Enviar pesquisa
Carregar
Criticalreview (1)
•
1 gostou
•
739 visualizações
Armando Castillo
Seguir
Denunciar
Compartilhar
Denunciar
Compartilhar
1 de 4
Baixar agora
Baixar para ler offline
Recomendados
Guidelines review article
Guidelines review article
said warsame nur
Guidelines review article
Guidelines review article
Abdullah Chaudhry
How to write review article
How to write review article
Asif nawaz khan (AUST)
Content (reading & writing)
Content (reading & writing)
Melanio Florino
Writing an article review
Writing an article review
dapuchak
How to develop a literature review
How to develop a literature review
EtieneIma123
Guidelines for article review assignment
Guidelines for article review assignment
Adibah H. Mutalib
Englis 202 February 24
Englis 202 February 24
lisyaseloni
Recomendados
Guidelines review article
Guidelines review article
said warsame nur
Guidelines review article
Guidelines review article
Abdullah Chaudhry
How to write review article
How to write review article
Asif nawaz khan (AUST)
Content (reading & writing)
Content (reading & writing)
Melanio Florino
Writing an article review
Writing an article review
dapuchak
How to develop a literature review
How to develop a literature review
EtieneIma123
Guidelines for article review assignment
Guidelines for article review assignment
Adibah H. Mutalib
Englis 202 February 24
Englis 202 February 24
lisyaseloni
Critical review writing_help essay sample from assignmentsupport.com essay wr...
Critical review writing_help essay sample from assignmentsupport.com essay wr...
https://writeessayuk.com/
Crafting the literature review
Crafting the literature review
Ahmed Hamdy
How to write a literature review
How to write a literature review
Editage Insights (Resources for authors and journals)
Generic lecture 3 literature review tutor
Generic lecture 3 literature review tutor
moduledesign
Review article
Review article
AffShfq
Literature review
Literature review
Aņïźä Kȟäņ
Lit review
Lit review
Arjona Pecaj
Presentation1
Presentation1
Dele-Francis Ifenowo
Writing a review article in 7 steps
Writing a review article in 7 steps
Eric Lichtfouse
Individual project instructions mgmt 338 you have been
Individual project instructions mgmt 338 you have been
simba35
How To Write A Critical Review
How To Write A Critical Review
City Cool Pvt Limited
Converting theses and dissertations into journal articles
Converting theses and dissertations into journal articles
Jeanette C. Patindol
Publishing your First Few Papers_TUE_130_catlos
Publishing your First Few Papers_TUE_130_catlos
SERC at Carleton College
Touchstone 3 presenting a research plan scenario your
Touchstone 3 presenting a research plan scenario your
raju957290
Writing your term paper
Writing your term paper
dalwritingcentre
Annotated bib
Annotated bib
Katherine Quinnell, Ph.D.
Edu706 articlerevw
Edu706 articlerevw
MARA Junior Science College
Manuscript submission checklist
Manuscript submission checklist
Editage Insights (Resources for authors and journals)
Lit review
Lit review
Edwin Singh
How to Write Literature Review
How to Write Literature Review
Syamsul Nor Azlan Mohamad
EAPP w3.pptx
EAPP w3.pptx
joymagboo
Alternatives to Empirical Research (Dissertation by literature review) Dec 23...
Alternatives to Empirical Research (Dissertation by literature review) Dec 23...
hashem Al-Shamiri
Mais conteúdo relacionado
Mais procurados
Critical review writing_help essay sample from assignmentsupport.com essay wr...
