Information technology, Transformational change - Stories from the road. Presented by Robyn Cook, IT Project Manager, University of New South Wales, Australia, at HINZ 2014, 12 November 2014, 1.45pm, Marlborough Room
3. Sidra Medical and Research Center
Personally Accessible Record for Life - PEARL
Complete electronic medical record with device integration
300 unique devices
4000 devices to be installed
Cerner Full Solution Set, plus additional solutions specific areas e.g.
patient education, dietary, patient entertainment
Philips – PACS and VNA and Cardiology Solution
P
6. Patient Portal
Benefits Lessons Learnt
Communication – less telephone
“tag”
Overall approach to patient engagement
Access information:
• Care compliance
• Patient engagement
• Increase health literacy
USA versus Local Drivers
• Consumer loyalty
• Continuity of care – especially
complex care
Effectiveness and Efficiency
• Focused appointments
• Streamline follow up and
medication refill processes
Multilingual user interface and cultural
considerations
User Education and Support
Future monitoring health status Computer, Information & Health Literacy
8. Full Electronic Medication Management
P
Medication
Reconciliation
Patient
e- prescribing
with decision
support
Medication
Verification
Administration
and Recording
Dispensing
Patient Safety
9. Medication Reconciliation and E- Prescribing
Medication Reconciliation
• Order to complete reconciliation – reminder and tracking
• Standardised form and process – standard procedure
• Subsequent encounter – streamline and accuracy
Medication Orders
• Legibility, standard orders sentences
• Decision Support
• Duplicate Checking
• Allergy and Drug- Drug Interactions
10. Medication Reconciliation and E-Prescribing
Benefits Lessons Learnt
Legibility of medication order
Integration with MAR
Clinical documentation
dependency for best practice
Compliance medication
reconciliation policies
Agreement and compliance to
medication reconciliation
Orders only from formulary Formulary and drug availability,
standardised order sentences
Decision Support –
• Errors of omission
• Duplication
• Allergies
• Dosing support
• Alerts
Alert fatigue –priority safety
alerts
11. Medication Verification and Dispensing
Robotics and unit dose preparation
Medication
verification
Automated
Dispensing
Units
12. Medication Verification and Dispensing
Benefits Lessons Learnt
Verify correct drug for patient IV Medications
Unit dose
Decrease waste and specific to
patient
12
Liquids with Paediatrics
Reduced errors dispensing Maintenance / sychronisation drug
libraries and formulary
Improved inventory control Multilingual patient medication labels
Consistent administration
instructions & compliance Integration effort
Increased compliance home
medications
13. Electronic Medication Administration
Electronic Medication Administration Record
• Integrated with electronic prescribing, pharmacy verification and review
• Standardised Administration Instructions
Bar Coded Medication Administration
• 5 rights administration
Infusion Smart Pump Integration
• IV Order to Pump
• Infusion Data to EMR
14. Electronic Medication Administration
Plus Barcoded Medication Administration and Smart Infusion Pump
Benefits Lessons Learnt
Medication Administration 5
rights checking support
• Right Patient
• Right Drug
• Right Dose
• Right Route
• Right Time
P
Paediatric Dosing – Weight
based dose
Legibility of Medication Record Clinical Documentation
Integration
Reduced errors infusion dosing Integration Effort and Testing
significant
Standardised administration
instructions
16. Decision Support
Evidence Based Practice
Provation Order Sets
Provation Care Plans
• Evidence Content base – UptoDate and Lippincott
• Authoring, collaborative review and management tools
• Integration with Electronic Medical Record
17. Decision Support
Benefits Lessons Learnt
Consistent evidence based
practice
P 17
Commitment to evidence based
practice
Collaboration and agreement
across multidisciplinary team
Alignment service department
offerings (e.g. lab tests) with
evidence base
Customise to local
requirements
Full orders management
catalogue including formulary
Streamlined Governance
• On Line authoring
• Approvals
• Management review cycles
Resources for updates and
integration with EMR
Evidence Based Practice
18. Decision Support
Hand Over Summary
Views of clinical information based on role
Supports medical handover and nursing SBAR
19. Decision Support
Early Warning Systems
Modified Early Obstetric Warning System (MEOWS)
Paediatric Early Warning System (PEWS)
Early Warning System (EWS)
Australia “ Between the Flags”
Full clinical documentation
Algorithm
Alerts / Actions lists and routing of calls
20. Decision Support
Handover, SBAR, Early Warning Systems
Benefits Lessons Learnt
Consistent and standard
approach to handover
P
Standardisation versus
customisation
Improved communication Well accepted solution for all
clinical groups
Alerts and guidance for early
intervention
Aligned with international
evidence for practice
Reduced duplication of data
capture
22. Technologies
