP[ KLU 7SHUUNZ…ILYSLNUNLU ]LYIU 7SHUUN 0UZ[YTLU[L ):* +LaLU[YHSPZPLYUN KLY
KLU =PLS ^PJO[PNLY PZ[ HILY KHZZ ZPJO 4HUHNLY UK *VU[YVSSLY ]VY KLY 7SHUUN )LUJOTHYRPUN PU[L 7SHUUN
NYPLY[L VWLYH[P]L UK
.LKHURLU THJOLU welche Ziele primär ]LYMVSN[ ^LYKLU ZVSSLU Z[YH[LNPZJOL 7SHUUN
Motivation :[pYRLYLY -VRZ :[pYRLYLY -VRZ HM :LSIZ[HKQZ[PLYLUKL
HM THYR[VYPLU[PLY[L THYR[VYPLU[PLY[L APLS APLSZL[aUN YLSH[P]
APLSZL[aUN ZL[aUN a PU[LYULUL_[LYULU
=LYNSLPJOZVIQLR[LU
Koordination =VY^PLNLUK =VY^PLNLUK 2VVYKPUH +LaLU[YHSL THYR[pOU
2VVYKPUH[PVU …ILY [PVU …ILY 7SpUL SPJOL 2VVYKPUH[PVU
7SpUL U[LYZ[…[aUN KYJO
aLU[YHSL :[LSSLU
;HILSSL ! +PL IPZOLYPNLU (UZp[aL aY =LYpUKLYUN KLY )KNL[PLYUN PT =LYNSLPJO

8. 2. Moderne Budgetierung
Better Budgeting PZ[ RLPU NLZJOSVZZLULZ 2VUaLW[ ZVUKLYU UY LPU 6ILY ;YV[a KLY NLZJOPSKLY[LU 7YVISLTL RHUU UK ZVSS HM 7SHUUN UK )KNL[PLYUN
ILNYPMM M…Y LPUL =PLSaHOS ]VU =LYILZZLYUNZPKLLU UK PUZ[YTLU[LU KPL OLSMLU UPJO[ ]LYaPJO[L[ ^LYKLU ,Z PZ[ HILY UV[^LUKPN KPLZL a TVKLYUPZPLYLU UK HU
R€UULU KLU HSSLUMHSSZ HUNLZL[a[LU É:WLJR¸ ¶ HSZV PULMMPaPLU[L UK PULMMLR[P]L KPL HR[LSSLU .LNLILUOLP[LU UK T^LS[ILKPUNUNLU HUaWHZZLU ,PU ZVSJOLZ
;LPSL KLZ PU ZPJO LPNLU[SPJO ZJOSHURLU )KNL[PLYUNZRVUaLW[Z ¶ ^PLKLY HIa WYVISLTHKpXH[LZ 2VUaLW[ KHZ HJO PU KLY 7YH_PZ HU^LUKIHY PZ[ MLOS[L IPZ
IHLU ;ZJOHUKS:JOLU[SLY MM OLY +LY 0U[LYUH[PVUHSL *VU[YVSSLY =LYLPU 0*= OH[ KHOLY LPULU -HJOHYILP[ZRYLPZ
TP[ PZZLUZJOHM[SLYU UK 7YH_PZ]LY[YL[LYU
Advanced Budgeting aPLS[ ÉHM LPUL HIULOTLUKL )LKL[UN ]VU )KNL[Z ILHM[YHN[ LPU ^PZZLUZJOHM[SPJO MUKPLY[LZ -YHNL ! PYK RSHZZPZJOL
HM TP[[SLYL -YPZ[ ILP RYaMYPZ[PNLY :[LPNLYUN KLY 7SHUUNZXHSP[p[ UK =LYYPUNL Z[PTTPNLZ UK WYH_PZ[HNSPJOLZ 2VUaLW[ a )KNL[PLYUN U^PJO[PN
YUN KLZ )KNL[PLYUNZHM^HUKLZ¸ HI /VY]m[O
7HY[ULYZ T KPLZ LU[^PJRLSU! KPL 4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN
a LYYLPJOLU ZVSSLU LPULYZLP[Z KLY 7YVaLZZ KLY )KNL[PLYUN ]LYILZZLY[ UK
HUKLYLYZLP[Z 0UZ[YTLU[L ^PL KPL )HSHUJLK :JVYLJHYK 7YVaLZZRVZ[LUYLJOUUN ,Z ^PYK ^LP[LYOPU KLY )LNYPMM )KNL[PLYUN ]LY^LUKL[ KH ZPL HJO PU ARUM[
VKLY )LUJOTHYRPUN LPUNLZL[a[ ^LYKLU LPULZ KLY ^LZLU[SPJOLU 0UZ[YTLU[L aY :[LLYUN LPULZ U[LYULOTLUZ ZLPU
^PYK 5PJO[ UY KHZZ )HURLU ZJOVU ZLP[ )HZLS 00 KPL Z`Z[LTH[PZJOL (U^LUKUN
)LP KLT ]PLSMHJO PU 3P[LYH[Y UK 7YH_PZ KPZR[PLY[LU Beyond Budgeting OHU ]VU 7SHUUNZ UK *VU[YVSSPUNLYRaLNLU MVYKLYU (JO KPL PU ]PLSLU )YHU
KLS[ LZ ZPJO T ^LP[HZ TLOY HSZ UY 7SHUUN UK )KNL[PLYUN ,Z PZ[ LPU T JOLU aULOTLUKL 2VURYYLUa UK Z[LPNLUKL +`UHTPR aLPNLU KPL 5V[^LUKPN
MHZZLUKLZ 4HUHNLTLU[TVKLSS M…Y LPUL KLaLU[YHSPZPLY[L U[LYULOTLUZM…OYUN RLP[ NLaPLS[LY 7SHUUN :[LLYUN UK 2VU[YVSSL HM T HM aR…UM[PNL ,U[^PJR
UK Z[LLYUN KHZ HJO )KNL[PLYUNZHZWLR[L TMHZZ[ =VY KLT /PU[LY SUNLU ]VYILYLP[L[ a ZLPU UK LU[ZWYLJOLUK
NYUK KLY KLT 4VKLSS aNYUKL SPLNLUKLU 7YpTPZZLU LPUZLP[PNLZ 4LUZJOLU HNPLYLU UK YLHNPLYLU a R€UULU -LYULY IL -YHNL ! HYT
IPSK +`UHTPR HSZ )LNY…UKUN KLY 5V[^LUKPNRLP[ KLY 4HYR[ HSZ …ILYSLNLUL Z[p[PNLU U[LYZJOUNLU! 7SHUUN UK )K É4VKLYUL¸ )KNL[PLYUN ¶
2VVYKPUH[PVUZMVYT LUNLZ UK LPUZLP[PNLZ .LZJOpM[ZTVKLSS UK KLU PT 4V NL[PLYUN ZPUK KPL HT OpMPNZ[LU NLU[a[LU OH[ KPL É(S[L¸ HZNLKPLU[
KLSS ]VYOHUKLULU PKLYZWY…JOLU KLY THUNLSUKLU [OLVYL[PZJOLU -UKPLYUN *VU[YVSSPUNLYRaLNL
UK KLY MLOSLUKLU =LYIYLP[UN PU KLY 7YH_PZ ZJOLPU[ QLKVJO LPUL ,PNUUN M…Y
KLU NY€[LU ;LPS KLY U[LYULOTLU pLYZ[ MYHNSPJO 9PLN6LOSLY +LY AZH[a TVKLYU ZVSS KPL (UWHZZUN HU KPL HR[LSSLU (UMVYKLYUNLU ]LY
KL[SPJOLU 5HJO YUK 1HOYLU LYMVSNYLPJOLU ,PUZH[aLZ PU 4PSSPVULU ]VU U
[LYULOTLU ZL[aLU 7SHUUN UK )KNL[PLYUN VM[THSZ LPU ^LUPN É:WLJR¸ HU
+HZ HUNLZ[YLI[L APLS KLY 4VKLYULU )KNL[PLYUN PZ[ KLZOHSI RSHY! +PL )KNL
[PLYUN ZVSS ^PLKLY HM QLULU U[aLUIYPUNLUKLU UK Z[LLYUNZYLSL]HU[LU 2LYU