Critical review writing_help essay sample from assignmentsupport.com essay wr...
https://writeessayuk.com/
Crafting the literature review
Crafting the literature review
Ahmed Hamdy
How to write a literature review
How to write a literature review
Editage Insights (Resources for authors and journals)
Generic lecture 3 literature review tutor
Generic lecture 3 literature review tutor
moduledesign
Review article
Review article
AffShfq
Literature review
Literature review
Aņïźä Kȟäņ
Lit review
Lit review
Arjona Pecaj
Presentation1
Presentation1
Dele-Francis Ifenowo
Writing a review article in 7 steps
Writing a review article in 7 steps
Eric Lichtfouse
Individual project instructions mgmt 338 you have been
Individual project instructions mgmt 338 you have been
simba35
How To Write A Critical Review
How To Write A Critical Review
City Cool Pvt Limited
Converting theses and dissertations into journal articles
Converting theses and dissertations into journal articles
Jeanette C. Patindol
Publishing your First Few Papers_TUE_130_catlos
Publishing your First Few Papers_TUE_130_catlos
SERC at Carleton College
Touchstone 3 presenting a research plan scenario your
Touchstone 3 presenting a research plan scenario your
raju957290
Writing your term paper
Writing your term paper
dalwritingcentre
Annotated bib
Annotated bib
Katherine Quinnell, Ph.D.
Edu706 articlerevw
Edu706 articlerevw
MARA Junior Science College
Manuscript submission checklist
Manuscript submission checklist
Editage Insights (Resources for authors and journals)
Mais procurados
(18)
Critical review writing_help essay sample from assignmentsupport.com essay wr...
Critical review writing_help essay sample from assignmentsupport.com essay wr...
Crafting the literature review
Crafting the literature review
How to write a literature review
How to write a literature review
Generic lecture 3 literature review tutor
Generic lecture 3 literature review tutor
Review article
Review article
Literature review
Literature review
Lit review
Lit review
Presentation1
Presentation1
Writing a review article in 7 steps
Writing a review article in 7 steps
Individual project instructions mgmt 338 you have been
Individual project instructions mgmt 338 you have been
How To Write A Critical Review
How To Write A Critical Review
Converting theses and dissertations into journal articles
Converting theses and dissertations into journal articles
Publishing your First Few Papers_TUE_130_catlos
Publishing your First Few Papers_TUE_130_catlos
Touchstone 3 presenting a research plan scenario your
Touchstone 3 presenting a research plan scenario your
Writing your term paper
Writing your term paper
Annotated bib
Annotated bib
Edu706 articlerevw
Edu706 articlerevw
Manuscript submission checklist
Manuscript submission checklist
Semelhante a Criticalreview (1)
Lit review
Lit review
Edwin Singh
How to Write Literature Review
How to Write Literature Review
Syamsul Nor Azlan Mohamad
EAPP w3.pptx
EAPP w3.pptx
joymagboo
Alternatives to Empirical Research (Dissertation by literature review) Dec 23...
Alternatives to Empirical Research (Dissertation by literature review) Dec 23...
hashem Al-Shamiri
BBA 3651, Leadership 1 Course Description Presents .docx
BBA 3651, Leadership 1 Course Description Presents .docx
ikirkton
Litreview
Litreview
KhanhHoa Tran
Project Organizational Level of AnalysisPurpose · To explore.docx
Project Organizational Level of AnalysisPurpose · To explore.docx
wkyra78
Due 81618Discipline-Based Literature ReviewPrior to b
Due 81618Discipline-Based Literature ReviewPrior to b
wildmandelorse
Writing the Research Paper
Writing the Research Paper
dalwritingcentre
Soft-Sand-Minimalist-Modern-Thesis-Defense-Presentation.pdf
Soft-Sand-Minimalist-Modern-Thesis-Defense-Presentation.pdf
nicolebernabe0408
Literature review outline tips
Literature review outline tips
levibaxter
DISCUSSION 1 Elements of Critical Thinking [WLOs 2, 3, 4] .docx
DISCUSSION 1 Elements of Critical Thinking [WLOs 2, 3, 4] .docx
charlieppalmer35273
LiteratureReview_M AIslam CH 2
LiteratureReview_M AIslam CH 2
Dr. Mohammad Aminul Islam
BUSI 610Literature Review Title Page and Outline Rubric(50 P.docx
BUSI 610Literature Review Title Page and Outline Rubric(50 P.docx
felicidaddinwoodie
Case Study 1 Individual Level of AnalysisPurpose ·To rec.docx
Case Study 1 Individual Level of AnalysisPurpose ·To rec.docx
romeliadoan
172Business Communication Quarterly, Volume 69, Number 2, .docx
172Business Communication Quarterly, Volume 69, Number 2, .docx
novabroom
1University of PennsylvaniaSuite 300, Stouffer Commons.docx
1University of PennsylvaniaSuite 300, Stouffer Commons.docx
vickeryr87
How to write an article critique
How to write an article critique
sigmaessays
How to write an article critique
How to write an article critique
sigmaessays
By the type of writing that we both.docx
By the type of writing that we both.docx
write22
Semelhante a Criticalreview (1)
(20)
Lit review
Lit review
How to Write Literature Review
How to Write Literature Review
EAPP w3.pptx
EAPP w3.pptx
Alternatives to Empirical Research (Dissertation by literature review) Dec 23...