Mobile access
Notification critical results
Rapid login – fully integrated
Auto log off
Range of device for access to electronic medical record
Fully redundant, mirrored databases
05/05/2014 22
24. Translational Research Environment, the power of
information systems
Clinical Systems
Electronic Medical
Record, and Clinican
P
Tools
Data Warehouse
Clinical Improvement
Clinical Registries
Identified Data
Research
Information
Exchange
De identified Data
Cohort Search and
Selection
Clinical
Portal
Patient Portal Researcher
Portal
Surveys
etc
Biobank
Omics
Data Governance
Internal,
National,
International
Collaboration
26. Transformation with Information Technology
Understand clinical, research and operational practices and processes
Integrate information system into practice, leverage benefits
Monitor adoption with data feedback and continuous improvement
Health Information Technology (HIT) Safety Framework – Dean Sittig
and Joan Ash
Increased health informatics research to demonstrate effectiveness
P
27. People make the
transformation happen
Working together to
close the gap from
bench to practice
Thank you for the opportunity to speak at the conference today. Todays presentation is about the journey of the last 6 years where I was fortunate to be part of developing a truly greenfield fully digital hospital in the middle east and more recently a new journey into the cancer translational research environment.
Cover key aspects of information technology and how it can support transformational change and highlight lessons learnt on the journey, with a focus on patient engagement, patient safety with medication management, decision support and the translational research environment
Sidra Medical and Research Center – this you tube clip will give you an insight into the state of the art, academic medical center in Doha, Qatar – it may be a small country on a pensinsula in the Arabian Gulf, and has an ambitious vision to create one of leading academic medical centers in the world and has the financial capacity to do so with a $7.8Billion endowment.
Leading architectural design, steel, glass and ceramics, 3 atriums, representing the dow boats, creates healing gardens, effective use of natural light, visible from all patient rooms and extensive use of beautiful Italian marble in the lobby areas
Wireless, filmless and virtually paperless, it is all digital facility with all IT applications for clinical care, research and hospital operations. Integrated with robotics, computer aided surgery and diagnostics and advanced digital imaging. Wayfinding and real time location services are also included in the facility – RTLS – provides the ability to locate patients, equipment and staff at anytime, all equipped with an RTLS sensor.
The inpatient care areas were designed with technology in mind , with a large flat screen IP TV available on the wall opposite the end of the patient bed, iPad connectivity and wall mounted all in one devices for use by clinical staff in addition to mobile devices.
Clinical Focus is women and childrens services. One of the challenges in implementing the fully digital environment was the greenfield nature of the hospital, no current hospital moving to the site, no operational clinicians, no policies, procedures or processes.
Unfortunately even though construction commenced at beginning 2009 the building is still not complete and ready for occupation, so the stories I tell are about what was done to prepare for this fully digital environment but not from an operational perspective – at this stage it is anticipated that the hospital will open in 2016……..
To be able to support clinical transformation a Department of Health Informatics, with 65 staff, is being established along with a separate clinical IT group within the IT department
It was still a dream opportunity for a clinical informatician and an exotic location………….
The patient is at the center of care at Sidra and one of the key aspects of the clinical system is the patient portal. Creates a secure and private on line environment for the patient and family to engage with the health care providers. It includes secure messaging between the patient/ family and the health care providers, on line requests for appointments and confirmations. The ability to review results and summaries of hospital visits, request medication refills, provide access to or push patient education materials, complete on line patient surveys and reminders e.g. immunisations.
Benefits include streamlined communication between health care provider and patient / family. Provides the patient with access to health care information that can increase compliance with care activities, engages the patient in self care and increases their health literacy. It also supports streamlined patient care processes for appointment and medication refills. In the future it will have the opportunity for patients to enter health data for monitoring e.g. blood sugar levels for the diabetic that can be reviewed by the health care providers and discussed with the patient on the next visit.