aY…JRNLIYHJO[ ^LYKLU KLY M…Y LPUL YH[PVUHSL U[LYULOTLUZM…OYUN UK Z[LL
YUN U€[PN PZ[ +Ha ^PYK KPL )KNL[PLYUN
LPUMHJO MSL_PILS UK PU[LNYPLY[ NLZ[HS[L[ IPS -YHNL ! PL ^YKL KPL
KL[ KPL U[LYULOTLUZZ[YR[Y UK LY[ 4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN
ZJO€WMUN HI UK SLN[ KLU -VRZ HM KPL RVUaPWPLY[
=LYTP[[SUN ]VU (IZPJO[LU
=PLSLU 4HUHNLTLU[RVUaLW[LU RHUU THU KLU =VY^YM THJOLU KHZZ ZPL ^LKLY
^PZZLUZJOHM[SPJO HINLZPJOLY[ UVJO ^PYRSPJO PU KLY 7YH_PZ LYMVSNYLPJO LYWYVI[ ZPUK

9. +PL 4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN U[LYZJOLPKL[ ZPJO KH]VU KL[SPJO! ,YZ[LUZ ^LYKLU 2.1 Herausforderungen für die Moderne Budgetierung
HSSL (ZZHNLU ZV^LP[ ^PL T€NSPJO [OLVYL[PZJO MUKPLY[ UK LTWPYPZJO ILSLN[
UK a^LP[LUZ ^YKLU SHMLUK (UYLNUNLU UK 0KLLU HZ 7YH_PZ UK ;OLVYPL pOYLUK KLY (M^HUK KLY 7SHUUN YLJO[ N[
5[aLU NLNLU
¶ PT :PUUL LPULY RVU[PUPLYSPJOLU =LYILZZLYUN ¶ LPUNLHYILP[L[ TLZZIHY PZ[ NLSPUN[ KHZ ILPT 5[aLU UY
(M^HUK HI^pNLU
ZJO^LY U[LYULOTLU M…OYLU …ILY KPL 1HOYL
T ]VU ]VYUOLYLPU ]PLSL (ZWLR[L 0KLLU UK :PJO[^LPZLU LPUaIYPUNLU ^YKLU PTTLY TLOY UK RVTWSL_LYL 4L[OVKLU UK
ILYLP[Z ILP KLY ,U[^PJRSUN KPL ^LZLU[SPJOLU IL[YVMMLULU 7LYZVULUNYWWLU 0UZ[YTLU[L LPU ^VKYJO LZ aULOTLUK ZJO^PLYPNLY ^PYK KLYLU aZp[aSPJOLU
LPUILaVNLU! PZZLUZJOHM[SLY aR…UM[PNL (U^LUKLY HZ U[LYULOTLU ZV^PL 5[aLU a LYRLUULU ,Z LYZJOLPU[ ZVNHY WSHZPILS ILP THUJOLU 0UZ[YTLU[LU
)LYH[LY ]VU LPULT HIULOTLUKLU .YLUaU[aLU HZaNLOLU
+HTP[ RVUU[LU ,YMHOYUNLU UK (UMVYKLYUNLU HZ ]PLSLU )YHUJOLU UK U
[LYULOTLUZNY€LU ILY…JRZPJO[PN[ ^LYKLU +PLZ ^YKL KYJO LPU )LUJOTHY U[LYULOTLU ZPUK TP[ ]PLSLU (UZWY…JOLU
RPUN TP[ TLOY HSZ ,_WLY[LUPU[LY]PL^Z UK -HSSZ[KPLU LYNpUa[ 5LILU KLT RVUMYVU[PLY[ UK ZLOLU ZPJO SHMLUK =LYpU +LY +`UHTPR UK KLU
Z[pUKPNLU =LYpUKL
)LUJOTHYRPUN UK KLY )LY…JRZPJO[PNUN KLZ 0UW[Z KLY -HJOHYILP[ZRYLPZTP[ KLYUNLU HZNLZL[a[ HU KPL ZPL ZPJO TLOY
YUNLU LPULU MSL_PISLU