Alternatives to Empirical Research (Dissertation by literature review) Dec 23...
BBA 3651, Leadership 1 Course Description Presents .docx
BBA 3651, Leadership 1 Course Description Presents .docx
Litreview
Litreview
Project Organizational Level of AnalysisPurpose · To explore.docx
Project Organizational Level of AnalysisPurpose · To explore.docx
Due 81618Discipline-Based Literature ReviewPrior to b
Due 81618Discipline-Based Literature ReviewPrior to b
Writing the Research Paper
Writing the Research Paper
Soft-Sand-Minimalist-Modern-Thesis-Defense-Presentation.pdf
Soft-Sand-Minimalist-Modern-Thesis-Defense-Presentation.pdf
Literature review outline tips
Literature review outline tips
DISCUSSION 1 Elements of Critical Thinking [WLOs 2, 3, 4] .docx
DISCUSSION 1 Elements of Critical Thinking [WLOs 2, 3, 4] .docx
LiteratureReview_M AIslam CH 2
LiteratureReview_M AIslam CH 2
BUSI 610Literature Review Title Page and Outline Rubric(50 P.docx
BUSI 610Literature Review Title Page and Outline Rubric(50 P.docx
Case Study 1 Individual Level of AnalysisPurpose ·To rec.docx
Case Study 1 Individual Level of AnalysisPurpose ·To rec.docx
172Business Communication Quarterly, Volume 69, Number 2, .docx
172Business Communication Quarterly, Volume 69, Number 2, .docx
1University of PennsylvaniaSuite 300, Stouffer Commons.docx
1University of PennsylvaniaSuite 300, Stouffer Commons.docx
How to write an article critique
How to write an article critique
How to write an article critique
How to write an article critique
By the type of writing that we both.docx
By the type of writing that we both.docx
Mais de Armando Castillo
Syllabus 2014 2015-12-th_grade
Syllabus 2014 2015-12-th_grade
Armando Castillo
To kill a mockingbird Vocabulary
To kill a mockingbird Vocabulary
Armando Castillo
Oral presentation rubric
Oral presentation rubric
Armando Castillo
Chapter Presentation Rubric
Chapter Presentation Rubric
Armando Castillo
18 pop
18 pop
Armando Castillo
17 houses
17 houses
Armando Castillo
16 fish
16 fish
Armando Castillo
19 tea
19 tea
Armando Castillo
College board review
College board review
Armando Castillo
Tuck evelasting guide
Tuck evelasting guide
Armando Castillo
Classrules
Classrules
Armando Castillo
Transition words and phrases
Transition words and phrases
Armando Castillo
Ingl 12 syllabus
Ingl 12 syllabus
Armando Castillo
The Giver: Class Assignment
The Giver: Class Assignment
Armando Castillo
How to write a summary
How to write a summary
Armando Castillo
Edmodo
Edmodo
Armando Castillo
Summer syllabus
Summer syllabus
Armando Castillo
Edmodo
Edmodo
Armando Castillo
English 12 syllabus 2013 14
English 12 syllabus 2013 14
Armando Castillo
Travel brochure
Travel brochure
Armando Castillo
Mais de Armando Castillo
(20)
Syllabus 2014 2015-12-th_grade
Syllabus 2014 2015-12-th_grade
To kill a mockingbird Vocabulary
To kill a mockingbird Vocabulary
Oral presentation rubric
Oral presentation rubric
Chapter Presentation Rubric
Chapter Presentation Rubric
18 pop
18 pop
17 houses
17 houses
16 fish
16 fish
19 tea
19 tea
College board review
College board review
Tuck evelasting guide
Tuck evelasting guide
Classrules
Classrules
Transition words and phrases
Transition words and phrases
Ingl 12 syllabus
Ingl 12 syllabus
The Giver: Class Assignment
The Giver: Class Assignment
How to write a summary
How to write a summary
Edmodo
Edmodo
Summer syllabus
Summer syllabus
Edmodo
Edmodo
English 12 syllabus 2013 14
English 12 syllabus 2013 14
Travel brochure
Travel brochure
Criticalreview (1)
1.
