2. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office2
AgendaAgenda
• Allstate Insurance at a Glance
• Allstate Journey to IT Service Management
- Moving from concept and implementation to results
• Continual Service Improvement with Process
Assessments
• IT Service Management - Get back to the future
3. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office3
• The nation's largest publicly held personal lines
insurer
• A Fortune 100 company, selling 13 major lines of
insurance, including auto, property, life and
commercial
• Corporate headquarters in Northbrook, Illinois
• 2007 revenues more than $36 billion
• Insures 17 million households in the U.S. and
Canada
• Encompasses more than 70,000 professionals with
operations in 49 states and Canada
• Technology operations located around the globe
Allstate Insurance at a Glance
4. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office4
Allstate Insurance at a GlanceAllstate Insurance at a Glance
Allstate’s Technology Environment
• High-Speed Networking
• Integration Architecture
• J2EE and .Net
• Large Scale Networks
• Message Brokering
• Performance Management
• Rich Media Management
• Service Oriented Architecture
• Unix, Windows and Mainframe platforms
• Web Content Management
• Web Services
• Advanced Analytics
• Business Process Management
• Capacity Planning
• Data Warehousing
• Document Imaging
• Enterprise Content Management
• Enterprise Databases
• Enterprise Information Integration
• ETL (Extract, Transform, Load) Tools
• Financial Applications
• High-Availability and Disaster Recovery
• Multiple operating systems
• Multiple technology platforms
• Multiple database systems
• 6,000+ IT professionals
• 5,000+ software applications
• 100,000+ desktop computers supported
Applications and Services
5. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office5
AgendaAgenda
• Allstate Insurance at a Glance
• Allstate Journey to IT Service
Management - Moving from concept
and implementation to results
• Continual Service Improvement with Process
Assessments
• IT Service Management- Get back to the future
6. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office6
Allstate Journey to IT Service Management –
Moving from concept & implementation to
results
First Generation
(1939-1954) –
vacuum tube
Second Generation
Computers
(1954 -1959) - transistor
Third Generation
Computers
(1959 -1971)
Fourth Generation
(1971-1991) –
microprocessor
Fifth Generation
(1991 and Beyond)
7. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office7
Results
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2004 - Process Improvement –
2005: - Changed alignment to ITIL
- Standardized Priority Schema
- Reduced MTTR P1 Incidents
- Improved classification
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2006 - Enterprise enrollment of
2007: Change Management
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2008: Adoption and Maturity
Assessments –
reset our goals
refresh baseline
Opportunities
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2004 - Speed
2005: Cost efficiency
Ease of navigation
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2006 - Reduce
2007: - Processes
- Silos
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2008: Where are we?
Allstate Journey to IT Service Management –
Moving from concept & implementation to
results
8. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office8
Allstate Journey to IT Service Management –
Moving from concept & implementation to
results
What is our Vision and Strategy?
To Support common process across the Enterprise-
Allstate Technology and Operations; Investments; and Allstate Financial
Technology by Enterprise wide adoption of ITIL framework
• Common roles and responsibilities
across the Enterprise
• Common process language and
repeatable procedures - reduce the
learning curve from one area to another
• Increased visibility into change activities
• The ability to reduce change collision
Benefits for the organization:
• Recording of authorized changes to aid
resolution that improves Incident
activities
• Faster mean time to repair
• Support metrics that allows for
continued improvement
• Compliance with regulatory
requirements
• Common repository for approved
changes and reporting
11. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office11
October 5, 200818
Plan for education/training and communication Example
• Framework education
• Logistics
• Availability of students and instructors
• Measures of success
• Train the trainer
Framework & Role-Based Training:
Implementing an Enterprise Change
Management Process
Define your
tasks, effort,
duration, start
time
2007 ITIL
V3?
