Hays heeft onderzoek gedaan naar genderdiversiteit op de werkvloer in 31 landen wereldwijd. De onderzoeksvragen werden ingevuld door bijna 6.000 respondenten. In het onderzoeksrapport worden de belangrijkste globale en Nederlandse resultaten met u gedeeld.
2. 1 Hays Leading Women Hays Leading Women 1
GENDER DIVERSITY
THE ADVANCEMENT
OF WOMEN IN THE
WORKPLACE
Hays supports the advancement of women in the workplace.
Although progress is being made, this remains a business critical
issue. Many of the companies we speak to are suffering from
skill shortages and increasing the number of senior female
professionals will help to address these skills gaps.
By improving access to talent, organisations will be better
positioned to drive their performance, grow their businesses
and secure future success.
Our global gender diversity survey was completed by
almost 6,000 respondents across 31 countries. In this report
we highlight key global and local results and explore the
implications of these statistics. We have also included an
interview with Judith Peeters, Operations Director, Hays
Netherlands. Judith shares her experience of gender diversity
in the workplace and gives us insight into diversity within the
Dutch market.
3. 2 Hays Leading Women Hays Leading Women 3
44%
of respondents believe
flexible working practices
would have the biggest
impact on improving
gender diversity in
the workplace.
EXPLORING THE GENDER
DIVERSITY DIVIDE
61%
of respondents believe
that the same career
opportunities are available
regardless of gender.
CAREER
OPPORTUNITIES
Analysing male and female
responses shows that
almost one in two women
(48%) said the same career
opportunities were not open
to equally capable colleagues
of both genders.
Comparitively, 21% of men
said the same career
opportunities were not open
to equally capable colleagues
of both genders.
18%
of men think that equally
capable male and female
colleagues are not paid or
rewarded equally.
45%
of women think that
equally capable male and
female colleagues are not
paid or rewarded equally.
64%of respondents think that
there is equal pay between
genders, however these
results hide significant
differences in opinion
between gender and age.
EQUAL PAY
Analysing male and female
responses by age groups
shows an interesting trend
where younger people are
much less likely to think
there is discrimination in
the workplace.
Only 33% of females and
8% of males aged 25 or
under think there is gender
inequality of pay. 46% of
females and 17% of males
aged 55+ think there is
gender inequality of pay.
49%
of respondents said their
organisation did not have
a gender diversity policy
in place.
GENDER
DIVERSITY
POLICIES
50% of respondents working
in the Public/Not-for-profit
sector said their companies
had a gender diversity policy
in place, followed by Mining
& Resources at 37% and
Financial Services at 36%.
Advertising & Media
companies were least likely
to have a gender diversity
policy in place (17%), followed
by Construction, Property
& Engineering (25%) and
Manufacturing at 27%.
36%
of respondents who said
their organisation had a
formal gender diversity
policy in place said that it
was adhered to well.
31%
of respondents said their
organisation had a gender
diversity policy in place.
4. 4 Hays Leading Women Hays Leading Women 5
Do you think you and your equally capable colleagues are paid/rewarded in an equal manner
regardless of gender?
When looking at equal pay across all industries surveyed there is a similar trend: respondents believe there is equal pay
between genders across all industries.
GLOBAL RESULTS SHOW EQUAL PAY
ACROSS ALL INDUSTRIES
Advertising & Media
Construction, Property & Engineering
Financial Services
Hospitality, Travel & Entertainment
IT & Telecoms
Manufacturing
Mining & Resources
Professional Services
Public/Not-for-profit sector
Retail
Transport & Distribution
Overall, respondents tended to think that allowing more flexible working practices (44%) and changes in workplace culture
(44%) would have the biggest impact on gender diversity. In contrast, only 9% believed that introducing quotas would have
the biggest impact.
Which of these changes do you think would have the biggest impact on diversity in your world of work?
