3. Overcrowding of Prisons There are around 2.5 million people incarcerated in the United States Most prisons and jails (federal, state and local) are running above recommended capacity The Richmond jail is designed to house around 850 inmates. There are between 1,400 and 1,600 inmates incarcerated there currently
4. Effects of Overcrowding Higher stress levels among inmates Higher rates of assaults in overcrowded facilities Higher recidivism Rates among inmates housed in overcrowded facilities
5. Cost The United States spends around $214.5 billion dollars annually on corrections http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/glance/tables/expgovtab.cfm The United States spends about six times more on prisons than on education
8. So, it seems that prisons in the United States are a real problem, how can you feasibly ‘fix’ all of these problems? We believe that by abolishing mandatory minimal sentencing, we can make a huge improvement in the problems that we have outlined. Which included overcrowding, costs, and excessive sentencing.
9. What is Minimal Sentencing? Minimal Sentencing is defined as… “A criminal sentence set by a legislature that establishes the minimum length of prison time for specified crimes and thus limits the amount of discretion a judge has when sentencing a defendant”.
10. Why is Mandatory Sentencing a Problem? It is a way to require judges to deliver fixed sentencing to those convicted of crimes, regardless of the details of the crime. It takes away judicial power to consider motivation, the offender’s role, and their chances of recidivism Certain crimes will receive certain punishments, with few exceptions.
13. Costs Quite simply, the more people that you put in jail the higher costs will be. $20,108
14. Excessive Sentencing “big” criminals It takes away the ability for a judge to look at an individual case and make a decision based on the facts of the case.
15. An Example… In the state of Connecticut, committing a class A, B, or C class felony with a gun in ones possession gets you an additional 5 years added to your sentence. Selling drugs to a minor is a minimum of two years, unless it is in the close proximity of a school, day care, or public housing facility in which it is 3 years.
16. Wait a second, won’t changing the sentencing laws make the US less tough on crime ? No, in short, we are not lessening the sentencing we are only putting the power to sentence back in the hands of the judicial branch.
18. Strengths of abolishing mandatory minimum sentencing Ensures that there are no unnecessary harsh sentences. Does away with one-size-fit all approach to sentencing and assures that a sentence is proportionate to the gravity of the offence and the degree of responsibility of the offender Congress no longer limits judicial discretion. Judges will be able to consider the facts of individual cases and impose sentences that are fit and just in the circumstances of that particular case. There will be less unwarranted racial disparity in sentencing. Mandatory sentencing disproportionally affect minorities. Minorities tend to be over represented in prisons.
19. Strengths continued Allows for fair and effective sentencing and decreases over reliance on imprisonment. all crimes and offenders have different circumstances but mandatory minimum sentencing treats them all equally and this is unfair and unjust. Incarceration is an expensive investment with little return and great potential to be counterproductive Nonviolent offenders will have a chance to receive rehabilitation instead of lengthy incarceration sentences. If a first time offender or an aboriginal is sentenced to prison they become more entrenched in the criminal lifestyle and become more hardened criminals. Prosecutors will no longer be empowered to force defendants to assist them in their prosecutions. Under Mandatory minimum sentencing Prosecutors have the power to proceed, dismiss, or stay charges. By removing discretion from the judge in public proceedings conducted on the record in the courtroom, it shifts discretion to the prosecutor's office, off the record and behind closed doors. The lack of openness and accountability of charging and plea negotiation processes then undermines the integrity of the sentencing process.
23. Research/Background 2.3 million people in prison in the United States United States holds 5% of worlds population, and 25% of the world’s jail population $68,000,000,000 spent annually on prisons 50-70% of people let out of jail will return at some point in their lives Nearly 60% of the people in state prisons serving time for a drug offense had no history of violence or of any significant previous selling activity.
24. Steps already in action towards a better future… Prison Rape Elimination Act (2003) Fair Sentencing Act (2010) National Criminal Justice Commission Act of 2010 National Criminal Justice Commission Act of 2011
26. Private Prisons Private prisons receive funds from state governments per inmate per day. They also have an economic incentive to continue to increase prison population.
27. Wackenhut Number one in the corrections industry In 2000, made $118/day/inmate Expanded services to include providing food to private and state prisons
28. Corrections Corporations of America FY Q4 results Total management revenue for the fourth quarter of 2010 increased 3.6% to $430.8 million from $415.8 million during the prior year period, primarily driven by a 4.3% increase in average daily inmate populations. “Additionally we are pleased our populations have remained strong, in excess of the 80,000 inmate milestone we surpassed late in 2010."- Chief Executive Officer, Damon Hininger
29. Tough-on crime politicians Many politicians feel pressure from constituents to appear harsh on crime, which could prevent them from supporting legislation that may come off as lenient.
31. “New drunk driving laws crack down on repeat offenders and “super drunk” drivers Laws to mandate jail for drunks who drive with children in the car Laws to promote prosecution of child pornographers and sexual predators Laws to keep violent sexual predators off of school property during school hours”
33. Authored the PATRIOT Act “Law enforcement should be provided the appropriate tools to protect our borders and hunt down criminals and strong sentences are effective in deterring crime.”
35. American Civil Liberties Union Focus on Prison rights “The ACLU's National Prison Project is dedicated to ensuring that our nation’s prisons, jails, juvenile facilities and immigration detention centers comply with the Constitution, federal law, and international human rights principles, and to addressing the crisis of over-incarceration in the U.S. Since 1972” mostly likely support legislation that will reduce the prison sentence and thus reduce overcrowding
36. National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Law Organization that fights for drug law reform many prisoners in jail are being held for drug charges which have a minimum sentence depending on how much of the drug they were found with NORML would most likely support this policy because it could affect many of their members.
In Virginia there are over 80 crimes in which you can be get minimal sentencing for, they include drunk driving, drugs, sex crimes, non-DUI driving offences, firearm crimes, assault offences, and ‘other offences’ which includes vandalism and trespassing.
This will put power back in the hands of the judicial branch. It will allow the judge to look at the facts of each individual case and to allow sentencing to meet the crime that has been committed.
The prison system in our county can’t expand at a rate that meets the level of people who are being incarcerated, and so we get mass overcrowding in the system.
$20,108 is the average cost per year per prisoner in the State of Flordia, the longer that you keep someone in jail, the more it will cost.
Big criminals: one of the only way to get a lighter sentence is to give the prosecutor details about other criminals and only the “big” criminals have this information, so in effect they get the lesser sentenceing
Class A, B, and C felonies include:
Judges will still be able to give tough sentencing but they won’t have to if they feel that the defendant doesn’t need it. “The U.S. Sentencing Commission and the Department of Justice have both concluded that mandatory sentencing fails to deter crime.”