Allstate Journey to IT Service Management –
Moving from concept & implementation to
results
Governance
Continuous Improvement
Governance
Continuous Improvement
2007
Building the Bridge
• Business Service Management
office focused on Service Catalog
• One enterprise process for Change
Management
• Strong Project Management
• Strong Partnership with Claims
• Communications & Marketing
• Education & Training - ITIL V3
Increased visibility
across
the bridge!
Added dialog between
the groups
12. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office12
2008
Pulling it all together
• Acknowledging complementary
frameworks
• New ITSM Tool implemented
• Catalog acceleration
• Enterprise-wide goal adopt ITIL
• Centralizing ITSM governance
• Strong partnership with Enterprise
Application area
• Communications & Marketing
• Education & Training - ITIL V3
Allstate Journey to IT Service Management –
Moving from concept & implementation to
results
13. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office13
2008 - BSM
How can we leverage our Enterprise goal #4 to increase
availability with ITIL adoption?
How do we role out ITSM tool with 5000+ users active?
Are all problems created equal?
2004 - SMCOE
How do we build the Process behind the Process?
Red to green – can we improve Incident Classification?
How do we define Education & Training program in IT?
2005 - ITSM @
Allstate
How do we build the process with governance built in?
What does standard documentation look like?
How do we create process policies?
2006 - ITSM @
Allstate/Availability
Mgmt
How does a process become defined and documented
What does Business Service Management (BSM)
organization look like?
Can we move faster in a decentralized mode?
2007 - Availability
Management
How do we conduct an enterprise role out of change?
How do we introduce a Service Catalog?
What is the right ITSM tool with our complexity?
ITIL – Key Questions on the Journey
Allstate Journey to IT Service Management –
Moving from concept & implementation to
results
14. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office14
AgendaAgenda
• Allstate Insurance at a Glance
• Allstate Journey to IT Service Management
- Moving from concept and implementation to results
• Continual Service Improvement with
Process Assessments
• IT Service Management- Get back to the future
15. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office15
Continual Service Improvement with Process
Assessments
How does ITIL V3 fit in?
16. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office16
Goal:
• Continual Service Improvement (CSI) will move beyond talking to
action. CSI will address ways that overall process and service
provision can be improved.
Activities:
• Business case Return On Investment (ROI)
• Identify the overall health of IT Service Management
• Portfolio alignment in real-time with business needs
• Growth and maturity of the service management practice
• How to measure, interpret and execute results
Continual Service Improvement with Process
Assessments
17. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office17
ITIL’s 7-step Improvement process @ Allstate
Continual Service Improvement with Process
Assessments
18. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office18
Forrester - Inquiry Spotlight, ITIL Q4 2008
Evidence of increasing maturity of ITIL initiatives
Continual Service Improvement with Process
Assessments
19. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office19
2008 Adoption assessments
Objective: Understand the
adoption and adherence in different
functional organizations
1. Define what you should
measure
• 2008 success of adoption
• Catalog acceleration
• Project performance
• Operational measures
2. Define what you can measure
• Tangible evidence
• Focused on education
• Established roles
• number of Services on
boarded
Continual Service Improvement with Process
Assessments
20. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office20
3. Gather data, who, how, when
• By functional organization
• By the Assessment team
• Catalog tool
• Project Manager
4. Process data with frequency,
format, & system accuracy
• Success of Adoption
• Adoption Rating
• Project results
5. Analyze the data, trends, plans
• Observations
• Recommendations
Continual Service Improvement with Process
Assessments
21. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office21
Adoption assessment Reporting
6. Present and use information,
assessment summary, and action
plans
• Adapt the results to the
business
• All areas are not the same
• Areas covered:
Infrastructure, Application
Support, Application