CSU Learning Skills:
your link to success Prepared by Joel Russell http://www.csu.edu.au/division/studserv/learning © 2008 Our Self-help Resources are located at: http://www.csu.edu.au/division/studserv/learning/student_resources CSU Learning Skills: your link to success Academic writing Writing a critical review What is a critical review? In very simply terms, a critical review or appraisal is an academic review of an article that offers both a summary and critical comment. Book reviews, movie reviews, critical reviews and literature reviews all perform a similar task of evaluating or appraising how well various texts and artistic productions achieve their goals of communicating with the reader, or a wider audience. Project reviews evaluate whether the goals of a project have been achieved. They are not necessarily based on an appraisal of a text, but the process of critical evaluation is similar. As this is a general discussion of what a critical review is, you should consult your Subject Outline or subject coordinator to find out what structure and content to include when completing a critical review as an assessment task. Types of critical reviews Reviews include: appraisals of the artistic merit of movies or music albums; assessments of the effectiveness of government programs in catering for specific public needs; evaluations of the merit of an academic article or body of literature to the development of research and understanding of knowledge within a specific discipline (Northey, 2005, p. 35). A critical review is an academic appraisal of an article that offers both a summary and critical comment on the content. This makes it different to a literature review, which examines a body of literature or series of key academic articles addressing a specific topic of interest. A literature review is an important part of preparing to write a full thesis paper (Wallace & Wray, 2006, p.177). Why write a critical review? Here are a number of reasons why a critical review is written: To analyse the text and evaluate its relevance to your academic needs; To analyse, describe and interpret a text to show your understanding of what you have read; In some university courses, you are asked to write critical reviews in order to demonstrate that you: Understand the main points; Can analyse the main arguments or findings; Can evaluate the article using relevant criteria which you or the subject coordinator has selected. In order to write a critical review, you have to be able to read and think critically. These skills are just as important in daily life as they are for academic study. They help you to: Remain informed about issues relevant to your field of work; Assess and comment on problems you may encounter in work or domestic situations; Evaluate the solutions proposed by others; Generate alternative solutions (Wallace & Wray, 2006, p. 177).
2.
CSU Learning Skills:
your link to success Prepared by Joel Russell http://www.csu.edu.au/division/studserv/learning © 2008 Our Self-help Resources are located at: http://www.csu.edu.au/division/studserv/learning/student_resources A critical review is not just a summary. It is an evaluation of what an author has said about a topic. It is critical in the sense that it: is a thoughtful consideration of the validity and accuracy of the author's claims; considers the benefits and limitations of the author's point of view; identifies other valid points of view (Hart, 1998, p. 176). Qualities of an effective critical review To be effective a critical review must: 1. Engage the reader by indicating clearly what the reviewed article is about; 2. Take an investigative approach to examining the issues raised, rather than attempting to progressively discredit each point which is made (Fairburn & Winch, 1996, pp. 207-8); 3. Identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article, giving credit for new perspectives about the topic and checking that they are supported appropriately; 4. Evaluate the contribution of the article to developing a greater public knowledge and understanding of the topic (Hay, 1996, pp. 40-41). Planning your review Clanchy and Ballard (1991, pp. 91-92) indicate that there are several steps to follow before you start writing your critical review: 1. Gain an initial overview of the text by skimming: Title Abstract (if any) Introduction Subheadings (if any) Conclusion 2. Read the article in order to identify its aims and main ideas. 3. Re-read the article in detail, analysing the key content, and making notes: Highlight the main ideas Make brief notes: in the margin, on paper create a mindmap. 4. Check your notes to make sure they include: The purpose of the article The methods used by the authors to collect the information The main findings. 5. Use your notes to write a summary of the text.