NSPLKLY ^YKLU PT 9HOTLU KLY ,U[^PJRSUN KLZ 2VUaLW[Z HJO ILZ[LOLUKL VKLY ^LUPNLY HUWHZZLU ZVSS[LU T ^LP[LY 9HOTLU NLILU
U[LYULOTLUZRVUaLW[L HUHS`ZPLY[ UK LTWPYPZJOL ,YRLUU[UPZZL aY (ZNLZ[HS LYMVSNYLPJO a ZLPU +HZ ZWYpJOL M…Y YHZJOL
[UN KLY )KNL[PLYUN HZNL^LY[L[ +^VYZRP -YL`:JOLU[SLY (UWHZZUNLU ]VU 7SpULU UK )KNL[Z
,PUL a OpMPNL (UWHZZUN ^…YKL HILY KPL YZWY…UNSPJOLU APLSL ]LYNLZZLU
+PL PT 9HOTLU KLY 4VKLYULU )KNL[PLYUN OLYHZNLHYILP[L[LU =VYZJOSpNL SHZZLU UK KPL 7SHUUN I€[L KLU 4P[HYILP[LYU ^LUPN 6YPLU[PLYUN +HZ 4HUHNL
ZVSSLU aTPUKLZ[ HSZ É.VVK 7YHJ[PJL¸ VKLY PT 0KLHSMHSS HSZ É)LZ[ 7YHJ[PJL¸ HM TLU[ PZ[ NLMVYKLY[ OPLY LPUL HZNL^VNLUL 3€ZUN a MPUKLU
NLMHZZ[ ^LYKLU ,Z PZ[ KHILP a U[LYZ[YLPJOLU KHZZ M…Y LPUL OPLY HMNLUVT
TLUL LTWMVOSLUL /HUKSUNZ^LPZL VKLY 4L[OVKPR UPJO[ KPL /pMPNRLP[ KLY (U )KNL[Z R€UULU a^LP A^LJRLU KPLULU KPL
=LYOHS[LUZZ[LLYUN
^LUKUN PU U[LYULOTLU THNLISPJO PZ[ 4LOYMHJOULUUUNLU ZPUK HSSLUMHSSZ QLKVJO VM[ PU 2VURYYLUa aLPUHUKLY Z[LOLU
UK ,U[ZJOLPKUNZ
HSZ 0UKPa M…Y LPU IL^pOY[LZ =VYNLOLU a ^LY[LU =PLSTLOY OH[ ZPJO KLY -HJO ,PULYZLP[Z ZPUK ZPL KHa KH HSZ APLS]VYNHIL
U[LYZ[…[aUN HI^pNLU
HYILP[ZRYLPZ KPL (MNHIL NLZ[LSS[ KHZ =LYOHS[LU KLY 4HUHNLY a Z[LLYU UK
KLYLU 3LPZ[UN a TLZZLU HUKLYLYZLP[Z PZ[
‹ ULILU KLY /pMPNRLP[ KLY 0U[LY]PL^Z UK -HSSZ[KPLU TP[ U[LYULOTLU
LZ POY A^LJR ,U[ZJOLPKUNLU KLaLU[YHSLY )LYLPJOL a RVVYKPUPLYLU UK HM
+YJOM…OYUN HJO KYJONLM…OY[ H TP[ILP!
LPU …ILYNLVYKUL[LZ APLS HZaYPJO[LU 5Y ZLS[LU RHUU LPU UK KLYZLSIL 7SHU
‹ KPL )LNY…UKUNLU KLY U (J[LSPVU 7OHYTHJL[PJHSZ (_LS :WYPUNLY (. ILPKL A^LJRL LYM…SSLU +LUUVJO ZL[aLU ]PLSL U[LYULOTLU )KNL[Z KHM…Y LPU
[LYULOTLU M…Y KPL NL^pOS )(:- )LU[LSLY * )LYNTHUU 2. *3((: ,Z ]LY^UKLY[ UPJO[ KHZZ LZ KHUU a UaMYPLKLUOLP[ UK 2VUMSPR[LU RVTT[
[L =VYNLOLUZ^LPZL *5/ kZ[LYYLPJO +(;,= L. +L[ZJOL ;LSLRVT
‹ KPL NLTHJO[LU WVZP[P]LU ,U) ,ZJOLUIHJO 6W[PR -YPLKYPJO .YHLWLS (.