Lessons learnt
What is the overall approach to patient engagement in the organisation, strategic vision and objectives, the patient portal is a tool to support patient engagement and needs to support the organisations vision and meet the health information needs of the patient population.
Many of the patient portal solutions are based on the US model of health care – with a focus on gaining customer loyalty and encourage the patient to stay with the organisation. In other health care environments, especially public health systems such as the UK , Australia, New Zealand and Qatar – the focus is on supporting continuity of care, especially chronic and complex care such as diabetes, or obesity ( which is highly prevalent in the middle east) means you need to consider how you manage to bring together patient information from different organisations involved in patient care – this was not addressed at Sidra and yet the country is small , the largest public hospital was a short distance away, no connection with primary health care and all were implementing a Cerner solution.
As this is an arabic country, it was important to provide the portal in arabic and in a form that was suitable for an islamic environment. The development and implementation requires extensive community consultation to address the needs of the local qatari community and a mixed arabic and western expat population group. E.g. adolescent access western versus the male dominance in islam.
The use of mobile technology in the community is significant, ( many owning 2-3 mobile phones) especially with young people and families, therefore the challenges with accessing the internet were limited. The greatest challenges will be the information and health literacy of the community especially the local community, where bedouin folklore still has a strong influence on behaviour and beliefs.
In the arena of patient safety I have chosen one area to focus on medication management
Full Electronic Medication Management system – often in our health systems we do not have the opportunity to fully automate the clinical processes, thus leaving gaps in the processes, which can exacerbate patient safety risks, due to the automation of current practices – for Sidra it was fortunate that technology and information systems were applied for each process within the medical management system - from medication reconcilation, to e-prescribing, medication verification and dispensing to the administration and recording
It was when I observed the full automation of the medication management system that I could see the level of transformation that it could bring to clinical practice. Additional benefits from a clinical informatics perspective is the ability to collect data for “near misses” in medication orders and administration to identify opportunities for system improvements
The solution included
An order to complete the medication reconciliation was part of the standard admission / visit order set, transfer of care and as part of the discharge planning processes– this acts as reminder to complete the reconcilation and tracks if it has been completed – outstanding task if not done
Medication Reconcilation – completed using standard forms and therefore processes. Once patient medications are in the system it is streamlined and easier to complete the reconciliation and is a good check to remind the ordering physician to review and recommence home medications in preparation for discharge
Electronic medication orders – for all medications including IV therapy was included and the provision of decision support with alerts – duplicate checking, allergy and drug/ drug interactions – principle in initial design was to focus on the high risk interactions and gradually increase alerts – monitoring for alert fatigue
Benefits
Legibility
Order sets – compliance medication reconciliation, admission, care transfer and discharge
Limited to ordering from formulary – important in middle east – access to high quality medications can be difficult and significant controls on opiate based pain relief
Decision support
Dosing support for paediatrics – once the weight based dosing protocols defined it is easier to manage in an electronic system
Lesson Learnt
Medications are not ordered or administered without the context of patient information e,g vital signs, other clinical assessments – demonstrated the importance of having full clinical documentation in place in conjunction with electronic medication management systems
Drive standards based practice such as medication reconciliation with information systems – through orders, tracking completion, standard documentation and processes
Considerable effort to establish formulary for new hospital, where supply can be inconsistent, and agreement to use a standard medication coding system – Rx Norm was chosen as it covers all aspects of medication information.
Decision Support – need to have a balance with alerts for patient safety versus alert fatigue – reduces effectiveness of alerts and increases patient safety risks
Pharmacy automation
Clinical Pharmacists to verify all medication orders before dispensing unless in emergency circumstances
Use of robotics in both inpatient and outpatient pharmacy dispensing – with inpatient unit dose preparation – fully labelled and barcoded.