44%
44%
32%
28%
32%
27%
26%
21%
9%
Allowing more flexible working practices
Changes in workplace culture through
education across the business
Highlighting female role models
Changes to your organisation’s policy
Changes to recruitment practices
and policies
Changes to government policy
Better board backing for diversity issues
Positive discrimination for women
applying to management roles or above
Introducing quotas
Yes No
62%
60%
58%
64%
59%
62%
66%
69%
68%
66%
63%
38%
40%
42%
36%
41%
38%
34%
31%
32%
34%
37%
5. 6 Hays Leading Women Hays Leading Women 7
41%
41%
18%
71%
Yes
24%
25%
51%
75%
70%
68%
73%
25%
30%
32%
27%
GENDER DIVERSITY
IN THE DUTCH MARKET
How well are these adhered to do you think?
GENDER DIVERSITY POLICIES
Does your organisation have formal gender
diversity policies and practices in place?
Do you think you and your equally capable colleagues are paid/rewarded in an equal manner
regardless of gender?
EQUAL PAY
70% Yes
30% No
CAREER OPPORTUNITIES
Do you think the same career opportunities are open to equally capable colleagues
regardless of gender?
29%
No
58% Yes
42% No
84% Yes
16% No
Do you think the same career opportunities are open to equally capable colleagues regardless
of gender?
Do you think you and your equally capable colleagues are paid/rewarded in an equal manner
regardless of gender?
Do you think you and your equally capable colleagues are paid/rewarded in an equal manner
regardless of gender?
58% Yes
42% No
81% Yes
19% No
182 Dutch respondents completed the global gender diversity survey.
25 years and under
26-40 years
41-54 years
55+ years
Yes
Not sure
No
Well
Fairly well
Not well at all
Yes No
6. 8 Hays Leading Women Hays Leading Women 9
What was your route to Hays?
I studied neuropsychology at
university and initially planned to have
a clinical career using my degree.
I soon realised this wasn’t what I
wanted to do and started working at
Roozen & Van Hoof, the recruitment
company in the Netherlands that
was acquired by Hays. I worked here
for two years and then moved to an
international B2B sales role, where I
sold products to Proctor and Gamble.
My next career move was to Sara
Lee, I worked as a National Account
Manager for the retail industry. After
four years I moved to Coca Cola as
a Sales Manager, this was my first
leadership role. I then began working
for Hays in 2007, within the Sales and
Marketing sector. After four years my
role changed to Regional Director and
I was responsible for recruitment in the
South of the Netherlands. For the last
year and a half, as Operations Director,
I have been responsible for the
recruitment of all of the Netherlands.
Tell us about your progression
into a leadership role, what
challenges did you face along
the way?
My first management position was
with Coca Cola. I was younger than
the people reporting into me, who had
been working in sales for a long time.
Being younger and female (in a male
dominated sales environment) was a
challenge. At the time I was trying to
find my style as a manager. I found
that for me it is best to be genuine,
to combine honesty with empathy.
My advice would be to find a
managerial style that suits you, rather
than trying to replicate another style
of manager you have seen or had.
Another challenge I faced, again
relating to managerial style, was the
balance of being ‘one of the boys’
but also distancing myself from my
team so I was still viewed as the
decision maker. This was and is more
about personality rather than men vs.
women. I have never viewed being
a woman as a negative. The initial
challenge I faced in my career was
about adapting to a managerial level
role but I believe that we never stop
facing challenges because we never
stop learning. You should remain open
to change and keen to adapt, this will
allow you to continue to progress.
In your opinion is there a
difference between how men and
women progress in their careers?
Yes I think there is a difference
between how men and women
progress in their careers, the
difference in my opinion is because of
circumstances and image. I think part
of it is because of the image women
have of themselves, an image of
family life, responsibilities and abilities
– which links to confidence. I don’t
lack confidence. I believe I can do
everything which is important when in
a leadership role.
It also comes down to the fact that
women are expected to stay at home
and take care of the children, more
so than men. If a woman comes back
part time and works three days a
week then she takes a step back in
her career, which has an impact on her
career path. It is important for couples
to make a career plan for each other.
If a plan is in place it may be that the
man stays at home and it is agreed
that the woman goes back to work full
time to pursue her career and grow
professionally. I believe women lack
a career plan, or that it is not talked
about enough.
Have you encountered any gender
specific obstacles in your career?