A^HY ZPUK 7SHUUN UK )KNL[PLYUN ^PJO[PNL -…OYUNZPUZ[YTLU[L QLKVJO
UK ULNH[P]LU ,YMHOYUNLU .25 +YP]LSPUL .YPTTL 3HUKTHZJOPULU
UPJO[ KPL LPUaPNLU 0OY 5[aLU OpUN[ LU[
UK /HUZNYVOL /LPKLTHYR 4pZ[LYRYLPZ /PWW
3PUa ,ULYNPL :LY]PJL 4HPJV 4LKPLUNYWWL ZJOLPKLUK ]VU KLU -…OYUNZWLYZVULU KLY
‹ KPL lILY[YHNIHYRLP[ KLZ NL U[LYULOTLUZRS[Y KLU aNYUKL SPLNLU 7SHUUN UK )KNL
+Y /HHZ 7YLWHJ /VSKPUN 9V[LUIYNLY LYRL
^pOS[LU =LYMHOYLUZ(UZH[ KLU 2VU[L_[MHR[VYLU a ) L[[IL^LYIZ
[PLYUN PU KHZ NLZHT[L
9LZJO
-YPZJO 9KVSM /HML =LYSHN :PJR (. -…OYUNZZ`Z[LT
aLZ HM HUKLYL U[LYULO K`UHTPR ZV^PL ]VT AZHTTLUZWPLS TP[
: :WP[a :[`YPH 4LKPH .YVW ;LSLRVT (Z[YPH LPUIL[[LU
TLU a ILY…JRZPJO[PNLU HUKLYLU 0UZ[YTLU[LU HI

10. 2.2 Antworten der Modernen Budgetierung 2.3 Die Moderne Budgetierung im Überblick
+PL (U[^VY[LU KLY 4VKLYULU )KNL[PLYUN HM KPL ]PLY ^LZLU[SPJOLU /LYHZMVY :PJO …ILY )KNL[PLYUNZZ`Z[LTL .LKHURLU a THJOLU SVOU[ ZPJO LYZ[ HI LPULY
KLYUNLU M…Y LPUL =LYILZZLYUN ZPUK PU KLY UHJOMVSNLUKLU ;HILSSL KHYNLZ[LSS[ ILZ[PTT[LU .Y€L UK 2VTWSL_P[p[ KLZ U[LYULOTLUZ :V NPI[ LZ HSSLPU PU
+L[ZJOSHUK YUK U[LYULOTLU HI 4P[HYILP[LYU ZV^PL NLTLPUU…[aP
Herausforderungen Antworten der Modernen Budgetierung NL UK €MMLU[SPJOL 6YNHUPZH[PVULU KPL KHM…Y WYPTpY PU -YHNL RVTTLU ^…YKLU
É5[aLU NLNLU ‹ 2VTWSL_P[p[ YLKaPLYLU! ÉLPUMHJOLY ^LYKLU¸ PU )LaN HM 5PLTHUK RHUU KLU (UZWYJO LYOLILU M…Y KPLZL ¶ UK HSSL HUKLYLU U[LYULO
(M^HUK HI^pNLU¸ 0;0UZ[YTLU[L 4L[OVKLU 7YVaLZZL TLU HM KLY LS[ ¶ LPUL -LZ[SLNUN a [YLMMLU ^PL KPL 7SHUUN PT +L[HPS HZNL
‹ :PJO HM ^LZLU[SPJOL Z[LLYUNZYLSL]HU[L 7SHUUNZPUOHS[L
ILZJOYpURLU Z[HS[L[ ZLPU TZZ ,Z PZ[ QLKVJO T€NSPJO LPULU 9HOTLU a ZJOHMMLU KLY PUKP]P
É+LY +`UHTPR UK KLU ‹ É-SL_PISLY ^LYKLU¸ ILPZWPLSZ^LPZL KYJO :aLUHYPLU YVSSPLYLUKL KLSSL (ZNLZ[HS[UNZT€NSPJORLP[LU aSpZZ[ -…Y KHZ 2VUaLW[ KLY 4VKLYULU )K
Z[pUKPNLU =LYpUKL 7SHUUN UK -VYLJHZ[Z VKLY YLSH[P]L APLSL NL[PLYUN MVSNLU KHYHZ KYLP ^PJO[PNL ,JRWUR[L!