3.
CSU Learning Skills:
your link to success Prepared by Joel Russell http://www.csu.edu.au/division/studserv/learning © 2008 Our Self-help Resources are located at: http://www.csu.edu.au/division/studserv/learning/student_resources Organising your review As is the case with most of the writing you do at university, which is formal writing, a review should have an introduction, body and conclusion. However, if you are given a specific format in the Subject Outline, you should of course follow that. Introduction (10%) Identify the article you are reviewing, including the title of the text, the author's name and their expertise in the field being addressed in the article. Identify the purpose and context in which the article was written. Identify your purpose in writing the review and how your examination of the text will address the topic or problem you wish to resolve. Summarise the main issues raised by the author of the text (Wallace & Wray, 2006, p. 117). Body (80%) Analyse the key points made in the text. Evaluate the validity of the evidence used to support each point. Decide whether the conclusions which are reached are convincing when applied in a general sense as well as in the specific situations described in text. This should include both the strengths and weaknesses of the claims made in the article. Clearly distinguish between the views of the author and others (Northey, 2005, pp. 38-39). Conclusion (10%) Summarise your evaluation of the text. Make a judgement about the credibility of the overall claims made in the text. Evaluate the usefulness of the text in addressing the issues you wished to resolve in your review (Wallace & Wray, 2006, p. 118). Additional web resources A useful site providing a sample review from Clanchy and Ballard (1985), with commentary on the features that make it effective. http://arts.monash.edu.au/lls/resources-good-crit-review.pdf These sites provide structured information about how to write a critical review. The second site provides an extract from a critical review written by a student, with some commentary on how it is structured. http://www.lc.unsw.edu.au/onlib/critrev.html http://www.lc.unsw.edu.au/onlib/critrev2.html Critical review writing, Teaching & Learning Unit, Faculty of Economics and Commerce, The University of Melbourne http://tlu.ecom.unimelb.edu.au/pdfs/criticalreviewwriting.pdf For the busy student the following site provides a one page description of how to write a critical review. http://www.elssa.uts.edu.au/programs/EDUHSSworkshops/2007/Critical%20Review.pdf If you like detailed explanations of how to do things, this site provides an extensive description of how to write critical reviews for readers in the discipline of Psychology. http://www.psy.gla.ac.uk/~steve/resources/crs.html
4.
CSU Learning Skills:
your link to success Prepared by Joel Russell http://www.csu.edu.au/division/studserv/learning © 2008 Our Self-help Resources are located at: http://www.csu.edu.au/division/studserv/learning/student_resources References Anderson, J. & Poole, M. (2001). Thesis and assignment writing (4th ed.). Brisbane: John Wiley & Sons. Clanchy, J. & Ballard, B. (1991). Essay writing for students: A practical guide (2nd ed.). Melbourne: Longman Cheshire. Fairburn, G. J. & Winch, C. (1996). Reading, writing and reasoning: A guide for students (2nd ed.). Buckingham: Open University Press. Hay, I. (1998). Communicating in Geography and the Environmental sciences. South Melbourne: Oxford University Press. (Original work published 1996) Hart, C. (1998). Doing a literature review: Releasing the social science research imagination. London: Sage Publications. Northey, M. (2005). Making sense: A student's guide to research and writing (4th ed.). Don Mills, Ontario: Oxford University Press. Wallace, M. & Wray, A. (2006). Critical reading and writing for postgraduates. London: Sage Publications.
Baixar agora