I believe that there is a difference
between how men and women work
but I don’t believe these differences
are obstacles. I think obstacles exist
if you allow them to. Whether you are
male or female it is important to make
sure you are heard. If you feel less
important or if you feel your opinion is
less important this will be an obstacle.
If you ensure your opinion is heard you
will have an impact on the business
you are working in and will be able
to progress.
Do you have any advice for
female professionals who are in,
or looking to work in,
a leadership role?
Make a plan for your career, think
about where you want to go and
where you want to be. Be authentic in
your management style and believe in
your management value.
In the Netherlands, 51% of
respondents said that their
organisation did not have formal
gender policies in place and
25% weren’t sure. What do you
think are the implications of
these statistics?
These statistics lead me to believe
gender diversity policies do not exist
in businesses. Or if they are they are
not being spoken about, which makes
me think they are not working.
Access policy is important, it is vital
that companies have a diverse range
of professionals within the company at
a junior level. What you see, especially
in Holland, is that there is diversity in
top levels but less in junior roles, which
will cause problems in the future.
The implication of these statistics is
that it is important to have diversity
within all levels of companies.
However, out of the respondents
who said their organisation had
formal gender policies in place,
83% feel they are adhered to
well/fairly well. This implies that
gender policies are valued in
companies that have them. Is this
something you agree with?
These statistics show that if companies
have gender diversity policies in place
they work and work well. This makes it
even more important to ensure gender
policies are adopted and implemented
by organisations.
Globally, 48% of women do not
think they have the same career
opportunities as men. In the
Netherlands only 42% of females
do not think they have the same
career opportunities as men.
What do you think about this?
Cultural differences are an important
factor in how career opportunities
are perceived by men and women.
I think that in Holland we are quite
forward thinking about a lot of
things, so I am not surprised that we
are a bit further along and that more
women in Holland feel they have equal
career opportunities compared to
women globally.
Demographically we are an ageing
population and an ageing workforce.
There are more opportunities for
women to step in and pursue their
career after having a family because
they still have a relatively long career
path ahead of them. I think that this is
where demography has an impact on
the market.
58% of female Dutch respondents
believe there is equal pay
between genders, compared to
81% of male Dutch respondents.
Is this an expected trend?
These statistics are realistic. I’ve read
that 3 out of 10 women in Holland earn
less than men in comparable positions.
This is something that men are less
aware of, which is logical.
I believe in taking ownership of things,
just like a man you have to be able to
ask what is right for you. A man will
think ‘I am valuable’. A woman may
think in terms of consequences and
empathy, so if the company she works
for isn’t doing very well she may think
‘why should I ask for more money’.
Dutch respondents under the age
of 25 are less likely to think there
is unequal pay between genders.
Is this a trend you agree with?
In Holland, when you begin your
career as a young person, you see that
there is much more equality between
men and women. We see an increase
in women obtaining a technical
education and the implication here
is that women are becoming better
educated. This will have an impact on
their career path and opportunities.
This feeling of equality between the
sexes also relates back to our ageing
workforce. For older generations there
is a perceived ‘bigger gap’ between
men and women but this is not the
case now as our culture continues
to change and is influenced by new
generations.
Globally respondents (both male
and female) believe that allowing
more flexible working practices
and changes in workplace culture
through education across the
business, will have the biggest
impact on diversity in the
workplace. What do you think
about this?
I think flexible working is dependent
on the mind-set of a country.
‘It doesn’t matter where/when you are
at work as long as you do your job’,
this mentality is prevalent in Holland
and still progressing. So yes I agree
that flexible working hours will have
a positive impact on the diversity of
a workforce.
Access policy is also important for
diversity, it is vital for companies to
have a diverse workforce across all
levels. Career planning is significant
for women as well as challenging the
belief that you have to be at home to
be a good mother. Thinking about your
career path and trying not to create
a glass ceiling for yourself will help
you progress.
In this interview, Judith Peeters, Operations Director, Hays
Netherlands, based in Amsterdam, shares her experience
of gender diversity in the workplace, her progression into
a leadership role and the Dutch survey results.
INTERVIEW WITH A LEADING WOMAN