Outpatient dispensing included arabic and english patient instructions
All patient drugs including infusion were distributed to clinical units in automated dispensing units – integrate with order so that administration on the clinical unit – access the ADU with authentication
- monitor use and cost directly to the patient
Clinical Pharmacist increased involvement in patient care and confirming correct drug order for patients
Unit dose – specific to patient – less waste
Robotics improves inventory control
Agreed administration instructions are available with all medications – consistency of information and potential increase compliance for correct administration
Home medications – detailed legible instructions – increased compliance – including arabic speakers
Lessons learnt
Paediatric medications are liquid and therefore less opportunity unit dosing
Dug libraries and formularies sychonisation – robots, infusion pumps, Automated dispensing units and the electronic medical record systems
Patient labels in arabic – challenge as the characters and format – not just a direct language translation
Significant integration effort between EMR, robots, and ADU’s – need to plan sufficient time for interface specifications, development and testing – project impacts – also consideration during procurement of equipment
Scope in meds administration included bar coded medication administration and infusion pump integration – orders and infusion details
Benefits – cannot under estimate the benefits to administration of bar coded meds administration – support for the nurse along with the legibility of the medication order
IV infusion integration –less errors in infusion dosing – nurse still confirms the order
Standardise administration instructions are available at the point of care
Lesson learnt
Alogorithms with weight based paediatric dosing – especially for neonates as cannot round doses
Requirement for clinical documentation to support administration and assessing patient response to medications
Integration effort is significant – test test test test test……….
As the organisation was new, so there was the opportunity to embed evidence based practice from the beginning. Provation was chosen as the source of evidence based content for order sets, orders for specific conditions according to the phase of care for the patient and care plans from a nursing perspective.
Content source for the evidence – UpToDate (one of the most common and well used knowledge resource for physicians) and Lippincott for the nursing care plans
The Provation solution provides both the content and the tools for authoring, collaborative review and management – prior to review by clinicians – align the orders with the organisational order catalogue and formulary.
Establish team for the review which can be done on line and agreement to the final order set. The tools also support set timeframes for review and approval status for each order set
Once approved the order set or care plan is then uploaded into the electronic medical record/
Benefits
Consistent evidence based order sets or care plans, with specific customisation to the local requirements– monitor compliance and patient outcomes
Tools support collaboration on line across the multidisciplinary team
Tools support effective governance
Lessons learnt – whilst everyone is claimig evidence based practice – there is still reluctance to adopt external evidence base – despite all references being available within the order set / care plan
Lessons learnt
Set up for review is extensive initially – order catalogue from each service department – cross check with each order set before the initial review to ensure the orders / formulary are available or mapped to the local order
For evidence based updates and the upload into the electronic medical record does require dedicated resources to complete reviews and management of the integration
One of the advantages of the electronic medical record is the ability to provide information in formats that meet different clincal group needs and practices
Hand over summary – structured approach to providing key information for handover of care – less opportunity to miss key information -, flags abnormal results and the reviews of resulst
e.g. physician hand off and nursing SBAR – situation, background, assessment, recommendation
With all aspects of electronic clinical documentation available – able to construct new decision support tools
Able to design and implement international standard early warning systems for different clinical settings
Construct the algorithm to autocalculate score and then use alerts and actions to support clinical staff actions and can also automate the routing of calls for the response team – still expect the clinical staff to make the judgement
Standardised handover and improved communication – structured, no reliant on memory
Use alerts to guide clinical practice and early intervention
Does not require duplication of data capture
Minimal adoption issues as tools are designed to meet clinical needs and based on international practices
Important to provide effective technologies to access the electronic medical record
Also logon and log off – using integrate solutions – tap and go
Device needs to meet the clnical staff needs and operational environment
Just to finish off I will describe the value of information to support translational research environment – this has focus on cancer services and improve patient care.
Clinical Systems capturing data for patient care – provide data into a data warehouse to support clinical improvement activities, clinical registries with identified data
The data can then through a de identification process be transferred to research information exchange – cohort search and selectrion
Data can be delivered to different roles including clinicians, patient and researchers
Support for internal, national and international collaboration
For cancer services - supports specific research databases – omics data, biobank and qualitative data ( surveys etc)
Challenges are around effective data governance, including privacy and security as sharing data across organisations
Overall lessons learnt to transform health
Need to understand the operational and clinical processes – opportunities to radically change the process with the integration of technology – change the overall processes and practices
Technology and systems have to be integrated into the clinical, research and operational processes
Supports increased adoption, need to measure the effectiveness of the transformation and continuous improvement
Need to increase the application of HIT safety framework to reduce the impact of unintended consequences of information technology – the work or Dean Sittig and Joan Ash is important in this arena
And finally transformation will only occur when people are engaged in and leading the change – people are key to transformation in health care