Development
• Different Business Lines-
Financial; Investments;
Products; Claims
• Defined a report
7. Implement corrective action
Continual Service Improvement with Process
Assessments
22. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office22
Lessons Learned:
• Allow time for logistics & reporting
• Good note taking a must
• Be prepared for change
• All areas are not the same
Next Steps:
• Use the Information for 2009
planning & implementation
• Formalize CSI Manager role
• Confirm pain points
• Gap closure
Analyzing Data
Gathering Data
Processing Data
Gathering the
Data
Processing the
Data
Analyzing the
Data
Presenting
and using the
Information
From Figure 6.1 CSI – Activities
and skill levels needed for CSI
Continual Service Improvement with Process
Assessments
23. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office23
AgendaAgenda
• Allstate Insurance at a Glance
• Allstate Journey to IT Service Management
- Moving from concept, and implementation to results
• Continual Service Improvement with Process
Assessments
• IT Service Management- Get back to
the future
24. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office24
What:
• From grass roots to executive
sponsorship
• From program and operational
efforts, back to a program
governance approach
• Focus on the six core documents
• Establish standard roles
How:
• 7 step continual improvement
brought to life
• Applied to the program
• Applies to the process
• Centralize common functions within
an organization
• Creation of Continuous Process
Improvement Teams (CPIT)
• Establishing enterprise roles
• Utilize compliance avenues
IT Service Management-
Get back to the future
25. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office25
Service Strategy Roles
IT Service Management
Enterprise Service Lifecycle Stages
and Corresponding Roles
Service Operation Roles
Service Design Roles
Service Transition Roles
Continual Service Improvement
Process Owner
Process Lead
Process Analyst
IT Planner
IT Designer Architect
Service Design Manager/Architects
Service Catalog Manager
Service Level Manager
OLA Coordinator (s)
Availability Manager
Service Continuity Manager
Capacity Manager
Security Manager
Supplier Manager
Process Owner
Process Lead
Process Analyst
Service Managers
Financial Mgmt Mgr
Process Owner
Process Lead
Process Analyst
Service Desk Analyst
Service Desk Manager
Service Desk Supervisor
Incident Manager
Incident Coordinator (s)
Problem Manager
Problem Coordinator (s)
Process Owner
Process Lead
Process Analyst
Service Asset & Configuration
Manager
Change Manager
Change Coordinator (s)
CAB Members
Release Deployment Manager
Release Package Build Manager
Process Owner
Process Lead
CSI Manager
Service Owners
Reporting Analysts
IT Service Management-
Get back to the future
26. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office26
Business Rules
• Process Flows / Mapping
• Identify control points
• Roles & Responsibilities
• Policies – Scope, Authority
• Operational Procedures
• Education & Training
• Communications & Marketing
Corrective Action
• Communications
• Roles & Responsibilities
• Education &Training
• Policies & Procedures
• Performance Management
• Process Design
Governance Types
Strategy
Investment
Project
Process
Technology
Operations
Human Resources
Suppliers
Governance
Documents
Documents
& Records
ContinualImprovement
Various frameworks lead to governance. Governance is
the policies, procedures and regulations under which IT
operates. It is the mechanisms, put in place to ensure
adherence and compliance with those policies and regulations.
Operational Execution
PLANPLAN
DODO
Adherence & Compliance
• Metrics, Reporting
• Technology (Tools, Automation, Data)
• Self Assessment
• Independent Assessment Records
CHECKCHECK
ACTACT
PLAN
ACT
Check
DO
IT Service Management-
Get back to the future
27. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office27
• Going forward
• Functional areas on
boarded with vision and
target adoption rates
• Defined gap closure
• Enterprise audits
• Role based training
• Ongoing assessments
• Ensure we have tied our
work to the business
IT Service Management-
Get back to the future
28. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office28
IT Service Management-
Get back to the future
Too many people and too many organizations are looking for the big-bang approach to improvements. It is
important to understand that a succession or series of small, planned increments of improvements will not
stress the infrastructure as much and will eventually amount to a large amount of improvement over time.
CSI pg 113.
29. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office29
Measures
PLAN
ACT
Check
DO
Governance
PLAN
ACT
Check
DO
Continual Improvement
IT Service Management-
Get back to the future
Hold your position with the wedge
PLAN - Planning for improvement
initiatives- project plan
DO - Implementation of improvement
initiative- project
CHECK - Monitor, measure and
review services and service
management processes- audit
ACT - Continual service and service
management process improvement -
decisions made: status quo, close
the gap or add necessary resources
to support another round of Plan Do
Check Act for continual service
improvement
30. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office30
IT Service Management-
Get back to the future
• Govern continual process
improvement
• Advance training and
education for all levels
including new employees
• Adapt your goals and
deliverables to the business
needs
• Only one enterprise process
• Identify the different business
lines - financial, investments,
products, claims and advance
their adoption
Things to know:
• Adopting ITIL Version 3 and
widened adoption most likely
will impact maturity score
• Expect leap frogging between-
CobiT, ISO 20K and ITIL
• Clear roles are a requirement
within the Service
Management program
• Know the health of the
program through regular
assessments
• Incremental approach
31. ITIL® is a Registered Trade Mark of the Office31
IT Service Management-
Get back to the future
• We are always analyzing the
data- where are we now?
• We look for adherence to
policy and process
• We understand this all takes
time
• We run IT like a business
• We accept IT Service
Management is business as
usual
Things we have done to mature:
• We have not implemented
ITIL
• We are evolving IT Service
Management
• Moved from: managing
technology to managing
service processes
• We are always developing
service management for
customers and clients
<number>
6000 Professionsal – WOW think of that- larger than many corporations. This includes our Analysts, developers, engineers, operations, Service Desk, Leadership- also roles such as Change Manager, Change Coordinator, Incident Manager, Incident Coordinators.
As you can see we have many services- and think 6000 individuals applying changes in one way or another!
In summary we have a large organization- very dependent on Data, we are a regulated corporation that complies to SOX, Hippa, External Auditors and we have Internal Auditors as well as a strong compliance team
So I told you about Allstate- now let’s focus in on IT Service Management- how did we take a concept and framework like ITIL and bring it to life?
Like evolution of computers ITIL has had it’s own journey
We have seen many chanes
The first generation of computers were vacuum tube based and primarily developed for the military; The first computer bug was truly an insect in 1945; The computers moved on to assist in tin the 1952 presidential election- it’s first exposure on television.
Second generation introduced the transistor and the introduction of computers to be used for “business” one of the first uses was to capture information from personal checks in 1959. This was the foundation for transistor radios
Third generation moved onto circuits which were used for hearing aids, airline reservation tracking
Fourth Generation- first 8 inch memory disk- the floppy disk and LCD display in 1971; 1st hard disk drive and the personal computer was born with word processors, and a software called DOS was created
Fifth generation- the day of www- 1991
Meanwhile in the late 80’s ITIL was being crafted
V1- V2-Process V3- A Service Lifecycle
Many changes- and more to come- so how do we manage chagne?
’04- Why pursue ITSM? Customers said too slows; cost too mcuh and hard to navigate- we responded with process improvement.
1. Aligned ITIL for IM/CM
Std Priority Schema for Incident; Focus on MTTR on P1 Incidents; Improved classification
’06 Took on an operational focus for CM, IM
’07 Expanded our scope to the Enterprise- App Dev areas
’08- Question of what really is sticking, are we embracing and adopting?
We took on Assessments and made a large commitment through a new ITSM tool
From Concept to implementation- we sart with our Vision and Strategy
What do we get?
Let’s walk through step by step…
In the beginning it was about setting up the program and creating action plans around the strategy.
We began in 2004…
As we moved forward- we wanted to be sure that we were truly delivering with the end in mind. We created the baseline through a home grown Maturity Assessment that utilized both ITIL and CobiT
Clear deliverables were identified for each process- some common and some unique
As we moved forward with Change being Defined and Documented we had a solid base to advance to Enterprise Adoption
This is where we built a bridge between Infrastructure Services and the Application areas. We leveraged a strong partnership with the Claims Technology organization and were able to role out Change Management across the organization.
With the strategy in place, implementation moving forward it was time to really assess how the program was doing. 2008 focused on two key areas-
One was to replace our IT Service Management tool- moving 5000 active employees from one tool to another was no small task.