YUNLU LPULU ÅL_PISLU ‹ .Y€ILY ^LYKLU! 1HOYLZaPLSL HSZ 9HOTLU RYaMYPZ[PN RVURYL[L APLSL
9HOTLU NLILU¸ ]VYNLILU
‹ 4HNLZJOULPKLY[! 9O`[OTZ UK TMHUN ]VU 7SHUHUWHZZUNLU ,YMVSNYLPJOL U[LYULOTLUZM…OYUN ILU€[PN[
U[LYULOTLUZPUKP]PKLSS MLZ[SLNLU APLSL KYJO :[LLYUN
:[LLYUNZLU[ZJOLPKUNLU T KPL APLSL a
É=LYOHS[LUZZ[LLYUN ‹ )KNL[PLYUN ZVSS HM ,U[ZJOLPKUNZU[LYZ[…[aUN MVRZZPLYLU LYYLPJOLU
UK ,U[ZJOLPKUNZ ‹ =HYPHISL =LYN…[UN HM )HZPZ LPULY HZIHSHUJPLY[LU 4PZJOUN ]VU
LYYLPJOLU
U[LYZ[…[aUN HI^pNLU¸ RYa UK SHUNMYPZ[PNLU WLYZ€USPJOLU )LYLPJOZ UK U[LYULO
TLUZaPLSLU ,Z PZ[ HJO a ILY…JRZPJO[PNLU KHZZ 4V[P]H[PVU LOLY
KYJO UPJO[ TVUL[pYL 0UZ[YTLU[L ^PYR[
7SHUUN UK )KNL[PLYUN ZPUK KLY 2LYU
KLZZLU ^HZ LPU :[LLYUNZRVUaLW[ ILPUOHS
É7SHUUN UK )KNL ‹ )LY…JRZPJO[PNLU KLY 2VU[L_[MHR[VYLU a ) )YHUJOL 6YNHUPZH[PVU 7SHUUN UK
[PLYUN PU KHZ NLZHT[L LY[ZJO€WMUN 4HYR[ZP[H[PVU ILP KLY .LZ[HS[UN KLY 7SHUUN [LU ZVSS 1L UHJO )YHUJOL R€UULU ^LP[LYL
-…OYUNZZ`Z[LT UK )KNL[PLYUN )KNL[PLYUN HSZ 2LYU
;OLTLU ILHJO[L[ VKLY ILZVUKLYZ HZNL
LPUIL[[LU¸ ‹ 2Ya UK TP[[LSMYPZ[PNL 7SHUUNLU Z[pYRLY Z[YH[LNPZJO HZYPJO[LU
0U[LNYH[PVU KLY 4HUHOTLUWSHUUN WYpN[ ZLPU
;HILSSL ! +PL (U[^VY[LU KLY 4VKLYULU )KNL[PLYUN .SLPJO L[ HS
+PL ,TWMLOSUNLU ZPUK RLPUL 7H[LU[YLaLW[L
6ULZPaLMP[ZHSS2VUaLW[L
VKLY (SSOLPSTP[[LS M…Y KLU ZPJOLYLU UK LPUMH
ZPUK UPJO[ T€NSPJO
JOLU LN aT ,YMVSN +PLZLU LYYLPJO[ THU
UY KYJO Z[L[PNL (UZ[YLUNUN ILZZLY a
^LYKLU 2VUaLW[L OLSMLU KHILP ¶ TNLZL[a[ UK NLSLI[ ^LYKLU T…ZZLU ZPL KYJO
KPL 4P[HYILP[LY KLZ U[LYULOTLUZ
4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN M…OY[ aY…JR aT 7SHUUNZRLYU lILY LPU PU[LNYPLY[LZ
2VUaLW[ ]LYRU…WM[ TP[ KLY :[YH[LNPL KLU APLSLU UK KLT 4HUHNLTLU[Z`Z[LT
ZVSS KHZ )KNL[ RVUZLXLU[ LPUMHJO UK ]VY HSSLU +PUNLU TMLSKMSL_PILS ILZ[PTT[
^LYKLU 4VKLYUL )KNL[PLYUN ILKL[L[ UPJO[ ULL ;VVSZ UK NHY 2VUaLW[L
a LYMPUKLU
+PL 7YPUaPWPLU ^LYKLU PU a^LP 2H[LNVYPLU TP[ PUZNLZHT[ ZLJOZ +PTLUZPVULU LPU
NL[LPS[!