The other in support of our Enterprise goal to improve availability , reliability and security by Enterprise Wide adoption of ITIL needed to have a benchmark created. We went forward with two different measurements that I will talk about in a minute.
With advancing across to the Application areas we needed to be in tune with other frameworks being utilized in the organization. ITIL does not stand alone. There is Cmmi; PMBOK; 6 Sigma and CobiT all complimentary
<number>
So in summary- 2004 the official program began from a grass roots efforts. Process behind the Process; Focus on improving Availability through red to green;
2005- Ensure we deliver with the end in mind. Determine our documentation footprint
2005- Build in Governance with CobiT and ITIL artifacts defined within the process
2006- Assessing our documents- moving up the maturity scale as well as starting out BSM- focused on building a Service Catalog
2007- Moved us into an Enterprise project where we needed to review our training and education strategy; take a lok at our process and be sure that it would support the application areas as well as the Infrastructure groups where it came from and determine the best tool for IT Service Management.
2008 with a tool selected we focused on rolling this out. Many members from the project in 2007 were critical resources for the tool implementation. Determination of measurement for our Enterprise goal was also a critical track of work.
All of these questions produced tangible results and a
ITIL Version 3- what we have here are the 5 Core manuals which describe the approach to use in order to ensure our IT Services are aligned to the business needs and actively support them.
This in a nutshell allows us to bring change into our organization in order to ensure that we implement, manage and support services in a way that makes our business more successful – with less disruption and loss of productive hours- we want to reduce costs, increase revenue, and improve our relations with the business.
<number>
CSI is concerned with maintaining value for our customers not only with evaluation and improvement of the quality of services but also with the overall maturity of the ITSM service lifecycle and underlying processes.
The activities include ROI- for the improvements we take on, note also is is also the overall health of IT Service Management, along with the Portfolio and key to include the growth and maturity of the service management practice.
For us during 2008 we looked at and defined how we would measure, interpret and execute on our current results. This drove us to ask a lot of questions around our 2008 goal- Improve Availability, Reliability and Security by the Enterprise Implementation of ITIL
To pursue the answers of measurement around our Goal we turned to CSI- and focused on how to measure the growth and maturity of the service management practice.
What should you measure- we wanted to understand our progress- how are our processes performing? How is our adoption?
What can we measure- this was a little harder- we decided to separate maturity from adoption since we realized we had different levels of adoption in different verticals with the roll out.
Gather the date- we created a survey for adoption for each of our functional areas as well as identified the key players for each of our core 4 processes.
Process the data with frequency format and accuracy- I’ll show you a sample in a minute here of what that looked like.
Analyze data trends and plans- after our surveys we took a look at what we saw.
Present and use the information – bringing it back directly to each area
7. 2009 Implement corrective action is where we are today.
Validating our approach we turned to Forrester. This graph is from a survey on the types of questions received around ITIL. The results indicate based on questions for research that many are in the implementation and adoption phase as opposed to asking how to define ITIL, or pick a vendor or what the actual benefits of ITIl are.
<number>
Talked about the 7 steps in CIS- What you should measure and what you can measure.
Having ITIL as an Enterprise initiative and goal for adoption in 2008 had us take a looks at this question long and hard. We rolled out change management, now we needed to see if it really stuck. We designed a simple internal survey to check the health of our adoption across our four core processes. The survey was also self healing in the sense if you answered with a 1 you need to guide your organization up to a two and so forth. Let’s take a look here at the question-
Moving on to step 3 for two tracks of work- first the adoption assessments- and then our other two major initiatives was bringing our service catalog to life and migrating to a new IT Service Management tool.
From the data we were able to prepare results of each of our organizations rating regarding adoption
Step five moves us on to analysis of the data, observations and recommendations for adherenceremediation.
<number>
What do we do with the results?
We developed a comprehensive report for each area outlining the next steps for remediation. This included people, such as what roles are missing or need to be shored up. Process what activities need to be pursued. Technology was not a major focus at this time as we were rolling out a new IT Service Management platform.
Remember this is including all areas that represent the 6000+ employees serving Technology at Allstate.
Take a moment to see how has this all worked?
If we were to start over what could we have done better? What improvements would we apply to our own adoption assessment?
Time is always a factor- the amount of time it took to actually schedule all of the assessments was a lot longer than we had anticipated; As far a note taking this is a critical point. If you start with your report format asking the questions and taking the notes will be much easier and more meaningful.
All areas although representing IT may not actually be performing the processes being assessed.
Next Steps- Close the gaps. Bring adoption forward ensuring that we are actually answering to the pain points of each area.
So what do we really mean by “get back to the future?
Our IT Service Management initiative using ITIL started as a grass roots initiative and we have not come full circle by gaining Executive sponsorship.
We took one project at a time and improved on operational efforts; for a while broke off to focus strictly on operational efforts and now have a program approach again.
We utilize six core documents to bring each process to life- process, policy, procedure, roles & responsibilities, education & training, communications & marketing.
Bring the roles to life- take the 7 steps process from CSI and bring it to life in the services, technology, process, and program.
Centralizing common functions to an Enterprise process just makes sense. Why have 7 organizations keep up documentation to supply to auditors or compliance about change? Or how they do releases? We need all of the synergies we can get in tough economic times.
CPIT- bring all ideas to the table and drive forward together
Enterprise roles need to be visible and have authority. Change Managers is one of our most successful roles in the Enterprise and we are driving out additional roles such as Problem Mgr & Coordinator
Common footprint for our roles across the various processes
Key- only one process owner- at the Director level; one Process Lead who has an advanced level of ITIL knowledge; We often have process analysts to support the process- from an operational view.
Pulling our verticals together look at Service Transition in the bottom right- For Change Management we have a Change Manager in each vertical. Life Insurance; Products; Infrastructure; Marketing and Sales; Within each of those areas we have established Change Coordinators and the SMEs from all areas form our virtual CAB.
So a basic footprint of roles with some specialties such as the CAB
This slide shows on the left governance types- strategy delivers strategic alignment to the business; Investment ensures value delivery thorough the delivery cycle against the strategy to optimize costs; project- efficiencies; process; repeatable; technology –what types and kinds of hardware
We talked about a continual service improvement approach at the end of the day we are delivering services. When we improvement we must understand what area we are focusing on To deliver consistent quality services we need imprrove and build our Enterprise processes to work together and create our governance, which are the policies, procedures and regulations under which we operate. Stepping through the Deming cycle of plan –do – check- and act- we can apply the various frameworks-
Plan- PMBOK-ITIL What process do you need?
Do- Create the ITIL Processes- create discrete testing procedures through CMMi aligned processes;
Check- initiate a 6 Sigma improvement project; validate your output through a CobiT aligned Audit-
Act- Implement corrective action through a PMBOK aligned project
With Enterprise processes defined, and adoption assessment complete and governance built in we will move forward. We have established targets for each area we are working on defining the activities and projects to define and close the gaps.
Enterprise audits are playing a strong role in our CSI approach; this year we plan to role out stronger role based training to ensure alignment. Towards the middle or end of the year we will return and do another assessment to see how we have progressed.
At the end of the day these processes allow us to deliver better quality services.
Our program at a glance- aligned to the Demming cycle of plan/do/check/act- we start with our roadmap, we have a current state analysis for both our process maturity and our adoption rate; we move forward with a target for both adoption and maturity; create the project to facilitate this; implement the actual project and receive operational excellence. All along the program is supported with Project governance; active Process Owner activities; process governance and technology oversight for our support tools.
Something to remember- hold your position with reporting, metrics, and an action plan. It is easy to slide down on maturity or adoption if you are not constantly nurturing the process and communicating. Utilizing CSI for the service, process, and program are necessary steps to move forward in a continued advancement.